ejra review - university of oxford...ejra review working group history of the ejra at oxford...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
EJRA ReviewOpen meetings: gathering feedback
October / November 2016
![Page 2: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Open meetings
• Professor Irene Tracey (Review Committee Chair),
and members of the Review Group
• One-hour session: 15 minutes of input and 45
minutes of feedback, questions and comment
• Presentation will be put on EJRA website at:
www.ox.ac.uk/ejrareview
• Please provide written feedback to:
![Page 3: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
What is the EJRA?
• The Employer-Justified Retirement Age, or EJRA, is a
retirement age of 30 September before the 68th
birthday that is specific to employees at Oxford
• It applies to academic and academic-related staff ie
those in grade 6 and above
• Those who wish to work beyond 67 can apply for an
extension, which will be granted only if they meet
certain criteria; any decision not to grant an
extension can be appealed
• The EJRA does NOT relate to pension age
![Page 4: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
History of the EJRA at Oxford
• Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age,
following two consultations with Congregation and discussion with the
UCU – put in place for ten years, with a review after five
• Scheme reviewed and changed in 2015 to take account of comments by
the University Appeal Court in 2014:
• Clarified Aims
• Reordered and revised criteria for considering applications for
extensions
• Revised procedures for the submission and consideration of
applications for extensions
![Page 5: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
The legal position of the EJRA
• Age discrimination legislation is different from other
equality provisions in that direct age discrimination (eg the
maintenance of a retirement age) can be justified if it is a
proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
• The EJRA is a proportionate means of achieving the Aims
set out in the EJRA policy.
![Page 6: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
What are the Aims of the EJRA?
The EJRA is considered to be an appropriate and necessary
means of creating vacancies to meet the Aims, which are:• safeguarding high standards in teaching, research and professional services;
• promoting inter-generational fairness and maintaining opportunities for
career progression;
• refreshing the academic, research and other professional workforce;
• facilitating succession planning by maintaining predictable retirement dates;
• promoting equality and diversity;
• facilitating flexibility in the academic-related workforce; and,
• minimising the impact on staff morale by using retirement to manage any
future financial cuts or constraints by retiring staff at the EJRA.
![Page 7: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Review Committee’s terms of reference
The working party has been tasked with considering the following, at the point when the EJRA has been in operation for five years:
• the extent to which the EJRA is meeting the Aims identified when the policy was established, and thus can be justified in law;
• whether the EJRA is appropriately set at the 30 September before an individual’s 68th birthday; and
• whether the policy is applied to the right staff groups.
The group will take account of:• internal data, including diversity data; • information about other higher education institutions in the UK and abroad; • legal advice; and• the views of stakeholders from across the University, including recent
retirees.
![Page 8: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Data summary: exceptions process
In the last three complete years, 2012-15:
• 264 people have retired from the University’s employment, and
• 152 have applied for extended employment of which
• 138 (91%) have been accepted, in whole or in part (nb revised procedures apply from 1 October 2015)
• c. 30% from each of MSD and SSD, c. 20% from each of Humanities and MPLS – very few from GLAM or UAS
• c.23% from women
![Page 9: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Data summary: creation of vacancies
In the last three complete years, 2012-15, the % of posts vacated that were vacated by retirement was:
• 56% for statutory professors
• 50% for associate professors
• 41% for RSIVs (the most senior research grade)
• 1.7% for academic and research staff in grades 6-10
• 12.1% for administrative and professional staff
![Page 10: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Comments?
Questions?
Don’t forget that you can also send your comments and feedback to:
![Page 11: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
The slides that follow were not used in the main presentation but to assist in responding to specific questions.
![Page 12: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Relevant UK legislation
The main pieces of UK legislation governing retirement are:
• The Employment Rights Act 1996
• The Equality Act 2010
• The Employment Equality (Repeal of Retirement Age Provisions) Regulations 2011.
![Page 13: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Criteria for extensions
It is expected that:
• any applicant who occupies an academic post or other permanent post will vacate that post and move to a fixed-term contract on an appropriate grade; and
• the applicant will identify all possible means of supporting their salary and other costs.
In all but very rare cases, applications will only be approved where grant or other funding covers the employment costs.
This is to ensure that there is no financial detriment to the University and no impediment to the refilling of the post.
![Page 14: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Criteria for extensions
The EJRA Committee considers the following:
• Is there a need to complete a specific project or duties, or to
gain the benefit of tasks already completed, which are of
strategic importance and could not be completed by anyone
else, on a non-employed basis, or on a shorter contract?
• Will the proposed extension result in the creation of career
development opportunities for others?
• Is there a demonstrable need that arises in connection with a
specific event or circumstance and that could only be met by
retaining this particular employee in employment?
• Are there stakeholder views eg from a college or the NHS, or
any special personal circumstances, to be taken into account?
![Page 15: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Who else has an EJRA?
• Universities:
• Cambridge: EJRA of 67 since 2012
• St Andrews
• Many European HEIs (eg in France, Germany, Italy)
• The Ministry of Justice operates an EJRA of 70 for
judges
• Some law firms operate an EJRA of 60 or 65
![Page 16: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Who is on the Working Group?
• Professor Irene Tracey, Medical Sciences Division (chair)
• Professor Sandra Fredman, Social Sciences Division
• Professor Gideon Henderson, MPLS Division
• Professor Lyndal Roper, Humanities Division
• Mr Richard Ovenden, GLAM
• Dr Ali Rogers, Conference of Colleges Senior Tutors’ Committee
• Professor Jeremias Prassl, Conference of Colleges Legal Panel
• Dr Rebecca Surender, PVC and Advocate for Diversity
• Dr Saira Shaikh, Divisional Secretary, MPLS Division
• Four members of Council elected by Congregation: Dr Kate Blackmon,
Professor Helen McShane, Professor Lionel Tarassenko, Dr Ian Watson
![Page 17: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Detail for 2014-15
In 2014/15, of the 49 applicants:
• 44 (90%) were successful – 8 of those (18%) in part only• 13 (27%) were from women• 18 (37%) held academic posts, 26 (53%) held research posts,
and 5 (10%) held other academic-related posts• 14 (32%) applied to move into part-time posts• 7 (16%) of the 18 academics applied to vacate their substantive
posts and move to specially created, fixed-term posts• The length of extensions varied from 3 to 60 months (most in
the range 12-24 months).
![Page 18: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Proportion of applications by division
In 2012-15, the proportion of applications by division is (proportion of total staff subject to the EJRA in brackets)
• Medical Sciences Division – 30% (40%)• MPLS – 17% (19%)• Social Sciences Division – 29% (12%)• Humanities – 20% (7%)• GLAM – 2% (9%)• UAS – 3% (13%)
![Page 19: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Proportion of applications by role type
Of the 49 applicants in 2014-15:
• 9 (18%) held chairs (statutory professors comprise 2.5% of the relevant population)
• 9 (18%) held other academic posts (compared to 15% of the relevant population)
• 26 (53%) held research posts (compared to 51% of the relevant population)
• 5 (10%) held other academic-related posts (compared to 31% of the relevant population)
![Page 20: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Data: exceptions process
Sought
extension at
65-67
Retired at
65-67
Sought
extension in
advance ie
before they
were 65
Sought
further
extension ie
after age 67
Total sought
extension
(no. and %
successful)
Total retired at
any age (incl.
those who
applied
unsuccessfully
for extension)
2012-13 16 44 7 32 55 (49 – 89%) 81
2013-14 22 33 7 19 48 (45 – 94%) 89
2014-15 35 53 7 7 49 (44 – 90%) 94
Total 73 130 21 58 152 (138 –
(91%)
264
![Page 21: EJRA Review - University of Oxford...EJRA Review Working Group History of the EJRA at Oxford •Introduced in October 2011, after abolition of default retirement age, following two](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042211/5eb08dc280113674aa3b8941/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
EJRA Review Working Group
Data: exceptions process – applications by
gender and division
Medical
SciencesMPLS
Social
Sciences
Humani
tiesGLAM UAS Total
%
female
2012
/139 12 17 14 1 2 55 25.5%
2013
/1415 6 16 9 1 1 48 16.6%
2014
/1521 8 11 7 1 1 49 28.9%
Total 45 26 44 30 3 4 152 23.0%
% 29.6% 17.3% 28.9% 19.7% 2.0% 2.6% 100% -