earthquake microinsurance for …icrm.ntu.edu.sg/newsnevents/doc/mirt_froums/documents...kornelius...
TRANSCRIPT
Kornelius Simanjuntak
General Insurance Association of IndonesiaApril 2011
1
EARTHQUAKE MICROINSURANCE FOR INDONESIA
World’s and Indonesia’s EarthquakeEpicenter Map for Earthquake withMagnitude > 5.5 (1964 – 2010)
Almost 20% of Damageable andtsunamigenic Earthquake Occurred inIndonesia.
Earthquake occurrences in Indonesia formagnitude more than 5,0.
Overall, it is rising in number since year of2000.
Histogram: Number of Earthquake in Indonesia from 1965 to April 2009.
EARTHQUAKE HAZARD IN INDONESIA
ECONOMIC LOSSES AND HUMAN CASUALTIES DUE TO EARTHQUAKE 2004 – 2010
Huge losses …… Unprepared communities !!
EVENT DATE PROVINCE MAG. DEATH TOLL
DAMAGED HOUSES
ECONOMIC LOSSES
(Billion IDR)
INSURED LOSSES
(Billion IDR)
Letusan Gunung Merapi 25/10 and 05/11/10 Yogyakarta - 275 2,200 7,300 TBA
Gempa & Tsunami Mentawai 25/11/10 Sumatera Barat 7.7 450 720 NA TBA
Gempa Papua 16/6/10 Papua 7,1 17 3,422 800 16.85
Gempa Aceh 7/4/2010 Aceh 7,2 (USGS 7.7) - Hundreds NA 0.57
Gempa Jambi 1/10/2009 Jambi 7 N.A N.A N.A 0.26
Gempa Padang 30/9/2009 Sumatera Barat 7,6 1,117 279,472 23,000 1,475.59
Gempa Tasikmalaya 2/9/2009 Jawa Barat 7,3 81 225,051 8,790 45.81
Gempa Talaud 11/2/2009 Sulawesi Utara 7,2 1 1,400 NA 0.05
Gempa Manokwari 4/1/2009 Papua Barat 7,6 4 6,200 300 4.94
Gempa Gorontalo 17/11/2008 Gorontalo 7.3 4 2,300 400 0.69
Gempa Sumbawa 7/8/2008 Nusa Tenggara Barat 6,6 - 1,000 NA 7.14
Gempa Bengkulu 12 and 13/09/2007 Bengkulu 8,4 dan 7,9 25 59,000 1,500 55.21
Gempa Padang 6/3/2007 Sumatera Barat 6,2 68 43,000 1,470 38.08 Gempa & TsumaniPangandaran 17/7/2006 Jawa Barat 6,8 683 2,500 550 2.43
Gempa Yogyakarta 27/5/2006 Yogyakarta 5,9 5,716 414,000 31,000 325.37
Gempa dan tsunami Aceh 26/12/2004 Aceh 9,3 220,000 120,000 45,000 629.31
Source : BNPB, Bappenas, Media, World Bank, UNDP, MAIPARK
POST-DISASTER SPENDING 2001 - 2007
SOURCE: MINISTRY OF FINANCE, REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA
-
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
2001 2002 2004 2005 2006 2007
67 4 15
176
1,278
1,112
In Million USD
PRE-DISASTER SPENDING 2001-2007
-
50
100
150
200
250
300
2001 2002 2004 2005 2006 2007
62
97 114
136
232
262
SOURCE: MINISTRY OF FINANCE , REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA
In Million USD
8
The increasing tendency of government spending in pre- and post-disaster reliefalready create heavy burden to the state
budget.
It is therefore imperative that Indonesia should be able to perform more efficiently in
risk management performances.
Until now, all responsibility to finance the rehab-recon is in the Government
Society of all level should be made eager to prepare themselves against disaster
9
Microinsurance as a tool for homeowners and even the low
income to protect themselves against disaster risk
Insurance through its risk transfer mechanism provide a better alternative in disaster risk
financing
12
Value of Indonesia BuildingOverlayed with EQ events (1599 – Present)
Shallow EQIntermediate EQDeep EQ
10n IDR
Insurance penetration 2% of GDPInsurance bureau of Indonesia (2010)
13
Only 1,2% of Insured properties have EQ cover
PT. Asuransi MAIPARK Indonesia (2008 – 2010)
Alternatives of Insurance to be used in National Disaster Mitigation
14
A. National Disaster Insurance SchemeThe government insuring homeowners or its liability toprovide aid against disaster
B. MicroinsuranceEncourage society to invest in pre-disaster mitigation using(micro)insurances
16
A. National Disaster InsuranceScheme; Earthquake
- Government work together with InsuranceIndustry (PPP)
- Providing insurance cover for allhomeowners/householders in the country (orselected areas)
- Protection for state budget
NATIONAL EARTHQUAKE INSURANCE SCHEME
Features of Required Earthquake Insurance Scheme:
◦ The crux of the matter:Quick response to asses the damage (within two weeks after the area is “declared” accessible)Quick claims payment (two weeks after assessment)
• Deployment of nation wide insurance network necessary
• Strong local and international capacity needed
Insurance Industry through its representative, PT Asuransi MAIPARK Indonesia which is owned by all general insurance and reinsurance companies in
Indonesia, have prepared a product suitable for the national insurance scheme
The Product called : Jaminan Tunai RisikoGempa Bumi Indonesia - JTRGBI (Cash
Program for Earthquake Risk of Indonesia)
18
19
JAMINAN TUNAI RISIKO GEMPA BUMI INDONESIA (JTRGBI)
The Insured = The Government (central and/or local Government)
Insurer = General Insurance Industry represented by MAIPARK
JTRGBI low cost, simple administration, quick claim payment
20
Risks Covered :• Earthquake• Volcanic Eruption• Tsunami• Fire Following Earthquake
Insurable Property :All tax-registered dwelling houses in therelated administrative area
Limit of PaymentCATEGORY POINT ASSESSMENT CLAIM
PAYMENT *
Totally/Heavily Damaged > 50 IDR 15 mio
Medium Damaged 26 < Point < 50 IDR 10 mio
Lightly Damage 5 < Point < 25 IDR 2,5 mio
21
* Claim Payment limit is customable and prepared to meet specific requirement of the
government (or local government)
Detail of Construction Prosentase (%) PointPillar: 1 – 5 4
Ratio between number of damaged pillar to total pillar
6 – 10 811 – 20 1621 ‐ 30 2431 ‐ 40 32
More than 40 40Foundation: 1 ‐5 3
Ratio between length of damaged foundation to total length of foundation
6 ‐ 10 611 ‐ 25 1226 ‐ 40 1841 ‐ 50 24
More than 50 30Wall: 1 ‐ 5 2.5
Ratio between area of damaged wall to total area of wall
6 ‐ 20 521 ‐ 40 1041 ‐ 60 15
More than 60 20Roof: 1 ‐ 5 1
Ratio between area of damaged roof to total area of roof
6 ‐ 20 2.521 ‐ 40 541 ‐ 60 7.5
More than 60 10Total Point
Damage Classification:Light Damage
Medium DamageHeavy Damage
Damaged Assessment Table is adopted and adjusted from the same method used by the Japan Earthquake Reinsurance Company (JER).
Damage assessment will be conducted only by trained and certified assessors
Damage Assessment Check-list
24
+ Claim payment = actual losses
- Need long time to asses losses (months)
- Need a lot of assessors.- Moral hazard (aggravated claims).
Advantages and Disadvantages
INDEMNITY BASIS
+ Claim payment can be made quickly (2 – 4 weeks)
+ Objective Assessment
- Basis Risk (The insured suffered actual losses but no claim payable as the cover is not triggered)
PARAMETRIC METHOD
25
JTRGBI; Loss Assessment
Satellite Imagery and/or Cat Model calculation of first/Interim payment
Quick Assessment by certified assessors calculation of final claim payment
29
Claim Payment
Combined method allows insurer to make very quick claimpayment
First/Interim payment will be available within 3 weeks afterdisaster. The calculation based on satellite imagery and Cat.Modeling
Final calculation of claim will be based on field lossassessment by certified assessors, and claim will be payablewithin 3 months after the disaster affected area declared tobe accessible
30
Claim Payment
Claim payment will be addressed to the Government as the insured
Claim payment received by the Government distributed to the victims as cash aid for rehabilitation and reconstruction program
MAIPARK
Central and ProvincialGovernment
MAIPARK and IndonesianInsurance /Reinsurance Companies
•Munich Re•Swiss Re•ACR•AON-Benfield
A Full Applications of the PPP Principle and the Corporate Social Responsibility
TACTIC AND STRATEGY
PROGRESSMAIPARK has been in involved in discussions on DwellingHouse Earthquake Insurance Scheme between Government,World Bank and Asian Development Bank since severalyears ago.
Earthquake Insurance Scheme on dwelling houses has beenintensively discussed between Indonesia General InsuranceAssociation (AAUI) and National Agency for DisasterManagement - BNPB (since 2007)
The implementation of EQ insurance scheme was delayeddue to the Government lack of legal basis to use statebudget to buy commercial insurance
PROGRESS …………….… continued
At this time, MAIPARK and AAUI are having intensivediscussions with the Ministry of Finance to prepare aCatastrophe Insurance Scheme to protect state budgetholistically and integratedly (not only dwelling houses)
MAIPARK cooperates with AONBenfield, Munich Re, andSwiss Re to prepare the scheme.
35
Microinsurance is insurance characterized by :
low premium and affordable insurance productslow caps or low coverage limits, as a basiccoversold as part of atypical risk-pooling andmarketing arrangementsdesigned to service low-income people andbusinesses not served by typical social orcommercial insurance schemes.
What risks are they concerned about?Country Priority risk
Uganda Illness, death, disability, property loss, risk of loanMalawi Death, food insecurity, illness, educationPhilippines Death, old age, illnessViet Nam Illness, natural disaster, accidents, livestock diseaseIndonesia Illness, children’s education, poor harvestLao P.D.R. Illness, livestock disease, deathGeorgia Illness, business losses, theft, death, retirement income
Ukraine Illness, disability, theftBolivia Illness, death, property loss (including crop loss in rural
areas)Adapted from Cohen and Sebstad (2006)
Disaster risk is not on their priority !!
38
Available Product of Microinsurance in IndonesiaDengue Fever Insurance
Provided by Central Asia InsuranceIndemnify Insured against dengue feverClaim payout limit amounting IDR 2.000.000 with annual premium of IDR 50.000
Flood Insurance - Kartu Perlindungan Siaga Satu Manggarai(KPSSM)
Provided by Wahana Tata InsuranceA PPP project between Wahana Tata, GTZ, and Munich ReParametric Triggered insurance based on water level in Manggaraiwater stationClaim payout limit amounting IDR 250.000 with annual premium of IDR 50.000
39
EQ Microinsurance – New Product
A new Earthquake Insurance Product is being developed. Targeting low income societyAs a basic insurance cover for the low-income society
Introducing : “KARTU GEMPA”
Kartu Gempa provides cover up to IDR 2.000.000 (USD 225) cash payment to its holder whenever earthquake occurs and falls within pre-determined parameter
(shakemap, magnitude, distance, depth)
40
Introducing : “KARTU GEMPA”
41
The InsuredHome owners/householders
CoverageEarthquake (EQ)
Triggering parameter (shakemap, magnitude, distance, depth) is still under research
Product Specification “KARTU GEMPA”
PremiumRetail price for a voucher of KARTU GEMPA is +/- IDR 100.000 (USD 11) …. Fix price is still under researchCover effective for one year periodHomeowner is allowed to have max 5 units KARTU GEMPA
42
Cash payment of IDR 2.000.000 (USD 225) per KARTU GEMPABenefit will be paid if an earthquake occurs and reach the triggering parameterPre-determined Parametric Trigger Max benefit per homeowner is IDR 10.000.000)
43
Benefit
How to Buy and Activate Homeowner buys KARTU GEMPA at retail outletsUsing telephone or SMS (Sort Message Service) homeowner registers and activates the cover (data needed : name, ID card number, risk address, PIN number)After registration process Homeowner will receive confirmation through phone call and/or SMSHome owner keep the voucher card of KARTU GEMPA Homeowners are protected for one year !
44
Distribution ChannelsAll general insurance companiesInsurance agencies and brokersMini marketBuilding material storeHome appliance storeProperty agenciesBanksLocal governmentetc.
45
Claim PaymentCash payment will be paid If an earthquake occur and hit the triggering parameter (based on official report from USGS and/or BMKG – Meteorological, Climatological and Geophysical Agency of Indonesia)Homeowner notifies insurance company through phone call and/or SMS, or otherwise Insurance company will inform homeowner when claim is payable due to an earthquakePayment will be made within 2 weeks after disaster
46