education policies in the mindanao conflict, promoting an identity … · 2013-04-24 · mindanao...

1
Conflictive Context Education Policies in the Mindanao Conflict, promoting an identity supremacy or pluralism? Issues explored in a context of conflict: Inter-ethnic relations management through education Children’s (12 year-olds) process of meaning-making Teachers training (cultural awareness and pedadogy) Education Provider Schools’ approach to cultural diversity teachers background and dealings with diversity curriculum in/exclusive of Islamic narratives Textbooks, contact Pupils’ identities Social perceptions Understandings of Conflict Discrimination Assimilation Conflict ethos Inclusion Pluralism Peace ethos How do public schools and integrated madaris in the Philippines approach cultural diversity with respect to the Muslim minority and how do these schools influence students’ identities and their perceptions of social tensions in Mindanao? School 1: Public School School 2: Integrated Madaris Education Provider : DepEd & USAID Teachers: Background Christian with litte knowledge about Muslims’ culture and langauge Curriculum: exlusive of Arabic Language and Islamic Education Contact between Christian and Muslim peers: no Education Provider : DepEd & Islamic Development Bank Teachers Background: Christian and Muslim, the Ustad only teach Islamic subjects Curriculum Inclusive of Arabic Language and Islamic Education Contact between Christian and Muslim peers: yes The study highlights the political power of education with reference to Article 29 of the CRC, addressing how this is done in countries of conflict “Education systems may, for their part, be it through the structural effects of the social stats allocation through education careers, be it through the conveyed knowledge, attitudes and identity concepts, make a decisive contribution to the creation or intensification of societal tension, and in particular ethnic tension, which ultimately develops into violent conflicts.” (Seitz, 2004: 17) Mindanao Conflict Self determination of Muslim minority (about 5 % of Filipino population) historical roots in spanish and american colonization policies. Marginalization of muslim communities displacement A study by Ayana Fabris [email protected] FINDINGS Public schools such as school-1 seem to foster children’s development into a Tagalog (and Visayan) speaking Filipino with secular ambitions. Through contact, children develop knowledge about the other , yet differences are not critically discussed and the conflict is approached in terms of ‘bad people’ and ‘traitors’; which is problematic to the extent that children remain unaware of the historical injustice behind the tensions. In integrated madaris such as school-2, on the other hand, children develop a Maranao and Tagalog speaking Filipino identity inclusive of religious and secular ambitions. Lack of contact with peers of Christian backgrounds and the circulation of Muslim political narratives foster children’s appreciation of the political reasons of the conflict; yet distance them from the Christian perspective thus leaving room for biased information to be spread unchallanged. In both schools children’s identities and perceptions of their conflictive society tend to not be critically challenged which results in generally uncritical social perceptions.

Upload: others

Post on 09-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Education Policies in the Mindanao Conflict, promoting an identity … · 2013-04-24 · Mindanao Conflict Self determination of Muslim minority (about 5 % of Filipino population)

Conflictive Context

Education Policies in the Mindanao Conflict, promoting an identity supremacy or pluralism?

Issues explored in a context of conflict:● Inter-ethnic relations management through education ● Children’s (12 year-olds) process of meaning-making ● Teachers training (cultural awareness and pedadogy)

Education Provider

Schools’ approach to cultural diversity

teachers background and dealings with diversity

curriculum in/exclusive of Islamic narratives

Textbooks, contact

Pupils’ identities

Social perceptions Understandings of Conflict

Discrimination Assimilation Conflict ethos

Inclusion Pluralism Peace ethos

How do public schools and integrated madaris in the Philippines approach cultural diversity with respect to the Muslim minority and how do these schools influence students’ identities and their perceptions of social tensions in Mindanao?

School 1: Public School School 2: Integrated MadarisEducation Provider : DepEd & USAID

Teachers: Background Christian with litte knowledge about Muslims’ culture and langaugeCurriculum: exlusive of Arabic Language and Islamic EducationContact between Christian and Muslim peers: no

Education Provider : DepEd & Islamic Development Bank Teachers Background: Christian and Muslim, the Ustad only teach Islamic subjectsCurriculum Inclusive of Arabic Languageand Islamic EducationContact between Christian and Muslim peers: yes

The study highlights the political power of education with reference to Article 29 of the CRC, addressing how this is done in countries of conflict

“Education systems may, for their part, be it through the structural effects of the social stats allocation through education careers, be it through the conveyed knowledge, attitudes and identity concepts, make a decisive contribution to the creation or intensification of societal tension, and in particular ethnic tension, which ultimately develops into violent conflicts.” (Seitz, 2004: 17)

Mindanao Conflict Self determination of Muslim minority

(about 5 % of Filipino population)historical roots in spanish and

american colonizationpolicies. Marginalizationof muslim communities

displacement

A study by Ayana Fabris

[email protected]

FINDINGS Public schools such as school-1 seem to foster children’s development into a Tagalog (and Visayan) speaking Filipino with secular ambitions. Through contact, children develop knowledge about the other, yet differences are not critically discussed and the conflict is approached in terms of ‘bad people’ and ‘traitors’; which is problematic to the extent that children remain unaware of the historical injustice behind the tensions. In integrated madaris such as school-2, on the other hand, children develop a Maranao and Tagalog speaking Filipino identity inclusive of religious and secular ambitions. Lack of contact with peers of Christian backgrounds and the circulation of Muslim political narratives foster children’s appreciation of the political reasons of the conflict; yet distance them from the Christian perspective thus leaving room for biased information to be spread unchallanged. In both schools children’s identities and perceptions of their conflictive society tend to not be critically challenged which results in generally uncritical social perceptions.