emergence of zoonotic diseases and the link to land use...
TRANSCRIPT
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Emergence of Zoonotic Diseases and the Link to Land Use Change Presented by Tom Hughes Project Coordinator, EcoHealth Alliance Malaysia Country Coordinator, PREDICT Deputy Chief of Party, IDEEAL MPOC International Palm Oil Sustainability Conference 19-20 August 2014
Ph
oto
: T Hu
ghes Eco
Health
Allian
ce
Ph
oto
: T Hu
ghes Eco
Health
Allian
ce
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
EcoHealth Alliance • EcoHealth Alliance is an international organization of scientists dedicated to the
conservation of biodiversity. For more than 40 years, EcoHealth Alliance has focused its efforts on conservation. Today, we are known for our innovative research on the intricate relationships between wildlife, ecosystems and human health.
• EcoHealth Alliance's work spans the U.S. and more than 20 countries in Central and South America, the Caribbean, Africa and Asia to research ways for people and wildlife to share bioscapes for their mutual survival. Our strength is built on our innovations in research, education and training and our accessibility to international conservation partners.
• Internationally, our programs support conservationists in over a dozen countries at the local level to save endangered species and their habitats and to protect delicate ecosystems for the benefit of wildlife and humans.
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
USAID Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Goal: The early detection and prevention of emerging zoonotic diseases that
threaten human health
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Zoonotic pathogen Emergence • ~ 50% of known human pathogens are
zoonotic
• 75% of emerging human pathogens are zoonotic; most originate in wildlife.
• Most zoonoses emerge due to human activities
• Complex process!
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Copyright ©2004 by the National Academy of Sciences
Hufnagel, L. et al. (2004) PNAS
Global Aviation Network
10 25000
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program © 2011 Bio-era Economic Impact of Selected Infectious Disease Outbreaks
• Respiratory and neurological disease
• Infected 265 farm workers (40% mortality)
• Most cases worked on pig farms
Nipah Virus
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program Photo: KB Chua
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Global Challenges to Wildlife Surveillance and Response to Emerging Zoonoses
There is no single agency responsible for global
wildlife disease surveillance
Veterinary and wildlife departments often lack
expertise in wildlife health/disease
Laboratories in many countries are unable to detect/diagnose
wildlife pathogens; known or novel zoonoses
Inter-ministerial
cooperation/communication is often lacking
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
EPT Malaysia
• Malaysia has all phases of EPT operational
• PREDICT working closely with three sectors of government: Wildlife, Livestock, and Human Health
• Active on both Peninsular Malaysia and Borneo (Sabah)
• Deep Forest project will asses impact of land use change on viral diversity in wildlife
• Year 5 activities include surveillance, capacity building, and policy-level coordination
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
PREDICT Malaysia
Operationalizing One Health
Regular meetings with the Zoonosis Technical Working Committee – PREDICT Country Coordinator, Department of Veterinary Services (DVS), Ministry of Health (MOH) and the Department of Wildlife and National Parks (DWNP) discuss issues related to zoonoses. Regular meetings between PREDICT CC, Sabah Wildlife Department (SWD), and Department of State Health, Sabah (DSHS) to discuss issues related to biodiversity and zoonoses. Developing study with MOH and DWNP of Orang Asli exposure to wildlife viruses Human surveillance with SWD, DSHS and PREVENT in Sabah/Deep Forest.
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
PREDICT Malaysia DWNP Sampling and Outbreak Response Team
• EHA trained 30 DWNP officers; DWNP established dedicated, self-sufficient team
to conduct active wildlife surveillance and outbreak response.
• DWNP sampled 706 animals for WDSP (funded by DWNP).
• PREDICT will support sample testing at DWNP and VRI.
Ph
oto
: T Hu
ghes Eco
Health
Allian
ce
Ph
oto
: T Hu
ghes Eco
Health
Allian
ce
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
PREDICT Malaysia
Laboratory System Improvements
• Improved testing and biosafety protocols for PREDICT labs at DWNP and VRI. • DWNP staff working at VRI to screen wildlife samples. • PREDICT and IDENTIFY standardizing protocols and SOPs for the PREDICT
Laboratory Network Malaysia. (DWNP, VRI, SWD)
Ph
oto
: T Hu
ghes Eco
Health
Allian
ce
Ph
oto
: T Hu
ghes Eco
Health
Allian
ce
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
EHA, SWD & DGFC Collaborations • PREDICT Project will integrate wildlife disease surveillance into the public health
infrastructure in order to create an early warning system for potential zoonotic disease spillover into domestic animals and humans.
• Deep Forest project will asses impact of land use change on viral diversity in wildlife and wildlife populations.
• USFW Great Ape Grant is focused on understanding and mitigating the health threats facing endangered orangutans and Muller’s gibbons in Sabah.
• Infectious Disease Emergence and Economics of Altered Landscapes Project will examine how changes in land cover and land-use has affected the incidence of disease over the last few decades. We will calculate the value of damages from past disease outbreaks, and construct a model for expected damages under different land use scenarios, and different severity of outbreaks.
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
PREDICT Malaysia: Sabah 2013/2014 Capacity Building
EHA through PREDICT conducted biosafety
training at VRI in Nov. 2012
• 30 participants (SWD, DGFC, DWNP, and DVS)
and biosafety training at SWD Lok Kawi Zoo and the WHGFL Aug. 2013
• 22 participants (SWD, DGFC, DWNP, and DVS)
• Sample collection and handling, biosafety, PPE
and PAPR demonstrations, chemical spill
situational practice, risk assessments for field
and lab work, laboratory waste management
and biosafety cabinet use.
Photos: T Hughes EcoHealth Alliance
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
PREDICT Malaysia: Sabah 2013/2014
Capacity Building
3 PREDICT training sessions in Sabah:
• 82 participants from SWD, WWF Malaysia, DGFC, SORC, BSBCC and the Institute for Tropical Biodiversity and Conservation, University Malaysia Sabah.
• Zoonoses in wildlife; capture and sampling safety, sample handling and storage; PPE and hygiene.
• Wet labs on PPE use; primate, bat, and rodent handling and sampling. Photo: MH Lee EcoHealth Alliance
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
PREDICT Malaysia: Sabah 2013/2014 Laboratory System Improvements
• SWD, EHA and DGFC have established the Wildlife Health, Genetic and Forensic Laboratory that has all the equipment necessary to store samples, run extractions, PCR and analysis on biological samples for disease surveillance. The lab is used to conduct health checks on rescued and relocated wildlife before being released into new areas or sanctuaries, to screen samples for the PREDICT and Deep Forest Project and for genetic research and forensic investigations.
Ph
oto
: T Hu
ghes Eco
Health
Allian
ce
Ph
oto
: T Hu
ghes Eco
Health
Allian
ce
Ph
oto
s: T Hu
ghes Eco
Health
Allian
ce
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
PREDICT Malaysia: Sabah 2013/2014 Capacity Building: lab activities
• EHA has shared the PREDICT Positive Control with SWD that can be
used to screen for 25 different viral families.
• The Protocols and Positive Control have been used to screen samples
collected by EHA, SWD and DGFC at both WHGFL and VRI.
Ph
oto
: T Hu
ghes Eco
Health
Allian
ce
Ph
oto
: T Hu
ghes Eco
Health
Allian
ce
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
PREDICT Malaysia: Sabah 2013/2014 Sabah: PREDICT and Deep Forest Project
EHA established Sabah Wildlife Health Unit with SWD & DGFC. The WHU is
responsible for leading the physical and diagnostic evaluation of rescued and
relocated wildlife across the state as well as conducting sampling trips to trap and
sample free ranging wildlife.
Photo: T Hughes EcoHealth Alliance Photo: T Hughes EcoHealth Alliance Photo: J Lee EcoHealth Alliance
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Summary of Animals Sampled
WHU (EHA, SWD, DGFC) has collected 11,291 specimens from 1,144 animals EHA and DWNP have collected 15,656 specimens from 1060 animals in Peninsular Malaysia. DWNP dedicated sample team has collected 4900 specimens from 720 animals in Peninsular Malaysia. To date in Peninsular Malaysia and Sabah 3,146 samples from 1,127 animals have been screened for 21 viral families. Screening at CU, DWNP, VRI and WHGFL has found 9 novel viruses and 16 known viruses.
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Land use change and EIDs
• 43% of past EID events are attributable to land use change and agricultural changes, including extractive industries
• Economic impact: $10-40 billion in potential liability over the next 10 years
• Potential for intervention?
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
• Over 150 known cases of Marburg, 83% case fatality in an outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo 1998-2000
• The association between Marburg cases and local gold mines led to closure of one mine for six years
Government Mandated Operation Shutdown
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
• In the Northern Peruvian Amazon, oil concessions produced on average 70,000 barrels of oil per day
• Local protests regarding health concerns forced closure of facilities for two weeks in 2006
• Resulting production losses of approximately 980,000 barrels (~$63,837,200)
Protestors close operations
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Brazil: Amazon basin
Bwindi, Uganda
Borneo, Kinabatangan R.
USAID EPT-PREDICT: “DEEP FOREST”
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Standardized surveys across three land-use types
• Pristine forest • Fragmented habitats • Rural urban centers
LDI 10 LDI 4 LDI 1
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Valuing Ecosystem Services
$$ Economic damages to society from disease outbreaks if we convert the forest
Future deforestation scenarios:
• business-as-usual,
• increased deforestation, and
• no deforestation
Work with the Palm Oil industry to reduce impact.
Bring $$ value of health into carbon offset program (REDD+), a global strategy to reduce CO2 production by trading the value of intact forest
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Land use change: issues
• Evidence links land-use change to public health threats
• Damages are greater than the cost of infection - trade and commerce - productivity • Environmental impact of land-use change has been
well documented. What about health impacts?
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Land use change: why is it an economic problem?
• Economics: study of allocation of scarce resources
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Land use change: why is it an economic
problem?
Natural landscapes are limited in supply and valuable
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Land use change: why is it an economic problem?
Multiple land uses, must understand trade-offs of management decisions
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Land use change: why is it an economic problem?
Tropical forest landscape
Preserve Convert
Natural value Agricultural value
Which one is better? Cannot say without knowing more!
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Questions
• Are land-use related outbreaks costly enough to alter the management plan of a landscape?
– - How much land should be converted?
– - When should land be converted to minimize the cost of an outbreak?
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Modeling land use change
• Model: simplified version of a system
a tropical forest landscape
• Equations to represent the economic value of alternative land uses
Land preservation, conversion
• Equations contain costs and benefits of different land uses
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Conversion: Benefits
Benefits
• Meet global demand for goods and services
• Generate household income
• Regional/national economic growth
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Costs • Converting land costs money - clearing forest - cultivating field • Maintaining land productivity - fertilizer - irrigation • Lost ecosystem benefits - Abiotic and biotic services - Naturally derived products - Exposure to disease
Conversion: Costs
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Model objectives
• How much land should be converted to maximize the value of the landscape?
• When should land be converted?
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
What does the model do?
In every time step - measures what is gained (in $$) by converting land
- agricultural gains
- and what is lost - ecosystem services (biodiversity, pollination) - production and conversion costs - costs of infection
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Should land be converted?
Value of preserving
Value of converting
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Application: Brazilian Amazon
• Why the Amazon?
– ecosystem of global importance
– 20+ years of land use/land cover change data
– malaria known related to deforestation
– lots of existing data
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
How are results produced?
Model equations are tailored to a regional landscape - first simulations: Brazilian Amazon
- Collect data on - value of economic activity (agriculture, timber concessions, etc.) - ecosystem service production - economic cost of a disease (treatment + prevention + lost work time)
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Application to Brazilian Amazon
0
10000000
20000000
30000000
40000000
50000000
60000000
70000000
80000000
90000000
1970 1980 1990 2000 2010
Lan
d c
on
vers
ion
(h
ect
are
s)
Year
Total conversion: models and actual
Amazon (actual)
model - no outbreak
model - outbreak
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Results: economic impact
65813.72176
5575.716179
0
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
60000
70000
Model with outbreak Brazilian Amazon
Bill
ion
s
Value of landscape
~ $60 trillion loss
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Conclusions
• Damages from outbreak can alter land use
strategies • Very preliminary simulations for a very flexible
model. – can run model for a variety of land use scenarios
• Next steps: collect data and run simulations for Sabah
Emerging Pandemic Threats Program
Outreach, capacity building and results integration
• Launching a Development and Health Unit based in the School of Business and Economics at UMS
• A stakeholder engagement program is underway to bring industry, govt., academia and others together to increase outreach, disseminate findings, models, tool kits and handbooks
• Goal is to develop public-private partnerships that use this approach to build more sustainable development
EcoHealth Alliance: P. Daszak, W. Karesh, J. Epstein, K. Olival, T. Hughes, E. Loh, MH. Lee, J. Lee, A. Tahir, K. Murray, C. Zambrana-Torrelio, M. Rostal
Columbia University CII: W. Ian Lipkin, S. Anthony, M. Sanchez, Isa, E. Liang
SWD: Dato’ Ambu, A. Tuuga, J. Shukor, S. Nathan, R. Symphorosa, D. Ramirez, WHU , WRU
DSHS: C. Rundi, M. Suleiman, T. William
DGFC: B. Goossens, M. Lynn
HUTUAN: M. Ancrenaz, I. Lackman
Our Work is supported by: USAID Emerging Pandemic Threats: PREDICT USFW Great Ape Grant USAID Infectious Disease Emergence and Economics of Altered
Landscapes: IDEEAL
Acknowledgements
EcoHealth Alliance
ecohealthalliance.org USAID
www.usaid.gov