Download - Wk11 7805
Second Language Acquisition 1
Second Language Acquisition Semester 1, 2005
Week 11
Individual differences in SLA
Second Language Acquisition 2
Non-linguistic factors in L2 development
motivation personality / cognitive style factors
beliefs extroversion / introversion
affective states locus of control
anxiety risk-taking
field dependence / independence
age aptitude
learner strategies
Second Language Acquisition 3
Role of individual differences (ID) in L2 development
IDs more important in L2 than L1
IDs consist of states and traits
states: specific learning situation or state of mind
traits: enduring characteristics of a person
Direct versus indirect cause of L2 development. ID models are multivariate in that different factors combine to affect learning outcomes.
IDs are hard to measure.
Second Language Acquisition 4
Age
Does it make a difference?
What kind of difference does it make?
What is the cause of the difference?
Second Language Acquisition 5
Critical versus sensitive period for SLA
A critical period implies that there is an age, after which SLA is not possible.
A sensitive period implies that there is an age when (second) language acquisition is optimised.
Second Language Acquisition 6
A sensitive period for SLA
What is the evidence for a sensitive period in language acquisition?
Three generalizations.
1. Universal age of onset of production, rate of acquisition and age of completion of language learning (Slobin, 1982).
2. Relatively homogenous across individual cognitive abilities.
3. Little effect for environmental variation (social class, childrearing patterns).
4. “Feral” cases like Genie, where I child does not receive normal exposure.
Second Language Acquisition 7
Does age make a difference?1. Adults are faster than children at earlier stages of morphological
and syntactic development. (Holding time and exposure constant)
2. Older children acquire faster than younger children.
3. Child starters outperform adult starters in the long run.
4. Attainment of native-like fluency across all domains is only possible if the language is started prior to six years of age. Learners starting not much later than age 6 can become fluent but will have an accent in phonology. Learners starting after 15 will have 'accents' in all domains.
(Long 1990)See also DeKeyser, R. M. (2000). The robustness of critical period effects in
second language acquisition. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 22, 499-532.
Second Language Acquisition 8
What kind of difference does age make?
Phonology.
Evidence for a critical age of 6 for phonology has come from a number of studies looking at age-of-arrival (AO) (Oyama, 1976, Fathman, 1985). Counterevidence from Neufield, 1978.
Morphology and syntax.
Strong main effect for AO no main effect for other variables (Coppieters 1987 ; Newport & Johnson, 1989; DeKeyser, 2000).
Semantics, Discourse and Pragmatics.
Not much research but anecdotal evidence for an “accent” in this areas in adult learners.
Second Language Acquisition 9
What is the cause of age differences?Social/Affective factors. The development of identity makes adult learners
more self-conscious. Ego permeability and cultural identification make it difficult for adults to learn another language.
Input. Children receive more and better input than adults
Cognitive development. The cognitive system overrides natural language learning. The acquisition of metalinguistic skills occurs at around puberty.
Neurophysiological Loss due of natural language learning ability due to hemispheric lateralization, or changes due to mylenation of neural pathways. Recent evidence shows late acquired language to be localised in different part of the brain (Kim et al 1999).
Second Language Acquisition 10
What difference does it make?
Is the “native speaker” the appropriate target for adult SLA?
Second Language Acquisition 11
Social Distance
Acculturation model (Schumann, 1978) The learner needs to adapt to the target language culture in order for successful acquisition to take place.
Two kinds of distance:
Psychological (individual) distance
Social (group) distance
Second Language Acquisition 12
Beliefs
SLA can be affected by the attitudes, values, theories and assumptions about learning (& teaching) which learners build up over time and bring with them to the classroom.
Richards, J. C. & Lockhart, C. (1994) Reflective teaching in second language classrooms. Cambridge University Press.
Second Language Acquisition 13
MotivationIntegrative motivation is present in learners who
identify with the target culture, would like to resemble members of the target culture and who would like to participate in the target culture. It is assumed to be based in the personality of the learner.
Instrumental orientation refers to those cases where the learners are interested in learning the language for the possible benefits: professional advancement, study in the target language, business.
Second Language Acquisition 14
General findings on the role of motivation
Motivation plays an important role in L2 development.
Motivation is separate from aptitude.
Integrative motivation is more powerful for facilitating L2 development in some situations than in others.
Both integrative & instrumental motivations may lead to success, but lack of either causes problems.
Second Language Acquisition 15
Motivation as a multi-componential construct
Motivation
= effort + desire to achieve goal + attitudes
(Gardner, 1985)
Second Language Acquisition 16
The motivation construct
Short-term motivation towards the day-to-day activities in the classroom and general motivations for classroom learning are also important.
The instrumental-integrative dichotomy: is it real?
Does motivation drive achievement or vice versa?
Causal versus resultative effects
Second Language Acquisition 17
Affective states: Anxiety
state anxiety versus trait anxiety
state anxiety: anxiety related to a specific learning situation
trait anxiety: a predisposition to be anxious (unchangeable?)
Second Language Acquisition 18
There is a non-linear relationship between anxiety and performance:
Facilitating versus debilitating anxiety (Scovel, 1978; Bailey, 1995).
It depends on the amount and context of anxiety
Second Language Acquisition 19
Affective states: Locus of control
Internal External
Stable Ability Task difficulty
Unstable Effort Luck
Individuals who believe success is based internally on ability and externally on luck are likely to be less motivated.
Second Language Acquisition 20
Personality & cognitive style factors:Extroversion / Introversion
Extrovert: sociable; dislikes solitude; takes risks; impulsive.
Two main components are sociability and risk-taking.
Introvert: introspective; quiet; retiring; reserved; dislikes order.
Some evidence that introverts have higher academic achievement.
Extroversion has been linked to success in L2 development: sociable learners should generate more input, maximize contact and emphasize using the language.
Second Language Acquisition 21
Personality & cognitive style factors: Risk-taking
Risk-taking has been viewed positively in L2 learning, e.g., Naiman's GLLs.
Ely (1986): Risk-taking predicts classroom participation which in turn predicts proficiency.
Second Language Acquisition 22
The Good Language Learner
What strategies do successful language learners use that unsuccessful learners don't use?
Taxonomies of learner / learning strategies
Wong-Filmore (1976, 1979)
Naiman, Fröhlich, Stern & Todesco (1978)
O'Malley & Chamot (1985, 1990)
Oxford, R. (1990)
Second Language Acquisition 23
Learner strategies
“A behavioral or mental procedure used by learners to develop their interlanguages.” (Ellis, 1997)
Oxford's Strategy Inventory for Language Learning (SILL). SILL is designed to help students better understand how they learn a new language and to help them become better learners.
Second Language Acquisition 24
L2 Learning Aptitude
A generalized capacity to learn a foreign language.
> Separate from intelligence
> Reflects rate, not necessarily capacity.
> Concerned with prediction, not necessarily explanation.
Second Language Acquisition 25
Measuring Aptitude
Modern Language Aptitude Test (MLAT) developed by Carroll & Sapon (1959)
Designed to predict success in foreign language learning.
Four components of Aptitude.
Phonemic coding ability
Grammatical sensitivity
Inductive language learning ability
Rote memory skills
Second Language Acquisition 26
Aptitude has received limited attention in SLA research
Other factors more important. Motivation, cognitive style, attitude.
> ‘High' correlations leave much variance unaccounted for.
> Fixed and innate? Empirical question. People attacking the notion assume it is fixed, determinist
> Elitist. Focus should be learner styles. But could be used to identify particular areas of strength and weakness.
> Appears to only be relevant to formal learning
> Prediction not explanation.
Second Language Acquisition 27
End of individual differences.
Week 11 end