Download - Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
1/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 1
DiversityandPlurality:ThePublicsArtonExhibitioninVancouver
Preface
The$150MillionSolution(Iconicbuildingsplus$25millionforacquisitions)
TherehasbeenmuchdiscussionoflateaboutdirectionsfortheVancouverArtGallery.Unfortunately,muchofthisdiscussionisfocusedonasinglelargebuilding,a300,000squarefoot,$300millionbuilding.Thefocusputsthecartwellbeforethehorse,astheformtrulyshouldfollowthefunction:beforediscussingabuildingitisnecessarytoknowwhattheVancouverArtGallerymustdotofulfillitsresponsibilitiestothecommunitiesofVancouver.Detailsofthisbig-boxproposalarescarce,asarepublicallyavailabledocumentsthatprovideevidencethatsuchabuildingisbothappropriateandprudent,bothofwhichareessentialgiventheeconomicrealityofthecityandtheprovince.
ThisdocumentreflectsourperspectivesontheresponsibilitiesoftheVancouverArt
Galleryanddetailsastohowbesttomeetthem.WeareproposingthattheVancouverArtGallerybetransformedintotheVancouverArtGallerySystem,anorganizationofdiverse,dispersedandspecializedexhibitionspacesfocusedoncommunityaccesstoaniconicartcollection.ThisstructureisbasedonthenatureofVancouveranditscommunities,ontheresponsibilityoftheVancouverArtGallerytothese,andontheopportunitiesandconstraintsonpublicandprivateexpendituresonthearts.Thereisnothingrevolutionaryinourproposal,asitfollowsthedecentralizationofexhibitionspacesevidentinmanyothercities;noristhereanythingexcessiveaboutit,asitstrivestomeetcommunityresponsibilitiesinthemosteffectiveandefficientway,respectingtheconstraintsnotonlyonvisualartexhibitioninVancouver,butthoseonartfundingingeneral.
Forconvenience,belowisachecklistoftheelementsofourproposal:
-aniconicbuilding;-anewdowntownexhibitionspaceformajorshows;-acustomdesignedspaceforaGalleryofConceptualPhotography;-acustomdesignedspacefortheCanadianHistoricalCollection;-adedicatedbuildingforstorageandadministration;-fourthematiccommunitygalleries;-nointerruptioninexhibitionofthecollection;-atotalconstructioncostof$125million;-$25millionforacquisitions;
-astatementofvisionandstrategy;and-afinancialplananddevelopmentschedule.
Thankyoufortakingthetimetoread,consideranddiscussourproposal.Yoursrespectfully,
Bob Rennie David Baxter
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
2/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 2
DiversityandPlurality:PublicArtExhibitioninVancouver
AProposalByBobRennieandDavidBaxter
Introduction
ThesebriefnotesareourcontributiontothecurrentdiscussionaboutthefutureoftheVancouverArtGallery(VAG).Recentlymuchofthisdiscussionhasbeenframedinthecontextofalocationaldecision,ofwheretheVAGshouldbelocated,aproposalapparentlyinvolvingsome$300millionand300,000squarefeetofspaceatasinglesiteinthedowntowncore.Itistrulyunfortunatethatthediscussionhasbecomeoneofthesizeofabuilding,whenthediscussionshouldbeaboutthedesiredcontentandexhibitionofVancouverspublicartcollection.
Implicitinanydiscussionofwhereisavisionofwhat,oftheVAGsrolesandresponsibilitiestothediversityofpeopleandcommunitiesofVancouverandhowitshouldfunctionwithrespecttothese.Itistheseresponsibilitiesthatshoulddrive
thediscussionofbuildingsandlocations,asformshouldnotonlyfollowfunction,butinfactsupportit.ClearlyifbuildingsandlocationsevolvefromtheVAGsresponsibilities,theywillenhanceitsengagementwithVancouver;iftheyignoretheseresponsibilities,theywillimpedethisengagement-sodecisionsbetterbedemonstrablytherightones.
Art1isnotmereuselessbeauty,butratherperformsimportantsocialandcommunityfunctions,therebyexplainingtheroleoftheCityofVancouverasthedefactoprincipalintheVancouverArtGallery.Artholdsamirrorforustoseeourselves,itholdsalensforustoseeothers;itshowsuswherewecamefrom,wherewearegoing,andwherewemightgo.Artgivescomfortanddiscomforts,it
answersandquestions,itengagesandalienates,itoffershopeandportendsdespair.Arthelpsustonotmerelyexist,buttolive,withourselvesandwitheachother.Itcompelsustoengageindialogue,andithelpsustobetterunderstand,therebycontributingtobuildingandsupportingcommunities.
Itisartsroleinsustainingcommunitiesthatjustifiespublicvisualartexhibitionsandcivicgovernmentengagementintheartinstitutionbusiness.Certainlytherearelessprosaic,economicdevelopment,reasonsforpublicsectorinvolvementinthearts:weliveinaculturaleconomy2wherenotonlyistourismpulledbythearts,butwhereretentionandattractionofworkersissignificantlydependantontherelativeculturallifeofcommunities.Butthecorereasonremainstheroleoftheartsincivic
discourseandengagement,andtheneedtohaveart,anddiscourseaboutart,accessibleandaccessedbythepublic.Hencethepeopleandcommunitiesof
1Inthecontextofthisdiscussion,whilewereferspecificallytothevisualandplasticarts,theprinciplesconsideredhereequallyapplytotheotherdisciplinesofcreativeexpression.2TherecentlyopenedLouvresatelliteatLens,Calais-Pas-de-Nord,France,hasanexpliciteconomicdevelopmentpurpose,tobringtourismandEurostoaneconomicallydepressedregion.GangnamstylehasbeencreditedwithbringingmoreeconomicfocusonKoreathanyearsoftraditionaleconomicdevelopmentactivity.
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
3/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 3
Vancouver,andtheCityofVancouver,haveafundamentalinterestnotmerelyintheoutcomeofdecisionsconcerningtheVAG,butalsoinparticipatinginboththediscussionleadinguptodecisionsandinbeingrepresentedintheirmaking.
Itisessentialthatsuchdecisionsnotbemadeinisolationbyfocusingonlytheinterestsofthissingleartinstitution.Atthebestoftimes,fundingfortheartsfrombothphilanthropyandgovernmentarehardtocomebyinVancouver,andnowismostcertainlynotthebesttimes.Inthisneweconomy,nooneinstitutionshouldseekadisproportionateshareoftheavailableresources,therebyattemptingtocannibalizethefundingfromeitherpublicresourcesorprivatephilanthropyforotherinstitutions.FundingchangefortheVancouverArtGallerymustbeappropriateandprudentbothspecificallyandwithinthebroadcontextofartsfundingnowandinthefuture.ThefollowingisaproposalfordevelopmentoftheVancouverArtGallerySystem(VAGS)anditscollectioninawaythatreflectstheresponsibilityofVancouvers
publicartinstitutiontofacilitateVancouveritesengagementwithartandwitheachotherthroughtheestablishmentofpartnershipsandthedevelopmentofaccessibleexhibitionspacesinVancouvercommunities.Inpreparingthisproposal,weemphasizethattheresponsibilityofpublicartinstitutionsistoart,peopleandcommunities,nottobuildings,andthatoursisnotarevolutionaryproposal,asitfollowsamodelwidelyusedinotherregions.
Readerswilldiscoverthattwodistinctthreadsrunthroughtheproposal.Thefirstisanemotionalthread,onethatenvisionstheVAGShavingafundamentalroleincommunitybuildingandcommunityengagement,insustainingandsupportingVancouver,bothculturallyandeconomically.Thesecondthreadislesslofty,asitlooksforevidence-baseddecisionmaking:$300millionand300,000squarefeetarebignumbers,andthedecisiontocommittosuchaproposaloranyother(includingours)mustbesupportedbyindependent,objectiveandempiricalanalysisthatdemonstratesthatthedecisionisthemostappropriateandprudentone.
Decisionsaboutcollections,buildingsandlocationshavetobeindependentofpersonalities,aspersonalitieswillchangeoverthedecadesthatVancouverliveswithVAGSdecisions.TheconstantsaretheresponsibilitiesofVancouverspublicartinstitutionstoVancouverscommunities,andtherequirementthatdecisionsbetheonesthatwillbestservethismandate,andthepeopleandcommunitiesofVancouver,overthecomingdecades.
Torespondtotheimmediatediscussionofsizeandlocationthisproposalstartswithadescriptionofwhatweareproposingbeforepresentingthebackgrounddiscussionofwhyitisproposed:
-PartOnecontainsaspecific,coherentandcosted15-yearvisionandstrategyfortheVAGS,outliningthedevelopmentofpartnershipsforartexhibitionofapproximately180,000squarefeetofexhibitionspacesand95,000squarefeetofstoragespaceat7distinctvenues.
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
4/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 4
-PartTwoconsidersartandartinstitutions;costsandefficiency;andthediversenatureofthepopulationandcommunitiesofVancouvertowhichtheVAGSisresponsible.Italsodocumentsthewidespreaduseofadecentralizedgallerysysteminotherregions,rangingfromHonolulutoLondonandParis.
Pleasenotethatwhilewehavegonesofarastopresenttimingofdevelopmentandcosting,andevennamesforsomeofthefacilities,thesearemeanttobeillustrativeasaconstructfordiscussionratherthandefinitivewearespecificonlytoprovidegroundingforwhatwehopewillbethereadersfocus,a15yearvisionforpublicartexhibitioninVancouver.
Thisproposalwill,wehope,stimulatediscussion,debate,anddiscourse,therebycontributingtoabetterdecisionaboutthefutureoftheVAGS.Weaskthatyourespondtoitbyarticulatingyourperspectives,sharingthemwithyourfriendsandcolleagues,andforwardingthemtotheBoardoftheVancouverArtGalleryandTheCityofVancouver,therebyparticipatinginthediscussion,andultimately,inthedecisions.
Outofallofthis,whatmustbeforthcoming,fromtheCityofVancouverandtheBoardoftheVancouverArtGallery,isevidencethatalldecisionsabouttheVAGSarebasedonindependent,objectiveandempiricalevaluationofalloffeasibleoptionsinlightofthefiduciaryresponsibilityoftheVancouverArtGallerytotaxpayersanditscivicreasonabilitytothepeopleofVancouverandtheirart,thecollectionoftheVAGS.Weaskfornomore,andnoless.
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
5/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 5
PartOne:ElementsoftheProposal
I.TheResponsibilityoftheVAGS
Fromourperspective,itistheresponsibilityoftheVancouverArtGallerySystem
tosupportcommunitiesandcommunitybuildinginVancouverthroughengagementintheexhibitionsofartthatareaccessibletothesecommunitiesandthedevelopmentofacollectionthatwillfosterthisengagement.
II.VAGSStrategicGoalsfor2027
1.TheVAGSoperates180,000squarefeetofartexhibitionspaceslocatedinandaccessibletothecommunitiesofVancouver.Theseincludethreelargerexhibitionspacesinthedowntowncore(aGalleryofConceptualPhotographyandaGalleryofHistoricalCanadianArt,bothofwhichareinthecurrentRattenbury-designedvenueandanewspaceforaGalleryofContemporaryArt)andfoursmallerspecializedexhibitionsspacesinVancouvercommunities(ArtsPlaces).
2.TheVAGSistheleadpartnerintheoperationofArchiveArt,a108,000squarefootadministration,storage,restorationandpreservationfacilityatanappropriatelocationforstorageandbackofthehouseadministration.
3.TheVAGSissupportedandsustainedbyanactiveandengagedcommunityofprivatephilanthropists,assageadvisorsandasdonorsofbothcollectionsandfunds,andbythecommunitiesofVancouver.
4.TheVAGSisactiveandengagedinapartnershipoflocal,regionalandnationalartinstitutions,eachworkingtosustainandsupportitsownandothersuniqueandfocalstrategieswithrespecttoacquisitions,exhibitionsanddevelopment.
III.PrinciplesShapingAttainmentoftheStrategicGoals
1.Onthenationalandinternationalscale,Vancouverisasmallcityinasmallregion.TheVAGScannotbeallthingstoallpeopleanditcannotbeworldscalebutitcanbeworldclass,havingauniquefocusandaknownanddefineddifferencefromothercollectionsandinstitutions.Todosoitmustfocusonitscomparativeadvantagebydoingwhatitisbestsuitedtodoratherthantryingtodoabitofeverything.TheVAGSmustarticulatealong-termvisionforitscollectionandexhibitionsthatreflectsitcorecompetencies,andthenpursuethisvision.
2.Collaborationandpartnershipsaremoreproductiveinbuildinganddisplayingcollectionsthanisolationandcompetition.Focusedalliancesandpartnershipswillhelpallpartiesinachievingtheirgoals:theVAGScannotandshouldnotcompetewithMoA,AGOorTheNational,butrathershouldcollaboratewiththem.TheVAGSmustworkwithandsupportotherstoachieveitsacquisitionsandoperationgoals.
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
6/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 6
3.Vancouverisnotinaheadofficeregion,andhencewhilethecorporatephilanthropyitenjoysisgreatlyvalued,itisnotandwillnotbesufficienttosustainVancouverspublicartinstitutions.TheVAGSmustrelymuchmoreonthephilanthropyofindividualsandattractprivatecollectorsanddonors.
4.TheVAGSresponsibilityistothepeopleandcommunitiesofVancouverandtotheirart(thecollectionoftheVAGS).ThisresponsibilitymeansthattheVAGSmustarticulateavisionofitsfutures,andplansandstrategiestoattainthese,allofwhicharecommunicatedtoandknownbythepeopleandcommunitiesofVancouver.PlansforanddecisionsabouttheVAGSmustbeexpressedintermsofart,people,andcommunities,notintermsofarchitectureorbuildings.
5.Vancouverisplaceofdiversity,ofdiversevalues,interestsandcommunities.ThevisionandtheoperationoftheVAGSmustnotonlyreflectdiversitybutmustalsoactivelyengageinitsexpressionandlife.
6.Moneymatters:nopurposeisservedinhavingtheVAGSsstorageandbackofficeadministrationinthedowntowncoreontheregionsmostexpensiveandpublicallyaccessibleland.Choicesmustbepriced:engagementinartmeanshavinganengagingcollection,andhencedecisionsmustbemadebetweenspendingonsoaringmarblelobbiesoronacquisitionsandendowments.Decisionsaboutartcollections,exhibitionsandbuildingsmustreflecttheVAGSfiduciaryresponsibilitytotaxpayersanditscivicresponsibilitytoprovideforengagementinart,andhencemustmeetefficiencyandeffectivenesscriteria.
IV.ElementsandStepsinAttainingtheStrategicGoals.
A.OrganizationalPartnerships:
Fundamentaltoachievingitsstrategicgoals,theVAGSmustbecomeanengagedandactiveleaderinthedevelopmentofpartnershipsthatwillensurethatitmeetsitsresponsibilities.Foursuchpartnershipsarerequired,allofwhichshouldbeestablishedimmediatelysothattheymayprovideguidanceastheVAGSmovesfromvisiontoimplementationanddevelopment.
1.CommunityofMuseumsandGalleries.VAGSmustleadinthedevelopmentofpartnershipswithotherinstitutionsandagenciesengagedincollectionandexhibitionofart,inordertohelpeachandalltoachievetheirgoals.Whilemuch
ofthispartnershipwillbelocal,withformalengagementwithinstitutionssuchastheMuseumofAnthropology,theBelkinGallery,theBillReidGallery,EmilyCarrUniversity,andothers,itmustalsoberegional,involvingthegalleriesofothermunicipalitiesintheregion,andnational,includingtheAGOandtheNational.
Whilesuchpartnershipswillbeconcernedwithhigh-levelissues(acquisitions,specializations,andcuratingandcoordinationofshows,etc.),theymustalsoaddresspracticalissuessuchassharedticketing(aswiththeParismuseum
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
7/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 7
system),dayprograms,andstorageandmaintenance.OneearlytaskforsuchapartnershipwillbethedevelopmentofArchiveArt,theproposedartstoragefacility,whichcouldprovidestoragenotonlyfortheVAGScollection,butforothersaswell,sharingboththecostandthevalueofthefacility.
Additionally,articulationandsupportofeachinstitutionsfocuswillensurethatthereisnoduplicationofeffort,orofbricksandmortar,orcompetitionforacquisitions:answeringsuchquestionasWhichinstitutionwillbethechampionofcontemporaryFirstNationsart?andShouldEmilyCarrUniversityplayagreaterroleinthearteducationprogramsofotherinstitutions?willalsoprovideausefulfocusforthispartnership.
2.CommunityofPrivatePhilanthropy.InordertobuildthephilanthropythatwillsustaintheVAGSintermsoffinancing,collectionsandendowments,itisessentialtoengagethosewhomightbebenefactorsoftheVAGS.HavinglosttheAudaincollectiontoWhistler,itisimperativethisengagementtakeplacenowtostemthelossofphilanthropytootherplaces.Inordertodoso,itisessentialtofindoutwhysuchindividuals(andgroups)woulddonatemoneyandcollectionstoVAGSandrespondtothesereasons.Apermanentadvisorycouncilofcollectorsandbenefactorsmustbeestablished,allowingVAGStolistento,learnfrom,respondto,andrespect,them.
Itisanticipatedthatoneofthemajorobjectivesofpotentialbenefactorswillbethattheircontributionsandlegacybeacknowledgedandthattheircollectionsbeshown,ifnotpermanentlythenfrequentlysomethingthatwillrequiremore,andunique,exhibitionspacessuchaspresentedinthisproposal.Inparticular,thecommunitygalleries,whichwehavecalledArtsPlaces,havethepotentialforbeingsignificantmagnetsforfocusedphilanthropy.
ThisCommunityofPrivatePhilanthropywillbemostinterestedintheVAGSslongtermvisionforitscollectionandexhibitionsandthediscussionsoftheCommunityofMuseumsandGalleriesasthesewilleffectivelyidentifythebrandandspecializationofnotonlyVAGSbutofotherinstitutionsaswell,criticalinformationforbenefactorsinmakingplansforbequests.
3.CommunityofArtsPlaces.Foursignificant12,000squarefootexhibitionspacesinVancouvercommunitieswillreflectthedepthofVAGSresponsibilitytosupportcommunitybuildingandengageinthedailylifeofcommunitiestheywillalsoprovidetheopportunityforexhibitionfacilitiesthatattractfocused
benefactorsandcollections.Todesignandconstructthesefacilitieswillrequireaprocesswherebenefactorsandresidentsprovideguidanceconcerningthespecialization,characterizationanddevelopmentoftheseArtsPlaces.Thetaskofthisgroupwouldbeginataconceptuallevel,workingwiththephilanthropygroup,toarticulateopportunitiesandorganization,beforefocusingonaproposalforthefirstonesuchopportunityin2014.Notethatwhilewehaveproposedfoursuchspaces,theirnumberandsize,aswellastheirlocationandspecialization,
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
8/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 8
wouldinevitablydifferasaresultoftheengagementofthephilanthropicandresidentcommunities.
4.EstablishPlanningandDevelopmentCommitteesforeachspecificphysicalstructureasdetailedinthenextsection.
B.PhysicalStructures
Fromourperspective,inorderfortheVAGStomeetitsresponsibilitiestoVancouverscommunities,itwillneedtofocusandenhanceitscollection(discussedinIV.C.following)anddevelopanumberofspecializedartexhibitionspaces.Inthislatterregard,weproposetheretentionandredevelopmentofthecurrentGeorgiaStreetbuildingandthecontinuationoftheOffsiteatShangriLaplusthedevelopmentofanewmajorexhibitionspaceforcontemporaryartindowntownandoffourcommunitygalleries.ThissectionconsidersthesephysicalelementsrequiredtotheachievementoftheVAGSstrategicgoals,workingfromredevelopmentoftheexistingtothedevelopmentofthenew.
1.ExistingElementOffsiteatShangri-Laexhibitionspace-unchanged
2.ExistingElementCurrentGeorgiaStreetVenue.
Currentlythis165,000squarefootvenue3has40,000squarefeetofexhibitionspace,45,000squarefeetofstoragespaceand80,000squarefeetofspaceusedforshops,restaurants,administration,entrances,exits,lobbyandcorridors.
DuringthecurrentdiscussionofthefutureoflocationoftheVAGS,muchhasbeensaidabouttheneedforaniconicarchitectdesignedgallerybuilding
well,therealreadyisone.Intermsoficonsandarchitectsdesigns,itishardtotoptheiconiccharacterandiconiclocationofthisRattenbury-designedNationalHistoricSiteandClassAheritagebuilding,particularlywhenitisrenovatedtohousethecollectionoftwooftheVAGSunquestionedcorecompetencies,theCanadianHistoricalCollections,builtaroundCarrandtheGroupofSeven,andtheFoundationofConceptualPhotographyCollection,builtaroundnotablessuchasWall,Douglas,Graham,andWallace,tonamebutafew.
Tousethisstructureandlocationtoitsfullestpotential,thestorage4hastogotowhereitbelongs,whichisnotindowntown(seeIV.B.3,below).Oncethisis
done,themainandupperfloors,comprisingsome40,000squarefeetofspace,willberedevelopedintodedicatedexhibitionspacefortheCanadianHistoricalCollection.Wehaveprovided$425persquarefootforredevelopmentofthis
3AllmeasurementsreferringtotheRobsonSquareVenueandthebigboxproposalforasinglebuildingreplacementarebasedoninformationthatwehavebeenabletoobtainfrommediapublicationsandaresubjecttoclarification.4Storagehereisusedtoincludepassivestorage,maintenanceandrestoration,aswellrecordkeepingandotheradministrativeactivitiesnotrequireddowntown.
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
9/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 9
space(atotalcostof$17million),anumberthatmanywillseeasinordinatelyhighbutwhichwechoseinordernottobeaccusedoflow-ballingthecosts.
Thespacefreedupbytherelocationofthestoragewillberedevelopedintoapurpose-builtcustom40,000squarefootGalleryofConceptualPhotography.Asmuchofthestoragespaceisunderground,itisparticularlysuitableforthedisplayofphotography,whichmustbeprotectedfromsunlight.HousingthefoundationworksofthisschoolofphotographyandlayingclaimtothispracticeintheflagshipbuildingfortheVAGSwillbothcementVAGSworld-classstatusinthisgenreandfacilitatefocusedphilanthropy.Againacostof$425persquarefootisusedforredevelopmentcosts,foratotalof$17million.
AdditionallyitproposedthatthemanagementandappropriateadministrationfunctionsremainatthisvenueinitscurrentHooper-designedAnnexbuilding(withbackoftheofficeandnon-criticaladministrationshiftedtothestoragefacility),andthattherestaurantandgalleryshopfunctionscontinue.Retainingmanagementandcoreadministrationfunctionsatthisflagshiplocationandrelocatingstoragetoanappropriatespecializedfacilityremovestheneedforsuchactivitiesatotherexhibitionlocations,therebybothincreasingthebuildingefficiencyofnewconstructionandreducingconstructioncosts.
Overall,thisiconicbuildingwill,onitsown,contribute80,000oftheenvisioned180,000squarefeetofdisplayspaceatacostof$34million.Notethatwhilediscussedfirst,redevelopmentactivityherewouldnotcommenceuntil2016,awaitingcompletionofconstructiononboththestoragefacility(ArchiveArt)andanewdowntowngallery(TemporarytoContemporary,whichwouldbeusedtodisplaythecollectionandtravellingshowsduringrenovationoftheRattenburybuilding,therebyensuringcontinuityof
exhibitionintheVAGS,anapproachcurrentlybeingfollowedatSFMoMA).
3.NewElement-ArchiveArt.
Pivotalto,andhencethefirststepin,achievingthestrategicgoalsoftheVAGSistherelocationofstoragefromthedowntowniconicflagshipbuildingtoaspecializedstoragefacility,whichwehavecalledArchiveArt.Thisstoragefacility,whichwillalsoincludesomeoftheincreasinglyinterestingopenstorage,willbeoutsideofthedowntowncoreonlandandinabuildingwhosecostsareappropriateforastoragefunction.This108,000squarefootfacility,withnetuseablespaceofthe95,000squarefeet,willbepurposebuilt,atacost
of$60persquarefootbuildableforlandand$200persquarefootforconstruction,foratotalcostof$28million5.
TherelocationofstoragewillbothfreeupthespacefortheGalleryofConceptualPhotographyandremovetheneedtohavebackofthehouseadministration,storage,maintenanceandrestorationspaceinnewexhibition
5Pleasenotethatinallcostsassociatedwithourproposal,wehaveassumedthatdonations,bothfinancialandinkind,togetherwithjointdevelopmentusingCACs,willbeeffectivelypursued.
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
10/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 10
facilities,therebyreducingtheirsizeandincreasingtheirbuildingefficiency.ItisalsoproposedthattheArchiveArtfacility,whosedevelopmentwillbeleadbyVAGS,beapartnershipfacility,withotherartgalleriesandprivatecollectorsengagedinboththedevelopmentanduseofthefacility.Forthisreason,thereisayearfordevelopmentofaproposalandpartnershipatthe
beginningofthetimelineforthisfacility:the95,000squarefeetofstorageandadministrationisbasedonVAGSanticipatedfuturerequirementsplusamarginforotherpartners,afigurethatmaychangeasthepartnershipdevelops.AtthispointithasbeenassumedthatthecostofthefacilitywouldbemainlybornebyVAGS:itisimperativetoexplorethedegreetowhichthesecostscanbereducedbyapartnershipinadevelopmentusingsomeformofCACand/ordonations.
4.NewFacilityTemporarytoContemporaryGallery.
InparallelwiththedevelopmentofArchiveArt,workontheVAGSsfirstnewexhibitionspacewouldproceed.Thiswouldbeanewdowntowngallerywith50,000squarefeetofexhibitionspace,whichwouldultimatelybedevotedtolargercontemporary,travellingandborrowedshows,butwhichwouldprovidetemporaryaccommodationforshowswhilethegalleriesfortheCanadianHistoricalandConceptualPhotographyCollectionswerebeingdeveloped.Pleasenotethatthis50,000squarefeetdoesnotlimitthescaleofexhibitionspaceforblockbustershows,asitcanbeusedtogetherwiththespaceintheotherproposedgalleries,apracticethathasbecomecommoninothergallerysystems.
Ourproposalrequiresthat,asthepurposeoftheVAGSistoexhibitthecollectioninawaythatisaffordableandaccessibletoVancouvers
communities,strictbuildingefficiencyrequirementsbeimposedonnewdevelopment,withthegoalbeingtomaximizetheratioofexhibitionspacetogrossbuildingarea.Withnoneedforadministration,managementorstorageinnewdevelopment,andanemphasisonartexhibitionratherthanarchitecture,50,000squarefeetofnewexhibitionspacecaneasilybeachievedin90,000squarefeet(a55percentgallerytogrossbuildingefficiency),leavingroomforagalleryandcaf(andperhapsarestaurantifitcanbejustified,althoughthereisnocompellingreasonforone,giventhenumberofrestaurantspresentinthedowntown).Wewouldliketoseeanevenhigherbuildingefficiency,achievingthe50,000squarefeetofexhibitionspaceinasmallerandlessexpensivegrossbuildingarea,buthaveworkedwithinthis55percentratiotoavoidunnecessarydebateaboutdetail.
Wehaveusedacostof$500persquarefootforexhibitionspaceand$250fornon-exhibitionspace,foratotalcostof$35million.ItwillbeparticularlyexcitingtoexplorethepossibilityofthisgallerybeingintegratedintoanewdowntowncommercialdevelopmentthroughaCAC,alongthelinesoftheSunatoryMuseuminTokyo,theAsianArtMuseuminFukuoka,orthePeabody,somethingthatcouldhavebeendoneintheTelusorNordstrom
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
11/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 11
developmentsandthatcouldbedoneatafutureBayParkadeorLarwillParkdevelopment,andsomethingthatcouldbringthecostdownsignificantlyfromthe$35millionwehaveestimated.
5.NewFacility-CommunityArtsPlaces.
Havingaddressedtherequirementsforstorage,fordisplayoftheCanadianHistoricalandConceptualPhotographyCollections,andprovidedfordisplayofcontemporary,largeandtravellingshows,thefinal,butintegral,elementisthedevelopmentofexhibitionsspacesinandwiththecommunitiesofVancouver.ToengagewiththecommunitiesofVancouver,theVAGSmustbecomepartofthedailylivesofVancouversdiversepopulations,manyofwhomdonotliveorworkdowntown.TheVAGSmusthaveapresenceintheircommunities,certainlytoincreasetheiraccessibilitytothecollection,butalsotoinvitepeoplefromotherneighborhoodstovisit,sothatpeopleengagenotonlyinthecollection,butalsointheneighborhoods,ofVancouver.CommunityArtsPlaceswillprovidenotonlytheopportunityfortheresidentofCollingwoodtogoDowntowntoseeexhibitedart(andtoshop,haveacoffee,eatandmeetpeople),butalsofortheresidentofDowntowntogotoseeexhibitedart(andtoshop,haveacoffee,eatandmeetpeople)inCollingwood.
Forillustration,wehaveproposedfourArtsPlacesbedevelopedoverthenext15years.Theseareinthe12,000squarefeetofexhibitionspacerange,withagallerytobuildingefficiencyof75percent,aratiobasedontheabsenceofadministrationandstorage,andprovidingformodestgalleryshopsandcafes:itwasnotproposedthatextensivenon-exhibitionspaceforcommercialactivitiesbeprovidedinthesecommunityArtsPlace,astheintentionisthattheysupportlocalestablishmentsratherthancompetewiththem.Withcosts
of$500persquarefootforexhibitionspaceand$250fornon-exhibitionspace,thesecommunitygalleriesarepricedinthe$7millionperstructurerange.Asthesesmallmodulegalleriescanoffernotonlystrongdonationandnamingattractionforbenefactors,butalsocanbereadilyincorporatedintonewrealestatedevelopmentandhencebenefitfromCACprovisions,theircosttothetaxpayercanbesignificantlyreducedfromthisestimate.
Thereareanumberofwaysthesespacesmaybefocused,withthespecificsemergingfromtheguidancecommunitiesofbenefactorsandresidents.Somemightbefocusedonthebasisofthecollectionofabenefactor,thewaytheAudiancollectionmighthavebeenhoused.Othersmightbefocused
thematically:wehaveaparticularinterestinseeingthedevelopmentofaspecializedcommunitygalleryfortheexhibitionofContemporaryAsianArtasanexpressionofanincreasedengagementoftheVAGSwithVancouverscommunitiesofAsianheritageandinterest.Further,thenumberandsizeofsuchspacesinourproposalissomewhatarbitrary,asthepotentialforagreaterdiversityofspacesandlocationsmayemergefromdiscussions.
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
12/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 12
Intermsofthescheduling,theprocessofdevelopmentofthefirstcommunityArtsPlacecommencesin2014,oncetheTemporarytoContemporaryGalleryandArchiveArtareoutoftheproposalstageandintothedesignstage.ThisistoensurethatthecommunitiesofbenefactorsandresidentsaresecurelyengagedandprovidingguidanceforthecommunityArtsPlaces.Thefull
developmentoftheseexhibitionspacesisseenasbeingthefocusofexpansionactivityforVAGSafter2018,withthefourthcompletedby2027,attheendofthe15-yeartimeframe.
C.TheCollectionandtheEndowment
TheheartoftheVAGS,theonethingwithoutwhicheverythingelseisirrelevant,isthecollectionandtheresourcestomaintain,expand,focusandexhibitit.Artgalleriesareaboutart-avitalartgallerymusthaveavital,focusedcollectingstrategytodisplaycollections.Toachievesuchacollection,theVAGSmustbeclearandspecificonwhatitisandwhatitdoes,definingitsbrandinordertodrawpeople,communities,acquisitionsandendowments.ThisisnottheplacetodiscusswhatthecollectionmustbeandhowitmustchangetofulfilltheVAGSstrategicgoals,butitistheplacetoinsistthatsuchadiscussion,anditsconfirmationwithVancouverscommunities,precedethediscussionofbuildingsthecollectionistobedisplayedin.
Ourproposalprovidesforamorethanfour-foldexpansionofexhibitionspacefortheVAGS,fromitscurrent40,000squarefeetto180,000,foracostof$125million.Thisincreaseinexhibitionspacewillnotonlyallowagreaterexpressionofthecurrentcollection,butwillre-assurepotentialbenefactorsthattheirgiftswillalsobeaccessibletoandappreciatedbythecommunitiesofVancouver,ratherthanbeinginstorageforever.Theproposalemphasizes
requiringefficientwaystoprovidetherequiredspaces,bothintermsofdesignandfinancing.Thisistomovethepricepointdownsufficientlysothatbenefactorswilldeemitreasonabletoprovidenotonlytheircollection,butalsoamatchingendowmenttoensurethatitwillbedisplayed.Theproposalalsoprovides$25milliontoexpandandrefinethecollection,tohelptokeepitvitalandcontemporary.
Indevelopingourproposal,weplacedacostconstraintofnotexceeding$150milliontoachieveourstatedvision.Ifthereisactually$300millionavailabletoexpandandrepositiontheVancouverArtGallery,thenwesuggestthatour$150millionproposalbefollowed,andthattheremaining$150millionbeput
intoanendowmentfundtoensurethatVancouverscommunitieshaveaccesstothecollectioninperpetuityinarangeofdistinctanddispersedgalleries.
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
13/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 13
DevelopmentSchedule
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
14/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 14
CostSchedule
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
15/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 15
PartTwo:BackgroundtoWhatWeareProposing
I.Asinglestaroraconstellation.
Thereisacontinuumofspatialarrangementsforculturalinstitutions,from
highlycentralizedtosignificantlydispersed.ThisrangemustbeconsideredinansweringquestionswithrespecttohowaculturalinstitutionsuchastheVAGScanbestrespondtothediversitythatcharacterizesthecommunitiesofthe21stcentury.Further,inthecontemporarycontext,asystematicanddynamicviewofinstitutionalresponse,ratherthanastaticone,isrequired.
ThehighlycentralizedapproachistheonethatothershavesuggestedfortheVAGSasinglebigbuildinglocateddowntown.ThisiswhatVAGisnow,writlarge,withanumberofgalleriesinasinglebuilding,muchlikeadepartmentstoreforart.Incelestialterms,thismightbecharacterizedasasinglebrilliantstarinanemptyskymodel.
Attheotherendofthecontinuumofspatialarrangementsisadistributedsystemcomprisedofanorganizationofanumberofsmaller,specializedgallerybuildingsthroughoutVancouver.Thismightbelikenedtoconstellationmodel,withmanyseparatestars,eachbrightinitsownaccordbutnoneblottingouttheothers,formingacoherentpattern.Functionally,itmaybemaybeseenassimplytakingthegalleriesoutofthebuildingandputtingtheminanappropriatelocationandbuildingforeachofthem(andseveralmoregiventheproposedspaceexpansion).SuchadecentralizationprocessfortheVAGS,itshouldbenoted,hasalreadybegun,asevidencedbytheexistenceofOffsiteexhibitionspaceattheShangri-LaHotel.
Betweenafullydistributedmodelandafullycentralizedone,ofcourse,lieanumberofcombinationsoflargeandsmallexhibitionspaces.OurconsiderationoftheresponsibilitiesandrealitiesoftheVAGSleadus,ascribingaswedototheprincipleofformfollowsfunction,toaformatwithinthisintermediaterange.Whatweproposeisaconstellationinwhichthedowntowncoreremainsdominant.Themajor,iconic,flagshipbuildingwouldbetheRattenburyheritagebuilding(anditstwospecializedgalleries)aspartofasystemthatincludesanewcontemporaryartgalleryinthedowntowncore,fourcommunitygalleriesandadedicatedstoragefacility.Inthisformat,theVancouverArtGallerywouldceasetobesynonymouswithanedificeandinsteadwouldbecomesynonymouswithadiversityofplacesandpresentations,asitappropriateinadiversecitythat
participatesinadiverseglobalculture.
Elementsofaconstellationapproachtothedisplayofpublicallyownedartcollectionsarealreadyevidentinothercities.Asonecurrentexample,theLouvresfirstsatellitelocation,theLouvreGalleryintheFrenchcityofLens,openedthisweektodisplayover200worksfromitscollection.Interestingly,thepurposeofdevelopingthisgallerywasessentiallybuildingandsupportingacommunity,asitisintendedtobringtouristsandtheirEurostotheeconomically
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
16/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 16
depressedNord-Pas-de-CalaisnorthwesternregionofFrance,aspartoftheLouvresacknowledgingitsresponsibility,inLouvrePresidentHenriLoyretteswords,togetoutofitscocoon.
Otherexamplesofdistributedgallerysystemsinclude:
-TheSeattleArtMuseumwithitsthreespatiallyseparatelocations;-TheStaatlicheKunstsammlungenDreseden(DresdenStateArtCollection)ispresentedbya12-museumalliancethatseesitselfasapointofintersectionbetweenthepastandthefuture;-TheParisMuseumPasssystemprovidesamethodofbothlinkingandpromotingattendanceatover60museumsandmonumentsinParis.-RomesMACRO(MuseodArteContemporaneaRoma),locatedinnorthcentralRomeopenedMACROTestacciointheoldmeatpackingdistrictofsouthRome;-TheHonoluluMuseumofArtwithfivevenues(TheoriginalMuseumneardowntownHonolulu,HonoluluMuseumofArtatFirstHawaiianCentre,SpaldingHouse,ShangriLainpartnershipwiththeDorisDukeFoundationforIslamicArt,andtheMuseumArtSchool);-ArtSetouchi,anamazingcoordinatedcollectionofinstallationsandgalleries,locatedinJapanonsevenislandsintheSetoInlandSeaandinTakamatsuonShikokuIsland;and,ofcourse,-TheTate,theTateModern,theTateSt.Ives,andtheTateLiverpool.
Readers,ofcourse,willhaveotherexamplesthatmightbeconsidered.
II.Storage.
DecentralizationoffunctionisfundamentaltothefutureoftheVAGS,asthereis
nocaseforhavingcollectionarchivingfunctions(storageofcollections;restoration,repairandmaintenanceofworks;andofarchivalandresearchactivities)androutinerecordkeepingandadministrationindowntownVancouveronthemostexpensivelandintheregion.Thereisnojust-in-timeneedforimmediateaccessforanyofthesefunctions,andtheirpresenceproximatetodisplayspaceshasnosynergisticvaluetheydonotbelongdowntownandtheydonothavetobeinagallerybuilding.Thereisnoneedforthesefunctionstobeinthesamebuildingand/orlocationasgalleries(bigorsmall);inallcases,individualgalleries,betheythesinglestarorpartoftheconstellation,candrawonthecollectionandservicesofferedbyaspecialized(non-downtown)storageandbackofficefunctioninanon-corelocation.
III.Synergyormereproximity
Theexplanationthathasrepeatedlybeengivenforhavingasingle300,000squarefootbuildingforVancouverspublicartexhibitionspacethatbyhavingalloftheworkstogetherinoneplace,visitorswillbemorelikelytoseeworksandshowsthatwerenottheirfocalreasonforvisitingamuseumbuildingthanif
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
17/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 17
theworkswereinspatiallyseparatebuildingsisanincrediblysimplisticvisionofbothartmuseumsandofthepublic.
Themany-rooms-single-buildingoptionsuggeststhatthereisagreatdegreeofsynergyresultingfromproximity.Theassertionthatexhibitionspaceshavetobeinthesamebuildinginordertotemptpeopletoventureintotheunfamiliarseemsakintosayingthatpeopleareonlygoingtosamplenewcuisinesinafoodcourt.Similarlypositingtheonestopshoppingdepartmentstoremodelofgettingallofyourartinasinglevisitisakintosayingthatpeoplewanttobuytheirunderwearinaplacewheretheycan,atthesametime,buyadeepfreeze.Theinternethasshownthatweareallspecialists,evenaswebecomegeneralists.
Itwouldseemsomewhatextremeweresomeonetosuggestthattherebeonlyonemassivepublicvenueformusic,ortheatre,ordance,soitishardtounderstandwhyitiseversuggestedforthevisualarts.Justastheonemassivemegastoresellingeverythinghasnotreallyworkedoutforretailexceptintherealmofbulkdiscountsales.Astructureofadiversityofsizes,specialization,andlocationsseemsmorecharacteristicofretailing,asitdoesofexhibitionofvisualarts,atleastinpersonalexperience,forthewalkfromtheMuseeDOrsaytotheRodintothelOrangerietotheLouvretotheCentrePompidoutotheMuseePicassoisastapleofvisitstoParis,asarenumerousotherwalksinnumerousothercities.ItseemsdemeaningtosuggestthatinacityasdiverseasVancouverpeoplearenotadventurousenoughtoeitherseekotherartvenuesorothervisualexperiencesiftheyhavetotravelabit6Onecouldassertthattheexcitementofexploringthecity,itsneighborhoods,anddistinctcommunitygalleryexhibitionswithinanartconstellationwouldbringmore,notless,traffictothecollectionoftheVAGS.TheVAGStotakeonanartsandculturalleadershiprole,aspartofitsengagementincommunitiesandpartnerships,theVancouver.
Havingsaidallofthis,ifa$300millionexpenditureistobejustifiedbyaone-stop-shoppingmodel,itmustbebackedupbyalotofhard,independentobjectiveevidence,ratherthanmereopinion,asitrunscountertonotonlyexperience,butthedecentralizationthatmanymajorgalleriesandmuseumsarepursuingastheygetoutoftheircocoons,andthatisreflectedinthepatternofbothcontemporaryprogrammingandphilanthropy.Soweask,WhereistheobjectivecomparativeanalysisthatshowsthatabigboxistheonlyviablewayforVancouverspublicartcollectiontobedisplayed?LetusalsounderstandthatthismodelfreesupthevalueofLarwillParkwhichcouldbemonetizedforabroaderpublicgood.
IV.CommunityArtsplaces
Tomeetitsresponsibilities,theVAGSmustbepartofcommunities,withapresenceintheirdailylifethatsupportstheirsocial,culturalandeconomicbase.
6Ofcoursethesehavetobeadequatelymarketedtoensurethatpeopleareawareofwhatisonwhereandwhen.
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
18/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 18
Locatedalongcommunityhighstreetsandatcommunitycenters,theindividualstarsintheconstellationoftheVAGSwillbringcustomerstolocalrestaurantsandstores,helpingtosupportcommunityeconomies,andbringpeopletoshareinthecommunity.
AconstellationapproachwithanumberofexhibitionplacesthroughoutVancouverwillalsopermitincrementaldevelopment,easingbudgeting,fundraisingandfinancingrequirementsbyspreadingcostsandactivityoveranumberofyearsandanumberofsources.Thiswillmaintaininterestintheon-goingactivitiesoftheVAGS;totheextentthatgovernmentfundingisinvolved,itissafetosaythatpoliticianswouldprefer8ribboncuttings,and10budgetyears,toone;anditsrangeofspecializationwillopenthedoortoawideranddeeperrangeofphilanthropy.
Thepluralisticmodelmeansgreaterdiversityinourartportfolio.Therearemanycontextsinwhichgreaterdiversitycouldbeconsidered.Oneverypracticalconsiderationiswithrespecttoriskmanagementhavingallarteggsinonebasketismuchriskierthanhavingthemspreadout.Anotherdimensionofdiversityistheexcitementofdifferentprogrammingthatwouldinevitablyresult,withdifferentopeninghours7andcuratorialstylesattractingandcreatingdifferentaudiencesatdifferenttimes,reflectingnotonlycollectionsbutneighbourhoodcharacteristics.
FrequentopeningswouldalsobringmoreexcitementandtraffictotheVAGSbrand.Withsucharangeofvenues,evenwithafourmonthshowcycletherewouldover20openingsayear,bringingaconstantrefreshmentandbuzztonotonlytheVAGSbrand,butalsotothecommunitieswherethegallerieswerelocated:insteadofgoingtoapublicartgallerythreetimesayearpeoplemightgo
twiceamonthiftheycouldseenewfocusedshowsinadiversityoflocations.
Thedecentralizedexhibitionspacemodelwillalsobroadendonoropportunitiesandincreasedonationattractiveness.Itwillattractdonorsseekingagreatervisibilityingiving,asratherthanhavingtherenamesingalleriesinsideabuilding(whichthecommunityseesonlyonceinsidethebuilding)itwouldbebuildingsthatwouldbenamedtorepresentedtheirlegacy,namesthatwouldbeoneverycommunitymap.WhileVancouverhaslosttheopportunityfortheMichaelAudainMuseumofFirstNationsArt,thereareperhapseightotherremainingopportunitiesforVancouver(perhapstheAudainWhistlerMuseumcouldbepartofVAGS).8
7Asanexample,RomesMACROhasopeninghoursfrom11:00to19:00,whileMACROTestacciohoursarefrom16:00to22:00.Thedifferencesreflectthenatureoftheprogrammingatthetwovenuesandthespecificcharacterofthecommunitiesinwhichtheyarelocated.8InSaskatoon,agiftof$30millionfromtheFrankandEllenRemaiFoundationunder-wrotethesuccessfulfundingoftheRemaiArtGalleryofSaskatchewan.GiventhecomparativescalesoftheSaskatoonandVancouverregionalpopulations,thissuggeststhatsomeeightsuchdonationsmightbeachievedhere.
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
19/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 19
Ithasbeensuggestedthatthepluralistmodelwouldinvolvehigheroperatingcoststhanthebig-boxmodel,andthismaywellbethecase.Thisissomethingthatmustbeconsideredinacomparativeevaluation,butthisconsiderationmustbeinacost/benefitframeworkmeasuredintermsoftotalcostsandbenefitsinmeetingVAGSresponsibilities.Aloweroperatingcostmodelthatdoesnotmeet
theseresponsibilitiesisnotsuperiortoahigheroperatingcostmodelthatdoes.Relativeoperatingcostsinisolationarenotajustificationforadecision,butrathersomethingtoprovideforinmakingthedecisionthereismorethanonehospital,morethanonerestaurant,oneschool,andmorethanonetheatreinVancouverinspiteofthefactthatthisinvolveshigheroperatingcosts.
V.Costsandefficiencies9
Thesimplemathofthebigboxproposalisthat$300millionwillbuy300,000squarefeetofartgallerybuilding,and,withinthatbuildingtherewillbe80,000squarefeetofexhibitionspace.Thissuggeststhatthecostsare$1000persquarefootofgrossbuildingareaand$3750persquarefootofexhibitionspace.ThesearesimplynotreasonableforpublicartexhibitionbyaninstitutionwhoseresponsibilitiesaretothecommunitiesofVancouverandtheirartcollection,andwhichmustconsideritsrequestsforfunding,beitfrompublicorprivatesources,inlightofnotonlyitsvision,butinlightofthelimitedresourcesavailabletoallofVancouversartscommunity.
Thereisawiderangeofissuesthatthisexcessivecostraises,manyofwhichcanbeconsideredundertheheadingofbuildingefficiency,theratiobetweenexhibitionspaceandgrossbuildingarea.Inthebigboxmodel,thisratiois27percent:wemustaskwhatishappeningtotheother73percent,whichiscostingthesame$1000persquarefootasthedisplayspace?
Obviously,someofitisbeinglosttostorageandadministration,butaswehavearguedelsewhereinthesenotes,neitheroftheseshouldbelocatedinprimespace,beitmeasuredintermsoflocationorconstruction.ThefirststeptowardsprudentfundingofVAGSexhibitionspaceistomoveactivitiesthatarenotimmediatelyconnectedtotheexhibitionofarttoanon-core,lessexpensivelandandconstructioncostlocation.Rightnowtheartgalleryisusingaboutonesquarefootofstoragespaceforeachsquarefootofexhibitionspace,sopresumablyinthe300,000squarefootbuilding,some80,000feetareforstorage.Movingthisstorage(andaddingabit)toanon-corelocationwouldcost$28million($260asquarefootbuildable),butwouldreducestheexpensive
constructionto220,000squarefeettoget80,000squarefeetofdisplayspace(a36percentefficiency),knocking$54millionoffofthepricetag.
Thisstillwouldrequireconstructing220,000squarefeettoget80,000squarefeetofexhibitionspaceasourproposaldemonstrates,thismuchspacecanbe
9Toreiteratetoensurethatthereisnomisunderstanding,pleaserecallthatforallcostsassociatedwithourproposal,wehaveassumedthatdonations,bothfinancialandinkind,togetherwithjointdevelopmentusingCACswillbeeffectivelypursued.
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
20/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 20
foundintheiconicRattenburybuildingalone.Withrenovationcostsestimatedatasubstantial$425asquarefootofgalleryspace(asthebuildingisalreadybuilt),andwiththestoragegone,80,000squarefeetofexhibitionspacecanbeachievedintheRattenburybuildingforacostof$34million.Foratotalof$62millionthesamequantitativeincreaseinexhibitionspacefortheVAGScanbeachievedas
thebigboxwouldachievefor$300million.
Fromourperspective,inordertomeetitsresponsibilities,theVAGSrequiresmorethanwhatthebig-boxoffers,andspecificallyitneedsanewdowntowncontemporarygalleryandfour(ormore)communitygalleries.Inthebig-boxproposal,toget80,000squarefeetofdisplay220,000squarefeetofconstructionisrequired(a36percentbuildingefficiency).Forourperspective,aminimumbuildingefficiencyof55percentmustbethestandardforthenewdowntownexhibitionspace,andaminimumof75percentmustapplyforcommunityArtsPlaces.Todosorequireseliminatingthingsfromnewconstructionthatisnotnecessary.Onthefunctionside,meetingrooms,loftyentrancewaysandlobbies,
grandstaircases,extensiveoffices,allofthethingsthatarenotdirectlyconnectedwithexhibitionofart,havetobeevaluatedintermsoftheircontributionversustheircosts.ThisdoesnotmeanthattheVAGSdoesnothaveaccesstothese,butrathertheyareinthemostappropriateplace,giventheircostandfunction,withtheopportunitytouseotherspaces(forexample,atUBCRobsonSquare,EmilyCarr,orMoA)forthefunctionsthatarenecessary,andgettingridoftheonesthatarenot.Evenwiththeshopandcaf,efficiencyandeffectivenesscriteriamustapply,aseverydollarspentonconstructionoftheseisadollarnotgoingtoexhibition,collectionandendowment.
Itisalsopresumedthatlandcostsfornewexhibitionspaceswillbeeffectivelyzero,asitisintendedthatnewconstructionoccurinconjunctionwithappropriatecommercialdevelopment,bywayofaCAC,andhencethatonlyfacilityspecificconstructioncostareinvolved.Aswell,byincludinggalleryspacewithinnewcommercialdevelopment,theriskofexcessivespendingonwhathasbeencalledstarchitecturewillbeeliminated,keepingconstructioncostsintherangeofthoseforcommercialspace:themissionofVAGSinvolvessupportingcommunitiesandart,notarchitects.Wehaveused$500persquarefootfornewconstructionofexhibitionspaceand$250fornewnon-exhibitionspace,with$260persquarefootforthestoragefacilityand$425persquarefootfortherepositionofthecurrentspaceintheRattenburydesignedbuilding.
Whileitiseasiesttocontemplateco-ventureexhibitionspacedevelopmentinthecore,itcanalsooccuratthecommunitylocations,throughthesameCACapproach.Further,communitycenters,schools,andlibrariesmightbewillingtoprovidesitesinexchangefortheagglomerationadvantagesthatanadjacentartinstitutionwouldbring,andtheCityofVancouvermightprovidesitesfromitslandbank.TotheextentthattheVAGSisabletoattractphilanthropytofundlegacybuildings,costsforcommunityArtsPlaceswouldbefurtherreduced.Andfinally,ofcourse,aspartofthejointventurewithprivatedonorstobuilda
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
21/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
DraftDecember2012 21
culturalinstitutionforthefuture,thecurrentrealestateendowmentoftheVAGcouldbemonetizedtoprovidesitesforand/orfunddevelopmentoffacilities.
Asaclosetothecostdiscussion,someconsiderationshouldbegiventoensuringthatoperatingcostaresupportedbyendowments:clearlydonorswanttoseenotonlytheirnamesonbuildingsbutthatthecollectionsareviewedandbenefitourcommunities.ToreturntotheexamplefromSaskatoon,theRemaifundingwas$15millionforcapitalanda$15millionendowmentforprogrammingoverthenext30years.
XIV.ABackgroundofDiversity.
Diversityisamainstayindiscussionsofcommunities:ironically,inmostofthesediscussions,thereislittleacknowledgementofhowdiversediversityis.Mostcommonly,thereissomementionofculturaldiversity(usuallyinareferencetomulticultural),whichis,sadly,equatedwithancestry,asthoughwhereancestorscamefromexplainsculture.InVancouveratleastdiversityis
muchmorethanmerelyderivedfromancestry,and,moresignificantly,cultureismostcertainlynotequateablewithancestry,andhenceVAGSmustaddresscontemporarydiversity.
Vancouverisaspecializedandmobilesociety,theproductandtheproducerofamulti-dimensioneddiversity.Certainlyitisdiverseintermsofancestry,withpeoplefrom223distinctethicoriginsresidentinmetropolitanVancouverascountedinthe2006Census.Notonlyisitdiversebut,withintheCanadiancontextitisalsodistinct,withoneoutoffivepeopleinthisregioncitinganethnicorigininEastorSouthEastAsia,fourtimesthenationalaverageandthehighestpercentageofthecountrysmajorurbanareas(forexample,ourshareis1.5
timessecondplaceTorontos13percentshare).ThissuggeststhatVAGSshouldincludeinitsvisionsomespecializationtowardsanAsiancollection.
Forsome,theconnectionwithanethnicoriginisdirect,assomehaveimmigrated,eitherrecentlyorinthepast.Forothers,theconnectionisindirectandgenerational,throughancestorswhoimmigrated.Theresultisthatwhilepeoplemaysharethesameancestry,theydonotsharethesameexperienceofit,withthoseborninCanadahavingtheirformativeexperienceswithinthematrixofCanadascommunities.Thismeansthatevenwithinancestrygroupsthereisagreatdiversityofpeopleandperceptions.
Thesamemaybesaidofreligiontwo-thirdsofourcommunitytakepartinone(ormore)of80differentreligiousaffiliationswhileone-thirdbelongtonoreligionagainthereisagreatdiversityofreligiousaffiliationswithinwhichthereisagreatdiversityofinterpretationandexpression.
Whileancestryandreligionmayinfluencehowpeopleseetheworld,incontemporarysocietyitishardtoarguethattheyaretheonlylensesthroughwhichpeopleview:thereareothermeasurabledimensionsofsocietythatdemonstratediversityage,gender,relationships,income,education,etc.For
-
7/30/2019 Vancouver Art Gallery Proposal
22/22
VAGSACommunityCenteredVisionofTheVancouverArtGallerySystem
many,occupationsandvocationsplayasignificantrole,andinthiscontextagainthereisagreatdiversityofhowpeopleearntheirlivinganddedicatetheirlives.
Suchmeasuresareformalmetricsofthedimensionsofdiversity;thereisalsoawiderangeofinformaldimensions.Theregionsresidentshaveawiderangeofexperiences,withmanyhavingtravelledandlivedelsewhereontheglobe,andofhobbies,recreationsandskills.Peopleliveinadiversityoftypesofneighbourhoods,fromsparselyruraltodenselyurban,andformanydowntownisneitherafocusorofmuchinterest.Evenhoursofworkdemonstrateawidediversity,with9to5nowmerelyanexampleratherthanarule.
Placingindividualsinthismatrixofmulti-dimensionaldiversity,linkingancestry,age,occupation,experience,income,gender,orientation,interestsandskills,noconcentrationofsimilarityemergesnotonlyistherenotamajoritywithsharedcharacteristics,thereisnotevenasinglespacethatwouldincludeasignificantminority.Thisisnotahomogenoussociety,norisitasocietycharacterizedbyahomogenoussub-group.Ratheritisasocietyofpluralities,asingleatomizedmass,witheachindividualadistinctelementmovingwithinlargerinter-connectednetworksoffamily,friends,co-workers,clients,acquaintances,andstrangerswithinthebroadandchangingmatrixofactionsandactivitiesthatisoursharedculture.
Insuchadiversesociety,whattiespeopletogetherisculture,theamalgamofindividualculturalexpressions.AndgivenVancouversdiversity,individualculturalexpressionsarealsoverydiverse,creatinganencompassingculturethatisasearatherthanalandscape.Everyoneisaculturalswimmernow,navigatingtheirwaythroughthechangingcurrentsofaseaofonewaterbutmanywaves,currents,andtides,eachofwhichreflectingthingsthathistoricallyhavebeen
calledthedeterminantofcultureandeachofwhicharenowoneofthemanyelementsofpersonalculture.Inswimminginthissea,apersonisatanyonetimeperhapsinaparticularbasinofaculture,andshortlythereafterinanother,butalwaysinthesea.
Culturenowisnotaninheritance,northedomainofastateorreligionorregion,butratherafluidandnuancedsharedexpressionofthelives,aspirations,imaginations,skillsandtalentsofthepeopleincommunities,bothlocalandglobalcultureisareflectionofpeopleastheymoveandchange.
Formalculturethebusinessofculturalinstitutionsistheprocess(nolonger
themechanism)bywhichindividuals,andhencecommunities,record,archive,document,analyze,transmit,andformalizetheirsharedculturalexperience,andourartitonewaythatthisformalizationisviewed.
Artisoneofthewayscommunitiescommunicate,andgiventheirdiversity,thereistheneedandtheopportunityforarangeofwaysandplacesforsuchcommunication,forarangeofaccesspointstoart,andhenceforadiversegallerysystemthatplacesartinthedailylivesofcommunities.