Download - Vandana MA Corrected
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
1/21
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
2/21
UWBL-Background
y Found in 1936 by Waman Ganesh Chirmule.
y Operational since 8th March1937.
y Since 1951, UWBL is declared as a Scheduled Bank as per RBI Act 1934.
y Union Bank of Kolhapur merged with UWBL in 1956, Satara SwadeshiCommercial Bank Limited followed merger in 1961.
y Upgraded as Class A bank in 1974. (CAMELS ratings)
y UWBL operated only in INDIA.
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
3/21
CAMELS Ratingy CAMELS ratings on scale of 1-5. A corresponding to 1 being the best
rating.
C Capital Adequacy
A Asset Quality
M Management
E Earnings
L Liquidity
S Sensitivity to Mar et is
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
4/21
y O er the decades, UWBL became one of the most preferred pri ate sectorcommercial banks in western India.
y UWBL offered di ersified products like automobiles finance, housing finance,corporate finance, export finance, finance for education, finance to SMEs, etc.
y Crossed 100 Crores Net worth in 1996.
y In 1997 opened first ATM in Satara, By 2006, the bank had 230 branches, 12extension counters and 75 ATMs spread o er nine Indian states that werecontrolled by fi e zonal offices at Mumbai, Pune, Kolhapur, Jalgaon and
Nagpur.
KeyAchievements
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
5/21
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
6/21
The Problems Fall of Bank
These are the main reasons for its collapse:
Irregular transactions -Makharia Group Companies (MGC)
Ownership issue between banks main shareholders i.e. SICOM & MGC
Increase in Non Performing Assets(NPA) and fall in Capital Adequacy Ratio(CAR)
Poor go ernance and inefficient management of capital
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
7/21
T
heM
akharia Group
y The Company under the aegis of Maliram Makharia Group was
incorporated in 1982 as Maliram Makharia Textile Mills P t. Ltd.
y Subsequently, the name was changed to Emtex Industries (India) Ltd. to
reflect the related expansion and di ersification acti ities under one single
corporate roof.
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
8/21
Transactions with theMakharia
groupy The Makharia family owned Emtex Industries was gi en o erdraft facility
of Rs. 68.8 million to subscribe to the 1995rights issue of the UWBL bank.
y Also, a letter of credit(LC) was sanctioned to MGC by UWBL
y RBI feltthatthe LC facilitywas providedwiththeintentionofpreventingMGCsloanaccountwith UWBL from becomingnon-
performingassets (NPAs)
y On May 30, 1998, UWBL was penalized for Rs. 1 million by the RBI for
irregular transactions with the MGC.
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
9/21
Transactions with theMakharia
group Contdy In the year 2000, UWBL filed a petition in the Mumbai High Court against
Emtex for defaulting on loan repayment. As of late 2006, Emtex owed Rs.
499.1 million to UWBL and this was classified as doubtful assets by thebank.
y In another transaction in the year 2003, UWBL entered into a settlement
with Maliram Makharia Stockbrokers Pri ate Limited (MMSPL), a
brokerage house under MGC to pay back Rs. 57.5 million, on account of aloan that was earlier gi en to MMSPL. Howe er, as of August 02, 2006,
UWBL had not recei ed any loan installment from the firm.
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
10/21
The Ownership Issue
y In Aug 2000, infighting broke out for a controlling stake in UWBL between
the banks main shareholders i.e State Industrialand Investment
Corporationof Maharashtra Limited (SICOM) and the Makharia family.
y SICOM & MGC they held a 24% equity stake in UWBL out of which MGC
held a 14.5%stake.
y Each of the shareholders wanted four representati es on UWBLs board.
y On the other hand, nine professional directors of the UWBL board strongly
opposed the idea.
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
11/21
The Ownership Issue
Contd
y The management board of UWBL sought RBIs inter ention to seize the oting
rights of the MGC as they did not ha e the regulators' appro al for holding a more
than 5% equity stake in UWBL.
y To a oid Makharias takeo er, UWBL management team decided to grant Rs.200
million interest free loan to employees, to buy shares from secondary market.
y RBI appro ed only Rs.60 million for the purpose, yet UWBL team went ahead to
issue Rs. 200 million.
y RBI imposed Rs 5 lakhs penalty on UWBL for the loan issue and ordered to recall
the issued loan amount.
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
12/21
The Other Problemsy Inefficient Management of Capital.
y Rising Non Performing Assets (NPAs) and Poor Go ernance .
y UWBL-Asset-Liability Mismatch Details - RBI noted
deficiencies in the asset-liability management of UWBL. This
huge asset-liability mismatch ad ersely affected the liquidity
position of the bank.
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
13/21
UWBL-A
sset-LiabilityM
ismatchDetails(2005-06) Contd
(Rs. in crore)
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
14/21
Financial of UWBL (FY 2001-FY 2006)Financial Year 2000-01 2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06
(Rs. in crore)
Capital 29.89 29.89 29.89 29.89 29.89 35.87
Reser es 203.58 223.92 249.07 274.08 214.07 50.85
Deposits 5,221.22 4,491.03 5,391.08 6,430.19 6,452.88 NA
Ad ances 2740.06 2657.68 3145.45 3744.47 3976.28 NA
Assets 5738.80 5134.46 5991.90 7139.34 7055.77 NA
Gross NPA 339.58 389.08 447.71 516.34 450.20 490.97
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
15/21
Failure of UWBLy In general, one can say it was inefficient management of
the bank. In the last two years, huge losses were made,
leading to erosion of the net worth and negati e capitaladequacy ratio.
-Anand Sinha,Executi e Director, RBI.
yI dont accept that the bank has failed. We ha econsolidated.We did not ha e the capital but if we were
gi en more time we would ha e raised it.
-Satish Marathe, CEO, United Western Bank.
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
16/21
Steps Taken by RBI
y On May 30, 1998 RBI penalized Rs.1 Million to UWBL for
irregular transactions with the MGC.
y RBI Seized oting rights of MGC.
y RBI imposed a penalty of Rs.5,00,000/- on UWBL in 2000.
y From June 2001, UWBL was plead under monthly monitoring by
the RBI.
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
17/21
StepsT
akenC
ontdy RBI issued 13 directions to UWBL
y
RBI ad ised the bank to increase its Equity Capital tomeet the prescribed capital adequacy norms.
y To RBI issued an application suggesting Moratorium toGo ernment of India (GOI).
y On September 13,2006 RBI announced that UWBL wouldMerge with IDBI( The Industrial and De elopment Bank ofIndia)
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
18/21
AMALGAMATION OFTHE UWBL WITH IDBI
y The business, properties, assets and liabilities of UWBL shall
stand transferred to IDBI Bank Ltd.
y
All contracts, deeds, bonds, agreements, powers of attorney etc.ha ing effect immediately before the date of amalgamation,
shall be effecti e and may be acted upon as if IDBI Bank Ltd.
had been a party thereto or as if it had been issued in fa our of
UWBL.
y any suit, appeal or legal proceedings pending shall not abate,be discontinued or be prejudicially affected but shall be subject
to the other pro isions of the Scheme, be prosecuted and
enforced by or against the transferee bank;
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
19/21
y the books of UWBL shall be closed and balanced and
balance sheet prepared at the close of business on the date
immediate preceding imposition of moratorium and thebalance sheet shall be got audited and certified
y IDBI Bank Ltd. shall, in consultation with UWBL, alue
the assets and reckon the liabilities of UWBL in the
manner prescribed in the Scheme. IDBI Bank Ltd. shalldischarge the liabilities of UWBL and make payment to
the creditors and depositors in the manner specified in the
Scheme.
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
20/21
y IDBI Bank Ltd. shall make an upfront payment in cash of
Rs. 28/- in respect of e ery fully paid-up share in UWBL,
to the Members of the UWBL, who were, as on theprescribed date, registered as the holders of shares of the
transferor bank.
y All the employees of UWBL shall continue in ser ice and
be deemed to ha e been appointed in IDBI Bank Ltd. atthe same remuneration and on the same terms and
conditions of ser ice as were applicable to them before the
amalgamation
-
8/6/2019 Vandana MA Corrected
21/21
Thank You!!!