National Rural Support Programme - January 2019
We would like to thank Muhammad Irshad Khan, Syeda Farheen Javed, and Soman ul Haq from GIZ for their support during the workshop and in preparing this report. We would also like to thank Dr. Irfan Yousaf, Director-AEDB, Maha Arshad, Manager Sector Development Department-PMIC and all representatives of the companies for their participation.
Inception Workshop Report - Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency (REEE) Project
Authored by: Sarah Hayat Malik (Programme Officer - MER)Reviewed and Supervised by: Muhammad Tahir Waqar (Senior Programme Manager - MER) Design & Layout: Mansoor Abid
Monitoring, Evaluation & Research Sectioni
Table of Contents
Executive Summary 1
Introduction and Background 3
Objectives of the workshop 4
Workshop Proceedings 5
Session 1: Results-based Financing for Off-Grid Electrification in Pakistan 5
Session 2: Role of NRSP 6
Session 3: RBF Incentive Structure 7
Session 4: Third-party Validation 8
Session 5: Introduction of Companies 8
Session 6: Gender Mainstreaming through Rural Electrification 11
Session 7: Field Monitoring, Verification Tools and Reporting 11
Conclusion 13
Annexures Annex 1: RBF Approach 14
Annex 2: Agenda 15
Annex 3: List of Participants: 16
Annex 4: Photo Gallery 17
Inception Workshop Report | Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency (REEE) Project
National Rural Support Programme (NRSP) ii
List of Acronyms
AEDB Alternative Energy Development BoardAGAHE Association of Gender Awareness and Human EmpowermentCEO Chief Executive OfficerFMFB First MicroFinance BankGIZ Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale ZusammenarbeitHRD Human Resource DevelopmentIFC International Finance CorporationKPK Khyber PakhtunkhwaMEDP Microfinance and Enterprise Development ProgrammeMER Monitoring, Evaluation & ResearchMFBs Microfinance BanksMFIs Microfinance institutionsNRSP National Rural Support ProgrammePAYGO Pay As You GOPC Project CoordinatorPM Programme ManagerPMIC Pakistan Microfinance Investment Company LimitedPO Programme OfficerPV PhotovoltaicQ&A Questions and AnswersRBF Results Based FinancingREEE Renewable Energy & Energy EfficiencySHP Social & Human ProtectionSHS Solar Home SystemSO Social OrganizerSPM Senior Programme ManagerSPO Senior Programme Officer
Monitoring, Evaluation & Research Section1
Executive Summary
The inception workshop for the project “Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency – Result-based
Financing for Off-Grid Electrification in Pakistan” was held on 24th January 2019, in Islamabad.
The workshop kick started a one year initiative aimed at developing sustainable markets for
affordable and quality Solar Home System (SHS) products in off-grid rural areas.
Project activities include the sale of
good quality Solar Home Systems
to off-grid areas of district Badin,
Thatta and Muzaffargarh, through
eight vendors of SHS, who will receive
incentives based on their sales to
off-grid communities. These eight
vendors have been selected through a
competitive bidding process, based on
their proposals. One of the outcomes
of the project will be the use of energy efficient electric appliances for off-grid areas, while
testing the RBF model, for the first time in Pakistan.
The 35 participants of the workshop included representatives from eight SHS-based companies,
Team Lead, Technical Advisors and Junior Advisor of REEE-GIZ, Team lead and support staff of
REEE-NRSP, as well as local support staff from district teams. The workshop was also attended
by representatives from PMIC, IFC and the government.
The inception workshop began with the description of the workshop agenda, followed by a
presentation on the RBF Approach by Muhammad Irshad Khan from GIZ. The workshop was
divided into 7 sessions, including one session for presentations from each vendor, which
introduced all attendees to the company profile, its setup in the project districts and its rollout
plan. The workshop also included constructive timely discussions between sessions which
helped all attendees clarify their queries.
The participants mainly discussed the Service Level Agreement, signed by all companies, and
how the project would benefit the consumers through the implementation of these agreements.
The discussions covered project aims and objectives, as well as operational procedures. Details
regarding the Android Application, vendors’ claims processing and data management were also
discussed.
The main points raised in the discussions included clarifications of the term “off-grid” to ensure
that all the stakeholders, especially the vendors, understood their targeted areas. Another point
Inception Workshop Report | Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency (REEE) Project
National Rural Support Programme (NRSP) 2
discussed was the strategies, risks, and benefits of involving Microfinance Institutions (MFIs) as
part of the payment process between the vendor and the end-consumer.
Since the RBF Approach is being implemented in Pakistan for the first time, participants also
raised the question of whether this would work well in the country. Muhammad Tahir Waqar
(Senior Programme Manager, MER - NRSP) appreciated the REEE Project Approach, in terms of
raising awareness among off-grid communities about quality SHSs and linking them with the
market. Moreover the project would provide a platform to increase a dialogue between the SHS
vendors and the target consumers thereby improving their understanding of the solar energy
market in Pakistan.
Overall, the Inception Workshop reconfirmed the high interest and commitment to the project
by all project partners and stressed the importance to adhere to project objectives, ensuring
sustainable market development for renewable energy supply to off-grid communities.
Monitoring, Evaluation & Research Section3
Introduction and Background
Pakistan is one of the countries struck
with energy poverty in the South Asian
region. Most of the areas in Pakistan are
grid connected, however, the generation of
electricity in Pakistan is not enough even to
fulfil the needs of the consumers connected
to the grid. According to an IFC report
published in 2016, approximately 36%
population of Pakistan, 67 million out of 185
million, does not have access to electricity.
The cost of extending the grid to these scattered off-grid communities and villages is very high
and would further increase the losses of the overall transmission of electricity.
After thoroughly studying the market and failure of grant-based interventions and microfinance-
based lending mechanisms for alternative energy sources, especially solar energy, efforts were
put in to look for successful market mechanisms around the globe.
Based on the aforementioned research, GIZ came up with a hybrid model which combines the
provision of microfinance for customers, with an incentive system for the vendors of Solar Home
Solutions (SHS). This model called Result-based Finance is being tested for the first time in
Pakistan through the REEE Project. The salient features of this model are:
» Payment of incentives subject to delivery of pre-defined results » Market-based model; additional incentives to continue the business as usual practice » Sustainable development of market in the areas of operation; subsidies to the end-
consumers are not allowed » Large scale implementation with relatively smaller amount of development budget
A representation of the model is shown in Annex 1.
National Rural Support Programme (NRSP) is well known for its outreach in rural areas and
connections with the poor and the targeted project communities i.e. people residing in Off-Grid
areas. NRSP has also worked in various sectors to enable these communities to access a variety
of services through social marketing, such as sale of Insecticide Treated Bednets, Business in
a Box etc. NRSP has also enabled these communities to access microfinance from NRSP’s own
sources as well as from other MFIs/MFBs to meet their needs for home appliances such as
washing machines and solar-based appliances. NRSP’s Procurement Department possesses vast
experience of selecting vendors and monitoring their work.
Inception Workshop Report | Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency (REEE) Project
National Rural Support Programme (NRSP) 4
A brief of project functions among GIZ, NRSP and the vendors, is as follows:
GIZ: Responsible for funding the incentives
NRSP: Responsible for successful implementation of the project; managing funds, releasing
incentives after sample-based verification; training and consumer awareness raising at the
district level; reporting to GIZ
Vendors: Continue business as usual while fulfilling the eligibility criteria for claiming the
incentives under the RBF scheme
Consumers: Buy quality verified Lighting Global certified solar home solutions on installments
Inception Workshop Objectives:
The Inception Workshop aimed to:
» Orient the participants about project objectives; » Explain how the Result-based Financing Approach would work; » Application process and usage of the Android App and web portal; » Ensuring ways for inclusion of women; » Presentation by vendors on their company profiles, their setup in the project districts
and rollout plans; » Q&A session on for queries of all stakeholders
Monitoring, Evaluation & Research Section5
Workshop Proceedings
Session 1: Results-based Financing for Off-Grid Electrification in Pakistan:
Muhammad Irshad Khan, Chief Technical Advisor and Deputy Team Lead for REEE project, GIZ,
presented the main elements of the project, and explained the RBF approach as well as the
targeted objectives.
There are 50 million people in Pakistan,
without access to electricity and 75 million
people suffering from load shedding.
Irshad Khan explained that Solar PV has
high potential in Off-grid areas, however,
the market in those areas is saturated with
substandard quality products. Since the
consumers in rural communities do not have
enough knowledge and information on solar
products and also lack access to financial capital they are either not able to buy solar products or
buy low quality products. To remove these bottlenecks in demand and supply of quality verified
solar home systems, the RBF model has been introduced. This model provides an incentive for
vendors, as well as connects MFIs to consumers of solar products. Irshad Khan also explained
that the project aims to develop sustainable markets for affordable and quality Solar Home
Systems in Off-Grid rural communities. The aim is to target 10,000 households in District Thatta,
Badin and Muzaffargarh.
Regarding the Result-based Financing approach, incentives are linked to achievement and
verification of pre-defined results. Since the project is targeting the delivery of quality products
to off-grid communities, as a pre-requisite all products must be certified by Lighting Global.
The vendors are also required to provide after-sales service to the end-users. The RBF aims to
incentivize, and does not allow the incentives to be used as subsidies for reducing prices. Irshad
Khan emphasized that the aim is not to distort the market but to develop it, thereby ensuring
stability in prices.
During the presentation, it was also explained why GIZ will involve a third-party verifier. The need
of a third-party verifier exists since NRSP would conduct the disbursement of funds to vendors
and therefore, the third-party verifier would look over all the process to further ensure that
project implementation is being conducted as per design.
The project time-frame of implementation is from January 2019 to December 2019.
Inception Workshop Report | Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency (REEE) Project
National Rural Support Programme (NRSP) 6
Session 2: Role of NRSP:
Senior Programme Manager - Monitoring, Evaluation and Research, Muhammad Tahir Waqar,
explained the role of NRSP in the REEE project.
While explaining the background of NRSP,
and its work in the REEE project districts –
Thatta, Badin and Muzaffargarh – Tahir Waqar
explained that NRSP already has worked on
the energy component in projects such as
Tribal Area Development Project in DG Khan,
Rajanpur and Sindh Coastal Community
Development project in Thatta and Badin.
However, all these projects provided grant
support for the provision of solar systems to the target poor communities, while the REEE project
aims at increasing access to solar energy through a business model which recognizes the need
for providing incentives and resources to develop infrastructure, and to increase demand and
supply of quality-certified SHS in off-grid rural communities.
The goal of the project is to give access to high quality SHS in off-grid areas. The outcome of
the project is to give access to off-grid communities through flexible financing mechanisms. The
output would be measured according to the number of SHS that are provided to households.
Tahir Waqar also emphasized that the workshop is being conducted to brief the private sector
suppliers on the expected quality, service delivery, market development and financing mechanism,
to ensure smooth implementation of the project.
Presenting on the role of NRSP, he explained that NRSP’s role for the REEE project is of a verifier
and fund manager. After installing Lighting Global certified products, vendors can claim their
incentives, by filling out an RBF Results form, and submitting it to NRSP.
With the claims that are received by NRSP, a percentage of them would be shared with the third-
party verifiers. The third-party would then verify the authenticity of claims and henceforth, NRSP
would pay the due incentives to the companies. With this, NRSP would also extend its support
to the third-party verifier, in terms of data sharing, monitoring reports, financial reports and
facilitation in the field.
NRSP has also designed a comprehensive integrated computerized database application, which
will be used by companies to enter data for all the users. For easy access, a web portal has also
been designed for data entry. This application will collect information on items provided, quality
Monitoring, Evaluation & Research Section7
of the items provided (i.e. whether they are Lighting Global certified and correspond to the claim
submitted by the vendor), working status, after-sales service, customer satisfaction etc. All this
will be Oracle based.
The online information of all the customers of SHS in these targeted off-grid areas will be shared
with NRSP by their respective suppliers. This information would be used by NRSP for verification.
Only 50% of the total customers would be verified, with 25% physical verification and 25% over
mobile phones. After verification, NRSP will submit the approved claims to GIZ, seeking approval
for the release of payments.
Session 3: RBF Incentive Structure:
Syeda Farheen Javed, Technical Advisor GIZ-
REEE, presented on the RBF Incentive structure
to make sure that all companies have the
required information on what the incentives
are based on, how they are calculated and the
maximum amount of incentives that may be
received by a company.
Syeda Farheen introduced this session by an
overview of the incentive structure, saying that the aim of this incentive is to empower private
sector stakeholders in off-grid areas to overcome, to a small degree, the lack of capital obstacle
and provide them with an opportunity to invest in the network and infrastructure development
in new off-grid areas.
For the purpose of this project, the vendors
will be provided with a pre-decided cash
incentive, based on different performance
and cost factors. The list of products and
their incentives is available on NRSP’s
website. The companies may use this
incentive to invest in remote monitoring
technologies, such as PAYGO models to
improve customer service and to ensure the
payments of customers on time, thereby improving their business models.
With the discussions held between sessions, Syeda Farheen clarified the queries of the vendors
saying that the factors such as currency exchange rates may be revised depending on the
situation, as well as the changes in prices of products may be discussed on a case-to-case basis.
Inception Workshop Report | Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency (REEE) Project
National Rural Support Programme (NRSP) 8
Session 4: Third-party Validation:
Following the 3rd session, Soman ul Haq,
Junior Advisor GIZ-REEE, presented on the
third party validation mechanism, as well as
the dos and dont’s that the vendors must keep
in mind for the course of this project.
He emphasized that it is important for the
vendors to provide the right information,
strictly avoid using the incentive as subsidies
and ensure there is no unverifiable result, non-functioning device, or incomplete claims.
Session 5: Introduction of Companies:
This session was an introduction of all the companies, who have formed partnerships with NRSP
and GIZ for the course of this project. Each of the companies presented on its company profile,
setup in the project districts and rollout plans. A brief introduction of each partner company is
given below:
1. Adaptive Technologies:
Adaptive technologies has its offices in
Karachi, Lahore and Islamabad. The company
will partner with MFIs to provide financing to
end-users. They have already signed an MoU
with First Microfinance Bank, and will use
support of the bank’s 189 branches to reach
out to consumers. Sharjeel Sulehri, Manager
Sales of Adaptive technologies, presented the
company’s rollout plan, saying that there will
be technical teams posted in District Thatta, Badin and Muzaffargarh, with support staff available
within 100km radius of the offices. However, later the company will establish its own unit.
Currently, the company only works through dealers, and plans to pay the dealers a percentage
of the incentive. For capturing the data, the dealers would initially do it on their own, and the task
would later be taken up by the company when their own unit is established.
2. Allied Solar:
Allied Solar works under multiple sectors, such as rural and off-grid sector, agricultural,
residential and commercial sector etc. Allied Solar has developed partnerships with Microfinance
Monitoring, Evaluation & Research Section9
Institutions such as Khushali Bank, FMFB,
and Thardeep Microfinance Foundation. For
the off-grid sector, the company would be
providing ‘D.light’ products to consumers.
Haseeb Saadat, CEO Allied Solar, says that the
company would be providing bundled loans
and individual loans to consumers so they
may have a variety of options for funding. The
company plans to operate in District Thatta,
Badin and Muzaffargarh for this project. For this, the company will have units established in all
three districts and the required team would be hired for all the tasks.
3. Asian Kings Association:
Asian Kings Association uses products by
Greenlight Planet, a US based manufacturer
of off-grid products. Asian Kings works with
multiple ministries, retail outlets and MFIs.
They deal with retail and sole distributions,
supply plug and play systems, and also have
a strong standing with the pay-as-you-go
model. Tariq Zaman from Greenlight Planet
and Tahir Siddiq, representative of Asian Kings
Association, said that the company would be operating in all three targeted districts.
4. EcoEnergy Pakistan:
EcoEnergy Pakistan has conducted a micro
level research in 44000 households in off-
grid communities of Pakistan. This research
has helped EcoEnergy to understand the
needs of the off-grid rural communities, and
thereby, help them provide economical energy
solutions. EcoEnergy is backed by pay-as-
you-go technology. Jeremy Higgs explained
that their strategy, previously, and for this
project is to have local staff communicate with customers, and provide products according to
the customer needs. EcoEnergy would be operating in District Thatta and Badin, for this project,
and it already has established small shops in District Badin and adjoining districts within the
Sindh province.
Inception Workshop Report | Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency (REEE) Project
National Rural Support Programme (NRSP) 10
5. Harness Energy:
Harness Energy has been working in the
off-grid sector for the past 3 years. The
company has focused its approach to lighting,
ventilation and mobile charging, currently.
Harness Energy works by importing products
from Lighting Global - certified companies,
and other suppliers based in China. It provides
these products to end-users through sales
agents, MFIs and MFBs, and retailers. For this
project, Muhammad Sheharyar, said that they plan to focus on District Thatta and Muzaffargarh.
Their rollout plan includes marketing their products to MFI clients, provide samples, organize
field visits and give demonstrations. It also plans to target other clients through pop-up stores
in markets and partnerships with retailers. The products would ultimately be installed and sold
at the client premises.
6. SABCO Solutions:
SABCO Solutions was established in 2017.
The company provides products through 2-3
vendors. SABCO Solutions plans to appoint
Local Sales Agents / Community Mobilizers to
generate local demand, and act as after-sales
contact points. Through Local Sales Agents,
SABCO Solutions will approach financial
partners as well as local sales channels. With
financial partners, SABCO Solutions plans to
have revenue-sharing for sustainability and with the local sales channels, there will be point-
of-sale marketing. Fareed Shahid said that for this project, SABCO Solutions will only focus on
off-grid rural communities within District Muzaffargarh.
7. Solar Sigma:
Solar Sigma is based in Malaysia and has its
offices located in Islamabad, Sialkot, Lahore,
and Swat. Solar Sigma has conducted several
solar installation projects in KPK, Sindh
and Punjab, as well as numerous projects
in Malaysia. Solar Sigma’s manufacturing
partner is Poly Solar technologies, China. For
Monitoring, Evaluation & Research Section11
REEE project, Solar Sigma will operate in all 3 districts – Badin, Thatta and Muzaffargarh. Nisar
A. Latif said that the company plans to import the required amount of products, and with its
existing MFI partner AGAHE, and other MFIs, it will finalize agreements, and market its products
in the targeted areas, consequently.
8. Zeus Energy:
Zeus Energy operates in the off-grid sector,
along with other sectors, for alternative
energy provision. The company has a number
of projects running throughout the four
provinces of Pakistan. The supplier of all
products for Zeus Energy is Omnivoltic. Zeus
Energy plans to focus on all three targeted
districts, with its local office to be situated in
District Muzaffargarh and representatives to
be present in District Badin and Thatta. Faheem Ashraf explained that the rollout plan includes
financing of the products through FMFB, engaging the company’s staff as well as youth and
local communities, and establishing connections with the agricultural community of the targeted
areas. The company will then establish POS and shops in the targeted areas.
Session 6: Gender Mainstreaming through Rural Electrification
Delivered by Salma Khalid, Programme
Manager - Gender and Communication-NRSP,
this session helped to engage the audience
on the Gender component of the REEE-
GIZ. As part of the project, at least 10% of
the end-users must be women, to ensure
their participation. The discussion allowed
everyone to provide their insights on how
women may be incorporated in the project,
as well as what benefit they may be able to derive from this initiative.
Session 7: Field Monitoring, Verification Tools and Reporting:
This session was conducted by Muhammad Ayub Zafar to give a demonstration of the Android
application to the attendees and involved a discussion on data entry, and possible modifications.
Ayub Zafar introduced the application by showing its interface, during the presentation. The
vendors were guided on how they would be required to enter the information and about checks
Inception Workshop Report | Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency (REEE) Project
National Rural Support Programme (NRSP) 12
and restraints on data entry. The application,
prepared by NRSP, can be used off line and
the data can be uploaded, from a location
that has internet access. This application will
also allow NRSP to generate reports, which
could be used for monitoring, and during the
finalization stages of the project, to measure
the overall impact.
Further modifications of the application were thoroughly discussed, and the modified version of
the application would henceforth be provided to the vendors.
Monitoring, Evaluation & Research Section13
Conclusion
The REEE Inception Workshop was concluded by a few remarks from Tahir Waqar, who further
answered queries of the representatives of solar companies, and discussed the time-frame.
He also introduced local staff to the companies for their facilitation during the work in the
targeted districts. He also invited all representatives of solar companies to take part in the
awareness raising workshops, which will be held in District Thatta, Badin and Muzaffargarh,
to interact with the local communities, especially women. Sajjad Ashraf, Project Coordinator -
District Muzaffargarh based in Muzaffargarh is incharge for REEE Project activities in the district
and Khalid Noor, Project Coordinator - District Badin & Thatta based in District Hyderabad is
responsible for REEE project activities in District Thatta and Badin.
The Inception Workshop reconfirmed the high interest and commitment to the project by all
project partners.
Inception Workshop Report | Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency (REEE) Project
National Rural Support Programme (NRSP) 14
Annex 1: RBF Approach
Annexures
GIZ
3rd Party
NRSP
Vendors
Off Grid Customer
Reporting, auditing, payments
Reporting
Incentives Reporting
Verification
Verification
Products Payment
Monitoring, Evaluation & Research Section15
Annex 2: Agenda
Time Session Responsibility 0900 Registration, Introduction and Objectives Imran Alvi (NRSP)
0930 GIZ’s Result Based Financing for Off-grid Electrification in Paki-stan M. Irshad Khan (GIZ)
0945 Role of NRSP Waqar (NRSP)
1000RBF Incentive Structure• Sharing Result and Lesson Learnt – NRSP &
CompaniesFarheen (NRSP)
1020 Third Party Validation Soman ul Haq (GiZ)1035 Tea Break
1100
Introduction of Companies• Company Business Profile• Company Setup in the Project District• How will Company Roll it out?• Adaptive Technologies Private Ltd• Allied Solar Private Ltd• Asian Kings Associates Private Ltd.• Eco Energy Solutions Ltd• Harness Energy Private Ltd• SABCO Solutions (SMC-PVT) Ltd• Solar Sigma Ltd• Zeus Energy Private Ltd
Ten minutes for each presentation
Selected Companies
1230 Gender Mainstreaming through Rural Electrification Salma Khalid / Imran (NRSP)
1315 Lunch Break1400 Field Monitoring, Verification Tools and Reporting Ayub Zafar (NRSP)
1430 Operational Procedure for reporting, invoicing and payments Waqar (NRSP)
1500 Questions & Feedback from participants GIZ / NRSP
Inception Workshop Report | Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency (REEE) Project
National Rural Support Programme (NRSP) 16
Annex 3: List of Participants
Sr# Name Designation Organization/ Company1 Muhammad Irshad Khan Chief Technical Advisor GIZ2 Syeda Farheen Javed Technical Advisor GIZ
3 Soman ul Haq Junior Advisor – Renewable Energy Implementation GIZ
4 Syed Mehdi Mustafa Technical Advisor – Financial Instruments GIZ
5 Ibrar Khattak Consultant – IFC Lighting Pakistan IFC
6 Dr. Irfan Yousaf- Director SolarAlternative Energy Development Board (AEDB)
7 Maha Arshad Manager PMIC
8 Sharjeel Sulehari Manager Adaptive Technologies Private Ltd
9 Irfan ul Haq Allied Solar Private Ltd10 Muhammad Haseeb Saadat CEO Allied Solar Private Ltd11 Tariq Zaman Global Partnership Green Light
12 Tahir Siddiq General Manager Sales Asian Kings Associates Private Ltd.
13 Osama Manager Asian Kings Associates Private Ltd.
14 Jeremy Higgs Executive Director Eco Energy Solution Pvt. Ltd
15 Muhammad Shehryar Founder & Managing Director Harnes Energy Private Ltd
16 Fareed Shahid Director Commercial SABCO Solutions (SMC-PVT) Ltd
17 Nisar A. Latif CEO Solar Sigma Ltd18 Sobia Nisar CIO Solar Sigma Ltd19 Muhammad Faheem Ashraf CEO Zeus Energy Private Ltd20 Muhammad Tahir Waqar SPM –MER NRSP21 Sohail Manzoor PM - HRD/SHP NRSP22 Salma Khalid PM – Gender NRSP23 Tallat Mehmood PM – MEDP NRSP24 Khalid Noor PC -Thatta and Badin NRSP25 Muhammad Sajjad Ashraf PC – Muzaffargarh NRSP26 Abid Qayyum SPO – Procurement NRSP27 Muhammad Aamir Miraj SPO -HRD/SHP NRSP28 Muhammad Ayub Zafar Software Developer NRSP
29 Zeeshan Khan Communication and Documentation Officer NRSP
30 Sami-ullah SO – Muzaffargarh NRSP31 Shamusdin Mangrio SO – Hyderabad NRSP32 Raja Zulfiqar Ali Media Officer NRSP33 Muhammad Imran Alvi SPO - HRD/SHP NRSP34 Sarah Hayat Malik PO – MER NRSP35 Umar Idrees SPO – MEDP NRSP
Monitoring, Evaluation & Research Section17
Annex 4:
Photo Gallery
Inception Workshop Report | Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency (REEE) Project
National Rural Support Programme (NRSP) 18
Workshop opening by Muhammad Imran Alvi, Project CoordinatorInception Workshop Banner
Dr. Irfan Yousaf
Sobia Nisar and Nisar A. Latif
Syeda Farheen Javed
Muhammad Irshad Khan
Ibrar Khattak
Maha Arshad
Monitoring, Evaluation & Research Section19
Presentation by a participant
Sajjad Ashraf with workshop participants
Sohail Manzoor, Programme Manager HRD & SHP (NRSP)
Muhammad Tahir Waqar addressing the participants
Group Photo
Jeremy Higgs, Muhammad Shaharyar and Fareed Shahid
Abid Qayyum, Procurement Officer (NRSP)
Muhammad Aamir Miraj PO - HRD & SHP (NRSP) with other participants