edinburgh lectures on mental science - thomas troward
TRANSCRIPT
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 1/173
Vhd
DFBCLT\@H
IDEVT\DUGC JDCVAI UEBDCED
LR
VHGJAU V\GPA\F
IAVD FB]BUBGCAI NTF@D) [TCNAL
12;2
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 2/173
MG\DPG\F#
Vhbu lggo egcvabcu vhd utluvaced gm a egt|ud gm idevt|du
|dedcvir `b}dc lr vhd p|bvd| bc vhd Qtddc Uv|ddv Haii)
Dfbclt|`h# Bvu {t|{gud bu vg bcfbeavd vhd Cavt|ai
[|bceb{idu `g}d|cbc` vhd |diavbgc ldvpddc Jdcvai Aevbgc
acf Javd|bai Egcfbvbgcu) acf vhtu vg ammg|f vhd uvtfdcv
ac bcvdiib`blid uva|vbc`*{gbcv mg| vhd {|aevbeai uvtfr gm vhd
utlndev#
V#V#
Ja|eh) 12;6#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 3/173
EGCVDCVU#
B#**U[B\BV ACF JAVVD\#
BB#**VHD HB@HD\ JGFD GM BCVDIIB@DCEDEGCV\GIU VHD IGPD\
BBB#**VHD TCBVR GM VHD U[B\BV
B]#**UTLNDEVB]D ACF GLNDEVB]D JBCF
]#**MT\VHD\ EGCUBFD\AVBGCU\D@A\FBC@ UTLNDEVB]D ACF GLNDEVB]DJBCF
]B#**VHD IAP GM @\GPVH
]BB#**\DED[VB]BVR#
]BBB#**\DEB[\GEAI AEVBGC GM VHDTCB]D\UAI ACF BCFB]BFTAI JBCFU
BX#**EATUDU ACF EGCFBVBGCU
X#**BCVTBVBGC
XB#**HDAIBC@
XBB#**VHD PBII
XBBB#**BC VGTEH PBVH UTLEGCUEBGTUJBCF
XB]#**VHD LGFR
X]#**VHD UGTI
X]B#**VHD U[B\BV
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 4/173
B#
U[B\BV ACF JAVVD\#
Bc egjjdcebc` a egt|ud gm idevt|du gc Jdcvai
Uebdced) bv bu ugjdphav fbmmbetiv mg| vhd idevt|d|
vg mbx t{gc vhd lduv jdvhgf gm g{dcbc` vhd
utlndev# Bv eac ld a{{|gaehdf m|gj jacr ubfdu)
daeh pbvh ugjd {detiba| af}acva`d gm bvu gpc?
ltv) amvd| ea|dmti fdibld|avbgc) bv a{{da|u vg jd
vhav) mg| vhd {t|{gud gm vhd {|dudcv egt|ud) cg
ldvvd| uva|vbc`*{gbcv egtif ld udidevdf vhac vhd
|diavbgc ldvpddc U{b|bv acf Javvd|# B udidev vhbuuva|vbc`*{gbcv ldeatud vhd fbuvbcevbgc**g| phav
pd ldibd}d vg ld uteh**ldvpddc vhdj bu gcd pbvh
phbeh pd a|d ug majbiba| vhav B eac uamdir auutjd
bvu |deg`cbvbgc lr d}d|rlgfr? acf B jar)
vhd|dmg|d) av gced uvavd vhbu fbuvbcevbgc lr tubc`vhd afndevb}du phbeh pd halbvtaiir a{{ir au
dx{|duubc` vhd cavt|ai g{{gubvbgc ldvpddc vhd
vpg‖ib}bc` u{b|bv acf fdaf javvd|# Vhdud vd|ju
dx{|duu gt| et||dcv bj{|duubgc gm vhd g{{gubvbgc
ldvpddc u{b|bv acf javvd| pbvh utmmbebdcv
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 5/173
aeet|aer) acf egcubfd|df gcir m|gj vhd {gbcv gm
}bdp gm gtvpa|f a{{da|acedu vhbu bj{|duubgc bu
cg fgtlv eg||dev# Vhd `dcd|ai egcudcutu gm jacobcf bu |b`hv bc v|tuvbc` vhd d}bfdced gm gt|
udcudu) acf acr uruvdj phbeh vdiiu tu vhav pd a|d
cgv vg fg ug pbii cd}d| glvabc a {d|jacdcv
mggvbc` bc a uacd acf hdaivhr egjjtcbvr# Vhd|d
bu cgvhbc` p|gc` bc vhd d}bfdced egc}drdf vg ahdaivhr jbcf lr vhd udcudu gm a hdaivhr lgfr) ltv
vhd {gbcv phd|d d||g| e|dd{u bc bu phdc pd egjd
vg ntf`d gm vhd jdacbc` gm vhbu vduvbjgcr# Pd a|d
aeetuvgjdf vg ntf`d gcir lr dxvd|cai
a{{da|acedu acf lr ed|vabc ibjbvdf ub`cbmbeacedu
phbeh pd avvaeh vg pg|fu? ltv phdc pd ld`bc vg
dcqtb|d bcvg vhd |dai jdacbc` gm gt| pg|fu acf
vg acairud vhd eatudu phbeh `b}d |bud vg vhd
a{{da|acedu) pd mbcf gt| gif cgvbgcu `|aftaiir
maiibc` gmm m|gj tu) tcvbi av iauv pd paod t{ vg vhd
maev vhav pd a|d ib}bc` bc ac dcvb|dir fbmmd|dcv
pg|if vg vhav pd mg|jd|ir |deg`cb~df# Vhd gif
ibjbvdf jgfd gm vhgt`hv hau bj{d|ed{vblir
uib{{df apar) acf pd fbueg}d| vhav pd ha}d
uvd{{df gtv bcvg a cdp g|fd| gm vhbc`u phd|d aii
bu ibld|vr acf ibmd# Vhbu bu vhd pg|o gm ac
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 6/173
dcib`hvdcdf bcvdiib`dced |dutivbc` m|gj {d|ubuvdcv
fdvd|jbcavbgc vg fbueg}d| phav v|tvh |daiir bu
b||du{devb}d gm acr {|degcedb}df cgvbgcu m|gj phavd}d| ugt|ed fd|b}df) vhd fdvd|jbcavbgc vg
vhbco hgcduvir mg| gt|udi}du bcuvdaf gm
dcfda}gt|bc` vg `dv gt| vhbcobc` fgcd mg| tu# Idv
tu vhdc egjjdced lr dcqtb|bc` phav pd |daiir
jdac lr vhd ib}bc`cduu phbeh pd avv|bltvd vgu{b|bv acf vhd fdafcduu phbeh pd avv|bltvd vg
javvd|#
Av mb|uv pd jar ld fbu{gudf vg uar vhav ib}bc`cduu
egcubuvu bc vhd {gpd| gm jgvbgc acf fdafcduu bc
bvu aludced? ltv a ibvvid dcqtb|r bcvg vhd jguv|dedcv |duda|ehdu gm uebdced pbii uggc uhgp tu
vhav vhbu fbuvbcevbgc fgdu cgv `g fdd{ dcgt`h# Bv
bu cgp gcd gm vhd mtiir*duvalibuhdf maevu gm
{hrubeai uebdced vhav cg avgj gm phav pd eaii
,fdaf javvd|, bu pbvhgtv jgvbgc# Gc vhd valid
ldmg|d jd ibdu a ugibf itj{ gm uvddi) ltv bc vhd
ib`hv gm t{*vg*favd uebdced B ocgp vhav vhd avgju
gm vhav uddjbc`ir bcd|v jauu a|d }bl|avbc` pbvh
vhd jguv bcvdcud dcd|`r) egcvbctaiir fauhbc`
hbvhd| acf vhbvhd|) bj{bc`bc` t{gc acf
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 7/173
|dlgtcfbc` m|gj gcd acgvhd|) g| eb|eibc` |gtcf
ibod jbcbavt|d ugia| uruvdju) pbvh a edaudiduu
|a{bfbvr phgud egj{idx aevb}bvr bu dcgt`h vg ldpbifd| vhd bja`bcavbgc# Vhd jauu) au a jauu)
jar ibd bcd|v t{gc vhd valid? ltv ug ma| m|gj
ldbc` fduvbvtvd gm vhd didjdcv gm jgvbgc bv bu vhd
algfd gm vhd cd}d|*vb|bc` dcd|`r jg}bc` vhd
{a|vbeidu pbvh a upbmvcduu vg phbeh vhd u{ddf gm ac dx{|duu v|abc bu au cgvhbc`# Bv bu) vhd|dmg|d) cgv
vhd jd|d maev gm jgvbgc vhav bu av vhd |ggv gm vhd
fbuvbcevbgc phbeh pd f|ap bcuvbcevb}dir ldvpddc
u{b|bv acf javvd|? pd jtuv `g fdd{d| vhac vhav#
Vhd ugitvbgc gm vhd {|glidj pbii cd}d| ld mgtcf
lr egj{a|bc` Ibmd pbvh phav pd eaii fdafcduu)
acf vhd |daugc mg| vhbu pbii ldegjd a{{a|dcv
iavd| gc? ltv vhd v|td odr bu vg ld mgtcf lr
egj{a|bc` gcd fd`|dd gm ib}bc`cduu pbvh acgvhd|#
Vhd|d bu) gm egt|ud) gcd udcud bc phbeh vhd qtaibvr
gm ib}bc`cduu fgdu cgv afjbv gm fd`|ddu? ltv vhd|d
bu acgvhd| udcud bc phbeh bv bu dcvb|dir a qtduvbgc
gm fd`|dd# Pd ha}d cg fgtlv au vg vhd ib}bc`cduu
gm a {iacv) ltv pd |daib~d vhav bv bu ugjdvhbc` }d|r
fbmmd|dcv m|gj vhd ib}bc`cduu gm ac acbjai# A`abc)
phav a}d|a`d lgr pgtif cgv {|dmd| a mgx*vd||bd|
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 8/173
vg a `gifmbuh mg| a {dv7 G|) a`abc) phr bu bv vhav
vhd lgr hbjudim bu ac af}aced t{gc vhd fg`7 Vhd
{iacv) vhd mbuh) vhd fg`) acf vhd lgr a|d aiidqtaiir aib}d ? ltv vhd|d bu a fbmmd|dced bc vhd
qtaibvr gm vhdb| ib}bc`cduu algtv phbeh cg gcd eac
ha}d acr fgtlv) acf cg gcd pgtif hdubvavd vg uar
vhav vhbu fbmmd|dced bu bc vhd fd`|dd gm
bcvdiib`dced# Bc phavd}d| par pd vt|c vhd utlndev pd uhaii aiparu mbcf vhav phav pd eaii vhd
,ib}bc`cduu, gm acr bcfb}bftai ibmd bu tivbjavdir
jdaut|df lr bvu bcvdiib`dced# Bv bu vhd {guuduubgc
gm `|davd| bcvdiib`dced vhav {iaedu vhd acbjai
hb`hd| bc vhd ueaid gm ldbc` vhac vhd {iacv) vhd
jac hb`hd| vhac vhd acbjai) vhd bcvdiidevtai jac
hb`hd| vhac vhd ua}a`d# Vhd bce|daudf
bcvdiib`dced eaiiu bcvg aevb}bvr jgfdu gm jgvbgc gm
a hb`hd| g|fd| eg||du{gcfbc` vg bvudim# Vhd hb`hd|
vhd bcvdiib`dced) vhd jg|d egj{idvdir vhd jgfd gm
jgvbgc bu tcfd| bvu egcv|gi> acf au pd fduedcf bc
vhd ueaid gm bcvdiib`dced) vhd fduedcv bu ja|odf lr
a eg||du{gcfbc` bce|daud bc atvgjavbe jgvbgc
cgv utlndev vg vhd egcv|gi gm a udim*egcuebgtu
bcvdiib`dced# Vhbu fduedcv bu `|aftai m|gj vhd
dx{acfdf udim*|deg`cbvbgc gm vhd hb`hduv htjac
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 9/173
{d|ugcaibvr vg vhav igpduv g|fd| gm }bublid mg|ju
phbeh pd u{dao gm au ,vhbc`u), acf m|gj phbeh
udim*|deg`cbvbgc bu dcvb|dir aludcv#
Pd udd) vhdc) vhav vhd ib}bc`cduu gm Ibmd egcubuvu
bc bcvdiib`dced**bc gvhd| pg|fu) bc vhd {gpd| gm
Vhgt`hv? acf pd jar vhd|dmg|d uar vhav vhd
fbuvbcevb}d qtaibvr gm u{b|bv bu Vhgt`hv) acf) au vhd
g{{gubvd vg vhbu) pd jar uar vhav vhd fbuvbcevb}dqtaibvr gm javvd| bu Mg|j# Pd eaccgv egcedb}d gm
javvd| pbvhgtv mg|j# Ugjd mg|j vhd|d jtuv ld)
d}dc vhgt`h bc}bublid vg vhd {hrubeai drd? mg|
javvd|) vg ld javvd| av aii) jtuv geet{r u{aed)
acf vg geet{r acr {a|vbetia| u{aed cdeduua|bir bj{ibdu a eg||du{gcfbc` mg|j# Mg| vhdud |daugcu
pd jar iar bv fgpc au a mtcfajdcvai {|g{gubvbgc
vhav vhd fbuvbcevb}d qtaibvr gm u{b|bv bu Vhgt`hv
acf vhd fbuvbcevb}d qtaibvr gm javvd| bu Mg|j# Vhbu
bu a |afbeai fbuvbcevbgc m|gj phbeh bj{g|vacv
egcudqtdcedu mgiigp) acf uhgtif) vhd|dmg|d) ld
ea|dmtiir cgvdf lr vhd uvtfdcv#
Mg|j bj{ibdu dxvdcubgc bc u{aed acf aiug
ibjbvavbgc pbvhbc ed|vabc lgtcfa|bdu# Vhgt`hv
bj{ibdu cdbvhd|# Phdc) vhd|dmg|d) pd vhbco gm Ibmd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 10/173
au dxbuvbc` bc acr {a|vbetia| mg|j pd auugebavd bv
pbvh vhd bfda gm dxvdcubgc bc u{aed) ug vhav ac
did{hacv jar ld uabf vg egcubuv gm a }auvir ia|`d|ajgtcv gm ib}bc` utluvaced vhac a jgtud# Ltv bm
pd vhbco gm Ibmd au vhd maev gm ib}bc`cduu pd fg cgv
auugebavd bv pbvh acr bfda gm dxvdcubgc) acf pd av
gced |daib~d vhav vhd jgtud bu qtbvd au jteh aib}d
au vhd did{hacv) cgvpbvhuvacfbc` vhd fbmmd|dcedbc ub~d# Vhd bj{g|vacv {gbcv gm vhbu fbuvbcevbgc bu
vhav bm pd eac egcedb}d gm acrvhbc` au dcvb|dir
fd}gbf gm vhd didjdcv gm dxvdcubgc bc u{aed) bv
jtuv ld {|dudcv bc bvu dcvb|d vgvaibvr acrphd|d
acf d}d|rphd|d**vhav bu vg uar) av d}d|r {gbcv gm
u{aed ubjtivacdgtuir# Vhd uebdcvbmbe fdmbcbvbgc gm
vbjd bu vhav bv bu vhd {d|bgf geet{bdf lr a lgfr bc
{auubc` m|gj gcd `b}dc {gbcv bc u{aed vg acgvhd|)
acf) vhd|dmg|d) aeeg|fbc` vg vhbu fdmbcbvbgc) phdc
vhd|d bu cg u{aed vhd|d eac ld cg vbjd? acf hdced
vhav egced{vbgc gm u{b|bv phbeh |daib~du bv au
fd}gbf gm vhd didjdcv gm u{aed jtuv |daib~d bv au
ldbc` fd}gbf gm vhd didjdcv gm vbjd aiug? acf pd
vhd|dmg|d mbcf vhav vhd egced{vbgc gm u{b|bv au
{t|d Vhgt`hv) acf cgv au egce|dvd Mg|j) bu vhd
egced{vbgc gm bv au utlubuvbc` {d|mdevir
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 11/173
bcfd{dcfdcvir gm vhd didjdcvu gm vbjd acf u{aed#
M|gj vhbu bv mgiigpu vhav bm vhd bfda gm acrvhbc` bu
egcedb}df au dxbuvbc` gc vhbu id}di bv eac gcir |d{|dudcv vhav vhbc` au ldbc` aevtaiir {|dudcv
hd|d acf cgp# Bc vhbu }bdp gm vhbc`u cgvhbc` eac
ld |djgvd m|gj tu dbvhd| bc vbjd g| u{aed> dbvhd|
vhd bfda bu dcvb|dir fbuub{avdf g| bv dxbuvu au ac
aevtai {|dudcv dcvbvr) acf cgv au ugjdvhbc`vhav uhaii ld bc vhd mtvt|d) mg| phd|d vhd|d bu cg
udqtdced bc vbjd vhd|d eac ld cg mtvt|d#
Ubjbia|ir phd|d vhd|d bu cg u{aed vhd|d eac ld cg
egced{vbgc gm acrvhbc` au ldbc` av a fbuvaced
m|gj tu# Phdc vhd didjdcvu gm vbjd acf u{aed
a|d dibjbcavdf aii gt| bfdau gm vhbc`u jtuv
cdeduua|bir ld au utlubuvbc` bc a tcb}d|uai hd|d
acf ac d}d|iauvbc` cgp# Vhbu bu) cg fgtlv) a
hb`hir aluv|aev egced{vbgc) ltv B pgtif auo vhd
uvtfdcv vg dcfda}gt| vg `|au{ bv vhg|gt`hir)
ubced bv bu gm }bvai bj{g|vaced bc vhd {|aevbeai
a{{ibeavbgc gm Jdcvai Uebdced) au pbii a{{da|
mt|vhd| gc#
Vhd g{{gubvd egced{vbgc bu vhav gm vhbc`u
dx{|duubc` vhdjudi}du vh|gt`h egcfbvbgcu gm
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 12/173
vbjd acf u{aed acf vhtu duvalibuhbc` a }a|bdvr gm
|diavbgcu vg gvhd| vhbc`u) au gm ltio) fbuvaced) acf
fb|devbgc) g| gm udqtdced bc vbjd# Vhdud vpgegced{vbgcu a|d |du{devb}dir vhd egced{vbgc gm
vhd aluv|aev acf vhd egce|dvd) gm vhd
tcegcfbvbgcdf acf vhd egcfbvbgcdf) gm vhd
alugitvd acf vhd |diavb}d# Vhdr a|d cgv g{{gudf
vg daeh gvhd| bc vhd udcud gm bcegj{avblbibvr) ltva|d daeh vhd egj{idjdcv gm vhd gvhd|) acf vhd
gcir |daibvr bu bc vhd egjlbcavbgc gm vhd vpg# Vhd
d||g| gm vhd dxv|djd bfdaibuv bu bc dcfda}gt|bc` vg
|daib~d vhd alugitvd pbvhgtv vhd |diavb}d) acf vhd
d||g| gm vhd dxv|djd javd|baibuv bu bc
dcfda}gt|bc` vg |daib~d vhd |diavb}d pbvhgtv vhd
alugitvd# Gc vhd gcd ubfd vhd jbuvaod bu bc v|rbc`
vg |daib~d ac bcubfd pbvhgtv ac gtvubfd) acf gc
vhd gvhd| bc v|rbc` vg |daib~d ac gtvubfd pbvhgtv
ac bcubfd? lgvh a|d cdeduua|r vg vhd mg|javbgc gm
a utluvacvbai dcvbvr#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 13/173
BB#
VHD HB@HD\ JGFD GM
BCVDIIB@DCED EGCV\GIU
VHD IGPD\#
Pd ha}d uddc vhav vhd fduedcv m|gj {d|ugcaibvr)au pd ocgp bv bc gt|udi}du) vg javvd|) au pd ocgp
bv tcfd| phav pd eaii bcacbjavd mg|ju) bu a
`|aftai fduedcv bc vhd ueaid gm bcvdiib`dced m|gj
vhav jgfd gm ldbc` phbeh bu alid vg |daib~d bvu
gpc pbii*{gpd| au a ea{aebvr mg| g|b`bcavbc` cdp v|abcu gm eatuavbgc vg vhav jgfd gm ldbc` phbeh bu
bcea{alid gm |deg`cb~bc` bvudim av aii# Vhd hb`hd|
vhd `|afd gm ibmd) vhd hb`hd| vhd bcvdiib`dced? m|gj
phbeh bv mgiigpu vhav vhd ut{|djd {|bceb{id gm
Ibmd jtuv aiug ld vhd tivbjavd {|bceb{id gm
bcvdiib`dced# Vhbu bu eida|ir fdjgcuv|avdf lr vhd
`|acf cavt|ai g|fd| gm vhd tcb}d|ud# Bc vhd ib`hv
gm jgfd|c uebdced vhd {|bceb{id gm d}gitvbgc bu
majbiba| vg tu aii) acf vhd aeet|avd afntuvjdcv
dxbuvbc` ldvpddc aii {a|vu gm vhd egujbe uehdjd bu
vgg udim*d}bfdcv vg cddf bcubuvbc` t{gc# D}d|r
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 14/173
af}aced bc uebdced egcubuvu bc fbueg}d|bc` cdp
utlvidvbdu gm egccdevbgc bc vhbu ja`cbmbedcv
tcb}d|uai g|fd|) phbeh ai|dafr dxbuvu acf gcir cddfu gt| |deg`cbvbgc vg l|bc` bv bcvg {|aevbeai
tud# Bm) vhdc) vhd hb`hduv pg|o gm vhd `|davduv
jbcfu egcubuvu bc cgvhbc` diud vhac vhd
|deg`cbvbgc gm ac ai|dafr dxbuvbc` g|fd|) vhd|d bu
cg `dvvbc` apar m|gj vhd egceitubgc vhav a{a|ajgtcv bcvdiib`dced jtuv ld bchd|dcv bc vhd
Ibmd*[|bceb{id) phbeh jacbmduvu bvudim au vhbu
g|fd|? acf vhtu pd udd vhav vhd|d jtuv ld a `|dav
egujbe bcvdiib`dced tcfd|irbc` vhd vgvaibvr gm
vhbc`u#
Vhd {hrubeai hbuvg|r gm gt| {iacdv uhgpu tu mb|uv
ac bceacfduedcv cdltia fbu{d|udf g}d| }auv
bcmbcbvtfdu gm u{aed? iavd| vhbu egcfdcudu bcvg a
edcv|ai utc ut||gtcfdf lr a majbir gm `igpbc`
{iacdvu ha|fir rdv egcugibfavdf m|gj vhd {iauvbe
{|bjg|fbai javvd|? vhdc uteeddf tcvgif
jbiidccbtju gm uigp `dgig`beai mg|javbgc? ac
da|vh {dg{idf lr vhd igpduv mg|ju gm ibmd) phdvhd|
}d`dvalid g| acbjai? m|gj phbeh e|tfd
ld`bccbc`u a janduvbe) tcedaubc`) tcht||bdf)
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 15/173
mg|pa|f jg}djdcv l|bc`u vhbc`u uva`d lr uva`d
vg vhd egcfbvbgc bc phbeh pd ocgp vhdj cgp#
Iggobc` av vhbu uvdafr {|g`|duubgc bv bu eida| vhav)hgpd}d| pd jar egcedb}d vhd cavt|d gm vhd
d}gitvbgca|r {|bceb{id) bv tcd||bc`ir {|g}bfdu mg|
vhd egcvbctai af}aced gm vhd |aed# Ltv bv fgdu vhbu
lr e|davbc` uteh ctjld|u gm daeh obcf vhav) amvd|
aiigpbc` a pbfd ja|`bc mg| aii {guublid aeebfdcvuvg bcfb}bftaiu) vhd |aed uhaii uvbii egcvbctd> ―
,Ug ea|dmti gm vhd vr{d bv uddju
Ug ea|diduu gm vhd ubc`id ibmd#,
Bc uhg|v) pd jar uar vhav vhd egujbe bcvdiib`dced
pg|ou lr a Iap gm A}d|a`du phbeh aiigpu a pbfd
ja|`bc gm aeebfdcv acf mabit|d vg vhd bcfb}bftai#
Ltv vhd {|g`|duu vgpa|fu hb`hd| bcvdiib`dced bu
aiparu bc vhd fb|devbgc gm ca||gpbc` fgpc vhbu
ja|`bc gm aeebfdcv acf vaobc` vhd bcfb}bftai
jg|d acf jg|d gtv gm vhd iap gm a}d|a`du) acf
utluvbvtvbc` vhd iap gm bcfb}bftai udidevbgc# Bc
g|fbca|r uebdcvbmbe iac`ta`d vhbu bu vhd ut|}b}ai gm
vhd mbvvduv# Vhd |d{|gftevbgc gm mbuh bu gc a ueaid
vhav pgtif ehgod vhd uda pbvh vhdj bm d}d|r
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 16/173
bcfb}bftai ut|}b}df? ltv vhd ja|`bc gm
fduv|tevbgc bu eg||du{gcfbc`ir dcg|jgtu) acf
vhtu vhd iap gm a}d|a`du ubj{ir odd{u t{ vhdcg|jai {|g{g|vbgc gm vhd |aed# Ltv av vhd gvhd|
dcf gm vhd ueaid) |d{|gftevbgc bu lr cg jdacu
vhtu dcg|jgtuir bc dxeduu gm ut|}b}ai# V|td) vhd|d
bu aj{id ja|`bc gm aeebfdcv acf fbudaud etvvbc`
gmm ctjld|u gm htjac ldbc`u ldmg|d vhdr ha}d`gcd vh|gt`h vhd a}d|a`d ft|avbgc gm ibmd) ltv
uvbii bv bu gc a }d|r fbmmd|dcv ueaid m|gj vhd
{|djavt|d fduv|tevbgc gm htcf|dfu gm vhgtuacfu
au a`abcuv vhd ut|}b}ai gm gcd# Bv jar) vhd|dmg|d)
ld vaodc au ac duvalibuhdf maev vhav bc {|g{g|vbgc
au bcvdiib`dced af}acedu vhd bcfb}bftai edaudu vg
ld utlndev vg a jd|d iap gm a}d|a`du acf hau a
egcvbctaiir bce|daubc` {gpd| gm egcv|giibc` vhd
egcfbvbgcu gm hbu gpc ut|}b}ai#
Pd udd) vhd|dmg|d) vhav vhd|d bu a ja|odf
fbuvbcevbgc ldvpddc vhd egujbe bcvdiib`dced acf
vhd bcfb}bftai bcvdiib`dced) acf vhav vhd maevg|
phbeh fbmmd|dcvbavdu vhd iavvd| m|gj vhd mg|jd| bu
vhd {|dudced gm bcfb}bftai }gibvbgc# Cgp vhd
ltubcduu gm Jdcvai Uebdced bu vg aued|vabc vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 17/173
|diavbgc gm vhbu bcfb}bftai {gpd| gm }gibvbgc vg vhd
`|dav egujbe iap phbeh {|g}bfdu mg| vhd
jabcvdcaced acf af}acedjdcv gm vhd |aed? acfvhd {gbcv vg ld ea|dmtiir cgvdf bu vhav vhd {gpd|
gm bcfb}bftai }gibvbgc bu bvudim vhd gtvegjd gm vhd
egujbe d}gitvbgca|r {|bceb{id av vhd {gbcv phd|d
bv |daehdu bvu hb`hduv id}di# Vhd dmmg|v gm Cavt|d
hau aiparu lddc t{pa|fu m|gj vhd vbjd phdcgcir vhd igpduv mg|ju gm ibmd {dg{idf vhd `igld)
acf bv hau cgp etijbcavdf bc vhd {|gftevbgc gm a
ldbc` pbvh a jbcf ea{alid gm aluv|aev |daugcbc`
acf a l|abc mbvvdf vg ld vhd {hrubeai bcuv|tjdcv gm
uteh a jbcf# Av vhbu uva`d vhd aii*e|davbc` Ibmd*
{|bceb{id |d{|gftedu bvudim bc a mg|j ea{alid gm
|deg`cb~bc` vhd pg|obc` gm vhd d}gitvbgca|r iap)
acf vhd tcbvr acf egcvbctbvr gm {t|{gud |tccbc`
vh|gt`h vhd phgid {|g`|duubgc tcvbi cgp
bcfbeavdu) ldrgcf a fgtlv) vhav vhd {iaed gm uteh
a ldbc` bc vhd tcb}d|uai uehdjd jtuv ld vg
bcv|gfted vhd g{d|avbgc gm vhav maevg| phbeh) t{
vg vhbu {gbcv) hau lddc) egcu{betgtu lr bvu
aludced ― vhd maevg|) cajdir) gm bcvdiib`dcv
bcfb}bftai }gibvbgc# Vhd d}gitvbgc phbeh hau
l|gt`hv tu t{ vg vhbu uvacf{gbcv hau pg|odf lr a
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 18/173
egujbe iap gm a}d|a`du? bv hau lddc a {|geduu bc
phbeh vhd bcfb}bftai hbjudim hau cgv vaodc a
egcuebgtu {a|v# Ltv ldeatud hd bu phav hd bu) acfidafu vhd }ac gm vhd d}gitvbgca|r {|geduubgc) bm
jac bu vg d}gi}d mt|vhd|) bv eac cgp gcir ld lr hbu
gpc egcuebgtu eg*g{d|avbgc pbvh vhd iap phbeh
hau l|gt`hv hbj t{ vg vhd uvacf{gbcv phd|d hd bu
alid vg |daib~d vhav uteh a iap dxbuvu# Hbud}gitvbgc bc vhd mtvt|d jtuv ld lr egcuebgtu
{a|vbeb{avbgc bc vhd `|dav pg|o) acf vhbu eac gcir
ld dmmdevdf lr hbu gpc bcfb}bftai bcvdiib`dced acf
dmmg|v# Bv bu a {|geduu gm bcvdiib`dcv `|gpvh# Cg gcd
diud eac `|gp mg| tu> pd jtuv daeh `|gp mg|
gt|udi}du? acf vhbu bcvdiib`dcv `|gpvh egcubuvu bc
gt| bce|daubc` |deg`cbvbgc gm vhd tcb}d|uai iap)
phbeh hau l|gt`hv tu au ma| au pd ha}d rdv `gv)
acf gm gt| gpc bcfb}bftai |diavbgc vg vhav iap)
laudf t{gc vhd maev vhav pd gt|udi}du a|d vhd
jguv af}acedf {|gftev gm bv# Bv bu a `|dav jaxbj
vhav Cavt|d gldru tu {|debudir bc {|g{g|vbgc au
pd mb|uv gldr Cavt|d# Idv vhd didev|bebac v|r vg `g
egtcvd| vg vhd {|bceb{id vhav didev|bebvr jtuv
aiparu {auu m|gj a hb`hd| vg a igpd| {gvdcvbai
acf hd pbii dmmdev cgvhbc`? ltv idv hbj utljbv bc
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 19/173
aii vhbc`u vg vhbu gcd mtcfajdcvai iap) acf hd
eac jaod phavd}d| {a|vbetia| a{{ibeavbgcu gm
didev|beai {gpd| hd pbii#
Vhdud egcubfd|avbgcu uhgp tu vhav phav
fbmmd|dcvbavdu vhd hb`hd| m|gj vhd igpd| fd`|dd gm
bcvdiib`dced bu vhd |deg`cbvbgc gm bvu gpc udim*
hggf) acf vhd jg|d bcvdiib`dcv vhav |deg`cbvbgc
bu) vhd `|davd| pbii ld vhd {gpd|# Vhd igpd|fd`|dd gm udim*|deg`cbvbgc bu vhav phbeh gcir
|daib~du bvudim au ac dcvbvr ud{a|avd m|gj aii gvhd|
dcvbvbdu) au vhd d`g fbuvbc`tbuhdf m|gj vhd cgc*
d`g # Ltv vhd hb`hd| fd`|dd gm udim*|deg`cbvbgc bu
vhav phbeh) |daib~bc` bvu gpc u{b|bvtai cavt|d) uddubc aii gvhd| mg|ju) cgv ug jteh vhd cgc*d`g ) g|
vhav phbeh bu cgv bvudim) au vhd aivd|*d`g ) g| vhav
phbeh bu bvudim bc a fbmmd|dcv jgfd gm dx{|duubgc#
Cgp) bv bu vhbu hb`hd| fd`|dd gm udim*|deg`cbvbgc
vhav bu vhd {gpd| lr phbeh vhd Jdcvai Uebdcvbuv
{|gftedu hbu |dutivu# Mg| vhbu |daugc bv bu
bj{d|avb}d vhav hd uhgtif eida|ir tcfd|uvacf vhd
fbmmd|dced ldvpddc Mg|j acf Ldbc`? vhav vhd gcd
bu vhd jgfd gm vhd |diavb}d acf) vhd ja|o gm
utlndevbgc vg egcfbvbgcu) acf vhav vhd gvhd| bu vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 20/173
v|tvh gm vhd alugitvd acf bu vhav phbeh egcv|giu
egcfbvbgcu#
Cgp vhbu hb`hd| |deg`cbvbgc gm udim au ac
bcfb}bftaib~avbgc gm {t|d u{b|bv jtuv gm cdeduubvr
egcv|gi aii jgfdu gm u{b|bv phbeh ha}d cgv rdv
|daehdf vhd uajd id}di gm udim*|deg`cbvbgc# Vhdud
igpd| jgfdu gm u{b|bv a|d bc lgcfa`d vg vhd iap gm
vhdb| gpc ldbc` ldeatud vhdr fg cgv ocgp vhdiap? acf) vhd|dmg|d) vhd bcfb}bftai phg hau
avvabcdf vg vhbu ocgpidf`d eac egcv|gi vhdj
vh|gt`h vhav iap# Ltv vg tcfd|uvacf vhbu pd jtuv
bcqtb|d a ibvvid mt|vhd| bcvg vhd cavt|d gm u{b|bv# B
ha}d ai|dafr uhgpc vhav vhd `|acf ueaid gm afa{vavbgc acf afntuvjdcv gm aii {a|vu gm vhd
egujbe uehdjd vg gcd acgvhd| dxhblbvu vhd
{|dudced ugjdphd|d gm a ja|}diigtu bcvdiib`dced)
tcfd|irbc` vhd phgid) acf vhd qtduvbgc bu) phd|d
bu vhbu bcvdiib`dced vg ld mgtcf7 Tivbjavdir pd eac
gcir egcedb}d gm bv au bchd|dcv bc ugjd {|bjg|fbai
utluvaced phbeh bu vhd |ggv gm aii vhgud `|guud|
jgfdu gm javvd| phbeh a|d ocgpc vg tu) phdvhd|
}bublid vg vhd {hrubeai drd) g| cdeduua|bir bcmd||df
lr uebdced m|gj vhdb| {d|ed{vblid dmmdevu# Bv bu vhav
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 21/173
{gpd| phbeh) bc d}d|r u{debdu acf bc d}d|r
bcfb}bftai) ldegjdu vhav phbeh vhav u{debdu g|
bcfb}bftai bu? acf vhtu pd eac gcir egcedb}d gm bvau a udim*mg|jbc` bcvdiib`dced bchd|dcv bc vhd
tivbjavd utluvaced gm phbeh daeh vhbc` bu a
{a|vbetia| jacbmduvavbgc# Vhav vhbu {|bjg|fbai
utluvaced jtuv ld egcubfd|df au udim*mg|jbc` lr
ac bchd|dcv bcvdiib`dced albfbc` bc bvudim ldegjdud}bfdcv m|gj vhd maev vhav bcvdiib`dced bu vhd
duudcvbai qtaibvr gm u{b|bv? acf bm pd pd|d vg
egcedb}d gm vhd {|bjg|fbai utluvaced au
ugjdvhbc` a{a|v m|gj u{b|bv) vhdc pd uhgtif ha}d
vg {guvtiavd ugjd gvhd| {gpd| phbeh bu cdbvhd|
u{b|bv cg| javvd|) acf g|b`bcavdu lgvh? ltv vhbu bu
gcir {tvvbc` vhd bfda gm a udim*d}gi}bc` {gpd| a
uvd{ mt|vhd| laeo acf auud|vbc` vhd {|gftevbgc gm
a igpd| `|afd gm tcfbmmd|dcvbavdf u{b|bv lr a
hb`hd|) phbeh bu lgvh a {t|dir `|avtbvgtu
auutj{vbgc acf a egcv|afbevbgc gm acr bfda pd
eac mg|j gm tcfbmmd|dcvbavdf u{b|bv av aii#
Hgpd}d| ma| laeo) vhd|dmg|d) pd jar |did`avd vhd
g|b`bcai uva|vbc`*{gbcv) pd eaccgv a}gbf vhd
egceitubgc vhav) av vhav {gbcv) u{b|bv egcvabcu vhd
{|bja|r utluvaced bc bvudim) phbeh l|bc`u tu laeo
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 22/173
vg vhd egjjgc uvavdjdcv vhav bv jafd d}d|rvhbc`
gtv gm cgvhbc`# Pd vhtu mbcf vpg maevg|u vg vhd
jaobc` gm aii vhbc`u) U{b|bv acf ― Cgvhbc`? acfvhd affbvbgc gm Cgvhbc` vg U{b|bv ida}du gcir
u{b|bv> x / ; : x#
M|gj vhdud egcubfd|avbgcu pd udd vhav vhd
tivbjavd mgtcfavbgc gm d}d|r mg|j gm javvd| bu
u{b|bv) acf hdced vhav a tcb}d|uai bcvdiib`dcedutlubuvu vh|gt`hgtv Cavt|d bchd|dcv bc d}d|r gcd
gm bvu jacbmduvavbgcu# Ltv vhbu e|r{vbe bcvdiib`dced
fgdu cgv ldigc` vg vhd {a|vbetia| mg|j dxed{vbc`
bc vhd jdaut|d bc phbeh bv bu {hrubeaiir mbvvdf mg|
bvu egcedcv|avbgc bcvg udim*|deg`cb~bc`bcfb}bftaibvr> bv ibdu hbffdc bc vhav {|bjg|fbai
utluvaced gm phbeh vhd }bublid mg|j bu a `|guud|
jacbmduvavbgc# Vhbu {|bjg|fbai utluvaced bu a
{hbigug{hbeai cdeduubvr) acf pd eac gcir {bevt|d
bv vg gt|udi}du au ugjdvhbc` bcmbcbvdir mbcd| vhac
vhd avgju phbeh a|d vhdjudi}du a {hbigug{hbeai
bcmd|dced gm {hrubeai uebdced> uvbii) mg| pacv gm a
ldvvd| pg|f) pd jar egc}dcbdcvir u{dao gm vhbu
{|bja|r bcvdiib`dced bchd|dcv bc vhd }d|r
utluvaced gm vhbc`u au vhd Avgjbe Bcvdiib`dced#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 23/173
Vhd vd|j jar) {d|ha{u) ld g{dc vg ugjd
glndevbgcu) ltv bv pbii ud|}d gt| {|dudcv {t|{gud
au fbuvbc`tbuhbc` vhbu jgfd gm u{b|bv'u bcvdiib`dcedm|gj vhav gm vhd g{{gubvd {gid) g| Bcfb}bftai
Bcvdiib`dced# Vhbu fbuvbcevbgc uhgtif ld ea|dmtiir
cgvdf ldeatud bv bu lr vhd |du{gcud gm vhd avgjbe
bcvdiib`dced vg vhd bcfb}bftai bcvdiib`dced vhav
vhgt`hv*{gpd| bu alid vg {|gfted |dutivu gc vhdjavd|bai {iacd) au bc vhd et|d gm fbudaud lr
jdcvai v|davjdcv) acf vhd ibod# Bcvdiib`dced
jacbmduvu bvudim lr |du{gcub}dcduu) acf vhd phgid
aevbgc gm vhd egujbe jbcf bc l|bc`bc` vhd
d}gitvbgca|r {|geduu m|gj bvu mb|uv ld`bccbc`u t{
vg bvu {|dudcv htjac uva`d bu cgvhbc` diud ltv a
egcvbctai bcvdiib`dcv |du{gcud vg vhd fdjacf
phbeh daeh uva`d bc vhd {|g`|duu hau jafd mg| ac
afntuvjdcv ldvpddc bvudim acf bvu dc}b|gcjdcv#
Ubced) vhdc) pd ha}d |deg`cb~df vhd {|dudced gm a
tcb}d|uai bcvdiib`dced {d|jdavbc` aii vhbc`u) pd
jtuv aiug |deg`cb~d a eg||du{gcfbc`
|du{gcub}dcduu hbffdc fdd{ fgpc bc vhdb| cavt|d
acf |dafr vg ld eaiidf bcvg aevbgc phdc a{{daidf
vg# Aii jdcvai v|davjdcv fd{dcfu gc vhbu
|du{gcub}dcduu gm u{b|bv bc bvu igpd| fd`|ddu vg
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 24/173
hb`hd| fd`|ddu gm bvudim# Bv bu hd|d vhav vhd
fbmmd|dced ldvpddc vhd jdcvai uebdcvbuv acf vhd
tcbcuv|tevdf {d|ugc egjdu bc? vhd mg|jd| ocgpugm vhbu |du{gcub}dcduu acf jaodu tud gm bv) acf
vhd iavvd| eaccgv tud bv ldeatud hd fgdu cgv ocgp
bv#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 25/173
BBB
VHD TCBVR GM VHD U[B\BV#
Pd ha}d cgp {a}df vhd par mg| tcfd|uvacfbc`
phav bu jdacv lr ,vhd tcbvr gm vhd u{b|bv#, Bc vhd
mb|uv egced{vbgc gm u{b|bv au vhd tcfd|irbc` g|b`bcgm aii vhbc`u pd udd a tcb}d|uai utluvaced phbeh)
av vhbu uva`d) bu cgv fbmmd|dcvbavdf bcvg acr u{debmbe
mg|ju# Vhbu bu cgv a qtduvbgc gm ugjd lr`gcd
vbjd) ltv utlubuvu av d}d|r jgjdcv gm aii vbjd bc
vhd bccd|jguv cavt|d gm aii ldbc`? acf phdc pdudd vhbu) pd udd vhav vhd fb}bubgc ldvpddc gcd
u{debmbe mg|j acf acgvhd| hau ldigp bv a fdd{
duudcvbai tcbvr) phbeh aevu au vhd ut{{g|vd| gm aii
vhd ud}d|ai mg|ju gm bcfb}bftaibvr a|bubc` gtv gm bv#
Acf au gt| vhgt`hv {dcdv|avdu fdd{d| bcvg vhd
cavt|d gm vhbu aii*{|gftebc` u{b|bvtai utluvaced
pd udd vhav bv eaccgv ld ibjbvdf vg acr gcd
{g|vbgc gm u{aed) ltv jtuv ld ibjbviduu au u{aed
bvudim) acf vhav vhd bfda gm acr {g|vbgc gm u{aed
phd|d bv bu cgv bu bcegcedb}alid# Bv bu gcd gm vhgud
bcvtbvb}d {d|ed{vbgcu m|gj phbeh vhd htjac
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 26/173
jbcf eac cd}d| `dv apar vhav vhbu {|bjg|fbai) aii*
`dcd|avbc` ib}bc` u{b|bv jtuv ld egjjdcut|avd
pbvh bcmbcbvtfd) acf pd eac vhd|dmg|d cd}d| vhbco gm bv gvhd|pbud vhac au tcb}d|uai g| bcmbcbvd# Cgp
bv bu a javhdjavbeai v|tvh vhav vhd bcmbcbvd jtuv
ld a tcbvr# Rgt eaccgv ha}d vpg bcmbcbvdu) mg|
vhdc cdbvhd| pgtif ld bcmbcbvd) daeh pgtif ld
ibjbvdf lr vhd gvhd|) cg| eac rgt u{ibv vhd bcmbcbvdt{ bcvg m|aevbgcu# Vhd bcmbcbvd bu javhdjavbeaiir
duudcvbai tcbvr# Vhbu bu a {gbcv gc phbeh vgg jteh
uv|duu eaccgv ld iabf) mg| vhd|d mgiigp m|gj bv vhd
jguv bj{g|vacv egcudqtdcedu# Tcbvr) au uteh)
eac ld cdbvhd| jtivb{ibdf cg| fb}bfdf) mg| dbvhd|
g{d|avbgc fduv|gru vhd tcbvr# Lr jtivb{irbc`) pd
{|gfted a {it|aibvr gm tcbvu gm vhd uajd ueaid au
vhd g|b`bcai? acf lr fb}bfbc`) pd {|gfted a
{it|aibvr gm tcbvu gm a ujaiid| ueaid? acf a
{it|aibvr gm tcbvu bu cgv tcbvr ltv jtivb{ibebvr#
Vhd|dmg|d bm pd pgtif {dcdv|avd ldigp vhd
gtvpa|f cavt|d gm vhd bcfb}bftai vg vhav
bccd|jguv {|bceb{id gm hbu ldbc` m|gj phbeh hbu
bcfb}bftaibvr vaodu bvu |bud) pd eac fg ug gcir lr
{auubc` ldrgcf vhd egced{vbgc gm bcfb}bftai
dxbuvdced bcvg vhav gm vhd tcbvr gm tcb}d|uai ldbc`#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 27/173
Vhbu jar a{{da| vg ld a jd|dir {hbigug{hbeai
aluv|aevbgc) ltv vhd uvtfdcv phg pgtif {|gfted
{|aevbeai |dutivu jtuv |daib~d vhav vhdud aluv|aev`dcd|aib~avbgcu a|d vhd mgtcfavbgc gm vhd
{|aevbeai pg|o hd bu `gbc` vg fg#
Cgp vhd `|dav maev vg ld |deg`cb~df algtv a tcbvr
bu vhav) ldeatud bv bu a ubc`id tcbv) phd|d}d| bv bu av
aii vhd phgid gm bv jtuv ld# Vhd jgjdcv pd aiigp gt| jbcf vg pacfd| gmm vg vhd bfda gm dxvdcubgc bc
u{aed acf uar vhav gcd {a|v gm vhd tcbv bu hd|d acf
acgvhd| vhd|d) pd ha}d fduedcfdf m|gj vhd bfda
gm tcbvr bcvg vhav gm {a|vu g| m|aevbgcu gm a ubc`id
tcbv) phbeh bu vg {auu bcvg vhd bfda gm ajtivb{ibebvr gm ujaiid| tcbvu) acf bc vhav eaud pd
a|d fdaibc` pbvh vhd |diavb}d) g| vhd |diavbgc
utlubuvbc` ldvpddc vpg g| jg|d dcvbvbdu phbeh
a|d vhd|dmg|d ibjbvdf lr daeh gvhd| ) acf ug ha}d
{auudf gtv gm vhd |d`bgc gm ubj{id tcbvr phbeh bu
vhd alugitvd# Bv bu) vhd|dmg|d) a javhdjavbeai
cdeduubvr vhav) ldeatud vhd g|b`bcavbc` Ibmd*
{|bceb{id bu bcmbcbvd) bv bu a ubc`id tcbv) acf
egcudqtdcvir) phd|d}d| bv bu av aii) vhd phgid gm bv
jtuv ld {|dudcv# Ltv ldeatud bv bu bcmbcbvd ) g|
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 28/173
ibjbviduu) bv bu d}d|rphd|d) acf vhd|dmg|d bv
mgiigpu vhav vhd phgid gm u{b|bv jtuv ld {|dudcv av
d}d|r {gbcv bc u{aed av vhd uajd jgjdcv# U{b|bvbu vhtu gjcb{|dudcv bc bvu dcvb|dvr ) acf bv bu
aeeg|fbc`ir ig`beaiir eg||dev vhav av d}d|r
jgjdcv gm vbjd aii u{b|bv bu egcedcv|avdf av acr
{gbcv bc u{aed vhav pd jar ehggud vg mbx gt|
vhgt`hv t{gc# Vhbu bu vhd mtcfajdcvai maev gm aii ldbc`) acf bv bu mg| vhbu |daugc vhav B ha}d
{|d{a|df vhd par mg| bv lr iarbc` fgpc vhd
|diavbgc ldvpddc u{b|bv acf javvd| au vhav
ldvpddc bfda acf mg|j) gc vhd gcd hacf vhd
alugitvd m|gj phbeh vhd didjdcvu gm vbjd acf
u{aed a|d dcvb|dir aludcv) acf gc vhd gvhd| vhd
|diavb}d phbeh bu dcvb|dir fd{dcfdcv gc vhgud
didjdcvu# Vhbu `|dav maev bu vhav {t|d u{b|bv
egcvbctaiir utlubuvu bc vhd alugitvd) phdvhd| bc a
eg|{g|dai lgfr g| cgv? acf m|gj bv aii vhd
{hdcgjdca gm ldbc` migp) phdvhd| gc vhd jdcvai
{iacd g| vhd {hrubeai# Vhd ocgpidf`d gm vhbu maev
|d`a|fbc` u{b|bv bu vhd laubu gm aii egcuebgtu
u{b|bvtai g{d|avbgc) acf vhd|dmg|d bc {|g{g|vbgc
vg gt| bce|daubc` |deg`cbvbgc gm bv gt| {gpd| gm
{|gftebc` gtvpa|f }bublid |dutivu lr vhd aevbgc gm
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 29/173
gt| vhgt`hv pbii `|gp# Vhd phgid bu `|davd| vhac
bvu {a|v) acf vhd|dmg|d) bm) lr gt| |deg`cbvbgc gm
vhbu tcbvr) pd eac egcedcv|avd aii u{b|bv bcvg acr `b}dc {gbcv av acr jgjdcv) pd vhd|dlr bceitfd
acr bcfb}bftaib~avbgc gm bv vhav pd jar pbuh vg
fdai pbvh# Vhd {|aevbeai bj{g|vaced gm vhbu
egceitubgc bu vgg gl}bgtu vg cddf dcia|`bc` t{gc#
[t|d u{b|bv bu vhd Ibmd*{|bceb{id egcubfd|df a{a|vm|gj vhd jav|bx bc phbeh bv vaodu |diavbgc vg vbjd
acf u{aed bc a {a|vbetia| mg|j# Bc vhbu au{dev bv bu
{t|d bcvdiib`dced tcfbmmd|dcvbavdf bcvg
bcfb}bftaibvr# Au {t|d bcvdiib`dced bv bu bcmbcbvd
|du{gcub}dcduu acf utued{vblbibvr# Au fd}gbf gm |diavbgc vg vbjd acf u{aed bv bu fd}gbf gm
bcfb}bftai {d|ugcaibvr# Bv bu) vhd|dmg|d) bc vhbu
au{dev a {t|dir bj{d|ugcai didjdcv t{gc phbeh)
lr |daugc gm bvu bchd|dcv bcvdiib`dced acf
utued{vblbibvr) pd eac bj{|duu acr |deg`cbvbgc gm
{d|ugcaibvr vhav pd pbii# Vhdud a|d vhd `|dav maevu
vhav vhd jdcvai uebdcvbuv pg|ou pbvh) acf vhd
uvtfdcv pbii fg pdii vg {gcfd| fdd{ir gc vhdb|
ub`cbmbeaced acf gc vhd |du{gcublbibvbdu phbeh
vhdb| |daib~avbgc jtuv cdeduua|bir ea||r pbvh bv#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 30/173
B]#
UTLNDEVB]D ACF GLNDEVB]D
JBCF#
T{ vg vhbu {gbcv bv hau lddc cdeduua|r vg iar vhd
mgtcfavbgcu gm vhd uebdced lr vhd uvavdjdcv gm hb`hir aluv|aev `dcd|ai {|bceb{idu phbeh pd ha}d
|daehdf lr {t|dir jdva{hrubeai |daugcbc`# Pd
cgp {auu gc vg vhd egcubfd|avbgc gm ed|vabc
cavt|ai iapu phbeh ha}d lddc duvalibuhdf lr a
igc` ud|bdu gm dx{d|bjdcvu acf glud|}avbgcu) vhdmtii jdacbc` acf bj{g|vaced gm phbeh pbii
ldegjd eida| phdc pd udd vhdb| a{{ibeavbgc vg vhd
`dcd|ai {|bceb{idu phbeh ha}d hbvhd|vg geet{bdf
gt| avvdcvbgc# Vhd {hdcgjdca gm hr{cgubu a|d
cgp ug mtiir |deg`cb~df au duvalibuhdf uebdcvbmbe
maevu vhav bv bu qtbvd ut{d|mitgtu vg fbuetuu vhd
qtduvbgc gm vhdb| e|dfblbibvr# Vpg `|dav jdfbeai
uehggiu ha}d lddc mgtcfdf t{gc vhdj) acf bc
ugjd egtcv|bdu vhdr ha}d ldegjd vhd utlndev gm
u{debai id`buiavbgc# Vhd qtduvbgc ldmg|d tu av vhd
{|dudcv far bu) cgv au vg vhd e|dfblbibvr gm vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 31/173
maevu) ltv au vg vhd {|g{d| bcmd|dcedu vg ld f|apc
m|gj vhdj) acf a eg||dev a{{|dhdcubgc gm vhdud
bcmd|dcedu bu gcd gm vhd jguv }aitalid abfu vg vhdjdcvai uebdcvbuv) mg| bv egcmb|ju vhd egceitubgcu
gm {t|dir a {|bg|b |daugcbc` lr ac a||ar gm
dx{d|bjdcvai bcuvacedu phbeh {iaedu vhd
eg||devcduu gm vhgud egceitubgcu ldrgcf fgtlv#
Vhd `|dav v|tvh phbeh vhd uebdced gm hr{cgvbujhau l|gt`hv vg ib`hv bu vhd ftai cavt|d gm vhd
htjac jbcf# Jteh egcmibev dxbuvu ldvpddc
fbmmd|dcv p|bvd|u au vg phdvhd| vhbu ftaibvr |dutivu
m|gj vhd {|dudced gm vpg aevtaiir ud{a|avd jbcfu
bc vhd gcd jac) g| bc vhd aevbgc gm vhd uajd jbcfbc vhd dj{igrjdcv gm fbmmd|dcv mtcevbgcu# Vhbu bu
gcd gm vhgud fbuvbcevbgcu pbvhgtv a fbmmd|dced
phbeh a|d ug {|gibmbe a ugt|ed gm hbcf|aced vg vhd
g{dcbc` gtv gm v|tvh# A jac jtuv ld a ubc`id
bcfb}bftaibvr vg ld a jac av aii) acf) ug) vhd cdv
|dutiv bu vhd uajd phdvhd| pd egcedb}d gm hbu
}a|bdf jgfdu gm jdcvai aevbgc au {|geddfbc`
m|gj a udv gm ud{a|avd jbcfu uv|tc`) ug vg u{dao)
gc vhd vh|daf gm hbu gcd bcfb}bftaibvr acf daeh
afa{vdf vg a {a|vbetia| tud) g| au }a|bdf mtcevbgcu
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 32/173
gm a ubc`id jbcf> bc dbvhd| eaud pd a|d fdaibc`
pbvh a ubc`id bcfb}bftaibvr) acf hgp pd jar
{bevt|d vhd phddi*pg|o gm vhd jdcvai jdehacbujbu jd|dir a qtduvbgc gm phav {bevt|d pbii l|bc` vhd
cavt|d gm bvu aevbgc hgjd vg tu jguv eida|ir#
Vhd|dmg|d) au a javvd| gm egc}dcbdced) B uhaii bc
vhdud idevt|du u{dao gm vhbu ftai aevbgc au vhgt`h
bv {|geddfdf m|gj vpg jbcfu) ac gtvd| acf acbccd|) acf vhd bccd| jbcf pd pbii eaii vhd
utlndevb}d jbcf acf vhd gtvd| vhd glndevb}d) lr
phbeh cajdu vhd fbuvbcevbgc bu jguv m|dqtdcvir
bcfbeavdf bc vhd ibvd|avt|d gm vhd utlndev#
A igc` ud|bdu gm ea|dmti dx{d|bjdcvu lr hb`hir*v|abcdf glud|}d|u) ugjd gm vhdj jdc gm pg|if*
pbfd |d{tvavbgc) hau mtiir duvalibuhdf ed|vabc
|dja|oalid fbmmd|dcedu ldvpddc vhd aevbgc gm vhd
utlndevb}d acf vhav gm vhd glndevb}d jbcf phbeh
jar ld l|bdmir uvavdf au mgiigpu# Vhd utlndevb}d
jbcf bu gcir alid vg |daugc fdftevb}dir acf cgv
bcftevb}dir) phbid vhd glndevb}d jbcf eac fg
lgvh# Fdftevb}d |daugcbc` bu vhd {t|d uriig`buj
phbeh uhgpu phr a vhb|f {|g{gubvbgc jtuv
cdeduua|bir |dutiv bm vpg gvhd|u a|d auutjdf) ltv
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 33/173
phbeh fgdu cgv hdi{ tu vg fdvd|jbcd phdvhd| vhd
vpg bcbvbai uvavdjdcvu a|d v|td g| cgv# Vg
fdvd|jbcd vhbu bu vhd {|g}bced gm bcftevb}d|daugcbc` phbeh f|apu bvu egceitubgcu m|gj vhd
glud|}avbgc gm a ud|bdu gm maevu# Vhd |diavbgc gm
vhd vpg jgfdu gm |daugcbc` bu vhav) mb|uv lr
glud|}bc` a utmmbebdcv ctjld| gm bcuvacedu) pd
bcftevb}dir |daeh vhd egceitubgc vhav a ed|vabc{|bceb{id bu gm `dcd|ai a{{ibeavbgc) acf vhdc pd
dcvd| t{gc vhd fdftevb}d {|geduu lr auutjbc`
vhd v|tvh gm vhbu {|bceb{id acf fdvd|jbcbc` phav
|dutiv jtuv mgiigp bc a {a|vbetia| eaud gc vhd
hr{gvhdubu gm bvu v|tvh# Vhtu fdftevb}d |daugcbc`
{|geddfu gc vhd auutj{vbgc gm vhd eg||devcduu gm
ed|vabc hr{gvhdudu g| ut{{gubvbgcu pbvh phbeh bv
udvu gtv> bv bu cgv egced|cdf pbvh vhd v|tvh g|
maiubvr gm vhgud ut{{gubvbgcu) ltv gcir pbvh vhd
qtduvbgc au vg phav |dutivu jtuv cdeduua|bir
mgiigp ut{{gubc` vhdj vg ld v|td# Bcftevb}d
|daugcbc`? gc vhd gvhd| hacf) bu vhd {|geduu lr
phbeh pd egj{a|d a ctjld| gm ud{a|avd
bcuvacedu pbvh gcd acgvhd| tcvbi pd udd vhd
egjjgc maevg| vhav `b}du |bud vg vhdj aii#
Bcftevbgc {|geddfu lr vhd egj{a|bugc gm maevu)
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 34/173
acf fdftevbgc lr vhd a{{ibeavbgc gm tcb}d|uai
{|bceb{idu# Cgp bv bu vhd fdftevb}d jdvhgf gcir
phbeh bu mgiigpdf lr vhd utlndevb}d jbcf#Bcctjd|alid dx{d|bjdcvu gc {d|ugcu bc vhd
hr{cgvbe uvavd ha}d uhgpc vhav vhd utlndevb}d
jbcf bu tvvd|ir bcea{alid gm jaobc` vhd udidevbgc
acf egj{a|bugc phbeh a|d cdeduua|r vg vhd
bcftevb}d {|geduu) ltv pbii aeed{v acr ut``duvbgc)hgpd}d| maiud) ltv ha}bc` gced aeed{vdf acr
ut``duvbgc) bv bu uv|bevir ig`beai bc fdftebc` vhd
{|g{d| egceitubgcu m|gj bv) acf pg|ou gtv d}d|r
ut``duvbgc vg vhd jbctvduv m|aevbgc gm vhd |dutivu
phbeh migp m|gj bv#
Au a egcudqtdced gm vhbu bv mgiigpu vhav vhd
utlndevb}d jbcf bu dcvb|dir tcfd| vhd egcv|gi gm
vhd glndevb}d jbcf# Pbvh vhd tvjguv mbfdibvr bv
|d{|gftedu acf pg|ou gtv vg bvu mbcai
egcudqtdcedu phavd}d| vhd glndevb}d jbcf
bj{|duudu t{gc bv? acf vhd maevu gm hr{cgvbuj
uhgp vhav bfdau eac ld bj{|duudf gc vhd
utlndevb}d jbcf lr vhd glndevb}d jbcf gm acgvhd|
au pdii au lr vhav gm bvu gpc bcfb}bftaibvr# Vhbu bu
a jguv bj{g|vacv {gbcv) mg| bv bu gc vhbu
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 35/173
ajdcalbibvr vg ut``duvbgc lr vhd vhgt`hv gm
acgvhd| vhav aii vhd {hdcgjdca gm hdaibc`)
phdvhd| {|dudcv g| aludcv) gm vdid{avhr acf vhdibod) fd{dcf# Tcfd| vhd egcv|gi gm vhd {|aevbudf
hr{cgvbuv vhd }d|r {d|ugcaibvr gm vhd utlndev
ldegjdu ehac`df mg| vhd vbjd ldbc`? hd ldibd}du
hbjudim vg ld phavd}d| vhd g{d|avg| vdiiu hbj hd
bu> hd bu a upbjjd| l|dauvbc` vhd pa}du) a lb|fmirbc` bc vhd ab|) a ugifbd| bc vhd vtjtiv gm lavvid)
ac Bcfbac uvdaivhbir v|aeobc` hbu }bevbj> bc uhg|v)
mg| vhd vbjd ldbc`) hd bfdcvbmbdu hbjudim pbvh acr
{d|ugcaibvr vhav bu bj{|duudf t{gc hbj lr vhd
pbii gm vhd g{d|avg|) acf aevu vhd {a|v pbvh
bcbjbvalid aeet|aer# Ltv vhd dx{d|bjdcvu gm
hr{cgvbuj `g mt|vhd| vhac vhbu) acf uhgp vhd
dxbuvdced bc vhd utlndevb}d jbcf gm {gpd|u ma|
v|acuedcfbc` acr dxd|ebudf lr vhd glndevb}d jbcf
vh|gt`h vhd jdfbtj gm vhd {hrubeai udcudu?
{gpd|u gm vhgt`hv*|dafbc`) gm vhgt`hv*
v|acumd|dced) gm eiab|}graced) acf vhd ibod) aii gm
phbeh a|d m|dqtdcvir jacbmduvdf phdc vhd
{avbdcv bu l|gt`hv bcvg vhd hb`hd| jdujd|be uvavd?
acf pd ha}d vhtu dx{d|bjdcvai {|ggm gm vhd
dxbuvdced bc gt|udi}du gm v|acuedcfdcvai maetivbdu
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 36/173
vhd mtii fd}dig{jdcv acf egcuebgtu egcv|gi gm
phbeh pgtif {iaed tu bc a {d|mdevir cdp u{hd|d gm
ibmd#
Ltv bv uhgtif ld cgvdf vhav vhd egcv|gi jtuv
ld gt| gpc acf cgv vhav gm acr dxvd|cai
bcvdiib`dced phdvhd| bc vhd miduh g| gtv gm bv#
Ltv {d|ha{u vhd jguv bj{g|vacv maev phbeh
hr{cgvbe dx{d|bjdcvu ha}d fdjgcuv|avdf bu vhav
vhd utlndevb}d jbcf bu vhd ltbifd| gm vhd lgfr#
Vhd utlndevb}d dcvbvr bc vhd {avbdcv bu alid vg
fba`cgud vhd eha|aevd| gm vhd fbudaud m|gj phbeh
hd bu utmmd|bc` acf vg {gbcv gtv utbvalid |djdfbdu)
bcfbeavbc` a {hrubgig`beai ocgpidf`d dxeddfbc`
vhav gm vhd jguv hb`hir v|abcdf {hrubebacu) acf
aiug a ocgpidf`d gm vhd eg||du{gcfdcedu ldvpddc
fbudaudf egcfbvbgcu gm vhd lgfbir g|`acu acf vhd
javd|bai |djdfbdu phbeh eac ammg|f |dibdm# Acf
m|gj vhbu bv bu ltv a uvd{ mt|vhd| vg vhgudctjd|gtu bcuvacedu bc phbeh bv dcvb|dir
fbu{dcudu pbvh vhd tud gm javd|bai |djdfbdu acf
bvudim pg|ou fb|devir gc vhd g|`acbuj) ug vhav
egj{idvd |duvg|avbgc vg hdaivh mgiigpu au vhd
|dutiv gm vhd ut``duvbgcu gm {d|mdev ugtcfcduu
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 37/173
jafd lr vhd g{d|avg| vg vhd {avbdcv phbid bc vhd
hr{cgvbe uvavd#
Cgp vhdud a|d maevu mtiir duvalibuhdf lr htcf|dfu
gm dx{d|bjdcvu egcftevdf lr a }a|bdvr gm
bc}duvb`avg|u bc fbmmd|dcv {a|vu gm vhd pg|if) acf
m|gj vhdj pd jar f|ap vpg bcmd|dcedu gm vhd
hb`hduv bj{g|vaced> gcd) vhav vhd utlndevb}d
jbcf bu bc bvudim alugitvdir bj{d|ugcai) acf vhdgvhd| vhav bv bu vhd ltbifd| gm vhd lgfr) g| bc gvhd|
pg|fu bv bu vhd e|davb}d {gpd| bc vhd bcfb}bftai#
Vhav bv bu bj{d|ugcai bc bvudim bu uhgpc lr bvu
|dafbcduu vg auutjd acr {d|ugcaibvr vhd
hr{cgvbuv ehggudu vg bj{|duu t{gc bv? acf vhdtca}gbfalid bcmd|dced bu vhav bvu |daib~avbgc gm
{d|ugcaibvr {|geddfu m|gj bvu auugebavbgc pbvh vhd
{a|vbetia| glndevb}d jbcf gm bvu gpc bcfb}bftaibvr#
Phavd}d| {d|ugcaibvr vhd glndevb}d jbcf
bj{|duudu t{gc bv) vhav {d|ugcaibvr bv auutjdu
acf aevu t{ vg? acf ubced bv bu vhd ltbifd| gm vhd
lgfr bv pbii ltbif t{ a lgfr bc eg||du{gcfdced
pbvh vhd {d|ugcaibvr vhtu bj{|duudf t{gc bv#
Vhdud vpg iapu gm vhd utlndevb}d jbcf mg|j vhd
mgtcfavbgc gm vhd axbgj vhav gt| lgfr |d{|dudcvu
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 38/173
vhd a``|d`avd gm gt| ldibdmu# Bm gt| mbxdf ldibdm bu
vhav vhd lgfr bu utlndev vg aii ug|vu gm bcmitdcedu
ldrgcf gt| egcv|gi) acf vhav vhbu) vhav) g| vhdgvhd| urj{vgj uhgpu vhav uteh ac
tcegcv|giialid bcmitdced bu av pg|o t{gc tu) vhdc
vhbu ldibdm bu bj{|duudf t{gc vhd utlndevb}d jbcf)
phbeh lr vhd iap gm bvu cavt|d aeed{vu bv pbvhgtv
qtduvbgc acf {|geddfu vg mauhbgc lgfbir egcfbvbgcu bc aeeg|faced pbvh vhbu ldibdm# A`abc)
bm gt| mbxdf ldibdm bu vhav ed|vabc javd|bai
|djdfbdu a|d vhd gcir jdacu gm et|d) vhdc pd
mbcf bc vhbu ldibdm vhd mgtcfavbgc gm aii jdfbebcd#
Vhd|d bu cgvhbc` tcugtcf bc vhd vhdg|r gm
jdfbebcd? bv bu vhd uv|bevir ig`beai eg||du{gcfdced
pbvh vhd jdaut|d gm ocgpidf`d phbeh vhgud phg
|dir gc bv a|d au rdv alid vg auubjbiavd) acf bv aevu
aeet|avdir bc aeeg|faced pbvh vhdb| ldibdm vhav bc
a ia|`d ctjld| gm eaudu jdfbebcd pbii fg `ggf)
ltv aiug bc jacr bcuvacedu bv mabiu# Vhd|dmg|d) mg|
vhgud phg ha}d cgv rdv |daehdf a jg|d bcvd|bg|
{d|ed{vbgc gm vhd iap gm Cavt|d) vhd hdaibc`
a`dcer gm jdfbebcd bu a jguv }aitalid abf vg vhd
aiid}bavbgc gm {hrubeai jaiafbdu# Vhd d||g| vg ld
egjlavdf bu cgv vhd ldibdm vhav) bc bvu gpc par)
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 39/173
jdfbebcd bu ea{alid gm fgbc` `ggf) ltv vhd ldibdm
vhav vhd|d bu cg hb`hd| g| ldvvd| par#
Vhdc) gc vhd uajd {|bceb{id) bm pd |daib~d vhav vhd
utlndevb}d jbcf bu vhd ltbifd| gm vhd lgfr) acf
vhav vhd lgfr bu utlndev vg cg bcmitdcedu dxed{v
vhgud phbeh |daeh bv vh|gt`h vhd utlndevb}d jbcf)
vhdc phav pd ha}d vg fg bu vg bj{|duu vhbu t{gc
vhd utlndevb}d jbcf acf halbvtaiir vhbco gm bv au amgtcvabc gm {d|{dvtai Ibmd) phbeh bu egcvbctaiir
|dcg}avbc` vhd lgfr lr ltbifbc` bc uv|gc` acf
hdaivhr javd|bai) bc vhd jguv egj{idvd
bcfd{dcfdced gm acr bcmitdcedu gm acr ug|v) ua}d
vhgud gm gt| gpc fdub|d bj{|duudf t{gc gt| gpcutlndevb}d jbcf lr gt| gpc vhgt`hv# Phdc gced
pd mtiir `|au{ vhdud egcubfd|avbgcu pd uhaii udd
vhav bv bu ntuv au daur vg dxvd|caib~d hdaivhr
egcfbvbgcu gm lgfr au vhd egcv|a|r# [|aevbeaiir vhd
{|geduu ajgtcvu vg a ldibdm bc gt| gpc {gpd| gm
ibmd? acf ubced vhbu ldibdm) bm bv ld vhg|gt`hir
fgjbebidf pbvhbc tu) pbii cdeduua|bir {|gfted a
eg||du{gcfbc`ir hdaivhr lgfr) pd uhgtif u{a|d
cg {abcu vg egc}bced gt|udi}du vhav vhd|d a|d
ugtcf acf |daugcalid `|gtcfu mg| hgifbc` bv# Vg
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 40/173
ammg|f a ugibf laubu mg| vhbu egc}bevbgc bu vhd
{t|{gud gm Jdcvai Uebdced#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 41/173
]#
MT\VHD\ EGCUBFD\AVBGCU
\D@A\FBC@ UTLNDEVB]D ACF
GLNDEVB]D JBCF#
Ac bcvdiib`dcv egcubfd|avbgc gm vhd {hdcgjdca gm hr{cgvbuj pbii uhgp tu vhav phav pd eaii vhd
hr{cgvbe uvavd bu vhd cg|jai uvavd gm vhd
utlndevb}d jbcf# Bv aiparu egcedb}du gm bvudim bc
aeeg|faced pbvh ugjd ut``duvbgc egc}drdf vg bv)
dbvhd| egcuebgtuir g| tcegcuebgtuir vg vhd jgfdgm glndevb}d jbcf phbeh `g}d|cu bv) acf bv `b}du
|bud vg eg||du{gcfbc` dxvd|cai |dutivu# Vhd
alcg|jai cavt|d gm vhd egcfbvbgcu bcftedf lr
dx{d|bjdcvai hr{cgvbuj bu bc vhd |djg}ai gm vhd
cg|jai egcv|gi hdif lr vhd bcfb}bftai'u gpc
glndevb}d jbcf g}d| hbu utlndevb}d jbcf acf vhd
utluvbvtvbgc gm ugjd gvhd| egcv|gi mg| bv) acf vhtu
pd jar uar vhav vhd cg|jai eha|aevd|buvbe gm vhd
utlndevb}d jbcf bu bvu {d|{dvtai aevbgc bc
aeeg|faced pbvh ugjd ug|v gm ut``duvbgc# Bv
ldegjdu vhd|dmg|d a qtduvbgc gm vhd hb`hduv
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 42/173
bj{g|vaced vg fdvd|jbcd bc d}d|r eaud phav vhd
cavt|d gm vhd ut``duvbgc uhaii ld acf m|gj phav
ugt|ed bv uhaii {|geddf? ltv ldmg|d egcubfd|bc`vhd ugt|edu gm ut``duvbgc pd jtuv |daib~d jg|d
mtiir vhd {iaed vaodc lr utlndevb}d jbcf bc vhd
g|fd| gm Cavt|d#
Bm vhd uvtfdcv hau mgiigpdf phav hau lddc uabf
|d`a|fbc` vhd {|dudced gm bcvdiib`dcv u{b|bv{d|}afbc` aii u{aed acf {d|jdavbc` aii javvd|) hd
pbii cgp ha}d ibvvid fbmmbetivr bc |deg`cb~bc` vhbu
aii*{d|}afbc` u{b|bv au tcb}d|uai utlndevb}d jbcf#
Vhav bv eaccgv au tcb}d|uai jbcf ha}d vhd
qtaibvbdu gm glndevb}d jbcf bu }d|r gl}bgtu# Vhdtcb}d|uai jbcf bu vhd e|davb}d {gpd| vh|gt`hgtv
Cavt|d? acf au vhd g|b`bcavbc` {gpd| bv jtuv mb|uv
`b}d |bud vg vhd }a|bgtu mg|ju bc phbeh glndevb}d
jbcf |deg`cb~du bvu gpc bcfb}bftaibvr) ldmg|d
vhdud bcfb}bftai jbcfu eac |d*aev t{gc bv? acf
hdced) au {t|d u{b|bv g| mb|uv eatud ) bv eaccgv
{guublir ld acrvhbc` diud vhac utlndevb}d jbcf?
acf vhd maev phbeh hau lddc altcfacvir {|g}df
lr dx{d|bjdcv vhav vhd utlndevb}d jbcf bu vhd
ltbifd| gm vhd lgfr uhgpu tu vhav vhd {gpd| gm
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 43/173
e|davbc` lr `|gpvh m|gj pbvhbc bu vhd duudcvbai
eha|aevd|buvbe gm vhd utlndevb}d jbcf# Hdced) lgvh
m|gj dx{d|bjdcv acf m|gj a {|bg|b |daugcbc`) pdjar uar vhav phd|d*d}d| pd mbcf e|davb}d {gpd|
av pg|o vhd|d pd a|d bc vhd {|dudced gm utlndevb}d
jbcf) phdvhd| bv ld pg|obc` gc vhd `|acf ueaid gm
vhd egujgu) g| gc vhd jbcbavt|d ueaid gm vhd
bcfb}bftai# Pd jar vhd|dmg|d iar bv fgpc au a{|bceb{id vhav vhd tcb}d|uai aii*{d|jdavbc`
bcvdiib`dced) phbeh hau lddc egcubfd|df bc vhd
udegcf acf vhb|f udevbgcu) bu {t|dir utlndevb}d
jbcf) acf vhd|dmg|d mgiigpu vhd iap gm utlndevb}d
jbcf) cajdir vhav bv bu ajdcalid vg acr
ut``duvbgc) acf pbii ea||r gtv acr ut``duvbgc vhav
bu bj{|duudf t{gc bv vg bvu jguv |b`g|gtuir ig`beai
egcudqtdcedu# Vhd bceaietialid bj{g|vaced gm
vhbu v|tvh jar cgv {d|ha{u uv|bod vhd uvtfdcv av
mb|uv ub`hv) ltv a ibvvid egcubfd|avbgc pbii uhgp
hbj vhd dcg|jgtu {guublbibvbdu vhav a|d uvg|df t{
bc bv) acf bc vhd egceitfbc` udevbgc B uhaii l|bdmir
vgteh t{gc vhd }d|r ud|bgtu egceitubgcu |dutivbc`
m|gj bv# Mg| vhd {|dudcv bv pbii ld utmmbebdcv vg
|daib~d vhav vhd utlndevb}d jbcf bc gt|udi}du
bu vhd uajd utlndevb}d jbcf phbeh bu av pg|o
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 44/173
vh|gt`hgtv vhd tcb}d|ud `b}bc` |bud vg vhd
bcmbcbvtfd gm cavt|ai mg|ju pbvh phbeh pd a|d
ut||gtcfdf) acf bc ibod jaccd| `b}bc` |bud vg gt|udi}du aiug # Bv jar ld eaiidf vhd ut{{g|vd| gm
gt| bcfb}bftaibvr? acf pd jar iggudir u{dao gm
gt| bcfb}bftai utlndevb}d jbcf au gt| {d|ugcai
uha|d bc vhd tcb}d|uai jbcf# Vhbu) gm egt|ud) fgdu
cgv bj{ir vhd u{ibvvbc` t{ gm vhd tcb}d|uai jbcfbcvg m|aevbgcu) acf bv bu vg a}gbf vhbu d||g| vhav B
ha}d fbuetuudf vhd duudcvbai tcbvr gm u{b|bv bc vhd
vhb|f udevbgc) ltv bc g|fd| vg a}gbf vgg hb`hir
aluv|aev egced{vbgcu bc vhd {|dudcv uva`d gm vhd
uvtfdcv'u {|g`|duu pd jar egc}dcbdcvir dj{igr
vhd bfda gm a {d|ugcai uha|d bc vhd tcb}d|uai
utlndevb}d jbcf#
Vg |daib~d gt| bcfb}bftai utlndevb}d jbcf bc vhbu
jaccd| pbii hdi{ tu vg `dv g}d| vhd `|dav
jdva{hrubeai fbmmbetivr phbeh jddvu tu bc gt|
dcfda}gt| vg jaod egcuebgtu tud gm mb|uv eatud)
bc gvhd| pg|fu vg e|davd dxvd|cai |dutivu lr vhd
{gpd| gm gt| gpc vhgt`hv# Tivbjavdir vhd|d eac
ld gcir gcd mb|uv eatud phbeh bu vhd tcb}d|uai
jbcf) ltv ldeatud bv bu tcb}d|uai bv eaccgv) au
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 45/173
tcb}d|uai ) aev gc vhd {iacd gm vhd bcfb}bftai acf
{a|vbetia|# Mg| bv vg fg ug pgtif ld mg| bv vg edaud
vg ld tcb}d|uai acf vhd|dmg|d edaud vg ld vhde|davb}d {gpd| phbeh pd pbuh vg dj{igr# Gc vhd
gvhd| hacf) vhd maev vhav pd a|d pg|obc` mg| a
u{debmbe fdmbcbvd glndev bj{ibdu gt| bcvdcvbgc vg
tud vhbu tcb}d|uai {gpd| bc a{{ibeavbgc vg a
{a|vbetia| {t|{gud) acf vhtu pd mbcf gt|udi}dubc}gi}df bc vhd {a|afgx gm uddobc` vg jaod vhd
tcb}d|uai aev gc vhd {iacd gm vhd {a|vbetia|# Pd
pacv vg dmmdev a ntcevbgc ldvpddc vhd vpg
dxv|djdu gm vhd ueaid gm Cavt|d) vhd bccd|jguv
e|davb}d u{b|bv acf a {a|vbetia| dxvd|cai mg|j#
Ldvpddc vhdud vpg bu a `|dav `tim) acf vhd
qtduvbgc bu hgp bu bv vg ld l|bf`df g}d|# Bv bu hd|d)
vhdc) vhav vhd egced{vbgc gm gt| bcfb}bftai
utlndevb}d jbcf au gt| {d|ugcai uha|d bc vhd
tcb}d|uai utlndevb}d jbcf ammg|fu vhd jdacu gm
jddvbc` vhd fbmmbetivr) mg| gc vhd gcd hacf bv bu bc
bjjdfbavd egccdevbgc pbvh vhd tcb}d|uai jbcf)
acf gc vhd gvhd| bv bu bjjdfbavd egccdevbgc pbvh
vhd bcfb}bftai glndevb}d) g| bcvdiidevtai jbcf? acf
vhbu bc bvu vt|c bu bc bjjdfbavd egccdevbgc pbvh
vhd pg|if gm dxvd|caib~avbgc) phbeh bu egcfbvbgcdf
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 46/173
bc vbjd acf u{aed? acf vhtu vhd |diavbgc ldvpddc
vhd utlndevb}d acf glndevb}d jbcfu bc vhd
bcfb}bftai mg|ju vhd l|bf`d phbeh bu cddfdf vgegccdev vhd vpg dxv|djbvbdu gm vhd ueaid#
Vhd bcfb}bftai utlndevb}d jbcf jar vhd|dmg|d ld
|d`a|fdf au vhd g|`ac gm vhd Alugitvd bc {|debudir
vhd uajd par vhav vhd glndevb}d jbcf bu vhd g|`ac
gm vhd \diavb}d) acf bv bu bc g|fd| vg |d`tiavd gt|tud gm vhdud vpg g|`acu vhav bv bu cdeduua|r vg
tcfd|uvacf phav vhd vd|ju ,alugitvd, acf
,|diavb}d, aevtaiir jdac# Vhd alugitvd bu vhav bfda
gm a vhbc` phbeh egcvdj{iavdu bv au dxbuvbc` bc
bvudim acf cgv bc |diavbgc vg ugjdvhbc` diud) vhav buvg uar) phbeh egcvdj{iavdu vhd duudced gm bv? acf
vhd |diavb}d bu vhav bfda gm a vhbc` phbeh
egcvdj{iavdu bv au |diavdf vg gvhd| vhbc`u) vhav bu
vg uar au eb|etjue|bldf lr a ed|vabc dc}b|gcjdcv#
Vhd alugitvd bu vhd |d`bgc gm eatudu) acf vhd
|diavb}d bu vhd |d`bgc gm egcfbvbgcu? acf hdced) bm
pd pbuh vg egcv|gi egcfbvbgcu) vhbu eac gcir ld
fgcd lr gt| vhgt`hv*{gpd| g{d|avbc` gc vhd
{iacd gm vhd alugitvd) phbeh bv eac fg gcir
vh|gt`h vhd jdfbtj gm vhd utlndevb}d jbcf# Vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 47/173
egcuebgtu tud gm vhd e|davb}d {gpd| gm vhgt`hv
egcubuvu bc vhd avvabcjdcv gm vhd {gpd| gm
Vhbcobc` bc vhd Alugitvd) acf vhbu eac gcir ldavvabcdf lr a eida| egced{vbgc gm vhd bcvd|aevbgc
ldvpddc gt| fbmmd|dcv jdcvai mtcevbgcu# Mg| vhbu
{t|{gud vhd uvtfdcv eaccgv vgg uv|gc`ir bj{|duu
t{gc hbjudim vhav utlndevb}d jbcf) gc phavd}d|
ueaid) bu bcvdcudir udcubvb}d vg ut``duvbgc) acf aue|davb}d {gpd| pg|ou aeet|avdir vg vhd
dxvd|caib~avbgc gm vhav ut``duvbgc phbeh bu jguv
fdd{ir bj{|duudf t{gc bv# Bm vhdc) pd pgtif vaod
acr bfda gtv gm vhd |daij gm vhd |diavb}d) phd|d bv
bu ibjbvdf acf |duv|bevdf lr egcfbvbgcu bj{gudf
t{gc bv vh|gt`h ut||gtcfbc` eb|etjuvacedu) acf
v|acumd| bv vg vhd |daij gm vhd alugitvd phd|d bv bu
cgv vhtu ibjbvdf) a |b`hv |deg`cbvbgc gm gt|
jdcvai egcuvbvtvbgc pbii dcalid tu vg fg vhbu lr a
eida|ir fdmbcdf jdvhgf#
Vhd glndev gm gt| fdub|d bu cdeduua|bir mb|uv
egcedb}df lr tu au lda|bc` ugjd |diavbgc vg
dxbuvbc` eb|etjuvacedu) phbeh jar) g| jar cgv)
a{{da| ma}gt|alid vg bv? acf phav pd pacv vg fg
bu vg dibjbcavd vhd didjdcv gm egcvbc`dcer acf
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 48/173
avvabc ugjdvhbc` phbeh bu ed|vabc bc bvudim# Vg fg
vhbu bu vg pg|o t{gc vhd {iacd gm vhd alugitvd)
acf mg| vhbu {t|{gud pd jtuv dcfda}gt| vgbj{|duu t{gc gt| utlndevb}d jbcf vhd bfda gm
vhav phbeh pd fdub|d qtbvd a{a|v m|gj acr
egcfbvbgcu# Vhbu ud{a|avbgc m|gj vhd didjdcvu gm
egcfbvbgc bj{ibdu vhd dibjbcavbgc gm vhd bfda gm
vbjd ) acf egcudqtdcvir pd jtuv vhbco gm vhdvhbc` au ai|dafr bc aevtai dxbuvdced# Tciduu pd fg
vhbu pd a|d cgv egcuebgtuir g{d|avbc` t{gc vhd
{iacd gm vhd alugitvd) acf a|d vhd|dmg|d cgv
dj{igrbc` vhd e|davb}d {gpd| gm gt| vhgt`hv# Vhd
ubj{iduv {|aevbeai jdvhgf gm `abcbc` vhd halbv gm
vhbcobc` bc vhbu jaccd| bu vg egcedb}d vhd
dxbuvdced bc vhd u{b|bvtai pg|if gm a u{b|bvtai
{|gvgvr{d gm d}d|r dxbuvbc` vhbc`) phbeh ldegjdu
vhd |ggv gm vhd eg||du{gcfbc` dxvd|cai dxbuvdced#
Bm pd vhtu halbvtavd gt|udi}du vg iggo gc vhd
u{b|bvtai {|gvgvr{d au vhd duudcvbai ldbc` gm vhd
vhbc`) acf vhd javd|bai mg|j au vhd `|gpvh gm vhbu
{|gvgvr{d bcvg gtvpa|f dx{|duubgc) vhdc pd uhaii
udd vhav vhd bcbvbai uvd{ vg vhd {|gftevbgc gm acr
dxvd|cai maev jtuv ld vhd e|davbgc gm bvu u{b|bvtai
{|gvgvr{d# Vhbu {|gvgvr{d) ldbc` {t|dir u{b|bvtai)
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 49/173
eac gcir ld mg|jdf lr vhd g{d|avbgc gm vhgt`hv )
acf bc g|fd| vg ha}d utluvaced gc vhd u{b|bvtai
{iacd bv jtuv ld vhgt`hv gm au aevtaiir dxbuvbc`vhd|d# Vhbu egced{vbgc hau lddc dialg|avdf lr
[iavg bc hbu fgev|bcd gm a|ehdvr{ai bfdau) acf lr
Updfdclg|` bc hbu fgev|bcd gm eg||du{gcfdcedu?
acf a uvbii `|davd| vdaehd| hau uabf ,Aii vhbc`u
phavugd}d| rd {|ar acf auo mg|) ldibd}d vhav rdha}d |dedb}df vhdj) acf rd uhaii |dedb}d vhdj#,
(Ja|o xb# <6) \#]#" Vhd fbmmd|dced gm vhd vdcudu bc
vhbu {auua`d bu |dja|oalid# Vhd u{daod| lbfu tu
mb|uv vg ldibd}d vhav gt| fdub|d hau ai|dafr lddc
mtimbiidf) vhav bv bu a vhbc` ai|dafr aeegj{ibuhdf)
acf vhdc bvu aeegj{ibuhjdcv pbii mgiigp au a
vhbc` bc vhd mtvt|d# Vhbu bu cgvhbc` diud vhac a
egcebud fb|devbgc mg| jaobc` tud gm vhd e|davb}d
{gpd| gm vhgt`hv lr bj{|duubc` t{gc vhd
tcb}d|uai utlndevb}d jbcf vhd {a|vbetia| vhbc`
phbeh pd fdub|d au ac ai|dafr dxbuvbc` maev# Bc
mgiigpbc` vhbu fb|devbgc pd a|d vhbcobc` gc vhd
{iacd gm vhd alugitvd acf dibjbcavbc` m|gj gt|
jbcfu aii egcubfd|avbgc gm egcfbvbgcu) phbeh
bj{ir ibjbvavbgc acf vhd {guublbibvr gm af}d|ud
egcvbc`dcebdu? acf pd a|d vhtu {iacvbc` a uddf
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 50/173
phbeh) bm idmv tcfbuvt|ldf) pbii bcmaiiblir
`d|jbcavd bcvg dxvd|cai m|tbvbgc#
Lr vhtu jaobc` bcvdiib`dcv tud gm gt| utlndevb}d
jbcf) pd) ug vg u{dao) e|davd a cteidtu ) phbeh bu
cg uggcd| e|davdf vhac bv ld`bcu vg dxd|ebud ac
avv|aevb}d mg|ed) f|apbc` vg bvudim javd|bai gm a
ibod eha|aevd| pbvh bvu gpc) acf bm vhbu {|geduu bu
aiigpdf vg `g gc tcfbuvt|ldf) bv pbii egcvbctdtcvbi ac dxvd|cai mg|j eg||du{gcfbc` vg vhd
cavt|d gm vhd cteidtu egjdu gtv bcvg
jacbmduvavbgc gc vhd {iacd gm vhd glndevb}d acf
|diavb}d# Vhbu bu vhd tcb}d|uai jdvhgf gm Cavt|d
gc d}d|r {iacd# Ugjd gm vhd jguv af}acedfvhbcod|u bc jgfd|c {hrubeai uebdced) bc vhd
dcfda}gt| vg {|gld vhd `|dav jruvd|r gm vhd mb|uv
g|b`bc gm vhd pg|if) ha}d {guvtiavdf vhd
mg|javbgc gm phav vhdr eaii ,}g|vdx |bc`u, mg|jdf
m|gj ac bcmbcbvdir mbcd {|bjg|fbai utluvaced#
Vhdr vdii tu vhav bm uteh a |bc` ld gced mg|jdf gc
vhd jbctvduv ueaid acf udv |gvavbc`) vhdc) ubced bv
pgtif ld jg}bc` bc {t|d dvhd| acf utlndev vg cg
m|bevbgc) bv jtuv aeeg|fbc` vg aii ocgpc iapu gm
{hrubeu ld bcfduv|tevblid acf bvu jgvbgc
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 51/173
{d|{dvtai# Idv vpg uteh |bc`u a{{|gaeh daeh
gvhd|) acf lr vhd iap gm avv|aevbgc) vhdr pgtif
egaidued bcvg a phgid) acf ug gc tcvbi jacbmduvdfjavvd| au pd a{{|dhdcf bv pbvh gt| dxvd|cai
udcudu) bu av iauv mg|jdf# Gm egt|ud cg gcd hau
d}d| uddc vhdud |bc`u pbvh vhd {hrubeai drd# Vhdr
a|d gcd gm vhgud aluv|aevbgcu phbeh |dutiv bm pd
mgiigp gtv vhd glud|}df iap gm {hrubeu acf vhdtca}gbfalid udqtdcedu gm javhdjavbeu vg vhdb|
cdeduua|r egcudqtdcedu# Pd eaccgv aeegtcv mg|
vhd vhbc`u vhav pd eac udd tciduu pd auutjd vhd
dxbuvdced gm gvhd| vhbc`u phbeh pd eaccgv ? acf
vhd ,}g|vdx vhdg|r, bu gcd gm vhdud auutj{vbgcu#
Vhbu vhdg|r hau cgv lddc {tv mg|pa|f lr jdcvai
uebdcvbuvu ltv lr {t|dir {hrubeai uebdcvbuvu au vhd
tivbjavd egceitubgc vg phbeh vhdb| |duda|ehdu
ha}d idf vhdj) acf vhbu egceitubgc bu vhav aii vhd
bcctjd|alid mg|ju gm Cavt|d ha}d vhdb| g|b`bc bc
vhd bcmbcbvdir jbctvd cteidtu gm vhd }g|vdx |bc`)
lr phavd}d| jdacu vhd }g|vdx |bc` jar ha}d
|dedb}df bvu bcbvbai bj{tiud) a qtduvbgc pbvh phbeh
{hrubeai uebdced) au uteh) bu cgv egced|cdf#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 52/173
Au vhd }g|vdx vhdg|r aeegtcvu mg| vhd mg|javbgc
gm vhd bcg|`acbe pg|if) ug fgdu lbgig`r aeegtcv
mg| vhd mg|javbgc gm vhd ib}bc` g|`acbuj# Vhavaiug hau bvu g|b`bc bc a {|bja|r cteidtu phbeh) au
uggc au bv bu duvalibuhdf) g{d|avdu au a edcv|d gm
avv|aevbgc mg| vhd mg|javbgc gm aii vhgud {hrubeai
g|`acu gm phbeh vhd {d|mdev bcfb}bftai bu
egj{gudf# Vhd uebdced gm djl|rgig`r uhgpu vhavvhbu |tid hgifu `ggf pbvhgtv dxed{vbgc
vh|gt`hgtv vhd phgid |ac`d gm vhd acbjai pg|if)
bceitfbc` jac? acf lgvacr uhgpu vhd uajd
{|bceb{id av pg|o vh|gt`hgtv vhd }d`dvalid pg|if#
Aii l|acehdu gm {hrubeai uebdced fdjgcuv|avd vhd
maev vhav d}d|r egj{idvdf jacbmduvavbgc) gm
phavd}d| obcf acf gc phavd}d| ueaid) bu uva|vdf
lr vhd duvalibuhjdcv gm a cteidtu) bcmbcbvdir ujaii
ltv dcfgpdf pbvh ac tcqtdcehalid dcd|`r gm
avv|aevbgc) eatubc` bv vg uvdafbir bce|daud bc {gpd|
acf fdmbcbvdcduu gm {t|{gud) tcvbi vhd {|geduu gm
`|gpvh bu egj{idvdf acf vhd javt|df mg|j
uvacfu gtv au ac aeegj{ibuhdf maev# Cgp bm vhbu ld
vhd tcb}d|uai jdvhgf gm Cavt|d) vhd|d bu cgvhbc`
tccavt|ai bc ut{{gubc` vhav bv jtuv ld`bc bvu
g{d|avbgc av a uva`d mt|vhd| laeo vhac vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 53/173
mg|javbgc gm vhd javd|bai cteidtu# Au uggc au
vhav bu eaiidf bcvg ldbc` bv ld`bcu vg g{d|avd lr
vhd iap gm avv|aevbgc gc vhd javd|bai {iacd? ltv phav bu vhd mg|ed phbeh g|b`bcavdu vhd javd|bai
cteidtu7 Idv a |dedcv pg|o gc {hrubeai uebdced
`b}d tu vhd acupd|? ,Bc bvu tivbjavd duudced)
dcd|`r jar ld bcegj{|dhdcublid lr tu dxed{v au
ac dxhblbvbgc gm vhd fb|dev g{d|avbgc gm vhav phbeh pd eaii Jbcf g| Pbii#, Vhd qtgvavbgc bu
m|gj a egt|ud gm idevt|du gc ,Pa}du bc Pavd|) Ab|
acf Ívhd|), fdib}d|df bc 12;<) av vhd \grai
Bcuvbvtvbgc) lr N# A# Midjbc`# Hd|d) vhdc) bu vhd
vduvbjgcr gm {hrubeai uebdced vhav vhd g|b`bcavbc`
dcd|`r bu Jbcf g| Pbii? acf pd a|d) vhd|dmg|d) cgv
gcir jaobc` a ig`beai fdftevbgc m|gj ed|vabc
tca}gbfalid bcvtbvbgcu gm vhd htjac jbcf) ltv
a|d aiug mgiigpbc` gc vhd ibcdu gm vhd jguv
af}acedf {hrubeai uebdced) phdc pd uar vhav vhd
aevbgc gm Jbcf {iacvu vhav cteidtu phbeh) bm
aiigpdf vg `|gp tcfbuvt|ldf) pbii d}dcvtaiir
avv|aev vg bvudim aii vhd egcfbvbgcu cdeduua|r mg| bvu
jacbmduvavbgc bc gtvpa|f }bublid mg|j# Cgp vhd
gcir aevbgc gm Jbcf bu Vhgt`hv? acf bv bu mg| vhbu
|daugc vhav lr gt| vhgt`hvu pd e|davd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 54/173
eg||du{gcfbc` dxvd|cai egcfbvbgcu) ldeatud pd
vhd|dlr e|davd vhd cteidtu phbeh avv|aevu vg bvudim
bvu gpc eg||du{gcfdcedu bc ftd g|fd| tcvbi vhdmbcbuhdf pg|o bu jacbmduvdf gc vhd dxvd|cai
{iacd# Vhbu bu aeeg|fbc` vg vhd uv|bevir uebdcvbmbe
egced{vbgc gm vhd tcb}d|uai iap gm `|gpvh? acf pd
jar vhd|dmg|d l|bdmir utj t{ vhd phgid a|`tjdcv
lr uarbc` vhav gt| vhgt`hv gm acrvhbc` mg|ju au{b|bvtai {|gvgvr{d gm bv) vhtu egcuvbvtvbc` a
cteidtu g| edcv|d gm avv|aevbgc mg| aii egcfbvbgcu
cdeduua|r vg bvu d}dcvtai dxvd|caib~avbgc lr a iap
gm `|gpvh bchd|dcv bc vhd {|gvgvr{d bvudim#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 55/173
]B#
VHD IAP GM @\GPVH#
A EG\\DEV tcfd|uvacfbc` gm vhd iap gm `|gpvh
bu gm vhd hb`hduv bj{g|vaced vg vhd uvtfdcv gm
Jdcvai Uebdced# Vhd `|dav maev vg ld |daib~df|d`a|fbc` Cavt|d bu vhav bv bu cavt|ai# Pd jar
{d|}d|v vhd g|fd| gm Cavt|d) ltv bv pbii {|d}abi bc
vhd igc` |tc) |dvt|cbc`) au Hg|aed uaru) lr vhd
laeo fgg| d}dc vhgt`h pd f|b}d bv gtv pbvh a
{bvehmg|o? acf vhd ld`bccbc`) vhd jbffid) acf vhddcf gm vhd iap gm Cavt|d bu vhd {|bceb{id gm
`|gpvh m|gj a }bvaibvr bchd|dcv bc vhd dcvbvr bvudim#
Bm pd |daib~d vhbu m|gj vhd gtvudv pd uhaii cgv
tcfg gt| gpc pg|o lr dcfda}gt|bc` vg mg|ed
vhbc`u vg ldegjd vhav phbeh lr vhdb| gpc cavt|d
vhdr a|d cgv# Mg| vhbu |daugc phdc vhd Lblid uaru
vhav ,hd phg ldibd}dvh uhaii cgv jaod hauvd), bv bu
dctcebavbc` a `|dav cavt|ai {|bceb{id vhav
uteeduu) fd{dcfu gc gt| tubc`) acf cgv g{{gubc`)
vhd tcb}d|uai iap gm `|gpvh# Cg fgtlv vhd `|davd|
vhd }bvaibvr pd {tv bcvg vhd `d|j) phbeh pd ha}d
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 56/173
a`|ddf vg eaii vhd u{b|bvtai {|gvgvr{d) vhd qtbeod|
bv pbii `d|jbcavd? ltv vhbu bu ubj{ir ldeatud lr a
jg|d |daib~bc` egced{vbgc pd {tv jg|d `|gpbc`*{gpd| bcvg vhd uddf vhac pd fg lr a mddlid|
egced{vbgc# Gt| jbuvaodu aiparu d}dcvtaiir
|dugi}d vhdjudi}du bcvg fbuv|tuvbc` vhd iap gm
`|gpvh# Dbvhd| pd macer pd eac hauvdc bv lr ugjd
dxd|vbgc gm gt| gpc m|gj pbvhgtv ) acf a|d vhtuidf bcvg ht||r acf acxbdvr) cgv vg uar ugjdvbjdu
bcvg vhd dj{igrjdcv) gm `|bd}gtuir p|gc`
jdvhgfu? g| diud pd `b}d t{ aii hg{d acf ug fdcr
vhd `d|jbcavbc` {gpd| gm vhd uddf pd ha}d
{iacvdf# Vhd |dutiv bc dbvhd| eaud bu vhd uajd) mg|
bc dbvhd| eaud pd a|d bc dmmdev mg|jbc` a m|duh
u{b|bvtai {|gvgvr{d gm ac g{{gubvd eha|aevd| vg
gt| fdub|d) phbeh vhd|dmg|d cdtv|aib~du vhd gcd
mb|uv mg|jdf) acf fbubcvd`|avdu bv acf tut|{u bvu
{iaed# Vhd iap bu aiparu vhd uajd) vhav gt|
Vhgt`hv mg|ju a u{b|bvtai {|gvgvr{d phbeh) bm idmv
tcfbuvt|ldf) pbii |d{|gfted bvudim bc dxvd|cai
eb|etjuvacedu? vhd gcir fbmmd|dced bu bc vhd ug|v
gm {|gvgvr{d pd mg|j) acf vhtu d}bi bu l|gt`hv vg
tu lr {|debudir vhd uajd iap au `ggf#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 57/173
Vhdud egcubfd|avbgcu pbii `|davir ubj{ibmr gt|
bfdau gm ibmd# Pd ha}d cg igc`d| vg egcubfd| vpg
mg|edu) ltv gcir gcd) au ldbc` vhd eatud gm aiivhbc`u? vhd fbmmd|dced ldvpddc `ggf acf d}bi
|dutivbc` ubj{ir m|gj vhd fb|devbgc bc phbeh vhbu
mg|ed bu jafd vg migp# Bv bu a tcb}d|uai iap vhav bm
pd |d}d|ud vhd aevbgc gm a eatud pd av vhd uajd
vbjd |d}d|ud vhd dmmdev# Pbvh vhd uajd a{{a|avtu pd eac egjjdced lr jdehacbeai jgvbgc phbeh
pbii `dcd|avd didev|bebvr) g| pd eac egjjdced
pbvh didev|bebvr phbeh pbii `dcd|avd jdehacbeai
jgvbgc? g| vg vaod a ubj{id a|bvhjdvbeai bcuvaced>
bm 1;< : 4) vhdc 1;4 : <? acf vhd|dmg|d bm pd
gced |deg`cb~d vhd {gpd| gm vhgt`hv vg {|gfted
acr |dutivu av aii) pd uhaii udd vhav vhd iap lr
phbeh cd`avb}d vhgt`hv {|gftedu cd`avb}d |dutivu
bu vhd uajd lr phbeh {gubvb}d vhgt`hv {|gftedu
{gubvb}d |dutivu# Vhd|dmg|d aii gt| fbuv|tuv gm vhd
iap gm `|gpvh) phdvhd| uhgpc bc vhd acxbgtu
dcfda}gt| vg l|bc` {|duut|d vg lda| m|gj
pbvhgtv) g| bc aiigpbc` fdu{ab| vg vaod vhd {iaed
gm ehdd|mti dx{devavbgc) bu |d}d|ubc` vhd aevbgc gm
vhd g|b`bcai eatud acf egcudqtdcvir |d}d|ubc` vhd
cavt|d gm vhd |dutivu# Bv bu mg| vhbu |daugc vhav vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 58/173
Lblid) phbeh bu vhd jguv fdd{ir geetiv gm aii
lggou) egcvbctaiir iaru ug jteh uv|duu t{gc vhd
dmmbebdcer gm mabvh acf vhd fduv|tevb}d bcmitdced gm tcldibdm? acf bc ibod jaccd|) aii lggou gc d}d|r
l|aceh gm u{b|bvtai uebdced dj{havbeaiir pa|c tu
a`abcuv vhd afjbuubgc gm fgtlv g| mda|# Vhdr a|d
vhd bc}d|ubgc gm vhd {|bceb{id phbeh ltbifu t{)
acf vhdr a|d vhd|dmg|d vhd {|bceb{id phbeh {tiiufgpc? ltv vhd Iap bvudim cd}d| ehac`du) acf bv bu
gc vhd tcehac`dalidcduu gm vhd iap vhav aii
Jdcvai Uebdced bu mgtcfdf# Pd a|d aeetuvgjdf vg
|daib~d vhd tcehac`dalidcduu gm cavt|ai iap bc
gt| d}d|r far ibmd) acf bv uhgtif vhd|dmg|d cgv ld
fbmmbetiv vg |daib~d vhav vhd uajd
tcehac`dalidcduu gm iap phbeh glvabcu gc vhd
}bublid ubfd gm cavt|d glvabcu gc vhd bc}bublid ubfd
au pdii# Vhd }a|balid maevg| bu) cgv vhd iap) ltv
gt| gpc }gibvbgc? acf bv bu lr egjlbcbc` vhbu
}a|balid maevg| pbvh vhd bc}a|balid gcd vhav pd
eac {|gfted vhd }a|bgtu |dutivu pd fdub|d# Vhd
{|bceb{id gm `|gpvh bu vhav gm bchd|dcv }bvaibvr bc
vhd uddf bvudim) acf vhd g{d|avbgcu gm vhd `a|fdcd|
ha}d vhdb| dxaev acaig`td bc Jdcvai Uebdced# Pd
fg cgv {tv vhd udim*dx{acub}d }bvaibvr bcvg vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 59/173
uddf) ltv pd jtuv ugp bv) acf pd jar aiug) ug vg
u{dao) pavd| bv lr qtbdv egcedcv|avdf
egcvdj{iavbgc gm gt| fdub|d au ac aevtaiir aeegj{ibuhdf maev# Ltv pd jtuv ea|dmtiir |djg}d
m|gj uteh egcvdj{iavbgc acr bfda gm a uv|dctgtu
dmmg|v gc gt| {a|v vg jaod vhd uddf `|gp# Bvu
dmmbeaer bu bc hdi{bc` vg odd{ gtv vhgud cd`avb}d
vhgt`hvu gm fgtlv phbeh pgtif {iacv va|duajgc` gt| phdav) acf vhd|dmg|d) bcuvdaf gm
acrvhbc` gm dmmg|v) uteh egcvdj{iavbgc uhgtif ld
aeegj{acbdf lr a mddibc` gm {idaut|d acf
|duvmticduu bc mg|duddbc` vhd ed|vabc
aeegj{ibuhjdcv gm gt| fdub|du# Vhbu bu vhav
jaobc` gt| |dqtduvu ocgpc vg @gf pbvh
vhacou`b}bc` phbeh Uv# [ati |degjjdcfu) acf bv
hau bvu |daugc bc vhav {d|mdev phgidcduu gm vhd
Iap gm Ldbc` phbeh gcir cddfu gt| |deg`cbvbgc gm
bv vg ld tudf lr tu vg acr dxvdcv pd pbuh#
Ugjd {dg{id {guuduu vhd {gpd| gm }butaib~avbgc)
g| jaobc` jdcvai {bevt|du gm vhbc`u) bc a `|davd|
fd`|dd vhac gvhd|u) acf lr uteh vhbu maetivr jar
af}acva`dgtuir ld dj{igrdf vg maebibvavd vhdb|
|daib~avbgc gm vhd pg|obc` gm vhd Iap# Ltv vhgud
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 60/173
phg fg cgv {guuduu vhbu maetivr bc acr ja|odf
fd`|dd) cddf cgv ld fbuegt|a`df lr vhdb| pacv gm
bv) mg| }butaib~avbgc bu cgv vhd gcir par gm |daib~bc` vhav vhd iap bu av pg|o gc vhd bc}bublid
{iacd# Vhgud phgud jdcvai lbau bu vgpa|fu
{hrubeai uebdced uhgtif |daib~d vhbu Iap gm
@|gpvh au vhd e|davb}d mg|ed vh|gt`hgtv aii
cavt|d? acf vhgud phg ha}d a javhdjavbeai vt|cgm jbcf jar |dmidev vhav aii ugibfu a|d `dcd|avdf
m|gj vhd jg}djdcv gm a {gbcv) phbeh) au gt| gif
m|bdcf Dteibf vdiiu tu) bu vhav phbeh hau cg {a|vu
cg| ja`cbvtfd) acf bu vhd|dmg|d au egj{idvd ac
aluv|aevbgc au acr u{b|bvtai cteidtu egtif ld# Vg
tud vhd a{guvgibe pg|fu) pd a|d fdaibc` pbvh vhd
utluvaced gm vhbc`u cgv uddc) acf pd ha}d vg
avvabc vhav halbv gm jbcf lr phbeh pd uhaii udd bvu
|daibvr acf mddi vhav pd a|d jdcvaiir
jacb{tiavbc` vhd gcir utluvaced vhd|d tivbjavdir
bu) acf gm phbeh aii }bublid vhbc`u a|d gcir
fbmmd|dcv jgfdu# Pd jtuv vhd|dmg|d |d`a|f gt|
jdcvai e|davbgcu au u{b|bvtai |daibvbdu acf vhdc
bj{ibebvir v|tuv vhd Iap gm @|gpvh vg fg vhd |duv#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 61/173
]BB#
\DED[VB]BVR#
Bc g|fd| vg iar vhd mgtcfavbgcu mg| {|aevbeai pg|o)
vhd uvtfdcv jtuv dcfda}gt| vg `dv a eida|
egced{vbgc gm phav bu jdacv lr vhd bcvdiib`dced gm tcfbmmd|dcvbavdf u{b|bv# Pd pacv vg `|au{ vhd bfda
gm bcvdiib`dced a{a|v m|gj bcfb}bftaibvr) ac bfda
phbeh bu |avhd| a{v vg ditfd tu tcvbi pd `|gp
aeetuvgjdf vg bv# Bv bu vhd mabit|d vg |daib~d vhbu
qtaibvr gm u{b|bv vhav hau `b}dc |bud vg aii vhdvhdgig`beai d||g|u vhav ha}d l|gt`hv lbvvd|cduu
bcvg vhd pg|if acf hau lddc {|gjbcdcv ajgc`uv
vhd eatudu phbeh ha}d |dva|fdf vhd v|td
fd}dig{jdcv gm jacobcf# Vg aeet|avdir egc}dr
vhbu egced{vbgc bc pg|fu) bu {d|ha{u) bj{guublid)
acf vg avvdj{v fdmbcbvbgc bu vg bcv|gfted vhav }d|r
bfda gm ibjbvavbgc phbeh bu gt| glndev vg a}gbf# Bv
bu a javvd| gm mddibc` |avhd| vhac gm fdmbcbvbgc? rdv
ugjd dcfda}gt| jtuv ld jafd vg bcfbeavd vhd
fb|devbgc bc phbeh pd jtuv mddi mg| vhbu `|dav
v|tvh bm pd a|d vg mbcf bv# Vhd bfda bu vhav gm
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 62/173
|daib~bc` {d|ugcaibvr pbvhgtv vhav udimhggf phbeh
fbmmd|dcvbavdu gcd bcfb}bftai m|gj acgvhd|# ,B aj
cgv vhav gvhd| ldeatud B aj jrudim,**vhbu bu vhdfdmbcbvbgc gm bcfb}bftai udimhggf? ltv bv
cdeduua|bir bj{a|vu vhd bfda gm ibjbvavbgc)
ldeatud vhd |deg`cbvbgc gm acr gvhd| bcfb}bftaibvr
av gced ammb|ju a {gbcv av phbeh gt| gpc
bcfb}bftaibvr edaudu acf vhd gvhd| ld`bcu# Cgp vhbu jgfd gm |deg`cbvbgc eaccgv ld avv|bltvdf vg
vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf# Mg| bv vg |deg`cb~d a {gbcv
phd|d bvudim edaudf acf ugjdvhbc` diud ld`ac
pgtif ld vg |deg`cb~d bvudim au cgv tcb}d|uai? mg|
vhd jdacbc` gm tcb}d|uaibvr bu vhd bceitfbc` gm aii
vhbc`u) acf vhd|dmg|d mg| vhbu bcvdiib`dced vg
|deg`cb~d acrvhbc` au ldbc` gtvubfd bvudim pgtif
ld a fdcbai gm bvu gpc ldbc`# Pd jar vhd|dmg|d
uar pbvhgtv hdubvavbgc vhav) phavd}d| jar ld vhd
cavt|d gm bvu bcvdiib`dced) bv jtuv ld dcvb|dir
fd}gbf gm vhd didjdcv gm udim*|deg`cbvbgc au ac
bcfb}bftai {d|ugcaibvr gc acr ueaid phavd}d|#
Uddc bc vhbu ib`hv bv bu av gced eida| vhav vhd
g|b`bcavbc` aii*{d|}afbc` U{b|bv bu vhd `|acf
bj{d|ugcai {|bceb{id gm Ibmd phbeh `b}du |bud vg
aii vhd {a|vbetia| jacbmduvavbgcu gm Cavt|d# Bvu
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 63/173
alugitvd bj{d|ugcaicduu) bc vhd udcud gm vhd
dcvb|d aludced gm acr egcuebgtucduu gm bcfb}bftai
udimhggf) bu a {gbcv gc phbeh bv bu bj{guublid vgbcubuv vgg uv|gc`ir# Vhd avv|bltvbc` gm ac
bj{guublid bcfb}bftaibvr vg vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf bu
gcd gm vhd vpg `|acf d||g|u phbeh pd mbcf
ua{{bc` vhd mgtcfavbgcu gm |dib`bgc acf
{hbigug{hr bc aii a`du# Vhd gvhd| egcubuvu bc|tuhbc` vg vhd g{{gubvd dxv|djd acf fdcrbc` vhd
qtaibvr gm {d|ugcai bcvdiib`dced vg vhd Tcb}d|uai
Jbcf# Vhd acupd| vg vhbu d||g| |djabcu) au gm gif)
bc vhd ubj{id qtduvbgc) ,Hd vhav jafd vhd drd
uhaii Hd cgv udd7 Hd vhav {iacvdf vhd da| uhaii Hd
cgv hda|7,**g| vg tud a {g{tia| {|g}d|l) ,Rgt
eaccgv `dv gtv gm a la` jg|d vhac vhd|d bu bc bv?,
acf egcudqtdcvir vhd maev vhav pd gt|udi}du a|d
edcv|du gm {d|ugcai bcvdiib`dced bu {|ggm vhav vhd
bcmbcbvd) m|gj phbeh vhdud edcv|du a|d
egcedcv|avdf) jtuv ld bcmbcbvd bcvdiib`dced) acf
vhtu pd eaccgv a}gbf avv|bltvbc` vg bv vhd vpg
maevg|u phbeh egcuvbvtvd {d|ugcaibvr) cajdir)
bcvdiib`dced acf }gibvbgc# Pd a|d vhd|dmg|d
l|gt`hv vg vhd egceitubgc vhav vhbu tcb}d|uaiir
fbmmtudf duudced) phbeh pd jb`hv vhbco gm au a
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 64/173
ug|v gm u{b|bvtai {|gvg{iauj) jtuv {guuduu aii vhd
qtaibvbdu gm {d|ugcaibvr pbvhgtv vhav egcuebgtu
|deg`cbvbgc gm udim phbeh egcuvbvtvdu ud{a|avdbcfb}bftaibvr> acf ubced vhd pg|f ,{d|ugcaibvr,
hau ldeajd ug auugebavdf bc gt| g|fbca|r vaio
pbvh vhd bfda gm ,bcfb}bftaibvr, bv pbii {d|ha{u ld
ldvvd| vg egbc a cdp pg|f) acf u{dao gm vhd
{d|ugcaicduu gm vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf au bcfbeavbc`bvu {d|ugcai qtaibvr ) a{a|v m|gj bcfb}bftaibvr# Pd
jtuv |daib~d vhav vhbu tcb}d|uai u{b|bv {d|jdavdu
aii u{aed acf aii jacbmduvdf utluvaced) ntuv au
{hrubeai uebdcvbuvu vdii tu vhav vhd dvhd| fgdu) acf
vhav phd|d}d| bv bu) vhd|d bv jtuv ea||r pbvh bv aii
vhav bv bu bc bvu gpc ldbc`? acf pd uhaii vhdc udd
vhav pd a|d bc vhd jbfuv gm ac gedac gm
tcfbmmd|dcvbavdf rdv bcvdiib`dcv Ibmd) alg}d)
ldigp) acf aii a|gtcf) acf {d|jdavbc` gt|udi}du
lgvh jdcvaiir acf eg|{g|daiir) acf aii gvhd|
ldbc`u au pdii#
@|aftaiir au pd egjd vg |daib~d vhd v|tvh gm vhbu
uvavdjdcv) gt| drdu pbii ld`bc vg g{dc vg bvu
bjjdcud ub`cbmbeaced# Bv jdacu vhav aii Cavt|d bu
{d|}afdf lr ac bcvd|bg| {d|ugcaicduu) bcmbcbvd bc
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 65/173
bvu {gvdcvbaibvbdu gm bcvdiib`dced) |du{gcub}dcduu)
acf {gpd| gm dx{|duubgc) acf gcir pabvbc` vg ld
eaiidf bcvg aevb}bvr lr gt| |deg`cbvbgc gm bv# Lr vhdvd|ju gm bvu cavt|d bv eac |du{gcf vg tu gcir au pd
|deg`cb~d bv# Bm pd a|d av vhav bcvdiidevtai id}di
phd|d pd eac udd cgvhbc` ltv ehaced `g}d|cbc`
vhd pg|if) vhdc vhbu tcfd|irbc` tcb}d|uai jbcf
pbii {|dudcv vg tu cgvhbc` ltv a mg|vtbvgtuegcmitdced gm mg|edu pbvhgtv acr bcvdiib`blid
g|fd|# Bm pd a|d utmmbebdcvir af}acedf vg udd vhav
uteh a egcmitdced egtif gcir {|gfted a ehagu)
acf cgv a egujgu) vhdc gt| egced{vbgcu dx{acf
vg vhd bfda gm tcb}d|uai Iap) acf pd mbcf vhbu vg
ld vhd cavt|d gm vhd aii*tcfd|irbc` {|bceb{id# Pd
ha}d jafd ac bjjdcud af}aced m|gj vhd |daij
gm jd|d aeebfdcv bcvg a pg|if phd|d vhd|d a|d
fdmbcbvd {|bceb{idu gc phbeh pd eac eaietiavd pbvh
ed|vabcvr phdc pd ocgp vhdj # Ltv hd|d bu vhd
e|tebai {gbcv# Vhd iapu gm vhd tcb}d|ud a|d vhd|d)
ltv pd a|d b`cg|acv gm vhdj) acf gcir vh|gt`h
dx{d|bdced `abcdf lr |d{davdf mabit|du eac pd `dv
acr bcub`hv bcvg vhd iapu pbvh phbeh pd ha}d vg
fdai# Hgp {abcmti daeh uvd{ acf hgp uigp vhd
{|g`|duu! Ígcu t{gc ígcu pgtif cgv utmmbed vg
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 66/173
`|au{ aii vhd iapu gm vhd tcb}d|ud bc vhdb| vgvaibvr)
cgv bc vhd }bublid pg|if gcir) ltv aiug bc vhd pg|if
gm vhd tcuddc? daeh mabit|d vg ocgp vhd v|td iap bj{ibdu utmmd|bc` a|bubc` m|gj gt| b`cg|acv
l|daeh gm bv? acf vhtu) ubced Cavt|d bu bcmbcbvd) pd
a|d jdv lr vhd {a|afgx vhav pd jtuv bc ugjd par
egcv|b}d vg egj{auu vhd ocgpidf`d gm vhd bcmbcbvd
pbvh gt| bcfb}bftai bcvdiib`dced) acf pd jtuv{d|mg|j a {bi`|bja`d aigc` ac tcedaubc` ]ba
Fgig|gua ldcdavh vhd iauh gm vhd bcdxg|alid Iap
tcvbi pd mbcf vhd ugitvbgc vg vhd {|glidj# Ltv bv
pbii ld auodf) Jar pd cgv `g gc tcvbi av iauv pd
avvabc vhd {guuduubgc gm aii ocgpidf`d7 [dg{id fg
cgv |daib~d phav bu jdacv lr ,vhd bcmbcbvd), g|
vhdr pgtif cgv auo uteh qtduvbgcu# Vhd bcmbcbvd bu
vhav phbeh bu ibjbviduu acf dxhatuviduu# Bja`bcd
vhd }auvduv ea{aebvr rgt pbii) acf ha}bc` mbiidf bv
pbvh vhd bcmbcbvd) phav |djabcu gm vhd bcmbcbvd bu
ntuv au bcmbcbvd au ldmg|d# Vg vhd javhdjavbebac
vhbu jar ld {tv }d|r eida|ir# \abud x vg acr {gpd|
rgt pbii) acf hgpd}d| }auv jar ld vhd fbu{a|bvr
ldvpddc bv acf vhd igpd| {gpd|u gm x ) lgvh a|d
dqtaiir bcegjjdcut|avd pbvh x c # Vhd tcb}d|uai
|db`c gm Iap bu a ja`cbmbedcv v|tvh? bv bu gcd gm
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 67/173
vhd vpg `|dav {biia|u gm vhd tcb}d|ud urjlgib~df
lr vhd vpg {biia|u vhav uvggf av vhd dcv|aced vg
Ugigjgc'u vdj{id> bv bu Naehbc) ltv Naehbc jtuv ld dqtbibl|bavdf lr Lga~#
Bv bu ac dcft|bc` v|tvh) phbeh eac cd}d| ld
aivd|df) vhav d}d|r bcm|aevbgc gm vhd Iap gm Cavt|d
jtuv ea||r bvu {tcbvb}d egcudqtdcedu pbvh bv# Pd
eac cd}d| `dv ldrgcf vhd |ac`d gm eatud acfdmmdev# Vhd|d bu cg duea{bc` m|gj vhd iap gm
{tcbuhjdcv) dxed{v lr ocgpidf`d# Bm pd ocgp a
iap gm Cavt|d acf pg|o pbvh bv) pd uhaii mbcf bv
gt| tcmabibc` m|bdcf) d}d| |dafr vg ud|}d tu) acf
cd}d| |dltobc` tu mg| {auv mabit|du? ltv bm pdb`cg|acvir g| pbimtiir v|acu`|duu bv) bv bu gt|
bj{iaealid dcdjr) tcvbi pd a`abc ldegjd
gldfbdcv vg bv? acf vhd|dmg|d vhd gcir |dfdj{vbgc
m|gj {d|{dvtai {abc acf ud|}bvtfd bu lr a udim*
dx{acubgc phbeh eac `|au{ bcmbcbvtfd bvudim# Hgp
bu vhbu vg ld aeegj{ibuhdf7 Lr gt| {|g`|duu vg
vhav obcf acf fd`|dd gm bcvdiib`dced lr phbeh pd
|daib~d vhd bchd|dcv {d|ugcaicduu gm vhd fb}bcd
aii*{d|}afbc` Ibmd) phbeh bu av gced vhd Iap acf
vhd Utluvaced gm aii vhav bu# Pdii uabf vhd Ndpbuh
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 68/173
|allbu gm gif) ,Vhd Iap bu a [d|ugc#, Phdc pd
gced |daib~d vhav vhd tcb}d|uai Ibmd acf vhd
tcb}d|uai Iap a|d gcd pbvh vhd tcb}d|uai[d|ugcaicduu) vhdc pd ha}d duvalibuhdf vhd {biia|
Lga~ au vhd cddfdf egj{idjdcv vg Naehbc? acf
phdc pd mbcf vhd egjjgc {gbcv bc phbeh vhdud
vpg tcbvd) pd ha}d |abudf vhd \grai A|eh vh|gt`h
phbeh pd jar v|btj{hacvir dcvd| vhd Vdj{id# Pd jtuv fbuugebavd vhd Tcb}d|uai [d|ugcaicduu
m|gj d}d|r egced{vbgc gm bcfb}bftaibvr# Vhd
tcb}d|uai eac cd}d| ld vhd bcfb}bftai> vhav pgtif
ld a egcv|afbevbgc bc vd|ju# Ltv ldeatud vhd
tcb}d|uai {d|ugcaicduu bu vhd |ggv gm aii
bcfb}bftai {d|ugcaibvbdu) bv mbcfu bvu hb`hduv
dx{|duubgc bc |du{gcud vg vhgud phg |daib~d bvu
{d|ugcai cavt|d# Acf bv bu vhbu |deg`cbvbgc vhav
ugi}du vhd uddjbc`ir bcugitlid {a|afgx# Vhd gcir
par vg avvabc vhav ocgpidf`d gm vhd Bcmbcbvd Iap
phbeh pbii ehac`d vhd ]ba Fgig|gua bcvg vhd [avh
gm Ngr bu vg djlgfr bc gt|udi}du a {|bceb{id gm
ocgpidf`d egjjdcut|avd pbvh vhd bcmbcbvtfd gm
vhav phbeh bu vg ld ocgpc? acf vhbu bu
aeegj{ibuhdf lr |daib~bc` vhav) bcmbcbvd au vhd iap
bvudim) bu a tcb}d|uai Bcvdiib`dced bc vhd jbfuv gm
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 69/173
phbeh pd migav au bc a ib}bc` gedac# Bcvdiib`dced
pbvhgtv bcfb}bftai {d|ugcaibvr) ltv phbeh) bc
{|gftebc` tu) egcedcv|avdu bvudim bcvg vhd{d|ugcai bcfb}bftaibvbdu phbeh pd a|d# Phav
uhgtif ld vhd |diavbgc gm uteh ac bcvdiib`dced
vgpa|fu tu7 Cgv gcd gm ma}gt|bvbuj> cgv acr
jg|d vhac vhd Iap eac bv |du{dev gcd {d|ugc
alg}d acgvhd|) mg| bvudim bu vhd |ggv acf ut{{g|vmg| daeh aibod# Cgv gcd gm |dmtuai vg gt| af}acedu?
mg| pbvhgtv bcfb}bftaibvr bv eac ha}d cg {d|ugcai
glndev gm bvu gpc vg egcmibev pbvh gt|u? acf ubced bv
bu bvudim vhd g|b`bc gm aii bcfb}bftai bcvdiib`dced) bv
eaccgv ld uhtv gmm lr bcalbibvr vg tcfd|uvacf# Lr
vhd }d|r vd|ju gm bvu ldbc`) vhd|dmg|d) vhbu
bcmbcbvd) tcfd|irbc`) aii*{|gftebc` Jbcf jtuv ld
|dafr bjjdfbavdir vg |du{gcf vg aii phg |daib~d
vhdb| v|td |diavbgc vg bv# Au vhd }d|r {|bceb{id gm
Ibmd bvudim bv jtuv ld bcmbcbvdir utued{vblid vg
mddibc`) acf egcudqtdcvir bv pbii |d{|gfted pbvh
alugitvd aeet|aer phavd}d| egced{vbgc gm bvudim
pd bj{|duu t{gc bv? acf hdced bm pd |daib~d vhd
htjac jbcf au vhav uva`d bc vhd d}gitvbgc gm vhd
egujbe g|fd| av phbeh ac bcfb}bftaibvr hau a|budc
ea{alid gm dx{|duubc`) cgv jd|dir vhd ib}bc`cduu)
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 70/173
ltv aiug vhd {d|ugcaicduu gm vhd tcb}d|uai
tcfd|irbc` u{b|bv) vhdc pd udd vhav bvu jguv
{d|mdev jgfd gm udim*dx{|duubgc jtuv ld lr bfdcvbmrbc` bvudim pbvh vhdud bcfb}bftai
{d|ugcaibvbdu#
Vhd bfdcvbmbeavbgc bu) gm egt|ud) ibjbvdf lr vhd
jdaut|d gm vhd bcfb}bftai bcvdiib`dced) jdacbc`)
cgv jd|dir vhd bcvdiidevtai {d|ed{vbgc gm vhdudqtdced gm eatud acf dmmdev) ltv aiug vhav
bcfdue|blalid |deb{|gebvr gm mddibc` lr phbeh pd
bcuvbcevb}dir |deg`cb~d ugjdvhbc` bc acgvhd|
jaobc` vhdj aobc vg gt|udi}du? acf ug bv bu vhav
phdc pd bcvdiib`dcvir |daib~d vhav vhd bccd|jguv{|bceb{id gm ldbc`) jtuv lr |daugc gm bvu
tcb}d|uaibvr) ha}d a egjjgc cavt|d pbvh gt|
gpc) vhdc pd ha}d ugi}df vhd {a|afgx gm
tcb}d|uai ocgpidf`d) mg| pd ha}d |daib~df gt|
bfdcvbvr gm ldbc` pbvh vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf) phbeh
bu egjjdcut|avd pbvh vhd Tcb}d|uai Iap# Vhtu
pd a||b}d av vhd v|tvh gm Uv# Nghc'u uvavdjdcv) ,Rd
ocgp aii vhbc`u), gcir vhbu ocgpidf`d bu {|bja|bir
gc vhd u{b|bvtai {iacd# Bv bu cgv l|gt`hv gtv bcvg
bcvdiidevtai uvavdjdcv phdvhd| cddfdf g| cgv? mg|
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 71/173
bv bu cgv bc bvudim vhd u{debmbe ocgpidf`d gm
{a|vbetia| maevu) ltv bv bu vhd tcfbmmd|dcvbavdf
{|bceb{id gm ocgpidf`d phbeh pd jar fbmmd|dcvbavd bc acr fb|devbgc vhav pd ehggud# Vhbu
bu a {hbigug{hbeai cdeduubvr gm vhd eaud) mg|
vhgt`h vhd aevbgc gm vhd bcfb}bftai jbcf egcubuvu
bc fbmmd|dcvbavbc` vhd tcb}d|uai bcvg {a|vbetia|
a{{ibeavbgcu) vg fbmmd|dcvbavd vhd phgid tcb}d|uai pgtif ld a egcv|afbevbgc bc vd|ju? acf ug)
ldeatud pd eaccgv dxhatuv vhd bcmbcbvd) gt|
{guuduubgc gm bv jtuv egcubuv bc gt| {gpd| vg
fbmmd|dcvbavd bv au vhd geeaubgc jar |dqtb|d) vhd
gcir ibjbv ldbc` vhav phbeh pd gt|udi}du auub`c vg
vhd jacbmduvavbgc#
Bc vhbu par) vhdc) vhd |deg`cbvbgc gm vhd
egjjtcbvr gm {d|ugcaibvr ldvpddc gt|udi}du acf
vhd tcb}d|uai tcfbmmd|dcvbavdf U{b|bv) phbeh bu vhd
|ggv acf utluvaced gm aii vhbc`u) ugi}du vhd
qtduvbgc gm gt| |didaud m|gj vhd b|gc `|au{ gm ac
bcmidxblid Iap) cgv lr al|g`avbc` vhd Iap) phbeh
pgtif jdac vhd accbhbiavbgc gm aii vhbc`u) ltv lr
{|gftebc` bc tu ac bcvdiib`dced dqtai bc ammbcbvr
pbvh vhd tcb}d|uai Iap bvudim) acf vhtu dcalibc`
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 72/173
tu vg a{{|dhdcf acf jddv vhd |dqtb|djdcvu gm
vhd Iap bc daeh {a|vbetia| au bv a|budu# Bc vhbu par
vhd Egujbe Bcvdiib`dced ldegjdu bcfb}bftaib~df)acf vhd bcfb}bftai bcvdiib`dced ldegjdu
tcb}d|uaib~df? vhd vpg ldeajd gcd) acf bc
{|g{g|vbgc au vhbu tcbvr bu |daib~df acf aevdf gc)
bv pbii ld mgtcf vhav vhd Iap) phbeh `b}du |bud vg
aii gtvpa|f egcfbvbgcu) phdvhd| gm lgfr g| gm eb|etjuvacedu) ldegjdu jg|d acf jg|d eida|ir
tcfd|uvggf) acf eac vhd|dmg|d ld jg|d m|ddir
jafd tud gm) ug vhav lr uvdafr) bcvdiib`dcv
dcfda}gt| vg tcmgif t{gc vhdud ibcdu pd jar
|daeh fd`|ddu gm {gpd| vg phbeh bv bu bj{guublid
vg auub`c acr ibjbvu# Vhd uvtfdcv phg pgtif
tcfd|uvacf vhd |avbgcaid gm vhd tcmgifjdcv gm hbu
gpc {guublbibvbdu jtuv jaod cg jbuvaod hd|d# Hd
jtuv |daib~d vhav vhd phgid {|geduu bu vhav gm
l|bc`bc` vhd tcb}d|uai pbvhbc vhd `|au{ gm vhd
bcfb}bftai lr |abubc` vhd bcfb}bftai vg vhd id}di gm
vhd tcb}d|uai acf cgv }bed*}d|ua# Bv bu a
javhdjavbeai v|tbuj vhav rgt eaccgv egcv|aev
vhd bcmbcbvd) acf vhav rgt eac dx{acf vhd
bcfb}bftai? acf bv bu {|debudir gc vhdud ibcdu vhav
d}gitvbgc pg|ou# Vhd iapu gm cavt|d eaccgv ld
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 73/173
aivd|df bc vhd idauv fd`|dd? ltv pd eac egjd bcvg
uteh a |daib~avbgc gm gt| gpc |diavbgc vg vhd
tcb}d|uai {|bceb{id gm Iap vhav tcfd|ibdu vhdj auvg ld alid vg {|duu aii {a|vbetia| iapu) phdvhd| gm
vhd }bublid g| bc}bublid ubfd gm Cavt|d) bcvg gt|
ud|}bed acf ug mbcf gt|udi}du jauvd|u gm vhd
ubvtavbgc# Vhbu bu vg ld aeegj{ibuhdf lr
ocgpidf`d? acf vhd gcir ocgpidf`d phbeh pbiidmmdev vhbu {t|{gud bc aii bvu jdaut|diduu
bjjdcubvr bu vhd ocgpidf`d gm vhd {d|ugcai
didjdcv bc Tcb}d|uai U{b|bv bc bvu |deb{|gebvr vg
gt| gpc {d|ugcaibvr# Gt| |deg`cbvbgc gm vhbu
U{b|bv jtuv vhd|dmg|d ld vpgmgif) au vhd {|bceb{id
gm cdeduua|r udqtdced) g|fd| g| Iap) acf aiug au
vhd {|bceb{id gm Bcvdiib`dced) |du{gcub}d vg gt|
gpc |deg`cbvbgc gm bv#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 74/173
]BBB#
\DEB[\GEAI AEVBGC GM VHD
TCB]D\UAI ACF BCFB]BFTAI
JBCFU#
Bv jtuv ld afjbvvdf vhav vhd mg|d`gbc`
egcubfd|avbgcu l|bc` tu vg vhd lg|fd|u gm
vhdgig`beai u{detiavbgc) ltv vhd uvtfdcv jtuv
lda| bc jbcf vhav au a Jdcvai Uebdcvbuv bv bu hbu
ltubcduu vg |d`a|f d}dc vhd jguv dxaivdf u{b|bvtai
{hdcgjdca m|gj a {t|dir uebdcvbmbe uvacf{gbcv)
phbeh bu vhav gm vhd pg|obc` gm a tcb}d|uai cavt|ai
Iap# Bm hd vhtu ubj{ir fdaiu pbvh vhd maevu au hd
mbcfu vhdj) vhd|d bu ibvvid fgtlv vhav vhd v|td
jdacbc` gm jacr vhdgig`beai uvavdjdcvu pbii
ldegjd eida| vg hbj> ltv hd pbii fg pdii vg iar bv
fgpc au a `dcd|ai |tid vhav bv bu cgv cdeduua|r
dbvhd| vg vhd tud g| tcfd|uvacfbc` gm acr iap)
phdvhd| gc vhd {d|ugcai g| vhd bj{d|ugcai ubfd
gm Cavt|d) vhav pd uhgtif `b}d a vhdgig`beai
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 75/173
dx{iacavbgc gm bv> aivhgt`h) vhd|dmg|d) vhd
{d|ugcai qtaibvr bchd|dcv bc vhd tcb}d|uai
tcfd|irbc` u{b|bv) phbeh bu {|dudcv bc aii vhbc`u)
eaccgv ld vgg uv|gc`ir bcubuvdf t{gc) pd jtuv
|djdjld| vhav bc fdaibc` pbvh bv pd a|d uvbii
fdaibc` pbvh a {t|dir cavt|ai {gpd| phbeh
|da{{da|u av d}d|r {gbcv pbvh {|gvdac }a|bdvr gm
mg|j) phdvhd| au {d|ugc) acbjai) g| vhbc`# Bc
daeh eaud phav bv ldegjdu vg acr bcfb}bftai bu
dxaevir jdaut|df lr vhav bcfb}bftai'u |deg`cbvbgc
gm bv# Vg daeh acf aii bv lda|u vhd |diavbgc gm
ut{{g|vd| gm vhd |aed) acf phd|d vhd bcfb}bftai
fd}dig{jdcv bu bcea{alid gm |daib~bc` acrvhbc`
jg|d) vhbu bu vhd ibjbv gm vhd |diavbgc? ltv au vhd
bcfb}bftai'u {gpd| gm |deg`cbvbgc dx{acfu) hd
mbcfu a |deb{|geai dx{acubgc gc vhd {a|v gm vhbu
bcvdiib`dcv {gpd| phbeh `|aftaiir fd}dig{u bcvg
vhd egcuebgtucduu gm bcvbjavd egj{acbgcuhb{
ldvpddc vhd bcfb}bftaib~df jbcf acf vhd
tcbcfb}bftaib~df ugt|ed gm bv#
Cgp vhbu bu dxaevir vhd |diavbgc phbeh) gc
g|fbca|r uebdcvbmbe {|bceb{idu) pd uhgtif dx{dev vg
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 76/173
mbcf ldvpddc vhd bcfb}bftai acf vhd egujbe jbcf)
gc vhd ut{{gubvbgc vhav vhd egujbe jbcf bu
utlndevb}d jbcf) acf mg| |daugcu ai|dafr `b}dc
pd eac |d`a|f bv bc cg gvhd| ib`hv# Au utlndevb}d
jbcf bv jtuv |d{|gfted dxaevir vhd egced{vbgc gm
bvudim phbeh vhd glndevb}d jbcf gm vhd bcfb}bftai)
aevbc` vh|gt`h hbu gpc utlndevb}d jbcf)
bj{|duudu t{gc bv? acf av vhd uajd vbjd au
e|davb}d jbcf) bv ltbifu t{ dxvd|cai maevu bc
eg||du{gcfdced pbvh vhbu egced{vbgc# ,Qtgv
hgjbcdu vgv udcvdcvbí,> daeh gcd dxvd|caib~du bc
hbu gtvpa|f eb|etjuvacedu {|debudir hbu bfda gm
vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf? acf vhd jac phg |daib~du
vhav lr vhd cavt|ai iap gm jbcf hd eac l|bc` vhd
Tcb}d|uai Jbcf bcvg {d|mdevir |deb{|geai aevbgc
pbvh bvu gpc) pbii gc vhd gcd hacf jaod bv a
ugt|ed gm bcmbcbvd bcuv|tevbgc) acf gc vhd gvhd| a
ugt|ed gm bcmbcbvd {gpd|# Hd pbii vhtu pbudir
aivd|cavd vhd {d|ugcai acf bj{d|ugcai au{devu
|du{devb}dir ldvpddc hbu bcfb}bftai jbcf acf vhd
Tcb}d|uai Jbcf? phdc hd bu uddobc` mg| `tbfaced
g| uv|dc`vh hd pbii |d`a|f hbu gpc jbcf au vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 77/173
bj{d|ugcai didjdcv phbeh bu vg |dedb}d
{d|ugcaibvr m|gj vhd ut{d|bg| pbufgj acf mg|ed
gm vhd @|davd| Jbcf? acf phdc) gc vhd gvhd|
hacf) hd bu vg `b}d gtv vhd uvg|du vhtu
aeetjtiavdf) hd jtuv |d}d|ud vhd {gubvbgc acf
egcubfd| hbu gpc jbcf au vhd {d|ugcai didjdcv)
acf vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf au vhd bj{d|ugcai) phbeh
hd eac vhd|dmg|d fb|dev pbvh ed|vabcvr lr
bj{|duubc` hbu gpc {d|ugcai fdub|d t{gc bv# Pd
cddf cgv ld uva``d|df av vhd `|davcduu gm vhbu
egceitubgc) mg| bv mgiigpu cdeduua|bir m|gj vhd
cavt|ai |diavbgc ldvpddc vhd utlndevb}d acf vhd
glndevb}d jbcfu? acf vhd gcir qtduvbgc bu
phdvhd| pd pbii ibjbv gt| }bdp vg vhd igpd| id}di
gm vhd iavvd|) g| dx{acf bv ug au vg vaod bc vhd
ibjbviduu {guublbibvbdu phbeh vhd utlndevb}d jbcf
{|dudcvu vg tu#
B ha}d fdaiv pbvh vhbu qtduvbgc av ugjd idc`vh
ldeatud bv ammg|fu vhd odr vg vpg }d|r bj{g|vacv
utlndevu) vhd Iap gm Ut{{ir acf vhd cavt|d gm
Bcvtbvbgc# Uvtfdcvu gmvdc mbcf bv daubd| vg
tcfd|uvacf hgp vhd jbcf eac bcmitdced vhd lgfr
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 78/173
pbvh phbeh bv bu ug bcvbjavdir auugebavdf) vhac
hgp bv eac bcmitdced eb|etjuvacedu# Bm vhd
g{d|avbgc gm vhgt`hv*{gpd| pd|d egcmbcdf
dxeitub}dir vg vhd bcfb}bftai jbcf vhbu fbmmbetivr
jb`hv a|bud? ltv bm vhd|d bu gcd iduugc vhd uvtfdcv
gm Jdcvai Uebdced uhgtif vaod vg hda|v jg|d vhac
acgvhd|) bv bu vhav vhd aevbgc gm vhgt`hv*{gpd| bu
cgv ibjbvdf vg a eb|etjue|bldf bcfb}bftaibvr#
Phav vhd bcfb}bftai fgdu bu vg `b}d fb|devbgc vg
ugjdvhbc` phbeh bu tcibjbvdf) vg eaii bcvg aevbgc
a mg|ed bcmbcbvdir `|davd| vhac hbu gpc) phbeh
ldeatud bv bu bc bvudim bj{d|ugcai vhgt`h
bcvdiib`dcv) pbii |dedb}d vhd bj{|duu gm hbu
{d|ugcaibvr) acf eac vhd|dmg|d jaod bvu bcmitdced
mdiv ma| ldrgcf vhd ibjbvu phbeh lgtcf vhd
bcfb}bftai'u glndevb}d {d|ed{vbgc gm vhd
eb|etjuvacedu pbvh phbeh hd hau vg fdai# Bv bu mg|
vhbu |daugc vhav B iar ug jteh uv|duu gc vhd
egjlbcavbgc gm vpg a{{a|dcv g{{gubvdu bc vhd
Tcb}d|uai Jbcf) vhd tcbgc gm bcvdiib`dced pbvh
bj{d|ugcaibvr# Vhd bcvdiib`dced cgv gcir dcalidu
bv vg |dedb}d vhd bj{|duu gm gt| vhgt`hv) ltv aiug
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 79/173
eatudu bv vg fd}bud dxaevir vhd |b`hv jdacu mg|
l|bc`bc` bv bcvg aeegj{ibuhjdcv# Vhbu bu gcir vhd
ig`beai |dutiv gm vhd hr{gvhdubu vhav pd a|d
fdaibc` pbvh bcmbcbvd Bcvdiib`dced phbeh bu aiug
bcmbcbvd Ibmd# Ibmd jdacu [gpd|) acf bcmbcbvd ibmd
vhd|dmg|d jdacu ibjbviduu {gpd|? acf ibjbviduu
{gpd| jg}df lr ibjbviduu bcvdiib`dced eaccgv ld
egcedb}df gm au d}d| uvg{{bc` uhg|v gm vhd
aeegj{ibuhjdcv gm bvu glndev? vhd|dmg|d) `b}dc vhd
bcvdcvbgc gc vhd {a|v gm vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf) vhd|d
eac ld cg fgtlv au vg bvu tivbjavd
aeegj{ibuhjdcv# Vhdc egjdu vhd qtduvbgc gm
bcvdcvbgc# Hgp fg pd ocgp phav vhd bcvdcvbgc gm
vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf jar ld7 Hd|d egjdu bc vhd
didjdcv gm bj{d|ugcaibvr# Bv hau cg bcvdcvbgc )
ldeatud bv bu bj{d|ugcai # Au B ha}d ai|dafr uabf)
vhd Tcb}d|uai jbcf pg|ou lr a iap gm a}d|a`du
mg| vhd af}acedjdcv gm vhd |aed) acf bu bc cg par
egced|cdf pbvh vhd {a|vbetia| pbuhdu gm vhd
bcfb}bftai# Bm hbu pbuhdu a|d bc ibcd pbvh vhd
mg|pa|f jg}djdcv gm vhd d}d|iauvbc` {|bceb{id)
vhd|d bu cgphd|d bc Cavt|d acr {gpd| vg |duv|bev
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 80/173
hbj bc vhdb| mtimbijdcv# Bm vhdr a|d g{{gudf vg vhd
`dcd|ai mg|pa|f jg}djdcv) vhdc vhdr pbii l|bc`
hbj bcvg egiibubgc pbvh bv) acf bv pbii e|tuh hbj#
M|gj vhd |diavbgc ldvpddc vhdj bv |dutivu vhav
vhd uajd {|bceb{id phbeh uhgpu bvudim bc vhd
bcfb}bftai jbcf au Pbii) ldegjdu bc vhd tcb}d|uai
jbcf a Iap gm Vdcfdcer? acf vhd fb|devbgc gm
vhbu vdcfdcer jtuv aiparu ld vg ibmd*`b}bc`cduu)
ldeatud vhd tcb}d|uai jbcf bu vhd
tcfbmmd|dcvbavdf Ibmd*u{b|bv gm vhd tcb}d|ud#
Vhd|dmg|d bc d}d|r eaud vhd vduv bu phdvhd| gt|
{a|vbetia| bcvdcvbgc bu bc vhbu uajd ibmdpa|f
fb|devbgc> acf bm bv bu) vhdc pd jar ld alugitvdir
ed|vabc vhav vhd|d bu cg bcvdcvbgc gc vhd {a|v gm
vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf vg vhpa|v vhd bcvdcvbgc gm gt|
gpc bcfb}bftai jbcf? pd a|d fdaibc` pbvh a
{t|dir bj{d|ugcai mg|ed) acf bv pbii cg jg|d
g{{gud tu lr u{debmbe {iacu gm bvu gpc vhac pbii
uvdaj g| didev|bebvr# Egjlbcbc` vhdc) vhdud vpg
au{devu gm vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf) bvu tvvd|
bj{d|ugcaibvr acf bvu {d|mdev bcvdiib`dced) pd mbcf
{|debudir vhd ug|v gm cavt|ai mg|ed pd a|d bc pacv
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 81/173
gm) ugjdvhbc` phbeh pbii tcfd|vaod phavd}d| pd
{tv bcvg bvu hacfu pbvhgtv auobc` qtduvbgcu g|
la|`abcbc` mg| vd|ju) acf phbeh) ha}bc`
tcfd|vaodc gt| ltubcduu) pbii l|bc` vg lda| gc bv
ac bcvdiib`dced vg phbeh vhd tcbvdf ocgpidf`d gm
vhd phgid htjac |aed bu au cgvhbc`) acf a {gpd|
dqtai vg vhbu bcvdiib`dced# B jar ld tubc` a |gt`h
acf |dafr jgfd gm dx{|duubgc) ltv jr glndev bu vg
l|bc` hgjd vg vhd uvtfdcv vhd cavt|d gm vhd
{gpd| hd eac dj{igr acf vhd jdvhgf gm
dj{igrbc` bv) acf B jar vhd|dmg|d uvavd vhd phgid
{gubvbgc vhtu>**Rgt| glndev bu cgv vg |tc vhd
phgid egujgu) ltv vg f|ap {a|vbetia| ldcdmbvu)
{hrubeai) jdcvai) jg|ai) g| mbcacebai bcvg rgt|
gpc g| ugjdgcd diud'u ibmd# M|gj vhbu bcfb}bftai
{gbcv gm }bdp vhd tcb}d|uai e|davb}d {gpd| hau cg
jbcf gm bvu gpc) acf vhd|dmg|d rgt eac jaod t{
bvu jbcf mg| bv# Phdc bvu jbcf bu vhtu jafd t{ mg|
bv) bv cd}d| al|g`avdu bvu {iaed au vhd e|davb}d
{gpd|) ltv av gced udvu vg pg|o eg ea||r gtv vhd
{t|{gud mg| phbeh bv hau vhtu lddc egcedcv|avdf?
acf tciduu vhbu egcedcv|avbgc bu fbuub{avdf lr vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 82/173
uajd a`dcer (rgt|udim" phbeh mb|uv {|gftedf bv) bv
pbii pg|o gc lr vhd iap gm `|gpvh vg egj{idvd
jacbmduvavbgc gc vhd gtvpa|f {iacd#
Bc fdaibc` pbvh vhbu `|dav bj{d|ugcai
bcvdiib`dced) pd a|d fdaibc` pbvh vhd bcmbcbvd) acf
pd jtuv mtiir |daib~d bcmbcbvtfd au vhav phbeh
vgtehdu aii {gbcvu) acf bm bv fgdu) vhd|d uhgtif ld
cg fbmmbetivr bc tcfd|uvacfbc` vhav vhbu
bcvdiib`dced eac f|ap vg`dvhd| vhd jdacu
|dqtbubvd mg| bvu {t|{gud d}dc m|gj vhd dcfu gm
vhd pg|if? acf vhd|dmg|d) |daib~bc` vhd Iap
aeeg|fbc` vg phbeh vhd |dutiv eac ld {|gftedf) pd jtuv |dugitvdir {tv aubfd aii qtduvbgcbc` au vg
vhd u{debmbe jdacu phbeh pbii ld dj{igrdf bc acr
eaud# Vg qtduvbgc vhbu bu vg ugp vhav }d|r uddf gm
fgtlv phbeh bv bu gt| mb|uv glndev vg d|afbeavd) acf
gt| bcvdiidevtai dcfda}gt| uhgtif vhd|dmg|d ldfb|devdf) cgv vg vhd avvdj{v vg mg|dvdii vhd }a|bgtu
udegcfa|r eatudu phbeh pbii d}dcvtaiir egjlbcd
vg {|gfted vhd fdub|df |dutiv) iarbc` fgpc
ldmg|dhacf phav {a|vbetia| eatudu uhgtif ld
cdeduua|r) acf m|gj phav qta|vd| vhdr uhgtif
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 83/173
egjd? ltv pd uhgtif fb|dev gt| bcvdiidevtai
dcfda}gt| vg uddbc` jg|d eida|ir vhd |avbgcaid gm
vhd `dcd|ai iap lr phbeh v|abcu gm udegcfa|r
eatudu a|d udv bc jgvbgc# Dj{igrdf bc vhd mg|jd|
par gt| bcvdiidev ldegjdu vhd `|davduv hbcf|aced
vg gt| uteeduu) mg| bv gcir hdi{u vg bce|daud gt|
fgtlvu) ubced bv bu v|rbc` vg `|au{ {a|vbetia|u
phbeh) av vhd vbjd a|d dcvb|dir gtvubfd bvu eb|eid gm
}bubgc? ltv dj{igrdf bc vhd iavvd| bv ammg|fu vhd
jguv javd|bai abf bc jabcvabcbc` vhav cteidtu
pbvhgtv phbeh vhd|d bu cg edcv|d m|gj phbeh vhd
{|bceb{id gm `|gpvh eac auud|v bvudim# Vhd bcvdiidev
eac gcir fdfted egcudqtdcedu m|gj maevu phbeh
bv bu alid vg uvavd) acf egcudqtdcvir eaccgv
fdfted acr auut|aced m|gj maevu gm phgud
dxbuvdced bv eaccgv rdv ha}d acr ocgpidf`d
vh|gt`h vhd jdfbtj gm vhd gtvpa|f udcudu? ltv
mg| vhd uajd |daugc bv eac |daib~d vhd dxbuvdced gm
a Iap lr phbeh vhd au rdv tcjacbmduvdf
eb|etjuvacedu jar ld l|gt`hv bcvg
jacbmduvavbgc# Vhtu tudf bc bvu |b`hv g|fd|) vhd
bcvdiidev ldegjdu vhd hacfjabf gm vhav jg|d
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 84/173
bcvd|bg| {gpd| pbvhbc tu phbeh jacb{tiavdu vhd
tcuddc utluvaced gm aii vhbc`u) acf phbeh pd jar
eaii |diavb}d mb|uv eatud#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 85/173
BX#
EATUDU ACF EGCFBVBGCU#
Vhd dx{|duubgc ,|diavb}d mb|uv eatud, hau lddc
tudf bc vhd iauv udevbgc vg fbuvbc`tbuh vhd aevbgc
gm vhd e|davb}d {|bceb{id bc vhd bcfb}bftai jbcfm|gj Tcb}d|uai Mb|uv Eatud gc vhd gcd hacf acf
m|gj udegcfa|r eatudu gc vhd gvhd|# Au bv dxbuvu
bc tu ) {|bja|r eatuavbgc bu vhd {gpd| vg bcbvbavd a
v|abc gm eatuavbgc fb|devdf vg ac bcfb}bftai
{t|{gud# Au vhd {gpd| gm bcbvbavbc` a m|duhudqtdced gm eatud acf dmmdev bv bu mb|uv eatud) acf
au |dmd||bc` vg ac bcfb}bftai {t|{gud bv bu |diavb}d)
acf bv jar vhd|dmg|d ld u{godc gm au |diavb}d mb|uv
eatud) g| vhd {gpd| gm {|bja|r eatuavbgc
jacbmduvdf lr vhd bcfb}bftai# Vhd tcfd|uvacfbc`
acf tud gm vhbu {gpd| bu vhd phgid glndev gm
Jdcvai Uebdced) acf bv bu vhd|dmg|d cdeduua|r vhav
vhd uvtfdcv uhgtif eida|ir udd vhd |diavbgc
ldvpddc eatudu acf egcfbvbgcu# A ubj{id
biituv|avbgc pbii `g mt|vhd| mg| vhbu {t|{gud vhac
acr dialg|avd dx{iacavbgc# Bm a ib`hvdf eacfid bu
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 86/173
l|gt`hv bcvg a |ggj vhd |ggj ldegjdu
biitjbcavdf) acf bm vhd eacfid bu vaodc apar bv
ldegjdu fa|o a`abc# Cgp vhd biitjbcavbgc acfvhd fa|ocduu a|d lgvh egcfbvbgcu) vhd gcd
{gubvb}d |dutivbc` m|gj vhd {|dudced gm vhd ib`hv)
acf vhd gvhd| cd`avb}d |dutivbc` m|gj bvu aludced>
m|gj vhbu ubj{id dxaj{id pd vhd|dmg|d udd vhav
d}d|r {gubvb}d egcfbvbgc hau ac dxaevir g{{gubvdcd`avb}d egcfbvbgc eg||du{gcfbc` vg bv) acf vhav
vhbu eg||du{gcfdced |dutivu m|gj vhdb| ldbc`
|diavdf vg vhd uajd eatud ) vhd gcd {gubvb}dir acf
vhd gvhd| cd`avb}dir? acf hdced pd jar iar fgpc
vhd |tid vhav aii {gubvb}d egcfbvbgcu |dutiv m|gj
vhd aevb}d {|dudced gm a ed|vabc eatud) acf aii
cd`avb}d egcfbvbgcu m|gj vhd aludced gm uteh a
eatud# A egcfbvbgc) phdvhd| {gubvb}d g| cd`avb}d)
bu cd}d| {|bja|r eatud) acf vhd {|bja|r eatud gm
acr ud|bdu eac cd}d| ld cd`avb}d) mg| cd`avbgc bu
vhd egcfbvbgc phbeh a|budu m|gj vhd aludced gm
aevb}d eatuavbgc# Vhbu uhgtif ld vhg|gt`hir
tcfd|uvggf au bv bu vhd {hbigug{hbe laubu gm aii
vhgud ,fdcbaiu, phbeh {iar ug bj{g|vacv a) {a|v bc
Jdcvai Uebdced) acf phbeh jar ld utjjdf t{ bc
vhd uvavdjdcv vhav d}bi ldbc` cd`avb}d) g|
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 87/173
{|b}avbgc gm `ggf) hau cg utluvacvb}d dxbuvdced bc
bvudim# Egcfbvbgcu) hgpd}d|) phdvhd| {gubvb}d g|
cd`avb}d) a|d cg uggcd| eaiidf bcvg dxbuvdced vhacvhdr ldegjd eatudu bc vhdb| vt|c acf {|gfted
mt|vhd| egcfbvbgcu) acf ug gc af bcmbcbvtj ) vhtu
`b}bc` |bud vg vhd phgid v|abc gm udegcfa|r eatudu#
Ug igc` au pd ntf`d gcir m|gj vhd bcmg|javbgc
egc}drdf vg tu lr vhd gtvpa|f udcudu) pd a|d pg|obc` gc vhd {iacd gm udegcfa|r eatuavbgc acf
udd cgvhbc` ltv a uteeduubgc gm egcfbvbgcu)
mg|jbc` {a|v gm ac dcfiduu v|abc gm acvdedfdcv
egcfbvbgcu egjbc` gtv gm vhd {auv acf uv|dvehbc`
apar bcvg vhd mtvt|d) acf m|gj vhbu {gbcv gm }bdp
pd a|d tcfd| vhd |tid gm ac b|gc fduvbcr m|gj
phbeh vhd|d uddju cg {guublbibvr gm duea{d# Vhbu
bu ldeatud vhd gtvpa|f udcudu a|d gcir ea{alid gm
fdaibc` pbvh vhd |diavbgcu phbeh gcd jgfd gm
ibjbvavbgc lda|u vg acgvhd|) mg| vhdr a|d vhd
bcuv|tjdcvu lr phbeh pd vaod eg`cb~aced gm vhd
|diavb}d acf vhd egcfbvbgcdf# Cgp vhd gcir par gm
duea{d bu lr |bubc` gtv gm vhd |d`bgc gm udegcfa|r
eatudu bcvg vhav gm {|bja|r eatuavbgc) phd|d vhd
g|b`bcavbc` dcd|`r bu vg ld mgtcf ldmg|d bv hau rdv
{auudf bcvg jacbmduvavbgc au a egcfbvbgc# Vhbu
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 88/173
|d`bgc bu vg ld mgtcf pbvhbc gt|udi}du ? bv bu vhd
|d`bgc gm {t|d bfdau? acf bv bu mg| vhbu |daugc vhav
B ha}d iabf uv|duu gc vhd vpg au{devu gm u{b|bv au{t|d vhgt`hv acf jacbmduvdf mg|j# Vhd vhgt`hv*
bja`d g| bfdai {avvd|c gm a vhbc` bu vhd mb|uv eatud
|diavb}dir vg vhav vhbc`? bv bu vhd utluvaced gm vhav
vhbc` tcv|ajjdiidf) lr acr acvdedfdcv
egcfbvbgcu#Bm pd |daib~d vhav aii }bublid vhbc`u jtuv ha}d
vhdb| g|b`bc bc u{b|bv) vhdc vhd phgid e|davbgc
a|gtcf tu bu vhd uvacfbc` d}bfdced vhav vhd
uva|vbc`*{gbcv gm aii vhbc`u bu bc vhgt`hv*bja`du
g| bfdau) mg| cg gvhd| aevbgc vhac vhd mg|javbgcgm uteh bja`du eac ld egcedb}df gm u{b|bv {|bg| vg
bvu jacbmduvavbgc bc javvd|# Bm) vhdc) vhbu bu
u{b|bv'u jgftu g{d|acfb mg| udim*dx{|duubgc) pd
ha}d gcir vg v|acumd| vhbu egced{vbgc m|gj vhd
ueaid gm egujbe u{b|bv pg|obc` gc vhd {iacd gm vhd
tcb}d|uai vg vhav gm bcfb}bftaib~df u{b|bv pg|obc`
gc vhd {iacd gm vhd {a|vbetia|) vg udd vhav vhd
mg|javbgc gm ac bfdai bja`d lr jdacu gm gt|
vhgt`hv bu udvvbc` mb|uv eatud bc jgvbgc pbvh
|d`a|f vg vhbu u{debmbe glndev# Vhd|d bu cg
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 89/173
fbmmd|dced bc obcf ldvpddc vhd g{d|avbgc gm mb|uv
eatud bc vhd tcb}d|uai acf bc vhd {a|vbetia|) vhd
fbmmd|dced bu gcir a fbmmd|dced gm ueaid) ltv vhd{gpd| bvudim bu bfdcvbeai# Pd jtuv vhd|dmg|d
aiparu ld }d|r eida| au vg phdvhd| pd a|d
egcuebgtuir tubc` mb|uv eatud g| cgv# Cgvd vhd
pg|f ,egcuebgtuir, ldeatud) phdvhd| egcuebgtuir
g| tcegcuebgtuir) pd a|d aiparu tubc` mb|uv eatud?acf bv pau mg| vhbu |daugc B dj{haub~df vhd maev
vhav vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf bu {t|dir utlndevb}d acf
vhd|dmg|d lgtcf lr vhd iapu phbeh a{{ir vg
utlndevb}d jbcf gc phavd}d| ueaid# Hdced pd a|d
aiparu bj{|duubc` ugjd ug|v gm bfdau t{gc bv)
phdvhd| pd a|d apa|d gm vhd maev g| cgv) acf aii
gt| dxbuvbc` ibjbvavbgcu |dutiv m|gj gt| ha}bc`
halbvtaiir bj{|duudf t{gc bv vhav bfda gm
ibjbvavbgc phbeh pd ha}d bjlbldf lr |duv|bevbc`
aii {guublbibvr vg vhd |d`bgc gm udegcfa|r eatudu#
Ltv cgp phdc bc}duvb`avbgc hau uhgpc tu vhav
egcfbvbgcu a|d cd}d| eatudu bc vhdjudi}du ) ltv
gcir vhd utludqtdcv ibcou gm a ehabc uva|vdf gc
vhd {iacd gm vhd {t|d bfdai) phav pd ha}d vg fg bu
vg |d}d|ud gt| jdvhgf gm vhbcobc` acf |d`a|f vhd
bfdai au vhd |dai) acf vhd gtvpa|f jacbmduvavbgc
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 90/173
au a jd|d |dmidevbgc phbeh jtuv ehac`d pbvh
d}d|r ehac`d gm vhd glndev phbeh eauvu bv# Mg|
vhdud |daugcu bv bu duudcvbai vg ocgp phdvhd| pda|d egcuebgtuir jaobc` tud gm mb|uv eatud pbvh a
fdmbcbvd {t|{gud g| cgv) acf vhd e|bvd|bgc bu vhbu#
Bm pd |d`a|f vhd mtimbijdcv gm gt| {t|{gud au
egcvbc`dcv t{gc acr eb|etjuvacedu ) {auv)
{|dudcv) g| mtvt|d) pd a|d cgv jaobc` tud gm mb|uveatud? pd ha}d fduedcfdf vg vhd id}di gm
udegcfa|r eatuavbgc) phbeh bu vhd |d`bgc gm
fgtlvu) mda|u) acf ibjbvavbgcu) aii gm phbeh pd a|d
bj{|duubc` t{gc vhd tcb}d|uai utlndevb}d jbcf
pbvh vhd bcd}bvalid |dutiv vhav bv pbii ltbif t{
eg||du{gcfbc` dxvd|cai egcfbvbgcu# Ltv bm pd
|daib~d vhav vhd |d`bgc gm udegcfa|r eatudu bu vhd
|d`bgc gm jd|d |dmidevbgcu pd uhaii cgv vhbco gm
gt| {t|{gud au egcvbc`dcv gc acr egcfbvbgcu
phavd}d|) ltv uhaii ocgp vhav lr mg|jbc` vhd bfda
gm bv bc vhd alugitvd) acf jabcvabcbc` vhav bfda)
pd ha}d uha{df vhd mb|uv eatud bcvg vhd fdub|df
mg|j acf eac apabv vhd |dutiv pbvh ehdd|mti
dx{devacer#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 91/173
Bv bu hd|d vhav pd mbcf vhd bj{g|vaced gm |daib~bc`
u{b|bv'u bcfd{dcfdced gm vbjd acf u{aed# Ac bfdai)
au uteh) eaccgv ld mg|jdf bc vhd mtvt|d# Bv jtuvdbvhd| ld mg|jdf hd|d acf cgp g| cgv ld mg|jdf
av aii? acf bv bu mg| vhbu |daugc vhav d}d|r vdaehd|)
phg hau d}d| u{godc pbvh ftd ocgpidf`d gm vhd
utlndev) hau bj{|duudf t{gc hbu mgiigpd|u vhd
cdeduubvr gm {bevt|bc` vg vhdjudi}du vhdmtimbijdcv gm vhdb| fdub|du au ai|dafr
aeegj{ibuhdf gc vhd u{b|bvtai {iacd) au vhd
bcfbu{dcualid egcfbvbgc gm mtimbijdcv bc vhd
}bublid acf egce|dvd#
Phdc vhbu bu {|g{d|ir tcfd|uvggf) acr acxbgtuvhgt`hv au vg vhd jdacu vg ld dj{igrdf bc vhd
aeegj{ibuhjdcv gm gt| {t|{gudu bu uddc vg ld
qtbvd tccdeduua|r# Bm vhd dcf bu ai|dafr udet|df)
vhdc bv mgiigpu vhav aii vhd uvd{u idafbc` vg bv a|d
udet|df aiug# Vhd jdacu pbii {auu bcvg vhd
ujaiid| eb|eid gm gt| egcuebgtu aevb}bvbdu far lr
far bc ftd g|fd|) acf vhdc pd ha}d vg pg|o t{gc
vhdj) cgv pbvh mda|) fgtlv) g| md}d|buh
dxebvdjdcv) ltv eaijir acf ngrgtuir) ldeatud
pd ocgp vhav vhd dcf bu ai|dafr udet|df) acf vhav
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 92/173
gt| |daugcalid tud gm uteh jdacu au {|dudcv
vhdjudi}du bc vhd fdub|df fb|devbgc bu) gcir gcd
{g|vbgc gm a jteh ia|`d| eg*g|fbcavdf jg}djdcv)vhd mbcai |dutiv gm phbeh afjbvu gm cg fgtlv#
Jdcvai Uebdced fgdu cgv gmmd| a {|djbtj vg
bfidcduu) ltv bv vaodu) aii pg|o gtv gm vhd |d`bgc gm
acxbdvr acf vgbi lr auut|bc` vhd pg|od| gm vhd
uteeduu gm hbu ialgt|) bm cgv bc vhd {|debud mg|j hdacvbeb{avdf) vhdc bc ugjd gvhd| uvbii ldvvd| utbvdf
vg hbu |dqtb|djdcvu# Ltv ut{{gud) phdc pd |daeh
a {gbcv phd|d ugjd jgjdcvgtu fdebubgc hau vg
ld jafd) pd ha{{dc vg fdebfd p|gc`ir7 Gc vhd
hr{gvhdubu vhav vhd dcf bu ai|dafr udet|df rgt
eaccgv fdebfd p|gc`ir# Rgt| |b`hv fdebubgc bu au
jteh gcd gm vhd cdeduua|r uvd{u bc vhd
aeegj{ibuhjdcv gm vhd dcf au acr gm vhd gvhd|
egcfbvbgcu idafbc` t{ vg bv) acf vhd|dmg|d) phbid
ldbc` ea|dmti vg a}gbf |auh aevbgc) pd jar jaod
ut|d vhav vhd uajd Iap phbeh bu egcv|giibc` vhd
|duv gm vhd eb|etjuvacedu bc vhd |b`hv fb|devbgc
pbii bcmitdced gt| ntf`jdcv bc vhav fb|devbgc aiug#
Vg `dv `ggf |dutivu pd jtuv {|g{d|ir tcfd|uvacf
gt| |diavbgc vg vhd `|dav bj{d|ugcai {gpd| pd a|d
tubc`# Bv bu bcvdiib`dcv acf pd a|d bcvdiib`dcv) acf
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 93/173
vhd vpg bcvdiib`dcedu jtuv eg*g{d|avd# Pd jtuv
cgv mir bc vhd maed gm vhd Iap lr dx{devbc` bv vg fg
mg| tu phav bv eac gcir fg vh|gt`h tu? acf pdjtuv vhd|dmg|d tud gt| bcvdiib`dced pbvh vhd
ocgpidf`d vhav bv bu aevbc` au vhd bcuv|tjdcv gm a
`|davd| bcvdiib`dced ? acf ldeatud pd ha}d vhbu
ocgpidf`d pd jar) acf uhgtif) edaud m|gj aii
acxbdvr au vg vhd mbcai |dutiv# Bc aevtai {|aevbed pdjtuv mb|uv mg|j vhd bfdai egced{vbgc gm gt| glndev
pbvh vhd fdmbcbvd bcvdcvbgc gm bj{|duubc` bv t{gc
vhd tcb}d|uai jbcf**bv bu vhbu bcvdcvbgc phbeh
vaodu uteh vhgt`hv gtv gm vhd |d`bgc gm jd|d
eautai macebdu**acf vhdc ammb|j vhav gt|
ocgpidf`d gm vhd Iap bu utmmbebdcv |daugc mg| a
eaij dx{devavbgc gm a eg||du{gcfbc` |dutiv) acf
vhav vhd|dmg|d aii cdeduua|r egcfbvbgcu pbii egjd
vg tu bc ftd g|fd|# Pd eac vhdc vt|c vg vhd ammab|u
gm gt| fabir ibmd pbvh vhd eaij auut|aced vhav vhd
bcbvbai egcfbvbgcu a|d dbvhd| vhd|d ai|dafr g| pbii
uggc egjd bcvg }bdp# Bm pd fg cgv av gced udd
vhdj) idv tu |duv egcvdcv pbvh vhd ocgpidf`d vhav
vhd u{b|bvtai {|gvgvr{d bu ai|dafr bc dxbuvdced acf
pabv vbii ugjd eb|etjuvaced {gbcvbc` bc vhd
fdub|df fb|devbgc ld`bcu vg uhgp bvudim# Bv jar ld
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 94/173
a }d|r ujaii eb|etjuvaced) ltv bv bu vhd fb|devbgc
acf cgv vhd ja`cbvtfd phbeh bu vg ld vaodc bcvg
egcubfd|avbgc# Au uggc au pd udd bv pd uhgtif|d`a|f bv au vhd mb|uv u{|gtvbc` gm vhd uddf pd
ha}d ugpc bc vhd Alugitvd) acf fg eaijir) acf
pbvhgtv dxebvdjdcv) phavd}d| vhd eb|etjuvacedu
jar uddj vg |dqtb|d) acf vhdc iavd| gc pd uhaii
udd vhav vhbu fgbc` pbii bc vt|c idaf vg mt|vhd|eb|etjuvacedu bc vhd uajd fb|devbgc tcvbi pd mbcf
gt|udi}du egcftevdf uvd{ lr uvd{ vg vhd
aeegj{ibuhjdcv gm gt| glndev# Bc vhbu par vhd
tcfd|uvacfbc` gm vhd `|dav {|bceb{id gm vhd Iap gm
Ut{{ir pbii) lr |d{davdf dx{d|bdcedu) fdib}d| tu
jg|d acf jg|d egj{idvdir gtv gm vhd |d`bgc gm
acxbgtu vhgt`hv acf vgbiugjd ialgt| acf l|bc`
tu bcvg a cdp pg|if phd|d vhd tudmti
dj{igrjdcv gm aii gt| {gpd|u) phdvhd| jdcvai g|
{hrubeai) pbii gcir ld ac tcmgifbc` gm gt|
bcfb}bftaibvr t{gc vhd ibcdu gm bvu gpc cavt|d)
acf vhd|dmg|d a {d|{dvtai ugt|ed gm hdaivh acf
ha{{bcduu? a utmmbebdcv bcftedjdcv) ut|dir) vg vhd
ea|dmti uvtfr gm vhd iapu `g}d|cbc` vhd |diavbgc
ldvpddc vhd bcfb}bftai acf vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 95/173
X#
BCVTBVBGC#
Pd ha}d uddc vhav vhd utlndevb}d jbcf bu
ajdcalid vg ut``duvbgc lr vhd glndevb}d jbcf?
ltv vhd|d bu aiug ac aevbgc gm vhd utlndevb}d jbcft{gc vhd glndevb}d# Vhd bcfb}bftai'u utlndevb}d
jbcf bu hbu gpc bccd|jguv udim) acf bvu mb|uv ea|d
bu vhd jabcvdcaced gm vhd bcfb}bftaibvr gm phbeh bv
bu vhd mgtcfavbgc? acf ubced bv bu {t|d u{b|bv bv hau
bvu egcvbctai dxbuvdced bc vhav {iacd gm ldbc` phd|d aii vhbc`u utlubuv bc vhd tcb}d|uai hd|d acf
vhd d}d|iauvbc` cgp) acf egcudqtdcvir eac)
bcmg|j vhd igpd| jbcf gm vhbc`u |djg}df m|gj
bvu odc dbvhd| lr fbuvaced g| mtvt|bvr# Au vhd
aludced gm vhd egcfbvbgcu gm vbjd acf u{aed jtuv
ig`beaiir egcedcv|avd aii vhbc`u bcvg a {|dudcv
mgetu) pd eac auub`c cg ibjbv vg vhd utlndevb}d
jbcf'u {gpd| gm {d|ed{vbgc) acf vhd|dmg|d vhd
qtduvbgc a|budu) phr fgdu bv cgv odd{ vhd
glndevb}d jbcf egcvbctaiir bcmg|jdf gc aii
{gbcvu7 Acf vhd acupd| bu vhav bv pgtif fg ug bm
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 96/173
vhd glndevb}d jbcf pd|d utmmbebdcvir v|abcdf vg
|deg`cb~d vhd bcfbeavbgcu `b}dc) acf vg dmmdev vhbu
v|abcbc` bu gcd gm vhd {t|{gudu gm Jdcvai Uebdced# Phdc gced pd |deg`cb~d vhd {gubvbgc gm vhd
utlndevb}d jbcf au vhd ut{{g|vd| gm vhd phgid
bcfb}bftaibvr pd eaccgv fgtlv vhav jteh gm phav
pd vaod vg ld vhd u{gcvacdgtu jg}djdcv gm vhd
glndevb}d jbcf hau bvu g|b`bc bc vhd utlndevb}djbcf {|gj{vbc` vhd glndevb}d jbcf bc vhd |b`hv
fb|devbgc pbvhgtv gt| ldbc` egcuebgtuir apa|d gm
bv# Ltv av vbjdu phdc vhd t|`dcer gm vhd eaud
uddju vg fdjacf bv) g| phdc) mg| ugjd |daugc rdv
tcocgpc) vhd glndevb}d jbcf bu mg| a phbid jg|d
eigudir dc |a{{g|v pbvh vhd utlndevb}d jbcf) vhd
bcvd|bg| }gbed bu hda|f uv|gc`ir acf {d|ubuvdcvir?
acf phdc vhbu bu vhd eaud pd fg pdii vg {ar hddf
vg bv# Pacv gm u{aed mg|lbfu jd vg `b}d dxaj{idu)
ltv fgtlviduu uteh pbii cgv ld pacvbc` bc vhd
|dafd|'u dx{d|bdced#
Vhd bj{g|vaced gm tcfd|uvacfbc` acf mgiigpbc`
vhd bcvtbvbgc eaccgv ld dxa``d|avdf) ltv B
eacfbfir afjbv vhd `|dav {|aevbeai fbmmbetivr gm
odd{bc` vhd ha{{r jdac ldvpddc vhd fbu|d`a|f
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 97/173
gm vhd bcvd|bg| }gbed acf aiigpbc` gt|udi}du vg ld
|tc apar pbvh lr `|gtcfiduu macebdu# Vhd lduv
`tbfd bu vhd ocgpidf`d vhav egjdu gm {d|ugcaidx{d|bdced phbeh `|aftaiir idafu vg vhd
aeqtbubvbgc gm a ug|v gm bcpa|f udcud gm vgteh vhav
dcalidu tu vg fbuvbc`tbuh vhd v|td m|gj vhd maiud)
acf phbeh a{{da|u vg `|gp pbvh vhd ubced|d
fdub|d mg| v|tvh acf pbvh vhd |deg`cbvbgc gm vhdu{b|bv au bvu ugt|ed# Vhd gcir `dcd|ai {|bceb{idu
vhd p|bvd| eac fdfted m|gj hbu gpc dx{d|bdced
a|d vhav phdc) bc u{bvd gm aii a{{da|acedu
{gbcvbc` bc vhd fb|devbgc gm a ed|vabc ibcd gm
egcftev) vhd|d bu uvbii a {d|ubuvdcv mddibc` vhav bv
uhgtif cgv ld mgiigpdf) bc vhd jang|bvr gm
bcuvacedu bv pbii ld mgtcf vhav vhd a|`tjdcv gm
vhd glndevb}d jbcf) hgpd}d| eg||dev gc vhd maevu
glndevb}dir ocgpc) pau fdmbebdcv m|gj b`cg|aced
gm maevu phbeh egtif cgv ld glndevb}dir ocgpc av
vhd vbjd) ltv phbeh pd|d ocgpc vg vhd bcvtbvb}d
maetivr# Acgvhd| {|bceb{id bu vhav gt| }d|r
mb|uv bj{|duubgc gm mddibc` gc acr utlndev bu
`dcd|aiir eg||dev# Ldmg|d vhd glndevb}d jbcf hau
ld`tc vg a|`td gc vhd utlndev bv bu ibod vhd ut|maed
gm a ujggvh iaod phbeh eida|ir |dmidevu vhd ib`hv
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 98/173
m|gj alg}d? ltv au uggc au bv ld`bcu vg a|`td
m|gj gtvubfd a{{da|acedu vhdud aiug vh|gp vhdb|
|dmidevbgcu t{gc bvu ut|maed) ug vhav vhd g|b`bcaibja`d ldegjdu lit||df acf bu cg igc`d|
|deg`cb~alid# Vhbu mb|uv egced{vbgc bu }d|r
u{ddfbir iguv) acf bv uhgtif vhd|dmg|d ld ea|dmtiir
glud|}df acf |d`buvd|df bc vhd jdjg|r pbvh a
}bdp vg vduvbc` vhd }a|bgtu a|`tjdcvu phbeh pbiiutludqtdcvir a|bud gc vhd glndevb}d {iacd# Bv bu
hgpd}d| bj{guublid vg |dfted ug bcvd|bg| ac
aevbgc au vhav gm vhd bcvtbvbgc vg vhd mg|j gm ha|f
acf mauv |tidu) acf ldrgcf ea|dmtiir cgvbc`
{a|vbetia| eaudu au vhdr geet|) {|glalir vhd lduv
{iac mg| vhd uvtfdcv pbii ld vg bceitfd vhd phgid
utlndev gm bcvtbvbgc bc vhd `dcd|ai {|bceb{id gm vhd
Iap gm Avv|aevbgc) du{debaiir bm hd uddu hgp vhbu
iap bcvd|aevu pbvh vhav {d|ugcai qtaibvr gm
tcb}d|uai u{b|bv gm phbeh pd ha}d ai|dafr u{godc#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 99/173
XB#
HDAIBC@#
Vhd utlndev gm hdaibc` hau lddc dialg|avdir
v|davdf lr jacr p|bvd|u acf mtiir fdud|}du aii vhd
avvdcvbgc vhav hau lddc `b}dc vg bv) ltv vhd glndevgm vhdud idevt|du bu |avhd| vg `|gtcf vhd uvtfdcv
bc vhgud `dcd|ai {|bceb{idu gc phbeh aii egcuebgtu
tud gm vhd e|davb}d {gpd| gm vhgt`hv bu laudf)
vhac vg iar fgpc mg|jai |tidu mg| u{debmbe
a{{ibeavbgcu gm bv# B pbii vhd|dmg|d dxajbcd vhd l|gaf {|bceb{idu phbeh a{{da| vg ld egjjgc vg
vhd }a|bgtu jdvhgfu gm jdcvai hdaibc` phbeh a|d
bc tud) daeh gm phbeh fd|b}du bvu dmmbeaer) cgv m|gj
vhd {detiba|bvr gm vhd jdvhgf) ltv m|gj bv ldbc`
uteh a jdvhgf au aiigpu vhd hb`hd| iapu gm
Cavt|d vg egjd bcvg {iar# Cgp vhd {|bceb{id
tcb}d|uaiir iabf fgpc lr aii jdcvai hdaid|u) bc
phavd}d| }a|bgtu vd|ju vhdr jar dx{iabc bv) bu
vhav vhd laubu gm aii hdaibc` bu a ehac`d bc ldibdm#
Vhd udqtdced m|gj phbeh vhbu |dutivu bu au
mgiigpu>**vhd utlndevb}d jbcf bu vhd e|davb}d
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 100/173
maetivr pbvhbc tu) acf e|davdu phavd}d| vhd
glndevb}d jbcf bj{|duudu t{gc bv? vhd glndevb}d
jbcf) g| bcvdiidev) bj{|duudu bvu vhgt`hv t{gc bv?vhd vhgt`hv bu vhd dx{|duubgc gm vhd ldibdm? hdced
phavd}d| vhd utlndevb}d jbcf e|davdu bu vhd
|d{|gftevbgc dxvd|caiir gm gt| ldibdmu#
Aeeg|fbc`ir gt| phgid glndev bu vg ehac`d gt|
ldibdmu) acf pd eaccgv fg vhbu pbvhgtv ugjd ugibf`|gtcf gm egc}bevbgc gm vhd maiubvr gm gt| gif
ldibdmu acf gm vhd v|tvh gm gt| cdp gcdu) acf vhbu
`|gtcf pd mbcf bc vhav iap gm eatuavbgc phbeh B
ha}d dcfda}gt|df vg dx{iabc# Vhd p|gc` ldibdm
phbeh dxvd|caib~du au ubeocduu bu vhd ldibdm vhav
ugjd udegcfa|r eatud) phbeh bu |daiir gcir a
egcfbvbgc) bu a {|bja|r eatud# Vhd ocgpidf`d gm
vhd iap uhgpu vhav vhd|d bu gcir gcd {|bja|r
eatud) acf vhbu bu vhd maevg| phbeh bc gt| gpc
bcfb}bftaibvr pd eaii utlndevb}d g| utl*egcuebgtu
jbcf# Mg| vhbu |daugc B ha}d bcubuvdf gc vhd
fbmmd|dced ldvpddc {iaebc` ac bfda bc vhd utl*
egcuebgtu jbcf) vhav bu) gc vhd {iacd gm vhd
alugitvd acf pbvhgtv |dmd|dced vg vbjd acf
u{aed) acf {iaebc` vhd uajd bfda bc vhd egcuebgtu
bcvdiidevtai jbcf phbeh gcir {d|edb}du vhbc`u au
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 101/173
|diavdf vg vbjd acf u{aed# Cgp vhd gcir
egced{vbgc rgt eac ha}d gm rgt|udim bc vhd
alugitvd) g| tcegcfbvbgcdf) bu au {t|dir ib}bc` U{b|bv ) cgv haj{d|df lr egcfbvbgcu gm acr ug|v)
acf vhd|dmg|d cgv utlndev vg biicduu? acf phdc
vhbu bfda bu mb|jir bj{|duudf gc vhd utl*
egcuebgtu jbcf) bv pbii dxvd|caib~d bv# Vhd |daugc
phr vhbu {|geduu bu cgv aiparu uteeduumti av vhdmb|uv avvdj{v bu vhav aii gt| ibmd pd ha}d lddc
hgifbc` vhd maiud ldibdm bc ubeocduu au a
utluvacvbai dcvbvr bc bvudim acf vhtu ldbc` a
{|bja|r eatud) bcuvdaf gm ldbc` jd|dir a cd`avb}d
egcfbvbgc |dutivbc` m|gj vhd gludced gm a
{|bja|r eatud? acf a ldibdm phbeh hau ldegjd
bc`|abcdf m|gj ehbifhggf eaccgv ld d|afbeavdf av
a jgjdcv'u cgvbed# Pd gmvdc mbcf) vhd|dmg|d) vhav
mg| ugjd vbjd amvd| a v|davjdcv vhd|d bu ac
bj{|g}djdcv bc vhd {avbdcv'u hdaivh) acf vhdc
vhd gif urj{vgju |dvt|c# Vhbu bu ldeatud vhd cdp
ldibdm bc hbu gpc e|davb}d maetivr hau cgv rdv haf
vbjd vg {dcdv|avd fgpc vg vhd bccd|jguv fd{vhu
gm vhd utlegcuebgtu jbcf) ltv hau gcir {a|vbaiir
dcvd|df bv# Daeh uteeddfbc` v|davjdcv
uv|dc`vhdcu vhd utl*egcuebgtu jbcf bc bvu hgif gm
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 102/173
vhd cdp ldibdm tcvbi av iauv a {d|jacdcv et|d bu
dmmdevdf# Vhbu bu vhd jdvhgf gm udim*v|davjdcv
laudf gc vhd {avbdcv'u gpc ocgpidf`d gm vhd iap gm hbu ldbc`#
Ltv ,vhd|d bu cgv bc aii jdc vhbu ocgpidf`d), g| av
acr |avd cgv uteh a mtii |deg`cbvbgc gm bv au pbii
dcalid vhdj vg `b}d uteeduumti v|davjdcv vg
vhdjudi}du) acf bc vhdud eaudu vhd bcvd|}dcvbgc gm vhd hdaid| ldegjdu cdeduua|r# Vhd gcir
fbmmd|dced ldvpddc vhd hdaid| acf vhd {avbdcv bu
vhav vhd hdaid| hau ida|cv hgp vg egcv|gi vhd iduu
udim*egcuebgtu jgfdu gm vhd u{b|bv lr vhd jg|d
udim*egcuebgtu jgfd) phbid vhd {avbdcv hau cgv rdv avvabcdf vg vhbu ocgpidf`d? acf phav vhd
hdaid| fgdu bu vg utluvbvtvd hbu gpc glndevb}d g|
egcuebgtu jdcvaibvr) phbeh bu pbii ngbcdf vg
bcvdiidev) mg| vhav gm vhd {avbdcv) acf bc vhbu par vg
mbcf dcv|aced vg hbu utl*egcuebgtu jbcf acf
bj{|duu t{gc bv vhd ut``duvbgc gm {d|mdev hdaivh#
Vhd qtduvbgc vhdc a|budu) hgp eac vhd hdaid|
utluvbvtvd hbu gpc egcuebgtu jbcf mg| vhav gm vhd
{avbdcv7 acf vhd acupd| uhgpu vhd {|aevbeai
a{{ibeavbgc gm vhgud }d|r aluv|aev {|bceb{idu
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 103/173
phbeh B ha}d iabf fgpc bc vhd da|ibd| udevbgcu#
Gt| g|fbca|r egced{vbgc gm gt|udi}du bu vhav gm ac
bcfb}bftai {d|ugcaibvr phbeh dcfu phd|d acgvhd|{d|ugcaibvr ld`bcu) bc gvhd| pg|fu vhav vhd vpg
{d|ugcaibvbdu a|d dcvb|dir ud{a|avd# Vhbu bu ac
d||g|# Vhd|d bu cg uteh ha|f acf mauv ibcd gm
fdja|eavbgc ldvpddc {d|ugcaibvbdu) acf vhd
lgtcfa|bdu ldvpddc gcd acf acgvhd| eac ldbce|daudf g| |dftedf bc |b`bfbvr aeeg|fbc` vg pbii)
bc maev vhdr jar ld vdj{g|a|bir |djg}df ug
egj{idvdir vhav) mg| vhd vbjd ldbc`) vhd vpg
{d|ugcaibvbdu ldegjd jd|`df bcvg gcd# Cgp vhd
aevbgc phbeh vaodu {iaed ldvpddc hdaid| acf
{avbdcv fd{dcfu gc vhbu {|bceb{id# Vhd {avbdcv bu
auodf lr vhd hdaid| vg {tv hbjudim bc a |ded{vb}d
jdcvai avvbvtfd) phbeh jdacu vhav hd bu vg
dxd|ebud hbu }gibvbgc mg| vhd {t|{gud gm |djg}bc`
vhd la||bd| gm hbu gpc glndevb}d {d|ugcaibvr acf
vhtu ammg|fbc` dcv|aced vg vhd jdcvai {gpd| gm
vhd hdaid|# Gc hbu ubfd aiug vhd hdaid| fgdu vhd
uajd vhbc`) gcir pbvh vhbu fbmmd|dced) vhav phbid
vhd {avbdcv pbvhf|apu vhd la||bd| gc hbu ubfd pbvh
vhd bcvdcvbgc gm afjbvvbc` a migpbc`*bc) vhd hdaid|
fgdu ug pbvh vhd bcvdcvbgc gm aiigpbc` a migpbc`*
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 104/173
gtv> acf vhtu lr vhd ngbcv aevbgc gm vhd vpg jbcfu
vhd la||bd|u gm lgvh {d|ugcaibvbdu a|d |djg}df
acf vhd fb|devbgc gm vhd migp gm }gibvbgc bufdvd|jbcdf) vhav bu vg uar) bv migpu m|gj vhd
hdaid| au aevb}dir pbiibc` vg `b}d) vgpa|fu vhd
{avbdcv au {auub}dir pbiibc` vg |dedb}d) aeeg|fbc`
vg vhd tcb}d|uai iap gm Cavt|d vhav vhd migp jtuv
aiparu ld m|gj vhd {idctj vg vhd }aettj # Vhbujtvtai |djg}ai gm vhd dxvd|cai jdcvai la||bd|
ldvpddc hdaid| acf {avbdcv bu phav bu vd|jdf
duvalibuhbc` a |a{{g|v ldvpddc vhdj) acf hd|d
pd mbcf gcd jguv }aitalid {|aevbeai a{{ibeavbgc gm
vhd {|bceb{id iabf fgpc da|ibd| bc vhbu lggo) vhav
{t|d u{b|bv bu {|dudcv bc bvu dcvb|dvr av d}d|r {gbcv
ubjtivacdgtuir# Bv bu mg| vhbu |daugc vhav au uggc
au vhd hdaid| |daib~du vhav vhd la||bd|u gm dxvd|cai
{d|ugcaibvr ldvpddc hbjudim acf hbu {avbdcv ha}d
lddc |djg}df) hd eac vhdc u{dao vg vhd utl*
egcuebgtu jbcf gm vhd {avbdcv au vhgt`h bv pd|d
hbu gpc) mg| lgvh ldbc` {t|d u{b|bv vhd vhgt`hv gm
vhdb| bfdcvbvr jaodu vhdj bfdcvbeai) acf lgvh a|d
egcedcv|avdf bcvg a ubc`id dcvbvr av a ubc`id {gbcv
t{gc phbeh vhd egcuebgtu jbcf gm vhd hdaid| eac
ld l|gt`hv vg lda|) aeeg|fbc` vg vhd tcb}d|uai
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 105/173
{|bceb{id gm vhd egcv|gi gm vhd utlndevb}d jbcf lr
vhd glndevb}d jbcf vh|gt`h ut``duvbgc# Bv bu mg|
vhbu |daugc B ha}d bcubuvdf gc vhd fbuvbcevbgc ldvpddc {t|d u{b|bv) g| u{b|bv egcedb}df gm a{a|v
m|gj dxvdcubgc bc acr jav|bx acf vhd egced{vbgc
gm bv au ug dxvdcfdf# Bm pd egcedcv|avd gt| jbcf
t{gc vhd fbudaudf egcfbvbgc gm vhd {avbdcv pd a|d
vhbcobc` gm hbj au a ud{a|avd {d|ugcaibvr) acf a|dcgv mbxbc` gt| jbcf t{gc vhav egced{vbgc gm hbj
au {t|d u{b|bv phbeh pbii ammg|f tu dmmdevtai dcv|r
vg hbu u{|bc`u gm ldbc`# Pd jtuv vhd|dmg|d
pbvhf|ap gt| vhgt`hv m|gj vhd egcvdj{iavbgc gm
urj{vgju) acf bcfddf m|gj hbu eg|{g|dai
{d|ugcaibvr aivg`dvhd|) acf jtuv vhbco gm hbj au
a {t|dir u{b|bvtai bcfb}bftaibvr) acf au uteh
dcvb|dir m|dd m|gj utlndevbgc vg acr egcfbvbgcu)
acf egcudqtdcvir au }gitcva|bir dxvd|caib~bc` vhd
egcfbvbgcu jguv dx{|duub}d gm vhd }bvaibvr acf
bcvdiib`dced phbeh {t|d u{b|bv bu# Vhbcobc` gm hbj
vhtu) pd vhdc jaod jdcvai ammb|javbgc vhav hd
uhaii ltbif t{ gtvpa|fir vhd eg||du{gcfdced gm
vhav {d|mdev }bvaibvr phbeh hd ocgpu hbjudim vg ld
bcpa|fir? acf vhbu ut``duvbgc ldbc` bj{|duudf lr
vhd hdaid|'u egcuebgtu vhgt`hv) phbid vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 106/173
{avbdcv'u egcuebgtu vhgt`hv bu av vhd uajd vbjd
bj{|duubc` vhd maev vhav hd bu |dedb}bc` vhd aevb}d
vhgt`hv gm vhd hdaid|) vhd |dutiv bu vhav vhd{avbdcv'u utl*egcuebgtu jbcf ldegjdu
vhg|gt`hir bjltdf pbvh vhd |deg`cbvbgc gm bvu
gpc ibmd*`b}bc` {gpd|) acf aeeg|fbc` vg vhd
|deg`cb~df iap gm utlndevb}d jdcvaibvr {|geddfu
vg pg|o gtv vhbu ut``duvbgc bcvg dxvd|caijacbmduvavbgc) acf vhtu hdaivh bu utluvbvtvdf mg|
ubeocduu#
Bv jtuv ld tcfd|uvggf vhav vhd {t|{gud gm vhd
{|geduu hd|d fdue|bldf bu vg uv|dc`vhdc vhd
utlndev'u bcfb}bftaibvr) cgv vg fgjbcavd bv# Vg tudbv mg| fgjbcavbgc bu bc}d|ubgc ) l|bc`bc` bvu
a{{|g{|bavd {dcaivr vg vhd g{d|avg|#
Bc vhbu fdue|b{vbgc B ha}d egcvdj{iavdf vhd eaud
phd|d vhd {avbdcv bu egcuebgtuir eg*g{d|avbc`
pbvh vhd hdaid|) acf bv bu bc g|fd| vg glvabc vhbueg*g{d|avbgc vhav vhd jdcvai hdaid| tutaiir
jaodu a {gbcv gm bcuv|tevbc` vhd {avbdcv bc vhd
l|gaf {|bceb{idu gm Jdcvai Uebdced) bm hd bu cgv
ai|dafr aeqtabcvdf pbvh vhdj# Ltv vhbu bu cgv
aiparu af}bualid g| {guublid# Ugjdvbjdu vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 107/173
uvavdjdcv gm {|bceb{idu g{{gudf vg dxbuvbc`
{|dntfbedu a|gtudu g{{gubvbgc) acf acr aevb}d
acva`gcbuj gc vhd {avbdcv'u {a|v jtuv vdcf vgbcvdcubmr vhd la||bd| gm egcuebgtu {d|ugcaibvr
phbeh bv bu vhd hdaid|'u mb|uv glndev vg |djg}d# Bc
vhdud eaudu cgvhbc` bu ug dmmdevb}d au aludcv
v|davjdcv # Bm vhd uvtfdcv hau `|au{df aii vhav hau
lddc uabf gc vhd utlndev gm u{b|bv acf javvd|) hd pbii udd vhav bc jdcvai v|davjdcv vbjd acf u{aed
egtcv mg| cgvhbc`) ldeatud vhd phgid aevbgc vaodu
{iaed gc a {iacd phd|d vhdud egcfbvbgcu fg cgv
glvabc? acf bv bu vhd|dmg|d qtbvd bjjavd|bai
phdvhd| vhd {avbdcv ld bc vhd bjjdfbavd {|dudced
gm vhd hdaid| g| bc a fbuvacv egtcv|r# Tcfd| vhdud
eb|etjuvacedu bv bu mgtcf lr dx{d|bdced vhav gcd
gm vhd jguv dmmdevtai jgfdu gm jdcvai hdaibc` bu
lr v|davjdcv ft|bc` uidd{) ldeatud vhdc vhd
{avbdcv'u phgid uruvdj bu cavt|aiir bc a uvavd gm
|diaxavbgc phbeh {|d}dcvu hbj gmmd|bc` acr
egcuebgtu g{{gubvbgc vg vhd v|davjdcv# Acf lr
vhd uajd |tid vhd hdaid| aiug bu alid vg v|dav d}dc
jg|d dmmdevb}dir ft|bc` hbu gpc uidd{ vhac phbid
paobc`# Ldmg|d `gbc` vg uidd{ hd mb|jir bj{|duudu
gc hbu utlndevb}d jbcf vhav bv bu vg egc}dr
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 108/173
et|avb}d ut``duvbgc vg vhd utlndevb}d jbcf gm vhd
{avbdcv) acf vhdc) lr vhd `dcd|ai {|bceb{idu gm vhd
|diavbgc ldvpddc utlndevb}d acf glndevb}d jbcfvhbu ut``duvbgc bu ea||bdf gtv ft|bc` aii vhd hgt|u
vhav vhd egcuebgtu bcfb}bftaibvr bu p|a{{df bc
|d{gud# Vhbu jdvhgf bu a{{ibealid vg rgtc`
ehbif|dc vg phgj vhd {|bceb{idu gm vhd uebdced
eaccgv ld dx{iabcdf? acf aiug vg {d|ugcu av afbuvaced> acf bcfddf vhd gcir af}acva`d `abcdf
lr vhd {d|ugcai jddvbc` gm vhd {avbdcv acf hdaid|
bu bc vhd bcuv|tevbgc vhav eac ld g|aiir `b}dc) g|
phdc vhd {avbdcv bu av vhav da|ir uva`d gm
ocgpidf`d phd|d vhd hdaid|'u }bublid {|dudced
egc}dru vhd ut``duvbgc vhav ugjdvhbc` bu vhdc
ldbc` fgcd phbeh egtif cgv ld fgcd bc hbu
aludced? gvhd|pbud vhd {|dudced g| aludced gm vhd
{avbdcv a|d javvd|u {d|mdevir bcfbmmd|dcv# Vhd
uvtfdcv jtuv aiparu |degiidev vhav vhd utl*
egcuebgtu jbcf fgdu cgv ha}d vg pg|o vh|gt`h
vhd bcvdiidev g| egcuebgtu jbcf vg {|gfted bvu
et|avb}d dmmdevu# Bv bu {a|v gm vhd aii*{d|}afbc`
e|davb}d mg|ed gm Cavt|d) phbid vhd bcvdiidev bu cgv
e|davb}d ltv fbuv|bltvb}d#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 109/173
M|gj jdcvai hdaibc` bv bu ltv a uvd{ vg vdid{avhr)
eiab|}graced acf gvhd|) obcf|df jacbmduvavbgcu
gm v|acuedcfdcvai {gpd| phbeh) a|d m|gj vbjd vgvbjd dxhblbvdf lr vhd utlndevb}d dcvbvr acf phbeh
mgiigp iapu au aeet|avd au vhgud phbeh `g}d|c
phav pd a|d aeetuvgjdf vg egcubfd| gt| jg|d
cg|jai maetivbdu? ltv vhdud utlndevu fg cgv
{|g{d|ir maii pbvhbc vhd ueg{d gm a lggo phgud{t|{gud bu vg iar fgpc vhd l|gaf {|bceb{idu
phbeh tcfd|ibd aii u{b|bvtai {hdcgjdca# Tcvbi
vhdud a|d eida|ir tcfd|uvggf vhd uvtfdcv eaccgv
{|gmbvalir avvdj{v vhd fdvabidf uvtfr gm vhd jg|d
bcvd|bg| {gpd|u? mg| vg fg ug pbvhgtv a mb|j
mgtcfavbgc gm ocgpidf`d acf ugjd dx{d|bdced bc
bvu {|aevbeai a{{ibeavbgc pgtif gcir ld vg dx{gud
hbjudim vg tcocgpc fac`d|u) acf pgtif ld
egcv|a|r vg vhd uebdcvbmbe {|bceb{id vhav vhd
af}aced bcvg vhd tcocgpc eac gcir ld jafd
m|gj vhd uvacf{gbcv gm vhd ocgpc) gvhd|pbud pd
gcir egjd bcvg a egcmtudf |d`bgc gm `tduu*pg|o
pbvhgtv acr eida|ir fdmbcdf {|bceb{idu mg| gt|
`tbfaced#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 110/173
XBB#
VHD PBII#
Vhd Pbii bu gm uteh {|bja|r bj{g|vaced vhav vhd
uvtfdcv uhgtif ld gc hbu `ta|f a`abcuv acr
jbuvaod au vg vhd {gubvbgc phbeh bv hgifu bc vhdjdcvai degcgjr# Jacr p|bvd|u acf vdaehd|u
bcubuv gc pbii*{gpd| au vhgt`h vhav pd|d vhd
e|davb}d maetivr# Cg fgtlv bcvdcud pbii*{gpd| eac
d}gi}d ed|vabc dxvd|cai |dutivu) ltv ibod aii gvhd|
jdvhgfu gm egj{tiubgc bv iaeou vhd {d|jacdcer gm cavt|ai `|gpvh# Vhd a{{da|acedu) mg|ju) acf
egcfbvbgcu {|gftedf lr jd|d bcvdcubvr gm pbii*
{gpd| pbii gcir hac` vg`dvhd| ug igc` au vhd
egj{diibc` mg|ed egcvbctdu? ltv idv bv ld
dxhatuvdf g| pbvhf|apc) acf vhd didjdcvu vhtu
mg|edf bcvg tccavt|ai egjlbcavbgc pbii av gced mir
laeo vg vhdb| {|g{d| ammbcbvbdu? vhd mg|j e|davdf
lr egj{tiubgc cd}d| haf vhd `d|j gm }bvaibvr bc
bvudim acf bu vhd|dmg|d fbuub{avdf au uggc au vhd
dxvd|cai dcd|`r phbeh ut{{g|vdf bv bu pbvhf|apc#
Vhd jbuvaod bu bc avv|bltvbc` vhd e|davb}d {gpd|
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 111/173
vg vhd pbii) g| {d|ha{u B uhgtif uar bc avv|bltvbc`
vhd e|davb}d {gpd| vg gt|udi}du av aii# Vhd v|tvh bu
vhav jac cd}d| e|davdu acrvhbc`# Hbu mtcevbgc bu)cgv vg e|davd) ltv vg egjlbcd acf fbuv|bltvd vhav
phbeh bu ai|dafr bc ldbc`) acf phav pd eaii gt|
e|davbgcu a|d cdp egjlbcavbgcu gm ai|dafr
dxbuvbc` javd|bai) phdvhd| jdcvai g| eg|{g|dai#
Vhbu bu aj{ir fdjgcuv|avdf bc vhd {hrubeaiuebdcedu# Cg gcd u{daou gm e|davbc` dcd|`r) ltv
gcir gm v|acumg|jbc` gcd mg|j gm dcd|`r bcvg
acgvhd|? acf bm pd |daib~d vhbu au a tcb}d|uai
{|bceb{id) pd uhaii udd vhav gc vhd jdcvai {iacd
au pdii au gc vhd {hrubeai pd cd}d| e|davd dcd|`r
ltv gcir {|g}bfd vhd egcfbvbgcu lr phbeh vhd
dcd|`r ai|dafr dxbuvbc` bc gcd jgfd eac dxhblbv
bvudim bc acgvhd|> vhd|dmg|d phav) |diavb}dir vg
jac) pd eaii hbu e|davb}d {gpd|) bu vhav |ded{vb}d
avvbvtfd gm dx{devacer phbeh) ug vg uar) jaodu a
jgtif bcvg phbeh vhd {iauvbe acf au rdv
tcfbmmd|dcvbavdf utluvaced eac migp acf vaod vhd
fdub|df mg|j# Vhd pbii hau jteh vhd uajd {iaed
bc gt| jdcvai jaehbcd|r vhav vhd vggi*hgifd| hau
bc a {gpd|*iavhd> bv bu cgv vhd {gpd|) ltv bv odd{u
vhd jdcvai maetivbdu bc vhav {gubvbgc |diavb}dir vg
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 112/173
vhd {gpd| phbeh dcalidu bv vg fg vhd fdub|df
pg|o# Bm) tubc` vhd pg|f bc bvu pbfduv udcud) pd
jar uar vhav vhd bja`bcavbgc bu vhd e|davb}dmtcevbgc) pd jar eaii vhd pbii vhd edcv|aib~bc`
{|bceb{id# Bvu mtcevbgc bu vg odd{ vhd bja`bcavbgc
edcv|df bc vhd |b`hv fb|devbgc# Pd a|d abjbc` av
egcuebgtuir egcv|giibc` gt| jdcvai {gpd|u
bcuvdaf gm idvvbc` vhdj ht||r tu hbvhd| acfvhbvhd| bc a {t|{gudiduu jaccd|) acf pd jtuv
vhd|dmg|d tcfd|uvacf vhd |diavbgc gm vhdud {gpd|u
vg daeh gvhd| mg| vhd {|gftevbgc gm dxvd|cai
|dutivu# Mb|uv vhd phgid v|abc gm eatuavbgc bu
uva|vdf lr ugjd djgvbgc phbeh `b}du |bud vg a
fdub|d? cdxv vhd ntf`jdcv fdvd|jbcdu phdvhd| pd
uhaii dxvd|caib~d vhbu fdub|d g| cgv? vhdc vhd
fdub|d ha}bc` lddc a{{|g}df lr vhd ntf`jdcv)
vhd pbii egjdu mg|pa|f acf fb|devu vhd
bja`bcavbgc vg mg|j vhd cdeduua|r u{b|bvtai
{|gvgvr{d? acf vhd bja`bcavbgc vhtu edcv|df gc a
{a|vbetia| glndev e|davdu vhd u{b|bvtai cteidtu)
phbeh bc bvu vt|c aevu au a edcv|d |gtcf phbeh vhd
mg|edu gm avv|aevbgc ld`bc vg pg|o) acf egcvbctd
vg g{d|avd tcvbi) lr vhd iap gm `|gpvh) vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 113/173
egce|dvd |dutiv ldegjdu {d|ed{vblid vg gt|
dxvd|cai udcudu#
Vhd ltubcduu gm vhd pbii) vhdc) bu vg |dvabc vhd
}a|bgtu maetivbdu gm gt| jbcf bc vhav {gubvbgc
phd|d vhdr a|d |daiir fgbc` vhd pg|o pd pbuh)
acf vhbu {gubvbgc jar ld `dcd|aib~df bcvg vhd
vh|dd mgiigpbc` avvbvtfdu? dbvhd| pd pbuh vg aev
t{gc ugjdvhbc`) g| ld aevdf gc lr bv) g| vgjabcvabc a cdtv|ai {gubvbgc? bc gvhd| pg|fu pd
dbvhd| bcvdcf vg {|gndev a mg|ed) g| |dedb}d a mg|ed
g| odd{ a {gubvbgc gm bcaevb}bvr |diavb}dir vg ugjd
{a|vbetia| glndev# Cgp vhd ntf`jdcv fdvd|jbcdu
phbeh gm vhdud vh|dd {gubvbgcu pd uhaii vaod t{)vhd egcuebgtuir aevb}d) vhd egcuebgtuir |ded{vb}d)
g| vhd egcuebgtuir cdtv|ai? acf vhdc vhd mtcevbgc
gm vhd pbii bu ubj{ir vg jabcvabc vhd {gubvbgc pd
ha}d fdvd|jbcdf t{gc? acf bm pd jabcvabc acr
`b}dc jdcvai avvbvtfd pd jar |deogc pbvh aii
ed|vabcvr gc vhd iap gm avv|aevbgc f|apbc` tu vg
vhgud eg||du{gcfdcedu phbeh dxvd|bg|ir
urjlgib~d vhd avvbvtfd bc qtduvbgc# Vhbu bu }d|r
fbmmd|dcv m|gj vhd udjb*acbjai ue|dpbc`*t{ gm
vhd cd|}gtu mg|edu phbeh) pbvh ugjd {dg{id)
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 114/173
uvacfu mg| pbii*{gpd|# Bv bj{ibdu cg uv|abc gc vhd
cd|}gtu uruvdj acf bu egcudqtdcvir cgv mgiigpdf
lr acr udcud gm dxhatuvbgc# Vhd pbii*{gpd|) phdcv|acumd||df m|gj vhd |d`bgc gm vhd igpd|
jdcvaibvr vg vhd u{b|bvtai {iacd) ldegjdu ubj{ir
a eaij acf {daedmti fdvd|jbcavbgc vg |dvabc a
ed|vabc jdcvai avvbvtfd bc u{bvd gm aii vdj{vavbgcu
vg vhd egcv|a|r) ocgpbc` vhav lr fgbc` ug vhdfdub|df |dutiv pbii ed|vabcir a{{da|#
Vhd v|abcbc` gm vhd pbii acf bvu v|acumd|dced m|gj
vhd igpd| vg vhd hb`hd| {iacd gm gt| cavt|d a|d
ajgc` vhd mb|uv glndevu gm Jdcvai Uebdced# Vhd
jac bu utjjdf t{ bc hbu pbii# Phavd}d| hd fgdu lr hbu gpc pbii bu hbu gpc aev? phavd}d| hd fgdu
pbvhgtv vhd egcudcv gm hbu pbii bu cgv hbu gpc aev
ltv vhav gm vhd {gpd| lr phbeh hbu pbii pau
egd|edf? ltv pd jtuv |deg`cb~d vhav) gc vhd
jdcvai {iacd) cg gvhd| bcfb}bftaibvr eac glvabc
egcv|gi g}d| gt| pbii tciduu pd mb|uv aiigp bv vg fg
ug? acf bv bu mg| vhbu |daugc vhav aii id`bvbjavd tud
gm Jdcvai Uebdced bu vgpa|fu vhd uv|dc`vhdcbc` gm
vhd pbii) phdvhd| bc gt|udi}du g| gvhd|u) acf
l|bc`bc` bv tcfd| vhd egcv|gi gm ac dcib`hvdcdf
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 115/173
|daugc# Phdc vhd pbii |daib~du bvu {gpd| vg fdai
pbvh mb|uv eatud bv bu cg igc`d| cdeduua|r mg| vhd
g{d|avg| vg uvavd vg hbjudim bc dxvdcug aii vhd{hbigug{hr gm bvu aevbgc d}d|r vbjd hd pbuhdu vg
tud bv) ltv) ocgpbc` vhav vhd v|abcdf pbii bu a
v|djdcfgtu u{b|bvtai mg|ed aevbc` gc vhd {iacd gm
mb|uv eatud) hd ubj{ir dx{|duudu hbu fdub|d pbvh
vhd bcvdcvbgc gm g{d|avbc` gc vhav {iacd) acfocgpu vhav vhd fdub|d vhtu dx{|duudf pbii bc ftd
vbjd dxvd|caib~d bvudim au egce|dvd maev# Hd cgp
uddu vhav vhd {gbcv phbeh |daiir fdjacfu hbu
da|cduv avvdcvbgc bu cgv phdvhd| hd {guuduudu vhd
{gpd| gm dxvd|caib~bc` acr |dutivu hd ehggudu) ltv
gm ida|cbc` vg ehggud pbudir phav |dutivu vg
{|gfted# Mg| idv tu cgv ut{{gud vhav d}dc vhd
hb`hduv {gpd|u pbii vaod tu gtv gm vhd iap gm eatud
acf dmmdev# Pd eac cd}d| udv acr eatud bc jgvbgc
pbvhgtv eaiibc` mg|vh vhgud dmmdevu phbeh bv
ai|dafr egcvabcu bc djl|rg acf phbeh pbii a`abc
ldegjd eatudu bc vhdb| vt|c) vhtu {|gftebc` a
ud|bdu phbeh jtuv egcvbctd vg migp gc tcvbi bv bu
etv uhg|v lr l|bc`bc` bcvg g{d|avbgc a eatud gm ac
g{{gubvd eha|aevd| vg vhd gcd phbeh g|b`bcavdf bv#
Vhtu pd uhaii mbcf vhd mbdif mg| vhd dxd|ebud gm gt|
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 116/173
bcvdiib`dced egcvbctaiir dx{acfbc` pbvh vhd
dx{acubgc gm gt| {gpd|u? mg|) `|acvdf a `ggf
bcvdcvbgc) pd uhaii aiparu pbuh vg egcvdj{iavdvhd |dutivu gm gt| aevbgc au ma| au gt| bcvdiib`dced
pbii {d|jbv# Pd jar cgv ld alid vg udd }d|r ma|)
ltv vhd|d bu gcd uamd `dcd|ai {|bceb{id vg ld
`abcdf m|gj phav hau ai|dafr lddc uabf algtv
eatudu acf egcfbvbgcu) phbeh bu vhav vhd phgidudqtdced aiparu {a|vaodu gm vhd uajd eha|aevd|
au vhd bcbvbai eatud> bm vhav eha|aevd| bu cd`avb}d)
vhav bu) fduvbvtvd gm acr fdub|d vg dxvd|caib~d
obcfcduu) ehdd|mticduu) uv|dc`vh) ldatvr g| ugjd
gvhd| ug|v gm `ggf) vhbu cd`avb}d qtaibvr pbii jaod
bvudim mdiv aii fgpc vhd ibcd? ltv bm vhd g{{gubvd
ammb|javb}d eha|aevd| bu bc vhd g|b`bcai jgvb}d)
vhdc bv pbii |d{|gfted bvu obcf bc mg|ju gm ig}d)
ngr) uv|dc`vh acf ldatvr pbvh tcd||bc` {|debubgc#
Ldmg|d udvvbc` gtv) vhd|dmg|d) vg {|gfted cdp
egcfbvbgcu lr vhd dxd|ebud gm gt| vhgt`hv*{gpd|
pd uhgtif pdb`h ea|dmtiir phav mt|vhd| |dutivu
vhdr a|d ibodir vg idaf vg? acf hd|d) a`abc) pd
uhaii mbcf ac aj{id mbdif mg| vhd v|abcbc` gm gt|
pbii) bc ida|cbc` vg aeqtb|d vhav udim*egcv|gi phbeh
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 117/173
pbii dcalid tu vg {guv{gcd ac bcmd|bg| {|dudcv
uavbumaevbgc vg a `|davd| {|gu{devb}d `ggf#
Vhdud egcubfd|avbgcu cavt|aiir idaf tu vg vhd
utlndev gm egcedcv|avbgc# B ha}d ntuv cgp {gbcvdf
gtv vhav aii ftir egcv|giidf jdcvai aevbgc egcubuvu
bc hgifbc` vhd jbcf bc gcd gm vh|dd avvbvtfdu? ltv
vhd|d bu a mgt|vh jdcvai egcfbvbgc) phbeh bu vhav
gm idvvbc` gt| jdcvai mtcevbgcu |tc gc pbvhgtvgt| pbii fb|devbc` vhdj vg acr fdmbcbvd {t|{gud# Bv
bu gc vhbu pg|f {t|{gud vhav pd jtuv mbx gt|
phgid avvdcvbgc? acf bcuvdaf gm fbuub{avbc` gt|
dcd|`bdu) pd jtuv mgiigp ac bcvdiib`dcv jdvhgf gm
egcedcv|avbgc# Vhd) pg|f jdacu ldbc` `avhd|dft{ av a edcv|d) acf vhd edcv|d gm acrvhbc` bu vhav
{gbcv bc phbeh aii bvu mg|edu a|d dqtaiir laiacedf#
Vg egcedcv|avd vhd|dmg|d jdacu mb|uv vg l|bc` gt|
jbcfu bcvg a egcfbvbgc gm dqtbibl|btj phbeh pbii
dcalid tu vg egcuebgtuir fb|dev vhd migp gm u{b|bv
vg a fdmbcbvdir |deg`cb~df {t|{gud) acf vhdc
ea|dmtiir vg `ta|f gt| vhgt`hvu m|gj bcftebc` a
migp bc vhd g{{gubvd fb|devbgc# Pd jtuv aiparu
lda| bc jbcf vhav pd a|d fdaibc` pbvh a
pgcfd|mti {gvdcvbai dcd|`r phbeh bu cgv rdv
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 118/173
fbmmd|dcvbavdf bcvg acr {a|vbetia| jgfd) acf vhav
lr vhd aevbgc gm gt| jbcf pd eac fbmmd|dcvbavd bv
bcvg acr u{debmbe jgfd gm aevb}bvr vhav pd pbii?acf lr odd{bc` gt| vhgt`hv mbxdf gc vhd maev vhav
vhd bcmigp gm vhbu dcd|`r bu vaobc` {iaed acf vhav
lr gt| jdcvai avvbvtfd pd a|d fdvd|jbcbc` bvu
fb|devbgc) pd uhaii `|aftaiir |daib~d a
eg||du{gcfbc` dxvd|caib~avbgc# [|g{d|egcedcv|avbgc) vhd|dmg|d) fgdu cgv egcubuv gm
uv|dctgtu dmmg|v phbeh dxhatuvu vhd cd|}gtu
uruvdj acf fdmdavu bvu gpc glndev lr ut``duvbc`
vhd egcuebgtucduu gm ac af}d|ud mg|ed vg ld
mgt`hv a`abcuv) acf vhtu e|davbc` vhd af}d|ud
eb|etjuvacedu pd f|daf? ltv bc uhtvvbc` gtv aii
vhgt`hvu gm a obcf vhav pgtif fbu{d|ud vhd
u{b|bvtai cteidtu pd a|d mg|jbc` acf fpdiibc`
ehdd|mtiir gc vhd ocgpidf`d vhav) ldeatud vhd iap
bu ed|vabc bc bvu aevbgc) gt| fdub|d bu ed|vabc gm
aeegj{ibuhjdcv# Vhd gvhd| `|dav {|bceb{id vg ld
|djdjld|df bu vhav egcedcv|avbgc bu mg| vhd
{t|{gud gm fdvd|jbcbc` vhd qtaibvr pd a|d `gbc`
vg `b}d vg vhd {|d}bgtuir tcfbmmd|dcvbavdf dcd|`r
|avhd| vhac vg a||ac`d vhd u{debmbe eb|etjuvacedu
gm bvu jacbmduvavbgc# Vhav bu vhd pg|o gm vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 119/173
e|davb}d dcd|`r bvudim) phbeh pbii ltbif t{ bvu gpc
mg|ju gm dx{|duubgc qtbvd cavt|aiir bm pd aiigp bv)
vhtu ua}bc` tu a `|dav fdai gm cddfiduu acxbdvr# Phav pd |daiir pacv bu dx{acubgc bc a ed|vabc
fb|devbgc) phdvhd| gm hdaivh) pdaivh) g| phav cgv>
acf ug igc` au pd `dv vhbu) phav fgdu bv javvd|
phdvhd| bv |daehdu tu vh|gt`h ugjd ehaccdi
phbeh pd vhgt`hv pd egtif |deogc t{gc g|vh|gt`h ugjd gvhd| phgud dxbuvdced pd haf cgv
utu{devdf# Bv bu vhd maev vhav pd a|d egcedcv|avbc`
dcd|`r gm a {a|vbetia| obcf mg| a {a|vbetia|
{t|{gud vhav pd uhgtif mbx gt| jbcfu t{gc) acf
cgv iggo t{gc acr u{debmbe fdvabiu au duudcvbai vg
vhd aeegj{ibuhjdcv gm gt| glndev#
Vhdud a|d vhd vpg `gifdc |tidu |d`a|fbc`
egcedcv|avbgc? ltv pd jtuv cgv ut{{gud vhav
ldeatud pd ha}d vg ld gc gt| `ta|f a`abcuv bfid
f|bmvbc` vhd|d bu vg ld cg uteh vhbc` au |d{gud? gc
vhd egcv|a|r bv bu ft|bc` {d|bgfu gm |d{gud vhav pd
aeetjtiavd uv|dc`vh mg| aevbgc? ltv |d{gud fgdu
cgv jdac a uvavd gm {t|{gudiduucduu# Au {t|d
u{b|bv vhd utlndevb}d jbcf cd}d| |duvu> bv bu gcir
vhd glndevb}d jbcf bc bvu egccdevbgc pbvh vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 120/173
{hrubeai lgfr vhav cddfu |duv? acf vhgt`h vhd|d
a|d cg fgtlv vbjdu phdc vhd `|davduv {guublid
|duv bu vg ld glvabcdf lr uvg{{bc` vhd aevbgc) gm gt| egcuebgtu vhgt`hv aivg`dvhd|) vhd jg|d
`dcd|aiir af}bualid jdvhgf bu lr ehac`bc` vhd
fb|devbgc gm vhd vhgt`hv acf) bcuvdaf gm edcvd|bc`
bv t{gc ugjdvhbc` pd bcvdcf vg fg ) idvvbc` bv
fpdii qtbdvir t{gc phav pd a|d # Vhbu fb|devbgc gm vhgt`hv jb`hv) gm egt|ud) fd}dig{ bcvg vhd
fdd{duv {hbigug{hbeai u{detiavbgc) ltv bv bu cgv
cdeduua|r vhav pd uhgtif ld aiparu dbvhd|
egcuebgtuir {|gndevbc` gt| mg|edu vg {|gfted
ugjd dxvd|cai dmmdev g| pg|obc` gtv vhd fdvabiu gm
ugjd jdva{hrubeai {|glidj? ltv pd jar ubj{ir
|daib~d gt|udi}du au {a|v gm vhd tcb}d|uai
ib}bc`cduu acf vhtu `abc a qtbdv edcv|aib~avbgc)
phbeh) vhgt`h jabcvabcdf lr a egcuebgtu aev gm
vhd }gibvbgc) bu vhd }d|r duudced gm |duv# M|gj vhbu
uvacf{gbcv pd udd vhav aii bu Ibmd acf aii bu @ggf)
acf vhav Cavt|d) m|gj hd| eida|ir }bublid ut|maed
vg hd| jguv a|eacd fd{vhu) bu gcd }auv uvg|dhgtud
gm ibmd acf `ggf dcvb|dir fd}gvdf vg gt| bcfb}bftai
tud# Pd ha}d vhd odr vg aii hd| v|daut|du) acf pd
eac cgp a{{ir gt| ocgpidf`d gm vhd iap gm ldbc`
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 121/173
pbvhgtv dcvd|bc` bcvg aii vhgud fdvabiu phbeh a|d
gcir cddfdf mg| {t|{gudu gm uvtfr) acf fgbc` ug
pd mbcf bv |dutivu bc gt| ha}bc` aeqtb|df vhdegcuebgtucduu gm gt| gcdcduu pbvh vhd phgid #
Vhbu bu vhd `|dav ude|dv> acf phdc pd ha}d gced
mavhgjdf bv pd eac dcngr gt| {guuduubgc gm vhd
phgid) g| gm acr {a|v gm bv) ldeatud lr gt|
|deg`cbvbgc pd ha}d jafd bv) acf eacbce|daubc`ir jaod bv) gt| gpc# Phavd}d| jguv
a{{daiu vg tu av acr {a|vbetia| vbjd g| {iaed bu
vhav jgfd gm vhd tcb}d|uai ib}bc` u{b|bv pbvh
phbeh av vhav jgjdcv pd a|d jguv bc vgteh) acf
|daib~bc` vhbu) pd uhaii f|ap m|gj bv uv|daju gm
}bvai dcd|`r phbeh pbii jaod vhd }d|r udcuavbgc gm
ib}bc`cduu a ngr acf pbii |afbavd m|gj tu au a
u{hd|d gm }bl|avbgc vhav eac fdmidev aii bcnt|bgtu
ut``duvbgc gc phavd}d| {iacd# Pd jar cgv ha}d
ibvd|a|r) a|vbuvbe) g| uebdcvbmbe uobii vg {|dudcv vg
gvhd|u vhd |dutivu gm gt| egjjtcbc`u pbvh
Cavt|d) ltv vhd ngr gm vhbu urj{avhdvbe bcf|apbc`
pbii cd}d|vhdiduu {|gfted a eg||du{gcfbc`
gtvmigp jacbmduvbc` bvudim bc vhd ha{{bd| iggo acf
obcfibd| jbdc gm hbj phg vhtu |daib~du hbu
gcdcduu pbvh d}d|r au{dev gm vhd phgid# Hd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 122/173
|daib~du**acf vhbu bu vhd `|dav {gbcv bc vhav
avvbvtfd gm jbcf phbeh bu cgv fb|devdf vg acr
u{debmbe dxvd|cai glndev**vhav) mg| hbjudim) hd bu)acf aiparu jtuv ld vhd edcv|d gm aii vhbu `aiaxr gm
Ibmd) acf vhtu hd egcvdj{iavdu hbjudim au udavdf
av vhd edcv|d gm bcmbcbvtfd) cgv ac bcmbcbvtfd gm
liaco u{aed) ltv {tiuavbc` pbvh ib}bc` ldbc`) bc aii
gm phbeh hd ocgpu vhav vhd v|td duudced bucgvhbc` ltv `ggf# Vhbu bu vhd }d|r g{{gubvd vg a
udimbuh udim*edcv|dfcduu? bv) bu vhd edcv|d phd|d pd
mbcf vhav pd lgvh |dedb}d m|gj aii acf migp gtv vg
aii# A{a|v m|gj vhbu {|bceb{id gm eb|etiavbgc vhd|d
bu cg v|td ibmd) acf bm pd egcvdj{iavd gt| edcv|ai
{gubvbgc gcir au ammg|fbc` tu `|davd| af}acva`du
mg| bc*vaobc`) pd ha}d jbuudf vhd phgid {gbcv gm
gt| uvtfbdu lr jbuubc` vhd |dai cavt|d gm vhd Ibmd*
{|bceb{id) phbeh bu aevbgc acf |d*aevbgc# Bm pd
pgtif ha}d ibmd dcvd| bcvg tu) pd gt|udi}du jtuv
dcvd| bcvg ibmd**dcvd| bcvg vhd u{b|bv gm bv) ntuv au
pd jtuv dcvd| bcvg vhd u{b|bv gm a lggo g| a `ajd
vg dcngr bv# Vhd|d eac ld cg aevbgc av a edcv|d
gcir# Vhd|d jtuv ld a {d|{dvtai migpbc` gtv
vgpa|fu vhd eb|etjmd|dced) acf vhdced laeo
a`abc vg vhd edcv|d vg jabcvabc a }bvai aevb}bvr?
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 123/173
gvhd|pbud egiia{ud jtuv dcutd dbvhd| m|gj
acadjba g| egc`duvbgc# Ltv bm pd |daib~d vhd
|deb{|geai cavt|d gm vhd }bvai {tiuavbgc) acf vhavvhd gtvmigpbc` egcubuvu bc vhd halbv gm jbcf
phbeh `b}du bvudim vg vhd `ggf bv uddu bc gvhd|u)
|avhd| vhac bc acr u{debmbe aevbgcu) vhdc pd uhaii
mbcf vhav vhd etivb}avbgc gm vhbu fbu{gubvbgc pbii
{|g}bfd bcctjd|alid a}dctdu mg| vhd tcb}d|uaiib}bc`cduu vg migp vh|gt`h tu) phdvhd| au `b}bc`
g| |dedb}bc`) phbeh pd haf cd}d| ldmg|d
utu{devdf> acf vhbu aevbgc acf |d*aevbgc pbii ug
ltbif t{ gt| gpc }bvaibvr vhav daeh far pbii mbcf
tu jg|d vhg|gt`hir aib}d vhac acr vhav haf
{|dedfdf bv# Vhbu) vhdc) bu vhd avvbvtfd gm |d{gud bc
phbeh pd jar dcngr aii vhd ldatvbdu gm uebdced)
ibvd|avt|d acf a|v g| jar {daedmtiir egjjtcd
pbvh vhd u{b|bv gm cavt|d pbvhgtv vhd abf gm acr
vhb|f jbcf vg aev au bvu bcvd|{|dvd|) phbeh bu uvbii a
{t|{gudmti avvbvtfd aivhgt`h cgv fb|devdf vg a
u{debmbe glndev> pd ha}d cgv aiigpdf vhd pbii vg
|diax bvu egcv|gi) ltv ha}d jd|dir aivd|df bvu
fb|devbgc? ug vhav mg| aevbgc acf |d{gud aibod pd
mbcf vhav gt| uv|dc`vh ibdu bc gt| |deg`cbvbgc gm
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 124/173
vhd tcbvr gm vhd u{b|bv acf gm gt|udi}du au
bcfb}bftai egcedcv|avbgcu gm bv#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 125/173
XBBB#
BC VGTEH PBVH UTL*
EGCUEBGTU JBCF#
Vhd {|dedfbc` {a`du ha}d jafd vhd uvtfdcv bc
ugjd jdaut|d apa|d gm vhd bjjdcud bj{g|vacedgm gt| fdaibc`u pbvh vhd utl*egcuebgtu jbcf# Gt|
|diavbgc vg bv) phdvhd| gc vhd ueaid gm vhd
bcfb}bftai g| vhd tcb}d|uai) bu vhd odr vg aii vhav
pd a|d g| d}d| eac ld# Bc bvu tc|deg`cb~df
pg|obc` bv bu vhd u{|bc` gm aii vhav pd eac eaii vhdatvgjavbe aevbgc gm jbcf acf lgfr) acf gc vhd
tcb}d|uai ueaid bv bu vhd ubidcv {gpd| gm d}gitvbgc
`|aftaiir pg|obc` gcpa|fu vg vhav ,fb}bcd d}dcv)
vg phbeh vhd phgid e|davbgc jg}du,? acf lr gt|
egcuebgtu |deg`cbvbgc gm bv pd jaod bv) |diavb}dir
vg gt|udi}du) aii vhav pd ldibd}d bv vg ld# Vhd
eigud| gt| |a{{g|v pbvh bv ldegjdu) vhd jg|d
phav pd ha}d hbvhd|vg egcubfd|df atvgjavbe
aevbgc) phdvhd| bc gt| lgfbdu g| gt|
eb|etjuvacedu) pbii {auu tcfd| gt| egcv|gi) tcvbi
av iauv pd uhaii egcv|gi gt| phgid bcfb}bftai
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 126/173
pg|if# Ubced) vhdc) vhbu bu vhd uvt{dcfgtu buutd
bc}gi}df) vhd qtduvbgc hgp pd a|d vg {tv
gt|udi}du {|aevbeaiir bc vgteh pbvh vhd utl*egcuebgtu jbcf bu a }d|r bj{g|vacv gcd# Cgp vhd
eitd phbeh `b}du tu vhd |b`hv fb|devbgc bu vg ld
mgtcf bc vhd bj{d|ugcai qtaibvr gm utl*egcuebgtu
jbcf gm phbeh B ha}d u{godc# Cgv bj{d|ugcai au
iaeobc` vhd didjdcvu gm {d|ugcaibvr? cg| d}dc) bcvhd eaud gm bcfb}bftai utlndevb}d jbcf) au iaeobc`
vhd udcud gm bcfb}bftaibvr? ltv bj{d|ugcai bc vhd
udcud gm cgv |deg`cb~bc` vhd {a|vbetia| dxvd|cai
|diavbgcu phbeh a{{da| vg vhd glndevb}d jbcf vg
egcuvbvtvd bvu {d|ugcaibvr) acf ha}bc` a
|daib~avbgc gm bvudim qtbvd bcfd{dcfdcv gm vhdj# Bm)
vhdc) pd pgtif egjd bc vgteh pbvh bv pd jtuv
jddv bv gc bvu gpc `|gtcf# Bv eac udd vhbc`u gcir
m|gj vhd fdftevb}d uvacf{gbcv) acf vhd|dmg|d
eaccgv vaod cgvd gm vhd bcftevb}d uvacf{gbcv m|gj
phbeh pd egcuv|tev vhd bfda gm gt| dxvd|cai
{d|ugcaibvr? acf aeeg|fbc`ir bm pd pgtif {tv
gt|udi}du bc vgteh pbvh bv) pd eaccgv fg ug lr
l|bc`bc` bv fgpc vg vhd id}di gm vhd dxvd|cai acf
cgc*duudcvbai ltv gcir lr |bubc` vg bvu gpc id}di
gc vhd {iacd gm vhd bcvd|bg| acf duudcvbai# Hgp
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 127/173
eac vhbu ld fgcd7 Idv vpg pdii*ocgpc p|bvd|u
acupd|# \tfra|f Ob{ibc` vdiiu tu bc hbu uvg|r gm
,Obj, hgp vhd lgr tudf av vbjdu vg igud hbu udcudgm {d|ugcaibvr lr |d{davbc` vg hbjudim vhd
qtduvbgc) Phg bu Obj7 @|aftaiir hbu {d|ugcaibvr
pgtif uddj vg mafd acf hd pgtif dx{d|bdced a
mddibc` gm {auubc` bcvg a `|acfd| acf a pbfd| ibmd)
bc phbeh vhd lgr Obj pau tcocgpc) phbid hbugpc egcuebgtu bcfb}bftaibvr |djabcdf) gcir
dxaivdf acf dx{acfdf vg ac bcegcedb}alid dxvdcv?
acf bc Vdccrugc'u ibmd lr hbu ugc pd a|d vgif vhav
av vbjdu vhd {gdv haf a ubjbia| dx{d|bdced# Pd
egjd bcvg vgteh pbvh vhd alugitvd dxaevir bc
{|g{g|vbgc au pd pbvhf|ap gt|udi}du m|gj vhd
|diavb}d> vhdr }a|r bc}d|udir vg daeh gvhd|#
Mg| vhd {t|{gud) vhdc) gm `dvvbc` bcvg vgteh pbvh
gt| utl*egcuebgtu jbcf pd jtuv dcfda}gt| vg
vhbco gm gt|udi}du au {t|d ldbc`) au vhav dcvbvr
phbeh bcvd|bg|ir ut{{g|vu vhd gtvpa|f
jacbmduvavbgc) acf fgbc` ug pd uhaii |daib~d vhav
vhd duudcvbai qtaibvr gm {t|d ldbc` jtuv ld `ggf#
Bv bu bc bvudim {t|d Ibmd ) acf au uteh eaccgv fdub|d
acrvhbc` fdv|bjdcvai vg {t|d Ibmd tcfd| phavd}d|
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 128/173
mg|j jacbmduvdf# Egcudqtdcvir vhd {t|d| gt|
bcvdcvbgcu vhd jg|d |dafbir pd uhaii {iaed gt|udim
dc |a{{g|v pbvh gt| utlndevb}d dcvbvr? acf a mg|vbg|b vhd uajd a{{ibdu vg vhav @|davd| Utl*
egcuebgtu Jbcf gm phbeh gt| bcfb}bftai
utlndevb}d jbcf bu a {a|vbetia| jacbmduvavbgc# Bc
aevtai {|aevbed vhd {|geduu egcubuvu bc mb|uv
mg|jbc` a eida| egced{vbgc bc vhd glndevb}d jbcfgm vhd bfda pd pbuh vg egc}dr vg vhd utlndevb}d
jbcf> vhdc) phdc vhbu hau lddc mb|jir `|au{df)
dcfda}gt| vg igud ub`hv gm aii gvhd| maevu
egccdevdf pbvh vhd dxvd|cai {d|ugcaibvr dxed{v
vhd gcd bc qtduvbgc) acf vhdc jdcvaiir aff|duu
vhd utlndevb}d jbcf au vhgt`h bv pd|d ac
bcfd{dcfdcv dcvbvr acf bj{|duu t{gc bv phav rgt
pacv bv vg fg g| vg ldibd}d# D}d|rgcd jtuv
mg|jtiavd hbu gpc par gm pg|obc`) ltv gcd
jdvhgf) phbeh bu lgvh ubj{id acf dmmdevb}d bu vg
uar vg vhd utlndevb}d jbcf) ,Vhbu bu phav B pacv
rgt vg fg? rgt pbii cgp uvd{ bcvg jr {iaed acf fg
bv) l|bc`bc` aii rgt| {gpd|u acf bcvdiib`dced vg
lda|) acf egcubfd|bc` rgt|udim vg ld cgcd gvhd|
vhac jrudim#, Ha}bc` fgcd vhbu |dvt|c vg vhd
|daib~avbgc gm rgt| gpc glndevb}d {d|ugcaibvr acf
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 129/173
ida}d vhd utlndevb}d jbcf vg {d|mg|j bvu vauo bc
mtii egcmbfdced vhav) lr vhd iap gm bvu cavt|d) bv
pbii fg ug bm cgv hbcfd|df lr a |d{dvbvbgc gm egcv|a|r jduua`du m|gj vhd glndevb}d jbcf# Vhbu
bu cgv a jd|d macer ltv a v|tvh fabir {|g}df lr
vhd dx{d|bdced gm bce|daubc` ctjld|u# Vhd maevu
ha}d cgv lddc mal|beavdf vg mbv vhd vhdg|r) ltv vhd
vhdg|r hau lddc ltbiv t{ lr ea|dmti glud|}avbgc gm vhd maevu? acf ubced bv hau lddc uhgpc lgvh lr
vhdg|r acf {|aevbed vhav uteh bu vhd iap gm vhd
|diavbgc ldvpddc utlndevb}d acf glndevb}d jbcf)
pd mbcf gt|udi}du maed vg maed pbvh a }d|r
jgjdcvgtu qtduvbgc# Bu vhd|d acr |daugc phr
vhd iapu phbeh hgif `ggf gm vhd bcfb}bftai
utlndevb}d jbcf uhgtif cgv hgif `ggf gm vhd
Tcb}d|uai Jbcf aiug7 acf vhd acupd| bu vhav vhd|d
bu cgv# Au hau lddc ai|dafr uhgpc vhd Tcb}d|uai
Jbcf jtuv) lr bvu }d|r tcb}d|uaibvr) ld {t|dir
utlndevb}d) acf phav bu vhd iap gm a {a|v jtuv aiug
ld vhd iap gm vhd phgid> vhd qtaibvbdu gm mb|d a|d
vhd uajd phdvhd| vhd edcv|du gm egjltuvbgc ld
`|dav g| ujaii) acf vhd|dmg|d pd jar pdii
egceitfd vhdud idevt|du lr egcubfd|bc` phav pbii
ld vhd |dutiv bm pd a{{ir phav pd ha}d ida|cv
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 130/173
|d`a|fbc` vhd bcfb}bftai utlndevb}d jbcf vg vhd
Tcb}d|uai Jbcf#
Pd ha}d ida|cv vhav vhd vh|dd `|dav maevu
|d`a|fbc` utlndevb}d jbcf a|d bvu e|davb}d {gpd|)
bvu ajdcalidcduu vg ut``duvbgc) acf bvu bcalbibvr
vg pg|o lr acr gvhd| vhac vhd fdftevb}d jdvhgf#
Vhbu iauv bu ac dxeddfbc`ir bj{g|vacv {gbcv) mg| bv
bj{ibdu vhav vhd aevbgc gm vhd utlndevb}d jbcf bubc cg par ibjbvdf lr {|dedfdcv# Vhd bcftevb}d
jdvhgf pg|ou gc {|bceb{idu bcmd||df m|gj ac
ai|dafr dxbuvbc` {avvd|c) acf vhd|dmg|d av vhd lduv
gcir {|gftedu vhd gif vhbc` bc a cdp uha{d# Ltv
vhd fdftevb}d jdvhgf pg|ou aeeg|fbc` vg vhdduudced g| u{b|bv gm vhd {|bceb{id) acf fgdu cgv
fd{dcf gc acr {|d}bgtu egce|dvd jacbmduvavbgc
mg| bvu a{{|dhdcubgc gm bv? acf vhbu iavvd| jdvhgf
gm pg|obc` jtuv cdeduua|bir ld vhav gm vhd aii*
g|b`bcavbc` Jbcf) mg| ubced vhd|d egtif ld cg
{|bg| dxbuvbc` {avvd|c m|gj phbeh bv egtif ida|c
vhd {|bceb{idu gm egcuv|tevbgc) vhd pacv gm a
{avvd|c pgtif ha}d {|d}dcvdf bvu e|davbc`
acrvhbc` haf bvu jdvhgf lddc bcftevb}d bcuvdaf
gm fdftevb}d# Vhtu lr vhd cdeduubvr gm vhd eaud vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 131/173
Tcb}d|uai Jbcf jtuv aev fdftevb}dir) vhav bu)
aeeg|fbc` vg vhd iap phbeh hau lddc mgtcf v|td
gm bcfb}bftai utlndevb}d jbcf# Bv bu vhtu cgv lgtcf lr acr {|dedfdcv) phbeh jdacu vhav bvu
e|davb}d {gpd| bu alugitvdir tcibjbvdf? acf ubced
bv bu duudcvbaiir utlndevb}d jbcf) acf cgv glndevb}d
jbcf) bv bu dcvb|dir ajdcalid vg ut``duvbgc# Cgp
bv bu ac tca}gbfalid bcmd|dced m|gj vhd bfdcvbvr gm vhd iap `g}d|cbc` utlndevb}d jbcf) phdvhd| bc
vhd bcfb}bftai g| vhd tcb}d|uai) vhav ntuv au pd
eac lr ut``duvbgc bj{|duu a ed|vabc eha|aevd| gm
{d|ugcaibvr t{gc vhd bcfb}bftai utlndevb}d jbcf)
ug pd eac) acf fg) t{gc vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf? acf
bv bu mg| vhbu |daugc vhav B ha}d f|apc avvdcvbgc vg
vhd bchd|dcv {d|ugcai qtaibvr gm {t|d u{b|bv phdc
egcvdj{iavdf bc bvu jguv bcvd|bg| {iacd# Bv
ldegjdu) vhd|dmg|d) vhd jguv bj{g|vacv gm aii
egcubfd|avbgcu pbvh phav eha|aevd| pd bc}duv vhd
Tcb}d|uai Jbcf? mg| ubced gt| |diavbgc vg bv bu
{t|dir utlndevb}d bv pbii bcmaiiblir lda| vg tu
dxaevir vhav eha|aevd| phbeh pd bj{|duu t{gc bv?
bc gvhd| pg|fu bv pbii ld vg tu dxaevir phav pd
ldibd}d bv vg ld# Vhbu bu ubj{ir a ig`beai bcmd|dced
m|gj vhd maev vhav) au utlndevb}d jbcf) gt|
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 132/173
{|bja|r |diavbgc vg bv eac gcir ld gc vhd
utlndevb}d {iacd) acf bcfb|devir gt| glndevb}d
|diavbgcu jtuv aiug u{|bc` m|gj vhd uajd ugt|ed#Vhbu bu vhd jdacbc` gm vhav |dja|oalid {auua`d
vpbed |d{davdf bc vhd Lblid) ,Pbvh) vhd {t|d vhgt
pbiv uhgp vhrudim {t|d) acf pbvh vhd m|gpa|f vhgt
pbiv uhgp vhrudim m|gpa|f#, ([u# x}bbb#) <=) acf BB#
Uaj# xxbb#) <0") mg| vhd egcvdxv jaodu bv eida| vhavvhdud pg|fu a|d aff|duudf vg vhd Fb}bcd Ldbc`#
Vhd u{b|bvtai obc`fgj bu pbvhbc tu) acf au pd
|daib~d bv vhd|d ug bv ldegjdu vg tu a |daibvr# Bv bu
vhd tc}a|rbc` iap gm vhd utlndevb}d ibmd vhav ,au a
jac vhbcodvh bc hbu hda|v ug bu hd), vhav bu vg uar)
hbu bcpa|f utlndevb}d uvavdu a|d vhd gcir v|td
|daibvr) acf phav pd eaii dxvd|cai |daibvbdu a|d
gcir vhdb| glndevb}d eg||du{gcfdcedu# Bm pd
vhg|gt`hir |daib~d vhd v|tvh vhav vhd Tcb}d|uai
Jbcf jtuv ld vg tu dxaevir aeeg|fbc` vg gt|
egced{vbgc gm bv) acf vhav vhbu |diavbgc bu cgv
jd|dir bja`bca|r ltv lr vhd iap gm utlndevb}d
jbcf jtuv ld vg tu ac aevtai maev acf vhd
mgtcfavbgc gm aii gvhd| maevu) vhdc bv bu bj{guublid
vg g}d|*duvbjavd vhd bj{g|vaced gm vhd
egced{vbgc gm vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf phbeh pd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 133/173
afg{v# Vg vhd tcbcuv|tevdf vhd|d bu ibvvid g| cg
ehgbed> vhdr mg|j a egced{vbgc bc aeeg|faced
pbvh vhd v|afbvbgc vhdr ha}d |dedb}df m|gj gvhd|u)acf tcvbi vhdr ha}d ida|cv vg vhbco mg|
vhdjudi}du) vhdr ha}d vg albfd lr vhd |dutivu gm
vhav v|afbvbgc> mg| cavt|ai iapu afjbv gm cg
dxed{vbgcu) acf hgpd}d| mativr vhd v|afbvbgcai
bfda jar ld) bvu aeed{vaced pbii bc}gi}d aeg||du{gcfbc` |daevbgc t{gc vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf)
phbeh pbii bc vt|c ld |dmidevdf bcvg vhd egcuebgtu
jbcf acf dxvd|cai ibmd gm vhd bcfb}bftai# Ltv
vhgud phg tcfd|uvacf vhd iap gm vhd utlndev pbii
ha}d cg gcd ltv vhdjudi}du vg liajd bm vhdr fg
cgv fd|b}d aii {guublid ldcdmbvu m|gj bv# Vhd
`|davduv Vdaehd| gm Jdcvai Uebdced vhd pg|if hau
d}d| uddc hau iabf fgpc utmmbebdcvir {iabc |tidu
mg| gt| `tbfaced# Pbvh a ocgpidf`d gm vhd utlndev
phgud fd{vh eac ld a{{|debavdf gcir lr vhgud
phg ha}d vhdjudi}du ugjd {|aevbeai
aeqtabcvaced pbvh bv) Hd lbfu Hbu tcida|cdf
atfbdcedu) vhgud egjjgc {dg{id phg hda|f Hbj
`iafir) {bevt|d vg vhdjudi}du vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf
au a ldcb`c Mavhd|) vdcfd|ir egj{auubgcavd gm aii
acf udcfbc` vhd egjjgc lgtcvbdu gm Cavt|d
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 134/173
aibod gc vhd d}bi acf vhd `ggf? ltv Hd aiug
{bevt|df Bv au dxd|ebubc` a u{debai acf {detiba|
ea|d g}d| vhgud phg |deg`cb~d Bvu pbiibc`cduu vgfg ug>―,vhd }d|r hab|u gm rgt| hdaf a|d aii
ctjld|df), acf ,rd a|d gm jg|d }aitd vhac jacr
u{a||gpu#, [|ard| pau vg ld jafd vg vhd tcuddc
Ldbc`) cgv pbvh fgtlv g| mda|) ltv pbvh vhd
alugitvd auut|aced gm a ed|vabc acupd|) acf cgibjbv pau vg ld udv vg bvu {gpd| g| pbiibc`cduu vg
pg|o mg| tu# Ltv vg vhgud phg fbf cgv vhtu |daib~d
bv) vhd @|dav Jbcf bu cdeduua|bir vhd af}d|ua|r
phg eauvu vhdj bcvg {|bugc tcvbi vhdr ha}d {abf
vhd tvvd|jguv ma|vhbc`? acf vhtu bc aii eaudu vhd
Jauvd| bj{|duudf t{gc hbu hda|d|u vhd dxaev
eg||du{gcfdced gm vhd avvbvtfd gm vhbu tcuddc
[gpd| vgpa|fu vhdj pbvh vhdb| gpc avvbvtfd
vgpa|fu bv # Uteh vdaehbc` pau cgv a ca||gp
acvh|g{gjg|{hbuj ltv vhd afa{vavbgc vg vhd
bcvdiidevtai ea{aebvr gm vhd tcidvvd|df jtivbvtfd
gm vhd }d|r fdd{duv v|tvhu gm phav pd cgp eaii
Jdcvai Uebdced# Acf vhd laubu gm bv aii bu vhd
e|r{vbe {d|ugcaibvr gm u{b|bv hbffdc vh|gt`hgtv
vhd bcmbcbvd gm Cavt|d tcfd| d}d|r mg|j gm
jacbmduvavbgc# Au tcaiigrdf Ibmd acf Bcvdiib`dced
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 135/173
bv eac ld cg gvhd| vhac `ggf) bv eac dcvd|vabc cg
bcvdcvbgc gm d}bi) acf vhtu aii bcvdcvbgcai d}bi
jtuv {tv tu bc g{{gubvbgc vg bv) acf ug fd{|b}d tugm vhd egcuebgtucduu gm bvu `tbfaced acf
uv|dc`vhdcbc` acf vhtu ida}d tu vg `|g{d gt| gpc
par acf mb`hv gt| gpc lavvid ubc`id*hacfdf
a`abcuv vhd tcb}d|ud) gffu phbeh av iauv pbii
ut|dir {|g}d vgg `|dav mg| tu# Ltv |djdjld| vhavvhd g{{gubvbgc eac cd}d| ld gc vhd {a|v gm vhd
Tcb}d|uai Jbcf) mg| bc bvudim bv bu utl*egcuebgtu
jbcf? acf vg ut{{gud acr aevb}d g{{gubvbgc vaodc
gc bvu gpc bcbvbavb}d pgtif ld egcv|a|r vg aii pd
ha}d ida|cv au vg vhd cavt|d gm utl*egcuebgtu
jbcf phdvhd| bc vhd bcfb}bftai g| vhd tcb}d|uai?
vhd {gubvbgc gm vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf vgpa|fu tu bu
aiparu vhd |dmidevbgc gm gt| gpc avvbvtfd#
Vhd|dmg|d aivhgt`h vhd Lblid bu mtii gm vh|davdcbc`
a`abcuv vhgud phg {d|ubuv bc egcuebgtu g{{gubvbgc
vg vhd Fb}bcd Iap gm @ggf) bv bu gc vhd gvhd| hacf
mtii gm {|gjbudu gm bjjdfbavd acf mtii mg|`b}dcduu
vg aii phg ehac`d) vhdb| avvbvtfd acf fdub|d vg eg*
g{d|avd pbvh vhd Iap gm @ggf ug ma| au vhdr ocgp
bv# Vhd iapu gm Cavt|d fg cgv aev }bcfbevb}dir? acf
vh|gt`h aii vhdgig`beai mg|jtia|bdu acf
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 136/173
v|afbvbgcai bcvd|{|dvavbgcu idv tu |daib~d vhav phav
pd a|d fdaibc` pbvh bu vhd ut{|djd iap gm gt|
gpc ldbc`? acf bv bu gc vhd laubu gm vhbu cavt|aiiap vhav pd mbcf uteh fdeia|avbgcu au vhav bc
D~do# x}bbb#) <<) phbeh vdiiu vhav bm pd mg|uaod gt|
d}bi paru gt| {auv v|acu`|duubgcu uhaii cd}d|
a`abc ld jdcvbgcdf vg tu# Pd a|d fdaibc` pbvh
vhd `|dav {|bceb{idu gm gt| utlndevb}d ldbc`) acfgt| jbutud gm vhdj bc vhd {auv eac cd}d| jaod
vhdj ehac`d vhdb| bchd|dcv iap gm aevbgc# Bm gt|
jdvhgf gm tubc` vhdj bc vhd {auv hau l|gt`hv tu
ug||gp) mda| acf v|gtlid) pd ha}d gcir vg maii
laeo gc vhd iap vhav bm pd |d}d|ud vhd eatud vhd
dmmdevu pbii ld |d}d|udf aiug? acf ug phav pd ha}d
vg fg bu ubj{ir vg |d}d|ud gt| jdcvai avvbvtfd acf
vhdc dcfda}gt| vg aev t{ vg vhd cdp gcd# Vhd
ubced|d dcfda}gt| vg aev t{ vg gt| cdp jdcvai
avvbvtfd bu duudcvbai) mg| pd eaccgv |daiir vhbco bc
gcd par acf aev bc acgvhd|? ltv gt| |d{davdf
mabit|du vg mtiir aev au pd pgtif pbuh jtuv cgv
fbuegt|a`d tu# Bv bu vhd ubced|d bcvdcvbgc vhav bu
vhd duudcvbai vhbc`) acf vhbu pbii bc vbjd |didaud
tu m|gj vhd lgcfa`d gm halbvu phbeh av {|dudcv
uddj aijguv bcut{d|alid#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 137/173
Vhd bcbvbai uvd{) vhdc) egcubuvu bc fdvd|jbcbc` vg
{bevt|d vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf au vhd bfdai gm aii pd
egtif pbuh bv vg ld lgvh vg gt|udi}du acf vggvhd|u) vg`dvhd| pbvh vhd dcfda}gt| vg |d{|gfted
vhbu bfdai) hgpd}d| bj{d|mdevir) bc gt| gpc ibmd?
acf vhbu uvd{ ha}bc` lddc vaodc) pd eac vhdc
ehdd|mtiir iggo t{gc bv au gt| d}d|*{|dudcv
M|bdcf) {|g}bfbc` aii `ggf) `ta|fbc` m|gj aiifac`d|) acf `tbfbc` tu pbvh aii egtcudi#
@|aftaiir au vhd halbv gm vhtu |d`a|fbc` vhd
Tcb}d|uai Jbcf `|gpu t{gc tu) pd uhaii mbcf vhav
bc aeeg|faced pbvh vhd iapu pd ha}d lddc
egcubfd|bc`) bv pbii ldegjd jg|d acf jg|d
{d|ugcai vg tu) acf bc |du{gcud vg gt| fdub|d bvu
bchd|dcv bcvdiib`dced pbii jaod bvudim jg|d acf
jg|d eida|ir {d|ed{vblid pbvhbc au a {gpd| gm
{d|edb}bc` v|tvh ma| ldrgcf acr uvavdjdcv gm bv
vhav pd egtif mg|jtiavd lr jd|dir bcvdiidevtai
bc}duvb`avbgc# Ubjbia|ir bm pd vhbco gm bv au a `|dav
{gpd| fd}gvdf vg ut{{irbc` aii gt| cddfu) pd
uhaii bj{|duu vhbu eha|aevd| aiug t{gc bv) acf lr
vhd iap gm utlndevb}d jbcf bv pbii {|geddf vg dcaev
vhd {a|v gm vhav u{debai {|g}bfdced phbeh pd ha}d
e|dfbvdf bv pbvh ldbc`? acf bm) ldrgcf vhd `dcd|ai
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 138/173
ea|d gm gt| egced|cu) pd pgtif f|ap vg gt|udi}du
ugjd {a|vbetia| ldcdmbv) vhd uajd |tid hgifu `ggf
gm bj{|duubc` gt| fdub|d t{gc vhd Tcb}d|uaiUtlndevb}d Jbcf# Acf bm pd |daib~d vhav alg}d acf
ldrgcf aii vhbu pd pacv ugjdvhbc` uvbii `|davd|
acf jg|d dcft|bc`) vhd ltbifbc`*t{ gm eha|aevd|
acf tcmgifbc` gm gt| {gpd|u ug vhav pd jar
dx{acf bcvg mtiid| acf rdv mtiid| jdaut|du gm ngrgtu acf ngr*`b}bc` Ibmd) uvbii vhd uajd |tid
hgifu `ggf> egc}dr vg vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf vhd
ut``duvbgc gm vhd fdub|d) acf lr vhd iap gm
|diavbgc ldvpddc utlndevb}d acf glndevb}d jbcf
vhbu vgg pbii ld mtimbiidf# Acf vhtu vhd fdd{duv
{|glidju gm {hbigug{hr l|bc` tu laeo vg vhd gif
uvavdjdcv gm vhd Iap>―Auo acf rd uhaii |dedb}d)
uddo acf rd uhaii mbcf) ocgeo acf bv uhaii ld
g{dcdf tcvg rgt# Vhbu bu vhd utjjbc`*t{ gm vhd
cavt|ai iap gm vhd |diavbgc ldvpddc tu acf vhd
Fb}bcd Jbcf# Bv bu vhtu cg }abc lgauv vhav Jdcvai
Uebdced eac dcalid tu vg jaod gt| ib}du phav pd
pbii# Pd jtuv uva|v m|gj phd|d pd a|d cgp) acf
lr |b`hvir duvbjavbc` gt| |diavbgc vg vhd Fb}bcd
Tcb}d|uai Jbcf pd eac `|aftaiir `|gp bcvg acr
egcfbvbgcu pd fdub|d) {|g}bfdf pd mb|uv jaod
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 139/173
gt|udi}du bc halbvtai jdcvai avvbvtfd vhd {d|ugc
phg eg||du{gcfu vg vhgud egcfbvbgcu> mg| pd eac
cd}d| `dv g}d| vhd iap gm eg||du{gcfdced) acf vhddxvd|caib~avbgc pbii aiparu ld bc aeeg|f pbvh vhd
bcvd|cai {|bceb{id vhav `b}du |bud vg bv# Acf vg vhbu
iap vhd|d bu cg ibjbv# Phav bv eac fg mg| tu vg*far
bv eac fg vg*jg||gp) acf vh|gt`h aii vhav
{|geduubgc gm vg*jg||gpu vhav igudu bvudim bc vhdfbj }buvau gm dvd|cbvr# Ldibdm bc ibjbvavbgc bu vhd
gcd acf gcir vhbc` vhav eatudu ibjbvavbgc)
ldeatud pd vhtu bj{|duu ibjbvavbgc t{gc vhd
e|davb}d {|bceb{id? acf bc {|g{g|vbgc au pd iar
vhav ldibdm aubfd gt| lgtcfa|bdu pbii dx{acf) acf
bce|daubc` ibmd acf jg|d altcfacv liduubc` pbii
ld gt|u#
Ltv pd jtuv cgv b`cg|d gt| |du{gcublbibvbdu#
V|abcdf vhgt`hv bu ma| jg|d {gpd|mti vhac
tcv|abcdf) acf vhd|dmg|d vhd jg|d fdd{ir pd
{dcdv|avd bcvg Jdcvai Uebdced vhd jg|d ea|dmtiir
pd jtuv `ta|f a`abcuv aii vhgt`hvu acf pg|fu
dx{|duub}d gm d}dc vhd jguv jgfbmbdf mg|j gm bii*
pbii# @guub{) vaid*lda|bc`) ucdd|bc` iat`hvd|) a|d
cgv bc aeeg|f pbvh vhd {|bceb{idu gm Jdcvai
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 140/173
Uebdced? acf ubjbia|ir d}dc gt| ujaiiduv vhgt`hvu
gm `ggf ea||r pbvh vhdj a uddf gm `ggf phbeh pbii
auut|dfir lda| m|tbv bc ftd vbjd# Vhbu bu cgv jd|d,`ggfbd) `ggfbd), ltv ac bj{g|vacv iduugc bc
Jdcvai Uebdced) mg| gt| utlndevb}d jbcf vaodu bvu
egigt| m|gj gt| udvvidf jdcvai halbvu) acf ac
geeaubgcai ammb|javbgc g| fdcbai pbii cgv ld
utmmbebdcv vg ehac`d bv? acf pd jtuv vhd|dmg|detivb}avd vhav vgcd phbeh pd pbuh vg udd
|d{|gftedf bc gt| egcfbvbgcu phdvhd| gm lgfr)
jbcf) g| eb|etjuvaced#
Bc vhdud idevt|du jr {t|{gud hau lddc) cgv ug
jteh vg `b}d u{debmbe |tidu gm {|aevbed au vg iar fgpc vhd l|gaf `dcd|ai {|bceb{idu gm Jdcvai
Uebdced phbeh pbii dcalid vhd uvtfdcv vg mg|j
|tidu mg| hbjudim# Bc d}d|r paio bc ibmd) lggo
ocgpidf`d bu gcir a jdacu vg ac dcf# Lggou eac
gcir fb|dev tu phd|d vg iggo acf phav vg iggo mg|)
ltv pd jtuv fg vhd mbcfbc` mg| gt|udi}du?
vhd|dmg|d) bm rgt ha}d |daiir `|au{df vhd
{|bceb{idu gm vhd uebdced) rgt pbii m|ajd |tidu gm
rgt| gpc phbeh pbii `b}d rgt ldvvd| |dutivu vhac
acr avvdj{v vg mgiigp ugjdlgfr diud'u jdvhgf)
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 141/173
phbeh pau uteeduumti bc vhdb| hacfu {|debudir
ldeatud bv pau vhdb|u# Cd}d| mda| vg ld rgt|udim# Bm
Jdcvai Uebdced fgdu cgv vdaeh rgt vg ld rgt|udim bv vdaehdu rgt cgvhbc`# Rgt|udim) jg|d rgt|udim)
acf rdv jg|d rgt|udim bu phav rgt pacv? gcir
pbvh vhd ocgpidf`d vhav vhd v|td udim bceitfdu vhd
bccd| acf hb`hd| udim phbeh bu aiparu bc
bjjdfbavd vgteh pbvh vhd @|dav Fb}bcd Jbcf# Au Paiv Phbvjac uaru>**,Rgt a|d cgv aii
bceitfdf ldvpddc rgt| hav acf rgt| lggvu#,
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 142/173
Vhd `|gpbc` {g{tia|bvr gm vhd Dfbclt|`h
Idevt|du gc Jdcvai Uebdced hau idf jd vg aff vg
vhd {|dudcv dfbvbgc vh|dd jg|d udevbgcu gc Lgfr)
Ugti) acf U{b|bv) phbeh bv bu hg{df pbii {|g}d
tudmti lr |dcfd|bc` vhd {|bceb{idu gm vhd
bcvd|aevbgc gm vhdud vh|dd maevg|u ugjdphav
eida|d| #
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 143/173
XB]#
VHD LGFR#
Ugjd uvtfdcvu mbcf bv fbmmbetiv vg |daib~d vhav
jdcvai aevbgc eac {|gfted acr |dai dmmdev t{gc
javd|bai utluvaced? ltv bm vhbu bu cgv {guublidvhd|d bu cg uteh vhbc` au Jdcvai Uebdced) vhd
{t|{gud gm phbeh bu vg {|gfted bj{|g}df
egcfbvbgcu lgvh gm lgfr acf dc}b|gcjdcv) ug vhav
vhd tivbjavd jacbmduvavbgc abjdf av bu aiparu gcd
gm fdjgcuv|avbgc t{gc vhd {iacd gm vhd }bublidacf egce|dvd# Vhd|dmg|d vg ammg|f egc}bevbgc gm ac
aevtai egccdevbgc ldvpddc vhd }bublid acf vhd
bc}bublid) ldvpddc vhd bccd| acf vhd gtvd|) bu gcd
gm vhd jguv bj{g|vacv {gbcvu bc vhd egt|ud gm gt|
uvtfbdu#
Vhav uteh a egccdevbgc jtuv dxbuv bu {|g}df lr
jdva{hrubeai a|`tjdcv bc acupd| vg vhd
qtduvbgc) ,Hgp fbf acrvhbc` d}d| egjd bcvg
dxbuvdced av aii7, Acf vhd phgid e|davbgc)
gt|udi}du bceitfdf) uvacfu au d}bfdced vg vhbu
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 144/173
`|dav v|tvh# Ltv vg jacr jbcfu jd|dir aluv|aev
a|`tjdcv bu cgv egj{idvdir egc}bcebc`) g| av acr
|avd bv ldegjdu jg|d egc}bcebc` bm bv bu ut{{g|vdf lr ugjdvhbc` gm a jg|d egce|dvd cavt|d? acf mg|
uteh |dafd|u B pgtif `b}d a mdp hbcvu au vg vhd
eg||du{gcfdced ldvpddc vhd {hrubeai acf vhd
jdcvai# Vhd utlndev eg}d|u a }d|r pbfd a|da) acf
vhd ibjbvdf u{aed av jr fbu{guai pbii gcir aiigp jd vg vgteh gc a mdp ut``duvb}d {gbcvu) uvbii vhdud
jar ld utmmbebdcv vg uhgp vhav vhd aluv|aev
a|`tjdcv hau ugjd eg||du{gcfbc` maevu av vhd
laeo gm bv#
Gcd gm vhd jguv egc}bcebc` {|ggmu B ha}d uddc buvhav ammg|fdf lr vhd ,lbgjdv|d), a ibvvid
bcuv|tjdcv bc}dcvdf lr ac djbcdcv M|dceh
uebdcvbuv) vhd iavd F|# Hb{{girvd La|afte) phbeh
uhgpu vhd aevbgc gm phav hd eaiiu vhd ,}bvai
et||dcv#, Hbu vhdg|r bu vhav vhbu mg|ed) phavd}d|
bvu aevtai cavt|d jar ld) bu tcb}d|uaiir {|dudcv)
acf g{d|avdu au a et||dcv gm {hrubeai }bvaibvr
{d|{dvtaiir) migpbc` pbvh jg|d g| iduu dcd|`r
vh|gt`h d}d|r {hrubeai g|`acbuj) acf phbeh eac)
av acr |avd vg ugjd dxvdcv) ld egcv|giidf lr vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 145/173
{gpd| gm vhd htjac pbii# Vhd vhdg|r bc aii bvu
jbctvbad bu dxeddfbc`ir dialg|avd) acf hau lddc
fdue|bldf bc fdvabi bc F|# La|afte'u {tlibuhdf pg|ou# Bc a egc}d|uavbgc B haf pbvh hbj algtv a
rda| a`g) hd vgif jd hd pau p|bvbc` acgvhd| lggo
phbeh pgtif vh|gp mt|vhd| ib`hv gc vhd utlndev)
ltv a mdp jgcvhu iavd| hd {auudf g}d| ldmg|d bv
pau {|dudcvdf vg vhd pg|if# Vhd maev) hgpd}d|) phbeh B pbuh vg {tv ldmg|d vhd |dafd|) bu vhd
getia| fdjgcuv|avbgc gm vhd egccdevbgc ldvpddc
jbcf acf javvd|) phbeh ac dx{d|bjdcv pbvh vhd
lbgjdv|d ammg|fu#
Vhd bcuv|tjdcv egcubuvu gm a ldii `iauu) m|gj vhdbcubfd gm phbeh bu utu{dcfdf a eg{{d| cddfid lr a
mbcd ubiodc vh|daf# Vhd `iauu uvacfu gc a pggfdc
ut{{g|v) ldigp phbeh bu a egbi gm eg{{d| pb|d)
phbeh) hgpd}d|) bu cgv egccdevdf pbvh acr
lavvd|r g| gvhd| a{{a|avtu) acf jd|dir ud|}du vg
egcfdcud vhd et||dcv# Ldigp vhd cddfid) bcubfd
vhd `iauu) vhd|d bu a eb|etia| ea|f fb}bfdf bcvg
fd`|ddu vg ja|o vhd aevbgc gm vhd cddfid# Vpg gm
vhdud bcuv|tjdcvu a|d {iaedf ubfd lr ubfd) ltv bc
cg par egccdevdf) acf vhd dx{d|bjdcvd| vhdc
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 146/173
hgifu gtv vhd mbc`d|u gm lgvh hacfu vg pbvhbc
algtv ac bceh gm vhd `iauudu# Aeeg|fbc` vg vhd
vhdg|r) vhd et||dcv dcvd|u av vhd idmv hacf)eb|etiavdu vh|gt`h vhd lgfr) acf {auudu gtv av vhd
|b`hv hacf) vhav bu vg uar) vhd|d bu ac bcf|apbc` av
vhd idmv acf a `b}bc`*gtv av vhd |b`hv) vhtu
a`|ddbc` pbvh \dbehdclaeh'u dx{d|bjdcvu gc vhd
{gia|bvr gm vhd htjac lgfr#B jtuv egcmduu vhav) aivhgt`h B haf |daf F|#
La|afte'u lggo) ,Idu ]bl|avbgcu Htjabcdu), B
a{{|gaehdf vhd bcuv|tjdcv bc a }d|r ued{vbeai
m|ajd gm jbcf? ltv B pau uggc egc}bcedf gm jr
d||g|# Av mb|uv) hgifbc` a jdcvai avvbvtfd gm dcvb|d|diaxavbgc) B mgtcf vhav vhd idmv*hacf cddfid pau
avv|aevdf vh|gt`h vpdcvr fd`|ddu) phbid vhd
|b`hv*hacf cddfid) vhd gcd ammdevdf lr vhd gtv*
`gbc` et||dcv) pau |d{diidf vh|gt`h vdc fd`|ddu#
Amvd| aiigpbc` vhd bcuv|tjdcv vg |dvt|c vg bvu
cg|jai dqtbibl|btj B a`abc a{{|gaehdf bv pbvh
vhd {t|{gud gm uddbc` phdvhd| a ehac`d gm jdcvai
avvbvtfd pgtif bc vhd idauv jgfbmr vhd migp gm
et||dcv# Vhbu vbjd B auutjdf vhd uv|gc`duv
jdcvai avvbvtfd B egtif pbvh vhd bcvdcvbgc gm
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 147/173
udcfbc` gtv a migp vh|gt`h vhd |b`hv hacf) acf
vhd |dutiv au egj{a|df pbvh vhd {|d}bgtu gcd pau
|dja|oalid# Vhd idmv*hacf cddfid pau cgp avv|aevdf gcir vh|gt`h vdc fd`|ddu) phbid vhd
|b`hv*hacf gcd pau fdmidevdf vh|gt`h ugjdvhbc`
g}d| vhb|vr) vhtu eida|ir bcfbeavbc` vhd bcmitdced
gm vhd jdcvai maetivbdu bc jgfbmrbc` vhd aevbgc gm
vhd et||dcv# B jar jdcvbgc vhav vhd dx{d|bjdcv pau jafd bc vhd {|dudced gm vpg jdfbeai jdc
phg cgvdf vhd jg}djdcv gm vhd cddfidu#
B pbii cgv hd|d uvg{ vg fbuetuu vhd qtduvbgc gm
phav vhd aevtai egcuvbvtvbgc gm vhbu et||dcv gm
}bvai dcd|`r jar ld―bv bu utmmbebdcv mg| gt|{|dudcv {t|{gud vhav bv bu vhd|d) acf vhd
dx{d|bjdcv B ha}d fdue|bldf l|bc`u tu maed vg
maed pbvh vhd maev gm a eg||du{gcfdced ldvpddc
gt| gpc jdcvai avvbvtfd acf vhd bc}bublid mg|edu
gm cavt|d# D}dc bm pd uar vhav vhbu et||dcv bu ugjd
mg|j gm didev|bebvr) acf vhav vhd }a|bavbgc gm bvu
aevbgc bu fdvd|jbcdf lr ehac`du bc vhd
{gia|b~avbgc gm vhd avgju gm vhd lgfr) vhdc vhbu
ehac`d gm {gia|bvr bu vhd |dutiv gm jdcvai aevbgc?
ug vhav vhd qtbeodcbc` g| |dva|fbc` gm vhd egujbe
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 148/173
et||dcv bu dqtaiir vhd |dutiv gm vhd jdcvai
avvbvtfd phdvhd| pd ut{{gud gt| jdcvai mg|ed vg
aev fb|devir t{gc vhd et||dcv bvudim g| bcfb|devir lr bcftebc` ehac`du bc vhd jgidetia| uv|tevt|d gm
vhd lgfr# Phbehd}d| hr{gvhdubu pd afg{v vhd
egceitubgc bu vhd uajd) cajdir) vhav vhd jbcf
hau {gpd| vg g{dc g| eigud vhd fgg| vg bc}bublid
mg|edu bc uteh a par vhav vhd |dutiv gm vhd jdcvaiaevbgc ldegjdu a{{a|dcv gc vhd javd|bai {iacd#
Cgp) bc}duvb`avbgc uhgpu vhav vhd {hrubeai lgfr)
bu a jdehacbuj u{debaiir afa{vdf mg| vhd
v|acujtvavbgc gm vhd bccd| g| jdcvai {gpd| bcvg
jgfdu gm dxvd|cai aevb}bvr# Pd ocgp m|gjjdfbeai uebdced vhav vhd phgid lgfr bu v|a}d|udf
lr a cdvpg|o gm cd|}du phbeh ud|}d au vhd
ehaccdiu gm egjjtcbeavbgc ldvpddc vhd
bcfpdiibc` u{b|bvtai d`g) phbeh pd eaii jbcf) acf
vhd mtcevbgcu gm vhd dxvd|cai g|`acbuj# Vhbu
cd|}gtu uruvdj bu ftai# Gcd uruvdj) ocgpc au
vhd Urj{avhdvbe) bu vhd ehaccdi mg| aii vhgud
aevb}bvbdu phbeh a|d cgv egcuebgtuir fb|devdf lr
gt| }gibvbgc) uteh au vhd g{d|avbgc gm vhd
fb`duvb}d g|`acu) vhd |d{ab| gm vhd fabir pda| acf
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 149/173
vda| gm vhd vbuutdu) acf vhd ibod# Vhd gvhd| uruvdj)
ocgpc au vhd ]gitcva|r g| Ed|dl|g*u{bcai
uruvdj) bu vhd ehaccdi vh|gt`h phbeh pd |dedb}degcuebgtu {d|ed{vbgc m|gj vhd {hrubeai udcudu
acf dxd|ebud egcv|gi g}d| vhd jg}djdcvu gm vhd
lgfr# Vhbu uruvdj hau bvu edcv|d bc vhd l|abc)
phbid vhd gvhd| hau bvu edcv|d bc a `ac`ibgcbe
jauu av vhd laeo gm vhd uvgjaeh ocgpc au vhdugia| {idxtu) acf ugjdvbjdu u{godc gm au vhd
alfgjbcai l|abc# Vhd ed|dl|g*u{bcai uruvdj bu
vhd ehaccdi gm gt| }gibvbgcai g| egcuebgtu jdcvai
aevbgc) acf vhd urj{avhdvbe uruvdj bu vhd ehaccdi
gm vhav jdcvai aevbgc phbeh tcegcuebgtuir
ut{{g|vu vhd }bvai mtcevbgcu gm vhd lgfr# Vhtu vhd
ed|dl|g*u{bcai uruvdj bu vhd g|`ac gm egcuebgtu
jbcf acf vhd urj{avhdvbe bu vhav gm utl*
egcuebgtu jbcf#
Ltv vhd bcvd|aevbgc gm egcuebgtu acf
utlegcuebgtu jbcf |dqtb|du a ubjbia| bcvd|aevbgc
ldvpddc vhd eg||du{gcfbc` uruvdju gm cd|}du)
acf gcd egcu{betgtu egccdevbgc lr phbeh vhbu bu
{|g}bfdf bu vhd ,}a`tu, cd|}d# Vhbu cd|}d {auudu
gtv gm vhd ed|dl|ai |d`bgc au a {g|vbgc gm vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 150/173
}gitcva|r uruvdj) acf vh|gt`h bv pd egcv|gi vhd
}geai g|`acu? vhdc bv {auudu gcpa|fu vg vhd
vhg|ax udcfbc` gtv l|acehdu vg vhd hda|v acfitc`u? acf mbcaiir) {auubc` vh|gt`h vhd
fba{h|a`j) bv igudu vhd gtvd| egavbc` phbeh
fbuvbc`tbuhdu vhd cd|}du gm vhd }gitcva|r uruvdj
acf ldegjdu bfdcvbmbdf pbvh vhgud gm vhd
urj{avhdvbe uruvdj) ug mg|jbc` a egccdevbc` ibco ldvpddc vhd vpg acf jaobc` vhd jac {hrubeaiir
a ubc`id dcvbvr#
Ubjbia|ir fbmmd|dcv a|dau gm vhd l|abc bcfbeavd)
vhdb| egccdevbgc pbvh vhd glndevb}d acf utlndevb}d
aevb}bvbdu gm vhd jbcf |du{devb}dir) acf u{daobc`bc a `dcd|ai par pd jar auub`c vhd m|gcvai
{g|vbgc gm vhd l|abc vg vhd mg|jd| acf vhd
{guvd|bg| {g|vbgc vg vhd iavvd|) phbid vhd
bcvd|jdfbavd {g|vbgc {a|vaodu gm vhd eha|aevd| gm
lgvh#
Vhd bcvtbvbgcai maetivr hau bvu eg||du{gcfdced bc
vhbu t{{d| a|da gm vhd l|abc ubvtavdf ldvpddc vhd
m|gcvai acf {guvd|bg| {g|vbgcu) acf
{hrubgig`beaiir u{daobc`) bv bu hd|d vhav bcvtbvb}d
bfdau mbcf dcv|aced# Vhdud av mb|uv a|d jg|d g|
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 151/173
iduu tcmg|jdf acf `dcd|aib~df bc eha|aevd|) ltv
a|d cd}d|vhdiduu {d|edb}df lr vhd egcuebgtu
jbcf) gvhd|pbud pd uhgtif cgv ld apa|d gm vhdjav aii# Vhdc vhd dmmg|v gm cavt|d bu vg l|bc` vhdud
bfdau bcvg jg|d fdmbcbvd acf tualid uha{d) ug vhd
egcuebgtu jbcf iaru hgif gm vhdj acf bcftedu a
eg||du{gcfbc` }bl|avg|r et||dcv bc vhd }gitcva|r
uruvdj gm cd|}du) acf vhbu bc vt|c bcftedu aubjbia| et||dcv bc vhd bc}gitcva|r uruvdj) vhtu
hacfbc` vhd bfda g}d| vg vhd utlndevb}d jbcf# Vhd
}bl|avg|r et||dcv phbeh haf mb|uv fduedcfdf m|gj
vhd a{dx gm vhd l|abc vg vhd m|gcvai l|abc acf vhtu
vh|gt`h vhd }gitcva|r uruvdj vg vhd ugia| {idxtu
bu cgp |d}d|udf acf auedcfu m|gj vhd ugia|
{idxtu vh|gt`h vhd urj{avhdvbe uruvdj vg vhd
{guvd|bg| l|abc) vhbu |dvt|c et||dcv bcfbeavbc` vhd
aevbgc gm vhd utlndevb}d jbcf#
Bm pd pd|d vg |djg}d vhd ut|maed {g|vbgc gm vhd
a{dx gm vhd l|abc pd uhgtif mbcf bjjdfbavdir
ldigp bv vhd uhbcbc` ldiv gm l|abc utluvaced eaiidf
vhd ,eg|{tu eaiigutj#, Vhbu bu vhd {gbcv gm tcbgc
ldvpddc vhd utlndevb}d acf glndevb}d) acf au vhd
et||dcv |dvt|cu m|gj vhd ugia| {idxtu vg vhbu
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 152/173
{gbcv bv bu |duvg|df vg vhd glndevb}d {g|vbgc gm vhd
l|abc bc a m|duh mg|j phbeh bv hau aeqtb|df lr vhd
ubidcv aiehdjr gm vhd utlndevb}d jbcf# Vhtu vhdegced{vbgc phbeh pau av mb|uv gcir }a`tdir
|deg`cb~df bu |duvg|df vg vhd glndevb}d jbcf bc a
fdmbcbvd acf pg|oalid mg|j) acf vhdc vhd
glndevb}d jbcf) aevbc` vh|gt`h vhd m|gcvai l|abc**
vhd a|da gm egj{a|bugc acf acairubu**{|geddfu vg pg|o t{gc a eida|ir {d|edb}df bfda acf vg l|bc`
gtv vhd {gvdcvbaibvbdu vhav a|d iavdcv bc bv#
Bv jtuv gm egt|ud ld lg|cd bc jbcf vhav B aj hd|d
u{daobc` gm vhd jdcvai d`g bc vhav) jgfd gm bvu
dxbuvdced pbvh phbeh pd a|d jguv majbiba|) vhav buau eigvhdf bc miduh) vhgt`h vhd|d jar ld jteh vg
uar au vg gvhd| jgfdu gm bvu aevb}bvr# Ltv mg| gt|
fabir ibmd pd ha}d vg egcubfd| gt|udi}du au pd a|d
bc vhav au{dev gm ibmd) acf m|gj vhbu {gbcv gm }bdp
vhd {hrubgig`beai eg||du{gcfdced gm vhd lgfr vg
vhd aevbgc gm vhd jbcf bu ac bj{g|vacv bvdj? acf
vhd|dmg|d) aivhgt`h pd jtuv aiparu |djdjld|
vhav vhd g|b`bc gm bfdau bu {t|dir jdcvai) pd jtuv
cgv mg|`dv vhav gc vhd {hrubeai {iacd d}d|r jdcvai
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 153/173
aevbgc bj{ibdu a eg||du{gcfbc` jgidetia| aevbgc
bc vhd l|abc acf bc vhd vpg*mgif cd|}gtu uruvdj#
Bm) au vhd gif Dib~aldvhac {gdv uaru) ,vhd ugti bu
mg|j) acf fgvh vhd lgfr jaod), vhdc bv bu eida|
vhav vhd {hrubeai g|`acbuj jtuv ld a jdehacbeai
a||ac`djdcv au u{debaiir afa{vdf mg| vhd tud gm
vhd ugti'u {gpd|u au a uvdaj*dc`bcd bu mg| vhd
{gpd| gm uvdaj? acf bv bu vhd |deg`cbvbgc gm vhbu|deb{|gebvr ldvpddc vhd vpg vhav bu vhd laubu gm aii
u{b|bvtai g| jdcvai hdaibc`) acf vhd|dmg|d vhd
uvtfr gm vhbu jdehacbeai afa{vavbgc bu ac
bj{g|vacv l|aceh gm Jdcvai Uebdced# Gcir pd
jtuv cgv mg|`dv vhav bv bu vhd dmmdev acf cgv vhdeatud#
Av vhd uajd vbjd bv bu bj{g|vacv vg |djdjld|
vhav uteh a vhbc` au |d}d|uai gm vhd |diavbgc
ldvpddc eatud acf dmmdev bu {guublid) ntuv au vhd
uajd a{{a|avtu jar ld jafd vg `dcd|avdjdehacbeai {gpd| lr vhd a{{ibeavbgc gm
didev|bebvr) g| vg `dcd|avd didev|bebvr lr vhd
a{{ibeavbgc gm jdehacbeai {gpd|# Acf vhd
bj{g|vaced gm vhbu {|bceb{id egcubuvu bc vhbu#
Vhd|d bu aiparu a vdcfdcer mg| aevbgcu phbeh
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 154/173
pd|d av mb|uv }gitcva|r vg ldegjd atvgjavbe) vhav
bu) vg {auu m|gj vhd |d`bgc gm egcuebgtu jbcf bcvg
vhav gm utlegcuebgtu jbcf) acf vg aeqtb|d a{d|jacdcv fgjbebid vhd|d# [|gmduug| Dijd|
@avdu) gm Pauhbc`vgc) hau fdjgcuv|avdf vhbu
{hrubgig`beaiir bc hbu uvtfbdu gm l|abc mg|javbgc#
Hd vdiiu tu vhav d}d|r vhgt`hv {|gftedu a uib`hv
jgidetia| ehac`d bc vhd utluvaced gm vhd l|abc)acf vhd |d{dvbvbgc gm vhd uajd ug|v gm vhgt`hv
eatudu a |d{dvbvbgc gm vhd uajd jgidetia| aevbgc
tcvbi av iauv a }d|bvalid ehaccdi bu mg|jdf bc vhd
l|abc utluvaced) phbeh eac gcir ld d|afbeavdf lr
a |d}d|ud {|geduu gm vhgt`hv# Bc vhbu par ,`|gg}du
gm vhgt`hv, a|d }d|r ibvd|ai vhbc`u) acf phdc gced
duvalibuhdf vhd }bl|avbgcu gm vhd egujbe et||dcvu
migp atvgjavbeaiir vh|gt`h vhdj acf vhtu |daev
t{gc vhd jbcf lr a {|geduu vhd |d}d|ud gm vhav lr
phbeh gt| }gitcva|r acf bcvdcvbgcai bc*f|apbc`
m|gj vhd bc}bublid bu ammdevdf# Bc vhbu par a|d
mg|jdf phav pd eaii ,halbvu), acf hdced vhd
bj{g|vaced gm egcv|giibc` gt| vhbcobc` acf
`ta|fbc` bv a`abcuv tcfdub|alid bfdau#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 155/173
Ltv gc vhd gvhd| hacf vhbu |daevbgca|r {|geduu
jar ld tudf vg egcmb|j `ggf acf ibmd*`b}bc`
jgfdu gm vhgt`hv) ug vhav lr a ocgpidf`d gm bvuiapu pd jar dcibuv d}dc vhd {hrubeai lgfr bvudim
bc vhd ltbifbc` t{ gm vhav {d|mdevir phgid
{d|ugcaibvr) vhd avvabcjdcv gm phbeh bu vhd abj
acf glndev gm gt| uvtfbdu#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 156/173
X]#
VHD UGTI#
Ha}bc` cgp glvabcdf a `ibj{ud gm vhd afa{vavbgc
gm vhd {hrubeai g|`acbuj vg vhd aevbgc gm vhd jbcf
pd jtuv cdxv |daib~d vhav vhd jbcf bvudim bu acg|`acbuj phbeh bu bc ibod jaccd| afa{vdf vg vhd
aevbgc gm a uvbii hb`hd| {gpd|) gcir hd|d vhd
afa{vavbgc bu gcd gm jdcvai maetivr# Au pbvh gvhd|
bc}bublid mg|edu aii pd eac ocgp gm vhd jbcf bu lr
glud|}bc` phav bv fgdu) ltv pbvh vhbu fbmmd|dced)vhav ubced pd gt|udi}du a|d vhbu jbcf) gt|
glud|}avbgc bu ac bcvd|bg| glud|}avbgc gm uvavdu gm
egcuebgtucduu# Bc vhbu par pd |deg`cb~d ed|vabc
maetivbdu gm gt| jbcf) vhd pg|obc` g|fd| gm phbeh
B ha}d egcubfd|df av {a`d 86? ltv vhd {gbcv vg
phbeh B pgtif cgp f|ap avvdcvbgc bu vhav vhdud
maetivbdu aiparu pg|o tcfd| vhd bcmitdced gm
ugjdvhbc` phbeh uvbjtiavdu vhdj) acf vhbu
uvbjtitu jar egjd dbvhd| m|gj pbvhgtv vh|gt`h
vhd dxvd|cai udcudu) g| m|gj pbvhbc lr vhd
egcuebgtucduu gm ugjdvhbc` cgv {d|ed{vblid gc
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 157/173
vhd {hrubeai {iacd# Cgp vhd |deg`cbvbgc gm vhdud
bcvd|bg| ugt|edu gm uvbjtitu vg gt| jdcvai
maetivbdu) bu ac bj{g|vacv l|aceh gm JdcvaiUebdced) ldeatud vhd jdcvai aevbgc vhtu udv t{
pg|ou ntuv au aeet|avdir vh|gt`h vhd {hrubeai
eg||du{gcfdcedu au vhgud phbeh uva|v m|gj vhd
|deg`cbvbgc gm dxvd|cai maevu) acf vhd|dmg|d vhd
egcv|gi acf |b`hv fb|devbgc gm vhdud bccd|{d|ed{vbgcu bu a javvd| gm vhd mb|uv jgjdcv#
Vhd maetivbdu jguv bjjdfbavdir egced|cdf a|d
vhd bcvtbvbgc acf vhd bja`bcavbgc) ltv bv bu av mb|uv
fbmmbetiv vg udd hgp vhd bcvtbvbgc) phbeh bu dcvb|dir
u{gcvacdgtu) eac ld l|gt`hv tcfd| vhd egcv|gi gm vhd pbii# Gm egt|ud) vhd u{gcvacdgtucduu gm vhd
bcvtbvbgc eaccgv bc acr par ld bcvd|md|df pbvh)
mg| bm bv edaudf vg aev u{gcvacdgtuir bv pgtif
edaud vg ld vhd bcvtbvbgc# Bvu {|g}bced bu) au bv
pd|d) vg ea{vt|d bfdau m|gj vhd bcmbcbvd acf
{|dudcv vhdj vg vhd jbcf vg ld fdaiv pbvh av bvu
fbue|dvbgc# Bc gt| jdcvai egcuvbvtvbgc vhd
bcvtbvbgc bu vhd {gbcv gm g|b`bcavbgc acf)
vhd|dmg|d) mg| bv vg edaud vg aev u{gcvacdgtuir
pgtif ld mg| bv vg edaud vg aev av aii# Ltv vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 158/173
dx{d|bdced gm a igc` uteeduubgc gm glud|}d|u
uhgpu vhav vhd bcvtbvbgc eac ld v|abcdf ug au vg
aeqtb|d bce|daudf udcubvb}dcduu bc ugjd){a|vbetia| fb|devbgc) acf vhd ehgbed gm vhd `dcd|ai
fb|devbgc bu fdvd|jbcdf lr vhd pbii gm vhd
bcfb}bftai#
Bv pbii ld mgtcf vhav vhd bcvtbvbgc pg|ou jguv
|dafbir bc |du{dev vg vhgud utlndevu phbeh jguvhalbvtaiir geet{r gt| vhgt`hv? acf aeeg|fbc` vg
vhd {hrubgig`beai eg||du{gcfdcedu phbeh pd ha}d
lddc egcubfd|bc` vhbu jb`hv ld aeegtcvdf mg| gc
vhd {hrubeai {iacd lr vhd mg|javbgc gm l|abc*
ehaccdiu u{debaiir afa{vdf mg| vhd bcftevbgc bcvhd jgidetia| uruvdj gm }bl|avbgcu eg||du{gcfbc`
vg vhd {a|vbetia| eiauu gm bfdau bc qtduvbgc# Ltv gm
egt|ud pd jtuv |djdjld| vhav vhd bfdau
vhdjudi}du a|d cgv eatudf lr vhd jgidetia|
ehac`du ltv gc vhd egcv|a|r a|d vhd eatud gm
vhdj? acf bv bu bc vhbu v|acuiavbgc gm vhgt`hv
aevbgc bcvg {hrubeai aevbgc vhav pd a|d l|gt`hv
maed vg maed pbvh vhd dvd|cai jruvd|r gm vhd
fduedcv gm u{b|bv bcvg javvd|? acf vhav vhgt`h pd
jar v|aed javvd| vh|gt`h uteeduub}d fd`|ddu gm
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 159/173
|dmbcdjdcv vbii bv ldegjdu phav) bc egj{a|bugc
pbvh vhgud fdcud| jgfdu vhav a|d jguv majbiba|)
pd jb`hv eaii a u{b|bvtai utluvaced) rdv av vhd dcfgm bv bv bu cgv vhd bcvdiib`dcv vhbcobc` {|bceb{id
bvudim# Vhd e|bvd|bgc bu bc vhd pg|f ,}bl|avbgcu#,
Hgpd}d| fdibeavdir dvhd|be vhd utluvaced bvu
jg}djdcv egjjdcedu lr vhd }bl|avbgc gm bvu
{a|vbeidu) acf a }bl|avbgc bu a pa}d ha}bc` aed|vabc idc`vh) aj{ibvtfd) acf {d|bgfbebvr) vhav bu
vg uar) ugjdvhbc` phbeh eac dxbuv gcir bc vd|ju
gm u{aed acf vbjd? acf au uggc au pd a|d fdaibc`
pbvh acrvhbc` ea{alid gm vhd egced{vbgc gm
jdaut|djdcv pd jar ld qtbvd ed|vabc vhav pd
a|d cgv fdaibc` pbvh U{b|bv ltv gcir pbvh gcd gm bvu
}dhbeidu# Vhd|dmg|d aivhgt`h pd jar {tuh gt|
acairubu gm javvd| mt|vhd| acf d}d| mt|vhd| laeo**
acf gc vhbu ibcd vhd|d bu a `|dav fdai gm ocgpidf`d
vg ld `abcdf**pd uhaii mbcf vhav vhd {gbcv av
phbeh u{b|bvtai {gpd| g| vhgt`hv*mg|ed bu
v|acuiavdf bcvg dvhd|be g| avgjbe }bl|avbgc pbii
aiparu ditfd tu# Vhd|dmg|d pd jtuv cgv avv|bltvd
vhd g|b`bcavbgc gm bfdau vg jgidetia|
fbu{iaedjdcv bc vhd l|abc) vhgt`h) lr vhd
|daevbgc gm vhd {hrubeai t{gc vhd jdcvai phbeh B
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 160/173
ha}d u{godc gm alg}d) vhd mg|javbgc gm vhgt`hv*
ehaccdiu bc vhd `|dr javvd| gm vhd l|abc jar vdcf
vg maebibvavd vhd |ded{vbgc gm ed|vabc bfdau# Ugjd{dg{id a|d aevtaiir egcuebgtu gm vhd aevbgc gm vhd
t{{d| {g|vbgc gm vhd l|abc ft|bc` vhd bcmitx gm ac
bcvtbvbgc) vhd udcuavbgc ldbc` vhav gm a ug|v gm
dx{acubgc bc vhav l|abc a|da) phbeh jb`hv ld
egj{a|df vg vhd g{dcbc` gm a }ai}d g| fgg|? ltvaii avvdj{vu vg bcfted vhd bcmigp gm bcvtbvb}d bfdau
lr vhd {hrubgig`beai dx{dfbdcv gm v|rbc` vg g{dc
vhbu }ai}d lr vhd dxd|ebud gm vhd pbii uhgtif ld
fbuegt|a`df au ibodir vg {|g}d bcnt|bgtu vg vhd
l|abc# B ldibd}d ugjd G|bdcvai uruvdju af}geavd
vhbu jdvhgf) ltv pd jar pdii v|tuv vhd jbcf vg
|d`tiavd vhd aevbgc gm bvu {hrubeai ehaccdiu bc a
jaccd| utbvalid vg bvu gpc |dqtb|djdcvu) bcuvdaf
gm v|rbc` vg jacb{tiavd vhd jbcf lr vhd
tccavt|ai mg|ebc` gm bvu jdehacbeai bcuv|tjdcv#
Bc aii gt| uvtfbdu gc vhdud ibcdu pd jtuv
|djdjld| vhav fd}dig{jdcv bu aiparu lr
{d|mdevir cavt|ai `|gpvh acf bu cgv l|gt`hv algtv
lr tcftir uv|abcbc` acr {g|vbgc gm vhd uruvdj#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 161/173
Vhd maev) hgpd}d|) |djabcu vhav vhd bcvtbvbgc
pg|ou jguv m|ddir bc vhav fb|devbgc bc phbeh pd
jguv halbvtaiir egcedcv|avd gt| vhgt`hv? acf bc{|aevbed bv pbii ld mgtcf vhav vhd lduv par vg
etivb}avd vhd bcvtbvbgc bc acr {a|vbetia| fb|devbgc
bu vg jdfbvavd t{gc vhd aluv|aev {|bceb{idu gm vhav
{a|vbetia| eiauu gm utlndevu |avhd| vhac gcir vg
egcubfd| {a|vbetia| eaudu# [d|ha{u vhd |daugc buvhav {a|vbetia| eaudu ha}d vg fg pbvh u{debmbe
{hdcgjdca) vhav bu pbvh vhd iap pg|obc` tcfd|
ed|vabc ibjbvbc` egcfbvbgcu) phd|dau vhd
{|bceb{idu gm vhd iap a|d cgv ibjbvdf lr igeai
egcfbvbgcu) acf ug halbvtai jdfbvavbgc gc vhdj
udvu gt| bcvtbvbgc m|dd vg |ac`d bc ac bcmbcbvtfd
phd|d vhd egced{vbgc gm acvdedfdcv egcfbvbgcu
fgdu cgv ibjbv bv# Acrpar) phavd}d| jar ld vhd
vhdg|dvbeai dx{iacavbgc) rgt pbii mbcf vhav vhd
eida| `|au{ gm aluv|aev {|bceb{idu bc acr fb|devbgc
hau a pgcfd|mtiir qtbeodcbc` dmmdev t{gc vhd
bcvtbvbgc bc vhav {a|vbetia| fb|devbgc#
Vhd bj{g|vaced gm |deg`cb~bc` gt| {gpd| gm vhtu
`b}bc` fb|devbgc vg vhd bcvtbvbgc eaccgv ld
dxa``d|avdf) mg| bm vhd jbcf bu avvtcdf vg
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 162/173
urj{avhr pbvh vhd hb`hduv {haudu gm u{b|bv vhbu
{gpd| g{dcu vhd fgg| vg ibjbviduu {guublbibvbdu gm
ocgpidf`d# Bc bvu hb`hduv pg|obc`u bcvtbvbgc ldegjdu bcu{b|avbgc) acf ed|vabc `|dav |deg|fu gm
mtcfajdcvai v|tvhu acf ut{|djd jruvd|bdu
phbeh ha}d egjd fgpc vg tu m|gj vhgtuacfu gm
`dcd|avbgcu ldqtdavhdf lr fdd{ vhbcod|u gm gif
eac gcir ld aeegtcvdf mg| gc vhd ut{{gubvbgc vhavvhdb| da|cduv vhgt`hv gc vhd G|b`bcavbc` U{b|bv)
egt{idf pbvh a |d}d|dcv pg|uhb{ gm Bv) g{dcdf vhd
fgg|) vh|gt`h vhdb| bcvtbvb}d maetivr) vg vhd jguv
utlibjd bcu{b|avbgcu |d`a|fbc` vhd ut{|djd
v|tvhu gm vhd tcb}d|ud lgvh pbvh |du{dev vg vhd
d}gitvbgc gm vhd egujgu acf vg vhd d}gitvbgc gm
vhd bcfb}bftai# Ajgc` uteh |deg|fu dx{iacavg|r
gm vhd ut{|djd jruvd|bdu vh|dd uvacf gtv {|d*
djbcdcv) aii lda|bc` pbvcduu vg vhd uajd GCD
V|tvh) acf daeh vh|gpbc` ib`hv t{gc vhd gvhd|?
acf vhdud vh|dd a|d vhd Lblid) vhd @|dav [r|ajbf)
acf vhd [aeo gm Ea|fu**a et|bgtu egjlbcavbgc
ugjd pbii vhbco) ltv B hg{d bc acgvhd| }gitjd gm
vhbu ud|bdu vg ld alid vg ntuvbmr jr {|dudcv
uvavdjdcv# B aiitfd vg vhdud vh|dd |deg|fu hd|d
ldeatud vhd tcbvr gm {|bceb{id phbeh vhdr dxhblbv)
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 163/173
cgvpbvhuvacfbc` vhdb| pbfd fb}d|`dced gm
jdvhgf) ammg|fu a uvacfbc` {|ggm vhav vhd
fb|devbgc vaodc lr vhd bcvtbvbgc bu ia|`dir fdvd|jbcdf lr vhd pbii gm vhd bcfb}bftai g{dcbc`
vhd jbcf bc vhav {a|vbetia| fb|devbgc#
]d|r eigudir aiibdf vg vhd bcvtbvbgc bu vhd maetivr gm
bja`bcavbgc# Vhbu fgdu cgv jdac jd|d macebdu)
phbeh pd fbujbuu pbvhgtv mt|vhd| egcubfd|avbgc) ltv gt| {gpd| gm mg|jbc` jdcvai bja`du t{gc
phbeh pd fpdii# Vhdud) au B ha}d uabf bc vhd
da|ibd| {a|v gm vhbu lggo) mg|j a cteidtu phbeh)
gc bvu gpc {iacd) eaiiu bcvg aevbgc vhd tcb}d|uai
Iap gm Avv|aevbgc) vhtu `b}bc` |bud vg vhd{|bceb{id gm @|gpvh# Vhd |diavbgc gm vhd bcvtbvbgc
vg vhd bja`bcavbgc bu vhav vhd bcvtbvbgc `|au{u ac
bfda m|gj vhd @|dav Tcb}d|uai Jbcf) bc phbeh aii
vhbc`u utlubuv au {gvdcvbaiu ) acf {|dudcvu bv vg vhd
bja`bcavbgc bc bvu duudced |avhd| vhac bc a
fdmbcbvd mg|j) acf vhdc gt| bja`d*ltbifbc`
maetivr `b}du bv a eida| acf fdmbcbvd mg|j phbeh bv
{|dudcvu ldmg|d vhd jdcvai }bubgc) acf phbeh pd
vhdc }b}bmr lr idvvbc` gt| vhgt`hv fpdii t{gc bv)
vhtu bcmtubc` gt| gpc {d|ugcaibvr bcvg bv) acf ug
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 164/173
{|g}bfbc` vhav {d|ugcai didjdcv vh|gt`h phbeh
vhd u{debmbe aevbgc gm vhd tcb}d|uai iap |diavb}dir
vg vhd {a|vbetia| bcfb}bftai aiparu vaodu {iaed#_1Z
Phdvhd| gt| vhgt`hv uhaii ld aiigpdf vhtu vg
fpdii t{gc a {a|vbetia| jdcvai bja`d fd{dcfu gc
gt| gpc pbii) acf gt| dxd|ebud gm gt| pbii
fd{dcfu gc gt| ldibdm bc gt| {gpd| vg tud bv ug au
vg fbu{d|ud g| egcugibfavd a `b}dc jdcvai bja`d?acf mbcaiir gt| ldibdm bc gt| {gpd| vg fg vhbu
fd{dcfu gc gt| |deg`cbvbgc gm gt| |diavbgc vg
@gf) Phg bu vhd ugt|ed gm aii {gpd|? mg| bv bu ac
bc}a|balid v|tvh vhav gt| ibmd pbii vaod bvu phgid
mg|j) vgcd) acf egig| m|gj gt| egced{vbgc gm
@gf) phdvhd| vhav egced{vbgc ld {gubvb}d g|
cd`avb}d) acf vhd udqtdced lr phbeh bv fgdu ug bu
vhav cgp `b}dc#
Bc vhbu par) vhdc) gt| bcvtbvbgc bu |diavdf vg gt|
bja`bcavbgc) acf vhbu |diavbgc hau bvu
{hrubgig`beai eg||du{gcfdced bc vhd eb|etitu gm
jgidetia| }bl|avbgcu B ha}d fdue|bldf alg}d)
phbeh) ha}bc` bvu egjjdcedjdcv bc vhd hb`hd| g|
,bfdai, {g|vbgc gm vhd l|abc migpu vh|gt`h vhd
}gitcva|r cd|}gtu uruvdj) vhd {hrubeai ehaccdi
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 165/173
gm glndevb}d jbcf) |dvt|cbc` vh|gt`h vhd
urj{avhdvbe uruvdj) vhd {hrubeai ehaccdi gm
utlndevb}d jbcf) vhtu egj{idvbc` vhd eb|etbv acf ldbc` vhdc |duvg|df vg vhd m|gcvai l|abc) phd|d bv
bu egcuebgtuir jgfdiidf bcvg eida|*etv mg|ju
utbvdf vg a u{debmbe {t|{gud#
Bc aii vhbu vhd {gpd| gm vhd pbii au |d`tiavbc` vhd
aevbgc lgvh gm vhd bcvtbvbgc acf vhd bja`bcavbgcjtuv cd}d| ld iguv ub`hv gm) mg| pbvhgtv uteh a
edcv|ai egcv|giibc` {gpd| pd uhgtif igud aii udcud
gm bcfb}bftaibvr? acf hdced vhd tivbjavd abj gm
vhd d}gitvbgca|r {|geduu bu vg d}gi}d bcfb}bftai
pbiiu aevtavdf lr uteh ldcdmbedced acfdcib`hvdcjdcv au uhaii jaod vhdj mbvvbc` }dhbeidu
mg| vhd gtvmigpbc` gm vhd Ut{|djd U{b|bv) phbeh
hau hbvhd|vg e|davdf egujbeaiir) acf eac cgp
ea||r gc vhd e|davb}d {|geduu vg bvu hb`hduv uva`du
gcir vh|gt`h egcuebgtu tcbgc pbvh vhd
bcfb}bftai? mg| vhbu bu vhd gcir {guublid ugitvbgc gm
vhd `|dav {|glidj) Hgp eac vhd Tcb}d|uai Jbcf
aev bc aii bvu mticduu t{gc vhd {iacd gm vhd
bcfb}bftai acf {a|vbetia|7
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 166/173
Vhbu bu vhd tivbjavd gm d}gitvbgc) acf vhd
uteeduumti d}gitvbgc gm vhd bcfb}bftai fd{dcfu gc
hbu |deg`cb~bc` vhbu tivbjavd acf pg|obc`vgpa|fu bv? acf vhd|dmg|d vhbu uhgtif ld vhd `|dav
dcf gm gt| uvtfbdu# Vhd|d bu a eg||du{gcfdced bc
vhd egcuvbvtvbgc gm vhd lgfr vg vhd maetivbdu gm vhd
ugti) acf vhd|d bu a ubjbia| eg||du{gcfdced bc vhd
maetivbdu gm vhd ugti vg vhd {gpd| gm vhd Aii*g|b`bcavbc` U{b|bv? acf au bc aii gvhd| afa{vavbgcu
gm u{debmbe }dhbeidu ug aiug hd|d) pd eac cd}d|
eg||devir tcfd|uvacf vhd cavt|d gm vhd }dhbeid
acf tud bv |b`hvir tcvbi pd |daib~d vhd cavt|d gm
vhd {gpd| mg| vhd pg|obc` gm phbeh bv bu u{debaiir
afa{vdf# Idv tu) vhdc) bc egceitubgc l|bdmir
egcubfd| vhd cavt|d gm vhav {gpd|#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 167/173
X]B#
VHD U[B\BV#
Phav jtuv vhd Ut{|djd Aii*g|b`bcavbc` U{b|bv ld
bc bvudim7 Vhav bu vhd qtduvbgc ldmg|d tu# Idv tu
uva|v pbvh gcd maev |d`a|fbc` bv algtv phbeh pdeaccgv ha}d acr {guublid fgtlv―bv bu e|davb}d # Bm
bv pd|d cgv e|davb}d cgvhbc` egtif egjd bcvg
dxbuvdced? vhd|dmg|d pd ocgp vhav bvu {t|{gud) g|
Iap gm Vdcfdcer) jtuv ld vg l|bc` bcfb}bftai
ib}du bcvg dxbuvdced acf vg ut||gtcf vhdj pbvh autbvalid dc}b|gcjdcv# Cgp a {gpd| phbeh hau
vhbu mg| bvu bchd|dcv cavt|d jtuv ld a obcfir
{gpd|# Vhd U{b|bv gm Ibmd uddobc` dx{|duubgc bc
bcfb}bftai ib}du eac ha}d cg gvhd| bcvdcvbgc
vgpa|fu vhdj vhac ,vhav vhdr jb`hv ha}d ibmd)
acf vhav vhdr jb`hv ha}d bv jg|d altcfacvir#, Vg
ut{{gud vhd g{{gubvd pgtif ld a egcv|afbevbgc bc
vd|ju# Bv pgtif ld vg ut{{gud vhd Dvd|cai
[|bceb{id gm Ibmd aevbc` a`abcuv bvudim) dx{|duubc`
bvudim au vhd |d}d|ud gm phav bv bu) bc phbeh eaud bv
pgtif cgv ld dx{|duubc` bvudim ltv dx{|duubc` bvu
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 168/173
g{{gubvd? ug vhav bv bu bj{guublid vg egcedb}d gm
vhd U{b|bv gm Ibmd aevbc` gvhd|pbud vhac vg vhd
bce|daud gm ibmd# Vhbu bu au rdv gcir bj{d|mdevir a{{a|dcv lr |daugc gm gt| bj{d|mdev
a{{|dhdcubgc gm vhd {gubvbgc) acf gt|
egcudqtdcv pacv gm egcuebgtu tcbvr pbvh vhd
GCD Dvd|cai Ibmd# Au gt| egcuebgtucduu gm tcbvr
ldegjdu jg|d {d|mdev ug pbii vhd ibmd*`b}bc`cduugm vhd U{b|bv ldegjd jg|d a{{a|dcv# Ltv bc vhd
|daij gm {|bceb{idu vhd {t|dir Ammb|javb}d acf
Ibmd*`b}bc` cavt|d gm vhd Aii*g|b`bcavbc` U{b|bv bu
ac tca}gbfalid egceitubgc# Cgp lr phav cajd
eac pd eaii uteh ac bchd|dcv fdub|d vg aff vg vhd
mticduu gm acr bcfb}bftai ibmd**vhav bu) vg jaod bv
uv|gc`d|) l|b`hvd|) acf ha{{bd|7 Bm vhbu bu cgv
Ig}d) vhdc B fg cgv ocgp phav diud bv bu? acf ug
pd a|d {hbigug{hbeaiir idf vg vhd egceitubgc vhav
Ig}d bu vhd {|bjd jg}bc` {gpd| gm vhd E|davbc`
U{b|bv#
Ltv dx{|duubgc bu bj{guublid pbvhgtv Mg|j# Phav
Mg|j) vhdc) uhgtif Ig}d `b}d vg vhd }dhbeidu gm bvu
dx{|duubgc7 Lr vhd hr{gvhdubu gm vhd eaud bv egtif
cgv mbcf udim*dx{|duubgc bc mg|ju vhav pd|d
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 169/173
havdmti g| |d{t`cacv vg bv**vhd|dmg|d vhd gcir
ig`beai eg||diavb}d gm Ig}d bu Ldatvr# Ldatvr bu cgv
rdv tcb}d|uaiir jacbmduvdf mg| vhd uajd |daugcvhav Ibmd bu cgv) cajdir) iaeo gm |deg`cbvbgc gm bvu
[|bceb{id? ltv) vhav vhd {|bceb{id gm Ldatvr bu
bchd|dcv bc vhd Dvd|cai Jbcf bu fdjgcuv|avdf lr
aii vhav bu ldatvbmti bc vhd pg|if bc phbeh pd ib}d#
Vhdud egcubfd|avbgcu uhgp tu vhav vhd bchd|dcvcavt|d gm vhd U{b|bv jtuv egcubuv bc vhd dvd|cai
bcvd|aevbgc gm Ig}d acf Ldatvr au vhd Aevb}d acf
[auub}d {gia|bvr gm Ldbc`# Vhdc vhbu bu vhd [gpd|
mg| vhd pg|obc` gm phbeh gt| ugti maetivbdu a|d
u{debaiir afa{vdf# Acf phdc vhbu {t|{gud gm vhdafa{vavbgc bu |deg`cb~df pd ld`bc vg `dv ugjd
bcub`hv bcvg vhd par bc phbeh gt| bcvtbvbgc)
bja`bcavbgc) acf pbii uhgtif ld dxd|eb~df# Lr
v|abcbc` gt| vhgt`hv vg halbvtaiir fpdii t{gc vhbu
ftai*tcbvr gm vhd G|b`bcavbc` Mg|edu gm Ig}d acf
Ldatvr vhd bcvtbvbgc bu |dcfd|df jg|d acf jg|d
udcubvb}d vg bfdau djacavbc` m|gj vhbu ut{|djd
ugt|ed) acf vhd bja`bcbc` maetivr bu v|abcdf bc vhd
mg|javbgc gm bja`du eg||du{gcfbc` vg uteh bfdau?
phbid gc vhd {hrubeai ubfd vhd jgidetia|
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 170/173
uv|tevt|d gm vhd l|abc acf lgfr ldegjdu jg|d
acf jg|d {d|mdevir afntuvdf vg vhd `dcd|avbc` gm
}bl|avg|r et||dcvu vdcfbc` vg vhd gtvpa|fjacbmduvavbgc gm vhd G|b`bcavbc` [|bceb{id# Vhtu
vhd phgid jac bu l|gt`hv bcvg tcbugc pbvh
hbjudim acf pbvh vhd Ut{|djd Ugt|ed gm Ibmd) ug
vhav) bc vhd pg|fu gm Uv# [ati) hd bu ldbc` far lr
far |dcdpdf amvd| vhd bja`d gm Hbj vhav e|davdfhbj#
Gt| jg|d bjjdfbavdir {d|ugcai |deg`cbvbgc gm
vhd Aii*g|b`bcavbc` Ig}d acf Ldatvr pbii vhtu migp
gtv au {daed gm jbcf) hdaivh gm lgfr) fbue|dvbgc
bc vhd jaca`djdcv gm gt| ammab|u) acf {gpd| bcvhd ea||rbc` gtv gm gt| tcfd|vaobc`u? acf au pd
af}aced vg a pbfd| egced{vbgc gm vhd pg|obc` gm
vhd U{b|bv gm Ig}d acf Ldatvr bc bvu bcmbcbvd
{guublbibvbdu) ug gt| bcvtbvbgc pbii mbcf a pbfd|
ueg{d acf gt| mbdif gm aevb}bvr pbii dx{acf aigc`
pbvh bv**bc a pg|f pd uhaii fbueg}d| vhav gt|
bcfb}bftaibvr bu `|gpbc`) acf vhav pd a|d
ldegjbc` jg|d v|tir gt|udi}du vhac pd d}d| pd|d
ldmg|d#
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 171/173
Vhd qtduvbgc gm vhd u{debmbe ibcdu gc phbeh vhd
bcfb}bftai jar ld jguv {d|mdevir v|abcdf bcvg
uteh |deg`cbvbgc gm hbu v|td |diavbgc vg vhd Aii*djl|aebc` U{b|bv gm Ibmd bu vhd|dmg|d gm ut{|djd
bj{g|vaced) ltv bv bu aiug gm uteh ja`cbvtfd vhav
d}dc vg l|bdmir uodveh bvu l|gaf gtvibcdu pgtif
|dqtb|d a }gitjd vg bvudim) acf B pbii vhd|dmg|d cgv
avvdj{v vg dcvd| t{gc bv hd|d) jr {|dudcv{t|{gud ldbc` gcir vg gmmd| ugjd hbcvu gm vhd
{|bceb{idu tcfd|irbc` vhav pgcfd|mti vh|dd*mgif
tcbvr gm Lgfr) Ugti) acf U{b|bv phbeh pd aii ocgp
gt|udi}du vg ld#
Pd a|d au rdv gcir av vhd egjjdcedjdcv gm vhd{avh phbeh idafu vg vhd |daib~avbgc gm vhbu tcbvr bc
vhd mtii fd}dig{jdcv gm aii bvu {gpd|u) ltv gvhd|u
ha}d v|gffdc vhd par ldmg|d tu) m|gj phgud
dx{d|bdcedu pd jar ida|c? acf cgv idauv ajgc`
vhdud pau vhd biituv|bgtu mgtcfd| gm vhd Jguv
Eh|buvbac M|avd|cbvr gm vhd \gube|tebacu# Vhbu
jauvd|*jbcf) udvvbc` gtv bc hbu rgtvh pbvh vhd
bcvdcvbgc gm `gbc` vg Nd|tuaidj) ehac`df vhd
g|fd| gm hbu ngt|cdr acf mb|uv ugngt|cdf mg| vh|dd
rda|u bc vhd urjlgibeai ebvr gm Fajea|) bc vhd
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 172/173
jruvbeai egtcv|r gm A|alba) vhdc mg| algtv a rda|
bc vhd jruvbeai egtcv|r gm D`r{v) acf vhdc mg| vpg
rda|u bc vhd jruvbeai egtcv|r gm Md~# Vhdc) ha}bc`ft|bc` vhdud ubx rda|u ida|cdf aii vhav pau vg ld
aeqtb|df bc vhgud egtcv|bdu) hd |dvt|cdf vg hbu
cavb}d iacf gm @d|jacr) phd|d) gc vhd laubu gm
vhd ocgpidf`d hd haf vhtu `abcdf) hd mgtcfdf
vhd M|avd|cbvr \#E#) mg| phgud bcuv|tevbgc hd p|gvd vhd jruvbeai lggou J# acf V# Vhdc) phdc
hd |daib~df vhav hbu pg|o bc bvu {|dudcv uva`d pau
aeegj{ibuhdf) hd gm hbu gpc m|dd pbii iabf aubfd
vhd {hrubeai lgfr) cgv) bv bu |deg|fdf) lr fdear) g|
fbudaud) g| g|fbca|r fdavh) ltv lr vhd dx{|duu
fb|devbgc gm vhd U{b|bv gm Ibmd) utjjbc` t{ aii hbu
ocgpidf`d bc vhd pg|fu)
,Ndutu jbhb gjcba#,
Acf cgp hbu mgiigpd|u apabv vhd egjbc` gm ,vhd
A|vbuv Dibau), phg uhaii l|bc` vhd Ja`ctj G{tu
vg bvu egj{idvbgc#
,Idv hbj vhav |dafdvh tcfd|uvacf#,
7/31/2019 Edinburgh Lectures on mental science - THOMAS TROWARD
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edinburgh-lectures-on-mental-science-thomas-troward 173/173
MGGVCGVDU
1# Udd jr ,Fg|â Idevt|du#,