-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
1/20
Ygbmsm`ab J`gngo} gdJntm{gnojnsab Y{gsj`smgn mn
Mncgnjpma
A{mansg A. Yaszn{z
Shj tmjup jxy{jppjc mn shmp yayj{'y{jpjnsasmgn a{j shj tmjup gd shj azshg{(p- anc cg ngs nj`jppa{mb} {jdbj`s shj tmjup g{ ygbm`mjp gdshj Apman Cjtjbgyojns Kanl (ACK-" g{ msp Kga{c gd Cm{j`sg{p" g{ shj egtj{nojnsp shj} {jy{jpjns. ACK cgjp ngs eza{ansjj shj
pgz{`j" g{memnabms}" a``z{a`}" `goybjsjnjpp g{ {jbmakmbms} gd an} psasjojns" mndg{oasmgn" casa" dmncmne" mnsj{y{jsasmgn" actm`j" gymnmgn"
g{ tmju y{jpjnsjc" ng{ cgjp ms oalj an} {jy{jpjnsasmgn `gn`j{nmne shj paoj.
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
2/20
Ka`le{gznc
Mncgnjpmap ygg{ a{j mn ba{ej ya{sappg`masjc umsh6 {z{ab'ae{m`zbsz{j"mndg{oab" japsj{n'{jogsj
Cgomnan`j gd ae{m`zbsz{j (mn KAZoannj{- moya`sp pmenmdm`ansb} gnjntm{gnojnsab cje{acasmgn anc nasz{ab{jpgz{`j cjybjsmgn
Cjyjncjn`j gn ae{m`zbsz{j mp pjnpmsmtjsg `bmoasj `hanej
Hjn`j shj `abb dg{ e{jjn j`gngo}
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
3/20
@z{{jns CjtjbgyojnsYgbm`mjp
Omcsj{o Cjtjbgyojns Yban ;919/;913 dg`zpjp gnegtj{nan`j {jdg{o" jcz`asmgn" hjabsh" ygtj{s}{jcz`smgn" dggc pj`z{ms}" mnd{aps{z`sz{j" mntjpsojns`bmoasj" jnj{e}" jntm{gnojnsab anc cmpapsj{oanaejojns" bjaps cjtjbgyjc g{ ygps/`gndbm`s a{jap"
anc `zbsz{j" `{jasmtms}" $ sj`hngbge} mnngtasmgn
Eggc6 jntm{gnojns anc ygtj{s} a{j shj{j. Kac6 psmbb{ashj{ zn`bja{ cm{j`smgn anc d{aojug{l.
@z{{jns pg`mab appmpsan`j y{ge{aop6 nasmgnab mnpz{an`jp}psjo (Faoljpnap-" `aph s{anpdj{" p`hggb gyj{asmgnabappmpsan`j (KGP-" @@S (YLH" YNYO- ngu uhj{j a{j
jntm{gnojns anc ygtj{s}7 Uhj{jp fgk `{jasmgn7
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
4/20
E{gush" Ygtj{s}" ancZnjoybg}ojns
Pgz{`j6 KYP" EGM ta{mgzp}ja{p
Ygtj{s} anc znjoybg}ojns cj`{japjc" kzs e{gush hap ngs kjjnmn`bzpmtj (nja{/ygg{ a{j oan}" fgkp `{jasjc ogpsb} mndg{oab-.Jntm{gnojns anc nasz{ab {jpgz{`jp a{j psmbb gzspmcj shj jqzasmgn
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
5/20
Ygtj{s} anc Mnjqzabms}
Pgz{`j6 ACK ;919
Ygtj{s} mp `goya{akbj sg @aokgcma" da{ kjhmnc Oaba}pma ancShambanc. Mncgnjpmap tzbnj{akbj (nja{/ygg{- a{j oan}6 1:* gdygyzbasmgn zncj{ ygtj{s} bmnj" kzs 3;* zncj{ ZPC ;/bmnjMnjqzabms} mp ngs shj ug{ps" kzs `j{samnb} ngs eggc jngzeh
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
6/20
Ygtj{s} Y{gdmbj (1=54/;99=-
Pgz{`j6 Pz{}ahacm js ab. ;919
Anc ygtj{s} mp ngs fzps akgzs ognjsa{}! Ngn/mn`goj ygtj{s} mp
og{j pjtj{j anc msp {z{ab/z{kan eayp a{j jtjn umcj{
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
7/20
[jemgnab Cmpya{ms}
Pgz{`j6 KYP ;99=" [jpgpzca{og anc ]zpzd ;99=Ngsj6 Mn`goj mn [y 999" ;998y{m`jp
Japsj{n Mncgnjpma y{gtmn`jp a{j mn ejnj{ab ygg{j{ shan shjm{ujpsj{n `gznsj{ya{sp
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
8/20
Cjdg{jpsasmgn anc @G;
Jomppmgn
Pgz{`j6 ACK ;919
Dg{jps `gtj{aej mp ph{mnlmne daps. Jomppmgn mn`{japjp {aymcb}" jtjnshgzeh pjjop {jbasmtjb} poabb mn yj{ `aymsa kapmp
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
9/20
Gshj{ Jntm{gnojnsabY{gkbjop
Pgz{`j6 ACK ;919Ngsjp6 (1- ;99: YYY ZPC'le gmb jqzmtabjns" (;- Atj{aej yj{`jns `hanej
;999/;995" (0"3- Ombbmgn ojs{m` sgnp @G; jqzmtabjns" ;99:" (:"4"5- Yj{`jnsgd banc a{ja" ;995
Gshj{ y{gkbjop a{j abpg moyg{sans" mn`bzcmne banc dg{ ae{m`zbsz{j
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
10/20
[jemgnab@G;
Jomppmgn(;99:-
Mn ombbmgnsgnp
Pgz{`j6 ]zpzd ;919
[jbasmtjb} {m`hy{gtmn`jp ancnasz{ab/{jpgz{`jcjyjncjns
joms og{j
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
11/20
[j`goojncasmgn
E{jjn j`gngo} d{aojug{l (moybjojnsjcas shj hmehjps bjtjb m.j. pzpsamnakbjcjtjbgyojns ap ya{acmeo-
Phg{s/sj{o" ygppmkbj ygbm`mjp'a`smgnp6 Oa`{g/bjtjb6 E{jjn ECY" E{jjn Kzcejsmne
Om`{g/bjtjb6 mn`jnsmtj acfzpsojns (y{m`mne gddzjb anc jbj`s{m`ms}" moy{gtjojns mns{anpyg{sasmgn" sax {jbmjd dg{ e{jjn y{ge{aop"YJP-" kmg/dzjb (7-
Ebgkab/ anc {jemgnab/bjtjb6 `gg{cmnasmgn
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
12/20
E{jjn ECY6 Shj Kayyjnap/BYJO Ogcjb
K{gun ECY E{jjn ECY M'G ogcjb
Omnzp cjybjsmgn $ cje{acasmgn
E{gush 7Jntm{gnojns 7
Kgsh 7
E{gush Eay
Ygbm`}
PU
GS
Y
{gfjsmg
np
Oa`{gj`gngom`p
Gzsyzs
Mn`goj
Egts [jtjnzjp
Tabzj Accjc
Bakg{
Pgz{`j6 BYJO/DJZM;993
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
13/20
E{jjn anc K{gun ECY
Pgz{`j6 BYJO/DJZM ;993" KYP ta{mgzp}ja{p
Mncgnjpmap jpsmoasjc E{jjn ECY e{gush mn ;991 uap 1;0 kypbguj{ shan msp K{gun ECY" anc 4; kyp mn ;99=" mdy{jpj{tasmgn anc`gnpj{tasmgn sggl yba`j (e{aczabb}- (BYJO/DJZM ;993-. Mn ngomnab
sj{op" shj e{jjn ECY uap 8:* gd shj k{gun ECY mn ;99: (]zpzd;919-
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
14/20
[jemgnab E{jjnECY
Pgz{`j6 ]zpzd ;919
Ap dg{ y{gtmn`jp"
Yayza" JapsLabmoansan" UjpsNzpa Sjneea{a" [maz"anc Pgzsh Pzoas{a{anl bgu. Shjpj a{jN[/kapjc y{gtmn`jp.
Shjm{ j`gngom`y{ge{jpp omehs ngs kjpzpsamnakbj
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
15/20
Pzkpmc} mn shj Kzcejs
Pgz{`j6 EGM ta{mgzp }ja{p
Kme `hznl gd psasj
ognj} egjp sg pzkpmc}"ogps gd uhm`h mp sgdmnan`j shj`gnpzoysmgn gd dzjb/kapjc jnj{e}Zndg{sznasjb} shmp
kjnjdmsp ngs shj ygg{!
Pgz{`j6 JMA ;919
Pzkpmcmvasmgn {asj (* gd oa{ljs y{m`j-
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
16/20
Ebgkab @gg{cmnasmgnPj`sg{
Sa{ejs;4 *
(Emea sgnp-
@gps
(MC[ S{mbbmgn- Sa{ejs 31 *
(accmsmgnab{jcz`smgn 1:*-
(Emea sgnp-
Accmsmgnab @gps(MC[ S{mbbmgn-
Jnj{e} 9.909 9.1 9.9195:
S{anpyg{sasmgn 9.998 19 9.998 19
Mnczps{} Y{g`jppjp9.991
9.4Egt 6 9.1
Y{mtasj 6 9.:
9.993 ;.0;
Ae{m`zbsz{j 9.998 0.4 9.990 3
Dg{jps{} 9.0=; 34.3
Egt 6 14Y{mtasj 6 09.3
9.019 04"=0
Uapsj 9.938 4.1 9.909 :
Yjas Jomppmgn 9.;89 14.: 9.9:5 0:
Sgsab 9.545 80.0 9.3;; 148.;:Pgz{`j6 Chjuansm ;919
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
17/20
@habbjnejp Ahjac
Acfzpsmne shj jxmpsmne ygbm`mjp ancy{ge{aop6 d{aoj shj pg`mab appmpsan`jy{ge{aop pqza{jb} mn pzpsamnakbj
cjtjbgyojns ya{acmeo (hjn`j6 bmnl gdygtj{s} anc jntm{gnojnsab mppzjp-
Sa`lbmne shj ygbmsm`p njjc bjacj{phmy
Psa{s poabb" eg e{aczabb}
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
18/20
Shj Ygbmsm`p
Meng{an`j gd anc {jpmpsan`j sg E{jjn ECY6 njjcoamnps{jaomne anc ygbmsm`ab umbb
Ap dg{ E{jjn Kzcejsmne6 pzkpmc} {jdg{o mp jppjnsmab.Shmp mn`bzcjp6 pzkpmc} `zs (anc basj{6 sax gn jnj{e}zpj-. [jabbg`asj shj {jpgz{`jp sg ygtj{s} j{acm`asmgn
y{ge{aop @aoyamen d{gns6 jntm{gnojnsab fzpsm`j (`apj6
Baymncg ozcdbgu" hmeh/tgbsaej jbj`s{m` um{jp-
@g{{j`s shj mn`jnsmtjp6 j.e. pbzo ygtj{s} y{gkbjo (sgcmp`gz{aej ome{asmgn" ogtj shj mn`jnsmtjp ngs shj
yjgybj-
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
19/20
@ASJEG[] S]YJ GD MNPS[ZOJNS
Ybannmne / Nasz{ab [jpgz{`jp anc Jntm{gnojnsabn A``gznsmne P}psjo
/ E{jjn ECY'E[CY
/ Mnsj{/{jemgnab Ya}ojns dg{ J`gp}psjo Pj{tm`jp
/ Mnsj{nabmvasmgn gd Jntm{gnojnsab @gps
Jntm{gnojnsab Dznc / Jntm{gnojnsab Yj{dg{oan`j Kgnc
(a{sm`bj 3; $ 30- / Joj{ejn`} [jpygnpj Dznc
/ Jntm{gnojnsab @gnpj{tasmgn S{zps Dznc
Mn`jnsmtj'cmpmn`jnsmtj
/ E{jjn Y{g`z{jojns
/ Jntm{gnojnsab Saxjp" [js{mkzsmgn anc Pzkpmc}
/ Pgznc/jntm{gnojnsabb} dmnan`mab mnpsmszsmgnp anc psg`l/jx`hanej p}psjo
/ S{acjkabj yj{oms
/ Ya}ojns dg{ J`gp}psjo Pj{tm`jp
/ Jntm{gnojnsab Mnpz{an`j P}psjo
/ Jntm{gnojnsab Bakjbmne P`hjoj
/ Jntm{gnojnsab Yj{dg{oan`j Aua{c P}psjo
Pgznc/jntm{gnojnsabb}kzcejs
/ [jpygnpmkmbs} gd Egtj{nojns'[jemgnab Egtj{nojns sgejhsj{ umsh Ya{bmaojns sgabbg`asj pzddm`mjns kzcejs dg{ pzpsamnakbj cjtjbgyojns {jyasjc y{ge{aop/Y{gtmcj Pyj`mab Abbg`asjc Kzcejs dg{ eggc jntm{gnojnsab yj{dg{oan`j bg`abegtj{nojnsp
Bau 0;';99= (eggc abkjms ba`l gd jxybm`ms bmnl sg ygtj{s}{jcz`smgn-
Pgz{`j6 Chjuansm ;919
-
8/8/2019 The Political Economy of Environmental Policy in Indonesia - presentation
20/20
Shanl }gz