THE MEDICAL AND DISABILITY COSTS OF THE IRAQ WAR
Professor Linda BilmesKennedy School of Government, Harvard University
Greater Boston Physicians for Social ResponsibilityMedical and Societal Consequences of the War
May 19, 2007
2
Dimensions of OIF/OEF Conflict*
Total deployed: 1.5 millionDischarged: 689,317 Deaths: 3748Wounded (combat only): 26,293Total “non-mortal casualties”: 60,433
Disability claimants: 180,000 Using VA medical care : 229,000
* Updated May 7, 2007
3
Costs of the Iraq War
Direct budgetary costs Economic and social costs
Veterans disability and health care
4
Before the Iraq War…. Costs of the War were estimated by
Mitch Daniels and Rumsfeld at $60bn Wolfowitz said it would pay for itself Lindsay predicted $100-$200 billion
CBO now projects past and future expenditures of $722 billion
Even this grossly underestimates full economic and budgetary costs
5
Objective of Paper was to Estimate Total cost of Iraq War
Budgetary costs: Money appropriated to
date Future running costs Veterans medical Veterans disability
benefits Military replenishment DOD structural
spending increases
Economic costs: Loss due to serious
injuries Loss of life Less veterans
disability pay Depreciation of
military hardware Macroeconomic
impacts Oil price increase
$2.3 bnThe Economic Costs of the Iraq War: An Appraisal Three Years After The Beginning of the Conflict” by Linda Bilmes and Joseph Stiglitz, January 2006 Updated 8/15/06
6
Costs to date
Congress has appropriated over $500Bn for Iraq and Afghanistan military operations, reconstruction, enhanced security at US bases and foreign aid programs $379bn for military operations in Iraq
Since FY 2003 the monthly average cost of operations has risen from $4.4bn to $9.8bn – largely due to Iraq.
7
Why is “burn rate” so high?
Combat pay High cost of reservists Contractors and security costs of
contracts Fuel, Maintenance and Repairs Re-enlistment bonuses, death
gratuities Medical care in field
8
Two Scenarios for Projecting LT costs
“Conservative” scenario: Assumes all US troops withdrawn by 2010
“Moderate” scenario Small but continuous US presence through 2015
Both scenarios Use 4% discount rate Use troop deployments based on projections by the
Congressional Budget Office, before surge Exclude Afghanistan Exclude costs by other countries Ignore important costs which are not easily quantifiable
9
Large Future Budgetary Expenses
Veterans Costs Disability pay +other benefits Medical costs Care of those with serious injuries
Increased defense spending/reset costs/replenishments
Continued military operations (Interest: large cumulative debt)
10
Other Costs
Social Costs:
1. Difference between military and civilian pay
2. Cost to families/societies of caring for wounded
3. Economic value of statistical life4. Economic value of serious wounds
11
Total Costs of the War in Iraq (excluding Afghanistan and debt)
Scenario Conservative Moderate
Direct costs 839 1104
Macroeconomic 178 750
1,017 1,854TOTAL COSTS
12
Soldiers Returning from Iraq and Afghanistan: The Long-term Costs of Providing Veterans Medical Care and Disability Benefits
1.Government overwhelmed by volume of disability claims
2. Insufficient funds and capacity, esp. in mental health
3. Long-term costs for returning OIF/OEF veterans from $300-$600bn
13
Veterans Medical Costs
“Non-mortal woundings” >62,000 which is 16:1 ratio to fatalities
229,000 veterans treated by VA: 37% mental health
43% musculoskeletal injuries34% symptoms without immediate cause
Many severe injuries; such as brain, head, spinal, amputations, severe burns, blindness
Estimated 10% of wounded have TBI
14
Veterans Medical Costs 48% of Gulf War I vets using VA health care
system
Assuming that OIF/OEF veterans build to same rate (from 38% now); cost of medical care for OIF/OEF veterans: $200-$538 bn
Depends on length of deployment, number of troops, wounded, medical inflation rate, claimant rate
15
Capacity Issues: Veterans Medical
Waiting lists esp. for psychiatric care “render care virtually inaccessible” – VA Under
Secretary for Health Frances MurphyVet Centers: 40% in inappropriate care, 17%
waiting listsVA Funding: Ran out of money in past 2 years
2006 ($2 bn)2005 ($1 bn)
16
Model: VA health usage
LOW MODERATE HIGH
Servicemen 1.5 million 1.7 million 2.0 million
Duration 2010 2016 2016
Usage rate 48% 48% 50%
Rate of growth 4% 4.5% 5.0%
Initial uptake 32.5% 32.5% 32.5%
Annual cost per patient
$3500 $4500 $5000
HC inflation 7.5% 8% 9.5%
# eventual users
700,000 790,000 930,000
Total cost ($bn)
190 285 536
17
Veterans Disability
Veterans eligible for disability for a wide number of conditions
44% of Gulf War I veterans claimed for disability benefits (87% granted)
Annual cost of disability pay for Gulf War I veterans is more than $4 billion
18
Veterans Disability (2) More than 25% of returning OIF/OEF vets
have already claimed disability
Assuming claims at same rate as Gulf War I veterans, the lifetime cost is $68 -$100bn
If 50% claim benefits and COLAs go up at higher rate, cost could reach $125bn
19
Capacity Issues: Veterans Disability
Backlog of pending claims2000: 69,0002006: 600,000
VA expects 1.6 million addl claims w/i 2 years
Average length of time = 6-24 monthsvs, industry average 90 days
900,000 GWOT troops deployed who have not returned yet
20
LOW MODERATE HIGH
Servicemen 1.4 million 1.7 million 2.0 million
Duration 2010 2016 2016
Claims rate 44% 44% 50%
Approval rate 87% 88% 88%
Initial uptake 25% 25% 25%
Avg. Benefit payment
$6506 $8890 $8890
Rate of increase
2.8% (COLA) 4.1% 6.1%
# eventual claimants
638,000 740,000 872,000
Total cost ($bn)
68 110 127
Disability benefits for OIF/OEF veterans
21
Recommendations
Disability Benefits:1. Change presumption so soldiers receive 2 years of
stipend (while claim is processed)2. Require all servicemen to have exit medical
medical examination; expand BDD program3. Streamline disability rating scale to 4 levels4. Fast track hiring of claims adjudicators5. Place claims specialists in VA centers and mobile
centers6. Extend free VA medical care to 3 years
22
Medical Recommendations1. Increase funding for VHA mental health care and
add hiring flexibilities
2. Expand “free” health care to 5 years
3. Change VHA funding to a Trust system (remove from discretionary)
4. Fund studies of long-term effects of TBI and PTSD
5. Fund National Vietnam Readjustment Study
23
OMITTED COSTS (1) Costs of risks borne by individuals
Health care costs not borne by the government All costs borne by other countries, including Iraq
Military costs Destruction of property Loss of life
All costs of increased insecurity Increased costs of cross border flows Reduced Private investment Value of reduced capability of responding to national
security threats elsewhere in the world Value of reduced capability of responding to domestic
situations in which the National Guard or the Reserves might have been called upon (as in New Orleans)
24
OMITTED COSTS (2) Indirect aggregate demand effects
Reduced incomes in trading partners Anti-American sentiment
Consequences of tighter monetary policy as a result of increased inflation
Costs of oil price volatility Investment, Bankruptcy
Losses in asset values (arising from increase in oil prices or otherwise Equity market Housing
Indirect consequences of worsening fiscal position Increased government expenditures on oil Increased expenditures on the war