educational materialthe main result of this study was that b2ar genotype (arg16 homozygotes)...

69
ERS Annual Congress Amsterdam 2630 September 2015 EDUCATIONAL MATERIAL Meet the expert 4 Asthma susceptibility Thank you for viewing this document. We would like to remind you that this material is the property of the author. It is provided to you by the ERS for your personal use only, as submitted by the author. ©2015 by the author Monday, 28 September 2015 13:00 14:00 Room G110 RAI

Upload: others

Post on 15-Oct-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

ERS Annual Congress Amsterdam

26–30 September 2015

EDUCATIONAL MATERIAL

Meet the expert 4

Asthma susceptibility

Thank you for viewing this document.

We would like to remind you that this material is the

property of the author. It is provided to you by the ERS

for your personal use only, as submitted by the author.

©2015 by the author

Monday, 28 September 2015

13:00 – 14:00

Room G110 RAI

Page 2: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

You can access an electronic copy of these educational materials here:

http://www.ers-education.org/2015me4

To access the educational materials on your tablet or smartphone please find below a list of apps to

access, annotate, store and share pdf documents.

iPhone / iPad

Adobe Reader - FREE

With the Adobe Reader app you can highlight, strikethrough, underline, draw (freehand), comment

(sticky notes) and add text to pdf documents using the typewriter tool. It can also be used to fill out

forms and electronically sign documents.

http://bit.ly/1sTSxn3

UPAD Lite - FREE

UPAD Lite is an advanced note-taking application with annotation features. You can handwrite notes,

highlight text, add sticky notes and reference images and export any type of document as a PDF or

PNG file by email or to cloud services.

http://bit.ly/1mQ1j0K

Noteability - $4.99

Noteability uses CloudServices to import and automatically backup your PDF files and allows you to

annotate and organise them (incl. special features such as adding a video file). On iPad, you can

bookmark pages of a note, filter a PDF by annotated pages, or search your note for a keyword.

http://bit.ly/TCrNad

Android

Adobe Reader - FREE

The Android version of Adobe Reader lets you view, annotate, comment, fill out, electronically sign

and share documents. It has all of the same features as the iOS app like freehand drawing,

highlighting, underlining, etc.

http://bit.ly/1deKmcL

iAnnotate PDF - FREE

You can open multiple PDFs using tabs, highlight the text and make comments via handwriting or

typewriter tools. iAnnotate PDF also supports Box OneCloud, which allows you to import and export

files directly from/to Box.

http://bit.ly/1p2SV00

ez PDF Reader - $3.99

With the ez PDF reader you can add text in text boxes and sticky notes; highlight, underline, or

strikethrough texts or add freehand drawings. Add memo & append images, change colour / thickness,

resize and move them around as you like.

http://bit.ly/1kdxZfT

Page 3: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Th e European Lung White Book is now available. It provides a comprehensive, detailed picture of the state of lung health in Europe. Drawing on a range of sources, including data from the World Health Organization and the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control, the editors have brought together epidemiologists, health economists and specialists in every respiratory fi eld to examine lung health and disease in Europe. Th e book covers:

• the health and economic burden of disease• the major genetic and environmental risk factors• individual respiratory diseases• respiratory medical practice and training• policy recommendations for a healthier future

Read it in print or online – you can’t aff ord to miss it.

To buy printed copies, visit the ERS Bookshop at the ERS International Congress 2015(Hall 1, Stand 1.D_12).

ERSWHITEBOOK.ORG

THE FACTS IN BLACK AND

white book

l1 2

INDG1X0280_Onbrez JournalAd_ERJ_r17.indd 1 7/9/12 2:48 PM

Supported by

Page 4: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Asthma susceptibility: from pathophysiology to personalised medicine

Prof. Dr Gerard Koppelman

Groningen Research Institute for Asthma and COPD

University Medical Center Groningen

Beatrix Children's Hospital

Hanzeplein 1

PO Box 30001

9700 RB Groningen

NETHERLANDS

[email protected]

Interviewer:

Ms. Carmen Veith

Maastricht University

Department of Toxicology

Universiteitssingel 50

6229 ER Maastricht

NETHERLANDS

[email protected]

AIMS: To explain asthma susceptibility by presenting the results of basic science in relation to

clinical observations. This will promote the development of personalised therapy on the basis of

pathophysiology.

TARGET AUDIENCE: Pulmonologists, paediatricians, respiratory therapists, basic scientists,

trainees, and anyone with an interest in asthma

AIMS

The aims of this session are to:

Define personalized and precision medicine in the context of asthma

Review the heterogeneity of treatment response in asthma

Analyse tools for precision medicine in asthma

Discuss evidence that this could work in clinical practice

SUMMARY

Despite progress in asthma research and management, asthma outcomes are still suboptimal. The

number of hospitalizations and number of deaths from asthma have stalled. Patients experience

insufficient asthma control in real life. [1] There are many reasons for this that include doctor related

factors (medical care that is suboptimal and not according to recent guidelines); patient related factors

(problems with inhalation technique, adherence, and personal factors that limit asthma control) and

finally disease related factors (therapy resistant asthma).

In the past, we have treated our patients as if they were the mean of a group of patients from a clinical

trial. However, it has become increasingly clear that there is a marked variability in response to

asthma treatment. Recent developments in understanding asthma pathophysiology now start to make

it possible to make asthma treatment choice more personal, called personalized medicine.

Personalized medicine is a medical model that proposes the customization of healthcare - with

4

Page 5: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

medical decisions, practices, and/or products being tailored to the individual patient. The word

“personalized” could be misinterpreted to imply that treatments and preventions are being developed

uniquely for each individual. Therefore, new concepts have been proposed, and currently perhaps the

better term ‘Precision Medicine’ is used instead.

In asthma, there is a marked heterogeneity of the disease, as well as heterogeneity in response to

asthma medication. For example, Sfezler and co-workers showed that in childhood asthma, response

to either inhaled corticosteroids and/or montelukast (defined by an improvement of FEV1 > 7.5 %)

was limited: 55 % did not improve to either drug, whereas 23 % improved after ICS and 5% to

Montelukast, and 17 % to both drugs. [2]

The question in precision medicine is if we could improve targeted treatment of asthma by

preselecting responders. Different tools could potentially be used: Genomics (DNA variation),

epigenomics, transcriptomics (mRNA expression profile), proteomics / metabolomics, phenomics

(based on a certain phenotype), exposomics, and humanomics. These tools coincide with genomic

tools that have improved our understanding of asthma pathophysiology. In this meet the professor

session, we will focus on genomic and transcriptomic tools.

Genomics: In asthma, several studies have been performed to relate the beta2 receptor (B2AR)

genotype at amino acid position 16 to the response to bronchodilators. One example is the Barge

study [3], a prospective, randomized, double blind trial, stratified on B2AR genotype. 4 times a day

salbutamol vs as needed in a 6 weeks, cross over design. The primary outcome was morning

peakflow. The main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively

affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared to placebo.

Follow up studies showed no effect of genotype on lung function when using combination therapy

LABA/ICS.

Transcriptomics: Another approach is to define subgroups of based on the transcriptome. Woodruff et

al defined a gene expression signature in airway epithelial cells of three genes that are upregulated by

Th2 cytokine IL13: ‘Th2 high’ pattern. These three genes are Periostin (POSTN), Chloride Channel

Regulator 1 (CLCA1) and Serpin peptidase inhibitor, B2 (SERPINB2). [4] In a study of 42 adult

patients with mild to moderate asthma and 28 healthy controls, gene expression signature in epithelial

brushes were related to clinical characteristics, parameters from airway wall biopsies and treatment

response to 8 weeks of inhaled corticosteroids. One of the most important findings of this study was

that ICS responders were amongst the Th2 high group. Also, novel biologicals in asthma, such as anti

IL13, may be efficacious in Th2 high asthma patients, as defined by high serum periostin levels. [5]

In conclusion, the time has come to make asthma treatment more precise. The first examples of

genomic and transcriptomic biomarkers that could be used to select patients for certain treatments

have been published. What is needed are real life studies that show that this ‘precise’ approach is

better than traditional approaches. Despite how biologically effective our treatment choices are, we

should always consider the ‘human’ factor: improve the quality of our clinical care, improving

adherence and involve out patients in making the best management decisions for themselves or their

children with asthma. [1]

REFERENCES

1. Thomas, M. Prim Care Resp J 2015 (25). 15004; 2. Szefler et al, J Allergy Clin Immunol 2005;

115:233-42.; 3. Israel E, et al. Lancet. 2004; 364:1505-1512; 4. Woodruff et al, AJRCCM 2009;

180:388-395; 5. Corren et al, N Engl J Med. 2011 Sep 22;365(12):1088-98

5

Page 6: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

EVALUATION

1. Asthma is a heterogeneous disease. In the GINA guidelines, the following patient related factors

are suggested to personalize treatment choices

a. The genotype at position 16 ( Arg / Gly) of the beta 2 adrenergic receptor gene

b. The presence of airway hyperresponsiveness

c. The level of serum periostin

d. Patient preference; practical issues inhaler technique, adherence, and cost

2. About 30 asthma genes have been discovered. Which statement is true?

a. The 17q12-21 (ORMDL3/GSDMB) genetic variants are associated with childhood onset

asthma

b. The 17q12-21 (ORMDL3/GSDMB) genetic variants are associated with adult onset asthma

c. IL1RL1 gene variants are associated with transient non atopic wheeze in early childhood

d. IL1RL1 gene variants predict treatment response to anti-IL4R antagonist

3. Genetic testing using a panel of well replicated asthma genetic variants

a. Is almost as good as flipping a coin

b. Can be implemented in clinical practice soon

c. Can distinguish between transient wheezers and persistent asthma in childhood

d. Has been FDA approved for direct to consumer genetic testing companies

4. Th2 high gene expression signature is defined based on

a. Gene expression of three genes POSTN, CLCA1 and SERPINB2 in blood

b. Gene expression of three genes POSTN, CLCA1 and SERPINB2 in nasal epithelium

c. Gene expression of three genes POSTN, CLCA1 and SERPINB2 in bronchial epithelium

d. Gene expression of three genes POSTN, CLCA1 and SERPINB2 in induced sputum

5. New therapeutic options, such as biologicals, have been developed for the following asthma

characteristics

a. Eosinophilic asthma

b. Neutrophilic asthma

c. Airway remodelling

6

Page 7: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Asthma susceptibility From pathophysiology to

personalised medicine

Gerard H. Koppelman, MD PhD

Pediatric Pulmonology and Pediatric Allergology, Beatix Children’s Hospital, University MedicalCenter Groningen, the Netherlands

Groningen Research Institute for Asthma and COPD

7

Page 8: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Conflict of interest

• No real or perceived conflict of interest relating to this presentation

• Grant support – Netherlands Lung Foundation, – Ubbo Emmius Foundation, – TEVA Pharmaceuticals, – Stichting Astma Bestrijding

8

Page 9: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

The problem

• Despite progress in asthma research and management, asthma outcomes are still suboptimal• Hospitalizations, deaths from asthma have

stalled• Insufficient asthma control in real life

• Reasons?

Mike Thomas, Why aren’t we doing better in asthma: time for

personalised medicine? Prim Care Resp J 2015 (25). 15004 9

Page 10: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

One size fits all medicine?

10

Page 11: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Time to make asthma management

more personal!

New!

11

Page 12: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

What is it?

• Personalised medicine is a medical model that proposes the customisation of healthcare - with medical decisions, practices, and/or products being tailored to the individual patient.

• First context: geneticsNow broadened to encompass all sorts of personalisation measures.

12

Page 13: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Is it a good term?

• The word “personalized” could be misinterpreted to imply that treatments and preventions are being developed uniquely for each individual

• Therefore, new concepts have been proposed: – Precision Medicine – Stratified Medicine– Genomic medicine

Momentum grows to make 'personalized' medicine more 'precise';

Alla Katsnelson; Nature Medicine 19, 249 (2013) ;

doi:10.1038/nm0313-24913

Page 14: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Expectations are high

“Tonight, I'm launching a new Precision

Medicine Initiative to bring us closer to curing diseases like cancer and diabetes — and to give all of us access to the personalized information we need to keep ourselves and our families healthier.” State of the Union 2015

14

Page 15: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

A new initiative on precision medicine

• “..approaches for detecting, measuring, and

analyzing a wide range of biomedical information — including molecular, genomic, cellular, clinical, behavioral, physiological, and environmental parameters..”

• Powered by omics techology, and large datasets handling

• Will start with cancer, but also be applied to chronic non-communicable diseases

Francis S. Collins, and Harold Varmus, N Engl J Med 2015;

372:793-795 15

Page 16: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Traditional approach

16

Page 17: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Precision medicine

a test

17

Page 18: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

This presentation

• Defining precision medicine in asthma• Review heterogeneity of asthma –

treatment response• Analyse tools for precision medicine in

asthma• Discuss evidence that this could work

18

Page 19: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Precision medicine in asthma

• What does it mean?

19

Page 20: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Precision medicine in asthma

• Use of patients characteristics to direct the best asthma management advices to this specific(group of) patient(s)

• Which characteristics?– Genomics– Epigenomics– Transcriptomics– Proteomics / Metabolomics– Phenomics– Exposomics– Humanomics

20

Page 21: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Asthma is a heterogenous

disease

“ Asthma is a heterogeneous disease, usually characterized by chronic

airway inflammation..” Global Initiative for Asthma (GINA) –Guidelines Update 2015

21

Page 22: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Asthma management guidelines do not take this into account

Reddel et al, ERJ Express. Published on July 23, 201522

Page 23: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Not really, but ….

• Treatment choices– Population-level decisions: efficacy,

effectiveness, safety, cost, regulations– Patient-level decisions for tailoring treatment:

also discuss patient characteristics (phenotype) that predict response or risk;

– patient preference; practical issues inhaler technique, adherence, and cost;

– treat modifiable risk factors; use non-pharmacological strategies where appropriate

Reddel et al, ERJ Express. Published on July 23, 201523

Page 24: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Treatment response in asthma is variable

Distribution of FEV1 response in 895 asthmatic patients aged 15 to 85 years treated with either

beclomethasone or montelukast for 12 weeks.

Data from Malmstrom et al., Ann Intern Med 1999;130,487-495

Larj and Bleecker,Chest. 2004;126(2_suppl_1):138S-149S. 24

Page 25: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Non response is significant

Larj and Bleecker,Chest. 2004;126(2_suppl_1):138S-149S. 25

Page 26: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Treatment response in childhood asthma

Szefler et al, J Allergy Clin Immunol 2005;115:233-42. 26

Page 27: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Fev1 response to ICS or LTRA in childhood is variable

Szefler et al, J Allergy Clin Immunol 2005;115:233-42.

17 %5 %

55 % 23 %

27

Page 28: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Strategies to improve

precision

• Genomics• Epigenomics• Transcriptomics• Proteomics / Metabolomics• Phenomics• Exposomics• Humanomics

28

Page 29: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

genes

Multifactorial:

Asthmaenvironment environment

Monogenic:

CF

CFTR

Genomics:

Asthma is a multifactorial disease

29

Page 30: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Asthma genetic variation

Moffatt et al, N Engl J Med 2010;363:1211-21

IL18R1 /

IL1RL117q 21 locus

IL33

30

Page 31: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Asthma GWAS Loci

Meyers et al, Lancet Respir Med 2014; 2: 405-15.

• 30 Loci identified by GWAS

• Some loci are ethnic specific

Afr Am / Japanese

• Only small risk increases

• Explains < 5 % of asthma

• Risk alleles are common

31

Page 32: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Disease subtypes: Chr 17q21 SNPs predict childhood onset

asthma

Bouzigon et al N Engl J Med 2008; 359:1985-1994

Age at onset asthma

32

Page 33: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

IL33-IL1RL1 pathway: from epithelial

damage to immune activation

Grotenboer NS et al. JACI 2013 Mar;131(3):856-6533

Page 34: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

• Study populations

PIAMA (Netherlands) & ALSPAC (UK)

• SNPs

91 SNPs in both cohorts

• Outcome

Wheezing phenotypes by latent class analysisAsthma at age 8

IL33-IL1RL1 pathway SNPs in wheezing

phenotypes and asthma

Savenije OEM et al., J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2014

Jul;134(1):170-734

Page 35: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Savenije OE/ Granell R et al., JACI 2011; 127(6):1505-12

Association of IL33-IL1RL1 pathway with

wheezing phenotypes

35

Page 36: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Association of IL33-IL1RL1 pathway with

wheezing phenotypes and asthma

Intermediate onset wheeze is strongly associated with variants in the IL33-IL1RL1 pathway (stronger effects than outcome asthma)

Gene

(nr

SNPs)

IL33

(20)

IL1RL

1

(12)

IL1RA

P

(42)

MYD8

8

(2)

TIRA

P

(8)

IRAK

4

(3)

TRAF

6

(4)

NW ref. ref. ref. ref. ref. ref. ref.TEW 2IOW 6 5 1LOW 1 2PW 1 1Asthma8 yr

3 4

Savenije et al., J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2014 Jul;134(1):170-7 36

Page 37: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Genomics

• Multiple SNPs• Some SNPs predict specific asthma

phenotypes– 17q12-21 SNPs and childhood onset asthma– IL33/IL1RL1 SNPs and wheezing phenotypes

• How good can we predict asthma withthese SNPs?

37

Page 38: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Genetic risk score

A truly useless test (one no better at identifying true positives than flipping a coin) has an area of 0.5. A perfect test (one that has zero false positives and zero false negatives) has an area of 1.00.

38

Page 39: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Fereira et al, Lancet, 2011; 378 (9795): 1006-14

Genetic risk score

39

Page 40: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Genomics

• Multiple SNPs• Some SNPs predict specific asthma

phenotypes– 17q12-21 SNPs and childhood onset asthma– IL33/IL1RL1 SNPs and wheezing phenotypes

• How good can we predict asthma withthese SNPs?

• Can SNPs predict treatment response?

40

Page 41: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Beta mimetics and bronchodilation

Salbutamol binds to the 2-

Adrenoceptor

41

Page 42: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

2-Adrenoceptor (2-AR)

genetic variation

Reishaus et al., 1993. AJRCMB; 8:334–339

COOH

Arg 16 Gly

Gln 27 Glu

Val 34 Met

Thr 164 Ile

NH2

Cell

membrane

42

Page 43: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

BARGE Beta-adrenergic response

by genotype

• Prospective, randomized, double blind trial,stratified on B2AR genotype

• B2AR –16 Arg Arg vs Gly Gly• 4 dgs salbutamol vs as needed• 6 weeks, cross over design• Primary outcome: Morning Peakflow

Israel E, et al. Lancet. 2004;364:1505-1512. 43

Page 44: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

BARGE: Patients

• Patients with mild asthma, no ICS– Mean age = 31 years– Mean FEV1 = 90% of predicted

• Patients were mathced in pairs for FEV1 and B2AR genotype

• Arg/Arg (n = 37)*

• Gly/Gly (n = 41) genotype

Israel E, et al. Lancet. 2004;364:1505-1512.44

Page 45: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

BARGE: AM PEF en B2AR Genotype

Israel E, et al. Lancet. 2004;364:1505-1512.

Albuterol modelledAlbuterol raw meansPlacebo modelledPlacebo raw means

P=0.0175

Treatment Washout

Time (weeks)

Gly/Gly

0 5 10 15 20

20

10

0

-10

-20

Mo

rnin

g P

EF

R (

L/m

in)

*

P=0.029

Treatment Washout

Time (weeks)

Arg/Arg

0 5 10 15 20

20

10

0

-10

-20

Mo

rnin

g P

EF

R (

L/m

in)

45

Page 46: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Conclusions BARGE

• B2AR genotype effects PEF response when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS)

• Asthma patients with B2AR Arg/Arggenotype (~1/6) : only salbutamol as needed

• Follow up studies: No effect of genotype on combination therapy LABA/ICS on lung function (retrospective studies in adults)

46

Page 47: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Treatment choice in B2AR Arg 16

homozygotes

•A pragmatic trial in children with asthma on inhaled corticosteroids (ICS)•1 year, 3 monthly visits, 62 children•Salmeterol SL (n=34) / Montelukast ML (n=28)•Outcome: School abcenses•Secundary: QOL, FEV1, Salbutamol use

Lipworth et al, Clin Science 2013: 124; 521-847

Page 48: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

ML reduces school absences in

B2AR Arg 16 homozygotes

Lipworth et al, Clin Science 2013: 124; 521-8

0 = no absences1 = 1-2 days2=> 2 days – 1 week3= > 1 week

48

Page 49: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

ML improves bronchodilator use,

but not FEV1 in B2AR Arg 16

Lipworth et al, Clin Science 2013: 124; 521-8

Salbutamol use

FEV1

49

Page 50: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Making therapy more precise

By understanding disease pathopysiology and targeting types of asthma, defined by transcriptomics

50

Page 51: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

T helper 2 mediated

inflammation• Woodruff et al defined a gene expression signature in airway epithelial cells of three genes that are upregulated by Th2 cytokine IL13: ‘Th2 high’ pattern

•Three genes: • Periostin (POSTN), • Chloride Channel Regulator 1 (CLCA1) • Serpin peptidase inhibitor, B2 (SERPINB2)

Woodruff et al, AJRCCM 2009; 180:388-39551

Page 52: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Th2 high

• 42 adult patients with mild to moderate asthma• 28 healthy controls• Gene expression signature in epithelial brushes related to

•Clinical characteristics• Parameters from airway wall biopsies•Treatment response to 8 weeks of ICS (fluticsone 500 mcg bid

Woodruff et al, AJRCCM 2009; 180:388-39552

Page 53: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Th2 high defines a subroups

of asthmatics

Woodruff et al, AJRCCM 2009; 180:388-39553

Page 54: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Th2 high: similar FEV1 and

reversibility, more severe AHR

Woodruff et al, AJRCCM 2009; 180:388-39554

Page 55: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Th2 high: defines group of ICS

responders

Woodruff et al, AJRCCM 2009; 180:388-39555

Page 56: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Kian Fan Chung,

J Int Med 201556

Page 57: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Kian Fan Chung,

J Int Med 201557

Page 58: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Understanding disease:

tailored treatment• Asthma

•Eosinophilis- Th2 type inflammation•Neutrophilic inflammation• Remodeling, repair

• Targeted treatment with biologicals(anti-IgE, IL4, IL5, IL13, etc)

58

Page 59: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Understanding disease:

tailored treatment• Asthma

• Anti-IL13 antibody in adult asthma, not well controlled on ICS/LABA• Efficacy in

•All patients•Subgroup of Th2 high, defined as high serum periostin

Corren et al, N Engl J Med. 2011 Sep 22;365(12):1088-9859

Page 60: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Anti-IL13 in asthma

Corren et al, N Engl J Med. 2011 Sep 22;365(12):1088-9860

Page 61: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Anti-IL13: and serum Periostin

Corren et al, N Engl J Med. 2011 Sep 22;365(12):1088-9861

Page 62: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Anti IL4R and IL4RA genotype

• Anti –IL4R antagonistand asthma exacerbations• Carriers of IL4RA risk alleleReduction in exacerbations

• Not seen in carriers non-riskallele

Slager et al, JACI 2012: 130:516-22

Meyers et al, Lancet Respir Med 2014; 2: 405-15. 62

Page 63: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Conclusion

• Asthma is a heterogeneous disease, and so is treatment response to asthma medication

•Personalised medicine holds promise for•Using genetic riks profiles, transcriptomics or biomarkers to select patient subgroups

•Most developments in eosinphilic asthma, not so much in neutrophil asthma / remodelling

63

Page 64: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Conclusion

• We are not there!

• Searching for missing heritability (Genetics/ Epigenetics

• Using Th2 type biomarkers in clinical care

• Trials comparing traditional versus personalised approach

64

Page 65: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Ready for Precision Medicine ?

“… We would be better off directing more resources to

understanding what it takes to solve messy problems about how humans behave as individuals and in groups. Ultimately, we almost certainly have more control over how much we exercise, eat, drink and smoke than we do over our genomes …”

Michael J. Joyner, Mayo Clinic, USA, New York Times

Jan 29, 2015

65

Page 66: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Future

• Improve our understanding of therapy resistent asthma

• ‘Omics methods help”

- Do not forget- improving quality of our clinical care- improving adherence - patient related factors

Mike Thomas, Why aren’t we doing better in asthma: time for personalised medicine?

Prim Care Resp J 2015 (25). 15004 66

Page 67: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Thank you!

[email protected]

67

Page 68: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Faculty disclosures

Prof. Dr Gerard Koppelman receives unrestricted grants from Dutch Lung Foundation, Stichting,

Astma Bestrijding and TEVA Pharmaceuticals for research projects non - related to this seminar.

68

Page 69: EDUCATIONAL MATERIALThe main result of this study was that B2AR genotype (Arg16 homozygotes) negatively affects lung function when salbutamol is used on a regular basis (no ICS), compared

Answers to evaluation questions

Please find all correct answers in bold below

Asthma susceptibility: from pathophysiology to personalised medicine - Prof. Dr Gerard

Koppelman

1. Asthma is a heterogeneous disease. In the GINA guidelines, the following patient related factors

are suggested to personalize treatment choices

a. The genotype at position 16 ( Arg / Gly) of the beta 2 adrenergic receptor gene

b. The presence of airway hyperresponsiveness

c. The level of serum periostin

d. Patient preference; practical issues inhaler technique, adherence, and cost

2. About 30 asthma genes have been discovered. Which statement is true?

a. The 17q12-21 (ORMDL3/GSDMB) genetic variants are associated with childhood onset

asthma

b. The 17q12-21 (ORMDL3/GSDMB) genetic variants are associated with adult onset asthma

c. IL1RL1 gene variants are associated with transient non atopic wheeze in early childhood

d. IL1RL1 gene variants predict treatment response to anti-IL4R antagonist

3. Genetic testing using a panel of well replicated asthma genetic variants

a. Is almost as good as flipping a coin

b. Can be implemented in clinical practice soon

c. Can distinguish between transient wheezers and persistent asthma in childhood

d. Has been FDA approved for direct to consumer genetic testing companies

4. Th2 high gene expression signature is defined based on

a. Gene expression of three genes POSTN, CLCA1 and SERPINB2 in blood

b. Gene expression of three genes POSTN, CLCA1 and SERPINB2 in nasal epithelium

c. Gene expression of three genes POSTN, CLCA1 and SERPINB2 in bronchial

epithelium

d. Gene expression of three genes POSTN, CLCA1 and SERPINB2 in induced sputum

5. New therapeutic options, such as biologicals, have been developed for the following asthma

characteristics

a. Eosinophilic asthma

b. Neutrophilic asthma

c. Airway remodelling