ee&c best practice in energy and chemical industry · rfcc power plant lpg recovery vaporizer...

38
0 EE&C Symposium held by EDB 15 October 2019 , Singapore EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry EE&C Best Practice in Japan for Petrochemical Industries in Singapore ECCJ Hidetoshi Suzuki

Upload: others

Post on 11-Mar-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

0

EE&C Symposium held by EDB

15 October 2019 , Singapore

EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industryEE&C Best Practice in Japan

for Petrochemical Industries in Singapore

ECCJ Hidetoshi Suzuki

Page 2: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

1

Energy Conservation Center Japan

Japan is one of advanced country of energy savings

Page 3: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

2

Introduction

Through the Best Practice

EECJ awards outstanding practices.

You can utilize these to improve your plants.

We’d like to provide you hints of improvement.

Advanced Effective

Versatile Sustainable

Page 4: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

3

NO.1 Energy Saving by Pinch TechnologyNO.1

NO.1 Energy Saving by utilization of LNG Cold EnergyNO.2

NO.1 Reduction of Steam Leakage from 100,000 Steam TrapsNO.3

Energy Conservation by Additional Boiler Installation to Gas Turbine NO.4

Energy Conservation of Hydrogen Plant by Utilization of Petrochemical by-product Hydrogen NO.5

NO.1 Energy Conservations by Surplus Steam UtilizationNO.6

NO.1 Energy Conservation for Liner Alkyl-benzene(LAB) Reaction optimization NO.7

Aromatic Plant Energy Conservation by Operating Supporting System NO.8

Energy Conservation of Hydrogen Plant by Reduction of Reformer Catalyst Deterioration NO.9

Recovery of Unused Waste Heat and Energy Conservation by Energy OptimizationNO.10

Investigating 10 winners’ best practices

Page 5: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

4

Categorize

5 Key issues

to realize energy conservation

a) Integration (Heat /Material)

b)Asset Integrity

c) Digitalization

d)Reaction

e) Subsidy/Fund (Governmental support)

Page 6: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

5

Analyzing 10 practices

10 practices categorize into 5 keys

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

e) Subsidy

d) Reaction

c) Digitalization

b) Asset Integrity

a) Pinch Tech.a) Integration

b) Asset Integrity

c) Digitalization

d) Reaction

e) Subsidy

Page 7: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

6

a) Integration

Pinch TechnologyPinch technology has been widely utilized from 1980s

It is a way to find an idea

of “Integration”

It cannot use only for

Heat integration but

also Materials one.Te

mp

era

ture

Enthalpy

Heat sink

Heat source

H req.

C req.

Composite Curve

Page 8: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

7

a) Integration

Targeting (Principles)

Te

mp

era

ture

Enthalpy

Heat sink

Heat source

H min.

C min.

ΔT min.

Heat source: Streams to be cooledHeat sink: Streams to be hot

Te

mp

era

ture

Enthalpy

H min.

C min.

ΔT min.

Ideal state: Vertical exchange

Page 9: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

Integration brings

•Effective use of energy• Heat Exchanging more

•Effective use of waste• Waste value up

•Reduction in environmental load• Energy conservation , Minimize losses

8

a) Integration

Page 10: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

9

a) Integration

Japanese Traditional IntegrationThe bigger the better in its effectiveness

Japanese Garden “Shakkei” : Borrowed scenery

Page 11: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

10

a) Integration

iv) Over fence integration

iii)Inside facilitiy

ii) Between 2 plants

i) inside a plant

Integration range and effectThe bigger range challenge brings the bigger fruit.

Process stream

Heat Medium

Process stream

Heat Medium

Page 12: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

2019/11/111

NO.10 Recovery of Unused Waste Heat and Energy Conservation by Energy Optimization

Te

mp

era

ture

Enthalpy

C req.

Condensing

i) Inside a plantHeat source temperature arrangement can be realized significant heat exchange.

Vaporizing

How to use this big Condense duty?Te

mp

era

ture

Enthalpy

C req.

H req.

A: Column temperature up ! = Pressure up

Steam generation

Page 13: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

12

NO.10 Recovery of Unused Waste Heat and Energy Conservation by Energy Optimization

Utilization of Waste Heat of Aromatic Distillation Tower

Low temp. Waste Heat on OH condensing

Steam Generator Low Press Steam Header

Para-Xylene Boiler

Reduction of Boiler Fuel

Installation of Steam Generator

⇒Low Press (0.2MPa) Steam:

About 20ton/h recovery

Adsorb

Separation

Section

Mixed Xylene

Xyle

ne

To

we

r

So

lven

t Sep

ara

tion

To

wer

Adsorbent

Low temp. Waste Heat recovery of Para-Xylene production apparatus

150℃

120℃

Air cooler → Kettle HX / Using Xy tower O/H heat

Page 14: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

2019/11/113

C5-

Gasoline

Mid STM headerBoiler

Tol.C9A

C10+

Condensate

Bz

C6

sp

litter

PX extract

Hot oil

120→200℃

De to

luen

e

C9

sp

litter

330℃

250℃

40→0ton/h

NO.10 Recovery of Unused Waste Heat and Energy Conservation by Energy Optimization

• 12,300coe-kl/y savings

Bottom temperature up ⇒ MP steam → Hot oil

The relative volatility goes down

Page 15: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

¥¥¥¥¥

2019/11/1

a) Integration

iii) Inside a facility

Pu

rity

%

Fuel80

95

100 H2 supplier

85

90

Quantity

H2 user

Higher

purity H2

Is required

H2 90%

Lower

purity

Can be

utilizeSM plant

A

plant

H2 97%

Naphtha

Reformer

B

plant

PSA

H2 98%+

Pu

rity

%

Fuel80

95

100 H2 supplier

85

90Plant A

Plant B

Plant A

Plant B

PSA

<Principles>Right people, Right place

Right purity, Right user

Page 16: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

15

NO.5 Energy Conservation of Hydrogen Plant by Utilization of Petrochemical

by-product Hydrogen

export

user

producer H2 purity

CO2export

H2 production

FuelHeader

PSA

Bypro

Bypro

Bypro

PSA

Bypro

Bypro

L user

L user

H user

Muser

Muser

Muser

Huser

PSA×

Page 17: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

16

High Operation Rate for H2 Plant Law Operation Rate for H2 Plant

H2 Plant

H2 Purity 97%

H2 from H2 Plant Over spec.

By-Product H2

H2 Consumption

Export

H2 Plant

purity

User classification

High purity H2

By proBy pro

Export

①Before

②After

H2 Generation in H2 PlantKNm3/d

Fuel Consumption in H2 PlantCOE-KL/d

Average from 1st April to 6th July 2014

Average from 1st December to 6th March 2015

Energy Conservation Effect

Reduction of Energy, Coe : 6,732 KL Reduction

Reduction CO2 Emission

Savings

= 791,000 coe-kl/y

Refinery Energy Saving Rate: 0.85%

H2 Supply from Hydrogen Plant

NO.5 Energy Conservation of Hydrogen Plant by Utilization of Petrochemical

by-product Hydrogen

②-①

720

580

-140

112.1

91.7

-20.4

ClassificationPurity Relaxation

Page 18: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

17

a) Integration

Deg.C

Potential

0

-50

-100

-150

-200

LNG vaporizing-160℃

Naphtha cracker-100~20℃

Chemical plant A,B,C

-13~15℃Elec. Refrigeration

The lower the moreEnergy !

En

erg

y r

eq

uir

em

en

t

LNG vaporizing

iv) Over fenceExtra low-level heat can be utilized for specific plants.

Page 19: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

City Gas

-160℃

Vaporizer

Chemical factoryLNG Depo.

LNG

Vaporizor

Over fence

Compressor

steam

Gene. Expander

Flexible operation can be realized

省エネ優秀事例-② 三井化学・大阪ガス等の事例NO.2 Energy Saving by utilization of LNG Cold Energy

Direct use of process stream

Page 20: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

Gas FacilityChemical Facility

Cracker

LNG

LNG Return 1km

省エネ優秀事例-② 三井化学・大阪ガス等の事例NO.2 Energy Saving by utilization of LNG Cold Energy

• 13,000coe-kl/y savings

• Governmental subsidy was

required

EnthalpyHeat sink

-150

-100

-50

0 H required

Page 21: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

×

“Projects for Stable Supply of Petroleum

Products” by RING

・Increase Recovery Ratioof LPG and Propylene

・Increase Crackability・Energy Conservation

RING:Research Association of Refinery Integration for Group-operation

Reduced 40,000Kl of crude oil throughput.

AichiRefinery

CDURFCC

PowerPlant

LPGRecovery

VaporizerLNG

CrudeOil

Residue Oil

LPG

GasolineGas Oil

Sea Water

Connectinga Pipeline

To reduce sea water intake.

Chita LNG ChitaLNG

×

Propylene

To reduce cold energy discharge.

Power PlantFuel

省エネ優秀事例-② 三井化学・大阪ガス等の事例For Panel Discussion

More versatile system

Sea water cooling down

Page 22: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

21

b) Asset Integrity

FoulingPlugging

AgingMechanical

Human

45%

40%

13%

Three Major cause of troubles- Fouling / Plugging

- Mechanical trouble cause of aging

(Vibration/Leakage/erosion/corrosion)

Keeping performanceShould be one of the grate energy saving solution

Page 23: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

CROF (CRude Oil Fouling) PJ *1)

Pre-heat train fouling is estimated to cost around $1.2 billion per annum in the US alone.

$ 6 billion/y losses in the World ! !

*1) Imperial College London

b) Asset Integrity

Cleaningbrings big energy saving

(=loss recovery)

Page 24: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

23

b) Asset Integrity

Recognize Specific lifespan

Each equipment have different

age and MTBF.

Appropriate maintenance brings

High performance continuously.

MTBF : Mean Time Between Failure

Page 25: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

NO.3 Reduction of Steam Leakage from 100,000 Steam Traps

24

Reduction of Steam Leakage from 100,000 Steam Traps

BPSTM(Best Practice of Steam Trap Management Translation of Boiler Evaporation

Infrastructure

Trap management

Initial zero reset

(1st Year)

Best practice

cycle (2nd

year or later)

Build complex database

Periodical all counts

accurate audit

Location analysis /

select best trap

Study zero fault

achievement method

Efficient replacement / repairment

Data update optimization

Steam Demand In Muroran RefineryFY2004 FY2005 FY2006 FY2008

Enforcement Of Trap Maintenance

Energy Conservation Diagnosis by TLV

Self EC Activity

• Managed 100,000 traps

• 18,000coe-kl/y savings

• 46,000 t/y CO2 reduction

Page 26: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

25

c) Digitalization

What does Digitalization mean?- Monitoring

- Computer control / Modeling

- OptimizationOne plant / multi plants / Whole complex

- Big Data, AIIn Japan, Artificial Intelligence has been delayed in practical use.

Page 27: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

26

c) Digitalization

Monitoring / VisualizationImprovement should start with awareness.

Recognize a gap !

Target

Benchmarking

Page 28: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

27

c) Digitalization

Computer controlThe bigger facility control brings the bigger fruit.

All facilities(Optimization)

Multi plants(Optimization)

Whole plant

Single unit

Page 29: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

28

Monitor

ActionReflux control

Reduction of Mid. Press. Steam

C5 Fraction Concentration

Toluene Tower

Pre-Splitter Feed oil

Middle Tray Temp.

Bottom Temp.

Benzene Temp.

Duty control

NO.8 Aromatic Plant Energy Conservation by Operating Supporting System

a) Optimization of Pre-Splitter Operation

b) Reduction of Load for Panel Operator

Results: Energy Conservation Achievement by Introduction of Operation System and Reduction

of Steam Ratio

• 19,600coe-kl/y savings

For Single unit

Page 30: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

29

Production PlantsCrude Oil Products

Hydrogen

Fuel

Steam

Electric

Power

Weekly Operation Schedule

Develop Cost minimum utility supply plan in real timePurchase

Purchase

Purchase

& Selling

All facilities (Optimization)

Utility control

System

Page 31: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

30

Beneficial

Optimization of Energy Balance

Optimization of SA (Steam Application)

Steam Balance

Heat And Electricity Balance

Importance of Quality & Productivity

Recovery & Reuse of Drain &

Waste Heat

Optimization of Steam System

Optimization of Drain Disposal PlaceReduction of Drain Obstacle

Reduction of Steam Loss

Fundamental Infrastructure for Steam System Optimization

NO.3 Reduction of Steam Leakage from 100,000 Steam Traps

Page 32: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

31

c) Digitalization

Big Data / AINo best practice is observed.

Page 33: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

32

d) Reaction

Process design procedureProcedure starts from a reaction.

It dominates the process.

Piping / Plots

Process control

Heat Exchange

Separation

ReactionOnion Diagram

Page 34: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

33

NO.7 Energy Conservation for Liner Alkyl-benzene(LAB) Plant

H2 Recycle

De

hyd

roP

rocess

Process Flow

Unreacted n-Paraffin Recycle

H2

Sep

ara

tion

Alk

yla

tion

P

rocess

Dis

tillatio

nP

rocess

LAB

n-paraffin

(NP) Fuel consumption(%)NP Recycle rate

Pla

nt

fuel

co

nsu

mp

tio

n

&N

P r

ec

yc

le r

ate

(%)

Recycle rate: 3% reduction

Fuel Consumption: 3% reduction

After Reduction of NP Recycle Rate

Conversion up bringsRecycle rate decreasing

Reducing distillation duty

Page 35: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

34

NO.9 Energy Conservation of Hydrogen Plant by Reduction of

Reformer Catalyst Deterioration

Desulfurization Reformer CO Conversion Decarbonate Methanation

High performCatalyst

④ Expansion of LP Steam ReboilerTube replace

Change catalysts

Reduction of Catalyst Determination

S/C Reduction

Item Target Coe ( tl/Y)

Fuel gas Consumption

Fuel gas Consumption

Steam Consumption(Equivalent to Fuel gas)

Target = Ratio to overall H2 plant energy consumption

2%Reduction

3%Reduction

7%Reduction Total

2%Reduction

Target of Energy Conservation

500

500

750

1, 750

For Steam ReformerFEED spec. relaxation

S/C ratio optimization

High performance catalyst

• 2,170coe-kl/y

savings are realized

Page 36: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

35

e) Subsidy

Support system in Japan

a. Green Investment tax reduction

b. EMS support subsidy

c. EE&C Investment

Page 37: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

36

Conclusion

New approach will be requiredJapan has been an advanced energy-saving country so far. The importance of “Best Practices” are never change.

However the evolution of digitalization will bring a grate change of energy use.

To accelerate advanced approach, we need a special supports and efforts.

We are now in a

same start line.

Page 38: EE&C Best practice in energy and chemical industry · RFCC Power Plant LPG Recovery Vaporizer LNG Crude Oil Residue Oil LPG Gasoline Gas Oil Sea Water Connecting a Pipeline To reduce

37

The Symbol of Energy Conservation

Since 2005ECCJ has been spread the

symbol mark with the visual image

of a flour-leaf clover which is

thought to bring happiness named

as “SMART CLOVER”, representing

everyone’s energy conservation

activities.

Thank You Very Much

The Energy Conservation Center, JapanSince 1978

For More Information;The Energy Conservation Center, Japanhttps://www.eccj.or.jp <from 1996>

Asia Energy Efficiency and Conservation Collaboration Center(Established in April 2007)https://www.asiaeec-col.eccj.or.jp

Japanese Business alliance for Smart Energy-Worldwide(Established in October 2008)https://www.jase-w.org/

<Disclaimer>

The views, opinions and information expressed in this presentation were compiled from sources believed to be reliable for information and sharing purposes only .Any other use of this presentation’s content should be subject to ECCJ’s approval.