earnings quality slides fsa
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
1/47
Chapter 17: Earnings Quality
T1: Earnings Quality
T2: Earnings management
T3: Cash flow management (Yes)
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
2/47
Page 2
T1: Earnings quality
Earnings quality: The egree to whi!h earnings refle!t unerlying e!onomi! performan!e
Chara!teristi!s of high quality earnings:Transparent: "ery little or nothing is hien (full is!lo
sure)Protecting proprietary information is understood, hiding
other information is less understood
Clearly stated accounting principles as opposed to havi
ng them vaguely definedConsistent
Accounts for similar economic transactions in a similar
manner
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
3/47
Page 3
Earnings quality
Earnings quality means ifferent things to ifferent finan!ial statements users (!onte#tual):$egulators will refer to earnings that ahere to the rules
%n&estors will refer to earnings that are prei!ti&e of futu
re !ash flows'eners will refer to earnings that are !onser&ati&e
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
4/47
Page 4
T2: Earnings management
A company is going through the interview process inorder to hire a new chief financial officer. In the last in
terview session, each of 3 finalists is given the comp
any's financial data and asked, "hat are the net ear
nings!" applicants diligently compute the net earnings. #either of them gets the $o%. &he candidate who
lands the position answers the uestion %y replying,
"hat do you want them to %e!( )loud laugh*
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
5/47
Page 5
Earnings management
ew efinitions of earnings management (E)* purposeful inter&ention in the e#ternal finan!ial reporti
ng purpose+ with the intent of o,taining some pri&ate gain (-!hipper+ 1./.)
The !hoi!e ,y a manager of a!!ounting poli!ies (a!!rual
s)+ or real a!tions+ that affe!t earnings so as to a!hie&e some spe!ifi! reporte earnings o,0e!ti&e
ra!ti!es ,y whi!h earnings reports refle!t the esiresof management rather than the unerlying finan!ial perf
orman!e of the !ompany4 (*rthur 'e&itt+ former -EC Chairman)
*!!oringly+ E often unermines EQ
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
6/47
Page 6
Earnings management
*rthur 'e&itt the num,ers game4 famous spee!h (fo
rmer -EC Chairman+ 1../+ 5Y6 Center for 'aw 8usiness): This pro!ess (E) has e&ol&e o&er the years into what !an ,est
,e !hara!teri9e as a game among maret parti!ipants * game that+ if not aresse soon+ will ha&e a&erse !onsequen!es for *meri!a;s finan!ial reporting system * game that runs !ounter to the
&ery prin!iples ,ehin our maret;s strength an su!!ess4 %n!reasingly+ % ha&e ,e!ome !on!erne that the moti&ation to me
et >>
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
7/47
Page 7
The impa!t of earnings management
Can amage the per!ei&e qualityof reporte earnings$esulting in the ,elief that reporte earnings o not ref
le!t e!onomi! reality
This un!ertainty ultimately has the potential to unermine the effi!ient flow of !apital there,y amaging effi!ient !apital allo!ation
Post+nron, post+financial crisis- Investors reuire large
discounts or withdraw from the stock market
iuidity pro%lems
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
8/47
Page 8
Earnings management
'et?s not ,e 0ust negati&e 5oti!e that earnings management !an ,e goo (really+ YE*)/anagers possess private information, and can use earnin
gs management to convey this information
arnings smoothing to avoid unnecessary costly de%t covenant violation
0 was known for its earnings smoothing practices
nsure investors of ongoing growth
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
9/47
Page 9
%n!enti&es for earnings management
* E#ternal a!tors *nalyst ore!asts (,etter meet or ,eat it) @euristi! 8en!hmars (a tiny profit is way ,etter than a tiny l
oss) A Be!how et al (23) why earnings are Diny4
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
10/47
Page 10
%n!enti&es for earnings management
*symmetry aroun was foun for:
Earnings relati&e to analysts? fore!astEarnings le&el
Earnings !hange
Be,t marets an !ontra!tual o,ligations (,etter not
&iolate e,t !o&enants) Competition (,etter !reate ,arriers to entry)
8 %nternal a!tors
otential mergers (ma#imi9e share pri!e to ,e use in a merger)
lanning an ,ugets (,etter meet the ,uget targets)
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
11/47
Page 11
%n!enti&es for earnings management
C ersonal a!tors
F ersonal ,onuses (@ealy+ 1./G) a
%f earnings are a,o&e the ma#imum for a ,onus or far fro
m the minimum+ ,etter lower earnings this year%f % am within the ,onus range+ then ma#imi9e earnings
romotions an 0o, retention8etter loo an ama9ing CEH
8ig ,ath ,y new CEHs
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
12/47
Page 12
%n!enti&es for earnings management
B oliti!al moti&ations (lower earnings)Buring tariff in&estigation Iones (1..1)
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
13/47
Page 13
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
14/47
Page 14
Jeneral earnings management tools
*!!rualK,ase earnings managementChange a!!ounting poli!ies
lay with estimates
Boes not affe!t !ash flow
anagers !an ,e!ome &ery !reati&e when it !omes to earnings management
*n the Hs!ar for most !reati&e a!!ounting awar goes to>Ieff -illings (Enron?s CEH)
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
15/47
Page 15
$eal earnings management
$eal (transa!tionK,ase) earnings management
Change real ,usiness a!ti&itiesCut 456 and advertising7 offer discounts7
&ime deliveries
8verproduce
Channel stuffing
Aggressive discounts
@as an immeiate effe!t on !ash flows
-hortKterm ,enefit+ ,ut a net negati&e o&erall effe!t
&he soup story
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
16/47
Page 16
$eal earnings management
@ow to sa&e money on Draft Binner K time your gro!
ery shopping to the last ays of the perioLL or soup sales in gro!ery stores+ Chapman an -tee
n,urgh (211) showe that managers use aggressi&e pri!e is!ounts+ feature a&ertisements aisle i
splays towars the en of the quarterMyear* willingness to sa!rifi!e longKterm &alue to meet shortKter
m sales or earnings ,en!hmars
areting a!tions ,oost quarterly net in!ome ,y up to GN
@owe&er+ there is a pri!e to pay: the !ost in the following perio ,eing appro#imately 7GN of quarterly net in!ome
5othing illegal
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
17/47
Page 17
$eal earnings management
ore iffi!ult to un!o&erBoes not &iolate J** (the soup is!ounts)
@ar to prote!t in&estors
@ar to tell the moti&e: a legitimate ,usiness e!ision+ ora shortKterm E mo&e
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
18/47
Page 18
Choi!e of a!!ounting poli!y
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
19/47
Page 19
*!!ounting estimates
reparation of finan!ial statements requires intensi&e use of estimates
Estimates !an ,e neutral+ or>opportunisti! to show a esire out!ome
'oan loss pro&ision in ,ans6seful life of assets
ension assumptions
*sset impairments
Joowill writeKoffs*llowan!e for ou,tful a!!ounts (8om,arier+ 21=+ Q1 2
1G)
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
20/47
Page 20
*nalysis of quality of re&enues
$e&enue re!ognition poli!ies at Oynga?s arti!le
%n groups: Bis!uss the following:
1 Bes!ri,e what Oynga i
2
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
21/47
Page 21
rauulent earnings management
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
22/47
Page 22
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
23/47
Page 23
i!rostrategy (0ust another e#ample)
8a!grounoune in 1./. ,y i!hael -aylor+ that was soon 0oine
,y -an0u 8ansal+ whi!h stuie with him at %T
The !ompany prou!e software for ata mining an ,usiness intelligen!e
%n 1..2+ the !ompany gaine its first ma0or !lient when itsigne a 1 million !ontra!t with !Bonal?s
$e&enues in!rease ,y 1N e&ery year ,etween 1.. an 1..P
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
24/47
Page 24
i!rostrategy
%n ar!h 2+ after a re&iew of its a!!ounting pra!ti!es+ i!ro-trategy announ!e that it woul restate its finan!ial results for pre!eing 2 years
This le to an -EC in&estigation+ an su,sequen
tly to a lawsuit against i!ro-trategy an !ertainof its offi!ials o&er frau was file
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
25/47
Page 25
i!rostrategy
E ra!ti!es: i!ro-trategy;s reporting failures were primarily the result of premature re&enue re!ognition"iolate a!!ounting rules in !ompli!ate transa!tions
i!ro-trategy ha esta,lishe a pattern of ha&ing top e#e!uti&es refrain from signing ma0or !ontra!ts until after the en of ea!h quarter Then they woul sign enough ofthem to ensure meeting re&enue targets
$e&enues were sha&e: 1... K G=m+ 1../ K 11m+ an 1
..7 K 1mAll 3 years turned from profita%le to losing money
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
26/47
Page 26
i!rostrategy
Consequen!es:
*fter it announ!e that it woul restate earnings for 3 years+ its sto! fell 3/N in 1 ay H&erall sto! pri!e roppe from a high of 333 per share to 33 per share
%n *pril 21+ the !ompany settle a !lassK a!tion suit all
eging frau arising from its a!!ounting pra!ti!es3 of its e#e!uti&es at the time of the restatement agree t
o frau in0un!tions an pai penalties of 3G+ ea!hThey also pai a !om,ine total of 1 in isgorgement
The !ompany agree to unertae !orporate go&ernan!e!hanges an implement a system of internal !ontrols
2ave an independent director reporting directly to the 1C )pr
e+18
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
27/47
Page 27
Earnings management hierar!hy
1 Choi!e of a!!ounting poli!ies
2 *ggressi&e a!!ounting estimates A a!!rual earnings management
3 -e!on ,est transa!tions K real earnings manageme
nt= rauulent transa!tions (J** &iolation)
=.
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
28/47
Page 28
%ni!ators of earnings quality
= Qualitati&erofita,le ,usiness moel
Effe!ti&e internal !ontrol systems -HR 32 == is!losure
Quality of the management team
-trong !orporate go&ernan!e
-pe!ial ,usiness e!isions ri&en to a!hie&e esire a!!ounting results (S of -Es+ *)
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
29/47
Page 29
%ni!ators of earnings quality
= Quantitati&e
$elation ,etween (a!!rualK,ase) net in!ome an (!ashK,ase) CH: are a!!ruals too ,ig
&he divergence, remem%er!
*!!ounting oli!y !hoi!es estimates
ersistentM sustaina,le earnings or 0ust oneKtime gainsro forma earning &ery ifferent from J** earnings
6o the reasons seem to make sense!
Earnings quality moels
These are only suggesti&e ini!ators
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
30/47
Page 30
*!!ruals
*!!ruals are funamental in a!!ounting
-u,0e!t to 0ugment an is!retion
The *!!rual *nomaly4 is!o&ere ,y $i!har -loan (1..P): You !an earn a,normal return ,y taing
a short position in the high a!!ruals firms an a long position on the low a!!rual firms*!!ruals are less persistent than !ash flow
%n&estors o not unerstan it
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
31/47
Page 31
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
32/47
Page 32
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
33/47
Page 33
Earnings management an fair &alue
@ow oes fair &alue a!!ounting affe!t earningsmanagement2 opposing ways
/ore earnings management %ecause >>>>>>>>>>>>
ess earnings management %ecause >>>>>>>>>>>>
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
34/47
Page 34
*!!ounting poli!y an estimation
Transparent a!!ounting poli!y is!losure
@ow &ague is it
Che! the re&enue re!ognition poli!y (footnotes)Boes it loo aggressi&e or !onser&ati&e
8a e,t allowan!e:
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
35/47
Page 35
Earnings persisten!e
%f earnings mostly !ome from firms? normal operati
ng ,usiness+ in general+ we shoul see a sta,le tren of earnings o&er years
easure earnings persisten!e
The resiuals from a firm spe!ifi! regression shoul ,e smallYou !an !he! on seasonal quarterly earnings
The closer to 1 is, the more persistence the earnings are
i t f i it
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
36/47
Page 36
ersisten!e of &arious items (sour!e: Be!how+22)
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
37/47
Page 37
-pe!ial ,usiness transa!tions
-E is use to stru!ture &ery !ompli!ate finan!ial transa!tions (Enron)
'eases: * !hange from !apital leases to operatingleases
$elateKparty transa!tions *!!ounts re!ei&a,le sale to ,ans aroun the en
of quarter to polish CH
*ll !an ,e ini!ati&e of low earnings quality
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
38/47
Page 38
8eneish?s earnings manipulation s!ore
K-!ore K=/= U .2 # B-$% U G2/ # J% U == # *Q% U /.2 # -J%U 11G # BE% K 172 # -J*% K 327 # '"J% U =P.7 # T*T*
Bays $e!ei&a,le %ne# (B-$%) (5et $e!ei&a,lestM -alest) M 5et $e!ei&a,lestK1M -
alestK1)
Jross argin %ne# (J%) V(-alestK1K CHJ-tK1) M -alestK1W M V(-alestK CHJ-t) M -ale
stW
*sset Quality %ne# (*Q%) V1 K (Current *ssetstU EtU -e!uritiest) M Total *ssetstW M V1 K ((Current *ssetstK1U EtK1U -e!uritiestK1) M Total *ssetstK1)W
-ales Jrowth %ne# (-J%) -alestM -alestK1Bepre!iation %ne# (BE%) (Bepre!iationtK1M (EtK1U Bepre!iationtK1)) M (Bepre!i
ationtM (EtU Bepre!iationt))
-J* E#pense %ne# (-J*%) (-J* E#pensetM -alest) M (-J* E#pensetK1M -alestK1)
'e&erage ine# ('"J%) V(Current 'ia,ilitiestU Total 'ong Term Be,tt) M Total *ss
etstW M V(Current 'ia,ilitiestK1U Total 'ong Term Be,ttK1) M Total *ssetstK1W
Total *!!ruals to Total *ssets (T*T*) (%n!ome from Continuing HperationstK C
ash lows from Hperationst) M Total *ssetst
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
39/47
Page 39
8eneish?s earnings manipulation s!ore
Ks!oreX K222 ini!ates noearnings manipulation
Ks!ore K222ini!ates earnings manipulation *ll &aria,les are !onstru!te from the finan!ial statem
ents (easy to !al!ulate) * shorter&ersion K-!ore:
K-!ore KPPG U /23 # B-$% U .P # J% U G.3 # *Q%U 717 # -J% U 17 # BE%
Eliminates the less signifi!ant parameters
rof 8eneish ,a!Kteste the moel against finan!ial r
eports release ,y !ompanies in 1./2K.2The K-!ore !orre!tly ientifie 7PN of the manipulations
17GN of falseKpositi&es were returne
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
40/47
Page 40
'et?s e&aluate Jroupon?s earnings quality
Jroupon?s K-!ore of 332G in 21
$estate earnings for 211-hares of Jroupon sun nearly 17N as in&estors rea!te
to a restatement of re&enue figures ,y the offers we,site as well as the !ompany?s amission of material wea
ness4 in its internal !ontrols (inan!ial Times+ *pril+ 2212)
Bo not 0ust apply it me!hani!allyBi&isions of ratios
Bollarama ha a high K-!ore+ ,ut ri&en ,y *$ that was minus!ule (all ratios)
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
41/47
Page 41
T3: Cash flow management
YE-L Cash flow !an also ,e manipulate> ,ut les
s -mart managers now that analystsMin&estors pay
attention to CH an now how to play the game
-ome of it is relate to !lassifi!ation within the statement of !ash flow
-ome is relate to real transa!tions
%t is all legal
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
42/47
Page 42
T3: Cash flow management
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
43/47
Page 43
-tret!h out paya,les
-low own the rate of payments to &enors to impr
o&e CHThis temporary in!rease in CH is unliely to ,e sustaina
,le
The e#tension of paya,les !an ,e ientifie ,y mon
itoring ays? sales in paya,les (B-)B- (Ening *MCHJ-) Z 3PG
Jeneral Ele!tri!: Bays? -ales aya,le
Year ening Be!31 23 22 21 2B- G31 G1G =77 =2
i ,l
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
44/47
Page 44
inan!e paya,les
* !ompany uses a thirKparty finan!ial institutio
n to pay the &enor in the !urrent perio+ with the !ompany then paying ,a! the ,an in a su,sequent perio
BelphiCorporation
"enors
JE CapitalCorp
Hperating !ashoutflow
inan!ing!ash outflow
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
45/47
Page 45
inan!e paya,les
*t the first quarterJE pai the amounts to Belphi?s &enor
Belphi in?t e#pan any !ash
= Then Belphi re!lassifie *M to shortKterm loans
* nonK!ash transa!tion= %n the su,sequent quarter
Belphi pai JE an the !ash outflow was a!!ounte for as a finan!ing a!ti&ity
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
46/47
Page 46
Capitali9ing normal operating e#penses
%t ,oosts operating !ash flow+ ,e!ause normal e#
penses (operating !ash outflows) get shifte to the in&esting se!tion as !apital e#penitures (in&esting !ash outflows)%n real life there are G shaes of grey
-
7/25/2019 Earnings Quality slides FSA
47/47
The happy ening
B%Y earnings management A the %8 !ase
*fter the game: