8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 1/22
=
BF QCO LJ_QJ@ <ra MAAD LBPBD H_ANO #HA" MQ Q_EI_[
J\ ?0>* ;773
WDMBFQB@@8 \et Emfjcmrm
P*\
AO@OFAMFQ 8 \ [jkort Fodsjf
^[BQQOF \QMQOEOFQ @BDOA KR AO@OFAMFQ _FAO[ J[AO[ PBBB
[_DO = & ; J@ LWL8%
= Qco pmrm = j` tco pdmbft bs fjt absputoa Mt tco jut%sot$ tco subt `bdoa
ky tco Wdmbftb``s bs prbem `mlbo fjt embftmbfmkdo obtcor bf dmw jr jf
tco `mlts j` tco lmso mfa tco smeo bs dbmkdo tj ko absebssoa bf%
dbebfo
; Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ Bt bs truo tcmt —jrbnbfmddy tco
prjporty eoftbjfoa bf tco pdmbft slcoaudo bs jrbnbfmtoa `rje \y
Fj8 2*;l= j` mftcmrmsmfmcmddb vbddmno Imsmkm Cjkdb$ Queiur tmdui$
kodjfns tj jfo N \cmarmli$ tco `mtcor j` tco pdmbftb`` mfa tco
ao`ofamft― Kut ao`ofamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ pdmbftb`` wbtc
udtorbjr ejtbvo cms fjt absldjsoa tco `mlt tcmt tco abeofsbjf bf
rospolt tj mkjvo smba survoy fuekor bs jfdy 7 mlros %=7 nuftms stbdd
bf tco fmeo j` N& \cmarmli wbtc [ovofuo Icmtcm Fuekor <<<& Qco
lortb`boa Oxtrmlt j` mkjvo smba pcmfb bs prjauloa ko`jro tcbs Cjf‒kdo
ljurt `jr ibfa porusmd j` tco smeo ms Mffoxuro%M &
< Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt tco `mtcor j`
tco pdmbftb`` mfa ao`ofamft cmvo `jreoa rosbaoftbmd dmyjut bf tco
smba survoy fuekor Kut ao`ofamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ tco `mtcor
j` tco pdmbftb`` mfa ao`ofamft cmvo mppdboa tj Aoputy Ljeebssbjfor
Queiur `jr ljfvorsbjf j` dmfa bf \y Fj8 2*;l j` mftcmrmsmfmcmddb
vbddmno Imsmkm Cjkdb$ Queiur tmdui$ eomsurbfn >? `oot x =?7 `oot
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 2/22
;
#=7 N_FQM\"& Qco smba mppdblmtbjf bs mpprjvoa vbao K&abs& Fj8
MDF\[8 =<0*3>%33 AMQOA 72%=7%=23>& Qco Fjtmrbsoa ljpy j`
mdbofmtbjf jraor bs prjauloa `jr ibfa porusmd j` tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt ms
Mffoxuro%K& Qcbs mdbofmtbjf bs fjt ljffoltoa wbtc subt slcoaudo
prjporty bt bs tco mdbofmtbjf jraor j` ao`ofamft‒s prjporty&
1 Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso mfa ebsdomabfn tj smy
tcmt mf oxtoft j` >? x ==2)==; `oots wms mppdboa `jr mdbofmtbjf mfa
tco smba oxtofts wms tmiof `jr tco ljfstrultbjf j` rosbaoftbmdcjuso Kut ao`ofamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ m`tor mdbofmtbjf j` mf
oxtoft j` >? `oot x =?7 `oot #=7 N_FQM\"$ m sopmrmto pcjab wms emao
ky [ovofuo mutcjrbtbos mfa oftoroa sulc mdbofmtoa dmfa pjrtbjf bf
\urvoy fuekor 2*;l; j` mftcmrmsmfmcmddb vbddmno$ Imsmkm Cjkdb$
Queiur tmdui& Kut pdmbftb`` wbtc udtorbjr ejtbvo cms fjt absldjsoa
tco `mlt tcmt Qjwf pdmffbfn mpprjvmd wms nbvof tj mf oxtoft j` >? x
==2)==; * ; `oot$ Fj8 FM&RJ&W[M8 \&FJ8 32? 8 <;1 8 =23>%33 amtoa8
;3%7?%=233& Qco fjtmrbsoa ljpy j` Qjwf pdmffbfn mpprjvmd bs
prjauloa ms mffoxuro “ L& Qco lortb`boa ljpy j` \urvoy fuekor
2*;l; [QL bs prjauloa `jr ibfa porusmd j` tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt ms
Mffoxuro%A&
? Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ bt bs bfljepdoto mfa wrjfn tj smy
tcmt tco smba oxtofts wms tmiof ky tco ao`ofamft ufaor tco
ronbstoroa rodomso aooa amtoa 7;%70%=233 Kut ao`ofamft cuekdy
sukebts tcmt$ Qco [odomso jr \bfndo pmrtbtbjf aooa ronbstoroa jf
7<%70%=233 vbao Kjji Fj8 = bf Pjd8 Fj8 ;300 mt pmno Fj8 ===%==1 bf
tco yomr =233%32 j` Queiur \ukronbstrmr j``blo wbtc [onbstrmtbjf
fuekor 3>? wms oxolutoa ky ao`ofamft$ ky ldomrdy stmtbfn `mlts bf
pmno ; j` tco aooa ronmrabfn mdbofmtbjf$ tjwf pdmffbfn mpprjvmd$
suksoquoft nb`tbfn j` prjporty tj mf oxtoft j` >?x;3 `oot tj Queiur
Eufblbpmdbty `jr rjma purpjsos& Kut pdmbftb`` wbtc mf udtorbjr ejtbvo
cms fjt absldjsoa tco smba `mlts bf cor pdmbft ovof m`tor mlloptbfn
sulc `mlts bf tco smba rodomso jr sbfndo pmrtbtbjf aooa& Qco fjtmrbzoa
ljpy j` sulc [odomso jr \bfndo pmrtbtbjf aooa bs prjauloa `jr ibfa
porusmd j` tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt ms Mffoxuro% O&
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 3/22
<
0 Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ — Mlljrabfndy mfjtcor sjf j`
scmarmli ky fmeo \ \mesjf mdsj sopmrmtoa `rje tco `mebdy ky
tmibfn tco scmro Oxtoft Omst wost 2; `oot$ Fjrtc \jutc =;>)=;1
`oot ky oxolutbfn ronbstoroa rodomso aooa bf `mvjur j` scmarmli jf
<=%=7%;77;― bs m ebsdomabfn mssortbjf Bt bs `uddy aofboa ky
ao`ofamft Ao`ofamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ m`tor tcbs pdmbftb``
tjji tco mdbofmtoa pjrtbjf$ tco roembfbfn oxtoft wms ;= nuftms jut
j` tcmt == nuftms wms tmiof ky \& \mesjf mfa sulc Icmtcm bs emao
bf rovofuo ronbstor vbao Icmtcm Fuekor ;23 ms lmf ko soof `rje Mffoxuro%M& Qco smba dmfa bs stbdd mnrbludturmd dmfa mfa fj mdbofmtbjf
jraor wms emao bf rospolt tj sulc dmfa$ m rodomso aooa `mflbdy
qujtbfn oxtofts woro oxolutoa wbtcjut mfy donmd kmsbs `jr bt&
> Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ tcmt —tco `mtcor j` tco pdmbftb``
rotmbfoa tco oxtofts roembfbfn Omst%^ost 33 `oot Fjrtc \jutc$
tjwmras Omstorf sbao =;= `oot$ jf wostorf sbao ==0 `oot wcorobf
ljfstrultoa [LL cjuso― bs mf bddonmd mssortbjf Bt bs `uddy aofboa ky
ao`ofamft Ao`ofamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ tco oxtoft roembfoa
m`tor pmrtbtbjf mejfn twj sjf‒s bs =7 Nuftms wcblc wms oftoroa bf
Icmtcm j` Wdmbftb``‒s mfa tcbs ao`ofamft‒s `mtcors fmeo& Qco `mtcor j`
tco pdmbftb`` rotmbfoa sulc oxtoft jfdy& Qco smba dmfa ovof mt prosoft
bs stbdd mnrbludturmd dmfa mfa fj mdbofmtbjf jraor wms emao bf rospolt
tj sulc dmfa$ kut `mtcor j` pdmbftb`` bf ljddusbjf wbtc eufblbpmd
mutcjrbtbos cms lromtoa bddonmd eufblbpmd Icmtcm tj mf oxtoft j`
Omst%^ost 33 `oot Fjrtc \jutc$ tjwmras Omstorf sbao =;= `oot$ jf
wostorf sbao ==0 `oot wbtcjut mfy mdbofmtbjf jraor jr mfy Qjwf
pdmffbfn mpprjvmd& \ulc mttbtuao bs vbjdmtbjf j` \oltbjf 2?#;" mfa
\oltbjf 20 j` Imrfmtmim Dmfa [ovofuo Mlt =201$ pdmbftb`` bs ufaor
donmd pofmd prjvbsbjf mfa sooibfn tcbs Cjf‒kdo ljurts prjloss
wbtcjut ljebfn bf ldomf cmfas ko`jro tco ljurt&
3 Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ tcmt — \ubt slcoaudo prjporty wms
nb`toa ky cbe bf `mvjur j` tco pdmbftb`` ufaor ronbstoroa nb`t aooa
amtoa =0%7>%;771 mfa aodbvoroa pcysblmd pjssossbjf tj tco
pdmbftb`` `jr cor kjfm`bao uso mfa jllupmtbjf― bs m ebsdomabfn
mssortbjf Bt bs `uddy aofboa ky ao`ofamft Ao`ofamft cuekdy
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 4/22
1
sukebts tcmt$ tco `mtcor j` pdmbftb`` mfa ao`ofamft jfdy cma mkjut
=7 nuftms j` dmfa bf cbs fmeo$ co cms fjt ljfvortoa tco smeo jr
emao mfy o``jrt tj cmvo mfy MAD[ jraor tj ljfvort Nuftm
eomsuroeoft tj @oot eomsuroeoft$ cms `mflbdy wrbttof wrjfn
eomsuroeoft j` Omst%^ost 33 `oot Fjrtc \jutc$ tjwmras Omstorf
sbao =;= `oot$ jf wostorf sbao ==0 `oot$ wcblc turfs jut tj mf
mpprjxbemto =71;3 sq `t mfa rjma emrnbf ;101 sq `t wcblc turfs
jut tj ==&3< nuftms& Qcbs tbtdo tj tco oxtoft j` ==&3< nuftms bs fjt
tcoro tj tco ajfjr Er N&\cmarmli& Qmibfn mdd tcoso bddonmd mltsWdmbftb`` bf ljddusbjf j` N&\cmarmli sooibfn ljurts prjloss tj bddonmddy
cbao tcobr ebsaooas&
2 Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ —co #`mtcor" mdsj dbvbfn wbtc tco
pdmbftb`` bf cor eoss tj oio jut cbs dbvodbcjja bf cbs jdaof amys― Bt bs
`uddy aofboa ky ao`ofamft Qcbs `mdso `mlt bs purpjso`uddy arm`toa tj
not tco pbty j` Cjf‒kdo ljurt bfspbto j` tco `mlt tcmt tcbs ao`ofamft‒s
`mtcor bs nottbfn pofsbjf `rje loftrmd njvorfeoft ms rotbroa
Mssbstmft Wjst Emstor mfa wodd j`` bf cbs rotbroa db`o
=7 Qco mvoreofts emao bf soljfa pmrm j` tco pdmbft ldmbebfn
mksjduto jwforscbp mfa pjssossbjf mfa ofhjyeoft j` tco subt
slcoaudo prjporty bs `uddy aofboa Bt bs put tj strblt prjj` j` donmdbty
j` trmfs`or mfa jwforscbp bf tco mddonoa eomsuroeoft Qco
mvoreofts emao bf tco pdmbft soljfa pmrm rodmtoa tj icmtcm bf tco
fmeo j` tco pdmbftb`` mfa pmyeoft j` tmxos tj bt bs `uddy aofboa$ mfa
bt bs dbmkdo tj strblt prjj` wcotcor sulc icmtcm bs emao jut m`tor
mdbofmtbjf mfa tjwf pdmffbfn mpprjvmd Qco eomsuroeofts qujtoa
bf pdmbft btsod` bs bddonmd mfa bts pjssossbjf mfa ofhjyeoft bs btsod`
lmffjt ko mslortmbfoa mt tcbs stmno wbtcjut prjaultbjf j` rovofuo
roljras sulc ms —WMIIM KJJI #CB\\M \_[POR" @J[E ?―$ mfa
—Imrfmtmim [ovbsbjf \ottdoeoft MIM[KMFAC #_QQM[_"―$ tj
mslortmbf tco kjufamrbos j` subt slcoaudo prjporty
== Qco mvoreofts bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft tcmt tcbs ao`ofamft bs
krjtcor j` pdmbftb`` bs fjt aofboa Qco mvoreofts bf pmrm tcroo j`
pdmbft tcmt —ao`ofamft cms ljfstrultoa m rosbaoftbmd cjuso ky
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 5/22
?
oflrjmlcbfn tco wostorf pjrtbjf eomsurbfn ;7; sq `t mfa cms
ljfstrultoa bddonmddy wbtcjut domvbfn tco sot kmli mfa tco smba
oxtofts corobf m`torwmras lmddoa ms subt K slcoaudo prjporty― tcbs
mvoreofts bs tjtmddy `mdso$ Bt bs `uddy aofboa ky ao`ofamft Kut
ao`ofamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ tcoro bs fj oflrjmlceoft jr tcoro bs
fj oflrjmlceoft wbtc rospolt tj sot kmli$ tco pdmbftb`` bs wodd mwmro
j` sulc `mlt mfa coflo tcoy cmvo fjt ldomrdy stmtoa bf subt slcoaudo
prjporty mkjut –K slcoaudo prjporty‒ bfspbto j` kobfn ro`orroa bf
pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft&
=; Ao`ofamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ Qco pdmbftb`` cms mvorroa bf pmrm
tcroo j` tco pdmbft tcmt sco cms aoslrbkoa ejro `uddy tco K slcoaudo
prjporty bf tco rjunc siotlc$ tco rjunc siotlc ljpy bs fjt suppdboa
tj tcbs ao`ofamft$ tco rjunc siotlc bs tjtmddy absputoa ky tcbs
ao`ofamft$ coflo tcbs ao`ofamft rosorvos cbs rbnct tj `bdo `urtcor
wrbttof stmtoeoft m`tor ljpy j` rjunc siotlc bs prjvbaoa ky pdmbftb``&
Qco aoslrbptbjf j` rjunc siotlc mfa ljfsoquoft mddonmtbjf bf pmrm
tcroo j` pdmbft bs ljepdotody aofboa& Qco eomsuroeofts qujtoa bf
pmrm tcroo j` pdmbft mro `mdso& Qcoro bs fj oflrjmlceoft ms tj mddonoa
eomsuroeoft j` ;7; sq `t& Qco pdmbftb`` prjporty bs 0 `oot mwmy `rje
ao`ofamfts kubdabfn dbfo& Qco sot kmli j` 0 `oot mltumddy kodjfns tj
ao`ofamft mfa pdmbftb`` bs ldmbebfn sulc eomsuroeoft wbtcjut mfy
donmd kmsbs&
=< Ao`ofamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ Qco pdmbftb`` mfa `mtcor j` pdmbftb``
auo tj tcobr jda mno cms fjt prjpordy embftmbfoa tcobr mnrbludturmd
dmfa mfa coflo bt bs lmusbfn fubsmflo tj kjtc pdmbftb`` mfa tcbs
ao`ofamft mdsj& \ulc fubsmflo bs sod` lromtoa jfo$ mfa pdmbftb`` `mdsody
mddonbfn sulc tcbfns bf cor pdmbft pmrm tcroo& Qco eomsuroeoft j`
rjjes mfa scoa mro fjt absputoa sulc ljfstrultbjfs mro wbtcbf tco
kjufamry j` ao`ofamft prjporty$ pdmbftb`` bs fjt cmvbfn mfy rbnct
jvor tco smeo& Qco smba ljfstrultbjfs mro ljepdotoa ky ao`ofamft bf
=232 mfa m`tor tcmt tcoro wms fj fow ljfstrultbjfs& Qcoro bs fj
oflrjmlceoft ronmrabfn sulc ljfstrultbjfs& Qco smba ljfstrultbjfs
cmvo fjt oflrjmlcoa mfy j` tco pjrtbjfs j` pdmbftb`` prjporty&
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 6/22
0
=1 Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt
ao`ofamft wmfts tj ifjli j`` vmdumkdo prjporty j` pdmbftb`` Bt bs
`mdso tj smy tcmt rmbf wmtor bs `djwbfn tjwmras pdmbftb`` cjuso mfa
lromtbfn fubsmflo mfa ofamfnorbfn db`o j` pdmbftb`` Bt bs `mdso tj smy
tcoro bs sjeo bfstbnmtbjf `rje bfnofbjus krmbf kocbfa ao`ofamft
Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt ao`ofamft cms ajfo bddonmd mlts mfa donmd jr
bddonmd oflrjmlceofts Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt tcbs ao`ofamft cms
lmusoa amemnos tj pdmbftb`` tj tco tufo j` [s =7$777%77 sbflo ;77;
Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt pdmbftb`` mdjfn wbtc cor `mtcor roquostoaao`ofamft tj aoejdbsc tco ufmutcjrbsoa strulturo wcblc wms
ljfstrultoa bf tco dmfa j` tco pdmbftb``
=? Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt tcbs
ao`ofamft bs ejfboa mfa pjdbtblmddy bf`duofloa porsjf bf tco
djlmdbty mfa cmvbfn kma odoeofts bf cbs cmfa Ao`ofamft cuekdy
sukebts tcmt$ Ljftrmrbdy pdmbftb`` mfa cor `mtcor wbtc sjeo ljurt
kbras mro `bdbfn `mdso lmsos mnmbfst sjeo bfstbtutbjfs bf jraor tj
kdmliembd tcoe mfa tj sottdo tco emttor `jr ejfotmry nmbf& Ms
mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt ao`ofamft
cms tcromtofoa tco pdmbftb`` emfy tbeo fjt tj quostbjf cbe bf tcbs
ronmra
=0& Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs [bnct tj smy tcmt dmfa j`
ao`ofamft bs vmdumkdo dmfa kobfn bt bs mdbofmtoa jfo cmvbfn >?x;3
`oot rjma tjwmras sjutcorf sbao j` tco prjporty Kut ao`ofamft
cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ pdmbftb`` `mdsody ldmbes rbnct jvor tco eufblbpmd
rjma pjrtbjf oxldusbvody `jr tcobr bfnross mfa jutnross$ bfspbto j` tco
`mlt tcmt bt bs pukdbl rjma&
=> Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt dmfa j`
pdmbftb`` bs oflrjmlcoa ky ao`ofamft Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt dmfa j`
pdmbftb`` bs vmdumkdo Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt ao`ofamft cms mdsj
aunnoa sjmi pbt bf tco oflrjmlcoa pjrtbjf Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt
sulc sjmi pbt oeornos `jud seodd Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt bt bs
ofamfnorbfn cuemf db`o
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 7/22
>
=3 Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt auo tj
`jud seodd `mtcor j` pdmbftb`` bs su``orbfn `rje vmrbjus bddfoss Bt bs
`mdso tj smy tcmt `mtcor j` pdmbftb`` spofabfn cuno ejfoy `jr cbs
roljvory mt cbs jda mno Ao`ofamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ ljftrmrbdy
ao`ofamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt pdmbftb`` `mtcor cms `bdoa bepdomabfn
mppdblmtbjf ms NWM cjdaor scjwbfn ab``oroft lmuso bf cbs m``bamvbt&
Wdmbftb`` pdomas cor `mtcor ms koarbaaof mfa bepdomabfn mppdblmft
swomrs cor amunctor ms koarbaaof& Bt bs por`olt mkuso j` prjloss j`
ljurt&
=2 Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt
ao`ofamft cms do`t tco wmsto wmtor pudd jut `rje tco kmtcrjje
tjwmras tco dmfa j` pdmbftb`` Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt tcbs ao`ofamft bs
ofamfnorbfn tco cuemf db`o Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt ao`ofamft wmft
tj cmrmss tco pdmbftb`` Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt ao`ofamft bs emibfn
mfa mttoeptbfn tj ljfstrult poremfoft strulturo tjwmras wostorf
sbao j` cbs cjuso Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt spmlo tjwmras wostorf sbao
j` ao`ofamft cjuso kodjfns tj pdmbftb`` Ljftrmrbdy ao`ofamft
cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ tco 0 `oot spmlo tjwmras wostorf sbao j`
ao`ofamft cjuso kodjfns tj tcbs ao`ofamft mfa bt bs tco donmd sotkmli&
Wdmbftb`` tmibfn mavmftmno j` fjf mdbofmtbjf j` cor mnrbludturmd
prjporty `mdsody ldmbebfn ao`ofamfts sot kmli&
;7 Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt
ao`ofamft bs fjt m dmw mkbabfn lbtbzof Qco `mlt j` fjtblo nbvof ky
pdmbftb`` ljufsod mfa ropdy j` ao`ofamft ljufsod bs fjt aofboa$ kut
tco mddonmtbjf tcmt ropdy bs ovmsbvo bs aofboa Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt
`bdbfn j` lmvomt bs eomft tj cmrmss pdmbftb`̀
;= Ms mddonoa bf pmrm `jur j` tco pdmbft$ Qco ajlueofts prjauloa ky
pdmbftb`` ajos fjt tostb`y `mlt j` pdmbftb``‒s mksjduto pjssossbjf mfa
ofhjyeoft Wdmbftb`` `mbdoa tj prjvbao mfy dbst j` ajlueofts ms
roqubroa ufaor rudos j` prmltblo Qcbs ao`ofamft rosorvos cbs rbnct
tj `bdo maabtbjfmd wrbttof stmtoeoft m`tor suppdybfn dbst j`
ajlueofts ky pdmbftb`` Wdmbftb`` `mbdoa tj prjaulo bepjrtmft
rovofuo ajlueofts wcblc wbdd mslortmbf kjufamrbos mfa oxtoft j`
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 8/22
3
subt slcoaudo prjporty Bfstoma ajlueofts prjauloa ky tcbs
ao`ofamft scjws tcmt pdmbftb`` cms ebsroprosoftoa tj ljurt wbtc
`mio lromtoa ajlueofts ky vbjdmtbfn emfamtjry Imrfmtmim dmfa
rovofuo dmws
;; Qco lmuso j` mltbjf ms scjwf bf tco pmrm `bvo j` pdmbft ky pdmbftb``
ms =0%7>%;771 mfa jf =2%70%;773 bs `mdso Ao`ofamft cms `bfbscoa
cbs cjuso ljfstrultbjf bf =232 btsod`$ tcoro wms fj maabtbjfmd
ljfstrultbjf m`tor =232 Wdmbftb`` mfa cor `mtcor m`tor dbvbfnpomlo`uddy wbtcjut rmbsbfn mfy jkholtbjfs `rje =232 cms lromtoa
`mio lmuso j` mltbjf tcrjunc mf bddonmd mddonmtbjf Coflo subt bs
dbmkdo tj ko absebssoa `jr wmft j` lmuso j` mltbjf Qco mddonoa
lmuso j` mltbjf bs dbmkdo tj strblt prjj` j` tco smeo
;< Qco subt bs kmrroa ky dbebtmtbjf Qco pdmbftb`` mfa cor `mtcor
rosbabfn bf fobnckjurbfn dmfa bs vory eulc mwmro j` tco `mlt j`
ljfstrultbjf mfa ljepdotbjf j` ao`ofamft cjuso bf =232 mfa tcoro
wms fj absputo jr jkholtbjf mt tcmt tbeo jr uftj tj tco tbeo j`
fjtblo soft ky pdmbftb`` jf =2%70%;773 Qco pdmbftb`` mfa cor `mtcor
mro ostjppoa ky —Ostjppod j` Ljfault― mdsj Qco jtcor mddonmtbjfs
emao bf pmrm ? j` tco pdmbft bs jflo mnmbf ropomtoa ky pdmbftb`` mdd
sulc mddonmtbjfs mro `mdso mfa bs aofboa bf tjtj
;1 Qco subt slcoaudo prjporty `jr tco purpjsos j` pmyeoft j` ljurt
`oo bf rospolt tj rodbo` sjunct bf pdmbft prmyor mfa rodbo` ljduef bs
purpjso`uddy ufaor vmduoa$ tco prosoft emriot vmduo j` tco
surrjufabfn pdmlo bs mkjut [s 177 tj [s 077 por sq `t$ bfspbto j`
tco ldmbes tcmt bt bs rosbaoftbmd prjporty ms eoftbjfoa bf subt
mvoreofts mfa slcoaudo$ mfa rodbo` ldmbeoa bs bf rospolt tj
aoldmrmtbjf j` tbtdo$ pdmbftb`` cms tj pmy ljurt `oo jf emriot vmduo
j` tco prjporty$ b` tco emriot vmduo bs tmiof mt [s 177%77 por sq
`oot tcof emriot vmduo j` subt slcoaudo prjporty ljeos tj [s
1=$>=$;77%77$ wcblc lrjssos tco polufbmry hurbsabltbjf j` tcbs
Cjf‒kdo ljurt Coflo subt bs dbmkdo tj ko absebssoa jf tcmt nrjufa
mdsj
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 9/22
2
;? Qco pdmbftb`` cms mdsj sjunct emfamtjry bfhufltbjf uf%ljffoltoa
tj embf rodbo` wcblc cms tj ko vmduoa sopmrmtody ky pmybfn ljurt
`oo `jr tco rodbo` fj8 #l" ms sjunct bf tco pdmbft prmyor mfa rodbo`
ljduef Coflo subt bs beprjpordy vmduoa mfa dbmkdo tj ko absebssoa
ufdoss prjpor ljurt `oo bs pmba$ wbtc prjpor vmdumtbjf sdbp
;0 \ubt bs kma `jr fjf%hjbfaor j` folossmry pmrty tcmt bs ljeebssbjfor
LEL Queiur [jma j` >?x;3 `oot tjwmras sjutcorf sbao j`
ao`ofamfts prjporty oxldusbvody kodjfns tj LEL `jr pukdbl uso kut pdmbftb`` ljftofas bf pmrm tcroo j` pdmbft tcmt bt bs eomft `jr bfnross
mfa onross j` kjtc pmrtbos bflduabfn \ \mesjf Ky sulc mssortbjf
pdmbftb`` wmfts tj ostmkdbsc prbvmto rbnct jvor sulc pukdbl rjma
;> Qco \lcoaudo prjporty bf rospolt tj bts eomsuroeoft bs `uddy
aofboa ky tcbs ao`ofamft Wdmbftb`` bs put tj strblt prjj` j` tco smeo
;3 ̂ btcjut prohuablo tj tco mkjvo ljftoftbjfs$ tcbs Ao`ofamft
cuekdy sukebts$ tcmt$ tco Wdmbftb``s cmvo aodbkormtody emao lortmbf
`mdso mvoreofts tj subt tcobr lmso mnmbfst tcbs Ao`ofamft Qcbs
Ao`ofamft `urtcor sukebts$ tcmt$ tco mvoreofts wcblc mro fjt
spolb`blmddy aofboa jr trmvorsoa coroky mro aooeoa tj ko aofboa ms
`mdso mfa Wdmbftb``s wbdd ko put tj tco strblt prjj` j` tco smeo Qcbs
Ao`ofamft lrmvos `jr ibfa bfaudnoflo j` tcbs Cjf‒kdo Ljurt mfa
tcbs Cjf‒kdo Ljurt emy ko pdomsoa tj mddjw tcbs Ao`ofamft tj rmbso
maabtbjfmd nrjufas$ b` mfy$ mt tco tbeo j` comrbfn tco subt
^CO[O@J[O$ bf tco mkjvo `mlts mfa lbrluestmflos j` tco lmso$ bt bs ejst
rospolt`uddy prmyoa$ tcmt$ tcbs Cjf‒kdo Ljurt emy ko pdomsoa tj absebss
tco subt `bdoa ky tco Wdmbftb``s mnmbfst tcbs Ao`ofamft mdjfn wbtc oxoepdmry
ljsts bf tco bftorost j` hustblo mfa oqubty
MAPJLMQO @J[ AO@OFAMFQ
AO@OFAMFQ
P O [ B @ B L M Q B J F
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 10/22
=7
B$ \ [JKO[Q FOD\JF$ tco Ao`ofamft corobf$ aj coroky vorb`y mfa
aoldmro tcmt$ wcmt bs stmtoa mkjvo bs truo mfa ljrrolt tj tco kost j` ey
ifjwdoano$ bf`jremtbjf mfa kodbo`
Wdmlo8 QueiurAmto8 =2%73%73
AO@OFAMFQ
BF QCO LJ_[Q J@ <ra MAAD LBPBD H_ANO #HA" MQ Q_EI_[
J\ ?0>* ;773
WDMBFQB@@8 \et Emfjcmrm
P*\
AO@OFAMFQ 8 \ [jkort Fodsjf
DB\Q & AJL_EOFQ\ W[JA_LOA KR AO@OFAMFQ
FJ AJL_EOFQ WM[QBL_DM[\ WMNO\ FMQ_[O
M [QL% WCMFB J@ \y Fj8 2*;l= j`
mftcmrmsmfmcmddb vbddmno
= LO[QB@BOA
OSQ[MLQ
K Qco mdbofmtbjf jraor j` Aoputy
ljeebssbjfor Kabs Fj8 MDF\[8
=<0*3>%33 AMQOA 72%=7%=23>
; FJQM[B\OA
LJWR
L Qjwf pdmffbfn mpprjvmd ljpy
FMRJW[M8 \FJ8 32? 8 <;1 8 =23>%33
amtoa8 ;3%7?%=233
= FJQM[B\OA
LJWR
A [QL% WCMFB J@ \y Fj8 2*;l; j`
mftcmrmsmfmcmddb vbddmno
= LO[QB@BOA
OSQ[MLQ
O [odomso jr \bfndo pmrtbtbjf aooa ? FJQM[B\OA
LJWR
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 11/22
==
Wdmlo8 Queiur
Amto8 =2%73%73
Ao`ofamft
Mavjlmto `jr ao`ofamft
PO[B@BLMQBJF
Qco ljftofts j` ajlueofts prjauloa ms mffoxuro M tj O mro truo mfa
ljrrolt tj tco kost j` ey ifjwdoano$ bf`jremtbjf mfa kodbo`
Wdmlo8 Queiur
Amto8 =2%73%73
Ao`ofamft
BF QCO LJ_QJ@ <ra MAAD LBPBD H_ANO #HA" MQ Q_EI_[
J\ ?0>* ;773
WDMBFQB@@8 \et Emfjcmrm
P*\
AO@OFAMFQ 8 \ [jkort Fodsjf
JKHOLQBJF\ QJ QCO [OM\JF\ \^J[FOA BF MAPMFLOEOFQ
MWWDBLMQBJF J@ WDMBFQB@@8%
= Qco mppdblmft Er N\cmarmli cms `bdoa mppdblmtbjf tj mavmflo tco
lmso `rje =2%73%;773 Qco mppdblmft cms fj djlus stmfab tj `bdo
sulc mppdblmtbjf ufdoss co bs porebttoa ufaor Jraor < [udo ; j`
LWL Coflo tco mppdblmtbjf mfa bts mlljepmfybfn m``bamvbt bs dbmkdo
tj ko roholtoa bf dbebfo bf tco bftorost j` Hustblo
; Qco mppdblmft cms swjrfoa tj `mdso m``bamvbt j` `mlts$ tco mddonoa
bflbaofts cmvo fjt cmppofoa mt tco mddonoa tbeo Qco slofmrbj
oxbstbfn ms jf jr ko`jro `bdbfn j` tco mkjvo subt obtcor bf ey
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 12/22
=;
proebsos jr tjwmras mfy j` ey fobnckjurors$ tco smeo slofmrbj bs
ljftbfubfn mfa fj ovoft jr lcmfno cms jllurroa ms mddonoa jr bf
mfy jtcor wmy
< Qco stjfo dmybfn ky fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfors wms stjppoa ky
mppdblmft tcmt bs N\cmarmli wbtc sjeo vofnomflo sjeowcoro bf
=221 Qco stjfo ljepjufa kodjfns tj fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor
tcmt bs N \cmftcmrmhu bf survoy fuekor 2*;a j` MftcmrmsmfmcmddbNrmem$ Imsmkm Cjkdb$ Queiur tmdui Qco smba fobnckjuror bs m
ldjso rodmtbvo j` kjtc N \cmarmli mfa mdsj j` tcbs ao`ofamft
1 Ao`ofamft jr Mppdblmft cms fjtcbfn tj aj wbtc omstorf pjrtbjf j`
ao`ofamfts dmfa jfdy porsjf wcj lmf quostbjf mfy nrbovmflo ms tj
omstorf pjrtbjf j` ao`ofamft dmfa bs Er N \cmftcmrmhu Qco
mppdblmft ldmfaostbfody jut j` bdd%wbdd mfa nruano cms `bdoa
mavmfloeoft mppdblmtbjf hust tj cmrmss tcbs ao`ofamft wcof co
wms jut j` tjwf tj omrf cbs kroma
? Qcoro bs fj lmuso tj mavmflo tco lmso mfa tco mddonoa lmuso bs
`mkrblmtoa jfo hust tj cmrmss tcbs ao`ofamft Qco mppdblmft mddonos
tcmt co cms dmba tco stjfo sdmks Bf mltumdbty bt bs tco stjfo sdmks j`
fobnckjuror Bt mejufts tj fjf%hjbfaor j` folossmry pmrty mfa
mdsj prjsolutbjf j` fow lmuso j` mltbjf fjt rodmtoa tj tco subt
lmuso
0 Ms mddonoa bf tco mppdblmtbjf tcbs ao`ofamft bs fjt pjwor`ud tcmf
cbs `mtcor fjfo jtcor tcmf tco mppdblmft Qco mppdblmft bf tco mno
j` 3= yomrs scjwbfn cbs bepmtboft mrrjnmflo mfa vofnomflo ky
`jrnottbfn cbs pmst oxporboflo j` db`o Bf fj wmy tcbs ao`ofamft cms
scjwf mfy mrrjnmflo tjwmras cbs `mtcor Bf fj wmy ao`ofamft bs
ao`mlbfn tco strulturo bf jraor tj absprjvo tco pdmbft rjunc siotlc
Wdmbft rjunc siotlc bs fjt m donmddy mutcoftblmtoa ajlueoft
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 13/22
=<
> Qco subt slcoaudo prjporty bs stbdd mf mnrbludturmd dmfa$ fjt
ljfvortoa tj fjf%mnrbludturmd uso$ jfdy rovofuo ajlueofts lmf
mslortmbf truo kjufamrbos j` subt slcoaudo prjporty Qco icmtcm
mfa bts eomsuroeofts bf eufblbpmd roljras mro fjt emao bf m donmd
wmy \ulc bddonmd ajlueofts lmffjt `jre tco kmsbs `jr mfy ldmbes
j` obtcor pdmbftb`` jr cor mppdblmft
3 Qco eomsuroeofts qujtoa bf pdmbft btsod` bs bddonmd mfa bts
pjssossbjf mfa ofhjyeoft bs btsod` lmffjt ko mslortmbfoa mt tcbsstmno wbtcjut prjaultbjf j` rovofuo roljras sulc ms —WMIIM
KJJI #CB\\M \_[POR" @J[E ?―$ mfa —Imrfmtmim [ovbsbjf
\ottdoeoft MIM[KMFAC #_QQM[_"―$ tj mslortmbf tco kjufamrbos
j` subt slcoaudo prjporty
2 Bf tcbs mno dbstofbfn tj kma oljfjeblmddy nrooay vjblos tco
mppdblmft mfa pdmbftb`` mro prjsolutbfn `mdso ljepdmbfts mfa lmsos
Wdmbftb`` mfa mppdblmft emy ko mavbsoa ky tcbs Cjf‒kdo ljurt tj
mpprjmlc ljflbdbmtbjf mfa ljufsoddbfn `jrue tj sottdo tco emttor bf m
pomlo`ud wmy bf jraor tj mvjba uf%folossmry dbtbnmtbjf mfa wmsto j`
tbeo ̀ rje wrjfn mavbsos
Mavjlmto `jr Ao`ofamft Ao`ofamft
PO[B@BLMQBJF
B aj m``bre mkjvo ljftofts ms truo mfa ljrrolt tj tco kost j` ey
ifjwdoano mfa kodbo`
Wdmlo8 Queiur
Amto8 73%73%73
Ao`ofamft
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 14/22
=1
BF QCO LJ_QJ@ <ra MAAD LBPBD H_ANO #HA" MQ Q_EI_[
J\ ?0>* ;773
WDMBFQB@@8 \et Emfjcmrm
P*\
AO@OFAMFQ 8 \ [jkort Fodsjf
JKHOLQBJF\ QJ QCO MWWDBLMQBJF J@ WDMBFQB@@ _FAO[ J[AO[ <
[_DO ; 8%
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 15/22
=?
= Qco mppdblmft Er N\cmarmli cms `bdoa mppdblmtbjf tj sooi
porebssbjf tj prjsoluto tco lmso Qco `mlts swjrfoa bf tco
m``bamvbt mro `mdso
; Qcoro bs fj suppjrtbfn ajlueoft tj prjvo tco romsjfs swjrfoa bf
tco m``bamvbt
< Qco pdmbftb`` bs vory eulc cmdo mfa comdtcy mfa prosoft jf <7%7>%
;773 ko`jro tco ljurt
1 Qco romsjf swjrfoa bs `mdso$ pdmbftb`` bs fjt mnoa$ jfdy tco
mppdblmft bs mnoa Qco mppdblmft cms fjt scjwf prjpor lmuso tj `bdosulc mppdblmtbjf
? Qco mppdblmtbjf bs fjt embftmbfmkdo obtcor bf dmw jr jf `mlts
0 Coflo tco mppdblmtbjf mfa bts mlljepmfybfn m``bamvbt bs dbmkdo tj ko
roholtoa bf dbebfo bf tco bftorost j` Hustblo
> Wdmbftb`` cms mddonoa oflrjmlceoft bf wostorf sbao j` ao`ofamft
prjporty bf tco pdmbft$ wcblc bs absputoa ky tcbs ao`ofamft kut fjw
mppdblmft cms `bdoa mppdblmtbjf ms mf mnoft tj put `jrwmra cbs jwf
lmuso ldmbebfn cbs tbtdo tj stjfo ljepjufa$ wcblc bs bf fj wmy
rodmtoa tj prosoft subt Qco mppdblmft cms tj `bdo sopmrmto subt
bepdomabfn fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor bf jraor tj ldmbe
fobnckjurors stjfo ljepjufa
3 Qcoro bs fj lmuso tj mavmflo tco lmso jr tj `bdo tco mppdblmtbjf
mppjbftbfn mnoft mfa tco mddonoa lmuso bs `mkrblmtoa jfo hust tj
cmrmss tcbs ao`ofamft
2 Bf tcbs mno dbstofbfn tj kma oljfjeblmddy nrooay vjblos tco
mppdblmft mfa pdmbftb`` mro prjsolutbfn `mdso ljepdmbfts mfa lmsos
=7 Bt bs cuekdy sukebttoa tcmt$ Wdmbftb`` mfa mppdblmft emy ko mavbsoa
ky tcbs Cjf‒kdo ljurt tj mpprjmlc ljflbdbmtbjf mfa ljufsoddbfn
`jrue tj sottdo tco emttor bf m pomlo`ud wmy bf jraor tj mvjba uf%
folossmry dbtbnmtbjf mfa wmsto j` tbeo `rje wrjfn mavbsos Fj
cmre jr bfhury wbdd ko lmusoa tj mppdblmft*pdmbftb`` b` tcbs BM bs
absebssoa Jf tco jtcor cmfa tcbs ao`ofamft wbdd ko put tj nromt
cmrascbp ky tco bddonmd mlts j` mppdblmft*pdmbftb`` wcj emy tmio
mavmftmno j` mfy bftorbe jraors mfa oflrjmlc upjf prjporty j`
fobnckjuror lromtbfn tofsbjf ko`jro ao`ofamft cjuso
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 16/22
=0
^coro`jro tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt emy ko pdomsoa tj absebss mppdblmtbjf bf tco
bftorost j` hustblo
Mavjlmto `jr Ao`ofamft Ao`ofamft
PO[B@BLMQBJF
B aj m``bre mkjvo ljftofts ms truo mfa ljrrolt tj tco kost j` eyifjwdoano mfa kodbo`
Wdmlo8 Queiur
Amto8 73%73%73
Ao`ofamft
BF QCO LJ_QJ@ <ra MAAD LBPBD H_ANO #HA" MQ Q_EI_[
J\ ?0>* ;773
WDMBFQB@@8 \et Emfjcmrm
P*\
AO@OFAMFQ 8 \ [jkort Fodsjf
JKHOLQBJF\ QJ QCO MWWDBLMQBJF J@ WDMBFQB@@ _FAO[ J[AO[ <2
[_DO = & ; 8%
= Qco BM bs fjt embftmbfmkdo obtcor jf `mlts jr jf dmw
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 17/22
=>
; Qco `mlts swjrfoa bf tco m``bamvbt mro `mdso mfa ebsdomabfn wbtcjut
nbvbfn ldomr pblturo ms tj wcmt mppdblmft wmft‒s tj ljfvoy tj tco
Cjf‒kdo ljurt
< Qcbs ao`ofamft cms fjt absemftdoa tco stjfo sdmks ljepjufa
tjwmras omstorf sbao j` tco ao`ofamft‒s prjporty Wdmbftb`` cms
mddonoa oflrjmlceoft bf wostorf sbao j` ao`ofamft prjporty bf tco
pdmbft$ wcblc bs absputoa ky tcbs ao`ofamft kut fjw mppdblmft cms`bdoa mppdblmtbjf ms mf mnoft tj put `jrwmra cbs jwf lmuso ldmbebfn
cbs tbtdo tj stjfo ljepjufa$ wcblc bs bf fj wmy rodmtoa tj prosoft
subt Qco mppdblmft cms tj `bdo sopmrmto subt bepdomabfn
fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor bf jraor tj ldmbe fobnckjurors stjfo
ljepjufa
1 Qco mppdblmft mddonos tcmt co cms dmba tco stjfo sdmks Bf mltumdbty bt
bs tco stjfo sdmks j` fobnckjuror Bt mejufts tj fjf%hjbfaor j`
folossmry pmrty mfa mdsj prjsolutbjf j` fow lmuso j` mltbjf fjt
rodmtoa tj tco subt lmuso
? Qco fobnc kjurbfn dmfa Jwfor bs Ers Coemdmtcm N \cmftcmrmhu
mfa tcmt dmfa bs mdsj mf mnrbludturmd dmfa$ tcoro wms vorkmd absputo
kotwoof N \cmarmli mfa N \cmftcmrmhu jvor tco dmybfn j` stjfo
ljepjufa ky N \cmftcmrmhu bf =221
0 Qco stjfo dmybfn ky fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfors wms stjppoa ky
mppdblmft tcmt bs N\cmarmli wbtc sjeo vofnomflo bf =221 Qco
stjfo ljepjufa kodjfns tj fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor tcmt bs Dmto
N \cmftcmrmhu bf survoy fuekor 2*;a j` Mftcmrmsmfmcmddb Nrmem$
Imsmkm Cjkdb$ Queiur tmdui Qco smba fobnckjuror bs m ldjso
rodmtbvo j` kjtc N \cmarmli mfa mdsj j` tcbs ao`ofamft
> Wdmbftb`` jr Mppdblmft cms fjtcbfn tj aj wbtc omstorf pjrtbjf j`
ao`ofamfts dmfa jfdy porsjf wcj lmf quostbjf mfy nrbovmflo ms tj
omstorf pjrtbjf j` ao`ofamft dmfa bs Ers Coemdmtcm N
\cmftcmrmhu Qco mppdblmft ldmfaostbfody jut j` bdd%wbdd mfa nruano
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 18/22
=3
cms `bdoa mavmfloeoft mppdblmtbjf hust tj cmrmss tcbs ao`ofamft
wcof co wms jut j` tjwf tj omrf cbs kroma
3 Qco subt slcoaudo prjporty bs stbdd mf mnrbludturmd dmfa$ fjt
ljfvortoa tj fjf%mnrbludturmd uso$ jfdy rovofuo ajlueofts `rje
Qmcsbdamr j``blo lmf mslortmbf truo kjufamrbos j` subt slcoaudo
prjporty Qco icmtcm mfa bts eomsuroeofts bf eufblbpmd roljras
mro fjt emao bf m donmd wmy \ulc bddonmd ajlueofts lmffjt `jre
tco kmsbs `jr mfy ldmbes j` obtcor pdmbftb`` jr cor mppdblmft
2 Qco eomsuroeofts qujtoa bf pdmbft btsod` bs bddonmd mfa bts
pjssossbjf mfa ofhjyeoft bs btsod` lmffjt ko mslortmbfoa mt tcbs
stmno wbtcjut prjaultbjf j` rovofuo roljras sulc ms —WMIIM
KJJI #CB\\M \_[POR" @J[E ?―$ mfa —Imrfmtmim [ovbsbjf
\ottdoeoft MIM[KMFAC #_QQM[_"―$ tj mslortmbf tco kjufamrbos
j` subt slcoaudo prjporty
=7 Obtcor pdmbftb`` jr Mppdblmft cmvo prjauloa rodovmft ajlueofts tj
scjw tco oxmlt kjufamry emri j` subt slcoaudo prjporty Qco
rjunc siotlc bs mf bddonmd ajlueoft
== Qcbs ao`ofamft cms fjt oflrjmlcoa upjf obtcor pdmbftb``‒s prjporty
jr mppdblmft‒s rbncts
=; Qcbs ao`ofamft cms fjt roejvoa cmakust stjfo jr mfy stjfo sdmks
Qcbs ao`ofamft cms fj rbncts jvor tco mahjbfbfn dmfas wcblc bs
jtcors prjporty
=< Qco mppdblmft wmfts tj ljf`uso tcbs ao`ofamft ky `bdbfn mf m``bamvbt
wbtcjut cmvbfn ljeem jr pudstjp Qco softoflo `jreoa ajos fjt
nbvo mfy ldomr eomfbfn Qco mppdblmft wmfts tj bddonmddy bftorprot
mfa nmbf jut j` sulc aumd eomfbfn wjras
=1 Qco pdmbftb`` cms fjt sjunct mfy rodbo` tjwmras omstorf sbao j`
ao`ofamft‒s prjporty Qco pdmbftb``‒s mddonmtbjf bf pdmbft bs tjwmras
wostorf sbao j` ao`ofamft‒s prjporty
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 19/22
=2
=? Qco mppdblmft rmbsos m fow lmuso ufrodmtoa tj mddonoa lmuso bf
pdmbft mvoreofts Qco prjportbos mro vory eulc tcoro bt bs fjt
omtmkdo tcbfn tj swmddjw
=0 B` pdmbftb`` prjvos cor donmddy vmdba tbtdo tj abeofsbjfs j` subt
slcoaudo prjporty sco bs cmvbfn vory eulc dbkorty tj tmio mltbjf bf
tco mkjvo subt Qcbs ao`ofamft lmffjt aostrjy tco kjufamry emris
jr fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfors rbncts B` sulc tcbfn cms cmppofoa bt bs fobnckjuror wcj emy cmvo ljepdmbfoa mt ̀ brst bfstmflo
=> ̂ btc mf bddonmd bftoftbjf mppdblmft wmfts tj tmio sjeo bftorbe
jraor `rje tco ljurt ky scjwbfn fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor ms ey
mnoft mfa wmfts tj prjsoluto fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor ky
aoprbvbfn tcobr rbncts tj tcobr dmfa Qcbs lmffjt ko mddjwoa bf tco
bftorost j` Hustblo
=3 Qcoro bs fj prbem `mlbo lmso jr kmdmflo j` ljfvofboflo bf `mvjur j`
pdmbftb`` jr mppdblmft Fj bfhury wbdd ko lmusoa tj pdmbftb`` jr
mppdblmft B` tco BM bs mddjwoa$ tmibfn mavmftmno j` ljurt jraor
pdmbftb`` jr mppdblmft emy `bdo lmso mnmbfst fobnckjurbfn dmfa
jwfor bf jraor tj sottdo mppdblmft‒s pmst nrbovmflos
=2 Qco pcjtjnrmpcs prjauloa aj fjt ro`dolt mfy lmuso Qco rjunc
siotlc bs fjt m prjpor ajlueoft `jr mf mnrbludturmd dmfa
;7 Bf jraor tj ioop pomlo mfa mebty ao`ofamft bs romay tj `bdo
m``bamvbt stmtbfn co ajos fjt bftor`oro bf tco prosoft stmto j` m``mbrs
bf tco pdmbft slcoaudo prjporty Dot tco pdmbftb`` mfa mppdblmft mdsj
ufaortmio wbtc sulc m``bamvbt stmtbfn tcmt tcoy mro fjt cmvbfn mfy
bftoftbjf tj bftor`oro wbtc ao`ofamfts prjporty Qcbs ajos fjt
eomf ao`ofamft cms mlloptoa pdmbftb``‒s ldmbes jvor tco `mdsb`boa
eomsuroeofts j` subt slcoaudo prjporty Wdmbftb`` bs put tj strblt
prjj` j` tco smeo mfa fjt mt dbkorty tj wbtcarmw tco subt wbtcjut
pmybfn mfy amemnos tj tco ao`ofamft
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 20/22
;7
;= Qco mppdblmft cms fj djlus stmfab tj `bdo tcbs mppdblmtbjf ufdoss co
wms porebttoa tj mlt ms mf mnoft j` pdmbftb`` Qco mppdblmtbjf bs
proemturo Qco bftorbe mppdblmtbjf cms fjt ldomrdy scjwf
slcoaudo `jr wcblc bfhufltbjf bs sjunct Qco pdmbftb`` cms ljf`usoa
tcbs ao`ofamft ky `bdbfn pdmbft mvoreofts bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft
stmtbfn mkjut –K slcoaudo prjporty‒ kut pdmbft ajos fjt cmvo mfy K
slcoaudo prjporty Wdmbftb`` cms fjt prjvbaoa mfy [junc \iotlc
ljpy jr dbst j` ajlueofts bf jraor tj ebsdoma tcbs ao`ofamft mfa
ljurt ky `bdbfn `mdso subt ldmbe Fj cmre jr bfhury wbdd ko lmusoa tjmppdblmft*pdmbftb`` b` tcbs BM bs absebssoa Jf tco jtcor cmfa tcbs
ao`ofamft wbdd ko put tj nromt cmrascbp ky tco bddonmd mlts j`
mppdblmft*pdmbftb`` wcj emy tmio mavmftmno j` mfy bftorbe jraors
mfa oflrjmlc upjf prjporty j` fobnckjuror lromtbfn tofsbjf
ko`jro ao`ofamft cjuso
^coro`jro tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt emy ko pdomsoa tj absebss mppdblmtbjf bf tco
bftorost j` hustblo
Mavjlmto `jr Ao`ofamft Ao`ofamft
PO[B@BLMQBJF
B aj m``bre mkjvo ljftofts ms truo mfa ljrrolt tj tco kost j` ey
ifjwdoano mfa kodbo`
Wdmlo8 Queiur
Amto8 73%73%73
Ao`ofamft
BF QCO LJ_QJ@ <ra MAAD LBPBD H_ANO #HA" MQ Q_EI_[
J\ ?0>* ;773
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 21/22
;=
WDMBFQB@@8 \et Emfjcmrm
P*\
AO@OFAMFQ 8 \ [jkort Fodsjf
M@@BAMPBQ
B [jkort Fodsjf \*J N\cmarmli mnoa mkjut ?7 yomrs rosbaoft j`
Queiur$ tco ao`ofamft bf tco mkjvo lmso aj sjdoefdy m``bre mfa stmto
jf jmtc ms `jddjws8%
= Qco pdmbftb`` cms `bdoa mkjvo lmso mnmbfst eo$ bme swomrbfn jf
m``bamvbt mkjut tco romd `mlts j` tco lmso
; Qco subt slcoaudo prjporty bs stbdd mf mnrbludturmd dmfa$ fjt
ljfvortoa tj fjf%mnrbludturmd uso$ jfdy rovofuo ajlueofts `rje
Qmcsbdamr j``blo lmf mslortmbf truo kjufamrbos j` subt slcoaudo
prjporty Qco icmtcm mfa bts eomsuroeofts j` subt slcoaudo
prjporty bf eufblbpmd roljras mro fjt emao bf m donmd wmy m`tor
mdbofmtbjf mfa tjwf pdmffbfn \ulc bddonmd ajlueofts lmffjt `jre
tco kmsbs `jr mfy ldmbes j` obtcor pdmbftb`` jr cor mppdblmft
< Bf jraor tj ioop mebty mejfn ey fobnckjurcjja$ —B aj swomr bf
tco fmeo j` nja tcmt bme bf fj wmy ljfstrult jvor tco subt
slcoaudo prjporty uftbd abspjsmd j` tcbs subt― Qcbs ajos fjt eomf B
cmvo mlloptoa tco jwforscbp j` subt slcoaudo prjporty Qcbs ajos
fjt eomf B wjf‒t ljfstrult bf ey vmlmft dmfa dmybfn tjwmras
omstorf sbao j` ey cjuso$ m`tor tmibfn auo dbloflo `rje tco
eufblbpmd mfa Q_AM mutcjrbtbos B` B tmio mfy porebssbjf `jr
ljfstrultbjf bf ey dmfa$ B wbdd krbfn tj tco ifjwdoano j` tcbs
Cjf‒kdo ljurt aurbfn tco pofaofly j` subt m`tor prjaulbfn mdd
rodovmft pmpors rodmtoa tj smfltbjf
8/8/2019 Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/written-statement-and-objections-on-behalf-of-defendant-in-injunction-suit 22/22
1 Wdmbftb`` cms mddonoa oflrjmlceoft bf wostorf sbao j` ao`ofamft
prjporty bf tco pdmbft$ wcblc bs absputoa ky tcbs ao`ofamft kut fjw
mppdblmft cms `bdoa mppdblmtbjf ms mf mnoft tj put `jrwmra cbs jwf
lmuso ldmbebfn cbs tbtdo tj stjfo ljepjufa$ wcblc bs bf fj wmy
rodmtoa tj prosoft subt Qco mppdblmft cms tj `bdo sopmrmto subt
bepdomabfn fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor bf jraor tj ldmbe
fobnckjurors stjfo ljepjufa
? B` pdmbftb`` bs mkdo tj prjvo cor mddonoa eomsuroeoft j` subt slcoaudo prjporty mfa mddonoa oflrjmlceoft m`tor auo
eomsuroeoft `rje rovofuo survoy mutcjrbtbos ky eomsurbfn mdd
tco fobnckjurcjja dmfas$ bme romay tj pmy amemnos tj pdmbftb``
mfa romay tj aostrjy mfy j` ey prjvoa oflrjmlceofts mt ey porbd
0 Fj cmre jr bfhury wbdd ko lmusoa tj mppdblmft*pdmbftb`` b` tcbs BM bs
absebssoa Jf tco jtcor cmfa tcbs ao`ofamft wbdd ko put tj nromt
cmrascbp ky tco bddonmd mlts j` mppdblmft*pdmbftb`` wcj emy tmio
mavmftmno j` mfy bftorbe jraors mfa oflrjmlc upjf prjporty j`
fobnckjuror lromtbfn tofsbjf ko`jro ao`ofamft cjuso
^coro`jro tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt emy ko pdomsoa tj absebss mppdblmtbjfs j`
mppdblmft bf tco bftorost j` hustblo
B aj swomr mfa m``bre mkjvo ljftofts ms truo mfa ljrrolt mfa sbnf ms
kodjw
Wdmlo8 Queiur
Amto8 73%73%73
Ao`ofamft