Exploration Alliance www.explorationalliance.com
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013
Chris Wilson, PhD, FAusIMM (CP), FSEG Principal Consultant: Exploration Alliance Andrew Tunningley, MGeol, MAusIMM (CP), FSEG Principal Consultant: Exploration Alliance
Understanding Low Sulphidation (LS) Epithermal Deposits
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 2 www.explorationalliance.com
Why are LS Epithermal Deposits Important?
www.explorationalliance.com
Unless shown, all deposits shown with Measured and Indicated Resources as of December 2011: Company Websites and BGS data
Hycroft – 1134 Mt @ 0.35 g/t Au, 13.44 g/t Ag
Sleeper – 327 Mt @ 0.33 g/t Au, 3.87 g/t Ag
Hishikari – 4 Mt @ 60-70 g/t Au 2 Mt @20-25 g/t Au
Kupol – 12.75 Mt @ 9.73 g/t Au, 120 g/t Ag
Ada Tepe – 7.29 Mt @ 2.37 g/t Au, 1.03 g/t Ag
Waihi – 4.81 Mt @ 5.62 g/t Au
LS Epithermal deposits are major sources of gold and silver. Lead and zinc are common at depth and there is usually a good correlation between silver and lead grades. Copper may be present in the deepest levels of some systems.
FDN – 25.4 Mt @ 8.21 g/t Au, 11.0 g/t Ag (P+P, Dec.
2012)
Lihir – 870 Mt @ 2.0 g/t Au
Guanajuato – Historic Production of 4 Moz Au, 1 Boz Ag
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 3 www.explorationalliance.com
Tonnage (Mt) Gold (g/t) Silver (g/t) Lead (%) Zinc (%) Copper (%) 1 to >200 1 - >15 2 to >300 0 - 2 0 – 2 0 - 2
What are Explorers Hoping For?
Example World-Class Drill Intercepts: Hycroft, USA (Allied Nevada): 168 meters @ 0.51 g/t gold and 17 g/t silver (Feb 4, 2008) 144 meters @ 0.40 g/t gold and 36.9 g/t silver (June 25, 2008) 212 meters @ 0.54 g/t gold and 14.2 g/t silver (Nov 1, 2007) Kupol, Russia (Kinross): 29.9 meters @ 28.4 g/t gold and 222.9 g/t silver (NI 43-101) 12.9 meters @ 30.5 g/t gold and 378.3 g/t silver (NI 43-101) 9.0 meters @ 8.7 g/t gold and 83.6 g/t silver (NI 43-101) FDN, Ecuador (Kinross): 224.8 meters @ 2.1 g/t gold and 5.8 g/t silver (NI 43-101) 40.1 meters @ 5.3 g/t gold and 88.8 g/t silver (NI 43-101) La Guitarra (First Majestic): 1.6 meters @ 1.1 g/t gold and 366.0 g/t silver (NI 43-101) 1.6 meters @ 1.8 g/t gold and 263 g/t silver (NI 43-101)
Mainly open pit, oxide material.
From surface, over at least 200 metres vertical.
Underground mining only, but high grade.
Combination of underground and potential open pit on oxide material.
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 4 www.explorationalliance.com
Global Distribution
The high and low sulphidation epithermal deposits associated with blue coloured belts are late Mesozoic and Cenozoic in age (generally <120 Ma) and are associated with recent subduction zones including the present day Pacific Ring of Fire. Deposits located in the middle of plates (grey coloured belts or metallogenic provinces) are associated with Paleozoic age (ca. 542 to 241 Ma) rocks which were formed in ancient subduction zones.
Paleozoic Belts Mesozoic - Cenozoic Belt
Paleozoic Belt
Pacific Ring of Fire
Pacific Ring of Fire
www.explorationalliance.com
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 5 www.explorationalliance.com
Plate Tectonic Setting
www.explorationalliance.com
Cross-section through the Earths crust showing convergent plate boundaries where oceanic crust is subducted beneath oceanic crust (Ocean Arc setting) and continental crust (Continental Arc setting). Epithermal deposits form in these arc settings at depths of generally <500 metres to less commonly between 1 – 2 kilometres. Due to their formation very close to the earths surface, in regions of active volcanic activity and mountain building which are highly susceptible to uplift and erosion, their preservation potential is very poor.
Oceanic Arc
Epithermal Deposits
Continental Arc
Epithermal Deposits
Clastic Sedimentary Rocks
Andesitic-Dacitic Volcanic Rocks
Intermediate-Felsic Intrusives / Volcanics
I-Type Calcalkaline Pluton
Oceanic Crust: Tholeilitic Mafic Rocks
Mantle: Ultramafic Rocks
Alkalic Pluton: Intermediate Felsic Rock
S-type Calcalkalic Pluton: Intermediate
Continental Crust
Carbonate Rocks
Clastic Sedimentary Rocks: Reducing
Clastic Sedimentary Rocks: Oxidizing
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 6 www.explorationalliance.com
Epithermal and Porphyry Hydrothermal System
Intermediate Sulphidation
Low Sulphidation Epithermal High Sulphidation
Porphyry and Skarn
The term epithermal is derived from the Latin for shallow heat – reflecting the shallow crustal environment in which they form. Epithermal deposits are classed as High, Low or Intermediate Sulphidation based on mineral assemblage and the pH/Eh of mineralizing fluids. Epithermal deposits in general may overlie or be spatially related to deeper porphyry systems.
www.explorationalliance.com
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 7 www.explorationalliance.com
What is a Low Sulphidation Epithermal Deposit ?
Low sulphidation epithermal deposits represent the uppermost (or most distal) parts of intrusion-related hydrothermal systems. They generally form within 500 metres of surface but may occasionally form between 1-2 kilometres deep. Metals are deposited at temperatures below 2500C through processes of fluid boiling, fluid mixing and vapour release. Where these systems break surface they form geysers, sinter terraces, and thermal mud pools. Modern day examples include the Yellowstone park and North Island, New Zealand.
Ascending hot metal-rich fluids
Descending cool meteoric fluids
Ascending fluids mix with near-surface meteoric fluids causing them to: • Cool • Change chemistry • Precipitate metals
Hydraulic fracturing of host rock releases pressure. As a result fluids boil and drop metals.
500 m
250 m
250°C
200°C
150°C
www.explorationalliance.com
Metals Leached from Host Rocks/Basement?
BOILING
MIXING
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 8 www.explorationalliance.com
Bulk Tonnage or Narrow High Grade Target?
Permeable horizon: • Laterally Extensive • Bedding Planes and Fractures act as conduits • Disseminated Mineralisation • Localised High Grades
500 m
250 m
250°C
200°C
150°C
www.explorationalliance.com
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 9 www.explorationalliance.com
LS Epithermal Deposits – A Detailed Overview for Reference !
Geyser with silica sinter terrace and mud pools
Ore
Rare Gold
Gold in pyrite Silver sulfosalts
Pyrargite Argentite Electrum
Argentite Electrum
Galena Sphalerite Chalcopyrite Argentite
Zeolite, Calcite, Clays
Calcite, Zeolite, Agate, Stibnite, Realgar
Quartz, Calcite, Pyrite
Quartz, Adularia, Sericite, Pyrite
Quartz, Fluorite, Pyrite
Pyrrhotite, Arsenopyrite, Pyrite
Lattice Bladed +Bladed Carbonate ± agate
Moss + Chalcedonic > Crystalline
Crystalline > Moss + Chalcedonic ± needle adularia ± sulphide bands
Crystalline Quartz + Adularia + Sulphide (crustiform)
Crystalline Quartz + Carbonate
Massive Chalcedonic ± Lattice bladed
Crystalline Carbonate
Low grade Precious Metal Interval
Main Base Metal Interval
Kaolinite (+ alunite alteration in some systems)
Sericite
Chlorite
Smectite
Silica
Silica adularia
Illite-Kaolinite
Chlorite-smectite
Kaolinite-smectite
Gangue Vein Textures
High grade Precious Metal Interval
Silica flooding and chalcedony
500 m
250 m
250°C
200°C
150°C
Modified after Buchanan 1981
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 10 www.explorationalliance.com
Strong Vertical Zonation in Vein Textures indicate Depth of Erosion
The uppermost parts of epithermal veins have distinct textures such as carbonate blades and moulds which are generally replaced by silica (forming resistant quartz veins). White saccharoidal (sugary) quartz is also common. The presence of moulds and blades indicates that the entire epithermal system is preserved. Precious metal concentrations are generally of very low tenor in bladed and saccharoidal quartz veins - even in systems where high grade ore shoots are present at depth.
2 cm
Quartz vein showing moulds and bladed textures. These textures were originally formed of carbonate and were subsequently replaced by quartz.
White saccharoidal (sugary) quartz vein. Note bladed carbonate texture now replaced by quartz.
2 cm
Sheeted veins
Low grade Precious Metal Interval
Base Metal Interval
High grade Precious Metal Interval
Stockwork Veins Breccia
Main quartz vein
Breccia
Stockwork Veins
500 m
250 m
250°C
200°C
150°C
www.explorationalliance.com
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 11 www.explorationalliance.com
High grade Precious Metal Interval
Barren quartz vein from upper parts of system. Note early amethystine quartz (purple), and angular, open-space breccia, partly infilled with cockade quartz and marcasite.
Strong Vertical Zonation in Vein Textures indicate Depth of Erosion
Stockwork veins with chalcedonic and agate-like textures are common in the uppermost parts of the system and quartz-flooding of host tuffs may be present. Breccias usually retain open space (due to low confining pressures). Sulphides include marcasite (low temperature polymorph of pyrite) and pyrite. Precious metals (if present) are of a low tenor.
2 cm
Stockwork of translucent to light brown chalcedonic quartz hosted in weakly clay altered tuff.
2 cm
Sheeted veins Stockwork Veins Breccia
500 m
250 m
250°C
200°C
150°C
Low grade Precious Metal Interval
Base Metal Interval
www.explorationalliance.com
Main quartz vein
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 12 www.explorationalliance.com
High grade Precious Metal Interval
Colloform banded quartz sulphide vein formed in the boiling zone. Gold is associated with dark ‘gringuro’ or sulphide-rich bands. Each band likely represents one boiling event.
Strong Vertical Zonation in Vein Textures indicate Depth of Erosion
Deposition of gold and silver in high grade ore shoots is associated with the process of fluid boiling. Deposition of quartz and gangue minerals from hydrothermal fluids heals fractures in host rocks. This results in over-pressured fluids which eventually causes sudden hydraulic fracturing of the host rocks. Fluids boil as pressure is released and precipitate metal and gangue minerals from solution. In mineralized systems the more times this process repeats in a given vein the higher the grade.
2 cm
Oxidized (limonitic) breccia with banded chalcedonic quartz infill. Some breccia fragments (clasts) show boxwork textures after dissolved sulphides.
2 cm
Sheeted veins Stockwork Veins Breccia
BOILING LEVEL
500 m
250 m
250°C
200°C
150°C
Low grade Precious Metal Interval
Base Metal Interval
www.explorationalliance.com
Main quartz vein
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 13 www.explorationalliance.com
High grade Precious Metal Interval
Hydraulically-brecciated grey sulphidic quartz vein with sphalerite-galena infill. The lack of banding and presence of base metals indicates formation below the boiling zone.
Strong Vertical Zonation in Vein Textures indicate Depth of Erosion
Base metal sulphides such as galena and sphalerite typically form below the boiling level. Dark grey sulphidic quartz with high grade gold and silver may be present with base metals in a transition zone close to the base of the boiling zone. Localized changes in pressure and temperature may cause the boiling level to migrate up and down – causing telescoping of mineral zones and vein textures.
2 cm
Colloform banded quartz sulphide vein formed in the boiling zone. Gold is associated with dark ‘gringuro’ or sulphide-rich bands. Note late marcasite veinlet.
2 cm
Sheeted veins Stockwork Veins Breccia
BOILING LEVEL
500 m
250 m
250°C
200°C
150°C
Low grade Precious Metal Interval
Base Metal Interval
www.explorationalliance.com
Main quartz vein
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 14 www.explorationalliance.com
High grade Precious Metal Interval
Massive galena with minor clots of green sphalerite. Note late carbonate and zeolite formed as the system cooled and surface fluids percolated downwards.
Strong Vertical Zonation in Vein Textures indicate Depth of Erosion
The lowest mineralized levels of a LS epithermal is dominated by lead and zinc sulphides where they may form massive quartz-poor base metal-dominant veins. Due to confining pressure at these depths stockwork and breccia development is limited, unless porous lithologies permit lateral and upward flow of fluids away from the main feeder structure. Chalcopyrite may be present in some systems.
2 cm
Quartz vein breccia infilled by grey galena and green sphalerite. The quartz appears to be a relatively early and unmineralized phase.
2 cm
Sheeted veins Stockwork Veins Breccia
Main vein
500 m
250 m
250°C
200°C
150°C
Low grade Precious Metal Interval
Base Metal Interval
www.explorationalliance.com
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 15 www.explorationalliance.com
Narrow Vein at Base of System
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 16 www.explorationalliance.com
Alteration in LS Epithermal Systems is Strongly Zoned
Strong alteration zonation outwards and upwards from feeder structures provides vectors to mineralization. However, propylitic and near-surface alteration can be widespread and extend over 10’s of square kilometres making it difficult to accurately target narrow high grade ore shoots. Silica sinters or hot springs are important indicators of the uppermost levels of low sulphidation epithermal systems, but can form on distal faults that are a considerable distance from ore zones.
2 cm
Kaolinite and weakly silica-altered fine-grained tuff hosting sheeted quartz veinlets displaying fracture oxidation.
Strongly sericite (apple green) moderately silica-altered tuff. Minor galena is present as grey flecks. Note fracture oxidation.
2 cm
Silica Sinter Kaolinite±alunite
500 m
250 m
250°C
200°C
150°C
Silica
Zoned Clay-Sericite
Silica-Adularia
Propylitic
www.explorationalliance.com
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 17 www.explorationalliance.com
Geochemistry Changes Vertically Through System
There is a strong vertical zonation of geochemical signature reflecting the vertical zonation in ore and gangue minerals. Major and trace element geochemistry can be used as an indicator of level of erosion.
500 m
250 m
250°C
200°C
150°C
Low grade Precious Metal Interval
Base Metal Interval
High grade Precious Metal Interval
As-Sb-Hg As-Sb-Hg
As-Sb
As±Au±Ag
Au-Ag
Au-Ag±Pb±Zn
Pb-Zn±Cu
Pb-Zn±Ag
www.explorationalliance.com
Barren of Precious and Base metals at surface. Arsenic, mercury and bismuth are common pathfinder elements
Gold-rich interval where fluids “boil”. May or may not contain silver.
Base Metal-rich interval may extend to depth +/- gold-silver credits.
BOILING LEVEL
ww
w.explorationalliance.com
W
ilson and Tunningley AM
A, London 2013
18
Low Sulphidation Exploration – Strategy and Challenges
www.explorationalliance.com
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 19 www.explorationalliance.com
Global Exploration Strategy – Identify Arc Settings
Low sulphidation epithermal deposits form in Continental and Oceanic Arc settings as subducting oceanic plates melt and generate large intrusive complexes and associated hydrothermal circulation cells. Correct identification of Continental and Oceanic Arc settings is a pre-requisite for successful exploration.
Paleozoic Belts
Paleozoic Belt
Mesozoic - Cenozoic Belt
www.explorationalliance.com
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 20 www.explorationalliance.com
Preservation Potential – Is the Volcanic Sequence Preserved ?
www.explorationalliance.com
Cross-section through the Earths crust showing convergent zones where oceanic crust is subducted beneath oceanic crust (Ocean Arc setting) and continental crust (Continental Arc setting). Epithermal deposits form in these arc setting at depths of generally <500 metres to less commonly between 1 – 2 kilometres. Due to their formation very close to the earths surface, in regions of active volcanicity and mountain building, their preservation potential is very poor.
Oceanic Arc
Epithermal Deposits
Continental Arc
Epithermal Deposits
Clastic Sedimentary Rocks
Andesitic-Dacitic Volcanic Rocks
Intermediate-Felsic Intrusives / Volcanics
I-Type Calcalkaline Pluton
Oceanic Crust: Tholeilitic Mafic Rocks
Mantle: Ultramafic Rocks
Alkalic Pluton: Intermediate Felsic Rock
S-type Calcalkalic Pluton: Intermediate
Continental Crust
Carbonate Rocks
Clastic Sedimentary Rocks: Reducing
Clastic Sedimentary Rocks: Oxidizing
Must Preserve these Rocks
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 21 www.explorationalliance.com
Carpathian Arc-Related Epithermal and Porphyry District
Beregovo (6.9 moz Au)
Baia Mare (4++ Moz Au)
Rochovce
Trepca
Lece
Krotovo Buchim
Osogovo
Ocna de Fler
Majdanapek (8+ Moz Au + Cu)
Bor-Timok (9 Moz Au + Cu)
Vekikj Krivelji
Elatsite
Assarel
Medet
Chelopech (5+ Moz Au)
Sofia
Radka
Brad (11 Moz Au)
Rosia Poieni
Rosia Montana (17 Moz Au and 80 Moz Ag)
Recsk
Banksia Stiacnica (2.3+ Moz Au)
Kremnica (2.5++ Moz Au)
UKRAINE
ROMANIA
SERBIA
HUNGARY
SLOVAKIA
BULGARIA
INNER CARPATHIAN ARC
SOUTH APUSENI MTS
BANAT-SREDNOGORA ARC
SUMADUA-CHALKIDIKI ARC
PERIADRIATIC-RECSK ARC
250 km
Epithermal
Porphyry
Deposit size taken from a variety of sources. Most figures are historic production and Moz ++ indicates that cited numbers are likely under-estimate)
www.explorationalliance.com
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 22 www.explorationalliance.com
Preserved Volcanic Sequences Host Epithermal and Porphyry Deposits
UKRAINE
ROMANIA
HUNGARY
SLOVAKIA
Epithermal
Porphyry
250 km
INNER CARPATHIAN ARC
SOUTH APUSENI MTS
BANAT-SREDNOGORA ARC
PERIADRIATIC-RECSK ARC
Beregovo
Baia Mare
Rochovce
Brad
Rosia Poieni Rosia Montana
Kremnica
Recsk
Banksia Stiacnica
Volcanic Arc Sequences
Major epithermal and porphyry deposits of the Inner Carpathian Arc. Note that epithermal deposits occur within the areas of preserved arc-related volcanic sequences in deposit clusters.
www.explorationalliance.com
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 23 www.explorationalliance.com
Martha Hill Mine – Multiple Unexposed Veins and Alteration Vectors
The Martha Hill Mine started production in 1878 following discovery of outcropping veins. The Mine closed in 1952 having produced 5.6 Moz Au and 38.4 Moz Ag from 11.93 Mt of ore at an average recovered grade of 14.6 g/t Au. Over 160 km of access and production drives were excavated. The mine was reopened 1987 by Newmont. Martha is now an open pit, and together with the Favona Underground Mine, produced 108,000 oz Au and 522,129 Ag in 2010.
Adularia-Illite Alteration
Smectite Alteration
Illite-Smectite Alteration
0 m
Mary Vein
Royal Vein
Unaltered Ignimbrite
Martha Vein
-100 m
-200 m
-300 m
NOTE
• Multiple veins with strong structural control;
• Most veins not exposed at surface but alteration provides vector;
• Former high grade UG mine now mined as open pit by Newmont.
Brathwaite et al. 2006 Lower Miocene
Andesite
Early Pliocene Dacite
Martha Vein
Favona Mine
Current Open Pit
500 m
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 24 www.explorationalliance.com
Geological Understanding Evolves Through Life of Mine ….
Outcropping veins at this LS epithermal mine in Mexico guided exploration and underground development. The lack of vein outcrop within the area of Miocene basalt suggested that the vein system did not extend into this region as evidenced by the location of the tailings dam. Once it was realised that the basalt was post-mineral, the prospectivity of this area was explored.
Tertiary Granite
Miocene Basalt
Veins at Surface
Underground Workings
Tailings
500 m
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 25 www.explorationalliance.com
…. Leading to Increased Resources
Linear Chargeability High. Drilling confirmed silver-base metal vein
IP studies across the SE extension of the veins was conducted and chargeability anomalies were defined beneath the basalt cover. Subsequent development indicated that these veins are pyrite and base-metal rich thereby explaining the chargeability anomalies. Magnetite destructive alteration in the host granites indicates that ground magnetics would be an effective exploration tool. Similarly, elevated potassium response associated with sericite development also suggests that radiometric studies would assist with delineation of veins.
Tertiary Granite
Miocene Basalt
500 m
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 26 www.explorationalliance.com
Sustained Drilling Required to Define High Grade Shoots
Although the vein system is over 2.5 km long, the ore bodies are discrete and lenticular, occurring on approximately 200 to 300 meter centres. Sub-economic and barren quartz veins occur between high grade ‘ore shoots’. Once a mineralized vein has been identified, sustained drilling is required to define the high grade shoots. This requires a robust understanding of structure which exerts a fundamental control on the distribution of the high grade zones. Note the vertical zonation from upper gold dominant to lower base-metal dominant veins. Typical mined grades were +1.5 g/t gold and +150 g/t silver.
Silver-Base Metal Rich
Quartz veins with stibnite and rhodochrosite at surface
-300
-200
-100
0
100
200
Gold Only
High Grade Gold and Gold-Silver ore-bodies with Classic Ginguro
Textures
Post-mineralization basalt cover
Long section of Mexican LS epithermal deposit
500 m
Association of Mining Analysts: London, July 2013 27 www.explorationalliance.com
Caution – The Majority of Epithermal Quartz Veins are Not Mineralized
A basic premise of exploration for Low Sulphidation Epithermal deposits is that the entire system will be preserved beneath outcropping veins displaying upper level textures, mineralogy and geochemistry. However, many epithermal systems that do show these signatures at surface are not mineralized at depth – even within an existing mineralized property. Moreover, high grade mineralization typically occurs in high grade shoots that may require sustained drilling and structural understanding.
High level epithermal textures – But is the vein mineralized at depth ? If so where are the highest grade shoots ? Are there veins not exposed at surface ? How do you explore under cover ?
Exploration Alliance S. A. www.explorationalliance.com
Industry Proven Geologists • Most Commodities • Most Deposits Styles • All Physiographic Regimes
Exploration Alliance Consultants have Worked in over 90 Countries
‘We Have the World Covered’
ww
w.explorationalliance.com
W
ilson and Tunningley AM
A, London 2013
29
Case Studies: Red Flags and Fatal Flaws
www.explorationalliance.com
Exploration Alliance S. A. www.explorationalliance.com
Underground Mine Review: Silver-Gold Epithermal: Mexico
Exploration Alliance . www.explorationalliance.com
Grass Roots Exploration and Target Generation • Advanced Project Management • Field Logistic Services Resource Definition Drilling • NI43-101 and JORC compliant Independent Reports • Project Review, Audit and Valuation
Geology Courses for Investors, Analysts and Managers • Tailor-Made In-House Courses As Requested
Services in Brief
Exploration Alliance S. A. www.explorationalliance.com
Industry Proven Geologists • Most Commodities • Most Deposits Styles • All Physiographic Regimes
Exploration Alliance Consultants have Worked in over 90 Countries
‘We Have the World Covered’
Exploration Alliance S. A. www.explorationalliance.com
Andrew Tunningley Principal Consultant and Director [email protected]
Chris Wilson Principal Consultant and Director [email protected]
Chris Wilson Principal Consultant and Director [email protected]
Liliana Betancurth Regional Manager Geological Services [email protected]
Brodie Sutherland Regional Manager Geological Services [email protected]
Donna Werbes Manager Corporate Development [email protected]
Shaun Adams Regional Manager Geological Services [email protected]
Jos Hantelmann Principal Consultant [email protected]
Peter Pollard Principal Consultant [email protected]