Legal Essentials in
Business ContractingUnderstanding the fine printUnderstanding the fine print
Kapil Dev Sapra
Founder & Managing Partner
Sanjeev Vasdev, Managing Director
Flash Electronics (India) Pvt. Ltd.
Table of contents
• Business Contracts - Their Significance
• Business Contracts - Their Objectives
Section I: Business Contracts
• Essential elements/ingredients of a contract
• Outline of Standard Business Contract
Section II: Structuring of business contracts
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
• Non-compete, Non-solicitation, Confidentiality
• Intellectual Property Rights
• Damages
• Boilerplates clauses
Section III: Key provisions of business contracts
• Use of ‘Not known’ & ‘Known not’
• Use of ‘comma’
• Some other drafting tips
Section IV: Illustrations and tips
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
2
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
BUSINESS CONTRACTS
Section I
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
3
Business Contracts- Their Significance
• Being a business owner means that you will have to sign many commercialcontracts, with vendors, customers, employees and others.
• Agreement versus Contract
• Written versus Oral
• Complex and heavily regulated business environment.
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
• Complex and heavily regulated business environment.
• Ensure competitive advantages.
• Comply with sectoral regulatory and legal requirements.
• Interpretation by a Court/Arbitral Tribunal.
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
4
Business Contracts- Their Objective
Legally binding
Privity of Clarity of
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
Objectives of contract structuring
Privity of Contract
Ease of implement
ation
Certainty of rights and obligations
Clarity of scope
5
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
STRUCTURING OF BUSINESS CONTRACTS
Section II
6
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Essential elements/ingredients of a
contract
Offer
Acceptance
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
Consideration
Object
7
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Essential elements/ingredients of a
contract
consensus ad idem: i.e., meeting of the minds
clear and comprehensive terms
consistency in expression and terminology
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
consistency in expression and terminology
coherent flow
intention of the parties explicitly laid down
simple language-words used in same sense as understood by men of commerce and business
8
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Outline of Standard Business Contract
S. NO MAIN HEADS
1 Place and Date of execution
2 Parties
3 Recitals
4 Definitions
5 Interpretations
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
5 Interpretations
6 Purpose/ Scope of the Agreement (i.e. of Appointment/ Engagement)
7 Rights and obligations of the Parties, which should include:
• Regulatory approvals;
• Licenses;
• Personnel;
• Penalties, etc.
8 Consideration and payment terms
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
9
9 Taxes
10 Term (including Renewal) and Termination
- Termination with Cause
- Termination without Cause
11 Consequences of Termination
12 Confidentiality
13 Intellectual Property Rights
14 Representation and Warranties of the Parties
Contd.
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
14 Representation and Warranties of the Parties
15 Indemnity (one way or both ways)
16 Limitation of liability (one way or both ways)
17 Co-operation between the Parties
18 Assignment and sub-contracting
19 Compliance of relevant laws
20 Non-Compete/ Exclusivity
21 Non-Solicitation 10
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
22 Waiver
23 Severability
24 Relationship of/ between the Parties
25 Entire Agreement/ modifications
26 Precedence Clause
27 Cumulative of Remedies
28 Right to set off
Contd.
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
29 Notice
30 Survival Clause
31 Force Majeure
32 Arbitration and Dispute Resolution Procedure
33 Governing Law and Jurisdiction
34 Execution
35 Witnesses
36 Schedules/ Annexures 11
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
KEY PROVISIONS OF BUSINESS CONTRACTS
Section III
12
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Non-Compete, Non-solicitation &
Confidentiality• Non-Compete
• Agreements in restraint of trade are void – Section 27 of the Indian Contract
Act, 1872
• Exception – Sale of Goodwill of a business. Buyer / person deriving title
from buyer may restrict seller from carrying on competing business provided
restrictions are reasonable on:
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
restrictions are reasonable on:
• Scope
• Time
• Geographic area
in context of business
• Common law → Reasonableness
• Indian Law → Sale of Goodwill + Reasonableness13
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Applicability of Non-Compete
• In Term or Post Term
• Qua employees in employment contracts:
• Service bonds – enforceability
• Qua vendors, suppliers, agents, etc.
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
• Qua vendors, suppliers, agents, etc.
• Qua shareholders in shareholders agreements
• Qua buyers and sellers of business
14
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Non-solicitation
• Meaning: An obligation not to take away customers, venders, employees, etc.
• Scope:
• In Terms
• Post Term
• Work Around & It's mitigation
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
• Work Around & It's mitigation
• Enforceability
• Burden of Proof
• Evidence
15
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Confidentiality• Meaning: Protection of trade secrets & proprietary information
• Contract must specify as to how a party can classify an oral information as being
“Confidential”.
• Exceptions
• information that can be demonstrated to have been in the public domain at
the time it was disclosed;
• information that can be demonstrated to have been known to the Receiving
Party at the time of disclosure with no obligation of confidence;
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
Party at the time of disclosure with no obligation of confidence;
• information that becomes known to the Receiving Party from a source other
than the Disclosing Party without breach of any obligation of confidence by
the Receiving Party; etc.
• Scope:
• In Terms
• Post Term
• Enforceability - Burden of Proof and Evidence 16
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Intellectual Property Rights• Means – Trademark, copyrights, Design, Patents and other proprietary rights.
• License versus Assignment
• Scope:
• In Terms
• Post Term
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
• an ideal contract should contain:
• define what constitutes IPR
• declare ownership on all IPR on the subject matter
• provide for accessibility and authority and conditions for use by the other
party
• provide for the protection of IPR
• provide for indemnification in case of infringement 17
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Damages
• Means: Compensation for loss or damaged caused to one party due to breach
of terms and conditions of the Contract, misrepresentation, negligence, etc.
of other party.
• Law of Damages
• Direct Damages versus Indirect Damages
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
• Direct Damages versus Indirect Damages
• Actual Damages versus liquidated Damages
• Enforceability - Burden of Proof and Evidence
18
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Boilerplate clauses
• Means: any text that is or can be reused in new contexts or applications
without being changed much from the original. In most negotiations, the
parties spend little or no time focusing on or re-writing these clauses.
• In most standard contracts, roughly the last part of the contract consists of
such, most standard, little-noticed boilerplates such as assignment, waiver,
notices, etc.
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
notices, etc.
• Boilerplate clauses are also important because they affect the legal rights of
the parties under the contract as much as any other important clauses.
19
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Boilerplate Clauses for Discussion
• Force majeure
• Entire Agreement
• Precedence
• Notice
• Waiver
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
• Waiver
• Term and Termination
• Clauses on settlement of disputes
20
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Force Majeure• ‘Force majeure’- a French phrase meaning superior force or overwhelming
circumstances.
• Normally events of ‘force majeure’ are interpreted to mean events over whicha party has no control and in some cases to mean events in the nature of ‘Actsof God’ e.g. flood, earthquake, fire, etc.
• Through careful drafting, the scope and kind of events that would constitute‘force majeure’ event can be limited or expanded.
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
• Inclusion of the words “beyond the control of the parties” expands the scopeof a ‘force majeure’ clause by encompassing events covered beyond thetraditional ‘Acts of God’ like extreme cold weather which may not beconsidered as an ‘Act of God’ as it cannot be regarded as ‘catastrophic’.
• Act of government
• Labour unrest – Affecting party or affecting industry as a whole
21
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
• Specific force majeure events or catchall category or both
• End result of the force majeure events:
• termination of the contract; or
• extension of time.
• Obligation of the Parties
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
22
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Entire Agreement
• The entire agreement clause (also called an integration clause) is typical language included in many contracts, which:
• limits the terms of a written agreement
• creates clarity and certainty
• Suggested Clause
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
“This Agreement constitutes the whole and entire agreement among the
parties in connection with the transactions contemplated herein and cancels
and supersedes any prior agreements, undertakings, declarations,
commitments, representations, written or oral, in respect thereof, and there are
no express or implied terms, conditions, agreements, undertakings,
declarations, commitments, representations or warranties or other duties
(legal, equitable, fiduciary or in tort) whatsoever among the parties not
expressly provided for in this Agreement.”23
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
• When there is more than one agreements, then in case of contradiction
which agreement will prevail over the other agreement.
• Suggested clause
“The following documents shall be deemed to form, and be read and
construed, as part of the Contract in the following order of precedence to
resolve any conflict between the documents:
Precedence
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
resolve any conflict between the documents:
a. This Contract;
b. Special conditions of contract, annexed as Annexure “A”;
c. General conditions of contract, annexed as Annexure “B”;
d. Purchase Order, annexed as Annexure “C”;
e. LOI, annexed as Annexure “D”;
f. Technical Specifications of Work, collectively annexed as Annexure “E”;
g. Price Schedule of Quantities/ BOQ, annexed as Annexure “F”; and
h. Any other documents forming part of this Contract.”
24
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Notice • Typically applies to all communication that is required or permitted to be
delivered to any party pursuant to the Contract.
• Needs to be drafted carefully, as disputes can arise regarding whether
effective notice was delivered or not.
• The notice provision include:
(i) the method by which notice should be given;
(ii) when notice is considered to be delivered and received;
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
(ii) when notice is considered to be delivered and received;
(iii)what, if any, is the effect of a disruption in delivery;
(iv) the nature of the notice provision, including whether the notice provision
is mandatory or permissive; and
(v) the individual to whom notice must be delivered when notice is required to
be delivered to a corporation, partnership or trust.
• Advisable to avoid identifying an individual by name, since people move
around and change positions. It is best to indicate an office, such as Manager,
Chief Executive Officer.
25
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Waiver • Limits and clarifies a party’s ability to avoid certain contractual obligations.
• Failure by a party to enforce any provision of a contract shall not be treated asa waiver of that provision, nor shall it affect the right of that party subsequentlyto enforce that provision.
• Express or inferred from conduct which is inconsistent with the right.
• Delay or failure to exercise a right may, in certain circumstances, constitute a
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
• Delay or failure to exercise a right may, in certain circumstances, constitute awaiver of that right. It is therefore common for parties to include in theiragreement a provision providing that no waiver of any clause in the agreementis binding unless it is made in writing and signed by all the parties entitled, aspursuant to the agreement, to grant the waiver.
• Any waiver must be made in writing.
• Distinguished from Estoppel.26
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Term & Termination/Expiry
• Fixed versus Ongoing/Evergreen
• Termination with cause
• Cure Period
• Immediate
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
• Immediate
• Termination without cause
27
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Settlement of Disputes• Mediation and Conciliation
• Arbitration
• Applicable law to arbitration,
• Venue of arbitration,
• number of arbitrators and their appointment,
• Interim measures / provisional remedies,
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
• Interim measures / provisional remedies,
• privacy, rules applicable, appeal and enforcement,
• Survival after termination of the main agreement.
• Governing Law
• Jurisdiction28
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
MISCELLANEOUS DRAFTING ISSUES
Section IV
29
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Use of ‘Not known’ & ‘Known not’
“Confidential Information shall not include any information which has been
obtained lawfully by the recipient from a third party who is known not to have
obtained such information directly or indirectly from the disclosing party.”
“Confidential Information shall not include any information which has been
obtained lawfully by the recipient from a third party who is not known to have
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
obtained lawfully by the recipient from a third party who is not known to have
obtained such information directly or indirectly from the disclosing party.”
30
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Use of ‘comma’
• Indian Income Tax Act provides “….secret formula, process…..”
• Indo-US Treaty provides “….. Secret formula or process……..”
• Company A, faced a tax liability of Rs. 200 crore as the comma in the Indian
Income Tax Act altered the definition of royalty. At the same time, the
absence of a comma in the Indo-US Treaty saved Company B from a liability of
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
absence of a comma in the Indo-US Treaty saved Company B from a liability of
Rs. 77 crore.
• As per Indian Income Tax Act even if process is not secret, it is classified as a
royalty and thus taxable. Whereas as per Indo-US Treaty , formula and process
both must be secret in order to be classified as royalty. If not. It is not taxable .
31
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Some other drafting tips
• Clarity on scope.
• Identification of specific exclusions.
• Inclusive versus definitive definitions.
• Cautious use of ‘indemnification’ language.
• Inclusion of limitation of liability clause, if appropriate
• Avoidance of use of expression such as “proper”, “reasonable”, as far
as possible.
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
as possible.
• Incorporation of an acceptance clause.
• Avoidance of use of long sentences or creative wording.
• Customization of the contract for a particular transaction.
• Proof reading of the contract carefully.
• Execution of a duly signed and dated contract.
• Consultation with a legal counsel.32
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates
Thank You!
For more details contact
Sanjeev Vasdev Kapil Dev Sapra
Se
pte
mb
er
30
, 2
01
1
Sanjeev Vasdev Kapil Dev Sapra
Managing Director Founder & Managing Partner
Flash Electronics (India) Pvt. Ltd. Kapil Sapra & Associates
A- 4, MIDC Chakan Industrial Area, M-34, Saket
Mahalunge, Chakan, Pune 410 501. New Delhi-110017
Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected]
Phone: +91-2135-666000 Phone:+91-11-2956-5201/ 02/ 03
Fax: +91-2135 - 666109 Fax:+91-11-2956-5204 33
Flash Electronics and Kapil Sapra & Associates