Download - The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
1/32
The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity
and Collective Bargaining in Major
Professional Sports
______________________________
By: Alex Stolls
For: Labor and Employment Relations Independent Study Research
December 2012
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
2/32
2
Table of Contents:
Introduction 3
NFLPA and agent regulations 5
1987 lockout and decertification 7
Quarterback Club and licensing wars 10
2011 NBA lockout and the Super Seven 14
Alan Eagleson 20
Larry Fleisher 22
Baseball agents and the 1994-95 labor dispute 26
Conclusion 27
Bibliography 30
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
3/32
3
Over the past few decades, sports agents have begun to step into the limelight of
the professional sports industry becoming more important and in some cases, even
becoming household names. You wont find any major motion pictures that detail the
stimulating inner-workings of professional sports unions, yet Tom Cruise was nominated
for an Academy Award for portraying Jerry Maguire, a sports agent with an interesting
love interest and a moral epiphany.
Agents are one of the most popularized and essential pieces of the professional
sports pie, but when did this happen? When did agents become this important, even part
of the union family as labor lawyer and former Interim Executive Director of the
National Football League Players Association (NFLPA)Richard Berthelsen put it during
my discussions with him?1 What has been the general impact of agents on union
solidarity and collective bargaining throughout history? And perhaps even more
important, what is the current landscape of the agent business and where is it heading?
By examining a number of specific examples across the four major professional
sports, this paper will attempt to validate the claim that throughout history, agents have
done more to harm union solidarity than to help it. In 1983, Mr. Berthelsen and the rest of
the NFLPA drafted the first set of agent regulations to govern the business practices and
list of union-approved agents.2 These regulations have since been adopted (in some form)
by the National Hockey League Players Association (NHLPA), Major League Baseball
Players Association (MLBPA), and National Basketball Players Association (NBPA),
and have helped clean up the system and avoid a Wild, Wild, West landscape, as
former Assistant Executive Director of the NFLPA Doug Allen put it.3 However,
following the implementation of these regulations a number of examples have arose in
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
4/32
4
which agents priorities differ from the goals of the union, one example being the
Quarterback Club and licensing wars that plagued the NFL-NFLPA relationship in the
late 1980s-early 1990s. In some instances, most notably the 2011 NBA lockout, agents
have even had a direct impact on actual collective bargaining between the league and
union. I will assert that agent impact can also be affected by sport, circumstance, and the
individuals involved. To do this I will examine the similarities and differences between
the Alan Eagleson-run NHLPA and the NBPA under Larry Fleishers leadership,
exploring why one relationship was able to thrive while the other fell victim to the
conflict of interest that existed with an agent in charge of the union.
However, this research paper will ultimately claim that agents play an imperative
role in todays professional sports landscape as a sounding board and go-between for the
league, union, and players. Based on my research and interviews with experienced
leaders in the industry, I will provide my opinion on why plenty of historical examples
exist of agents opposing union goals and ideas. Yet I will explain why the subjects of my
interviews and I have a generally positive outlook on the future role and importance of
agents in professional sports.
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
5/32
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
6/32
6
and beginning to get a bigger chunk of the pie, it was imperative to make sure they
were doing things fair and moral.5
Around this time, former Assistant Executive Director Doug Allen explained to
me that the NFLPAs next move was to hire a collection of outside lawyers to gauge the
possibility of agent regulations, who began by examining the precedent set by the Screen
Actors Guild out in Hollywood. Though the SAG did things differently, the basic
leverage of both groups came from their right under labor law as the exclusive
representatives of each respective group. With their outside lawyers insisting that agent
regulations were perfectly legal, the NFLPA traveled across the country to meet with
agents and inform them that for the first time in professional sports, the union would be
implementing agent regulations. This announcement was met with a wide variety of
emotions and opinions from agents who were unsure of the fairness and legality of these
new regulations. Arguments took place and threats were made but eventually the
regulations were accepted with the NBPA, NHLPA, and MLBPA eventually following
suit. By the mid-90s, agent regulations drafted by the unions existed in all of the four
major professional sports, and agents had finally become a governed and legitimate piece
of the sports industry.6
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
7/32
7
Ironically, the first substantial example of agents having an adverse effect on
union solidarity came a few years later when these regulations could not legally be
enforced. As the NFL players prepared for the 1987 CBA negotiations their main goal
was free agency, a concept that had become incrementally closer in the past couple
decades without being truly obtained. When the owners made it clear that they had no
intentions to change the current system they had spent years working towards keeping,
players voted on and prepared for another strike. Similar to their previous strike in 1982,
this one began at the start of the regular season where it would hurt the owners the most
financially. However, this time owners were prepared with replacement players and TV
deals that stated that the only way for the owners to receive TV revenue was to make
sure games were played.7
So that is exactly what happened. 24 days and three regular season games later,
NFL veterans left the picket lines and returned to work. Some players such as Mark
Gastinueau of the New York Jets and Howie Long of the Los Angeles Raiders crossed
the picket line weeks before, claiming they didnt believe in free agency or couldnt
afford to sit out.8 When the NFLPA began to realize it was fighting a losing battle,
players were forced to admit defeat and crawl back to work without free agency or a
guaranteed percentage of the leagues revenue.9
But the NFLPA and its players were far from dead. Learning once again from the
previous 1982 labor struggle, the union took to the courts on October 15, 1987 (the same
time players were sent back to work) and filed an anti-trust lawsuit against the league in
the name of Powell v. NFL, arguing that the NFL was enjoying certain exemptions from
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
8/32
8
challenges by the players under anti-trust laws that were only applicable if a Collective
Bargaining Agreement was in place regulating their relationship.
Essentially, the players were looking to challenge negotiated issues such as the
draft, the salary cap, restrictions on free agency, standard NFL contract, etc. The union
and its players felt that these were all considered anti-competitive and therefore illegal
under anti-trust law during the time that an agreement is not in place with the union.
Since an agreement was yet to be negotiated, the union felt that the NFL and its owners
had no right to be exempt from the challenges that the players were trying to make.
Judge David Doty agreed and ruled in their favor, proclaiming that the current
bargaining impasse the two sides were caught in ended any exemption that the owners
were enjoying from anti-trust challenge. The owners immediately appealed this decision
feeling confident it would be overturned by the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals, which
indeed it was. As the NFLPAs website perfectly puts it The Eighth Circuit ruled that, so
long as a union represented players, they had no rights under antitrust laws to sue owners.
The court said that players had to choose between being a union and using their right to
strike under labor laws, or relinquishing their union rights and pursing their antitrust
rights as individuals in court.10
So in a move that completely shocked the NFL owners, NFLPA leadership chose
the latter, and two days after the Eighth Circuit reversed Judge Dotys pro-union
decision, the NFLPA Executive Committee voted to give up its status as the collective
bargaining agent of the players.
A common misconception here is that the NFLPA officially decertified and was
no longer a union representing the players. In order to this, the National Labor Relations
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
9/32
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
10/32
10
This is significant because while the free agency battle was taking place in the
courtrooms, the league was waging another threatening battle against the union in the
form of player licensing deals. Player licensing deals provided revenue to fund the
NFLPA from the sale of player names and image rights for everything from trading
cards, apparel and memorabilia to player appearances. Licensing money was essentially
a fight over a finite amount of resources and control, and during the CBA negotiations
and in between agreements this revenue was essential to the union. The NFL recognized
an opportunity of their own, and began persuading players to join the leagues own
licensing program known as NFL Properties. Mr. Berthelsen explains that it got to the
point where league management was offering individual players large sums of money to
abandon the NFLPA and make NFL Properties their official licensing agent. When
players decided to go this route they were essentially withdrawing their authorization
from the group-licensing program set up and run by the NFLPA. Naturally this harmed
the union and was counter-productive to what it was currently fighting for, but the NFL
and its new licensing program were not easy to turn down. 12 They promised extra
opportunities off the field and broadcasting opportunities after their playing career,
according to Mr. Allen.13 These false promises, as well as a minimum payment of
$10,000, were enough to sway over 700 players to sign up for NFL Properties, with the
initial group being a collection of high-profile quarterbacks that became known as the
Quarterback Club.14
Eventually the tide started to turn in favor of the union, as the NLRB ruled in
March of 1990 that owners committed an unfair labor practice at the end of the
replacement-player fiasco by punishing players who participated in the strike by waiting
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
11/32
11
an extra week before allowing them to return to work. This ruling awarded $19 million in
damages to the 1,400 players affected. A little over a year later Judge Doty of Minnesota
ruled in favor of the players in McNeil v. NFL, setting the stage for a full-blown trial to
challenge the leagues longstanding free agent restrictions which the players eventually
won, sending both sides back to the negotiating table to complete the 1993 CBA.15
So what role did agents play in the Quarterback Club and licensing wars that
plagued this relationship in the early 90s? Mr. Berthelsen put it quite simply Up until the
union renounced its right as bargaining representative of the players, agents had an
adverse effect on union solidarity.
16
But why?
As Mr. Allen put it, mainly because agents will always be more motivated by the
needs of their clients than anything else. He noted that plenty of agents recognized the
importance of the union and advised their clients to avoid joining NFL Properties and the
Quarterback Club. Plenty more like Leigh Steinberg tried to have it both ways and
appease both sides while ultimately looking out for their clients.17 However for the most
part, agents felt that with the potential of no season it was more financially beneficial to
side with the NFL and join NFL Properties, taking the quick payday rather then duking
it out alongside the NFLPA.
While the union fought tirelessly to avoid situations like this and keep players and
agents committed to the NFLPAs group licensing system, I feel this time period best
represents the impact agents have had on this relationship throughout the course of
history. In the early 1980s before agent regulations were put in place, it was fair to say
that there was no shortage of agents taking advantage of players. It was not unheard of
for an agent to be taking bribes from management or leveraging players if they
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
12/32
12
represented multiple players from the same team or same position. A few agents were
even requiring exorbitant percentages as commission, then taking this commission out of
the signing-bonus or first-year of the players contract, even if that contract was not
guaranteed for injury or performance.18In addition, many agents during this time were
also responsible for providing financial advice, and some set clients up with raw deals or
bad investments that left young men recently out of college (or who never attended
college) scratching their heads.This naturally did not sit well with the union or its
members, which finally instituted the regulations governing the business practices of
individual agents and only allowing franchises to negotiate with union-approved agents.
Things were much different by the time the 1987 CBA negotiations rolled around.
Agents were still very much involved, even more so as they advised or advised against
their clients essentially ditching the NFLPA and jumping to NFL Properties and the
short-term payday it provided. For some particular players, this appeared to make sense
financially while for others, sticking it out with the union was the only option. Therefore
during this situation, there were a number of agents who had advised certain clients to
join NFL Properties and the Quarterback Club, and certain clients to remain loyal to the
unions group licensing system.
I feel that this variety of advice and opinions proves the true ultimate goal of
agents that has remained steadfast during a number of labor disputes, and that is to do
whatever is necessary to represent his/her client. Sometimes that is calling General
Managers urging them to take a look at a free agent, other times its answering phone calls
from clients and family members at 3am, and most times it means siding with whichever
side offers the most substantial and immediate financial support to their client.
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
13/32
13
Throughout the long and winding history of the NFL and NFLPAs relationship, agents
have always played an important role in collective bargaining and done plenty to frustrate
both the NFL and the NFLPA. With this responsibility certainly comes a great deal of
power that agents have been known to flaunt, yet I feel agents are only becoming more
important in the professional football landscape, so both the NFL and NFLPA will need
to continue to work on working with agents rather than around or against them.
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
14/32
14
However professional football is certainly not the only sport with a history of
agents being extremely involved in the labor struggle between league and union. The
National Basketball Association and its player union, the NBPA, have had somewhat of a
strained and tense relationship recently, which we saw play out right before our eyes in
the 2011 lockout.
After failing to come to an agreement with the existing CBA set to expire, the
NBA officially locked out its players on July 1, 2011. With the main issues of this dispute
being money-related in terms of the revenue split between the owners and the players, as
well as the exponential growth of salaries and lack of a hard salary cap, NBA deputy
Commissioner Adam Silver explained that the recently-expired 2005 CBA created a
broken system that produced huge financial losses for our teams.19 Simply put, a
younger, more corporate group of owners coupled with an economic recession had too
many owners looking at red on their balance sheets. The players were receiving 57% of
Basketball Related Income, a number that owners felt was incredibly high. With both
sides dangerously far apart on key issues, the summer of 2011 came and went without
virtually any hope or progress that a deal was on the horizon. 20
Enter the agents.
After a less than productive summer, the NBA and NBPA prepared for a huge
face-to-face meeting on October 4 that would effectively determine if the season was
going to start on time. The owners felt that the players resolve and commitment to the
union was wavering and would continue to, especially in the near future when they began
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
15/32
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
16/32
16
extreme alternative of renunciation of bargaining rights in order to file anti-trust litigation
(more similar to the NFLPAs 1987 strategy). It was mostly a belief and a mindset that
something substantial needed to be done, and that union management may not have what
it takes to do that without a little kick-in-the-butt.
However, this proposed (or strongly advised) strategy from the agents was met
with far greater scrutiny and debate in the circumstances of this particular labor struggle.
Unlike the NFL-NFLPA negotiation in 1987, the union was not suggesting this
decertification strategy nor were they on board with it, with NBPA Executive Director
Billy Hunter continuously insisting that the union would instead stay the course and
pursue the Unfair Labor Practice charge it filed with the National Labor Relations Board
(NLRB) against the league months earlier.24 Choosing to break apart the union and
pursue anti-trust litigation brought the battle to the courts and their time-frame and
schedule, effectively ensuring the entire NBA season would be lost. Some NBA players,
including superstars such as Kobe Bryant, felt short-term losses should be strongly
considered if they would eventually lead to long-term gains and victories for the players
and the union. However there were also plenty of others who had a fair point of their
own, explaining that Kobe certainly has the right idea, but also has less at stake regarding
these short term losses since hes got a little more in the bank than I do.25
When the NBA players and their union met with league officials on October 4 and
followed the advice of their agents by staying strong and refusing to accept a lower
percentage of Basketball Related Income, talks broke down once again. Next thing you
know, reports were surfacing that the relationship of Billy Hunter and Union President
Derek Fisher was crumbling and that Fisher was meeting secretly with Commissioner
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
17/32
17
David Stern and attempting to broker a deal on the side. Though Fisher immediately
denied these accusations, soon internal strife was threatening to sink the NBPA as players
began choosing sides in Derek Fisher and Billy Hunter spat and also in the decertification
or not debate.26
It is impossible to argue the impact and involvement that agents had on this
drawn-out, murky labor dispute. A better discussion might be whether this impact was
positive or negative. On one hand, this powerful group of agents clearly played a part in
creating the internal chaos and difference of opinion among players and union leadership.
In an article for CBSSports.com back in November 2011, Ken Berger argued Agents'
attempts to influence the negotiations can be harmful even if their overriding point that
the players have made too many concessions is accurate.27
Clearly this group of agents had seen numerous CBA negotiations come and go
during their collective time representing NBA players. However voicing their opinion
and asserting themselves into these labor talks could be taken as a clear sign of distrust
and lack of connection with the union. Itput players in a difficult position and if were
getting extreme, pitted them against each other in a sense. With the Super Seven agents
(as they came to be known) representing a large percentage of superstars and NBA All-
Stars, the suggestion of sacrificing short-term losses for eventual long-term gains was a
relatively easy one to propose and back up.However referring back to the earlier quote
from an unnamed NBA player, the lesser-known role players who relied on the game
checks they were beginning to miss out on had a difficult time supporting a strategy that
would effectively ruin any chances of an NBA season. This created a divide between the
union and its players at one of the most critical times in the negotiating process. With all
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
18/32
18
that being said, it is tough to argue that agents were not at least partially responsible for
the struggles and lack of unity in the NBPA as the 2011 lockout wore on. This lack of
unity is ultimately what doomed the NBPA and its players, as they struggled to gain any
real leverage and ultimately agreed to a deal that included a 50/50 split of Basketball
Related Income (drastically different from the 2005 CBA in which the players received
57% of BRI) as well as a number of other concessions.
However was their impact strictly negative? Some would say the agents were
simply doing what was necessary given the circumstances. Some would argue the
relationship with Billy Hunter and Derek Fisher was doomed regardless of the opinions
and actions of the agents. Finally, some would say that without the threat of
decertification, the league would not have gotten the kick-in-the-butt it needed to get
back to the negotiating table and hash out a deal with its players.
According an article in the Sports Business Journal in late September 2011, a
lower level NBA player agent noted that the fact that agents are not on the same page as
the union could actually spur a deal. He went on the say that though the agents
suggestion of decertification would certainly create a chaotic and uncertain situation, and
perhaps the threat of this madness could bring both sides together in an effort to avoid
this last resort. Giving the NBA and the union a common enemy, that being the agents,
is not necessarily the worst thing for the negotiation.28
Perhaps the Super Seven really did know exactly what they were doing. Could the
2011 CBA have been a lot worse for the players had the agents not stepped in and flexed
their muscles? Would the league have been truly motivated to return to the negotiating
table in good faith if not for the threat of decertification, or would they have been content
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
19/32
19
to sit on TV revenues for a year or so to make a statement? Despite the debate
surrounding the true impact agents had, it is clear that the 2011 NBA-NBPA labor
dispute and CBA negotiation was one of the most agent-involved negotiations in any of
the four major sports, proving that agents are only becoming more and more important in
the landscape of professional sports.
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
20/32
20
With player agents recently becoming more important and visible than they have
ever been in the sports business, their power and influence will assuredly be something
worth noting and managing. For a speech originally planned for the Jefferson Day Dinner
in 1945 Franklin D. Roosevelt acknowledged simply Great power involves great
responsibility, and one way to further examine the issues of excess power and conflict-
of-interest in professional sports is to compare and contrast the circumstances
surrounding Larry Fleisher and his time at the NBPA with Alan Eagleson and his reign of
power at the NHLPA.29 Both were player agents who also ran their respective unions,
certainly a potential conflict-of-interest scenario on the surface. The difference between
the two is how and why one was able to become one of the most celebrated and important
figures in the history of players rights, while the other spent years ripping off both the
league AND its players before being sentenced to 18 months in prison.
Im referring of course to Alan Eagleson, hockeys first player agent who became
the most celebrated and powerful man in hockey before his fall from grace in the mid-
1990s. After helping form the NHLPA back in the 60s, he was appointed its first
Executive Director in 1967. For the next 25 years, he held this position while also being
one of the most powerful agents in the business. He was inducted into the Hockey Hall of
Fame in 1989 for his work building the NHLPA and advancing the sport of hockey, and
was named an Officer of the Order of Canada that same year for his work promoting the
sport.30
However, people around the sport eventually began voicing their concerns
regarding the scope of Eaglesons power as union chief, player agent, and hockey
promoter. In 1989, a movement was led to review the NHLPAs operations under
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
21/32
21
Eagleson.31 While he was initially able to weather the storm, Eagleson eventually stepped
down from his post as Executive Director in 1992, hopeful that stepping out of the
limelight would be sufficient in slowing down the storm of controversy forming around
him. This was not the case, and in September 1991 Russ Conway, sports editor ofThe
Eagle-Tribune, began publishing a series of installments that revealed evidence collected
from Conways investigation into Eagleson and his business practices. The series was
called Cracking the Ice: Intrigue and Conflict in the World of Big-Time Hockey, and it
proclaimed that Eagleson had engaged in an astonishing collection of unethical and
criminal conduct for decades.
32
Eagleson essentially had his hand in the pockets of both the players and the
owners, profiting richly from the international hockey tournaments he was able to
organize.33 He embezzled player pension funds, manipulated all parties in order to profit
off of players filing for permanent disability due to injury, and used union money for
questionable and unauthorized loans to friends.34Eaglesons story ends with him being
sentenced 18 months in prison, serving six, resigning from the Hockey Hall of Fame and
disappearing from the spotlight, leaving a shameful but important legacy behind.
So where did he go astray, and why was he able to get away with his crimes for as
long as he did? What can we learn about the amount of power granted to Eagleson, and
this conflict of interest scenario in general?
Eagleson was able to succeed largely due to the tremendous amount of trust
placed in him by the players. As an agent, Eagleson built a client list of more than 150
NHL players, he negotiated Bobby Orrs first contract with the Boston Bruins and made
him the highest-played player in professional history, and was essential in the formation
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
22/32
22
of the NHLPA. He made players realize they should be earning more money, and was
instrumental in increasing player rights during the early days of the NHLPA.
However as his power continued to grow, so did his shady, behind-the-scenes
business practices. Eagleson was essentially too smart for his own good, finding ways to
manipulate the groups that trusted him due to his sterling reputation of supporting the
players. Holding the positions of union head, player agent, and worldwide promoter all at
once is a tremendous amount of power for one individual, and Eagleson simply did not
have the morals or will to succeed and leave himself a proper legacy
So the lesson learned from the Alan Eagleson mess is simple: Allowing an
individual to be a player agent while also holding an important and commanding role
with the union gives he/she too much power, and is nothing more than a clear example of
a conflict-of-interest.
Well in my opinion, not exactly.
Perhaps the circumstances and individuals involved are just as important as the
potential conflict-of-interest scenario itself. To support this claim one must simply
examine the similar power yet vastly different legacy of Larry Fleisher and his role in
professional basketball.
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
23/32
23
In terms of power and influence, there is perhaps no one who had a greater impact
on their particular sport than Larry Fleisher. A Harvard Law graduate working as a
lawyer and tax accountant, Fleisher was summoned by the young NBPA in 1962 and
immediately began making his presence felt as a true advocate for the players. Working
as President of the union as well as General Counsel, Fleisher organized a strike of the
All-Star game in 1964 that forced owners to finally adopt a pension plan for players
whose careers spanned longer than four years.35
In 1970, he filed a class-action lawsuit seeking to eliminate the leagues reserve
clause, which bound a player to a particular team indefinitely unless the team chose to
trade him. A lengthy six years later, the Oscar Robertson Settlement finally established
free agency for players, and was the first successful challenge to a professional-sports
reserve clause.36
In 1983 with NBA owners preparing to implement new methods to cut costs,
Fleisher and the union threatened the league with a potentially-crippling mid-season
strike. Then miraculously days before the deadline, the two sides reached an agreement
that has been called statesmanlike...one of the most innovative in any area of labor-
management relations."37
However, the most remarkable part of Larry Fleishers resume is that he did all of
this while also working as one of the most accomplished player agents in the business.
His clients have included NBA stars such as Bill Bradley, John Havlicek, Willis Reed,
Bob Lanier, Paul Silas, David Thompson, and Jim Paxton. When he negotiated a four-
year, $750,000 contract for Rhodes Scholar Bill Bradley with the New York Knicks, it
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
24/32
24
was by far the largest NBA contract signed to that pointand started the trend toward
astronomical player salaries.38
Yet even Fleisher wasnt able to completely escape the whispers and criticisms of
having conflicting interests. The argument is simple: How can a lawyer represent the
superstars of the league while leading a union that is supposedly bargaining for the
interests in many less-talented players? Others are concerned that player appearances and
endorsement requests received by the union could easily be funneled towards Fleishers
clients. And in 1978, he negotiated a lucrative contract for client Marvin Webster with
the New York Knicks, and then proceeded to criticize the extremely generous
compensation rewarded to the Seattle SuperSonics in return because he feared its size
would discourage teams from bidding on free agents.
Clearly these concerns and sticky situations are legitimate and worth considering.
Giving one individual the power that both Larry Fleisher and Alan Eagleson had will
never be a clean, perfect situation. However, there is a reason that Bill Bradley, a former
U.S. Senator from the state of New Jersey, called Fleisher One of the most effective
labor leaders in the past three decades.39 Fleisher was able to manage his power and
wear a number of different hats mainly due to his ability to always keep players informed
and educated. Unlike Eagleson who normally worked behind the scenes while assuring
the players he had their best interests in mind, Fleisher kept the players involved while
ruthlessly battling management on behalf of them. He even stayed on, without salary, as
General Counsel to the NBPA for 19 years after he stepped down from his post as union
president.
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
25/32
25
There are few men who could have thrived in such a difficult and potentially
murky situation the way Larry Fleisher did. One of the strongest negotiators in the history
of professional sports, Fleisher was responsible for numerous monumental victories as
the head of the NBPA, while also moonlighting as one of the most successful and
respected agents in professional basketball. He maintains great relationships with many
of his clients and was proof that if done the right way, it is possible to wear multiple hats
and manage a potential conflict-of-interest scenario to ultimately leave a legacy as a true
advocate for the players. His true motives and practices were rarely (if ever) questioned,
and the legal work he did as head of the union laid the groundwork for the business and
overall landscape of professional basketball that we see today.
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
26/32
26
Though Fleisher is certainly a tremendous example of positive agent impact, if
there is any sport that could and should be used as a model for agent involvement in
collective bargaining, I feel it is professional baseball. Even with agent regulations in
place similar to other three major professional sports, baseball player agents have still
been able to have a direct positive impact on union solidarity and the MLB and
MLBPAs most recent laborstruggle. During my interview with basketball agent David
Mondress of BDA Sports, he stated simply Donald Fehr and the MLBPA have
embraced the agents and that sport has been the most successful with collective
bargainingthere is a direct correlation.
40
During the 1994-95 labor dispute, agents played a heroic role in expediting the
process and getting a deal done. They helped explain the circumstances and bargaining
situation to certain owners who were unaware and uninformed of what exactly was
happening. They made sure owners were aware that the union was committed to getting a
deal done, a terrific example of agents working with the union rather then against it.41
Other high-profile agents even advised union and management officials to change
or enhance their leadership style to become more effective negotiators. They encouraged
MLBPA officers to abandon their loud, brash negotiating style and try to brainstorm
alternative, mutually beneficial solutions. Mondresss statement supports all of this and
indicates that the MLBPA took this advice and constructive criticism in stride,
establishing a working relationship between agents and the union which cannot be found
in any other professional sport.42
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
27/32
27
So what has history taught us about the impact of agents on collective bargaining
and union solidarity? On one hand, examples such as the Quarterback Club and the 2011
NBA lockout make it difficult to believe that agents can ever fully support union ideals
while ultimately looking out for the well-being of their individual clients. Alan Eagleson
seemed to be proof that giving one individual the power of being an agent and a high-
level union executive is a recipe for disaster.
However, my research has led me to conclude that this is simply a small part of
the story. Examples such as Larry Fleisher and the baseball agents in the mid-1990s are
encouraging examples of agents being able to represent and remain loyal to their clients
while also supporting the union. With plenty of evidence also suggesting that the NBA
agents may have ultimately expedited a deal in 2011 with their pressure, it is difficult to
argue the certain and positive impact that agents have had on the professional sports
landscape throughout history. With obvious conflict-of-interest pitfalls and numerous
delicate situations there are bound to be scattered examples of agents engaging in
immoral practices or standing in the way of the union. However, I feel agents in the past
have for the most part done an admirable job of representing and looking out for clients
while adhering to the union-governed agent regulations, creating a mutually beneficial
business relationship.
Also worth noting is that as player salaries in all sports continue to increase, I feel
agents will continue to become even more important and this delicate relationship will
occupy an even greater role in the landscape of professional sports. Agent regulations
have been effective in cleaning up thebusiness and allowing agents to be an information
source, as well as a communication source, as Mr. Berthelsen put it.43 Howeer these
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
28/32
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
29/32
29
said I am confident that as agents continue to become more important they will continue
the trend of being a constructive go-between and sounding board for players,
management, and the union.
After all, I hope to enter this business one day, and with inspiring examples to
look up to as well as a few less-than-stellar examples to learn from, it is easy to be
optimistic about the future of sports agents. The business does not need a mission
statement like Jerry Maguires The Things We Think and Do Not Say, it simply needs
agents to continue to be an ethical, honest piece of the professional sports pie by learning
from history. Whether it is older, established agentsyoung, up-and-coming agentsor
students like myself hoping to break into the business, it is up to everyone to ensure that
the business of sports agents continues on the successful, virtuous path that it should.
-
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
30/32
30
Bibliography:
1 Telephone Interview with Richard Berthelsen, November 6, 2012.
2
Telephone Interview with Richard Berthelsen, November 6, 2012.
3 Face-to-face Interview with Doug Allen, November 27, 2012.
4 Shropshire, Kenneth L. The Business of Sports Agents, 2nd Edition. University of Pennsylvania Press; 2ndedition (May 28, 2008)
5 Telephone Interview with Richard Berthelsen, November 6, 2012.
6 Face-to-face Interview with Doug Allen, November 27, 2012.
7National Football League Players Association,History.https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/
8Ethan Trex, Scab Story: The 1987 NFL Strike,Mental Floss, March 12, 2011.http://www.mentalfloss.com/blogs/archives/82262
9Mark Craig, The 1987 NFL Strike: Picking at an old Scab, Star Tribune, June 28, 2011.http://www.startribune.com/sports/vikings/124627618.html?refer=y
10National Football League Players Association,History.https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/
11National Football League Players Association,History.https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/
12 Telephone Interview with Richard Berthelsen, November 6, 2012.
13 Face-to-face Interview with Doug Allen, November 27, 2012.
14National Football League Players Association,History.https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/
15National Football League Players Association,History.https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/
16 Telephone Interview with Richard Berthelsen, November 6, 2012.
17 Face-to-face Interview with Doug Allen, November 27, 2012.
18 Face-to-face Interview with Doug Allen, November 27, 2012.
19Associated Press, NBA Owners Lockout Players After Sides Fail to Reach New Agreement,Fox News,June 30, 2011.http://www.foxnews.com/sports/2011/06/30/nba-lockout-looms-with-collective-bargaining-agreement-set-to-expire/
https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/http://www.mentalfloss.com/blogs/archives/82262http://www.mentalfloss.com/blogs/archives/82262http://www.startribune.com/sports/vikings/124627618.html?refer=yhttp://www.startribune.com/sports/vikings/124627618.html?refer=yhttps://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/http://www.foxnews.com/sports/2011/06/30/nba-lockout-looms-with-collective-bargaining-agreement-set-to-expire/http://www.foxnews.com/sports/2011/06/30/nba-lockout-looms-with-collective-bargaining-agreement-set-to-expire/http://www.foxnews.com/sports/2011/06/30/nba-lockout-looms-with-collective-bargaining-agreement-set-to-expire/http://www.foxnews.com/sports/2011/06/30/nba-lockout-looms-with-collective-bargaining-agreement-set-to-expire/http://www.foxnews.com/sports/2011/06/30/nba-lockout-looms-with-collective-bargaining-agreement-set-to-expire/https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/http://www.startribune.com/sports/vikings/124627618.html?refer=yhttp://www.mentalfloss.com/blogs/archives/82262https://www.nflplayers.com/About-us/History/ -
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
31/32
31
20Tyler Cowen and Kevin Grier, Two Economists Explain the NBA Lockout, Grantland, October 31,2011.http://www.grantland.com/blog/the-triangle/post/_/id/8300/two-economists-explain-the-nba-lockout
21Ken Berger, On NBA opening night, labor fight continues because of agents, CBSSports.com,
November 1, 2011.http://www.cbssports.com/nba/story/15945298/on-nba-opening-night-labor-fight-continues-because-of-agents
22Sam Amick, In joint letter, top NBA agents urge players to not back down in talks, Sports Illustrated,October 3, 2011.http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/writers/sam_amick/10/03/agents.letter/index.html
23 Official agents letter accessed via previous Sports Illustratedarticlehttp://ht.cdn.turner.com/si/nba/AgentsLetter100311.pdf
24Liz Mullen, Could fear of decertification drive NBA labor deal?, Sports Business Journal, September27, 2011.http://aol.sportingnews.com/nba/feed/2010-10/nba-labor/story/sbj-could-fear-of-decertification-drive-nba-labor-deal
25Sam Amick, In joint letter, top NBA agents urge players to not back down in talks, Sports Illustrated,October 3, 2011.http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/writers/sam_amick/10/03/agents.letter/index.html
26Kurt Helin, Players union executive board to meet, try to get on same page, ProBasketballTalk,November 3, 2011.http://probasketballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/11/03/players-union-executive-board-to-meet-try-to-get-on-same-page/
27Ken Berger, On NBA opening night, labor fight continues because of agents, CBSSports.com,November 1, 2011.
http://www.cbssports.com/nba/story/15945298/on-nba-opening-night-labor-fight-continues-because-of-agents
28Liz Mullen, Could fear of decertification drive NBA labor deal?, Sports Business Journal, September27, 2011.http://aol.sportingnews.com/nba/feed/2010-10/nba-labor/story/sbj-could-fear-of-decertification-drive-nba-labor-deal
29Franklin D. Roosevelt: "Undelivered Address Prepared for Jefferson Day.," April 13, 1945. Online byGerhard Peters and John T. Woolley, The American Presidency Project.http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=16602.
30The Canadian Encyclopedia, Alan Eagleson,
http://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.com/articles/alan-eagleson
31 Edge, Marc. Red Line, Blue Line, Bottom Line: How Push Came to Shove Between the National HockeyLeague and Its Players.New Star Books; First Edition edition (September 2004)
32Russ Conway, Cracking the Ice: Intrigue and Conflict in the World of Big -Time Hockey, The Eagle-Tribune, September, 1991.
33 Edge, Marc. Red Line, Blue Line, Bottom Line: How Push Came to Shove Between the National HockeyLeague and Its Players.New Star Books; First Edition edition (September 2004)
http://www.grantland.com/blog/the-triangle/post/_/id/8300/two-economists-explain-the-nba-lockouthttp://www.grantland.com/blog/the-triangle/post/_/id/8300/two-economists-explain-the-nba-lockouthttp://www.cbssports.com/nba/story/15945298/on-nba-opening-night-labor-fight-continues-because-of-agentshttp://www.cbssports.com/nba/story/15945298/on-nba-opening-night-labor-fight-continues-because-of-agentshttp://www.cbssports.com/nba/story/15945298/on-nba-opening-night-labor-fight-continues-because-of-agentshttp://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/writers/sam_amick/10/03/agents.letter/index.htmlhttp://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/writers/sam_amick/10/03/agents.letter/index.htmlhttp://ht.cdn.turner.com/si/nba/AgentsLetter100311.pdfhttp://ht.cdn.turner.com/si/nba/AgentsLetter100311.pdfhttp://aol.sportingnews.com/nba/feed/2010-10/nba-labor/story/sbj-could-fear-of-decertification-drive-nba-labor-dealhttp://aol.sportingnews.com/nba/feed/2010-10/nba-labor/story/sbj-could-fear-of-decertification-drive-nba-labor-dealhttp://aol.sportingnews.com/nba/feed/2010-10/nba-labor/story/sbj-could-fear-of-decertification-drive-nba-labor-dealhttp://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/writers/sam_amick/10/03/agents.letter/index.htmlhttp://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/writers/sam_amick/10/03/agents.letter/index.htmlhttp://probasketballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/11/03/players-union-executive-board-to-meet-try-to-get-on-same-page/http://probasketballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/11/03/players-union-executive-board-to-meet-try-to-get-on-same-page/http://probasketballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/11/03/players-union-executive-board-to-meet-try-to-get-on-same-page/http://www.cbssports.com/nba/story/15945298/on-nba-opening-night-labor-fight-continues-because-of-agentshttp://www.cbssports.com/nba/story/15945298/on-nba-opening-night-labor-fight-continues-because-of-agentshttp://www.cbssports.com/nba/story/15945298/on-nba-opening-night-labor-fight-continues-because-of-agentshttp://aol.sportingnews.com/nba/feed/2010-10/nba-labor/story/sbj-could-fear-of-decertification-drive-nba-labor-dealhttp://aol.sportingnews.com/nba/feed/2010-10/nba-labor/story/sbj-could-fear-of-decertification-drive-nba-labor-dealhttp://aol.sportingnews.com/nba/feed/2010-10/nba-labor/story/sbj-could-fear-of-decertification-drive-nba-labor-dealhttp://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=16602http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=16602http://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.com/articles/alan-eaglesonhttp://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.com/articles/alan-eaglesonhttp://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.com/articles/alan-eaglesonhttp://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=16602http://aol.sportingnews.com/nba/feed/2010-10/nba-labor/story/sbj-could-fear-of-decertification-drive-nba-labor-dealhttp://aol.sportingnews.com/nba/feed/2010-10/nba-labor/story/sbj-could-fear-of-decertification-drive-nba-labor-dealhttp://www.cbssports.com/nba/story/15945298/on-nba-opening-night-labor-fight-continues-because-of-agentshttp://www.cbssports.com/nba/story/15945298/on-nba-opening-night-labor-fight-continues-because-of-agentshttp://probasketballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/11/03/players-union-executive-board-to-meet-try-to-get-on-same-page/http://probasketballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/11/03/players-union-executive-board-to-meet-try-to-get-on-same-page/http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/writers/sam_amick/10/03/agents.letter/index.htmlhttp://aol.sportingnews.com/nba/feed/2010-10/nba-labor/story/sbj-could-fear-of-decertification-drive-nba-labor-dealhttp://aol.sportingnews.com/nba/feed/2010-10/nba-labor/story/sbj-could-fear-of-decertification-drive-nba-labor-dealhttp://ht.cdn.turner.com/si/nba/AgentsLetter100311.pdfhttp://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/writers/sam_amick/10/03/agents.letter/index.htmlhttp://www.cbssports.com/nba/story/15945298/on-nba-opening-night-labor-fight-continues-because-of-agentshttp://www.cbssports.com/nba/story/15945298/on-nba-opening-night-labor-fight-continues-because-of-agentshttp://www.grantland.com/blog/the-triangle/post/_/id/8300/two-economists-explain-the-nba-lockout -
7/30/2019 The Impact of Agents on Union Solidarity and Collective Bargaining in Major Professional Sports
32/32
32
34 Conway, Russ. Game Misconduct: Alan Eagleson And The Corruption of Hockey. Macfarlane Walter &Ross (January 1, 1997)
35 Basketball Hall-of-Fame Biographies, Lawrence Larry Fleisher.
http://www.hoophall.com/hall-of-famers/tag/lawrence-larry-fleisher36 Basketball Hall-of-Fame Biographies, Lawrence Larry Fleisher.http://www.hoophall.com/hall-of-famers/tag/lawrence-larry-fleisher
37Alexander Wolff, NBA Players Counsel Larry Fleisher Wears a Second Hat As An Agent, SportsIllustrated, February 11, 1985.http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1119142/index.htm
38Alexander Wolff, NBA Players Counsel Larry Fleisher Wears a Second Hat As An Agent, SportsIllustrated, February 11, 1985.http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1119142/index.htm
39Robert Thomas, Jr, Larry Fleisher, 58, Former Head of Pro Basketball Players Union, New York TimesObituaries, May 5, 1989.http://www.nytimes.com/1989/05/05/obituaries/larry-fleisher-58-former-head-of-pro-basketball-players-union.html
40 Telephone Interview with David Mondress, November 29, 2012.
41Jennings, Kenneth M. Swings and Misses: Moribund Labor Relations in Professional Baseball. Praeger(September 16, 1997)
42 Jennings, Kenneth M. Swings and Misses: Moribund Labor Relations in Professional Baseball. Praeger(September 16, 1997)
43 Telephone Interview with Richard Berthelsen, November 6, 2012.
44 Face-to-face Interview with Doug Allen, November 27, 2012.
http://www.hoophall.com/hall-of-famers/tag/lawrence-larry-fleisherhttp://www.hoophall.com/hall-of-famers/tag/lawrence-larry-fleisherhttp://www.hoophall.com/hall-of-famers/tag/lawrence-larry-fleisherhttp://www.hoophall.com/hall-of-famers/tag/lawrence-larry-fleisherhttp://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1119142/index.htmhttp://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1119142/index.htmhttp://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1119142/index.htmhttp://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1119142/index.htmhttp://www.nytimes.com/1989/05/05/obituaries/larry-fleisher-58-former-head-of-pro-basketball-players-union.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/1989/05/05/obituaries/larry-fleisher-58-former-head-of-pro-basketball-players-union.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/1989/05/05/obituaries/larry-fleisher-58-former-head-of-pro-basketball-players-union.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/1989/05/05/obituaries/larry-fleisher-58-former-head-of-pro-basketball-players-union.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/1989/05/05/obituaries/larry-fleisher-58-former-head-of-pro-basketball-players-union.htmlhttp://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1119142/index.htmhttp://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1119142/index.htmhttp://www.hoophall.com/hall-of-famers/tag/lawrence-larry-fleisherhttp://www.hoophall.com/hall-of-famers/tag/lawrence-larry-fleisher