emerging technologies showcase - e3te3tnw.org/portals/0/e3tfiles/showcase-roadmap-apr 30 2013...
TRANSCRIPT
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
Emerging Technologies ShowcaseApril 30, 2013
Welcome. Today’s webinar is being recorded and will be posted at:
• www.E3Tnw.org
• www.ConduitNW.org
You may submit questions at any time during the webinar. We’ll answer them during the Question & Answer session after the presentation.
The webinar will begin momentarily. Thank you for attending!
Technology Roadmaps and the Collaborative Approach to Save Energy:
The National Energy Efficiency Technology Roadmap Portfolio
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
Technology Roadmaps and the Collaborative Approach to Save Energy:
The National Energy Efficiency Technology Roadmap Portfolio
Emerging Technologies Showcase
James V. Hillegas-Elting, Bonneville Power Administration
April 30, 2013Sponsored by BPA’s E3T Program
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
1) Purpose
2) Audience
3) Background
4) Content
5) Examples
6) Next Steps
3
Agenda
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
The Roadmap Portfolio addresses a critical need within and beyond the region.
1) Helps “fill the pipeline”: Identifying promising products and services for utility EE programs.
2) Regional strategy: One way to help achieve Power Plan targets.
3) Facilitates collaboration: Helps align efforts within and beyond the region.
4
Purpose
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
5
Purpose
Now~0–5 Years from Now~5–20 Years from Now
Utility ProgramsEmerging TechnologiesTechnology Roadmapping
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
Because energy savings can best be achieved through some form of collaboration and coordination:
• The more we increase visibility on technology R&D needs and ongoing programs,
• The more we can coordinate our efforts, which will, in turn,
• Optimize all of our investments and quicken the pace of EE technology development and deployment.
6
Purpose
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
• Provides a standardized approach to identify and track EE R&D programs that are developing technologies with the potential to deliver energy savings.
• Can contribute to the strategic due diligence process to minimize redundant spending and align investments among organizations involved in EE emerging technology coordination.
7
Purpose
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
8
Audience
Type Examples Interest
Internal
EE Emerging Technologies & EE Programs
Insight “up the pipeline”; provide input into content; internal prioritization
Technology Innovation Office
Ensure internal alignment and prioritization for annual solicitations
Stakeholders
Ratepayers Ensure optimal EE programs and R&D investments
Utility customers Insight “up the pipeline”; provide input into content
Regional collaborators (i.e., NEEA)
Insight “up the pipeline”; provide input into content
Others
R&D funding institutions (i.e., U.S. DOE, CEC)
Align strategic planning to optimize R&D investments
R&D centers (i.e., EPRI, national labs, universities)
Provide input into content; knowledge of utility R&D needs
Entrepreneurs Provide input into content; knowledge of utility R&D needs
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
• Since 2006: BPA Technology Innovation’s annual solicitation each March based on roadmapcontent
• 2009: Northwest Energy Efficiency Taskforce called on BPA to deepen coordination & collaboration with regional stakeholders
• 2012: “Northwest” became “National”: BPA & the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) collaborated to convene the National EE Technology Roadmapping Summit
9
Background
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
• 2013: “Building bridges”
o Internal: Develop Focus Areas for the BPA Technology Innovation Office’s March 2014 solicitation
o Regional: ET Showcase Webinar, Efficiency Exchange, Oregon BEST Fest, etc.
o National: Outreach to the U.S. Dept. of Energy, Alliance to Save Energy, American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, etc.
10
Background
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
11
Background
To help achieve Power Plan targets, the Executive Committee of the Northwest Energy Efficiency Taskforce (NEET) recommended in 2009 that BPA and the Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) enhance collaboration on emerging technology research.
e3tnw.org
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
12
Background
The NEET Executive Committee’s request resulted in two robust & complementary initiatives:
• National Energy Efficiency Technology Roadmap Portfolio
• Provides strategic insight into the 20-year R&D horizon.
• Used to guide the BPA Technology Innovation Office’s annual solicitations for proposals.
• Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies (E3T)
• Identify and prioritize emerging technologies.
• Overcome barriers to bring promising technologies into the marketplace more quickly.
e3tnw.org
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
13
Background
Key Partners and Collaborators: • E Source
• Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)
• Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA)
• Portland State University Engineering and Technology Management Department
• Washington State University Energy Program
Since 2009, BPA has managed the development and maturation of the Roadmap Portfolio on behalf of regional stakeholders.
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
Key Contributors:
Since 2009, this resource has been developed through a collaboration of:
• More than 200 experts
• Representing nearly 120 research institutions, utilities, and vendors
• Who have contributed approximately 5,120 hours and $1,100,000 worth of voluntary input.
(Full list available on pp. i-iv of the March 2013 Roadmap Portfolio.)
14
Background
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
34 roadmaps in five residential- and commercial- sector product and service areas:
15
Content ̶ Residential/Commercial
Building Design/Envelope• Deep Retrofits for Residential and Commercial• Retrofit and New Construction Labeling• Solar/Smart Roofing• Retrofit Insulation• New Construction Insulation• Retrofit and New Construction Air / Water Management• Net Zero Energy Buildings• Manufactured Housing / Modular / Pre-Manufactured Systems / Offices• Fenestration & Daylighting
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
16
Content ̶ Residential/Commercial (continued)
Lighting• General Lighting • Solid State Lighting• Task/Ambient Lighting• Lighting Controls • Luminaires• Daylighting
Electronics• Direct Current (DC) Power • Use and Virtualization• Component-Level Efficiency• Complete Electronic System• Power Management Control and Communication
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
17
Content ̶ Residential/Commercial (continued)
Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning• Commercial and Residential Water Heating• Fault Detection, Predictive Maintenance, and Controls• Heat Recovery and Economizer Optimization• Heating & Cooling Production and Delivery • HVAC Motor-driven Systems• Commercial Integrated Buildings• Residential HVAC• Modeling, Lab and Field Testing
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
18
Content ̶ Residential/Commercial (continued)
Sensors, Meters & Energy Management System• Smart Device-Level Controls Responsive to User and Environment• Easy / Simple User Interface Controls• Energy Management Services• Low-Cost Savings Verification Techniques• Real-Time Smart Electric Power Measurement of Facilities• Enterprise Energy and Maintenance Management Systems
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
Seven roadmaps in two industrial-sector product and service areas:
19
Content ̶ Industrial
Industrial Food Processing• Heating• Cooling• Mechanical• Infrastructure
Combined Heat and Power• Production• Resources• Delivery
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
20
Content
Convene technology roadmapping workshops
Transcribe, review, fact-check, & refine output
Publish updated Roadmap Portfolio
The Roadmap Portfolio is a living, working document.Versions published in: March & July 2010; March 2011; March, August, September & November 2012; January & March 2013.
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
21
Content
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
22
Content
“Strategic”
“Tactical”
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
23
Content
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
24
Content
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
25
Content
Appendix B: Details on R&D programs identified in the Roadmap Portfolio.
Appendix A: Process documents, workshop agendas, workshop minutes, etc.
R&D Program Summaries: Pages in the Roadmap Portfolio that provide summaries and key research questions.
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
26
Examples
BPA’s Technology Innovation Office uses the Roadmap Portfolio and other, agency-specific, roadmaps to provide strategic guidance for its annual request for proposals:
• Offers 50% cost share
• Proposals evaluated by the Technology Confirmation and Innovation Council
• Accepted projects must meet clearly articulated stage gates or lose funding
BPA’s Technology Innovation Office has applied robust technology management best practices since its inception in 2006.
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
27
Examples
Given the 5- to 20-year period that is often required to translate ideas into research projects and projects into market-ready products and services, as yet there are no technologies in the field that one can point to as coming directly from the Roadmap Portfolio.
However:
• The work of BPA’s Technology Innovation (TI) Office has already provided many money-saving technologies for the agency and ratepayers (see following page)
• R&D projects “pruned” from the agency’s funding portfolio are examples of a healthy technology management process
• The Roadmap Portfolio has increasingly served as a medium for collaboration within and beyond the region
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
28
Examples
TI: Energy Efficiency• Ductless heat pumps: As of early 2013, more than 18,000 installed in Pacific
NW homes; success led to expansion of program into small businesses.
TI: Other• Seismic upgrades for substations: Reduced seismic acceleration; delivered
model validation capability for designers.• Conductor shunt for transmission lines: Saved $4M by decreasing material
and staff costs for 20-mile Ross-Lexington upgrade.• Syncrophasors for grid operations: Provided control functions for reliability;
oscillation dampening that will lead in the long-term to increase Pacific Intertie throughput.
• Multi-gigabit Ethernet for grid operations: Significantly increased communications bandwith; delivered $$ millions in initial savings.
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
29
Examples (continued)
EE Roadmap Portfolio• TIP 261 Microwave sterilization for the food processing industry (WSU &
PNNL): Presentation at the January 2013 TI Summit.
• TIP 248 Residential HVAC occupancy sensor (MountainLogic, Inc.): “Pruned” from the TI Portfolio because it did not meet a stage gate.
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
Continue outreach• Connect BPA and EPRI EE roadmapping project teams with interested staff
from DOE EERE, ARPA-E, ACEEE, ASE, etc.
National EE Technology Steering Committee• Facilitate inter-organizational collaboration• Identify need for future roadmapping workshops• Define features of EE Technology R&D website
Website pilot project• Phased project to migrate content to the web• Faster and less time-consuming updates• Moderated wiki-style organized around product and service areas
Future roadmapping workshops• Integrated Systems• Waste Energy Recovery
30
Next Steps
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
Questions, Comments, and Discussion
31
Navigation-enhanced PDF versions of all Roadmap Portfolio documents can be found at http://www.bpa.gov/energy/n/emerging_technology/; direct links at:
Roadmap Portfolio:http://www.bpa.gov/energy/n/emerging_technology/pdf/EE_Tech_RM_Portfolio.pdf.
Appendix A (process documents):http://www.bpa.gov/energy/n/emerging_technology/pdf/EE_Tech_RM_Portfolio_Appx_A.pdf.
Appendix B (summaries of selected existing R&D programs):http://www.bpa.gov/energy/n/emerging_technology/pdf/EE_Tech_RM_Portfolio_Appx_B.pdf.
September 2012 National Energy Efficiency Technology Roadmapping Summit presentations: http://online.etm.pdx.edu/bpa_summit/home.html.
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
32
Supplementary Information
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
The Roadmap Portfolio addresses a critical need
• The Northwest Power and Conservation Council’s Sixth Power Plan (2010) calls for about 85 percent of the region’s load growth to be met with energy efficiency by 2030.
• Recent studies from the Energy Trust of Oregon and the Northwest Power and Conservation Council’s NW Resource Adequacy Forum conclude that regional energy efficiency targets will fall short before 2020 without robust efforts to identify and bring to market EE technologies.
33
Purpose
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
Alliance to Save Energy’s February 2013 report, Energy 2030: Doubling U.S. Energy Productivity by 2030, recognizes the critical role that government plays in complementing private-sector energy productivity and market adoption of EE technologies.
“The benefits of strong ET coordination are myriad. However, to coordinate successfully, those involved need a solid understanding of each other’s perspectives, goals, strengths, and limitations, as well as requirements . . .”
Ryan Fedie, Gregg Ander, Jorge Marques and Jonathan Livingston “The View from Here: A Utility Perspective on North American Emerging Technology Alignment”
ACEEE Summer Study 2012
34
Purpose (continued)
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
• Helps “fill the pipeline” of EE products and services that emerging technologies teams evaluate for inclusion in utility EE programs
[e.g., BPA E3T, California Emerging Technologies Coordinating Council (ETCC), Consortium for Energy Efficiency (CEE)]
• Focuses on technology R&D programs that seek to address business challenges and opportunities in the 5- to 20-year time horizon.
35
Purpose (continued)
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
36
Commercial Introduction
Commercial Growth
Commercial Maturity
Commercial Decline
Basic Research
Dashed: Optimal Cumulative Effect of Successive Technologies
Time
Energy Efficient TechnologyCommercialization Process. Simplifiedschematic illustrating a broadly representative exampleof the process of bringing an idea for an energy-efficient product or service through the phases ofresearch, development, design, testing, evaluation,pilot-scale implementation, and commercialintroduction and maturity. For comparative purposes,this general process is roughly correlated with thephases of emerging technologies initiatives, the U.S.Department of Energy’s Technology Readiness Levels,and an ongoing effort at the Bonneville PowerAdministration to define a system of MeasureReadiness Levels to guide technology transfer.
(Adapted from a number of sources including: Institute for BuildingEfficiency, “Advancing Energy Efficiency Technology: California Helps Blazethe Trail: Insights from the Emerging Technologies Coordinating Council2010 Summit,” n.d. (ca. Nov. 2010), http://www.institutebe.com/Building-Efficiency-Events/ettc-summit-2010.aspx; BPA Measure Readiness Levelscurrently under development; BC Hydro “Shaping the ET Future:Innovation in ET Programs,” n.d.; U.S. Department of Energy Office ofEnergy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, “Technology Readiness Levels(TRLS),” http://www1.eere.energy.gov/manufacturing/financial/trls.html.)
R&D programs tracked in the National Energy Efficiency
Technology Roadmap Portfolio
Emerging technologies programs such as BPA’s
Energy Efficiency Emerging Technology (E3T) team and the E3TNW.org database
~5 to 20 years 0 to ~3 years
“Chasm” between R&D and emerging technology programs
“Chasm” between emerging technologies and utility programs
Utility programs in the residential, commercial, and
industrial sectors
Time to full CommercializationCommercialized
Iterative Process of Research, Lab Tests,
Engineering
Applied Research
Development
Field Tests, Pilot Projects
U.S. Dept. of EnergyTechnology Readiness Levels (TRLs)1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Bonneville Power AdministrationMeasure Readiness Levels (MRLs) [DRAFT]
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Technology Demonstration
Capacity Building
Market Programs Codes & Standards
Role of Emerging Technologies Initiatives
Green:Adoption Rate of Single Technology
Purpose (continued)
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
37
Purpose (continued)
ENER
GY
SAV
ING
S
BPA – PEJD TI Projects (from solicitation) EPRI (i.e., TIP 216) NREL (i.e., TIP 247) Others (i.e., WSU & TIP 261) EPRI collaboration Tailored Collaboration-funded EE Demo II Other Other PEJD projects Custom Industrial Other
EPRI Program 170 (EE & DR) Sub-categories that BPA is involved in Sub-categories that BPA is not
involved in Program 182 (Behavior-based EE) Other programs (BPA fully-funds 5 and
partially-funds 2 of 58 EPRI programs to include EE/DR, Transmission, and Cyber Security)
NREL Collaboration with BPA (i.e., TIP 247) Many other EE projects
BPA
EE
Pipe
line
Stage Gates incorporated into each project
BPA – PEJB, PEJC Program design Codes & standards Other
Nat
iona
l Ene
rgy
Effic
ienc
y Te
chno
logy
Roa
dmap
Por
tfol
ioO
ngoi
ng in
itiat
ives
bot
h to
upd
ate
cont
ent w
ith in
put
from
nat
iona
l SM
Es a
nd to
fost
er a
dopt
ion
and/
or
colla
bora
tion
on R
&D
trac
king
in m
utua
lly b
enef
icia
l way
s
BPA’s Projects
EPRI’s Projects
NREL’s Project
s
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging TechnologiesE3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
For More Information
38
James V. Hillegas-Elting
Program Analyst, Energy Efficiency
Project Manager, Energy Efficiency Technology Roadmapping
Bonneville Power Administration
503-230-5327
E3T Energy Efficiency Emerging TechnologiesE3T Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies
Low Energy Precision Application (LEPA)Wednesday May 22, 2013 at noon Pacific time
More information about emerging technologies:
E3T database: www.E3Tnw.org
E3T Program: ww.bpa.gov/energy/n/emerging_technology/
Conduit: www.ConduitNW.org
Next Webinar
39