drum publication group … · ,dr'd.tw>ph.cjrvxysxr shan folklore (karenversion) drum...

Drum Publication Groupusd.w>&RvDRvHmvJ>w>rRu%l>

,dR'd.tw>pH.CJRvXysXRShan Folklore (KarenVersion)

Drum Publication GroupP.O Box 66Kanchanaburi 71000Thailand

[email protected]

May, 2010ISBN 978-616-7225-19-7

iii

v

w>wJcd.wDw>wJcd.wD

zd.CJvXtul.w&H;w>ohw*R 1ydmcGgzdvXtzSD.w*R 4ySRrRn.zd'D;trg 6b.oHvXw>ol.vDo;uGHtCd 8bD.od.0gup> 10,k>vXttD.xJ.ue. 12w>tuh.weXRw>tbsX 14pkrk>'d. 16uqD0g 19n.qH.'X 21rhRwd>yHm 23ch,k>'D;eXRyS> 24q.bkrk> (rh) q.uqD 25ySR*H>ql.tH.[h.vD. 27pd;0.C;vXto;unDRw>oh 29tH.=uD>=[d 31ySRzSD.zdvXto;uGHw>'d.w*R 36tlwh. 38cDzsdvXrhRwzsX.tCd 42eXRyS>'D;trg 42bD.od.wtD.ye>t*h> 43,dR'd.uvkm'l.t*h>tusdRwqH;wuh> 44

w>tD.w>tD 44Õ

w>’hw>tltyD;tvDwz. 45Õ

w>'k.w>xkwz. 45Õ

w>z;qdw>tw>ohw>b.'D;w>'G;qdw> Õ

vXu[JuJxD.o;qlngwz. 46,dR'd.uvkm'l.tw>whw>zsD 47Õ

vi

w>uwdRvXngw>uwdRvXng

,dRuvkm’l.wz.td.qd;0JvXuD>y,DRuvHRpd;wuyRvDRI vX,dRuD>pJ.td.’D;uvkm’l.tguvkmvDRI ySR,dRzdwz.tgwuh>tw>pl>w>emrh>0Jbl;’; w>bgM.vDRI t0Joh.wz.td.’D;vk>v>xloElvXtxl;wDR0J’D; ySRCkxH.oh.ngw>pH.pdRwJpdRwz.wJ0JvXt0Joh.wz.tw>b.xGJtd.’D;ySRuFD.wJ.zd‘D;v.td.zdwz.M.vDRI

usd.w>&RvDRvHmvJ>td.’D;tw>wdmymwz.vXuxk;xD.0Juvkm’l.wz.tw>wJvXysXRwz.vDRI vXvHmzdwbh.tHRtylR< yxXEkmvDR,dRt*h>wpJ;wrSJ;’D;,dRtw>wJzdwz.vDRI ypH;bsK;b.ySRvXtqSXM>ySRw>wJzdwz.vDRI yemvXcDzsdyz;w>wJtCd< u’k;td.xD.w>eDRvDRM>vdmo;w>qJ;w>vR’D;yurRM>tgxD.w>e>yX>vdmo;< w>oh’dol.ymo;wz.M.vDRI

usd.w>&RvDRvHmvJ>ym’d.w>qJ;w>vR’D;rRw>vXurR’d.xD.vJRxD.w>qJ;w>vRtCdcgqlngyuqJ;xk;xD.’H;uvkm’l.t*Rwz.tw>pH.CJRwJCJRwz.M.vDRI

1

,dR'd.tw>pH.CJRvXysXR

zd.CJvXtul.w&H;zd.CJvXtul.w&H;w>ohw*Rw>ohw*R

w>wJ0JvXysXRwbsDzd.CJzSD.oHtd.0Jw*R’D;t0JzSD.wkR’.vJm[ko;vXutD.0Jt*D>r;wtd.vXRb.vDRI tCdb.vk>tD.to;orl’D;CktD.n.vXxHusdylRM.vDRI b.weHRzD.n.wM>eDwbh.b.M>xJ’h.zdwbh.{dRtCd<xXEkm0JqltxX.ylR’D;vJR0Jqlo0DylRvDRI vXusJM.< ySRuGJEkmtDRql[H.ylRb.q.t0JpH;qX ?,b.,d.vXeqDzgutD.uGHm,’h.zdvDRI/ ySReHRb.tDR<?,xd.zdqDzdrh>tD.uGHme’h.zdM.,u[h.uhReRtyORvDR/ 0HR‘D;t0JvJREkmql[H.ylRvDRI

zJySRwxH.tDReDw*Rtcg< t0Jys>vDRclol.’h.zdqlw>ysDvDRI ‘D;zJqDzguD>z;’d.wbh.xH.w>tHR’D;[JCh>ql’h.zdttd.’D;pd;tD.uGHm0JM.vDRI zd.CJym o;’d.xD.to;< tCdySRb.[h.uHGmtDRqDzgvXttD.uGHmt’h.zdM.vDRI

2


t0JpdmxD.qDzg’D;vJRqlo0Dt*RwzsX.M.vDRI zJM.t0JvJRwkR0JvX w>oH t[H.wzsX.’D;ySRud;rHtDRzJM.vDRI

b.q.t0JpH;qX ? wohb.< ,b.,d.vXew>oHpd.utD.uGHm,qDzg/ vDRI zJM.ySRcJvXmeHRb.tDR’D;pH;0J< ?w>pd.wusD.rh>tD.ew>wrHRrHRM.yu[h.vd;uhReRu,J>w>vXeChvDR/

rk>qh.xD.vX*DRcD< ySRqd;oDwz.rHb.o;< t0J[;xD.u,Du,D’D;’doHuGHmtqDzg’D;vJRzSLb.tXqDtql.’D;qDoGH.vXySRoHtrJmo.’D;cl.vDRuGHmtqDvX[D.cd.vm’D;uhRrHuhR0JvDRI

rk>qh.xD.< zJySRud;*R*JRxX.vXvD>rHM.< t0Jp;xD.CkuG>uhRtqDzgvDRI ySR*Rph>uD;CkuG>0J’DeHRngb.q.wxH.0Jb.< b.q.t0Joh.xH.0JvXqDql.’D;qDoGH.b.tXw>oHpd.tx;cd.’D;trJmo.vDRI zd.CJymo;xD.to;’d.’d.uvJm< wJ0JvXuvJRywHxD.w>*h>’D;o0Dcd.M.vDRI ySRtd.zJ[H.ylRwz.ysHRw>’d.r;tCd[h.tDRusd.{dRph{dR’D;rX[;uGHm’D;wb.wJw>eDwrHRb.C;w>*h>0JtHRb.M.vDRI

b.q.zd.CJpH;qX0J< ?erh>[h.,Rw>pd.wusD.M.,uymw>*h>cJvXmvX w>clol.vDRI/ ‘D;ySR[h.vDRtDRM.vDRI zJM.t0J,d;xD.w>pd.’D;vJRu’D;qlo0Dt*RwzsX.vDRI wkRvXySRuG>uqDtusg’D;ySRud;rHtDRzJM.vDRI t0J*h>vdm'D;pH;0J’.<?wohb.< cJuXm< uqDu,D>bH.b.,ySRqgw*RtHRvDRI/

zd.CJoh.ngvXtd.’D;uqD0gw’kvXtusgtCdo;vDb.0J’d.r;tCdul.w&H;xD.w>M.vDRI ySReHRb.tDR’D;wJ0JeysHRw>tvD>wtd.b.< tCdt0JrHzJM.vDRI vXrk>eRcDySRrHb.ySRo;cJvXmtqXuwD>< t0J*JRqXxX.u,Du,D’D;vJRymvDRw>pd.vXuqD0gtuyR 'D;uqDwxH.w>vXrk>eRcDtCd<

3


,D>wH>b.w>pd.vXtcD.M.vDRI wkRrk>qh.xD.uqDtup>zk;oHysD>*D>b.to;zJxH.b.0Jw>pd.vDRI zd.CJph>uD;ymo;’d.xD.to;vDRI wkREkmwpk< uqDup>tX.vDRto;’D;zd.CJvXw>tgrHRtylRvXwb.wJySReDw*Rw*hRvDRI zd.CJpH;< erh>[h.,RuqD0gw’kM.< ,wwJw>eDwrHRb.M.vDRI zJM.ySRt*Rwz.rRwoheDwrHRvXRb.tCd< ySRb.[h.vDRtDRuqD0gwz. ’D;p;xD.rk>eHRt0JM.uJ’d.xD.0JM.vDRI

4


ydmcGgzdvXtzSD.w*RydmcGgzdvXtzSD.w*R

vXysXRM.ydmcGgzdvXtzSD.td.w*R’D;td.’D;trd>o;yS>vXtrJmwxH.w>w*RM.vDRI t0Jrh>zdo.vXt*hR’D;wrRw>tXw>oDeDwbsDb.’D;wqdurd.’.vJmw>tXw>oDwz.eDwbsDb.I t0JusJ;pX;Ckw>rRvXweHR’D;weHRt*D>vXuvk>tD.trd>rJmbsD.w*Rt*D>M.vDRI b.weHRvJRb.0JvXpDRyRtEl>ylR’D;xH.0JvXySRwz.td.’D;w>ol.ud>o;*DRe;r;vDRI rh>vXw>eg’d;wugwz.[JEkmrRwHmwmw>’D;[JEkm*kmql.w>vD>w>usJvX0h>ylRtCdM.vDRI

b.weHRySRqSXw>upD.w*R[JqSXM>pDRyRw>upD.vX‘d;wugz;’d.M.wJ0JvXySR0h>zdwz.[J’k;w>’D;tDR’D;rRtDRrh>weXRb.M.ub.uJxD.t0Jtuk>tySRcJvXmM.vDRI pDRyRe>[lw>tHR’D;tol.ud>o;*DR’d.r;M.vDRI o;p>zdw*RtHRChvXuvJRxH.vdmto;’D;pDRyR’D;pH;0J’.< ?td< up>pDRyR< ymeo;rkmrkmck.ck.wcD< [h.vDR,RvXe;wbh.’D;,uvJRrRoHuGHm‘d;wugw>egz;’d.0JM.vDR/

5


xJM.wbsDySR[h.vDRtDRe;wbh.< ‘D;t0JvJRCh>ql’d;wugttd.M.vDRI zJ’d;wugxH.vDRzdo.tHR’D;ud;xD.0J< ? rwRvJ.< [JCDR< ,utD.uGHmeRwbDI/ b.q.ydmcGgzdwysHRw>b.’D;Ch>obsd.’.qlng< vXtpkylRwcDtd.’D;e;z;xDwbh.vDRI ‘d;wugz;’d.zD.tDRb.q.zD.0JwcsK;b.I rh>vXydmcGgzdtHRrh>ySRvXt*hRtCdxd;bl;0JwM>’.vJmb.M.vDRI vXcHydmcGgzdCh>obsd.’D;qJ;CDR’d;wugtCd'd;wugz;’d.w’ktHRvDRCHRoH0JzJM.vDRI zJySR*D>rk>wz.xH.w>tHRM.tol.cko;ck’d.’d.uvJm< ySRxHzduD>zdwz.pH;xD.y-wXRtDR’D;pDRyRwcDb.ol.b.o;’D;[h.yXtDRvXtclt0h>weDRtCdtd.b.uhR0J’D;trd>rkmrkmck.ck.M.vDRI

6


ySRrRn.zd'D;trgySRrRn.zd'D;trg

w>pH;0JvXysXRtd.’D;ySRrRn.zdvXtzSD.w*RM.vDRI t0JtJ.vdmto;’D;ydmrk.vXtzSD.’fod;tDR< b.q.rh>ydmrk.vXtul.w>ohw*RvDRI w,Hm b.t0Joh.zsDto;M.vDRI b.weHRvJR'd;vDRpXRt0RtpRvXxHusdylRvDRI

zJtvJR0J< t0RwJtDR< ?,rg< rh>exH.pd;0.C;wbh.M.{g< 0g’d.r;vDRI/trgpH;qX< ?,xH.vDRtJ.’d.{X< rh>t0g’d.r;vDRI/ vJRu’D;qlng< xd.vJR0gwbh.,lRuymtzDcd.< t0RpH;? ,rg< exH.xd.vJR0gwbh.M.{g<ol’d.r;vDRI/ trgpH;qX< ?,xH.vDR< tJ.’d.{X< rh>toleD>uD>vDR/

w,Hmb.’D;vJRwkRvXxHusd’D;'d;vDRoud;0JpRcH*RvDRI t0Joh.rRw>cH*R’DweHRng< ‘D;zD.M>n.tgtg*D>*D>wkR’.vJmuhRpdm0JwM>cJvXmb.M.vDRI p;xD.rk>weHRM.t0Joh.rRtD.w>vJRxD.vJRxD’D;uJ’d.xD.0JM.vDRI ySRzSD.zd’Drg0RvXt[H.CXRw’l.< oh.ng0J'.w>*h>vXt0Joh.tw>td.xD.

7


,XRxD.tCdo;uh.b.t0Joh.M.vDRI b.weHRpH;b.trg< ?yuvJRzD.n.’fw>’Drg0RcH*RM.rR0Jtod;vDR< b.oh.oh.ybl.wD>u*hRxD.’fod;t0Joh.vDR/< wJvdmto;’fM.0HRvJR0JqlxHusdvDRI zJtvJRvXusJtcgpd;0.C;wbh.,lRcD*mtzDcd.’D;t0RpH;b.tDR< ?,rg< exH.pd;0.C;wbh.M. {g< 0g’d.r;vDRI/ trgpH;qX< ? u0g0JvJ.< ol’fod;oGJ.v;vDRr;vJ./

vJRwkR,HRxD.wpJ;< xH.0Jxd.vJR0gwbh.’D;wJb.trg< ?,rg< exH.xd.vJR0gwbh.M.{g< ol’d.r;vDRI/ pH;qXt0R< ? eRw*RtHR< eo;yS>wvXvH< tCdewxH.xd.wbh.M.vXt0g*hR*hRb.vDRI/ tCdt0Joh.wJtgvdmo;vXusJ’DwbdngvDRI wkRtvJRwkRvXxHuds’D;Ckb.n.uDuDcJcJ’DweHRng< b.q.wzD.M>w>eDwrHRb.’D;td.b.zSD.zSD.,m,m’fvXngtod;vDRI

8


b.oHvXw>ol.vDo;uGHtCdb.oHvXw>ol.vDo;uGHtCd

w>pH;0JvXysXRM.< vX&c;yl.&;0h>tylRySRul.vJ>rRuRusD>ye>td.0Jw*RvDRI ySRw*RtHRe>[l0J’.w>[lxD.ogvDRvXok;0e;0h>tylRtd.’D;w>rs>vX>vhwz.tCdt0Jud;xD.tysJ>tbD.wz.Ckm’D;usD>t’k,J>u,R’D;p;xD.vJRw>vDRI zJtvJRwkRvXyS>wwDRM.t0Joh.tJ.’d;td.bSH;td.ogtCd< ysJvDR0JusD>vXuvJRtD.eD.zdrHRzd‘D;t0Joh.zDtD.zDtDw>M.vDRI zJt0Joh.zDtD.w>tcg< ySRul.vJRrRuRw>tHRxH.0JvXwd>bDwz.us;vXoh.ulmusD.wz.tvdRM.vDRI zJM.t0J*>vDRuGHm0J[ko;vXxX.tylR’D;xXwh>Ekm0Jwd>bDvXxX.tylRvDRI

zJM.t0Jol.vDo;uGHw>tgxD.’D;qdurd.0J< w>vD>tHRtd.’D;wd>bD’kw>rs>yvJvXtvk>’d.yOR’d.wz.utd.’H;tgr;vDRI ‘D;t0JrXtysJ>tbD.wz.cl.[D.cd.’D;phud.vd.wz.[JxD.0JvDRI zJM.ySRw*RtHR< *>vDRuGHm0Jwd>bDcJvXmvXxX.tylR’D;xXwh>Ekm0Jphud.vd.wz.vDRI ySRw*RtHRM>b.0Jphud.

9


vd.vHb.q.to;wrH’H;tCdqdurd.u’D;0J< phtd.’kxlutd.vDRI tCdrXu’D;0JtysJ>wz.cl.u’D;w>’D;xH.xltCd< uGHmvDRuGHm0Jphud.vd.’D;xXwh>Ekmu’D;0JxlvDRI

vXcHuwX>< ySRul.vJRrRuRw>tHRqdurd.u’D;0J xltd.’kw>vk>yOR’d.t *Rwz.utd.’H;tCd< t0JrXtysJ>wz.cl.u’D;w>vDRI zJM.w>rRto;vX[D.cd.vDRySD>uGHmtCdt0Joh.vDRbsXoHuGHmcJvXmvDRI

10


bD.od.0gup>bD.od.0gup>

vXysXRM.< pDRyRtd.0Jw*RvDRI zJt0JuJpDRyRvXrD,dRuD>tcgxD.zdtzdrk.zdw*RvDRI zJzdo.tHRtd.zsJ.xD.M.y.Ckm’D;trJmcsHw>qgvDRI ty>CkM>uoH.o&.oh.wz.’D;ulpg,gbsgtDRoemuh< w[gr>b.’D;trJmcsHbsD.uGHm0J’.M.vDRI pDRyRtHRo;unDRb.0Jtzdrk.zd’d.r;tCd< t0Jud;M>ySR’G;w>wz.’D;oHuG>0Jrh>usJutd.wbdbdvXtzdrk.zdtrJmcsHuxH.xD.uhRw>{gM.vDRI

zJM.ySR’G;w>zdwz.’G;uG>0J’D;wJ0J’.vXw>rh>xd.xGHvDReD>yRrk.zdtHRM.< zdo.rk.tHRtrJmcsHuxH.xD.uhRw>vDRI w>rh>wxd.xGHvDRtDRb.M.< eD> yRrk.zdtrJmcsHubsD.uGHmvDRpdR’D;xHuD>ph>uD;ub.o*X>’D;w>’k;w>,RM.vDRI tCdw>rh>xd.xGHvDReD>yRrk.zdM.< xHuD>urkmuck.0J’D;eD>yRrk.zdph>uD;trJmcsHuxH.xD.uhRw>M.vDRI ‘D;w>rRto;vXpDRyRM.em0JySR’G;w>zdtw>uwdRtCdt0Jud;M>txHzduD>zdwz.’D;rXtbSDxD.M>tDRxd0HRymxD.w>tD.w>tDvXvXySJRySJRCkm’D;eD>yRrk.zdvXuvJRxd.xGHvDR0Jt*D>M.vDRI

11


eD>yRrk.zdM.vk.oh.cgywmty>tw>uwdRwohtCdt0JbgxD.trd>ty>0HRxD.vXvh.tylR’D;vJR0JqlrDxHusdeHRvDRI ySRvXt,d;qSXtDRw*RtHRvJRwD.qSXvDReD>yRrk.zdqlxdtylR’D;xd.xGHvDR0JvXxHusdeHRtylRvDRI eD>yRrk.zdM.b.vDRz;’D;trd>tCdt0Jto;b.’d’d.r;’D;vDRxGHydmxHtcHu,Du,DvXxHusdylRM.vDRI t0JrRw>woheDwrHRb.tCdt0J[D.vXw>o;b.’dtylR’D;Chbgxkuz.oyS>yS>vXuylRzsJ;xD.vXw>oH’D;trJmcHsuxH.xD.uhRw>M.vDRI zJt0JvJRvDRxGHwkRvXxHusduX>eHRuyRtcg< bD.od.0gw’ke>[lt0J[D.tuvk>oD.M.vDRI tCdbD.od.0g[JvDRqlttd.’D;uhRud;0JeD>yRrk.zdvDRI bD.od.0gw’ktHRulpg,gbsg0J’.eD>yRrk.zdtrJmcsH’D;t0Joh.td.qd;uhR0JwylRCD’feD>’Drg0Rtod;vDRI w,Hmb.tvD>cHt0Joh.xD.zd0JzdcGgoX*RvDRI zdcGgt’d.trHRrh>0Jcl.t.< zdcGgcH*Rw*RtrHRrh>0Jcl.,H>‘D;zdcGgo’gtrHRrh>0Jcl.q.vDRI zdcGgoX*RtHRtd.qd;tvD>M.rh>vXbD.od.td.qd;tgM>’H;ySRunDtCd< w>vD>0JM.b.w>ud;tDRvX ?0h>bD.od.0g/ M. vDRI

12


,k>vXttD.xJ.ue.,k>vXttD.xJ.ue.

w>pH;0JvXysXR< ySR'DwHR'Doud;td.0JcH*RvDRI tusgw*RM.rh>ySRvXt vH.tD.vDtD.w>ohvDRI t*Rw*Rrh>0JySRvXtvXySJR'D;w>ul.b.ul.oh'D;ol.yh>o;qSgw*RvDRI

weHRM.< ySRcdcd.zdvJRqltoud;ySR0h>zdttd.'D;rXtqgM>tDRxJ.vXtyORvDRvX,J>u,Rb;M.vDRI ySR0h>zdw*RtHR vJRqgvDRtD.0JySRcdcd.zdtxJ.'D;phvXtM>M.oltD.uGHm0J0HRwtJ.'d;[h.uhR0Jtoud;b.tCd[H;M>0J,k>th.wz.'D;ymyl.xD.0JvXxJ.trJtvD>M.vDRI

eHRoDwz.vJRylRuGHm0JtvD>cH< ySRcdcd.zdw*RvJRxD.ql0h>ylRtcgwxH.txJ.tCdoh.ng0JvXySRqgvDRtD.uGHmtxJ.vHtCdt0JvJRqltoud;ySR0h>zdttd.'D;ChphM.vDRI zJM.toud;ySR0h>zdwJb.tDRvX,k>th.uGHmxJ.trJ

13


wz.vDRI ySRcdcd.zdw*RtHRwwJuhRtoud;ySR0h>zdw>eDwrHRb.I t0JwJ ogtJ.'d;vJRvk.xH'D;vJRud;Ckm0JySR0h>zdtzdcGgM.vDRI zJt0Jvk.xH0HRt vD>cH< t0Jymclol.Cmzdo.vXySRvXtoh.ng0Jw*Rttd.vDRI zJySR0h>zdxH.vXtoud;[JuhRxJw*R{dR'D;wxH.tzdcGgb.tCdt0JoHuG>toud;ySRcdcd.zdvXtzdcGgt*h>vDRI 'D;toud;ySRcdcd.zdw*RwJb.tDRvXzJt0Jvk.xHtcgvHmxd.wbh.[JvDR'D;,lRpdmuGHmtzdcGgqlrlcd.M.vDRI b.q.ySR0h>zdw*RtHRwemtoud;ySRcdcd.zdtw>uwdRb.tCdt0Joh.cH*RM.uwdRtgvdmto;w>M.vDRI t0Joh.cH*RuwdRtgvdmto;wuwX>eDwbsDb.tCdt0Joh.vJRqlpH.nD.uGD>ttd.M.vDRI zJpH.nD.uGD>oHuG>t0Joh.'D;w>*h>w>usdRrRto;0HRoHuG>ySRcdcd.zdvXrh>vHmxd.,lRpdmuGHmzdo.teD>uD> {gM.vDRI 'D;ySRcdcd.zdpH;qX0JvXrh>M.vDRI

zJM.pH.nD.uGD.to;[JxD.w>tCdwJb.ySRcdcd.zdvX< ?ewJw>M.tcDy nDwtd.b.I wJb.,Rw>*h>vXtuJxD.o;eD>uD>wuh>I/ zJM.wHRoud;ySRcd.zdwJyF;uhRpH.nD.uGD>vXtoud;ySR0h>zdwJ0JvX,k>tD.0JxJ.ue.t*h>M.vDRI zJM.pH.nD.uGD>oh.nguhRw>*h>w>usdRvXtuJxD.o;tCdwJb.ySR0h>zdvX< ?erh>tJ.'d;o;vDuhRezdM.vJR[H;M>uhR phvXeqgvDRxJ.ue.wz.wuh>I/ 'D;uG>CDRqlySRcdcd.zdttd.'D;wJ0J<?eJerh>tJ.'d;uhRephM.vJR[H;M>uhReoud;tzd'D;[JuhRqSXu'guhRM>tDRwuh>/ M.vDRI

14


w>tuh.weXRw>tbsXw>tuh.weXRw>tbsX

w>pH;0JvXysXRwbsDySRtd.0JcH*R< w*RtrHRrh>pDRph'D;w*RtrHRrh>w>rs>M.vDRI ySRcH*RtHRrh>ySR'DwHR'Doud;'D;td.oud;tD.oud;0J'fod;od;< wth.vdmqd;uhvdmo;eDwbsDb.M.vDRI weHRM.t0Joh.wJoud;vXurRw>ul.vJRrRuR'D;tX.vDRtDvDRvdmto;'D;p;xD.rRw>M.vDRI vXcHtw>zH;w>rR'd.xD.vJRxD.tCdtusd.phw>xl;w>wDRwz.td.tgxD.vDRI

b.weHRw>rs>qdurd.0J,rh>[h.vDRpDRphvX,phcJvXmw0mC.C.M.,w>utd.xJwpJ;M.vDRI 'fod;,urRM>tgtgt*D>ub.CkusJvDRI vXcHt0JwJb.pDRphvX<?phwz.tHRyeDRz;vDRw*Rw0mwohb.M.vDRI rh>vX,rHRrh>w>rs>tCd vk>'d.yS›R'd.M>'H;phM.vDRI/

zJM.pDRphwJu'guhRtDR< ?rh>b.wJ'fM.< rh>vX,rHRrh>phtCd,-uX;rRM>ph

15


wz.tHRcJvXmM.vDRI erHRrhrh>w>rs>M.vJR = vJRqlrdud;vJRCkw>rs>wuh>I/

th.vdmqd;uhvdmo;tCdvXcHwJvdmto;vXuvJRqlpHmvD>w>oeX.csX.wxH;tzDvm'D;rXcsX.qXwJmM>ySRw>*h>M.vDRI w>tHRrh>w>rs>tw>[h.ul.vDRI rhrh>pDRphwcDwtJ.'d;wJtgw>vXRb.tCdwJ0JuG>zJetJ.'d;vJRM.vJRp>cD< ,J',td.uwJmuwDRo;M.vDRI

zJw>rs>uhRwkR[H.M.w>rs>wJb.ty>o;yS>vXueDRvdmo;pht*h>M.vDRI 0HRcJrk>qh.*DRwcsK;t0JvJRw>M.rX0Jty>vJRcd;ympXRtDRvXoh.utdylRM.vDRI ty>ph>uD;'ftzdcGgwJtDRtod;*DRcD*DR*DRvJRqlyS>toeX.'D;vJRvDRtd.vXcsX.z;'d.tutdylRM.vDRI 0HRtvD>cHw>rs>'D;pDRphvJRpdm0Jw>tD.w>tDwz.'D;vJRqlcsX.cD.xH;M.vDRI zJt[JwkRvXcsX.cD.xH;'D;vk>xD.0Jw>tD.w>tDwz.0HRxkuz.o.urJRw>M.vDRI zJxkuz.o.urJRw>0HRtvD>cHoHuG>0JvXyrh>eDRvDRw>yub.eDRvDR'fvJ.M.vDRI zJM.y>vXttd.vX oh.utdw*RwJxD.0J<?w>rs>-uX;rRM>ttguwX>vDRI /

zJpDRphe>[lw>tHRto;[JxD.0J'D;wJ0J< ?rk>CgcsX.w*RtHRpH.nD.w>wwDb./ tCdt0J[H;xD.0Joh.'hwz.'D;'GJ.tlxD.0JcsX.utdylRM.vDRI zJM.wxH.CDw>rs>ty>vXttd.vXoh.utdylRw*Rwl>rh.tlvk>wuJvXRtCdud;yolxD.'D;wJ0J< ?w>tuh.eXRw>tbsXwohb.? 0HRpH.nD.M>0JvX -uX;[H;M>0Jphw*Rw0mM.vDRI

16


pkrk>'d.pkrk>'d.

w>pH;0JvXysXRM.w>’DzHvHRtd.cH*RvDRI tvHRcGgM.ud;0JtrHRvXpkrk>’d.vDRI tvHRzdw*RrXtzHtd.cd;M>tDRbkvXtvdvDRympXR0JM.vDRI zHw*RtHRrh>vXtd.cd;bkvXw>ud>usgtCd< weHRw>ud>ql.wvX’D;oHb.to;vDRI rhrh>tvHRwcDwJ0Jw>tHR,zHb.oHvXrk>tCd< t0JvJRqlrk>up>td. vXuvJRChuhRphtD.vd;vXtzHoHt*D>vDRI zJvJRvXusJM.xH.vdmto;’D;ytl;wbh.’D;ytl;oHuG>pkrk>’d.vXuvJRzJvJ.’D;pkrk>’d.pH;qXtDRvX ?,uvJRql,zHttd.vX,urRM>cd.o.CHyORt*D>/ vDRI zJM.ytl;ChydmtcHtCd< vJRud;0JvDRI zJtvJRvXusJwwDR’d.’d.< ytl;wJvXtvJRw>wuJvXRtCdpkrk>’d.wJtDR< ?rh>pH;’fM.< [JEkmvX,cHuD>tylR< ,uvJRud;Ckm’D;eRvDRI/ zJM.ytl;ph>uD;wwJtgw>eDwrHR’D;EkmvDRqlpkrk>’d.tcHylRM.vDRI rR’fM.vJRu’D;0Jqlngtcgt0JxH.vdmto;’D;,dR[D.w’ku’D;vDRI ,dR[D.oHuG>tDRvX ?euvJRzJvJ./I pkrk>’d.wJtDRvX ?,uvJRChuhR,zHtcd.

17


yORvXrk>ttd.vDRI/ zJM.,dR[D.wJtDRvXtJ.’d;vJRph>uD;0JtCd< pkrk>’d.[h.vDRtDRtcGJ;vXuvJRw>vDRI zJvJRwkRwwDR’d.’d.< ,dRuD>wJu’d;vX tvJRw>wuJrh>vXw>bSH;u’D;to;tCdvDRI zJM.pkrk>’d.wJ0J<?evJRrh>wuJEkmvDRql,cHylR/III zJM.,dR[D.ph>uD;wwJtgwJpSRw>vXRb.I ‘D;EkmvDRvXpkrk>’d.tcHylRvDRI

zJtvJRwkRwwDR’d.’d.xH.vdmu’D;to;’D;bD.od.w’kvDRI bD.od.oHuG>u’D;pkrk>’d.vX ?euvJRzJvJ.I/ pkrk>’d.wJtDR< ?,uvJRChuhR,zHtcd.tyORvDRI/ zJM.bD.od.ChvJRtDRtCdt0J[h.tcGJ;ysJvJR0JvDRI zJtvJRwkRusJwwDR’d.’d.M.bD.od.wJtDRvXtvJRwuJu’D;b.tCd< pkrk>‘d.wJtDR< ?evJRrh>wuJ[JEkmvDRql,cHylRwuh>/ M.vDRI bD.od.ph>uD;wwJtgwJpSRw>’D;EkmvDR qlpkrk>’d.tcHylRM.vDRI

zJrk>pDRyRoh.ngvXpkrk>’d.u[Jqlttd.vXu[JChphtD.vd;M.< t0JysJvDR0Jxd;uvJmvXuymywkmzd.CJt*D>vDRI b.q.pkrk>’d.wJ0Jytl;vX<?ytl; vXM.ew>tD.[JvH/ tCdytl;[;xD.vXtcHylR’D;tD.uGHmxd;uvJmvDRI

pkrk>’d.ph>uD;[Ju’D;0JqlngtCdrk>up>ph>uD;ysJCDR0JqDzgwbh.vXuzs;oHtD.ytl;t*D>vDRI qDzgwcD[JvXuzs;oHpkrk>’d.t*D>< b.q.pkrk>’d.wJ< ?,dR[D.{X< vXM.ew>tD.[JvH/ wxH.CD< ,dR[D.[JxD.vXpkrk>’d.tcHylRtD.oH0JqDzguD>M.vDRI

wbsDtHRw>uDb.rk>up>to;vHI qSXxd;uvJm{D>wM>< qDzg{D>wM>tCdqSXvDRu’D;0Jye>w’kvDRI zJpkrk>’d.xH.ye>w’ktcgwJ0J< ?bD.od.{X< vXM.ew>tD.[JvH/ zJM.bD.od.[J[;xD.’D;tD.uGHm0Jye>M.vDRI

zJpkrk>’d.[JwkRCDRqlrk>pDRyRttd.’D;rk>pDRyRwJtDR< ?ezHoHM.wb.C;’D;

18


,Rb.I/ rhrh>pkrk>’d.wcD< wJtDR< ?b.C;0JoX.III vXeCd,zHb.oHvDRI tCd[h.,RphtD.vd;wuh>/ zJM.rk>pDRyRto;’d.xD.w>’d.’d.uvJmtCdqJ;CDRtDR’D;rk>tw>uyDRql.ql.uvJmb.q.t0J’Do’X0J’D;uvHRck.M.vDRI zJM.rk>qJ;vDRu’D;tDRvXw>ck.b.q.t0J’Do’XuhR0J’D;uvHRud>M.vDRI vXcHrR0hRrR0DR,HmxD.’D;rk>w>bSH;xD.to;tCdwJtDR< ?uJRIII eo;vDw>rEkRvJ.wJwbDIII ,u[h.eRcJvXmvDRI/

zJM.t0J’gvDR0Jt,.vk;blovgzdwbh.’D;wJ0J< ?rhrh>’fM.< xXEkmvDRM>,Rxl< ph< w>rs>yvJvX,,.wbh.tHRtylRySJRySJRwuh>I/ zJwJ0J’fM.0HR< rk>[h.vDRtDRu,J>xl{dRph{dRw>rs>yvJvXvXySJRySJRM.vDRI

19


uqD0guqD0g

w>pH;0JwbsD< vX ?,.p.uFd.uD>/ tylRpDRyRyXw>w*RM.td.’D;uqD vDRqDw’kvDRI uqDtHRrh>uqDvXt’d.w>*hRb.’k.b.’hw’k’D;vDR*m’fphupX>tod;vDRI

weHRM.< pDRyRud;tuqDuGg’D;u,Xu,JxD.M>tuqD0HRvJRqlrl;yGJtylRvDRI zJtvJRwkRvXrl;yGJM.ySRtg*RxH.b.uqDtHRtCdpH;xD.y-wXRuqDM.vDRI t0Joh.wJ0J< ?tduqDtHR< vXySJR’D;tol;toh.tvRuyDR’D;rh>uqDw’kvXt-uX;’D;pDRyRpuF.ywh.’d.r;vDRI/

zJ,.p.uFd.pDRyRe>[lySRtg*Ry-wXRuqDM.< w>uh.w>usK[JxD.vXto;ylR’D;qdurd.0Jupk’kvXySRwz.tHRy-wXRuqDvXub.y-wXRpDRyRt vD>tCdow;’D;t0Jul.oH0JuqD0JM.vDRI

20


pDRyRud;0JtuqDuGg’D;oHuG>0J'.vXuqDtHRe>yX>ySRunDtw>uwdR{gM.vDRI ‘D;uqDuGgpH;qXtDRvXuqDe>yX>0J*hR*hRM.vDRI ‘D;pDRyRM.vJRud;0Ju qDqlw>}wduX>cd.’D;rX0JuqDrRyF;tDRw>t’dtwJmtuvkmuvkmM.vDRI ‘D;uqDM.rR0JM>cJvXm’fod;pDRyRrXtDRcJvXmvDRI pDRyRM.rXuqD[;yF;vXtcD.oXcD< 0HRrX[;yF;vXtcD.cHcD< 0HR’D;rXt[;yF;vXtcD.wcDM.vDRI zJuqDuGguG>0Jw>rRto;’ftHRM.t0Joh.ngw,muG>0JpDRyRtw>qdurd.b.tCdt0JwJb.uqDvXtd.’.ySRul.rRoHeRtCd< Ch>uGHmp>cDwbsDCD M.vDRI uqDM.zJte>[l0JuqDuGgwJtDR’fM.’D;t0J,lRuGHm0J'.qlb.&;eoH.uD>’D;uqDuGgM.vDRI

21


n.qH.'Xn.qH.'X

vXysXRM.td.’D;ySRwcGJtD.n.’Drg0RcH*RvDRI b.weHR0Rw*RM.vJRCktD.n.’D;rRM>n.tgtg*D>*D>tCd< t0Jwh>Ekmn.wz.vXw>’XtylR’D;rRqH.wCm0JvDRI zJtuJxD.n.qH.M.< t0JrXtrgvJRqg’D;t0JvJR[;CkwcGJtD.n.u’D;M.vDRI b.weHR< trgtd.wql.wcVe;e;uvJmtCdpl; uGHmto;M.vDRI b.q.oemuhrgw*RM.tJ.0J0Rw*RtHR’d.r;tCd< t0Jtd.qd;’D;t0RwylRCD ‘fw>0Hw>uvRvXw>oHwcDyRtod;vDRI

0Rw*RtHRqJ;rR’H;w>rRqH.tD.n.tw>rRvDRI w>rRto;vXt0JrRn.qH.< ‘D;zJt0J[;Ckn.vX[gcDvDR’D;[JuhRvX[H.tcg< xH.0JvXn.qH.’XtylRn.wz.[gr>uGHmtCdt0Jwh>Ekmu’D;n.vX0.yDRtylRvDRI rRu’D;weHRxH.0JvXn.vXmu’D;vDRI vXw>M.tCd< weHRM.t0JtJ.’d;oh.ngrh>rwRw*R[k.tD.tn.vJ.tCd< t0JymvDRto;vXucd;uG>pl.0J

22


vDRI t0JuG>pl.w>vXw>o;xD.’d.’d.uvJmtylR< ‘D;zJM.t0JxH.vXw>wC.rk.[JtD.tn.vDRI t0Jwoh.ngvXw>wC.rk.M.rh>trgb.tCd< vXw>yXRo;wM>tylR< [JCh>vXuuGHmoH0Jw>wC.rk.‘D;qX.wd>tcgtcD.vDRwvHmtCdt0JvDRwJmuGHmqlw>}wdtylR’D;< 0Rw*RtHRuJxD.uhRvXqDxHM.vDRI tCdyue>[lb.qDxHud;0JvX,dRusdm’ftHR< ?y.pd; p.rd; pd;cD; pd;tD; egxD; [d.[D; egxD; yd.rD./ M.vDRI

23


rhRwd>yHmrhRwd>yHm

w>pH;0JvXysXR< vX,dRo0DwzsX.tylRzdo.zdwz.thpd>thM’d.r;tCdrd>y>wz.Chud.vXvgrk>Cgttd.M.vDRI ‘D;rk>CgM.[h.vDR0Jzdo.wz.vXud.rhRwd>yHmM.vDRI w>pH;0JvXud.rhRwd>yHmvXw>ud;tDRvX ?cDyd;/ tHR[JvDRpJRvXrlcd.z;xDM.vDRI rd>y>wz.qSD0JrhRwd>yHmwpJ;wpJ;’D;‘k;tD.tzd< b.q.ud.tHRwvXmuGHmeDwbsDb.’D;td.uhR’.’ftvD>vD>M.vDRI b. weHR< ySRydmrk.vXtol.uh.o;ugw*R< vXtrHRrh>ph.pr.u.M.t0JvJR qDS0Jud.tHRvXt*H>xH;’D;‘k;tD.0JxJtzdw*R{dRvDRI zJrk>Cgoh.ngw>*h>tHRM.to;[J’d.xD.w>’d.r;tCdt0JuhRpdmuGHmud.tHRvDRI vXw>M.tCd< ySR,dRzdwz.rRtD.0JrhRwd>yHmvXud.tHRtvD>M.vDRI ‘D;,dRwz.vk>xD.ymxD.rhRwd>yHmvXurRM>uhR0Jud.tHRt*D>vDRI

24


ch,k>'D;eXRyS>ch,k>'D;eXRyS>

w>pH;0JvXysXRM.eXRyS>vXtvk>tD.o;orl’D;w>vlRtD.w>rHRvmtd.0Jw*RvDRI xDbdt0JvJRqlyS>ylR’D;Ckc;tD.w>rHRvmwz.vDRI weHRt0JvJREkmqlyS>ylRvXuc;tD.wRCDRw’kvDRI vJREkm0J’D;yS>,dmxD.uU>uU>oemuht0JwxH.wRCDReDw’kb.I tCdt0Jqh.eDRtd.bSH;td.ogvXoh.wxl.tcD.xH;M.vDRI zJM.tcgt0Je>[lw>uvk>vXtuyR’D;t0JqJxD.tusd’D;uwJmuwDRto;vXuc;0JvDRI t0JuG>0Jw>rHRvmvXuc;0Jtcg< wrh>wRCDRb.I b.vXch,k>w’kM.vDRI zJM.t0JysHRw>zk;w>’D;wJb.0Jch,k>< ?wb.rRoH,Rw*hRIII 0Ho;plR’k;ylRzsJ;,o;orl/ vDRI ch,k>uG>tDR‘D;oHuG>0JeXRyS>< ?etJ.eo;orl{g/ ‘D;t0JpH;qXuhR0J< ?rh>< ,tJ.,o;orl/ vDRI

zJM.ch,k>wJb.tDR< ?erh>tJ.vDReo;M.wb.rRoHySR*Rto;orlw*hRIII t0Joh.emuhtJ.vDRto;orl’fod;eRvDRI/ eXRyS>M.vXcHoh.ngyD>,>vDRuhRto;vXub.tJ.ySR*R’ftJ.vDRto;tod;tCd< t0J[;xD.vXyS>ylR’D;pl;uGHmnduGHm0JeXRyS>tw>rRM.vDRI

25


q.bkrk> (rh) q.uqDq.bkrk> (rh) q.uqD

w>pH;0J’.wbsD< td.’D;o0DvXtpDRpkR,HR’D;0h>wzsX.M.vDRI o0DwzsX.tylR< td.’D;ySRxlpHmzd[H.zdCDzdw’l.vDRI zJpHmylRtd.’D;qDrd>wbh.vXttd.’D;tzdqH;zdEGHbh.M.vDRI xDbdM.trd>wJb.t0Joh.vXwb.vJREkmvDRqlw>ol.w>zs;tvD>w*hR’D;wb.vJRbl;’D;[H.w*hRvDRI xDbdt0JwJ b.tzdvX ?okygM.cDzsdvJRCktD.pXRokw>bl;’D;[H.tCd< b.w>rRoHtD.tDRvDRI/

weHRySRwrSHRwzk[JvXySRxlpHmzdt[H.vDRI [H.zdCDzdwz.tJ.’d;wl>vdmcD.qXySRwrSHRb.q.< rh>vXuvJRyORw>tD.w>tDt*D>w>’h.pXR,HR’d.r;t CdvXcHt0Joh.oh.eD.to;vXtd.’D;qDrd>wbh.vDRI ?tX.III yqDrd>td.wbh.’H;< yuzDtD.M>ySRwrSHRvX[gw>tD.< wvd.yyORuol[D.bD.vXRb./ M.vDRI

zJqDrd>e>[lw>’ftHRto;b.’d’D;ud;zSd.tzdwz.’D;rRvdm0J’ftHR< ?zdoh.

26


{X< rdrdtd.’D;okwohvXRb.I b.q.wb.o;qH;w*hRI zJrdrdwtd.vXRb.M.wb.rReXRrRC.vdmo;w*hRI zJrdrdoH0HRtvD>cH< okwxH.b.rdrdvXRb.I ue.rdrdtw>uwdR< CktD.okup>’.0Jtw>tD.’D;zJw>*d>cgM.zd;[kvdmoko;wuh>I/ t0JwJw>0HR[H.up>[JzD.tDR’D;uhRrRoHzDtD.0JuolM.vDRI

tcJtHRqDzdwz.trd>wtd.vXRb.I t0Joh.[;CktD.w>tD.{D>wb.’D;to;b.’dvXtrd>tCdvDRI rk>eHRrk>oDvJRcDzsduGHmb.q.t0Joh.oh.eD.’H;’.trd>M.vDRI zJw>[JplRvDRrlcd.plR’d.r;tcgt0Joh.w>*d>to;’d.r;M.vDRI utD.w>tD.wtd.tCdt*H>tbgvXmxD.0JvDRI zJM.t0Joh.wJvdmto; ?rh>vXyrd>wtd.tCdyvDR*m’fwuGHxl.vXwtd.’D;t’ht-w> b.vDRI/ tCd< t0Joh.wX.yD.vdmto;’D;pH.vDRoHto;vXrh.tlyl.tylRvDRI zJt0Joh.oH0HRtvD>cH< uJxD.0Jq.zdwz.vDRI q.zdvXttd.EGHzsX.wu±l>CDM.< vX,dR’d.tusdmw>ud;tDRvX ?&DuJ.eJ./ ‘D;tcDynDrh>0J ?qDzdqH;wz./ ‘D;q.wz.tHRrh>0Jq.bkrk>vXttd.EGHzsX.M.vDRI

27


ySR*H>ql.tH.[h.vD.ySR*H>ql.tH.[h.vD.

w>pH;0JvXysXRM.< vXo0DqH;qH;zdwzsX.tylRtd.’D;zH’D;zk’Drg0RcH*RM.vDRI t0Joh.td.’d;tzdcGgw*R’D;zdcGgtHRt*H>ql.’d.r;vDRI zdcGgzdtHRw>ud;trHRvXtH.[h.vD.M.vDRI t0JySJR’D;*H>bgwu;b.< ymuJph>uD;trd>ty>’d.r;M.vDRI t0JrRw>ql.’d.r;tCdtd.’D;tu&X>z;vJ>’D;ol.w>zs;w>tgtg*D>*D>M.vDRI w>vXtol.0Jwz.qgvDR0JM>*hRtCdw,Hmb.rRxD.tD.xD.uJ’d.uJxDxD.M.vDRI

ySRo0Dzdt*Rwz.uG>t0Joh.rRw>’d.xD.vJRxD.0J’d.r;tCd< uG>wvDR0J’d.r;vDRI tCdt0Joh.ul.xD.w>tXvXtH.[h.vD.tzDcd.M.vDRI t0Joh.vJRqltH.[h.vD.ty>ttd.’D;rX0JtrRoHtzdM.vDRI ty>ph>uD;u b.rRw>rEkRvJ.M.woh.ng0JtCdrXtzdvJRqlxd.’d;wugz;’d.ttd.

28


wbh.’D;[JuhRpdmt’H.wz.vDRI tH.[h.vD.ph>uD;’fty>wJtDRtod;< t0JvJRqlxd.’d;wugttd.< rRoHuGHm0Jtrd>’D;[JuhRpdm0Jt’H.wz.M.vDRI rh>vXxd.’d;wugzgw’kxH.w>tHRtCd< to;xD.’d.r;tCd[JCh>vlRydmtH.[h.vD.tcH’D;qJ;zsduGHm0Jto;M.vDRI wcsK;tH.[h.vD.oHtcgrh>vXwl>b.w>qge;e;uvJmtCdud;yol0JvXt*H>vXmtuvk>z;’d.M.vDRI w>uvk>0JtHRoD.’fod;uvHRrk>tlw>tuvk>z;’d.tod;vDRI zJw>tHRuJxD.0HRtvD>cH< wkRrk>rqgweHRtHR< zJySRe>[luvHRtlw>oD.wbsDv>v>M.ySRwJ0JvXrh>0JtH.[h.vD.ud;yoltuvk>oD.M.vDRI

29


pd;0.C;vXpd;0.C;vXto;unDRw>ohto;unDRw>oh

w>pH;0JvXysXRwbsDtd.’D;pd;0.C;wbh.vXtw>ul.b.ul.oh< td.’D;touJmy0;*hRwbh.M.vDRI vXw>M.tCdpd;0.C;t*Rwz.wD.xD.tDR’fod;uuJxD.pDRyRvDRI weHRpd;0.C;0JM.teD>yRrk.wJb.t0RpDRyR<?o; bd{X< ,tJ.’d;tD.rhR’D;uolvXpDRyRtpD>eDRcd.wbD/ M.vDRI

pd;0.C;pDRyRqdurd.w>wpd>zd0HRtvD>cHvJR,lRCDR0JqlpDRyRzDtD.w>tvD>M.vDRI zJM.t0JvJRtd.cd;vDRw>vX’JzdvXttd.vXusJzJySRvJRpdmM>pDRyRw>tD.w>tDvXw>zDtD.w>tvD>qlpD>eDRcd.M.vDRI

zJ[gcDvDRw>uwJmuwDRvDRw>tD.w>tD0HRtvD>cH< w>xXEkmvDRw>tD.w>tDvXobH.vDcDtylR0HRvJRpdmtDRqlpDRyRtpD>eDRcd.M.vDRI zJM.pd;0.C;vXttd.vX’JzDcd.wbh.[J,lRvDRqlw>zDvmvXupd;zs;0JpDRyRtySRzDtD.w>trJmcsHM.vDRI b.q.ySRzDtD.w>zdw*RtHRrh>vXtpkcVcD.cV’D;*H> ql.bgql.tCdymvDRw>tD.w>tDobH.vXtuyR’D;zD.wH>0Jpd;0.C;M.

30


vDRI ?tX.IIIpd;0.C;wbh.tHR’k == weHRtHReub.oHvDRI/

zJM.pd;0.C;zdt*Rwbh.vXttd.vXoh.xl.vdRM.xH.w>rRto;’D;tpDRyRtCd< [JobHs;vDRqlySRzDtD.w>zdttd.M.vDRI zJM.ySRzDtD.w>zdysJvDRuhRxd.pDRyR’D;zD.u’guhRvXtDRwcDvDRI 0HR[JuhRpdm0Jpd;0.C;qlpDRyRttd.vDRI

pDRyRw*RoHuG>tDR< ?pd;0.C;{X< eogwJ,RwbD III b.rEkReb.[J,lRzs;ySRzDtD.w>zdtrJmcsHvJ.I/ zJM.pd;0.C;wJuhRpDRyR< ?up>pDRyR{X< rh>vXySRzDtD.w>zD.Cm,pDRyRvDRI pDRyRw*RrRbsK;rRzSd.wh>,R’D;ol.unDRo;unDR,RtCd,rh>b.oHvXtCd,oHuJ,JvDRI/

zJpDRyRxH.w>tHRe>[lw>tHR’D;[h.vDRtuvk>’ftHR< ?pd;0.C;zd{X< erh>ySRvXtoh.ngw>bsK;w>zSd.w*RvDRI ewl>oHo;vXySRvXtrRbsK;eRt*D>bl.upD’DvDRI ,ch,ySRoh.{X< rRvdM>w>vXpd;0.C;tHRttd.wuh>I/

pDRyRvXto;unDRw>ohw*RtHRys>uGHm0Jpd;0.C;zd’D;rXySRzDtD.w>tcd.xXEkmvDRrhRuolweDRvXemzdtylR’D;vJRbs;vDRpJRM>0JvXoh.cHvXpd;0.C;zdt*D>ud;eHR’J;vDRI

31


tH.=uD>=[dtH.=uD>=[d

w>pH;0JwbsD,dRrk>yS>zSD.oH,m*DRtd.w*RvDRI t0Jtd.zsJ.tzdw*R’D;tzdM.trd>yS>wtd.’D;td.xJtcd.wzsX.vDR< b.q.td.’D;tpdurDRvDRv;wz.M.vDRI rk>yS>uFHtHRvk>’d.xD.tzdvDRv;w*RtHRvXw>tJ.w>uGHylRvDRI zJto;td. 7=8 eH.M.pH;b.trd ?,b.o;rRw>rRwcgcgvXuM>phvXupl;ugt*D>M.vDRI vJRwJb.M>,RpHmup>vX,uwJmuwDR,o;vX,uuG>M>tDRtusD>< ye>vXpHmylRohvHM.vDR/

trdpH;b.tDR< ?euG>usD>ye>uoh’fvJ.I erd>yS>epkecD.r;wtd.b.M.II/ t0JpH;<? rd{X< ewoh.ng,pdurDR’fb.I/ trd>vJRwJb.M>tDRpHmup>’D;pH;0J< ?,zdcGgw*RtrHRvXtH.uD>[d (w>cd.o.CH) b.o;uG>xGJM>eusD> ye>vDRI/ pHmup>pH;qX<?ohvDR< uG>0Jrh>*hR< ,usD>ye>rh>w[gr>eDw’kb. M.< ,u[h.tDRw>tbl;vJM.vDR/

32


rk>qh.xD.< tH.uD>[dtrdxXEkmvDRtDRqlxX.ylRCkm’D;rk>xl.w>tD.’D;vJRbs;xD.0JvXoh.cHzJpHmysDylRM.vDRI ‘D;uhRwJb.pHmup>< ?eys>vDR*DRzH;ye>ohvHvDR/

zJusD>ye>b.w>ys>vDRtDR’D;tH.uD>[dtrd[DvDR0JqlpH.yDsylR’D;uhRqlt[H.M.vDRI tH.uD>[dtrdzXEkmvDRtDRqlxX.ylR’D;bs;vDRtDRvXoh.cHM.vDRI zJusD>ye>wz.tD.w>tD.0HRM.< [JrHvDR0Joh.cD.xH;’D;[JvDR*HmtD.tq.vXoh.cD.xH;zJw>bs;vDRtH.uD>[d;tzDvmM.vDRI wkR[gvDRcD< trd>[Jud;uhRtDRvXxX.ylR’D;uhR0H0JqlpHmup>t[H.’D;usD>ye>wz.ydmxGJxD.’.tcHvDRI rR0J’ftHRvXtgeH.twD>ylRM.vDRI

wkRtH.uD>[dto;td. 16=17 eH.M.< wJb.trd ?rd{X< ,tJ.’d;zsD,o;’D;pDRyRtzdrk.vDRI/ trd>pH;qX<?,vJRoHuG>pDRyRwbl.b.< urRoHb.zk;,R/III tH.uD>[dpH;b.trd< ?ysHRw>w*hR< ewoh.ng,pdurDR’fb.I/ rh>vXtzdcGgutH.utl;tDRcJtHRcJtHRtCdvXcHuwX>vJR0JqlpDyRtchtySRwz.ttd.M.vDRI

trd>vJRqlpDRyRtchtySRtd.< ‘D;wJb.0J’ftzdcGgwJ0Jtod;< vXuvJRud;xH.M>tDRpDRyRvDRI ‘D;ySReHRb.tDR’D;wJ0J’ftHR< ?tH.uD>[dtd.xJtcd.wzsX.vDR< yvJRwbl.b.I cJuXmpDRyRurRoHb.zk;ySR/ M.vDRI

vXcH< t0JvJRqlpDRyRtySRul.vdmw>vXtol.*hRo;0gw*Rttd.’D;tw>oHuG>tDR< ?rk>*>{X< evd.b.w>rEkRvJ.I/ t0JpH;qX< ?y’d.{X< ,zdcGg td.w*R< trHRrh>tH.uD>[dvDRI t0JtJ.’d;zsDo;’D;pDRyRtzdrk.tCdrh>eoHuG>M>,RpDRyRuoh{gI/

tcD.xH;pDRyRtySRul.vdmw>w*R*hRvdm0Jb.q.rh>vXrk>yS>w*RChun;

33


tDRcJtHRcJtHR’D;rh>vXySRul.vdmw>w*Ro;unDRb.tDRtCd< y’d.w*R< vXw>o;unDRtylRtX.vDR0JM.vDRI wkRpDRyRe>[lw>upD.tHRto;’d.xD.’d.’d.uvJm'D;pH;0J < ?tpSRuwX>,J>oDtwD>ylR< tH.uD>[dub.ol.’d.xD.oh.wxl.vXttd.’D;owd>v.< to.xlo.ph< ymCkm’D;pDRyRw>tD.w>tDwz.< rhwM>b.M.,urRoHeR< Ckm’D;tDRwbsDCDvDRI/

trd>uhRCh>ySJR’D;w>[D.w>,XRqlt[H.vDRI ?tH.uD>[d{X< erRw>rEkRvJ.< vX,J>oDwD>ylReol.’d.xD.oh.vDRv;vXpDRyReDylR< rhwM>b.M.yub.oHeD>uD>vDR/

tH.uD>[dwJb.trd< ?wb.o;ud>w*hRrd{X< w>cJvXmub.vdmb.p;0JvDRI [H;M>emcHzsX.< wzsX.xXEkmvDRbkbh.wkRtySJR< ‘D;t*RwzsX.xXEkmvDRzDpyJ.wkRtySJR< ymvDR,RvXw>uql;’D;uhRrHp>cDIII/ trd>rR0J’ftrXtDRtod;’D;uhRrH0JM.vDRI

zJrk>eRcDzJySRrHvXmtcg< t0Jwusdmtcd.’D;[D.cd.oXxH.vXuud;w>uvRwz.u[JrRpXRtDRM.vDRI wbsDCD< oh.vDRv;wxl.rJxD.vXpDRyReDu&X>ylRvDRI bkbh.vXemylRwz.uJxD.0JvX>vk>’d.yOR’d.CHvRwz.’D;zDwz.uJxD.qlw>tD.t0H.tbJwz.M.vDRI

rk>qh.xD.< wkRpDRyRrHeD.o;’D;uG>w>qlteDylRtcg’H;’l;trJm’D;pH;0J< ?w>rekRuyDRujyK>u_yDRwz.M.vJ.< ,xH.w>wqSHb./III ‘D;qdurd.xD.0J<?w>tHRurh>w>uJxD.o;vXySRvDRv;cd.wzsX.w*RM.tpdurDReD>eD>M. vDRI/

vXw>M.tCd< rXvDRySRvJRud;M>tDRtH.uD>[dM.vDRI zJtvJREkmqleDylRCkm’D;emwzsX.vXtySJR’D;vX>vk>’d.yOR’d.’D;w>tD.vXrlcd.wz.< ’D;tX.

34


vDR0JvXtzdrk.w*Rw*Rrh>wl>vdm0JM.u’k;zsD0J’D;tH.uD>[dM.vDRI ud;CDRtzdrk.Ck*Rqlttd.< wkReD>yRrk.zdCk*R[JwkR’D;pH;0J<?0Rw*R< tpktcD.wtd.< ,[H;wuJb.I/

wkRvXto’gw*R< pH;0J<? rddrd>rh>b.to;’D;,tX.vDR,JvDRI/ t0Joh.’d;wh’d;zsDto;’D; pDRyRbSDxD.M>tDRw>vD>vDRqDM.vDRI zJtH.uD>[dtd.vX tup>’.0JteDylRM.vd.uJxD.o;vXpDRyRzdcGg’d.w>*hRw*RvDR< b.q. ySRvXtxH.tDRM.rh>'.xJtrgw*R{dRM.vDRI

b.weHRpDRyRrRrl;z;’d.vXySRud;*Ru[Jt*D>‘D;ySRud;*R’J;vJR0J< b.q.tH.uD>[d'D;trgwvJR0Jb.M.vDRI zJt0Joh.uvJR0JM.tH.uD>[dorlxD.0Jtuoh.,lRw’k’D;’X;xD.0Jqlrlz;zD< ‘D;vJRpD>vDR0JvXpDRyRtrl;tyGJM.vDRI t0JvJRqh.eDRvXvX>z;’d.wbh.vX[H.cD.xH;M.vDRI zJM.t0Jzsg’d.w>*hR’D;ySJR’D;tol;toh.tCd< ySR[Jwl>vdmtDR’D;oH.{dRzD{dRwz.’fod;ySRrlcd.zdw*R0HR< t0J,lRxD.uhRqlrlz;zD’D;vDRr>uGHm0J’D;[JuhRqlteDylRvDRI

zJt’Dyk>0J>rk.wz.[JuhRvXt[H.< uvmtH.uD>[d’D;trgrh>vXwvJRrl;tCd‘D;wJ0J< ?y0JyxH.b.w>vDRv;vXweHRtHRvXwrh>okuxH.b.tDRwoheDwbsDb.M.vDR/

tyk>o’geHRxD.0J’D;b.o;wJyF;0JvXw>*h>b.q.wwJ0Jb.I zJM.tvD>cH< pDRyRrHrD>w>vDRI rHrD>0JvXpDRyRpJ;uF.[JpH;b.tDR< ?qSXvDRySRpdmw>upD.w*Rql,td.vXEGHoDwD>ylR< rhwrh>b.M.eub.oHvDRI/

vXCkoDtwD>ylRM.< pDRyR[;xD.[;vDR0JvXt0h>ylRvXuCkM>ySRvXuvJRql’d;wugt0h>M.vDRI b.q.wxH.0JeDw*Rb.t0JysHRw>wkRvXbl; uoHb.to;M.vDRI rh>vXcJrk>qh.rh>rk>eHRtuwX>weHRvDRI zJM.< tzd

35


rk.o’g[JwJrkmuhRto;’D;pH;0J< ?tH.uD>[dvJR0JohM.vDR I/b.q.ySRwemtDReDw*Rb.I

zJEGHeHRweHRM.tH.uD>[dvd.uJxD.o;qlpDRyRzdcGgCHvRw*R< ‘X;xD.tuoh.,lR’D;vJR0Jql’d;wugt0h>vXuvJR[H;w>upD.vXpDRyRpJ;uF.ttd. M.vDRI

zJM.tcgeD>yRrk.zdt*Rwz.vDuDuhR0JvXwzsDb.to;’D;tH.uD>[dM.vDRI b.q.tyk>o’gpH;b.t0Joh.< ?zJw>cGJ;w>,mtd.cgokys>uGHmtDR< tcJtHRokw>cGJ;w>,mwtd.vXRb.I/

vXcH< t0Joh.cH*Rtd.rkmqd;yXRuhR0JwkRvXtuwX>wpkM.vDRI

36


ySRzSD.zdvXto;uGHw>'d.w*RySRzSD.zdvXto;uGHw>'d.w*R

vXysXRM.ySRydmcGgvXtzSD.oH,m*DRtd.w*RvDRI weHRM.e>[l0JvXodwtd.vX0h>ylRvXRb.tCd< t0JChM>0JphwqH;wuh>vXtoud;ttd.’D;vJRyORod'D;vJRvDRql0h>ylRM.vDRI t0JvJRyORod0HR,d;xD.0JodcHudvXeD.,d;bdw bdtvdRvDRI vXusJM.t0JxH.vdmto;’D;wcl;wbd’D;wcl;M.Ch>uGHmtDRzJ txH.tDRwbsDCDM.vDRI o;p>tHRrh>vXtJ.’d;tD.wcl;tCd< Ch>vlRydmw cl;tcHvXuzD.tD.0Jt*D>vDRI wcl;{D>Ch>tCdt0JvlRydm0Jwcl;tcHw,HR’D;wcl;b.M.vDRI vXcHwcl;w’ktHRCh>EkmvDRqlw>ylRtylR’D;[gr>uGHm0JvDRI vXcHySRo;p>tHR< ymvDRtodcHud’D;p;xD.cl.0Jwcl;tylRvDRI zJcl.w>ylRw ,Hmb.’D;xH.0JphoXw&HR’D;xloXw&HRvDRI t0Jto;ck’d.r;tCd< [JuhR,d;0Jw&HR 6 zsX.’D;odcHudM.vDRI b.q.,HmxD.’D;CXxD.0JvDRI t0Jqdurd.xD.0JvXto;< ?vX,*D>odwz.tHRtbsK;wtd.b.I cJtHR,xl,phtd.vHIII,uuGHmwh>odw&HRzJtHRvDRI/ 0HRymwh>0JodvXusJcd.vDRI 0HRvJR,d;0Jxludphudwz.vDRI zJt0JvJRwkRvX0h>ylRtcg< oh.ng0JvXweHRtHR

37


td.‘D;zFgvX0h>ylRvDRI xlw&HRphw&HRwz.ph>uD;CXwu;’H;b.< t0JtJ.’d;vJR[;qltoud;td.tCd< uymwD>0Jtw&HRwz.vX[H.wzsX.tylRvDRI t0JwJb.[H.up>vX< ?0Ho;plR III ,tJ.‘d;ymwD>,w&HRzJtHRvDRI w&HRwz.tylRtd.’D;odwz.M.vDRI/

t0JymwD>tw&HRwz.0HR’D;vJR[;td.oud;toud;vX0h>ylRM.vDRI t0J[;’DweHRtCdt0Jwoh.ng’.vJmto;vXrh>tymwD>0Jto&HRvX[H.zJvJ.wzsX.b.M.vDRI tCdt0JEkmvDR[;xD.w[H.0HRw[H.’D;oHuG>0Jrh>ymwD>b.0Jw&HRzJvJ.b.q.ySRwJtDRvXwtd.b.M.vDRI

vXcHuwX>t0JxH.M>uhR’.xJvHmy&Xwbh.vXtvD>M.vDRI vHmy&XwJ0J< ?xlphw&HRtup>wJ0J< ogpH;bsK;b.eRvXe[JuhR,d;uhRM>txltphql0h>ylRtCdM.vDRI t0JymwD>M>w>rRtbl;tvJwpJ;vXe*D>vDRI/ vHmy&Xw bh.tHRtylRtd.’D;phzdpSRbh.M.vDRI

zJM.t0JyD>,>vDRuhRto;vXt0Jrh>wymwh>0JtodudM.u*hRvDRI cJtHRxlw&HRphw&HR[gr>< wu;b.odudph>uD;[gr>uGHmtCd[JuhR0Jqlto0DvXw>o;wrkmtylRM.vDRI

38


tlwh.tlwh.

w>pH;0JwbsD< ud.p.zH;M.eD>yRrk.td.0Jw*RI b.weHRt0Jtd.wql.e;r;M.vDRI tCdrHvDR0JvXtvD>rH’D;uRbXto;’D;owd>t*DRblblzdwbh.vDRI

zJM.tcgxd.z;’d.wbh.,lRvXw>z;zDvDRI uG>vDR0JxH.eD>yRrk.uRbXto;’D;owd>*DR*DR'D;qdurd.0JvXw>n.tCd,lRvDR’D;pSDRpdmuGHmeD>yRrk.qlw>vD>t,HRM.vDRI ,lR0JwkRvXt,HRwkRvXoh.z;’d.wxl.tcHM.vDRI zJM.eD>yRrk.t[XzXqgxD.’D;uDR0JwuJvXRtCdtd.zsJ.xD.tzdcGgzJoh.’hwz.tusgM.vDRI zdo.zdp;xD.[D.0J< ‘D;zJM.xd.z;’d.o;unDRb.zdo.tCd,lRuGHm0Jqlw>vD>t*R’D;ymwh>w>’Dzdrd>cH*RvXoh.cHM.vDRI

39


ylRuGHmwpd>zd< tH;oh;cH*R[Jb.0J’D;e>[l0Jzdo.[D.oD.M.vDRI zJuG>xD.0Jqlw>zDcd.’D;xH.0JvXeD>yRrk.pdm’D;tzdw*RM.vDRI t0Joh.vJRxD.rRM>w>’Dzdrd>cH*R[JuhRymvDR0Jqlw>zDvmM.vDRI zdo.trHRrh>0J< ?tlwh./ ’D;tcDynDrh>0JbO.rk>ypDRM.vDRI wkRt’d.xD.< rh>ySRvXt*H>ql.< ol.’lo;’l’D;vJRcDzsdb.w>tgrHRvXyS>ylRM.vDRI

b.weHRtH;oh;pH;b.eD>yRrk.< ?zJr[gw[gM.zJ,’G;q.vXrlcd.tcgtpX[JxD.vXpDRyRvXud.p.zH.M.oHvHM.vDR/ eD>yRrk.p;xD.[D.upGH< tCdoHuG>0J ?b.rEkRvXeb.[D.vJ.I/ ‘D;pH;qX0J< ?pDRyRw*RM.rh>,0RM.vDRI/tH;oh;w*Rtd.’D;we>wzsX.tysHRtd.0JwqHcHbdM.vDRI t0J[h.vDR0Jtlwh.vDRI eD>yRrk.ph>uD;[h.vDR0JtzdcGgxHzSH.xlwbd< yoH;’D;owd>t*DRblblwbh.‘D;vJRqSXtlwh.vXw>vD>tbl;’D;ud.p.zH.zJw>vD>vXty>pDRyRyXwh>w>M.vDRI

vJRb.0JvXtgoDtwD>ylR’D;wkR0JvX0h>t}wJRrJmngb.q.}wJRyH;wH>to;vDRI t0Jud;yol’D;ySRcd;w>zd[JoHuG>tDRvXtvd.b.w>rEkRvJ.M.vDRI t0JpH;qX< ? ,rh>pDRyRvXoHuGHmw*RtzdcGgvDRI/

ySRcd;yJ}wDvJRCh>ud;w>cd.w>e>’D;t0Joh.[JuG>0J’D;oHuG>0J’.< ?ewJvXeuJpDRyRzdcGg< etd.’D;w>tk.o;rEkRwz.vXerd>[h.vDReRvXtu’k;eJ.eRvXerh>pDRyRtzdeD>uD>vJ.I/ t0Jxk;xD.xHzSH.xl< yoH;< ‘D;w>uH;nmowd> t*DRblblwbh.M.vDRI w>cd.w>e>wz.pH;0J’.<?rh>eD>uD>vDR< t0Jub.uJypDRyRM.vDR / ‘D;tlwh.uJxD.b.pDRyRzJM.vDRI

b.weHRtlwh.b.o;’k;eJ.tw>ohw>b.qlursX>vDRI t0J’hxD.we>M.vDRI zJ’hvDR0JwbD< uqD’D;w>rHRvmwz.[JvXw>vD>,HR’D;[J’due.0JvDRI ‘hvDR0JcHbDwbD< ySRunD’D;w>egwz.[Jue. 0J’.’D;urXur.b.0Jw>’h

40


wcgtHRM.vDRI zJt’hvDR0JoXbdM.< u,J>uqDcJvXmwz.[JuhRu’guhR’D;wDRvDRbgxD.tDRM.vDRI

we>w>’htHRb.w>pH.wJRtDRvXtlwh.txHzduD>zdwz.tusgtgr;vDRI w,Hmb.< we>vDRv;wzsX.tHR[lxD.ogvDRqluD>t*Rwz.M.vDRI

pDRyRvXuD>t*Rwbh.e>[l0Jwe>wzsX.tHRtw>vDRv;’D;o;vDb.0JM.vDRI t0JrXvDRtySRpkohcD.b.vXubSDxD.M>tDRuqDvXoh.w’kM.vDRIrRutdwkRySRunDEkmvDR}wD>< bSDtqXpJbl;wz.tgtg< zl0gtDR’D’kng< qGJ’D;ysHRvXu’k;[l;0;twrsdR< te>< trJmud< ‘D;tcd.,>cD,>cDoh0Jt*D>M.vDRI 0HRtvD>cH< rXySRunDvJREkmxk;vDRqluqDylR’D;vJR0Jqltlwh.ttd.M.vDRI tlwh.xk;xD.we>’D;’h0JM.vDRI b.q.uqDw’k[;’.tw>wue.tlwh.b.‘D;vXuqDb.ydmxGJpDRyRtlwh.tvD>M.pDRyRtlwh.b.vlRydmxGJuqDtcHM.vDRI zJtvJRydm0JwkRvXpDRyRw*RvXto;vDb.twe>wzsX.M.txHuD>ylR’D;w>zD.xXEkmtDRqlCd.ylRvDRI wcsK;vXySR[H;M>uGHm twe>b.M.pH;0J< ?we>tHRerh>woh.ngtw>orlb.M.e'hwM>b.I/

zJySRvJRwJb.JpDRyRw>*h>tHRM.pDRyRpH;b.tysJ><?rXtod.vdySRw*R*RII/wkRySRvJRwJb.tDR’D;t0JpH;qX< ?ySRxJw*RvX,uod.vdtDRM.rh>pDRyRtzdrk.M.vDR /

pDRyRto;ckvX u’hb.we>M.vDRI ‘D;rXvDRtzdrk.w*RvXub.’hvdwe>M.vDRI t0JymEkmtzdrk.vX’X;vDRqDvXw>o;uH>wzsX.tylRM.vDRI ‘D;ymtlwh.vXb;cDwuyR< wJb.tlwh.vXeD>yRrk.zdtHRtrJmbsD.M.vDRI vJRymCDR0Jtzdrk.vX’X;t0JwcD’D;wJb.tzdrk.vXtlwh.tHRtrJmo.ySJR’D;w>zsX.oGHvDRo;b.tX’d.r;vDRI

41


eD>yRrk.zd[JrRvdto;ud;eHR’J;vDRI b.q.rRvd0Jwb.b.vDRI ‘D;tlwh.to;wxDvXRb.’D;pH;b.tDR< ? eD>yRrk.bsD.rJm{Xrh>etD&Dm’d.r;vJ.I/

zJpDRyRzdrk.e>[l’D;to;xD.0J’D;t0JpH;qX< ?ySRvDRo;b.tXrJmo.ySJRxJzsX.oGHw*R{X< eod.vd,RwusXb.wcDvDRI/ tlwh.pH;tDR< ?b.rekRvXepH;vX,vDRo;b.tXvJ.I/ t0JpH;qX< ?b.rEkRepH;vX,rJmbsD.vJ.I/ xJM.wbsDtlwh.td;xD.uG>,.bs;o’X’D;t0Joh.xH.vdmto;’D;tJ.vdmb.o;M.vDRI

wpd>zdtlwh.oHuG>tDRvXeuCh>ydm,cH{g< t0JtX.vDR0J’D;pH;b.tlwh.< ?vXeDylRtHRuqDwz.Ch>cVr;vDRI yrh>wCh>’X;tDRb.M.yCh>wylRb.I/eD>yRrk.zdvJRqlty>td.’D;pH;0J’.< ?o&.vmtXw*RM.pH;0JvX,b.rRM>xlxX.< phxX.< ‘D;w>rs>yvJxX.vXuvJRvk>xD.w>vXyS>ylR’D;,’hwe>ub.0JvDRI/

pDRyR[h.vDRtDRu,J>w>vXCh0Jwz.M.vDRI ‘D;weHR< eD>yRrk.zd’D;tlwh.’X;xD.clol.uqD’D;Ch>uGHm0JvDRI usJvJRqlud.p.zH;M.,Hm0JEHGvgvDRI tcD.xH;M.ySRwoh.ngeDw*Rb.< b.q.zJySRymo;vXuqDvDRr>w’k< ’D;wxH.eD>yRrk.zd’D;tlwh.vXRb.’D;vJRwJb.0JpDRyR’D;rXvDR0JvXySRuvJRCkuG>uhRM.vDRI

ySRvJRCkydmxGJ,Hm0JEGHoDvHvDRI vlR0J’D;uqDb.q.eD>yRrk.zdzSHvDRwh>xl’D;phwz.vXusJ< ySRvlRw>zdwz.ywkmuqD’D;cd;xX0Jxl’D;phwz.vDRI w>rs>yvJtxX.wzsX.vDRwJmzJw>vD>M.vDRI tCdySRvlRw>wz.td.vXyS>ylRtvgb.tvgM.vDRI tlwh.’D;eD>yRrk.zdwcDuhRb.0Jrkmrkmck.ck.M.vDRI w>rs>yvJvXySRwxH.'H;wz.td.'H;0Jtgr;vX[D.cd.vm’D;td.0JwkRrk>r qgweHRtHRvDRI ‘D;b.wb.utd.’H;0JvX[D.cd.csXvDRI

42


cDzsdvXrhRwzsX.tCdcDzsdvXrhRwzsX.tCd

eXRyS>'D;trgeXRyS>'D;trg

w>pH;0JvXysXRySR’Dyk>0J>td.cH*RvDRI chcgzJM.rh>vXw>o.0HRvDR’dvDRvXxHuD>ylRtCdySR’Dyk>0J>cH*RtHRb.urXRCmrhRzdwzsX.w*RwbsDM.vDRI zJtyk>ydmrk.zdw*RurXRrhRzsX.zdtHRtcgo;yhReD.b.to;’D;,lREkmvDRb.0JrhRzdwzsX.tHRvDRI zJM.t0J>cGgM.to;[J’d.xD.b.tDRtCdudoh.z;tyk>ydmrk.zdt[XzX’D;xk;xD.tD.0JrhRzdwzsX.tHRM.vDRI zJtyk>rk.oH0HRtvD>cH< uJxD.0J’.xd.zdwbh.vDRI

zJM.t0J>cGgw*Ro;unDRb.tyk>’d.r;tCdto;oh.z;’D;oHuGHm0J0HRuJxD.u’D;vXxd.zdwbh.M.vDRI xd.zdwbh.tHRo;unDRb.tyk>’hrk.’D;vlRud;uhR0Jtyk>trHRvX< ?pD±S0h. === pD±S0h./ M.vDRI tyk>wcDud;qXu’guhR ?bktgvH === [ktgvH/ M.vDRI wkRrk>rqgweHRtHRtd.’D;xd.vXtud; ?pD±S0h. == pD±S0h./ wz.M.vDRI

w>pH;0JvXysXReXRyS>’Drg0Rtd.cH*RvDRI eXRyS>M.rk>[gvDRcDtqXuwD>b.td.cd;c;w>rHRvmvXoh.cHtCd rXtrg[JqSXM>tDR[gw>tD.vDRI zJt rg[JqSXM>tDRrhRtcg< rh>vXyS>vdmtDR’D;trJmur.'D;qdurd.0JtrgvX wR [d< wR’d.wz.'D;c;pdCDR0J'D;b.vXtrgtCd trgoHuGHm‘D;uJxD.uGHmxd.rd>wbh.vDRI t0Rph>uD;to;b.’d’D;oHuGHmtCduJxD.0Jxd.M.vDRI xd. zdtHRud;0J< ?wR[d{g==wR’d.{g/ ‘D;rhrh>t0RwcDud;qXu’guhR0J< ?ur. tCd== ur.tCd/ M.vDRI

43


bD.od.wtD.ye>t*h>bD.od.wtD.ye>t*h>

w>vXysXRM.w>'Drg0Rtd.cH*RvDRI t0Joh.cH*Rbk.ympXRbD.od.zdw'k'D;bD.od.zdw'ktHRbSg'd.r;M.vDRI vXysXRM.bD.od.wz.wtd.'D;tuGDwz.b.'D;0g0J'D'kM.vDRI zJeD>'Drg0RcH*RvJRul;u[HtcgbD.od.zdwcDvJR,d;M>t0Joh.u[Hwz.vDRI weHRM.rh.tltD.xD.u[Hv.vXbD.od.tysd>vdRtCddbD.od.zdwcDw>ud>to;'D;Ch>wzSJ;xd0JM.vDRI vXusJxH.vdmto;'D;usD>w'k'D;oHuG>0JusD>vXub.rRoHrh.tl'fvJ.M.vDRI b.q. usD>wcDtJ.'d;0JvXrh.tlutD.bD.od.tCdwJ0JvXCh>xD.vXupX>cd.M.vDRI zJbD.od.Ch>xD.vXupX>cd.M.< uvHRql.tCdrh.tltD.tgxD.M.vDRI zJM.xH.u'D;ye>'D;oHuG>0JvXub.rRoHrh.tl'fvJ.'D;rh>vXye>rh>ySRvXto;*hRtCdrXtvJRpk.vDRto;vXxHusgM.vDRIxJM.bD.od.vJR pH.zkvDRqlxHusg'D;rh.tlvDRyHmuGHmtCdto;orlylRzsJ;xD.uGHmM.vDRI b. q.rh>vXrh.tltD.vJ;b.ye>tudmbdtCdrk>rqgweHRtHRyuxH.b. ye>tudmbd0g0JM.vDRI rhrh>bD.od.wcDrh.tltD.vXtrd>yS>'D*RtCd< p; xD.zJM.wdRuUwdRuGD0J'D'kM.vDRI

vXcHrh>vXusD>ul.tXbD.od.tCdzJbD.od.xH.usD>wbsDv>v>th.oHuGHm 0JM.vDRI b.q.ye>M.rh>ySRvXtrRylRzsJ;to;orltCd< bD.od.wtD.y e>eDwbsDb.M.vDRI rh>tD.0JwcD< ySRpH;0J'.vXrh>vXw>w*hRwb.'D;w> url>ur.uJxD.vX'lylRo0DylRtCdM.vDRI

44


,dR'd.uvkm'l.,dR'd.uvkm'l.t*h>tusdRwqH;wuh>t*h>tusdRwqH;wuh>

,dR rhwrh> ,dR'd.uvkm'l.wz.rh>uvkm'l.wzkvXttd.vXuD>y,DRtylRvXtxl;wDR'D;tw>qJ;w>vRwz.M.vDRI zJtHRyurRvdoud;t0Joh.t*h>wpJ;vDRI

w>tD.w>tDw>tD.w>tD = ,dR'd.uvkmwz.tD.rhR’D;uol’fuvkm*Rwz.tod;vDRI ,dR'd.uvkm’l.vXttd.vXo0DylRwz.tD.rhRweHRoXbsDvDRI zJvJRvDRqlpHmysDtcg‘fod;tD.rhRuwkmM>,Hm,Hmt*D>tD.0JytHwz.vDRI xDeD>tk.wz.rh>0J,dRuvkmtw>tD.w>tD’D;tD.0J’fn.tk.< n.tk.xHwz.tod;vDRI xDeD>Chwz.td.vX,dRwz.t[H.ud;zsX.’J;vDRI ,dR'd.vXuD>y,DRuvHRpd;wuyRrRqH.tD.ob.’d;tuvkmuvkm< w>’d;w>v.tqH.<

45


t[D< t[Jwz.ph>uD;vDRI cDyd;vXw>rRtDRvXytHolM.rh>0J,dR'd.uvkm’l.wz.tw>tD.w>tDvDRI ,dRzdud;*R’J;tD.0J’.vmz;< obsK.oJ;o.wz.vDRI ,dR'd.uvkm’l.wz.tDv.z;xHtgM>xHck.wuh>vDRI ‘D;w>wJ0JvXv.z;xHylRxXEkmph>uD;0J’D;tHo.wqH;wuh>vDRI

w>’hw>tltyD;tvDwz.w>’hw>tltyD;tvDwz. = ,dR'd.tw>’hw>tltyD;tvDwz.tusgy.Ckm’D;,dRt’XySD>pk< rdRtuvkmuvkm< pSX>pSH;‘D;0.’Jwz.M.vDRI ‘XySD>pkwz.rh>0Jw>t&h’d.uwX>vX,dR’d.tw>’hw>tlwz.tylRM.vDRI

rdRCkzsX.M.w>&J.vDRtDR’D;vXeD>wD>wbdCDtvdR&J.vDR0JeD>wD>,J>bd’D;zJtwD>0JM.tuvk>oD.wjyXCDM.vDRI

td.ph>uD;’D;w>’hw>tltyD;tvDt*hRwz.ph>uD;M.vDRI td.’D;we>vXw>rRtDR’D;oh.vXtd.’D;tysHRoXbd< oDwl>vXw>rRtDR’D;xHvlRo.Ch’D;oh.uhwz.M.vDRI w>’hw>tlwz.M.w>’htDRzJw>[;qS.rk.ueDRwz.tusgph>uD;vDRI rh>w>’hvXtoD.uzDvDzd’D;trkmM.vDRI

w>'k.w>xkwz.w>'k.w>xkwz. = ewb.tlyH< uUuvHRvXySRul.vJRrRuRw>wz.t[H.b.I w>pH;0JvXw>tHRrh>w>u;wHmw>qd.*hRtusJM.vDRI ‘dutdwz.rh>yOR (ud;) vX’lylRo0DylRM.w>ck.b.w>b.wrkmuJxD.oh0JM.vDRI [H.up>rh>w[h.tcGJ;b.M.ewb.vJREkmql[H.up>cGgtw>vD>vXtymyeD.Cm0JvXteD>w*Rt*D>b.I erh>xD.vX[H.ylRM.eb.bh.vDRecD.zH;vDRI erh>tD.w>tD.w>tD’D;v.z;xHvXtymvDRM>eRr;t0Joh.b.o;0JvDRI erh>wtD.b.M.pH;0JvXt&X>tpX>vDRI

,dRuvkm’l.wz.M.t0Joh.nDEk>rRvk>v>xloElw>qJ;w>vRtrl;wz.vXtb.C;’D;w>ul.vJRrRuRM.vDRI w>oh.wz.M.vDRqD’.w>b.

46


C;’D;pHmvD>ySJRvD>wz.vDRI zJw>plRvDRoD’D;w>vJRvDRqlpHmvD>ySJRvD>tqXuwD>rlcd.uvHRoD.*DRrh>wb.vdmb.p;b.M.w>rRw>xk;ysHRtrl;< w>vk>xD.ymxD.oH;cd.rk>Cgtrl;wz.M.vDRI cDzsdw>zdC>wz.vDRvXpHmvD>ySJRvD>wz.tylRtCd< w>rk>w>bdvXw>ol.vDRtDRwz.tcsHto.rh>w*hRM.<pH;0J’.vXrh>vXt0Joh.rRwh>w>w*hRwb.tCd< t0Joh.nDEk>rR0Jw>vk>xD.ymxD.oH;cd.rk>Cgtrl;wz.vXw>uChys>uGHmw>ur.< ‘D;w>rR[gr>uGHmw>w*hRwb.vXtrR[;*DRpHmvD>ySJRvD>wz.M.vDRI

w>xJ.vDRpHm{dRySJR{dR‘D;w>ol.vDRbk[kwz.t*D>< nDEk>w>CkxXvDRqDeHRt*hRwz.M.vDRI vgtD;uxdbX. (qH;q. = vgeD) rh>wvXuGHmM.w>wol.bk[kvXRb.I w>rh>ol.M.< w>pH;0J’.vXbk[kwzDwo.xD.b.M.vDRI

w>ul;bk[k0HRbk[kwz.uxG;xD.tgtgt*D>< w>’GJ.rh.tl0HRw>ChouGH>un;vk>xD.ymxD.w>vXpHmysDtylRvDRI w>ymylxD.bku’d.wz.0HRwcsK;w>yl.vDRbkcsHwz.M.< w>vk>xD.ymxD.yk;cJ.cJ.vXtrh>qD’H.csDcHzsX.vXb.w>[h.M>trHRvXzkt’H.< zHt’H.‘D;ud.zdeDzdwz.M.vDRI

zJw>uhR,d;bkvX[H.tcgnDEk>w>ymyl.vDRbkcsHwqH;wuh>wz.vXusJ’Dwbdp;xD.vXpHmysD< ck;oH.wkRvX[H.wpkM.vDRI w>yl.vDRbk[kwz.’ftHRtcDynDrh>0Jw>eDRtD.w>tD.w>tD’D;q.zduD>zd’D;xd.zdvH.zdwz.M.vDRI wu;’H;b.< w>tHRrh>ph>uD;w>’k;eJ.usJqlySRvJRw>zdvXtw>tD.w>tDvXmuGHmvXusJtylRwz.uG>Ckw>vD>vXbk[ktd.tvD>wz.unDubSgxD.t*D>M.vDRI

w>z;qdw>tw>ohw>b.'D;w>'G;qdw>vXu[JuJxD.o;qlngwz. = w>z;qdw>tw>ohw>b.'D;w>'G;qdw>vXu[JuJxD.o;qlngwz. = ,dR'd.wz.M.nDEk>uG>w>z;qdw>vXngcDwz.M.vDRI w>*h>vXtb.C;’D;w>zdw>vHRvDRr>‘D;w>td.ql.td.cVtw>td.o;wz.M.t0Joh.uG>0J

47


w>qJ;qDCHw>z;M.vDRI zJw>CkxXw>uol.xD.[H.CDtvD>tusJ’D;uFd{dRuD.{dRtvD>tusJwz.tcgw>yl.xD.bk’D;w>usX>bXCmtcd.0HRtvD>cHxkuz.o.urJR0JM.vDRI vXcHwoDM.w>td;xD.bktyl.0JM.0HRw>*H>bkcsH ?eD.*H>qdul< eD.*H>qdwul/ M.vDRI w>*H>tDRrh>M> ?eD.*H>qdul/ M.rh>w> xH.qdvXt*hR’D;rh>M> ?eD.*H>qdwul/ M.rh>w>xH.qdvXtw*hRM.vDRI w>z;qdusJt*RwuvkmM.w>uG>bkyl.tw>td.o;[;*DRw[;*DRM.vDRIbkyl.rh>w[;*DRM.rh>w>xH.qdvXt*hRvDRI rh>[;*DRM.rh>w>xH.qdvXw*hRM.vDRI vXt*RwuvkmM.< w>eDRz;bkteD.*H>eD.’G;’D;eD.*H>vGH>0HRw>uG>eD.*H>vXttd.wh>0HRw>[H;M>w>xH.pdvXt*hR< w*hRwz.M.vDRI

zJ[H.up>cGgvJRw>’h.pXRt,HRM.< ’fod;zDvXw>bgtvD>okwvDR!GH;vDRbJt*D>[H.up>rk.b.uG>xGJqDwvJ0JzDxDbdM.vDRI w>z;w>rRto;’D;ySRvJRw>zdb.Awb.uG>qX.rJm’D;w>uDw>cJcDzsdw>uG>zDvDRnGH;vDRbJ< [;*DRuGHm‘D;,k>th.uGHmtDRM.vDRI

zJt0Joh.td.wql.wcVtcgt0Joh.,gbsgto;vX[H.M.vDRI ySRvX’lylRo0DylRwz.b.oMRxD.’.to;vXuoH.o&.vXt,gbsgw>qg’D;w>tlw>orltusJwz.M.vDRI w>wvd.[h.w>tbl;tvJb.I nDEk>w>b.[h.uhRySR,gbsgw>vXw>ulw>uRM.vDRI

,dR'd.uvkm'l.tw>whw>zsD,dR'd.uvkm'l.tw>whw>zsD = ,dRuvkm'l.zdwz.tw>whw>zsDM.vDRqDvdmo;vXw>vD>w>usJtzDcd.M.vDRI nDEk>vDRqD'.w>ydmcGgzdtrd>ty>wz.b.vJRqdvXrk.ueDR[H.'D;vJRwJqdw>'D;rd>y>wz.M.vDRI ydmrk.zdtrd>ty>wz.[H;M>w>qXuwD>vGH>oD,J>oD'D;wX.yD.oud;0J'D;tbl;twH>wz.M.vDRI b.oHuG>ph>uD;0Jtzdrk.tw>b.o;M.vDRI tzdrk.rh>b.to;M.b.wJb.u'guhR0JydmcGgzdwcDM.vDRI 'fM.tod;< ydmcGgzdtrd>ty>w z.ph>uD;wX.yD.oud;w>'D;ySRo;yS>wz.'D;CkM>0Jrk>eHRrk>oDvXt*hRwz.

48


M.vDRI zJrRM>rk>eHRrk>oDvXt*hR0HRvHwpk< vJRu'D;vXrk.ueDRt[H.vXuChtzdrk.t*D>M.vDRI zJtqXuwD>0JM.< vXydmrk.t[H.utd.'D;wHRoud;'D; [H.zdCDzdwz.utd.cd;ympXRtcd.M.vDRI ySRo;p>vXydmrk.zdwcD}wDCmySRydmcGgt[H.zdCDzdtusJcHwDR< wwDRzJu&X>yJ}wDtcd.xd;'D;t*RwwDRM.rh>0JzJ[H.yJ}wDtcd.xd;wwDRM.vDRI ySRrh>[h.vDRtDRvXusd.zdphzdr;td;xD.M>0JyJ}wDM.vDRI

zJtvJRxD.wkRvX[H.zDcd.M.ySRo;yS>vXydmcGgzdwcDyRb.vJR[H;pkuG>rJm'D;ySRo;yS>vXydmrk.zdwcDM.vDRI ySRo;yS>vXydmrk.zdwcD< ub.ymwoh.ngto;vXydmcGgzdwuyR[Jt*h>M.vDRI ub.oHuG>0J[Jw>*h>t*h>M.vDRIydmcGgzdwuyRwcDwJ0J[JChydmrk.t*h>M.vDRI ub.wJoud;w>'ftHR,>cD,>cDM.vDRI

zJwJ0J'fM.tqXuwD>< ydmcGgzdwuyRub.[JpdmvDcDz;vJ>wbh.'D;vXtylRM.uxXEkmvDR'D;v.z; (eDrk>) cHbd.< obsK.,gcH,g< wuGHo.cHoH.tpSRuwX>ph,J>oH;'D;qD'H.cHzsX.qlydmrk.vXttd.'D;tzdtrgwz.M.vDRI wJw>rh>w0HRrh>ymvDRb.vDcDz;vJ>vXw>zDvmM.ydmrk.zdwuyRtD.uGHm0JohM.vDRI zJwJw>0HRM.ySRvXte>yX>w>wz.b.±l;M>tDRw>vDRI 0HRtvD>cHymwh>qD'H.cHzsX.0HRtD.uGHmw>tD.t*Rwz.w0mohM.vDRI 0HRtvD>cHvXttd.wh>w0mM.vJRvk>xD.0Jqlrk>Cgwz.ttd.M.vDRI

0HRydmrk.zdwuyRb.[h.'k;tD.0JydmcGgwuyRvXrhRM.vDRI b.q.b.u wJmuwDRM>0Jw>tD.vD>vDRqDvDRI zJt0Joh.tD.rhRtqXuwD>zdo.wz.b.[Jqh.eDRvXtuyRtd;M>tDRqD'H.tzH;'D;b.ud;t0Joh.wz.vX<?rdrd< ygyg/ 'D;b.'k;tD.0JqD'H.csDwz.M.vDRI w>ub.zsD.vDRM>wv;rl;ydmrk.ydmcGgtcd.'D;ysHRvXw>orlw,mCmtDRwz.M.vDRI rk.ueDRzd.o.cGgwz.wcDub.[h.'k;tD.vdmo;w>,>cD,>cDM.vDRI

49


wv;rl;ydmcGgub.[h.vDRwv;rl;trd>ty>vXph,J>b;cDzsdtd.zsJ.M>tzdrk.'D;[h.M>0Jw>Ek>xHyORM.vDRI 'fM.tod;vXrk.ueDRwcDub.[h.M>ph>uD;bl;wH>wz.w>tD.w>tDtyORM.vDRI rR0J'ftHRrh>vXuym0Jbl;wH>wz.'fySRtk.uDRw>tod;'D;rh>'fod;uod.uoDrRvdRrRb.tDRzJt0Joh.wz.vDRrl>vDRz;tcgM.vDRI

vXw>vD>weDRbl.xD.bgxD.w>'D;wuGHo.'D;xXEkmvDR0Jn.qH.bd.vXvDcDwz.tylRvDRI ol.uho;yS>wz.b.xk;xD.w>oh.wz.tHR'D;[h.eDRvDR0JqlySR*Roh.wz.ttd.vXutD.utDoud;0Jt*D>M.vDRI ySRvXtzsDM>w>w*R'k;tD0Jwv;rl;ydmrk.'D;xHvXw>xXEkmvDRtDR'D;xl{dRph{dRwz.M. vDRI 0HR'D;wv;rl;ydmrk.[h.'k;tDu'D;wv;rl;ydmcGgvXxHM.vDRI t0Joh.rh> zsDto;M.nDEk>[h.vdmto;'D;w>[h.wz.vDRI

ySRvXtxD.qSXw>wz.’D;ySRzsDM>w>wz.ub.td.’D;rd>y>vXvXySJRySJRvDRI ydmcGgzdtrd>ty>xD.Chydmrk.zd’D;xlph’D;w>ulw>uRwz.vDRI wxD.Ch0J’D;[H.CD[D.cd.vD>wz.b.I ydmcGgzdwz.b.[h.M>w>vXmbl.vXmphRwz.cJvXmvDRI

zJ,dRuD>uvHRpd;wcD< zJw>vJRxD.Chydmrk.zdtcgw>b.[h.vDRxHudvXttd.’D;xHySJRySJR< csD.wbh.vXtvJ>td.cHys>0;0;< xl.rDvXttd.’D;xl.< oJ; o.vXvXySJRySJR'D; rdmth.cG;vXttd.’D;rdmwz.vDRI

vX,dRuD>uvHRxH;wcD< w>b.vJRpdmv.z;b.pD.wyD>< tHo.wyD>< uxHvDRouRwyD>< wuGHo.z;’d.wzk0HRw>vJR[h.tDRqlydmrk.zdtrd>ty>ttd.’D;xlzdphzdvXydmrk.zduu,Xu,Jto;t*D>vDRI

zJvJRtcgub.vJRud;Ckm’D;ySRvXtuwdRw>oh< wJeHRwJthw>oh (tgw

50


uh>zd.o.cGgtcd.) wz.zJtvJRChydmrk.tcgvDRI nDEk>w>rRw>whw>zsDvXydmrk.zdwz.t[H.vDRI td.ph>uD;’D;w>vk>w>v>vXw>}wDxlysHRphysHRtvk>tv>’D;zJwv;rl;[JcDzsdxlysHRphysHRtcgb.[h.0Jusd.zdphzdwz.vDRI zJzsDto;0HRub.td.vXtrHRyS>t[H.weH.0HRr;vJRtd.qd;vXw>vD>t*RohvDRI w>tHRrh>,dRtw>whw>zsDtvk>tv>M.vDRI

drum publication group … · ,dr'd.tw>ph.cjrvxysxr shan folklore (karenversion) drum...

Documents