1 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
USPAS Accelerator Physics 2017 University of California, Davis
Chapter 9: RF Cavities and RF Linear Accelerators
Todd Satogata (Jefferson Lab) / [email protected] Randika Gamage (ODU) / [email protected]
http://www.toddsatogata.net/2017-USPAS
Happy Birthday to Hideki Yukawa, Paul Langevin, Rutger Hauer, and Gertrude Elion! Happy Rhubarb Pie Day, National Handwriting Day, and Measure Your Feet Day!
2 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Vertical Dispersion Correction
§ The end of section 6.10 in CM notes how sextupoles at locations of horizontal dispersion compensate both horizontal and vertical chromaticity
§ Normal sextupoles: § Horizontal dispersion:
§ First order in x, δ:
⇠x,N = � 1
4⇡QH
I�x(s)k0(s) ds CM 6.126
k(s) ⌘ B
0
(B⇢)�x
0 = [k(s)ds] x = (kL) x =x
f
⇡ [k0(s)ds] x(1� �)
b2(s) ⌘B
00
(B⇢)�x
0 ⇡ [b2(s)ds](x2 � y
2)(1� �)
x ! x+ ⌘
x
(s)�
�x
0 ⇡ b2 ds[x2 + 2⌘
x
(s)� x+ �
2](1� �) ⇡ 2[b2 ds ⌘x(s)�]x
3 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Vertical Dispersion Correction
§ Vertically for quads, sign flips and x goes to y
§ Sextupole effect is coupled in vertical plane, with horz dispersion:
k(s) ⌘ B
0
(B⇢)�x
0 = [k(s)ds] x = (kL) x =x
f
⇡ [k0(s)ds] x(1� �)
⇠x,N = � 1
4⇡QH
I�x(s)k0(s) ds ⇠x(sext) =
+1
4⇡QH
I�x(s)b2(s)⌘x(s) ds
⇠y,N =+1
4⇡QV
I�y(s)k0(s) ds
Quad
Sext
CM 6.127b
�x
0 ⇡ b2 ds[x2 + 2⌘
x
(s)� x+ �
2](1� �) ⇡ 2[b2 ds ⌘x(s)�]x
�y
0 ⇡ [b2(s)ds](2xy)(1� �) = [b2(s)ds][2(x+ ⌘
x
(s)�)y](1� �)
⇠y
(sext) = � 1
4⇡QV
I�y
(s)[2b2(s)⌘x(s)] ds
4 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
RHIC FODO Cell
Horizontal
Vertical
Horizontal dispersion
dipole dipole
quadrupole
half quadrupole
half quadrupole
H sext
V sext
5 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
6 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
RF Concepts and Design
§ Much of RF is really a review of graduate-level E&M § See, e.g., J.D. Jackson, “Classical Electrodynamics” § The beginning of this lecture is hopefully review
• But it’s still important so we’ll go through it • Includes some comments about electromagnetic polarization
§ We’ll get to interesting applications later in the lecture • (or tomorrow)
§ Particularly important are cylindrical waveguides and cylindrical RF cavities
• Will find transverse boundary conditions are typically roots of Bessel functions
• TM (transverse magnetic) and TE (transverse electric) modes • RF concepts (shunt impedance, quality factor, resistive losses)
7 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Electric charge density
Electric current density
9.1: Maxwell’s Equations
8 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Constitutive Relations and Ohm’s Law
⇥D = � ⇥E = �r�0 ⇥E �0 = 8.85� 10�12 C
N ·m2
⇥B = µ ⇥H = µrµ0⇥H µ0 = 4� � 10�7 N · s2
C2
�0µ0 =1
c2
⇥J = � ⇥E
� : conductivity
~D : Electric flux density
~E : Electric field density
" : Permittivity
~H : Magnetic field density
~B : Magnetic flux density
µ : Permeability
µ0 = 4⇡ ⇥ 10�7N · s2
C2⇡ 1.257
cm ·GA
9 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Boundary Conditions
§ Boundary conditions on fields at the surface between two media depend on the surface charge and current densities:
§ and are continuous
§ changes by the surface charge density (scalar)
§ changes by the surface current density
§ C&M Chapter 9: no dielectric or magnetic materials
Ek B?
D? ⇢s
Hk �Js
n⇥ ( �H1 � �H2) = �Js
µ = µ0 � = �0
10 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Wave Equations and Symmetry
§ Taking the curl of each curl equation and using the identity
then gives us two identical wave equations These linear wave equations reflect the deep symmetry between electric and magnetic fields. Harmonic solutions:
�⇤⇥ (�⇤⇥ �E) = �⇤(�⇤ · �E)�⇤2 �E = �⇤2 �E
r2 ⌅E = µ⇥⇤ ⌅E
⇤t+ µ�
⇤2 ⌅E
⇤t2r2 ⌅H = µ⇥
⇤ ⌅H
⇤t+ µ�
⇤2 ⌅H
⇤t2
��(�r, t) = �(�r)e�i�t for �� = �E, �H
) r2⇥ = �2⇥ where �2 = (�µ�⇤2 + iµ⇥⇤)
11 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Conductivity and Skin Depth
§ For high conductivity, , charges move freely enough to keep electric field lines perpendicular to surface (RF oscillations are adiabatic vs movement of charges) § Copper: § Conductivity condition holds for very high frequencies (1015 Hz)
§ For this condition
§ Inside the conductor, the fields drop off exponentially
� � !✏
� ⇡ 6⇥ 107 ��1 m�1
� ⇡r
µ⇥�
2(1 + i)
�(z) = �(0) e�z/�
skin depth � ⌘r
2
µ⇤⇥
e.g. for Copper
12 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Surface Resistance and Power Losses
§ There is still non-zero power loss for finite resistivity § Surface resistance: resistance to current flow per unit area
§ This isn’t just applicable to RF cavities, but to transmission lines, power lines, waveguides, etc – anywhere that electromagnetic fields are interacting with a resistive media
§ Deriving the power loss is part of your homework! § We’ll talk more about transmission lines and waveguides
after one brief clarification…
surface resistance Rs ⌘r
µ⇤
2⇥=
1
⇥�
surface power loss �Ploss
⇥ = Rs
2
Z
S
|Hk|2 dS
13 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Anomalous Skin Effect § Conductivity really depends on the frequency and mean
time between electron interactions (or inverse temperature)
§ Classical limit is , adiabatic field wrt electron interactions § For non-classical limit, no longer applies since electrons
see changing fields between single interactions
!⌧
�(⇤) =�0
(1 + i⇤⇥)!⌧ ! 0
⇥J = � ⇥E
Normal skin effect
Anomalous skin effect
Asymptotic value
Skin depth
Mean free path
Reuter and Sondheimer, Proc. Roy. Soc. A195 (1948), from Calatroni SRF’11 Electrodynamics Tutorial
14 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Plane Wave Properties
The source-free divergence Maxwell equations imply
so the fields are both transverse to the direction (This will be the direction in a lot of what’s to come) Faraday’s law also implies that both fields are spatially transverse to each other
[r2 + µ�⇥2] ⇤E = 0 ) ⇤E(⇤x, t) = ⇤E0 ei⇥k·⇥x�i�t
[r2 + µ�⇥2] ⇤B = 0 ) ⇤B(⇤x, t) = ⇤B0 ei⇥k·⇥x�i�t
�k · �E0 = �k · �B0 = 0�k
⇥B0 =⇥k ⇥ ⇥E0
�=
nn⇥ ⇥E0
c
z
k =2⇥
�rf(wave number)
vph =
�
k(phase velocity)
vg =
d�
dk(group velocity)
n ⌘�k
kindex of refraction
Generally F (z, t) =
Z 1
�1A(�)ei(�t�k(�)z)d�
15 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Standing Waves
Note that Maxwell’s equations are linear, so any linear combination of magnetic/electric fields is also a solution. Thus a standing wave solution is also acceptable, where there are two plane waves moving in opposite directions:
[r2 + µ�⇥2] ⇤E = 0 ) ⇤E(⇤x, t) = ⇤E0 ei⇥k·⇥x�i�t
[r2 + µ�⇥2] ⇤B = 0 ) ⇤B(⇤x, t) = ⇤B0 ei⇥k·⇥x�i�t
�E(�x, t) = �E0
⇣ei⇥k·⇥x�i�t + e�i⇥k·⇥x�i�t
⌘
�B(�x, t) = �B0
⇣ei⇥k·⇥x�i�t + e�i⇥k·⇥x�i�t
⌘
16 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Polarization
§ As long as the and fields are transverse, they can still have different transverse components. § So our description of these fields is also incomplete until we
specify the transverse components at all locations in space § This is equivalent to an uncertainty in phase of rotation of
and around the wave vector . § The identification of this transverse field coordinate basis
defines the polarization of the field.
[r2 + µ�⇥2] ⇤E = 0 ) ⇤E(⇤x, t) = ⇤E0 ei⇥k·⇥x�i�t
[r2 + µ�⇥2] ⇤B = 0 ) ⇤B(⇤x, t) = ⇤B0 ei⇥k·⇥x�i�t
�E �B
�B
�E�k
17 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Linear Polarization
§ So, for example, if and transverse directions are constant and do not change through the plane wave, the wave is said to be linearly polarized.
[r2 + µ�⇥2] ⇤E = 0 ) ⇤E(⇤x, t) = ⇤E0 ei⇥k·⇥x�i�t
[r2 + µ�⇥2] ⇤B = 0 ) ⇤B(⇤x, t) = ⇤B0 ei⇥k·⇥x�i�t
�E �B
Fields each stay in one plane
E/B field oscillations are IN phase
18 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Circular Polarization
§ If and transverse directions vary with time, they can appear as two plane waves traveling out of phase. This phase difference is 90 degrees for circular polarization.
�E �B
Two equal-amplitude linearly polarized plane waves 90 degrees out of phase
�E(�x, t) = �E0
⇣ei⇤k·⇤x�i⇥t + ei
⇤k·⇤x�i⇥t+�/2⌘
�B(�x, t) = �B0
⇣ei⇤k·⇤x�i⇥t + ei
⇤k·⇤x�i⇥t+�/2⌘
19 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
9.2: Cylindrical Waveguides
§ Consider a cylindrical waveguide, radius a, in z direction
§ can be imaginary for attenuation down the guide § We’ll find constraints on this cutoff wave number § Maxwell in cylindrical coordinates (math happens) gives
⇥E = ⇥E(r, �)ei(�t�kgz)
kg
k2c ⌘ k2 � k2g
k ⌘⇣�c
⌘(free space wave number)
(and the same for Hz)
20 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Transverse Electromagnetic (TEM) Modes
§ Various subsets of solutions are interesting § For example, the nontrivial solutions require
§ The wave number of the guide matches that of free space § Wave propagation is similar to that of free space § This is a TEM (transverse electromagnetic) mode
• Requires multiple separate conductors for separate potentials or free space
• Sometimes similar to polarization pictures we had before
Ez, Hz = 0
k2c = k2 � k2g = 0
Coaxial cable
21 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Transverse Magnetic (TM) Modes
§ Maxwell’s equations are linear so superposition applies § We can break all fields down to TE and TM modes § TM: Transverse magnetic (Hz=0, Ez≠0) § TE: Transverse electric (Ez=0, Hz≠0) § TM provides particle energy gain or loss in z direction!
§ Maxwell’s equations in cylindrical coordinates give
Separate variables Ez(r, �) = R(r)�(�)
Boundary conditions Ez(r = a) = E�(r = a) = 0
d2R
dr2+
1
r
dR
dr+
✓k2c �
n2
r2
◆R = 0
d2�
d�2+ n2� = 0
Bessel equation
SHO equation => n integer, real
22 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
TM Mode Solutions
§ The radial equation has solutions of Bessel functions of first Jn(kcr) and second Nn(kcr) kind § Toss Nn since they diverge at r=0 § Boundary conditions at r=a require Jn(kca)=0 § This gives a constraint on kc
§ This mode of this field is commonly known as the TMnj mode § The first index corresponds to theta periodicity, while the
second corresponds to number of radial Bessel nodes § TM01 is the usual fundamental accelerating mode
kc = Xnj/a where Xnj is the j
thnonzero root of Jn
) Ez(r, �, t) = (C1 cosn� + C2 sinn�)Jn
✓Xnj
ar
◆e
i(�t�kgz)
23 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
TM Mode Visualizations
§ Java app visualizations are also linked to the class website § For example, http://www.falstad.com/emwave2 (TM visualization)
• Scroll down to Circular Modes 1 or 2 in first pulldown
) Ez(r, �, t) = (C1 cosn� + C2 sinn�)Jn
✓Xnj
ar
◆e
i(�t�kgz)
24 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Cavity Modes
Dave McGinnis, FNAL
25 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
TM020 Mode
R
L
Ez ⇠ J0⇣u02
r
R
⌘
Beam
B✓ ⇠ �J1⇣u02
r
R
⌘
Peggs/Satogata
26 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
TM110 Mode
L
R
Beam
(a) (b)
Tail, Q = Ne/2 Head, Q = Ne/2
~B
~F on tail
~B(r, ✓) excited by head
Ez interacting with head
Peggs/Satogata
27 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Cutoff Frequency
§ It’s easy to see that there is a minimum frequency for our waveguide that obeys the boundary conditions § Modes at lower frequencies will suffer resistance § Dispersion relation in terms of radial boundary condition zero
§ A propagating wave must have real group velocity § This gives the expected lower bound on the frequency
§ Wavelength of lowest cutoff frequency for j=1 is
k2 � k2g =⇣�c
⌘2� k2g = k2c =
✓Xnj
a
◆2
k2g > 0
�c =2⇥
kc⇡ 2.61a
�
c� Xnj
a) cuto� frequency �c =
cXnj
a
28 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Dispersion or Brillouin Diagram
Propagating frequencies � > �c
�ph > 45�, vph > c
• Circular waveguides above cutoff have phase velocity >c • Cannot easily be used for particle acceleration over long distances
29 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Iris-Loaded Waveguides
§ Solution: Add impedance by varying cylinder radius § This changes the dispersion condition by loading the waveguide
30 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Cylindrical RF Cavities
§ What happens if we close two ends of a waveguide? § With the correct length corresponding to the longitudinal
wavelength, we can produce longitudinal standing waves § Can produce long-standing waves over a full linac § Modes have another index for longitudinal periodicity
Simplified “tuna fish can” RF cavity model
TM010 mode
31 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Boundary Conditions
§ Additional boundary conditions at end-cap conductors at z=0 and z=l
32 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
TEnmj Modes
fnmj =c
2�
s✓X 0
nj
a
◆2
+⇣m�
l
⌘2
Longitudinal periodicity
X 0nj is j
throot of J 0
n
Ez = 0 everywhere
33 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
TMnmj Modes
Hz = 0 everywhere
Longitudinal periodicity
fnmj =c
2�
s✓Xnj
a
◆2
+⇣m�
l
⌘2
Jn(kca) = 0 Xnj is the j
throot of Jn
Ez(r, �, z) ⇠ Jn(kcr)(C1 cosn� + C2 sinn�) cos⇣m⇥z
l
⌘
TM010 is (again) the preferred acceleration mode
34 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Equivalent Circuit
§ A TM010 cavity looks much like a lumped LRC circuit § Ends are capacitive § Stored magnetic energy is inductive § Currents move over resistive walls
§ E, H fields 90 degrees out of phase
§ Stored energy
C&M 9.82
35 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
TM010 Average Power Loss
ends
sides
§ Compare to stored energy § Both vary like square of field, square of Bessel root § Dimensional area vs dimensional volume in stored energy
U =�02E2
0⇥a2l[J1(X01)]
2
36 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Quality Factor
§ Ratio of average stored energy to average power lost (or energy dissipated) during one RF cycle § How many cycles does it take to dissipate its energy? § High Q: nondissipative resonator § Copper RF: Q~103 to 106
§ SRF: Q up to 1011
Q =U�
hPloss
i
U(t) = U0e��0t/Q
Pillbox cavity Q =
al
�(a+ l)
37 T. Satogata / January 2017 USPAS Accelerator Physics
Niobium Cavity SRF “Q Slope” Problem