ECAPOV Today & Tomorrow

By Victor SullaJune, 6 2013

Objectives

This presentation introduces…

ECAPOV Now… (Where we are standing) ECAPOV Soon… (What is in progress) ECAPOV Tomorrow… (Future plans) Ideas and requirements Discussion

ECAPOV Team

Mariam Lomaia – Data processing and analysis

Julia Duhno – ADP data processing

Helena Makarenko – Website, DDP Data uploading

Jose Montes – HOI/Labor work

Guidance Goao Pedro Azavedo Wagner Carolina Sanchez Paramo

ECAPOV Now ECA hub for regional poverty analysis.

Survey Repository and source for micro data standardization in the region (within the Bank).

The main source for poverty, social labor market indicators for ECA region.

Source for POVCALNET, DDI, WBI, ADP data platform, WDR as well as various Analytical projects ESW, PSIA for DPOs.

In God we trust. All others must bring data…

ECAPOV NowECAPOV - ECA poverty monitoring project provides vital assistance for cross-country analysis of poverty and social developments in the ECA region.

- Wide range of statistics (Adept and Pivot tables)- Standardized welfare aggregates and data standardization

- Regional poverty updates and monitoring

ECA DATABANK contains microdata raw data, processed data, and available documentation for:

479 households’ surveys from 27 ECA countries 380 standardized household surveys (HBS and LFS) Over 300 standardized Firm level surveys (Amadeus) EU-SIlC, LITs, EU-LFS, other specializing surveys

"I've given you an unlimited budget, and you have already exceeded it!"

HBS StandardizedCountry 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004  2005  2006 2007  2008 2009 2010 2011

Albania     LSMS LSMS LSMS  LSMS     LSMS      

Armenia DHS ILCS ILCS  ILCS  ILCS ILCS ILCS ILCS ILCS ILCS ILCS  ILCS

Azerbaijan MICS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS     LSMS   LSMS  

Belarus HBS HBS HHS HHS HHS HHS HHS HHS HHS HHS HHS HHS

Bosnia & Herzegovina

MICS LSMS    

HBS/

  MICS HBS        LSMS

Bulgaria   BIHS/IES   BIHS/IES     BIHS IHS     CMS  

Czech Rep.                        

Croatia     HBS HBS HBS       HBS HBS HBS  

Estonia HBS HBS  HBS HBS HBS               

Georgia HBS HBS  HBS HBS HBS  HBS  HBSHBS/

HBS HBS HBS HBSLSMS

Hungary HBS HBS  HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS        

Kazakhstan   HBS  HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS  

Kosovo LSMS   HBS HBS HBS  HBS  HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS

Kyrgyz Republic HBS HBS  HBS HBS/HIES HIES  HBS  HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS

Latvia HBS   HBS HBS HBS      HBS HBS HBS HBS  

Lithuania HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS        HBS      

Macedonia HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS  HBS   HBS HBS HBS HBS

MoldovaHBS/

HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS  HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBSMICS

Montenegro     HHS HHS HHS HBS  HBS HBS  HBS  HBS HBS HBS

Poland HBS HBS HBS HBS  HBS  HBS HBS  HBS  HBS   HBS   HBS  HBS

Romania HBS/LCS HBS/LCS HBS/LCS  HBS  HBS  HBS  HBS  HBS  HBS  HBS HBS HBS

Russia HBS/RLMS HBS/RLMS HBS/RLMSHBS/RLMS/

NOBUSHBS/RLMS HBS/RLMS HBS/RLMS HBS/RLMS HBS/RLMS HBS/RLMS    

Serbia     HPS HBS HBS HBS HBSHBS/

HBS HBS HBS  LSMS

Slovak Rep.         HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS    

Slovenia     HBS HBS HBS               

Tajikistan MICS     LSMS THES MICS   LSMS   LSMS    

Turkey   HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS  

Ukraine HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS HBS

UzbekistanHBS/

  HBS HBS                 MICS

Labor Force Surveys

 Country  2000 2001 2002  2003  2004  2005  2006 2007  2008 2009 2010 2011

Albania               LFS LFS      Armenia                           Azerbaijan                        Belarus                        

Bosnia & Herzegovina             LFS   LFS LFS LFS  

Bulgaria LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS  Czech Rep. LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS  Croatia   LFS LFS LFS LFS       LFS      Estonia LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS  Georgia                           Hungary LFS LFS  LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS  Kazakhstan                    LFS LFS    Kosovo     LFS LFS LFS  LFS     LFS      

Kyrgyz Republic                        

Latvia LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS  Lithuania LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS  Macedonia LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS          Moldova LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS    Montenegro         LFS LFS      LFS LFS LFS  LFSPoland LFS LFS LFS LFS  LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS  Romania LFS LFS LFS LFS  LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS  Russia     LFS                     Serbia   LFS             LFS LFS LFS LFSSlovak Rep. LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS  Slovenia LFS LFS LFS LFS  LFS  LFS  LFS  LFS  LFS  LFS  LFS   Tajikistan                        Turkey LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS LFS  Ukraine   LFS      LFS LFS LFS LFS    LFS    Uzbekistan                   .      

Latest available dataCountry Type, year, avail. Country Type, year, avail.

Albania LSMS 2008 Lithuania HBS 2008

Armenia ILCS 2011 Macedonia HBS 2011

Azerbaijan LSMS 2010 Moldova HBS 2011

Belarus HHS 2011 Montenegro HBS 2009

Bosnia & Herzegovina HBS 2007 Poland HBS 2011

Bulgaria HIS 2007 Romania HBS 2011

Croatia HBS 2010 Russia HBS 2009

Czech Rep. PHC 2001 Serbia HBS 2010

Estonia HBS 2004 Slovak Rep. HBS 2009

Georgia HBS 2011 Slovenia HBS 2004

Hungary HBS 2007 Tajikistan LSMS 2008

Kazakhstan HBS 2010 Turkmenistan DHS 2000

Kosovo HBS 2011 Turkey HBS 2010

Kyrgyz Republic HBS 2011 Ukraine HBS 2010

Latvia HBS 2010 Uzbekistan HBS 2003

Repository Households’ Budget Surveys and Labor Force surveys (total

480)

EU – SILC – Three rounds of the surveys covering 10 ECA countries members of EU and other developed countries in the region

EU-LFS – the database of standardized EU labor force surveys covering 10 ECA and other developed countries in the region

LITs – life in transition surveys. Two rounds of the surveys covering 30 ECA countries

Other specializing surveys - Rapid Response, Migration surveys, time use surveys and others specializing surveys done in the region

What is harmonized?RosterConsumption ModuleLabor ModuleEducation ModuleSocial ProtectionUtilities and Energy useNewIncome module HOI variables (recent years)Migration module (recent years)

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Standardization Procedure: Consumption Aggregates (main welfare indicators)

• Use current consumption per capita

• Uniform approach to correct for inflation and regional price differences

• Uniform cleaning/correction for outliers

• Use standard classification by items (COICOP)

• Exclude rental payments (issues of imputation), health-care and all durables purchases (lumpy expenditures)

ECA DATABANK Archive

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Standardization Procedure: Consumption Components of the consumption aggregate(1) Food (purchase and in kind)(2) Alcohol Tobacco(3) Cloth/Foot ware(4) Utilities(5) Housing(6) Health (calculated but not included)(7) Transportation(8) Communication(9) Recreation(10) Education(11) Restaurants(12) Miscellaneous(13) Durables (calculated but not included)(14) Rents (calculated but not included, no

imputation)

ECA DATABANK Archive

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(2) Household and individual characteristics (education, health, employment) and non-income indicators (water) uniformly defined and linked to consumption poverty

(3) International poverty lines of $PPP2.5 (poverty) and $PPP5.0 (vulnerability) per capita per day used with 2005 ICP (as in ECAPOV2); poverty lines updated using CPI.

(4) Income sources from wage (employee and self-employed) , agricultural income, social assistance, property and other.

ECA DATABANK Archive

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Standardized modules currently available• Household Roster• Consumption• Labor• Income• Education• Health• Housing• Infrastructure• Land-use• Location

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Standardized modules available• Roster• Consumption• Labor• Income• Education• Health• Housing• Infrastructure• Land use• Location

ECA DATABANK Archive

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Standardized modules available• Roster• Consumption• Labor• Income• Education• Health• Housing• Infrastructure• Land use• Location

ECA DATABANK Archive

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Standardized modules available• Roster• Consumption• Labor• Income • Education• Health• Housing• Infrastructure• Land use• Location

ECA DATABANK Archive

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Standardized modules available• Roster• Consumption• Labor• Income• Education• Health• Housing• Infrastructure• Land use• Location

ECA DATABANK Archive

Total income

Other income

Wage income

Social assistance

Remittances

Pension

Child and family benefits

Unemployment benefit

Income from property - interests, capital, land

Agricultural income

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Standardized modules available• Roster• Consumption• Labor• Income• Education• Health• Housing• Infrastructure• Land use• Location

ECA DATABANK Archive

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Standardized modules available• Roster• Consumption• Labor• Income• Education• Health• Housing• Infrastructure• Land use• Location

ECA DATABANK Archive

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Standardized modules available• Roster• Consumption• Labor• Income• Education• Health• Housing• Infrastructure• Land use• Location

ECA DATABANK Archive

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Standardized modules available• Roster• Consumption• Labor• Income• Education• Health• Housing• Infrastructure• Land use• Location

ECA DATABANK Archive

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Standardized modules available• Roster• Consumption• Labor• Income• Education• Health• Housing• Infrastructure• Land use• Location

ECA DATABANK Archive

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

(1) Currently standardized modules• Roster• Consumption• Labor• Income• Education• Health• Housing• Infrastructure• Land use• Location

ECA DATABANK Archive

Overview

Goals

Major activities

Inventory

Standardization

Modules

Policy of data release

Dissemination

Data Access Policy and Release

Each survey in the archive has sharing policy agreed with client-countries:

• In public domain - free to share with everybody (a few LSMS)

• Can share within the World Bank • Can share upon country team approval• Can not share outside ECAPOV team• Fully restricted• Other restrictions on sharing

ECA DATABANK Archive

Indicators produced1. Poverty Indicators at regional, national and subnational level (ECAPOV and POVCALNET indicators, $1.25, $2.5 and $5.0)2. Inequality indicators3. Poverty statistics disaggregated by demographics, location, education, labor status4. ADePT poverty outputs for all countries5. Regional maps of poverty for all countries

What’s NEW?

New HBS modules standardizedIncome module (in progress)

Income sources of the populationHOI Module (recent years in progress)

20 variables for human opportunity indicatorsMigration Module

Indicators of migration and identifier of remittancesEnergy Module

Database of Energy indicators used in energy report produced by Caterina Rughery Laderchi

Database of indicators in DDPNew ECA regional database of indicators is available in DDPThe database includes:

1. International and national poverty indicators

2. Inequality indicators3. Poverty by age, gender, education, labor

status4. Composition of the poor

Micro Data Classifications Unrestricted Data

Includes data that is available to the general public outside the Bank.

Internal Data

This data classification includes restricted data used by WB employees but not available to people outside the Bank.

Sensitive/Confidential Data

Includes data not released to anybody besides ECAPOV team or require special permission.

In progress:

Coming soon

- Accelerated Data Program (ADP)- Income, HOI modules- New version of the website- New database of indicators will be shared online

Example: ADP

ADP in collaboration with DECDG. Archiving: Metadata Editor

Compile survey data, documentation and metadata in a standard format (Nesstar/DDI). Free data reader for users.

Built on Nesstar Publisher

Nesstar Explorer Free software Access metadata & data and export to common statistical

formats

IHSN Tools Reporting, diagnostics and other utilities

Future plans (short and medium)ECAPOV short-term target:1.Micro-simulation and projections2.Housing imputation3.Repository of panel data4.Regional poverty update5.New database of social and labor indicators

Future Plans General StrategyDevelop a hub for sharing and dissemination of micro- and macro- indicators in ECA region. Develop tools for data sharing, presentation, and monitoring. Center for regional poverty analysis. •Access to micro data:

– Expand range of micro data with clear mechanism of obtaining the data and sharing

– More detailed harmonized unit record data– Linked and longitudinal datasets– Rich metadata

•Real-time access to indicators• - collection and maintenance of the databases of indicators

•Use of Flexible analytical tools•Automation in dissemination (system-to-system interfaces)•Connection between tools (BOOST, ADePT, BUDDY, Maps, Other tools •Further Develop analytical capacity

Example 1: RAS system• Remote, real-time analysis system for

within and outside the Bank• Access to entire ECAPOV datasets without giving

access to raw data• Confidentiality processes performed on outputs• Complex analysis services• The system could be developed In collaboration

with ADePT team

Example 2: Survey Data Storage Server IT Services should provide space on a dedicated

survey data storage server to WB staff who use ECAPOV Surveys tools.

This server should be accessible via a WB computer. If you are outside the Bank, you must use secure ID in order to access this server.

You can share your space with individuals who have a valid SecurID and password.

You can request ‘workgroup’ space on this server.

Example 3: Sharing and Analysis tools

New data sharing tools Data Analysis Tools

Thank you!