Würzburg
N. Oswald
Workshop: Adolf Hurwitz and David
Hilbert.
Two universal mathematicians.
Nicola Oswald
July 22, 2014
1 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
WorkshopA definition...
a place where things are made or repaired
a class or series of classes in which a small group of peoplelearn the methods and skills used in doing something
2 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Research questionTeacher-Student-Relation.
Question
Adolf Hurwitz and David Hilbert:
When was the turning point in their relationship? Who
benefited from whom?
3 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Adolf Hurwitz.A zealous character.
* 1859 in Hildesheim
”He was of enormous reliability, loyalty and love
of justice.”
Ida Samuel-Hurwitz, Biographical Dossier, Archive ETH Zurich.
6 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Adolf Hurwitz.A zealous character.
* 1859 in Hildesheim
Student of H.C.H. Schubert
”He was of enormous reliability, loyalty and love
of justice.”
Ida Samuel-Hurwitz, Biographical Dossier, Archive ETH Zurich.
6 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Adolf Hurwitz.A zealous character.
* 1859 in Hildesheim
Student of H.C.H. Schubert
1881 Doctorate with advisor FelixKlein
”He was of enormous reliability, loyalty and love
of justice.”
Ida Samuel-Hurwitz, Biographical Dossier, Archive ETH Zurich.
6 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Adolf Hurwitz.A zealous character.
* 1859 in Hildesheim
Student of H.C.H. Schubert
1881 Doctorate with advisor FelixKlein
1882 Habilitation in Göttingen
”He was of enormous reliability, loyalty and love
of justice.”
Ida Samuel-Hurwitz, Biographical Dossier, Archive ETH Zurich.
6 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Adolf Hurwitz.A zealous character.
* 1859 in Hildesheim
Student of H.C.H. Schubert
1881 Doctorate with advisor FelixKlein
1882 Habilitation in Göttingen
1884 Professorship in Königsberg
”He was of enormous reliability, loyalty and love
of justice.”
Ida Samuel-Hurwitz, Biographical Dossier, Archive ETH Zurich.
6 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Adolf Hurwitz.A zealous character.
* 1859 in Hildesheim
Student of H.C.H. Schubert
1881 Doctorate with advisor FelixKlein
1882 Habilitation in Göttingen
1884 Professorship in Königsberg
1892 Professorship at Polytechnic(ETH) Zurich
”He was of enormous reliability, loyalty and love
of justice.”
Ida Samuel-Hurwitz, Biographical Dossier, Archive ETH Zurich.
6 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Adolf Hurwitz.A zealous character.
* 1859 in Hildesheim
Student of H.C.H. Schubert
1881 Doctorate with advisor FelixKlein
1882 Habilitation in Göttingen
1884 Professorship in Königsberg
1892 Professorship at Polytechnic(ETH) Zurich
| 1919 in Zurich
”He was of enormous reliability, loyalty and love
of justice.”
Ida Samuel-Hurwitz, Biographical Dossier, Archive ETH Zurich.
6 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Adolf Hurwitz.A mathematical talent with prominent contacts.
Additive Geometry: Theorem of Chasles (1876)
7 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Adolf Hurwitz.A mathematical talent with prominent contacts.
Additive Geometry: Theorem of Chasles (1876)
Modular Forms (1881), Riemann-Hurwitz-Formula (1893)
7 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Adolf Hurwitz.A mathematical talent with prominent contacts.
Additive Geometry: Theorem of Chasles (1876)
Modular Forms (1881), Riemann-Hurwitz-Formula (1893)
Theorem about zeros of sequences of functions (1889)
7 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Adolf Hurwitz.A mathematical talent with prominent contacts.
Additive Geometry: Theorem of Chasles (1876)
Modular Forms (1881), Riemann-Hurwitz-Formula (1893)
Theorem about zeros of sequences of functions (1889)
Results on continued fraction expansions (since 1882)
7 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Adolf Hurwitz.A mathematical talent with prominent contacts.
Additive Geometry: Theorem of Chasles (1876)
Modular Forms (1881), Riemann-Hurwitz-Formula (1893)
Theorem about zeros of sequences of functions (1889)
Results on continued fraction expansions (since 1882)
Approximation Theorem (1891)
Since 1888 regular exchange with
7 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
David Hilbert.As well a zealous character.
* 1862 in Königsberg
” [...] Then Hilbert’s greatness is based on an
overwhelming sensibility.”
Otto Blumenthal, Lebensgeschichte, Collected Papers of David Hilbert, 1932
8 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
David Hilbert.As well a zealous character.
* 1862 in Königsberg
Student of Adolf Hurwitz
” [...] Then Hilbert’s greatness is based on an
overwhelming sensibility.”
Otto Blumenthal, Lebensgeschichte, Collected Papers of David Hilbert, 1932
8 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
David Hilbert.As well a zealous character.
* 1862 in Königsberg
Student of Adolf Hurwitz
1885 Doctorate supervized byFerdinand Lindemann
” [...] Then Hilbert’s greatness is based on an
overwhelming sensibility.”
Otto Blumenthal, Lebensgeschichte, Collected Papers of David Hilbert, 1932
8 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
David Hilbert.As well a zealous character.
* 1862 in Königsberg
Student of Adolf Hurwitz
1885 Doctorate supervized byFerdinand Lindemann
1885/6 at the University ofLeipzig (Felix Klein), Stay in Paris
” [...] Then Hilbert’s greatness is based on an
overwhelming sensibility.”
Otto Blumenthal, Lebensgeschichte, Collected Papers of David Hilbert, 1932
8 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
David Hilbert.As well a zealous character.
* 1862 in Königsberg
Student of Adolf Hurwitz
1885 Doctorate supervized byFerdinand Lindemann
1885/6 at the University ofLeipzig (Felix Klein), Stay in Paris
1886 Habilitation in Königsberg
” [...] Then Hilbert’s greatness is based on an
overwhelming sensibility.”
Otto Blumenthal, Lebensgeschichte, Collected Papers of David Hilbert, 1932
8 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
David Hilbert.As well a zealous character.
* 1862 in Königsberg
Student of Adolf Hurwitz
1885 Doctorate supervized byFerdinand Lindemann
1885/6 at the University ofLeipzig (Felix Klein), Stay in Paris
1886 Habilitation in Königsberg
1892 Professorship in Königsberg
” [...] Then Hilbert’s greatness is based on an
overwhelming sensibility.”
Otto Blumenthal, Lebensgeschichte, Collected Papers of David Hilbert, 1932
8 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
David Hilbert.As well a zealous character.
* 1862 in Königsberg
Student of Adolf Hurwitz
1885 Doctorate supervized byFerdinand Lindemann
1885/6 at the University ofLeipzig (Felix Klein), Stay in Paris
1886 Habilitation in Königsberg
1892 Professorship in Königsberg
1895 Professorship in Göttingen
” [...] Then Hilbert’s greatness is based on an
overwhelming sensibility.”
Otto Blumenthal, Lebensgeschichte, Collected Papers of David Hilbert, 1932
8 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
David Hilbert.As well a zealous character.
* 1862 in Königsberg
Student of Adolf Hurwitz
1885 Doctorate supervized byFerdinand Lindemann
1885/6 at the University ofLeipzig (Felix Klein), Stay in Paris
1886 Habilitation in Königsberg
1892 Professorship in Königsberg
1895 Professorship in Göttingen
| 1943 in Göttingen
” [...] Then Hilbert’s greatness is based on an
overwhelming sensibility.”
Otto Blumenthal, Lebensgeschichte, Collected Papers of David Hilbert, 1932
8 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Königsberg 1884 - 1892Hilbert.
”At that time still a student, Hurwitz soon encouraged me for ascientific exchange and I was lucky, that by being together withhim, in the easiest and most interesting way, I got to know thedirections of thoughts of the at that time opposite, howevereach other superbly complementing shools, the geometricalschool of Klein and the algebraic-analytical school of Berlin.[...]”’Adolf Hurwitz’, David Hilbert, 1921
11 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Königsberg 1884 - 1892Hilbert as a student.
”New ideas were stimulated by the Mathematical Colloquium[...], however, in particular by the walks with Hurwitz ”preciselyat 5 o’clock in the afternoon next to the apple tree”. ”Lebensgeschichte, Otto Blumenthal, 1932
Let’s start the analysis...
In the beginning naturally it was Hilbert, who benefited of histeacher Hurwitz. Their roles were still clear defined.
12 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The corpus of investigation:Adolf Hurwitz’s estate in the ETH Zurich.
In the directory HS 582 and 583 of the archive in Zurichreferences to Hilbert can be found:
Greeting cards from conferences
13 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The corpus of investigation:Adolf Hurwitz’s estate in the ETH Zurich.
In the directory HS 582 and 583 of the archive in Zurichreferences to Hilbert can be found:
Greeting cards from conferences
Lectures notes of Hilbert, edited by Julius Hurwitz
13 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The corpus of investigation:Adolf Hurwitz’s estate in the ETH Zurich.
In the directory HS 582 and 583 of the archive in Zurichreferences to Hilbert can be found:
Greeting cards from conferences
Lectures notes of Hilbert, edited by Julius Hurwitz
A biographical dossier of Ida Samuel-Hurwitz
13 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The corpus of investigation:Adolf Hurwitz’s estate in the ETH Zurich.
In the directory HS 582 and 583 of the archive in Zurichreferences to Hilbert can be found:
Greeting cards from conferences
Lectures notes of Hilbert, edited by Julius Hurwitz
A biographical dossier of Ida Samuel-Hurwitz
A letter of condolence to Ida Samuel-Hurwitz by DavidHilbert
13 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The corpus of investigation:Adolf Hurwitz’s estate in the ETH Zurich.
In the directory HS 582 and 583 of the archive in Zurichreferences to Hilbert can be found:
Greeting cards from conferences
Lectures notes of Hilbert, edited by Julius Hurwitz
A biographical dossier of Ida Samuel-Hurwitz
A letter of condolence to Ida Samuel-Hurwitz by DavidHilbert
Remarks about Hilbert in the register of ...
13 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Hurwitz’s mathematical diaries.An overview.
”Since his habilitation in 1882, Hurwitz took notes of everythinghe spent time on with uninterrupted regularity and in this wayhe left a series of 31 diaries, which give a true [...] .”’Adolf Hurwitz’, David Hilbert, 1921
14 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The corpus of investigation:Hurwitz’s mathematical diaries.
Diary No. 4, 1885
Diary No. 5, 1886 - 1888
30 diaries,ca. 6000 pages
15 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The corpus of investigation:Hurwitz’s mathematical diaries.
Diary No. 4, 1885
Diary No. 5, 1886 - 1888
30 diaries,ca. 6000 pages
from March 1882until September 1919
15 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The corpus of investigation:Hurwitz’s mathematical diaries.
Diary No. 4, 1885
Diary No. 5, 1886 - 1888
30 diaries,ca. 6000 pages
from March 1882until September 1919
reviewed and registered byGeorg Pólya
15 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The corpus of investigation:Hurwitz’s mathematical diaries.
Diary No. 4, 1885
Diary No. 5, 1886 - 1888
30 diaries,ca. 6000 pages
from March 1882until September 1919
reviewed and registered byGeorg Pólya
Contents include NumberTheory, Geometry,Complex Analysis as wellas Algebra
15 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The corpus of investigation:Hurwitz’s mathematical diaries.
Diary No. 4, 1885
Diary No. 5, 1886 - 1888
30 diaries,ca. 6000 pages
from March 1882until September 1919
reviewed and registered byGeorg Pólya
Contents include NumberTheory, Geometry,Complex Analysis as wellas Algebra
and at least 15 directreferences about Hilbert.
15 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Hilbert.Publications - fields of interest.
� 1885 - 1892 Algebra: Theory of Invariants� 1890 ”Ueber die Theorie der algebraischen Formen”
(P in GA Bd. 2)� 1892 Theorem on irreducibility� 1892 - 1899 Number Theory: Theory of Number Fields� 1893 Simplification of the Hermite-Lindemann proof of the
transcendence of e and π (P in GA Bd. 1)� 1894 ”Zwei neue Beweise für die Zerlegbarkeit der Zahlen
eines Körpers in Primideale” (L in Munich DMV + P)� 1896 ”Die Theorie der algebraischen Zahlkörper”, often
called ’Zahlbericht’ (P on demand of DMV, in GA Bd. 1)� 1891 - 1902 Geometry: Axiomatization of Geometry
16 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Hilbert.Publications - fields of interest.
� 1895 - 1903 ”Grundlagen der Geometrie” includingComplements (GG)
� 1895 ”Über die gerade Linie als kürzeste Verbindung zweierPunkte” (Complement I in GG)
� 1900 ”Über den Zahlbegriff” (Complement VI in GG):Axiomatization of Arithmetic
� 1900 Hilberts 23 Mathematical Problems, InternationalCongress of Mathematics in Paris (T at ICM)
� 1902 - 1910 Complex Analysis
� 1904 - 1910 Linear Algebra, Functional Analysis:”Grundzüge einer allgemeinen Theorie der linearenIntegralgleichungen” with Supplements (GZ with six Sup.)
17 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Hilbert.Publications - fields of interest.
� 1907 (published 1910) Analysis meets Geometry:Analytical refounding of Minkowski’s theory of volumes andsurfaces of convex bodies (Sixth Sup. of GZ)
� 1907 Analysis meets Number Theory: ”Beweis für dieDarstellbarkeit der ganzen Zahlen durch eine feste Anzahln-ter Potenzen (Waringsches Problem)” (P in GA Bd.1)
� 1902 - 1918 Axiomatization of Physics and Mechanics:Theory of Relativity
� 1904 - 1934 Mathematical Foundation
� 1904 Axiomatization of theory of numbers: ”Über dieGrundlagen der Logik und der Arithmetik”(T in Heidelberg in Sup. VII, GG)
� 1922 - 1934 Hilbert Programme on consistency,Formalism, Proof Theory, ....
18 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Hilbert in the diaries...... first references.
No. 6: 1888 IV. 1889 XI.p. 44 ”On Noether’s Theorem
(concerning a message of Hilbert)”p. 45 ”Hilbert’s Fundamental Theorem”p. 93 Studies on convergent series,
”Hilbert proved the mentioned theorems as follows”No. 7: 1890 IV.9. - 1891 XI.
p. 94 ”[...] the figures of Hilbert”
Hurwitz noticed Hilbert as student: Their exchange begins!
19 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
According to Blumenthal... prime ideals.
Talk of Hilbert in Munich (1893), annual meeting DMV:”Two new proofs of the decomposability of numbers of a field
into prime ideals”
”It was the first result from the walks with Hurwitz. The secondwas Hurwitz’s published proof of the same theorem one yearlater, which Hilbert gave preference in his ’Zahlbericht’.”Lebensgeschichte, Otto Blumenthal, 1932
20 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Theory of Invariants.No. 8, p. 207; No. 14, p. 204; No. 25, p. 77
No. 14: 1896 I.1. - 1897 II.1., p. 204 ”Hilberts 2nd Theorem”
”This is probably the easiest way to regard Hilbert’s proof ofTheorem II (Ann 36. p. 485).”
”Hilbert’s Theorem is also valid for forms, which coefficients areintegers of a finite number field.”
Hurwitz is still on top: He completed and generalized Hilbert’stheorem.
21 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Zahlbericht.No. 15: 1897 II.1. - 1898 III.19., p. 175 ’Concerning Hilbert’s
”Report on Number Fields” ’
”Concerning Chapter V of Hilbert’s report we remark thefollowing.”
Here, we consider a number field K and subfields ki resp.concerning ’Grundideale’ ν and νi :
”According to Hilbert p. 209 [...] the equation νν12 = ν1ν2
would lead to νk1νk2
= νk12”. First Hurwitz verified this
consequence of Hilbert’s formula νk1νk2
= νk12, then continued
to compare it with his assumption:22 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Zahlbericht.No. 15: 1897 II.1. - 1898 III.19., p. 175 ’Concerning Hilbert’s
”Report on Number Fields” ’
”I assume that the theorem holds: If K is a composition ofk1, k2, furthermore k12 is the greatest common divisor of k1 andk2, we have ννk12
= νk1νk2
, with basic ν, ν12, ν1, ν2 ideals of thenumber fields K , k12, k1, k2.”
23 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Zahlbericht.No. 15: 1897 II.1. - 1898 III.19., p. 175 ’Concerning Hilbert’s
”Report on Number Fields” ’
Finally, Hurwitz concluded a new generalized theorm:
”[...] consequently the generalized theorem holds: ν = ν1·ν2ν
,where ν
1 is a common divisor of ν1 and ν2. Or also: In theequation ν1ν2 = νν12 · j is ν12 · j a common divisor of ν1 andν2.”
1probably ν12 and ν were mixed up24 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Zahlbericht.No. 16: 1898 III.20. - 1899 II.23., p. 129 ”Concerning
Hilbert’s report pag. 287”
Hurwitz refered to the later called ’Hilbert’s Symbol’...
.... and in particular to the equation:
25 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Zahlbericht.No. 16: 1898 III.20. - 1899 II.23., p. 129 ”Concerning
Hilbert’s report pag. 287”
Within one page Hurwitz gave the proof:
On the one hand, Hurwitz used Hilbert’s ’Zahlbericht’ astextbook, on the other hand, he improved and complemented italso.
26 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Hilbert’s Axiomatization.No. 19: 1901 XI.1. - 1904 III.16., p. 29 ”Hilberts axiomatische
Größenlehre” (Theory of quantities)
What makes Hurwitz’s entry so interesting is the exact copyingof
”II. Axioms of Calculation. [...]” Hilbert’s axioms aboutoperations, calculation, order and continuity...
27 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Hilbert’s Axiomatization.No. 19: 1901 XI.1. - 1904 III.16., p. 29 ”Hilberts axiomatische
Größenlehre”
... as well as Hilbert’s conclusions:
”Some notes about the dependence of the axioms were addedby Hilbert: [...]”and Hilbert’s new terminology:
”What follows is the existence of the ”Verdichtungsstelle” (asHilbert expresses himself.)”
It seems that the Axiomatization is a completely new topic forHurwitz. In any case, he benefited from his progressive formerstudent Hilbert.
28 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Integral Equation V.No. 21: 1906 II.1. - 1906 XII.8., p. 166 ”Hilbert’s Vth
supplement on integral equations”
In the fifth supplement on page 459 Hilbert wrote: ” The valuesare [...] significantly determined by the kernel(s,t); I called themEigenvalues resp. Eigenfunctions [...].”
29 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Integral Equation V.No. 21: 1906 II.1. - 1906 XII.8., p. 166 ”Hilbert’s Vth
supplement on integral equations”
Hurwitz familiarized himself with the terminology as well as itsapplication:
Obviously Hurwitz did neither know about Hilbert’s methodsconcerning integral equations before, nor his newly introducedterminology.
30 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Minkowski’s theory of convex bodies.No. 18: 1900 XII. - 1901 X.
In 1907 David Hilbert succeeded in developing the analyticalfoundation of Minkowki’s theory of volumes and surfaces ofconvex bodies in his sixth supplement.There is a diary entry about a colloquium talk of Hurwitz from21.01.1901:
”Minkowski’s theroems on convex bodies.” Hurwitz was notsatisfied:
”It remains doubtful if simple results can be discovered.”31 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Minkowski’s theory of convex bodies.A consequence of No. 18?
One year later, in 1902, Hurwitz published the article ’Surquelques applications geometriques des séries de Fourier’, inwhich he tried a respective new foundation of Minkowski’stheory ”using his theory of spherical functions [...], however, heonly had a partial success. Hilbert, with his powerful tool onintegral equations, replaces the spherical function by moregeneralized ones and passes through.”(’Lebensgeschichte’, Otto Blumenthal, 1932)
Hilbert is on the fast lane.
32 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Waring’s Problem.No diary entry...
On November 20, 1907 Hurwitz published a note on
Waring’s Problem
For each positive integer k does there exist a positive integern(k) such that every natural number is the sum of at most n(k)kth powers of natural numbers?
Again Hurwitz succeeded again only partially. He proved” Is the nth power of x2
1+ x2
2+ x2
3+ x2
4equal to a sum of 2nth
powers of a linear rational form of x1, x2, x3, x4, and does theWaring Conjecture hold, it is also valid for 2n.”
33 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
Waring’s Problem.... instead a nice quotation.
Hilbert deduced ”from a general principle, which was used byHurwitz 1897 for the theory of invariants, a formula [...]” withwhich he finally solved Waring’s problem.
Therewith, Hilbert gave a wonderful proof of his emancipationfrom his former teacher Hurwitz:
”Because he fought together with a master of Hurwitz’s highlevel and won with the weapons from Hurwitz’s armor chamberon a point, when [Hurwitz] had no prospect of success”(’Lebensgeschichte’, Otto Blumenthal, 1932)
34 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
An answer...... to the question of research.
The turning point
At the latest in 1907 there was a significant turning point in thestudent-teacher-relation of Hurwitz and Hilbert!
35 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The personal relation.Livelong...
Greeting cards from the ’Dirichletkommers am 13. Februar1905’ and the ’Landau-Kommers 18. Jan. 1913’, signed byHilbert (and other mathematicians):
”Sending warm greetings, wishing good recovery and hoping fora soon reunion longer than the last time. Hilbert”.
36 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The personal relation.... Hilbert directly in the mathematical diaries...
In the register made by Georg Pólya, the ’32nd diary’, thefollowing notes can be found:”the first nine volumes and table of contents are for the purposeof editing temporarily at Prof. Hilbert in Göttingen” and
”22. for editing temporarily at Prof. Hilbert in Göttingen”.The above mentioned quotation of Hilbert is to be continued”[...] which give a true view of his constantly progresssivedevelopment and at the same time they are a rich treasure trovefor interesting and for further examination appropriate thoughtsand problems.”(’Adolf Hurwitz’, David Hilbert, 1921)
37 / 40
Würzburg
N. Oswald
The personal relation..... and even longer.
In a letter of condolence to Ida Samuel-Hurwitz with dateDecember 15, 1919 Hilbert wrote that for Pólya and him the”matter of publishing the Hurwitz’s treatises [is] of utmostconcern”.He offers, ”The negotiations could be done verbally withSpringer by a local, very skillful, math. colleague.”Some years later his efforts turn out to be successful: Hurwitz’s’Mathematischen Werke’ were published in 1932.
38 / 40