Transcript
Page 1: What defines good science?

What defines good science?

• Science must continually generate innovative new ideas and technologies.

• We must therefore focus much more intensely on stimulating and rewarding innovation and risk taking.

Page 2: What defines good science?

How best to stimulate innovation?

In attempting to address this question, it is important to recognize how new knowledge arises

Page 3: What defines good science?

http://www.BeyondDiscovery.org

Page 4: What defines good science?

www.BeyondDiscovery.org

Timeline for Global Positioning System (GPS)

Page 5: What defines good science?

www.BeyondDiscovery.org

Timeline continued

Page 6: What defines good science?

RESULT

TIM

E

1985

1970

1960

1980

1950

Watson& Crick

Radioisotopesin biology

Barry &Alberts

etc. etc.

Epstein& Edgar

Woodet al

Delbrucket al

Marmur& Doty

Kornberget al

My fieldfrom 1950-1985

How do productive ideas in science arise?

A personal example

Page 7: What defines good science?

THE FUNDAMENTAL REASON FOR THE EXPLOSIVE GROWTH OF SCIENCE

100 units of knowledgecan be combined

in 100 times more waysthan can

10 units of knowledge

Page 8: What defines good science?

RESULTTI

ME

1985

1970

1960

1980

1950

Watson

& Cric

kRadioisotop

esin biology

Barry &

Alberts

etc.

etc.

Epstein

& Edga

r

Wood

et al

Delbruck

et al

Marmur

& Doty

Kornberg

et al

My fieldin 1950 - 1985

My fieldin 1985 - 2020

RESULT

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

Barry &Alberts

TIM

E

2020

1985

Page 9: What defines good science?

But there is a catch!

As knowledge grows, it becomes increasingly difficult to find the right

combinations

Page 10: What defines good science?

To create consists precisely in not making useless combinations and in making those which are useful and which are only a small minority. Invention is discernment, choice… Among chosen combinations the most fertile will often be those formed of elements drawn from domains which are far apart. … The true work of the inventor consists in choosing among these combinations so as to eliminate the useless ones.

Henri Poincaré1908

The source of creativity in science

Page 11: What defines good science?

decades

A problem: the channeling of research topics due to “training inertia”

Unexplored experimental

spaces

Overcrowded experimental

spaces

Page 12: What defines good science?

How then should research be organized to stimulate innovation?

• Here I will give you my personal view, based on my 40 years in universities.

Page 13: What defines good science?

Structuring institutions to maximize innovation

• In general, we should encourage our institutions to support a set of laboratories of modest size (9 to 12 people, maximum), each headed by an outstanding, innovative independent investigator.

• These laboratories should be clustered, embedded in a cooperative culture in which techniques and equipment are freely shared.

• Our reward systems must change to strongly encourage risk taking and originality.

• And everything must be done to encourage a random collision of people and ideas.

Page 14: What defines good science?

Where I am now: UCSF new Mission Bay Campus in San Francisco

Page 15: What defines good science?

Another part of my education at the Academy: recognition of the critical

importance of Science for all !

Page 16: What defines good science?

Lake Victoria, western Kenya, 1998

Page 17: What defines good science?

Pondicherry, India, 2000

Page 18: What defines good science?

Village “knowledge worker” using wireless internet

Page 19: What defines good science?

A “science franchise” that produces parasitic moths


Top Related