Download - The Horizontal Learning Program BANGLADESH
The Horizontal Learning ProgramBANGLADESH
HLP - DefinedHorizontal Learning Program is a local government led peer-to-peer learning platform initiated by the
Government of Bangladesh and supported by development partners.
HLP - ProcessHorizontal Learning enables local governments to
connect with each other to identify, share and replicate the good practices of their peers.
HORIZONTAL
LEARNING
PROCESS
Replicate through holding
hands
Validate
good
practices
Identify good
practices
Learn viaAppreciativeinquiry
Discuss
with
citize
ns and
integrate into
the ADPPrioritize
practices to replicate
Appreciate: To realize our inherent value, strength and potential to overcome the limits that we often unconsciously impose on ourselves.
Connect: To break down the distinctions that separate us from the essence of our peers and detract from our collective well being.
Adapt/Replicate: To start with those things that are already working and enable learning through exposure to good practices within their local context.
HLP - Principles
HLP - Value Added
The bottom-up process complements top-down capacity building
Cascade Training
Starting Point? Deficiency
What? Should be …
Who teaches? Experts
Who decides? Program does
Why? To meet standards
Where? Classroom
What knowledge? Codified knowledge
Result? Increased Capacity
Horizontal Learning
Capacity
Is working …
Peers
Self selection
To address my needs
Field based
Tacit knowledge
Increased Confidence
What works?
What to teach?
Working Area FY13
The peer-to-peer learning process is led by 568 Union Parishad (Union Council, the smallest local government system in Bangladesh) in 48 upazilas and supported by 32 partners with presence in over 3000 UPs.
HLP - Results
Open Budget/Participatory Planning100% Sanitation
Raising Tax / Tax Book / Tax MelaSafe Water Supply
Mini Parliament / UDCCM/GO-NGO MeetingEradicate Early Marriage
Tree PlantationImprovement of Roads
Village CourtEnsure quality education
100% Tubewell ProtectionMenstrual /Adolescent Hygiene/Labonnya
Sanitation + Education ActivitiesUISC
Digital UP / Mobile Banking100% enrollment in school
Safe Motherhood CareCommunity Clinics
100% Birth & Death RegistrationIntegrated Village Cooperative
Biodervisity ProgramArsenecosis Patient Management
Arsenic Screening of TubewellsArsenic Safe Options
Play Pump UP tender tubewell Installation NGO Transfer of Funds to UPs
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8# Good Practices
111 Practices36 Fact Sheets
Community Clinics
Eradicate Early Marriage
Improvement of Roads
Safe Water Supply
UISC
Electic Lighting in Public Places
Income Generation for Poor
100% enrollment in school
Eliminate drug addiction
Services to Hard Core Poor
100% Birth & Death Registration
Eliniation of illiteracy
Arsenic Safe Options
Establish Village Sanitation Centre
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
# Good Practices
293 practices115 fact sheets
Community Clinics
Eradicate Early Marriage
UISC
100% enrollment in school
100% Birth & Death Registration
Village Court
Medical Service for Poor People
Improvement of Roads
Human Resources Development
Safe Motherhood Care
UP PPP with entrepreneurs
Eco - Friendly Model Village
Composting / Fertilizer
Ensure quality education
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40# Good Practices
466 practices113 fact sheets
UP Good Practices FY13+UP Good Practices FY11-12UP Good Practices FY08-10
100% Sanitation
Safe Water Supply
Mini Parliament / UDCCM/GO-NGO Meeting
Elimiation of illiteracy
Improvement of Roads
Disaster Relief Services
UISC
Books for Poor Students
Improve Sporting Event Quality
Ensure quality education
Arsenic Screening of Tubewells
0% 50% 100%
FY12, #UP Plans
100% Sanitation
Tree Plantation
Ensure quality education
UISC
100% enrollment in school
Disaster Relief Services
Raising Tax / Tax Book / Tax Mela
Extension of HLP at Ward Level
Village Court
Elimination of illiteracy
Ward Taskforce activation
Improvement of Roads
0% 50% 100%
100% SanitationSafe Water Supply
Tree PlantationMini Parliament / UDCCM/GO-NGO Meeting
Open Budget/Participatory Planning100% Birth & Death Registration
UISC Disaster Relief Services
100% Tubewell ProtectionHuman Resources DevelopmentExtension of HLP at Ward LevelArsenic Screening of Tubewells
Ensure quality educationEco - Friendly Model Village
Arsenecosis Patient ManagementVillage Court
Menstrual /Adolescent Hygiene/LabonnyaRaising Tax / Tax Book / Tax Mela
Upazila Womens ForumCommunity policing
Arsenic Safe OptionsWard Taskforce activation
Budget Review MeetingsSocial Safet Net
0% 50% 100%
100% FY12 = 303 UPs 100% FY13 = 357 UPs
FY13, #UP Plans
100% FY14 = 378 UPs
FY14, #UP Plans50%
Safe Water Supply
Improvement of Roads
Services to Hard Core Poor
Raising Tax / Tax Book / Tax Mela
Disaster Relief Services
UISC
Income Generation for Poor
One House One Farm
100% Tubewell Protection
Mini Parliament / UDCCM/GO-NGO Meeting
0 50000‘000 taka
100% Sanitation
Safe Water Supply
Tree Plantation
UISC
Disaster Relief Services
100% Tubewell Protection
100% Birth & Death Registration
Ensure quality education
Human Resources Development
Mini Parliament / UDCCM/GO-NGO Meeting
Open Budget/Participatory Planning
Arsenic Screening of Tubewells
Extension of HLP at Ward Level
Piped water supply
Arsenic Safe Options
Handpump registration & mechanic
Eco - Friendly Model Village
Menstrual /Adolescent Hygiene/Labonnya
Arsenecosis Patient Management
0 40000 80000
'000 taka
FY12, UP Budgets
Safe Water Supply
100% Sanitation
Ensure quality education
Tree Plantation
UISC
100% enrollment in school
100% Tubewell Protection
Disaster Relief Services
Piped water supply
100% Birth & Death Registration
Mini Parliament / UDCCM/GO-NGO Meeting
Open Budget /Participatory Planning
Human Resources Development
Arsenic Screening of Tubewells
Extension of HLP at Ward Level
Services to Hard Core Poor
Community Clinics
Improvement of Roads
Elimination of illiteracy
0 40000 80000
'000 taka
FY13, UP BudgetsFY14, UP Budgets50%
HLP - Limitations
Under HLP, external agents can not impose anything on UPs
SIPP
CB
Os
LGSP
NIL
G
Plan
CB
Os
WA
NG
O / C
BO
s
LIC
LGSP-LIC
HYSAWA
DANIDA
Sharique
SDC JICA
PR
DP
: Lin
k Mo
de
l
“What are the deficiencies in capacity?”
WB
E.g. Best practices are determined by UPs and policy reform is proposed by the peer-to-peer collectives of UPs (not by support partners).
“What has worked!”
“What capacities do we already have?”
6 upazilas 13 upazilas 24 upazilas
HORIZONTAL LEARNING PROCESS AppreciationInnovationPartnershipsConfidence
?? upazila
66 UP
232UP
128UP
??UP
Thank you