driving profitable growth for your firm€¦ · law firm failures below average financial...
TRANSCRIPT
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
LawNet Practice Management 16 October
Robin Dicks, The Thriving Company
Phil Gott, Peopleism
Driving profitable growth
for your firm
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Our work with law firms
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Agenda
• What drives the ongoing financial success of your firm?
• What key elements build profit per partner?
• Measuring success
• Introducing the PEP diagnostic
• Growing billings and managing costs – a chance to review your current capability
• Management information that will help drive improvement
• How do successful firms manage performance?
• What third party investors or partners may look for
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Gaining the value from this session
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Law firm failures
Below average financial performance – often including excessive borrowing, significant deferred obligations, low productivity, and poor profitability and housekeeping; Internal dynamics – primarily involving leadership issues, partners with incompatible goals, differences over profit share philosophy, and lack of succession planning; and External dynamics – primarily involving competitive pressures related to the firm’s historical client base, access to new clients and desirable work, and inability to recruit key talent.
Source: Hildebrandt
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Prospects
and
pipeline Order
Book Hours
worked
WIP
WIP billed
Cash
collected
One Model of a Law Firm...
Source: Mark Feeney, The Winning Firm Alliance
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Law Firm Cost Structure
People Direct 50%
People Indirect 10%
Overheads fixed 26%
Overheads variable
8%
Investment 6%
% of cost
Source: Mark Feeney, The Winning Firm Alliance
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
MPF CEO Priorities Monitor
Management teams are expected to give the greatest priority to:
• client relationships
• delivering the firm’s strategy
• process improvement
• motivation & reward
• system & processes
• profitability
Source: Managing Partner’s Forum (June 2012)
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
How do you drive?
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
What drives profitability?
PEP
Increased Billings
Reduced Costs
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Lagging indicators
• Utilisation
• Billing
• Recovery
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
What do leading indicators do?
• Should you care about them?
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
So...
• Financial performance
• Operational Performance
• Market performance
• Client needs
• Prospect needs
• Referrer needs
• Competitor actions
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Some of the problems
Growing external and marketplace
pressures
Management time & resources stretched
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Drivers of financial health
Increased Billings
Reduced Write-off
Improved client acquisition Improved
ability to extend relationships
Increased client value
More productive referrer relationships
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Drivers of financial health
Reduced Costs
Reduced sales costs
Better use of human resources
Resource management
Technologyuse
Risk Management
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Financial health – a closer look at billings
• Today, we will look at:
– Client value
– Ability to extend client relationships
– Ability to acquire new clients
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Self review
Part One – Client Value
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Retaining and developing clients; most important factors (recent law firm example)
14
11
10
5
5
3
3
3
3
1
1
0
0
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
Meeting deadlines, keeping commitments
Cumulative knowledge and expertise
Value for Money
Care and Attention given
Personable and Likeable People
Ability to Communicate Knowledge
Ability to offer Advice quickly
Accessibility and Availability of people
Keeping you informed of progress
Quality of People Overall
Rapport with Team
Billing as Expected
Interest in/Knowledge of Association/Authority
Keeping you informed on issues...
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
“Being a good lawyer isn’t enough”
• “Our most successful relationships are with businesses who have a deep understanding of us...(who) operate as partners”
• “(I value) the over and above things...providing updates, trends seen and training sessions”
• “What would happen if in the panel process they were up against a firm who were essentially as good at claims, but better at some of the added-value things? It would reduce their risk if they were to increase their strategic input.”
• “To put the firm in the best position to win more work, build up a relationship with the people that do the work in certain areas – e.g. the HR team. They may be the ones with work to hand out, not necessarily the Chairman, MD, or myself”
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Self review
Part Two – Extending client relationships
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Self review
Part Three – Acquiring new clients
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Effective Management information
• Is important
• On a subject which can be influenced
• Impacts decision making
• Is measureable
• Enables the firm to respond
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
How full are the columns?
No Commercial
Property
Company
Commercial
Emp’t Law Dispute
Resolution
Residential
Property
Private
Client
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Case Study – Key Performance Indicators
Before
• Fee earners divided into “transactional” and “business developers”
• Measured on number of networking plans produced
• One partner was the “policeman”
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Case Study – Key Performance Indicators
After
• Fee earners measured on the outcome by
– Referrals
– Client satisfaction
• Partner becomes the facilitator of skills improvement
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
The benchmark for you
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
What drives profitability?
PEP
Increased Billings
Reduced Costs
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
What drives profitability?
PEP
Increased Billings
Deliver greater value, cost-effectively
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
The healthy option The quick fix
People & Performance
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
The healthy option The quick fix
• Attract the right people
(for the right reasons)
• Get the very best from
them
• Give them reasons to
want to stay around
• Get the best people
(by throwing money at
them)
• Squeeze every last
hour from them
• Lock them in
People & Performance
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
26
21
21
10
4
11
2
1
29
33
25
25
7
15
2
1
0 10 20 30 40
Financial
Quality of work
More opportunity
Culture of firm
Equity sooner
Profile of firm
Personal reasons
Pushed out Number of times as 1st or 2nd reason
Total number of mentions
Why partners switch firms
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Maister’s “Predictive package”
• “Client satisfaction is a top priority at our firm”
• “We have no room for those who put their personal agenda ahead of the interests of the clients or the office”
• “Management gets the best work out of everybody in the office”
• “Around here you are required, not just encouraged, to learn and develop new skills”
• “People within our office always treat others with respect”
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Self review
Part Five – Productivity
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
“Heavyweight gorilla”
“You can’t
manage me.
I’m a big biller!”
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
“High-flier”
“I’m so marvellous..
…so why is she an
equity partner and
I’m not?”
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
“Individualist”
“That’s a great idea…
…for the rest of you”
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
“Winding down”
“Ahh….
......only 5 more years to go”
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Self review
Part Six – Extending capability
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Law
Firm
Clie
nts
Law
yers
Past
The scope of talent management
Past – Present - Future
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Law
Firm
Clie
nts
Law
yers
Present
The scope of talent management
Past – Present - Future
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Law
Firm
Clie
nts
Law
yers
Future
The scope of talent management
Past – Present - Future
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Self review
Part Seven – Maximising benefits from IT
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Professional services Source: David Maister
Nurse
Psychotherapist
Pharmacist
Brain surgeon
Degree
of intimacy
Degree of skillful customisation
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Rela
tiv
e V
alu
e A
dd
ed
Volume of work available
Unique services
Experiential services
Commodity + services
Commodity services
Price
Sensitive
Price
Insensitive
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
What external investors
would look for
• Profitability (£5m+ after partner earnings)
• Sustainable business model: – Volume / commoditised (but referral fees?)
– Sustainable without you and your partners
– People in the business who do not aspire to be partners
• Few equity partners, so easy to deal with
Is this your firm?
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
“I've never seen so much opportunity as now.”
Bruce McEwan
Adam Smith Blog (Economics of law firms)
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Your assessment of the outlook
for the legal profession ?
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Your assessment of the outlook
for the legal profession ? Happy days are here again
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Your assessment of the outlook
for the legal profession ? Happy days are here again
This is not the end…. the
end of the beginning
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Your assessment of the outlook
for the legal profession ? Happy days are here again
This is not the end…. the
end of the beginning
It’s life Jim, but not as we
know it
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Your assessment of the outlook
for the legal profession ? Happy days are here again
This is not the end…. the
end of the beginning
It’s life Jim, but not as we
know it
We’re doomed
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
Questions, further information, coffee drinking...
Robin Phil
07940 886677
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
07799 060159
www.peopleism.co.uk
Phil Gott
www.peopleism.co.uk
Robin Dicks
www.thrivingcompany.co.uk
The value we got exceeded our expectations. Robin offered ideas, examples and comments to help us decide the best course of action and provided a very high level of service, clarity of documentation and follow-up. The presentation of findings was handled very well and gained the respect of partners Head of Marketing, Regional law firm
The feedback from Phil Gott's sessions is uniformly excellent. He is one of the most successful outside providers we have ever used. He works with the minimum of fuss, and establishes a good rapport with partners. Director of Research & Development, City law firm
Us
Robin Dicks Expertise: Strategic Marketing Development of Client Relationships Key Performance Indicators Performance Management Client & Market Research Business Development
Phil Gott Expertise: Coaching Training Empowerment Performance Management Organisational Development