Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
csThe Nature of Classical PhysicsA Rehash Followed by Some New Stuff
1
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Determinism and Reversibility
We may regard the present state of the universe as the effect of its past and the cause of its future. —Pierre-Simon Laplace, A Philosophical Essay on Probabilities
Given the present there can be only one future and there can have been only one past.
2
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
State Machines
We used the notion of state machines to provide a simple analogy to examine the structure of physical laws.
The analogy is imperfect and we should be careful not to push it too far.
3
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Now suppose we have a law that, given the current state of the system, predicts the next state.Preliminaries:
Evolutionary Law:
State Machines (cont)
4
a function
n an integer
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
State Law of Motion
The law of motion:(something) is a function, a mathematical machine. It has• a domain – all of the things we can
legally feed into its parentheses, and• a range – all of the things it can
possibly return to us. 6
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
A Function Is A Rule
We stuff an object from the function’s domain, such as a number, into its parentheses,
and it returns an object from its range, such as a different number.
7
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
State Functions
In our case, the input to () is one of the system’s states, so
()’s domain is the set of system states.
When we give () a state as input, it gives us back a state as output so
()’s range is (also) the set of system states. 8
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Back to Physics and States
Consider once again
Note that only knows about Then can only depend upon .
That is, if we know the current state of the system, we know everything there is to know about its future. That’s determinism.
9
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Determinism and Reversibility Say
There is exactly one arrow entering each state box and exactly one arrow leaving.
the present state of the universe is the effect of its past and the cause of itsfuture
- Laplace10
214
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
A Short Digression on Infinities
• It’s good to be a tourist: we get to watch the slide shows and skip the final.
• Infinities make for fascinating pillow talk.
• I think it’s interesting.12
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Types of Infinity
Infinity comes in a variety of flavors:
• The set of natural numbers,, is countably infinite or denumerably infinite.
• Georg Cantor defined the cardinality (size) of the set of integers as , aleph-null, a transfinite number.
13
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Types of Infinity (cont.)
• Another type of infinity is that of the real numbers.
• Cantor called the cardinality of this set and found the remarkable result
A set like this is sometimes called a nondenumerable infinity. 14
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Nondenumerable Infinities
Rational numbers are numbers of the
form where both n and m are positive integers and Rational numbers include integers.• Decimal expansions of either
terminate or repeat.• Decimal expansions that terminate or
repeat represent rational numbers. 15
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Real Numbers
Real numbers are all the numbers on the real axis:
16
0 152 𝜋
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Nondenumerable Infinities (cont.)
• Between any two members of , i.e. any two rational numbers, there are an infinite number of real numbers.
• All non-rational real numbers are irrational numbers. Almost all reals are irrational.
17
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Hotel Tricks with
Suppose we own a hotel with the countably infinite rooms numbered 1, 2, …. Suppose our hotel is full.
1. How would you add one guest?
2. How would you add a countably infinite number of guests?
18
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Infinite Numbers of States
• Map states onto countably infinite () integers:
• Note that every state is an integer and every integer is a state.
20
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Rules for Infinite Numbers of States is a function encapsulating the history of a sequence of states. (Same as .)
For example:
leads to
22
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Λ (𝑘 )=𝑘+1• lead to
which satisfies determinism.
• We can trivially show
which satisfies reversibility.
23
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
𝑁 (𝑛+1 )=(−1 )𝑁 (𝑛 )𝑁 (𝑛)Easiest to work out specific cases. Then we find• 0 a static state• +1, -1 a cycle• 2 a static state• -2 a static state• +3, -3 a cycle• et cetera et cetera et cetera
25
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Here are Some Cycles of States
26
871
3
7We’ll see later that cyclesare associated with theconservation of something,usually energy.
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Reversibility and Precision
States of “real” systems will be associated with continuous, real values. Capturing the complete state of the system at some instant will require specifying a set of real numbers with unlimited precision.
The effects of finite precision will be to introduce error in the backward computation. 27
Natu
re o
f C
lass
ical Physi
cs
Reversibility and Precision (cont.)
The cumulative effect of error when we run a system backwards leads to chaotic behavior, in both the technical and practical senses.
We’re going to leave this topic for now.
28