-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
1/16
70 History Today, No.15, 2014
Education is the basic element for development of anysociety. India has a long and prosperous tradition since the
Vedic age. During the Vedic and post-Vedic era, Indianeducation was based on Shrutitradition and continuedthrough the temples, mathas, viharas and other religious
and social institutions. Gradually, these religious centreswere converted into educational institutions such as
Takshashila, Nalanda and other universities, which werethe backbone of education in India. During the medieval
period, these educational patterns continued alongwith Islamic educational system. In the colonial period,tralatitious education system was drastically changed. In
this paper, author has tried to give an outline about thechanges in education system during the colonial period
and the factors responsible for these changes along withthe positive and negative impacts on contemporary
society as well as the present day educational system ofthe country.
First of all, we have to understand the objectives ofcolonial powers in their colonies. The main objectives
were to utilize the resources of colonies for promoting the
needs and interest of their own nation. Generally, thesepowers shaped and guided the educational policies andinstitutions of their colonies according to the needs of thecolonizer and ignored the aspiration of the colonized.
Therefore, the policies of different colonizers had certaincommon characteristics. Sometimes the same colonial
The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
Ankit Agarwal*
* Research Associate, Indian Archaeological Society, New Delhi. Email: [email protected]
power had differing policies in different countries andin the same country at different times. While there weresome similarities in the education policies of the African
colonies of two different colonizers British and French,some fundamental differences were also there.1Again,
the British policy in India in the eighteenth century wasdifferent from that in the nineteenth or twentieth century.
In Indonesia, the Dutch had followed two differenteducational policies in the first four hundred years andthereafter in twentieth century.2
In Indian context, British were the main colonizers,
who came as a trading company to India after receivinga Royal Charter from Queen Elizabeth in 1600. This
Company was known as English East India Company.Formally known as Governor and Company of Merchants
of London Trading into the East Indies (16001708),or United Company of Merchants of England Tradingto the East Indies (17081873), it was formed for the
exploitation of trade with East and Southeast Asia andIndia. Before the Battle of Plassey (1757), the primary
interest of Company was to trade and get economic
benefits from India such as exploiting their prosperousresources and exploring a market for her products. Forfulfilling these motives, Company did not feel any needfor promoting education and did not take any initiative to
promote the educational institutions during the first twohundred years in India.
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
2/16
71The Educational Policy in Colonial India: Causes and Effects
During this time, traditional education system
existed in India. The ancient Indian educational system,Gurukulacontinued in the colonial phase, which led to
the origin of Monitorial System. This system was very well
understood and appreciated by the officials of the EastIndia Company.3Some other educational institutions such
as maktabs(part-time schools that offered basic instructionin reading the Quran and basics of Islam)and madrasahs
(institute of comprehensive study of Islamic education),mosques, khanqahs (Sufi centers), and private houses
were also providing education. All kinds of institutionsexisted in harmony.4Local Nawabs, political entities andother well-to-do people considered it an act of virtue to
build educational institutions and to support teachersand students.
After the Battle of Plassey, East India Company
emerged as a supreme political power in north India.Gradually, British entities and English East India Companyrealized the need for educational expansion in India. The
author has divided the Indian colonial education system infive phases on the basis of the changes and effects of their
education policies to analyze the ideological conflicts,policy decisions, effects of the pressure from Indians and
changes during these different phases.
First Phase (1758-1812 CE)
One can ponder why British took interest in the Indian
education after the Battle of Plassey. Several changes came
into the position as per the needs of the British colonizersin the first phase. The Bengal province came under their
control with the defeat of the Nawab of Murshidabad atPlassey in but the British set their administration only in
1772-1773 CE, beginning with a judicial system.5
After1772-73 CE, the Company required more skilled andeducated indigenous people for lower administration and
for interpreting the religious laws.
During this phase, the English East India Company didnot show any interest directly into the promotion of theeducation in India but the senior officials of the Company
personally took interest and put efforts for establishingsome new educational setups for providing a regular
supply of qualified Indians to help in the administration oflaw in the courts.6Warren Hastings established Calcutta
Madrasah in October, 1780 for the study and teaching
of Muslim law and subjects, whereas Jonathan Duncanset up Sanskrit College at Varanasi in 1791 for the study
of Hindu Law and Philosophy.7During this period, TheMaulavieand Punditsit with the Judge on the Bench, and
give their opinion as to the Mahomdan or the Hindu lawin particular case.8
In the later half, several British scholars alsopressurized the Company and British entities for the
expansion of education in India. Gradually, Britishentities and Company realized the need for expansion
of education in India. Behind this approach, a broadereconomic, political, administrative and religious interest
Fig. 1: British interest in the expansion of education in India
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
3/16
72 History Today, No.15, 2014
of British entities and Company were hidden (Fig. 1).
During this time, the Company faced serious financialproblems due to the Bengal famine of 1770 and
commercial stagnation and trade depression throughout
Europe.9
Due to financial crisis, the Company was notable to afford the expenditure on the high salaries of
English officers. So the Company required local Indianemployees, who were able to read, write and speak
English. It was also hoped that education would providea positive bond between rulers and the ruled and lead to
the permanence and stability of the British Raj.
In the 18thcentury, Christian missionaries spread
religious education pertaining Christianity in India. Butthe East India Company felt that it would encourage
adversely religious sentiments among the Indian massesthat could affect the business policy and the diplomatic
role of the East India Company. Therefore, they didnot support the missionaries for the propagation of thereligious education to the common people in India during
the period from1793 to 1812.10Thus, missionaries andEvangelicals (evangelical Christian) created an agitation
and opposed the Company for disrupting the teachings ofChrist and reluctance to provide education for the Indians.
Interestingly, this agitation was supported by many inEngland and pressurized the Company for taking interest
in the Indian education sector.
Second Phase (1813-1853 CE)
In 1813, the Charter of the East India Company wasrenewed and from here, the second phase of colonialeducation started in india. Christian Religious institutions
pressurized the British Parliament so that the CompanyCharter contained a clause setting aside a lakh of rupeesfor education. The British Parliament insisted, in spite of
opposition from the Directors of the Company on insertinga clause in the Charter, giving missionaries full freedom
to settle and work in India. Soon afterwards, there was agreat influx of missionaries into India.11These missionaries
frequently opened schools, hospitals and orphanages.Behind their generosity, the hidden reason of missionaries
was not related to any humanitarian motive but theyused education as a vehicle to westernize the indigenouspeople in every aspect of human life.
During the first part (1813-1835) of this phase, two
controversies about the nature of education arose betweenthe British scholars and the administrators. These were:
Whether to lay emphasis on the promotion of modernwestern studies or on the expansion of traditional
Indian learning?
Whether to adopt Indian languages or use English
as the medium of instruction in modern schools andcolleges to spread western learning?
On these controversies, opinions of British scholarsand administrators were divided into three groups. First
group was headed by H.T. Princep (1792-1878) whosupported the traditional Indian learning system.12Second
group was headed by Thomas B. Macaulay (1800-1859),he supported the Modern Western Studies system. 13
The third group was headed by Sir Thomas Munroand Elphistonson, who supported the Modern WesternStudies in indigenous Language. These controversies got
settled in March 1835, when William Bentinck appliedModern Western Studies system in English language on
the suggestion of his legal advisor Thomas Macaulay.14Indicating the purpose of contemporary western education
system in India, Macaulay said that We must at presentdo our best to form a class who may be interpretersbetween us and the millions whom we govern, a class of
persons Indian in blood and colour, but English in tastes,in opinions, in morals and in intellect.15
Some scholars pushed Macaulays Minutes on Indian
Education into the background and argued instead,that Bentinck had already made his Anglicist decision
effectively before Macaulay even arrived. Suresh Ghoshargued that Bentinck had been steadily pursuing a policyof gradual introduction of English education in India since
1829.16Even before Macaulay, Bentinck had opened
subordinate positions in judicial and revenue sections ofthe government to natives who were able to understandEnglish. It is the wish and admitted policy of the British
Government to render its own language gradually andeventually the language of public business throughoutthe country, wrote Bentinck.17Overall, we cannot deny
or ignore the importance of Macaulay in introducing thewestern education system in India.
Secondly, the East India Company had to renew its
Charter after every twenty years. While renewing theCharter in 1833, the British Parliament increased the
sum of money from one lakh rupees in 1813 to onemillion yearly to be spent on education in India. In1844, Lord Hardinges administration announced that
all those educated in English would be preferred in officeappointments.18Given the new importance placed upon
English training, English education began to flourish inIndia through both government and private schools.19Itmade good progress in the three Presidencies of Bengal,
Bombay and Madras where the number of schools andcolleges increased. During this phase, education of girls
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
4/16
73The Educational Policy in Colonial India: Causes and Effects
was officially sanctioned. In fact, Lord Dalhousie offered
open support of government for educating girls.
Establishment of medical and engineering colleges
was the other notable event of this phase, which markeda beginning in professional education. Having given the
expense of training to European doctors and engineersfor service in India with their relatively high salaries, it
was imperative from the standpoint of the Company inthe respective fields that Indian subordinates perform
routine duties. To fulfil the growing need for healthprofessionals, Calcutta Medical College was establishedby an order in February 1835 during the regime of Lord
William Bentinck, which was the first institute of westernmedicine in Asia.20With the establishment of Thomason
Civil Engineering College by Colonel Cautley in 1847at Roorkee on the suggestion of James Thomason,
Lieutenant-Governor of the North-West Provinces,education in Engineering was introduced in India.21
During this Phase (1813-1853 CE), the colonial entityopened a few English schools and colleges instead of a
large number of elementary schools, this led to the neglectof the education of the masses. This policy of colonial
ruler was called Downwards Filtration Theory, whichmeant coming down of education or knowledge from
the top to the bottom, i.e., from the higher class peopleto the lower classes or the general people.22This policywas well supported by the contemporary higher officials
such as Lord Macualay. Behind this policy, Company
officials had several reasons. One of the main reasonsfor supporting this policy was the need of educatedindigenous lower staff and forming a loyal Indian class
for Company under the limited expense of their moneyresources. Filtration Theory fulfilled the aim of LordMacaulay and the directors of the Company.
Third Phase (1854 -1900 CE)
The British educational policy continued on the basis of
recommendations of Macaulay till changes were madeunder Dalhousie, although it was officially abandoned
in 1854 and hence began the next phase of Colonialeducation in India. The British Empire had grown to fullshape when Dalhousie came to India. Lord Dalhousie
realized the need of mass education and desired toestablish a complete class of vernacular schools to
expand throughout the whole of India, with a view toconvey instruction to the masses of the people.23Whenthe time of renewal of Charter came in 1853, the directors
of the Company decided to lay down a definite policyfor education in India and made a comprehensive survey
of the entire field of education. As such, a Selection
Committee of the British Parliament was set up in order toinstitute an inquiry into the measures for their reforms. The
Committee studied the issue thoroughly and reported that
the question of Indian education should not be ignoredand its development would not in any case be harmful to
the British Empire. The suggestions of the Committee werefavourably considered by the Board of Directors. As Sir
Charles Wood was the president of the Board of Control,so the declaration was christened as Woods Educational
Despatch though it was written by the famous thinkerJohn Stuart Mill.24
Educational despatch of 1854 (Woods Despatch) wasa long document of 100 paragraphs which deals with the
various aspects of educational importance and holds aunique place in the history of Indian education. Therefore,
it is often described as the Magna Carta of moderneducation in India and then the third phase of Colonialeducation (1854 -1900 CE) started in India. For the first
time, it clearly accepted the responsibility of the BritishGovernment for education in India.25It officially rejected
the filtration theory and laid stress on mass education,female education and improvement of vernaculars,
favoured secularism in education and teachers training.
As a result of the Despatchs recommendation, thefirst secondary training school for teachers in the countrywas established in March, 1856 in Madras.26 Woods
Despatch also paid attention to vocational education
and encouraged Muslim education27and presented acomprehensive scheme of education embracing primary,secondary and higher education. It recommended the
creation of a separate Department of Public Instruction infive provinces and scholarships for the poor and deservingstudents. Indian elite class people have shown great
urge for higher education and learning. To satisfy thisurge, three universities were set up in Calcutta (January
1857), Bombay (July 1857) and Madras (September 1857)on the model of the University of London as affiliating
university.28Thereafter, there was a continuous stream toset up universities one after the other. Thus India had 21
universities at the time of Independence (Appendix I).
In 1882, the Government of India constituted a
Commission with the objective to enquire into themanner in which effect had been given to the principles
of the Despatch of 1854 and to suggest such measuresas it may think desirable in order to the further carryingout of the policy therein laid down.29The Commission
was constituted by Lord Ripon under Sir W. W. Hunter,and therefore, it is also known as Hunter Commission.
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
5/16
74 History Today, No.15, 2014
The Commission adopted the Policy of Laissez faire and
advocated the gradual withdrawal of the state from thedirect support and management of institutions of higher
education.30
Hunter Commission suggested that local bodies
(district boards and municipalities) should be entrustedwith the management of primary schools. The Commission
advised for increasing the number of High Schools andcolleges31and emphasized that they should not only be
maintained by government but some of them should alsobe run by private bodies. After the recommendations ofHunter Commission, Punjab University was formally
constituted under the Act of 1882 and AllahabadUniversity under the Act of 1887.32 The number of
colleges was also increased. In 1882 the total numberof colleges were less than 75 (68 of them were regularly
affiliated) whereas during 1901-02 the number of collegesincreased to 126.33 When the recommendations ofthe Hunter Commission (1882) were implemented, a
phenomenal growth of secondary and higher educationtook place and both college and secondary education
expanded enormously.
During this phase, emphasis on western educationalso had some important effect on the mind-set of Indian
people. One of these effects was described by Anand K.Coomarswamy in 1908 by a graphic description of theIndians educated under Macaulays education system.
He said that Speak to the ordinary graduate of an Indian
University, of the ideals of the Mahabharata- he willhasten to display his knowledge of Shakespeare: talk tohim of religious philosophy- you find that he is an atheist
of the crude type common in Europe a generation ago:talk to him of Indian music he will produce a gramophoneor a harmonium, and inflict upon you one or both; talk to
him of Indian dress or jewellery - he will tell you that theyare uncivilized and barbaric He is indeed a stranger in
his own land.34These words of Coomarswamy clearlyshow that the colonial education policy of the third phase
was successful in forming a class of persons who wereIndian in blood and colour, but English in tastes, opinions,
morals and intellect.
Colonial education during this phase had also a
domino effect on the Indian Independence movementand the mind-set of indigenous people. Due to the
emphasis on western education during this phase, Indianscould understand Western thoughts such as nationalism,equality, independence, organization etc. and their
values. These thoughts encouraged the Independencemovement, nationalism and social political organizations
in India. During this phase, Arya Samaj was established
in 1875,35 whose founder Swami Dayanand made aforceful plea for Indias political independence and
said that self-government is by far the best. Arya Samaj
played a very important role in spreading awarenessand education among the Indians. The Indian National
Congress was founded in1885, which also played a keyrole in independence movement.36
From the closing years of the nineteenth century,
there was a growing awareness among British officialsof the political dangers of English education. Awarenesswas also growing among them about the impact of English
education on emerging social-political organizations andtheir growing influence among the indigenous people.
British thinkers and officials felt that most of the leadersof these social-political fronts were educated in western
system and well aware about the western thoughts. Theyalso felt that familiarity with western ideas, not enoughjobs for the educated and unemployment was breeding
political discontent and sedition among the Indians.37Sothey stressed on the review of educational system in India.
Fourth phase(1901 1920 CE)
This phase of colonial education started in 1902, when
Lord Curzon tried to introduce some administrativereforms of the university education by instituting aUniversity Education Commission in 1902, followed
by India University Act, 1904. Lord Curzon appointed
University Commission under Chairmanship of ThomasRaleigh (Law member of the Viceroys Executive Council)on 27th January, 1902. The purpose of the committee
was to enquire into the conditions and prospects ofthe universities. The committees main finding was:no change had been seen in university education
because they failed to follow the guidelines of LondonUniversity.38 In addition to this, some other findings
were with regard to defects noticed in the developmentof collegiate education in India. These were lopsided
development of liberal education and the neglect ofprofessional education in general and technical education
in particular, uneven spread of higher education amongdifferent communities and followers of different sections,neglect of women education and Indian languages. The
Commission submitted its report in June 1902 and itsmajor recommendations were39:
The existing universities should be reorganized asteaching bodies and enlarge their legal powers.
No new university should be set up.
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
6/16
75The Educational Policy in Colonial India: Causes and Effects
The undergraduate work should be left to affiliated
colleges and only advanced courses should beprovided in the university campus.
The number of Senators should also be reduced and
the period of their tenure should be 5 years at themost.
University and college teachers, renowned scholars
and Government officials should get adequaterepresentation in the senate.
The territorial jurisdiction of a university should bedefined.
The number of members on the Syndicate shouldbe reduced to 9 and to 15 in exceptional cases. All
members should be elected.
Rules of affiliation should be strict and affiliation
should not be granted to second grade colleges. Theaffiliation rules have to be framed in such a way as
to secure-
(a) That no institution shall be admitted to affiliation
unless on the fullest information;
(b) That no institution once admitted be allowed to
fall below the standards of efficiency required foraffiliation and the Syndicate should satisfy itself
from time to time on this point.
Every affiliated college should be under the control
of a Governing Body which should pay attention to
staff, library, hostel and buildings.
The recommendations invited severe criticism
both by press and public opinion in India. It wasconsidered as a step towards checking the spread andthe scope of education and virtually destroying the
limited independence of the Indian Universities. Therecommendations of the Indian Universities Commission
(1902) were incorporated in the Indian Universities Act,1904 which limited the size of the senate, authorised
teaching by the university (hitherto they were mainlyexamining bodies), periodic inspection of institutions,
speedier transaction of business, strict conditions foraffiliation and imposed more close supervision on itswork etc.40 Universities Act of 1904 was criticized by
nationalists for its tightening government control overuniversities.
The Act conferred on the Universities of India aworking constitution investing them with the authority to
control and supervise higher education in accordance withthe principles and policy approved by the Government
of India. But the unfortunate result of Curzons reforms
was the exorbitant officialisation of the Universityadministration. It did not encourage the policy of laissez
faire. No doubt, Curzon was trying to bring education
under the control of the Government to suppress thenationalist movement in India, but his educational policy
introduced efficiency and improvement in the quality ofeducation and was the basis of the educational system
for many years to come.
The educational progress received another impetuswith the initiation by G.K. Gokhale with the introduction ofa Bill to make elementary education free, compulsory for
children aged between 6 and 10 years. Gokhales effortshad far-reaching consequences in the subsequent period.
His efforts were responsible for the creation of a separateeducation department in 1910 and the strengthening of
the movement in favour of mass education.
The Calcutta University Commission was appointed
by Viceroy Lord Chelmsford, the Government of Indiain 1917, under the Chairmanship of M.E.S. Sadler, to
study its working. Two Indians Dr. Zia Uddin Ahmed andSir Asutosh Mukerji were appointed as members of this
Commission. Sir Asutosh Mukerji was the most influentialmember of the Commission. It is said that most of the
recommendations of the Commission were patternedon his views. The Commission submitted a voluminousreport in 1919, practically dealing with every problem of
Secondary and University Education, which was a great
turning point, since its recommendations were adoptedby several other universities. The Commission discussedthe main weaknesses of Higher Education in Bengal and
offered the following recommendations41:
The intermediate classes of the University were to be
transferred to Secondary Institutions and Secondaryand Intermediate Education was to be controlledby a Board of Secondary Education and not by the
University.
The government interference in the academic mattersshould stop.
University course divided into pass course andHonours and duration of the Degree Course shouldbe three years after the Intermediate stage.
The teaching resources of the city of Calcutta were to
be organised to create a real teaching university andthe project of a university at Dacca was to be carriedinto effect at the earliest possible moment.
Special attention was to be paid to womens
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
7/16
76 History Today, No.15, 2014
education and a Board constituted for the purpose.
The medium of instruction for most subjects up toHigh School stage was to be Vernacular but for
late stages it should be English (except in dealing
with Classical and Modern English Language).
7 new universities were opened (total 12 now) atBanaras, Mysore, Patna, Aligarh, Dhaka, Lucknow
and Osmania.
Kashi Vidyapeeth and Jamia Milia Islamia were
established.
During this phase, new universities, colleges and
schools were opened rapidly by the colonial entities.Here, some questions can be raised in ones mind. Firstquestion raised is why did Indians go to the new schools
and colleges? Primarily Indians were going to the new
educational institutions for economic self-betterment.During the colonial period, knowledge of Englishwas necessary for traders and businessmen. People in
the colonies joined the new educational institutionsbecause this was means for entering government service
and professions such as law, medicine, teaching orjournalism.42English education was also a means of socialmobility. Men from lower castes could raise their social
status by acquiring western education.
Second question raised in mind is who were theIndians who availed of the new schools and colleges?
While in theory, English education was available to all,but in reality, it was not equally diffused in all regions oramong all communities and castes. Everywhere it was
more widespread among men than women, in cities thanin villages and among the higher castes. The first impact
of English education was felt by the three Presidenciesbecause Britain was a sea empire and these were the first
areas to be captured. Literacy varied enormously betweenprovinces.43The residents of these three Presidencies werenot equally availing the benefits of the new educational
system and institutions. The first beneficiary group of itwas the traditionally literate castes, such as the Brahmins
in Madras and Maharshtra, the Kayasthas, Baidyas and
Brahmins in Bengal or the Kayasthas and Sayeeds inUnited province. Usually the higher castes stood at thetop of the education ladder and the scheduled castesand tribes at the bottom.44Caste was not the only scale
of education but the level of education depended onoccupation and dwelling place. In many cases, middle
class engaged in trade were more literate than otherswhich had a higher social ranking.45We can say that the
distribution of education during the colonial period wasnot equal.
Fifth phase(1921 1947 CE)
The Central Advisory Board of Education (CABE) wasestablished in 1921 to bring consensus on policy matters
among provincial governments, but it was not operationaltill 1935. During this phase, education system came underthe Indian control officially, as it became a provincial
subject administered by provincial legislature underthe provision of the Government of India Act of 1919.46
Thus, expansions started everywhere. Most of the Indianpeople and parties were dissatisfied with the act of 1919.Gradually, dissatisfaction of Indians was converted into
storm of protest and agitation against the rulers. Then,the Britishers felt necessary to give due importance to
education in India. By responding to the dissatisfactionof Indian people, Indias government appointed Indian
Statutory Commission on November 8, 1927, which
was commonly referred as Simon Commission.47 ThisCommission was made to enquire into the working of the
administration under the Government of India Act, 1919.
The government authorised Simon Commissionto appoint a committee to help in preparing a report
on education known as Hartog Committee, underthe leadership of Sir Phillip Hartog48 to enquire intothe conditions of education in India. In 1929, Hartog
Committee submitted its report and recommendedthe policy of consolidation, improvement of primary
education. In the opinion of this Committee, theMatriculation of the University still dominated the whole
of the secondary course. In order to obviate this defect, theCommittee recommended the diversified curriculum inthe schools. The Committee also recommended diversion
of more boys to industrial and commercial careers at theend of the middle stage, preparatory to special instruction
in technical and industrial schools and a selective systemof admission to universities (Fig. 2).
The work initiated by the Sadler Commissionwas further carried on by the Hartog Committee. The
Committee was primarily concerned with primaryeducation but it also reviewed the problems relating
to the teachers training and the service conditionsof the secondary teachers, and made far-reaching
recommendations for teacher training as well. It rightlyobserved that the success of education depended on thequality of the training, the status and the pay of teachers.
On the basis of the recommendations of the Committee,13 out of 18 universities setup faculties for education.
Andhra University started a new degree, the B.Ed. in1932. Bombay launched a post-graduate degree, the
M.Ed. in 1936.49
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
8/16
77The Educational Policy in Colonial India: Causes and Effects
Since 1931 there had been a slump in the economicfield in India resulting into much unemployment. Muchof the unrest was primarily due to mass unemployment.
Therefore, the U.P. (United Provinces) Government
appointed a Committee, known as Sapru Committeein 1934 to enquire about the causes of unemploymentin U.P. This committee came to the conclusion that
the system of education commonly prevalent preparedstudents only for examinations and degrees and not forany vocation in life and suggested that:50
Diversified courses at the secondary stage should
be introduced, one of these leading to the universitydegree;
The intermediate stage be abolished and thesecondary stage be extended by one year;
The vocational training and education should beginafter the lower secondary stage;
The degree course at the university should extendover a period of three years.
In 1935-36, the Central Advisory Board of Education
(CABE) was revived and it recommended the appointmentof a committee to advise the Government on certainproblems of educational reorganization and particularly
on problems of Vocational education. One of the basicreasons for instituting this enquiry was the fact that alarge number of University graduates were not securing
employment of a kind for which their education qualified
them. So the Government of India invited two Britishexperts, A. Abbott51and S. H. Wood52for preparing a planon vocational education in the country. The committee
strongly believed the problem of unemployment in Indiacould be solved only through industrial development ofthe country.
In June 1937, Abbott and Wood submitted their report
in two parts viz., Technical and General, which was basedon the experience of their visits to UP, Delhi and the
Punjab and known as the Abbot-Wood Report. On thetechnical parts, the report suggested a complete hierarchy
of vocational institutions parallel general education.53On
the general part, the report suggested about the mediumof education, which was similar to the earlier committee
reports. One important result of their recommendationshad been that a new type of technical institution called
the Polytechnic came into existence for training of middlelevel technical personnel. Delhi Polytechnic (1941) which
has now been converted into an Engineering College wasthe first in the chain of such polytechnics.54
Fig. 2:The main recommendations of Hartog committee
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
9/16
78 History Today, No.15, 2014
In 1937, the Congress Ministry assumed responsibility
of administration in seven major Provinces of India andconcentrated their attention on educational reforms.
In October 1937, an all-India National Educational
Conference was summoned at Wardha under thepresidentship of Mahatma Gandhi and the following
resolutions were adopted:
Free and compulsory education to be provided forseven years on a nation-wide scale.
Medium of instruction to be the mother- tongue.
Conference endorses the proposal made by MahatmaGandhi, in which Gandhiji proposed that the process
of education should centre around some form ofmanual and productive work, and all other abilities
to be developed or training to be given should be
integrally related to the central handicraft chosen withdue regard to the environment of the child.
The conference expected that this system of educationwill be gradually able to cover the remuneration ofteachers.
The conference then appointed a committee, with
Dr. Zakir Hussain, Principal of Jamia Millia Islamia,Delhi, as its chairman, to formulate a scheme of basic
education on the lines suggested by its resolutions. TheBritish Government had now commenced to understand
the seriousness of the situation of education in India.
On 28th
January, 1938, meeting of CABE was held andappointed a Committee under the chairmanship of the
Honble B. G. Kher, Premier and Education Minister,Government of Bombay, to examine the scheme of
educational reconstruction incorporated in the WardhaScheme in the light of the Wood-Abbott Report on general
and vocational education and other relevant documents,and to make recommendations. Dr. Zakir Hussain wasthe member of this committee. This Committee submitted
its report to the Board on 3rdDecember, 193855and thescheme of education suggested by it is popularly known
as the Wardha Scheme, the main features of which areas follows:-
A basic craft is to serve as the centre of instruction.The idea is not to teach some handicraft side by side
with liberal education, but the entire education is tobe imparted through some industry or vocation.
The scheme is to be self-supporting to the extent ofcovering teachers salaries and aims at making pupils
self-supporting after the completion of their course.
Manual labour is insisted on so that every individual
may learn to earn his living through it in later life. It
is also considered non-violent, since an individualdoes not snatch away the living of others with the
help of a machine.
Instruction is closely coordinated with the childs life,i.e., his home and village crafts and occupations.
In the middle forties, the Government of India realizedthat it could no longer be indifferent to the problem ofIndian education and there was the need of bringing
about radical reform in all aspects of Indian education.During 1937-1944, eight meetings of CABE (Appendix II)
were held in various important centers of India and theirvarious recommendations were published as proceedings.
In 1943-44, as the British became hopeful of its victoryin the Second World War, it directed its attention to dosomething for the Indian people in the field of education
and advised Sir John Sargent, the Educational Advisor tothe Government of India, to prepare a comprehensive
scheme for educational reform in India.
In 1944, CABE submitted a comprehensive reporton post-war educational development, popularly knownas the Sargent Report. It was a full fledged educational
plan for the future educational reconstruction in India.For the first time in India, official attention was given
towards the pre-primary stageof education. The report ofthe committee consisted of 12 different chapters covering
from pre-primary to university education. In the II nd
chapter of report, suggestions were given for this stage.56
Some of the major recommendations in this regard may
be summarised below:-
Provision should be made for free pre-primaryeducation in the form of nursery schools for thesuccess of National Scheme of Education.
Children from 3-6 years of age should be admittedin these schools.
The basic aim of these schools should be to impart
social experience and education of general behaviourrather than giving formal education.
The nursery schools may be attached to junior basicschools in the rural areas. But in the urban areaswhere there are sufficient numbers of children,
nursery schools should have separate existence.
Sargent Report also made suggestions and certainpolicy regarding primary education to university
education.57They may be outlined below:
Universal, compulsory and free primary or basic
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
10/16
79The Educational Policy in Colonial India: Causes and Effects
education for all children between the ages 6-11
(junior basic) and 11-14 (senior basic).
High school education for six years for selected
children between the years 11-17.
Degree course for three years beginning after the
higher secondary examination for selected students.
Technical, commercial, agricultural and art educationfor full time and part time students, girls schools areto teach domestic science.
The liquidation of adult illiteracy and the developmentof public library system in about 20 years.
Full provision for the proper training of teachers.
Educational provision made for the physically andmentally handicapped children.
Provision for social and recreational activities andcompulsory physical education.
The creation of employment bureaus.
The creation of Department of Education in the centreand in the states.
The use of mother tongue is to be used as the mediumof instruction in all high schools.
This report was criticized by many scholars anddid not satisfy ardent educationists on several issues.
It had suggested an educational development in India
which required 40 years to be implemented. Accordingto the need of contemporary India, an acceptable planof educational development had been spread over a
much shorter time. It recommended a national patternof education which was completely based on the patternpracticed in England. This pattern was not appropriate in
the social, political and economic conditions of India andwrongly called a national scheme of education. The report
was also criticised on the ground that it was only a patch-work of the recommendations of different committees.
Due to criticism the Government of India decided that
the scheme should be implemented within 16 years insteadof 40 years but in principle the Government accepted therecommendations of the report and tried to implement
some of them. According to the recommendationsof the committee, an education department and
University Grants Committee was established in 1945.The committee of polytechnic school and the All IndiaTechnical Education Committee were set up in Delhi.
In 1946, the Provincial Governments were advised tomake five year plans for education, which were made in
some provinces. The aim of providing compulsory and
free education to children between 6-11 years of age wasaccepted. Overall, it was the first comprehensive report
embracing all aspects of education. For the first time, this
report had drawn the attention of the Government towardsthe education of the handicapped and equal educational
opportunities to all students at various stages.
Discussion and Concluding Remarks
Colonizer prepared the policies of colony accordingto their needs, various conditions of the colony andthe pressure of the people of colony. We saw clearly
the impact of these factors in the different educationalpolicies, which were adopted by Britishers in India (Fig.
3) in different time period. For example, Britishers wantedto form a class of faithful Indian people of western mind-
set. For fulfilling this need, Macualay introduced Englishas a medium of instruction in India. Gradually, it wasfound that knowledge of English familiarized the local
population with ideas of liberty and western thoughtsor made them potential competitors for superior jobs
reserved for Europeans. So, Britishers made attempts tode-emphasize the use of English in India58and Woods
Educational Despatch (1854) gave emphasis on thedevelopment of vernacular languages.
Macualay introduced modern western studiessystem and adopted the Downwards filtration theory
in the second phase. During the third phase of Indian
colonial education system, Revolt of 1857 and originof Congress were the major events of the Indian history,which changed the approach of Britishers and left definite
impact on British policies. Due to these nationalist events,Britishers emphasized mass education and adopted thePolicy of Laissez faire. So, we say that Indian colonial
education system was not only based on Britishers, needsand approaches but also depended on their experiences
in India and the pressure from Indian agitation andNationalist feelings.
In India, British Colonial education policies
were criticized on several grounds such as literacyratio, quantitatively inadequate, qualitative defects,predominantly literary bias and employment opportunities
etc. During the colonial rule, the diffusion of educationwas very disparate in India. Literacy varied enormously
between provinces.59 The first impact of colonialeducation was felt by the three Presidencies becausethese were the first areas to be annexed by Britishers.
But this education was not equally diffused in all parts ofthese presidencies or among all communities and castes.
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
11/16
80 History Today, No.15, 2014
Fig.
3:Phase
sofColonialEducationSystemi
nIndia
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
12/16
81The Educational Policy in Colonial India: Causes and Effects
Everywhere it was more widespread among men than
women, in cities than in villages and among the highercastes. Usually the higher castes stood at the top of the
education ladder and the scheduled castes and tribes at
the bottom.60
However, much depended on occupationand in many cases, middle castes, engaged in trade, were
more literate than others who had a higher social ranking.
During the Colonial period, not only quantitativeinadequacy was shown but several qualitative defects
were also revealed in education system. As regardscontent, there was an over-emphasis on the study oflanguages and humanities. In schools there was little
provision for vocational training and in colleges, thenumber of students enrolled in the humanities was far
greater than that in the sciences or professional courses. Somuch time of a student was spent on mastering a foreign
language that often the main purpose of education wasdefeated. Most of the students picked up only smatteringof English and a tendency towards repetition of half-
understood sentences from this education system.61Thisencouraged memorizing and did not train a student to
think for himself. To some extent, Britishers abolishedIndian traditional research oriented education system
and established an education system, which helpedthem convert Indians as a follower of western knowledge
and traditions. The side-effect of minimized researchorientation in colonial education system and somehowcontinuation of that education system after independence
appears in present Indian society.
Another great drawback India inherited from colonialtimes is literacy ratio. At the time of independence, literacy
in India was about 12 percent. During the colonial time,the employment opportunities for qualified and highlytrained Indians were very few. All higher appointments
in the engineering service, railway service, irrigationdepartment, ordinance factories, posts and telegraphs
and in fact in all superior services were reserved forEuropeans. In the private sector, except in Bombay,
modern industries were owned by Europeans, who whenthey required men with technical knowledge, always
preferred their own countrymen.
As the well-known American author Napoleon Hill
famously wrote that every negative event contains withinit the seed of an equal or greater benefit.62Similarly, the
colonial education, which had negative effects on the
Indian education system, also had their positive effectson India. In the initial days of British seigniory, Britishers
needed some reputed people, who were able to controlthe people. So, they gave land and titles to small rulers
for making them more powerful and got their supportagainst the local people. These small rulers started to
send their children in U.K. for higher education, fromthe money collected from land revenues. Gandhi, Nehru,Jinnah received western thoughts and knew the value
of independence. When they came back to India, theyspread an understanding about the value of swaraaj
among general people and led the people in Indianindependence movement. Of the participants of these
movements, most of the people were well qualifiedIndians, who did not get employment according to theirability. Due to unemployment, discontent and feelings of
sedition rapidly increased among the educated Indians.So, definitely employment opportunity which was one
of the biggest problems of Colonial India had a positiveeffect on Indian National movements.
In the field of medical education, Britishers
had changed the traditional Indian system such asayurvedic medicines and encouraged the modernmedical education. They opened modern hospitals for the
treatment of their own countrymen, who worked in India.
In present days, both the modern medical system and thetraditional Indian medical system exist simultaneouslyin India. After the pressure of Indians, Britishers also
encouraged engineering and other vocational educationin India, which was the base of present vocationaleducation system in India. In conclusion, we can say
that the colonial education system, which started as thefulfillment of colonial needs, had several positive and
negative effects. After Independence, the need was toutilize the beneficial aspects of colonial education system
and remove their negative impacts from our presenteducation system.
Appendix I
No. University Place Foundation year Character
1. Calcutta University Calcutta January, 1857 Affiliating and teaching
2. Bombay University Bombay July, 1857 Affiliating and teaching
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
13/16
82 History Today, No.15, 2014
3. Madras University Chennai September, 1857 Federative, affiliating and teaching
4. Punjab University, Lahore 1882 Affiliating
5. Allahabad University Allahabad 1887 Teaching
6. Banaras Hindu University Varanasi 1916 Teaching
7. University of Mysore Mysore 1916 Affiliating and teaching
8. University of Patna Patna 1917 Affiliating and teaching
9. Osmania University Hyderabad 1918 Teaching
10. Aligarh Muslim University Aligarh 1920 Teaching
11. Lucknow University Lucknow 1921 Teaching
12. Dhaka University Dhaka 1921 Teaching
13. Delhi University Delhi 1922 Federative and teaching
14. Nagpur University Nagpur 1923 Affiliating and teaching
15. Andhra University Hyderabad 1926 Affiliating and teaching
16. Agra University Agra 1927 Affiliating
17. Annamalai UniversityChidambaram, Tamil
Nadu1929 Teaching
18.University of Travancore
(now University of Kerala)Thiruvananthapuram 1937 Affiliating and teaching
19. Utkal University Bhubaneshwar 1943 Affiliating
20. Saugor University Sagar 1946 Affiliating and teaching
21.Rajputana University (now
University of Rajasthan)
Jaipur 1947 Affiliating
Appendix II
CABEMeeting
Place Date Chairman Main Considerations
Third New Delhi28thJan.,
1938Kunwar Jagdish
Prasad
The Report of the Vernacular Education Committee connected with theadministration and control of Primary Education in India,The Report of the Womens Education Committee on the curriculum ofGirls Primary Schools in India,The Abbott-Wood Report on Vocational Education in India.
Fourth New Delhi3rdDec.,
1938Kunwar Jagdish
Prasad
The Report of the Wardha Education Committee,Another important question was the removal of illiteracy, Adult Education
and Village Libraries.
FifthShimla 6-7thMay,
1940Sir Girija
Shankar Bajpai,
Action taken by Provincial Governments on the recommendations of theVernacular Education Committee,Report of the Adult Education Committee,Report of the Second Wardha Education Committee,A draft scheme (received from Sir Francis Younghusband, the Chairmanof the Indian Village Welfare Association, Westminster) for theestablishment of a centre in India for the study of Social Service andPublic Administration.
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
14/16
83The Educational Policy in Colonial India: Causes and Effects
Sixth Madras11-12th
Jan., 1941Sir Girija
Shankar Bajpai,The Report of Scientific Terminology Committee,The question of School Buildings.
Seventh Hyderabad 14-15th
Jan., 1942Sir MauriceGwyer
Action taken by Provincial Governments on the recommendations of theReport of Scientific Terminology Committee,
The Report of the School Building Committee,The Uniform Braille Code Committee,The Report of the Joint Committee of the Central Advisory Boards ofEducation and Health.
EighthLucknow
14-15thJan., 1943
Sardar JogendraSingh
Report of the committee on examinations in India,Report of the committee on recruitment, training and service conditionsof teachers,Report of the committee on the recruitment of education officers,The Report of the committee to advise the Government of Bombay inregard to basic education,Question of promotion of technical and industrial education.
Ninth(Special)
Dehradun13-15th
Oct., 1943Sir Maurice
Gwyer
Memorandum prepared by the Educational Adviser to the Governmentof India (lately designated as Educational Commissioner) on Post-WarEducational Development in India.
TenthBaroda
19-21stJan., 1944
Sardar JogendraSingh
Reports of the Committees on Technical Education, Textbooks andTechnique of Examinations,The question of Basic English in relation to the Indian educationalsystem,A proposal for making adequate arrangements for the study of Chinese,
Japanese and Russian languages at selected centres.
EleventhKarachi
16-18thJan., 1945
Sardar JogendraSingh
The reports of the Committees on (i) Training, Recruitment and ServiceConditions of Teachers in Universities, (ii) Agricultural Education and(iii) Administration,The Report of the Joint Committee of the Central Advisory Boards ofEducation and Health.
Twelfthmysore
24-26thJan., 1946
Right Rev. G.D.Barne
The views of the reconstituted Committee on Religious Education,
Thirteenth Bombay9-11thJan.,
1947Shri C. RajaGopalachari
The Report of the Committee on Basic English,The Report of the Committee appointed to examine the formation of aSecondary Schools Examination Council for India.
1 Khapoya, Vincent B., The African Experience: an Introduction (4thedition), Pearson, 2010, pp. 99-134.
2 Basu, Aparna, Essay in the History of Indian Education, concept,
New Delhi, 1982, p. 60.
3 Bose, Sujatha Freeda Nesamani and L. Selvamuthu Kumarasami,Evolution of Colonial Educational Policy In India And MadrasPresidency, Review of Research, Vol. 2, Issue. 1, October 2012,p. 1.
4 Bashir, Aamir, Some Aspects of the Muslim Educational Systemin Pre-Colonial India. http://www.academia.edu/806133/Aspects_of_Muslim_Educational_System_in_Precolonial_India.
Notes and References
5 Kochhar, R., Muslims and English Education in Colonial Bengal:Calcutta Madrasa and Hooghly Mohsin College in a historicalperspective, Hooghly College 175, Hooghly Mohsin College,Hooghly, 2011, pp. 18.
6 Ibid, p. 22.
7 Ibid, pp. 22, 27.
8 Thomas, Alexander, Wise before the Select Committee of Houseof Lords, 30 June 1853,in Lords 1853, p. 223, para 6925.
9 Snyder, Michael R., A Victim of Circumstance: The Timber Bill of1772 and the East India Company, Past Imperfect, Vol. 1, 1992,pp. 27-47.
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
15/16
84 History Today, No.15, 2014
10 Ingham, Kenneth, Reformers in India, 1793-1833: An accountof the work of Christian missionaries on behalf of social reform,Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1956, P. 6.
11 Farquhar, J.N., Modern Religious Movements in India, TheMacmillan Company, New York, 1915, p. 15.
12 Kachru, Braj B., The Alchemy of English. The Spread, Functionsand Models of Non-Native Englishes,Pergamon Press Ltd., Oxford,1986, p. 35.
13 Ibid.
14 Caton, Alissa, Indian in Colour, British in Taste: William Bentinck,Thomas Macaulay, and the Indian Education Debate, 1834-1835,
Voces Novae: Chapman University Historical Review, Vol. 2, No.2, Chapman University, USA, 2011, p. 39.
15 Macaulay,Thomas Babington, Minutes Dated Feburary 2, 1835, inH. Sharp (ed.) Bureau of Education: Selections From EducationalRecords, Part I, 1781-1839, National Archives of India, Delhi,1965, p. 107-117. http://www.columbia.edu/itc/mealac/pritchett/00generallinks/macaulay/txt_minute_education_1835.html.
16 Ghosh, Suresh, Bentinck, Macaulay and the Introduction of EnglishEducation in India, History of Education, Vol. 24, issue 1, 1995,p. 17.
17 Ibid, p. 22.
18 Sharma, Ram Nath and Rajendra Kumar Sharma, History ofEducation in India, New Delhi, Atlantic Publishers & Dist,1996, p. 86.
19 Mukherjee, Sumita, Nationalism, Education and Migrant Identities:The England-returned, Routledge, London and New York, 2010,p. 13.
20 Centenary of Medical College, Bengal, 1835-1934, Medical collegeof Bengal, Calcutta, 1935, pp. 6-7; Basu, B.D., Education in Indiaunder Rule of the East India Company, Calcutta, Modern ReviewOffice, 1867, p. 136.
21 The Imperial Gazetteer of India, Vol. 21, Oxford, Clarendon Press,1908, p. 325; For detail- Account of Roorkee College Establishmentfor the instruction of Civil Engineering, with a scheme for itsenlargement, Secundra Orphan Press, Agra, 1851, pp. 3, 5.
22 Sharma, Ram Nath and Rajendra Kumar Sharma, op.cit., p. 85.
23 Sarma, Bina Kumari, Development of Modern Education in India:An Empirical Study of Orissa, M D Publication, New Delhi, 1996,p. 40.
24 Sharma, Ram Nath and Rajendra Kumar Sharma, op.cit., p. 102.
25 Mandal, Madan Mohan, A Critical Note On Wood s EducationalDespatch of 1854, Indian Streams Research Journal, Vol. 3,Issue 9, Oct. 2013. http://www.isrj.net/ArchiveArticleList.aspx?VolumeID=33
26 Bose, Sujatha Freeda Nesamani and L .Selvamuthu Kumarasami,
op.cit.,p. 3.
27 Sharma, Ram Nath and Rajendra Kumar Sharma, op.cit., pp. 102-103.
28 Mandal, Madan Mohan, op.cit.; Sharma, K.R., AccountingEducation in South Asia, New Delhi, Concept PublishingCompany, 2004, pp. 102-103.
29 The Report of the University Education Commission, (December1948 August 1949), Volume I, Ministry of Education, Governmentof India, 1962 (First Reprint Edition), p. 17.
30 Ibid, p. 18.
31 Ibid, p. 19.
32 Ibid, pp. 17-18.
33 Ibid, p. 19.
34 Coomaraswamy, Anand K., Modern Review, Vol.4, Calcutta,Oct.1908, p. 338;
35 Hasting, James and John A. Selbie (ed.), Encyclopedia of Religionand Ethics, Part 3, Kessinger Publishing, 2003, p. 57.
36 Bevir, Mark, Theosophy and the Origins of the Indian NationalCongress, International Journal of Hindu Studies 7, 2003, pp. 99-115.
37 Basu, Aparna, op.cit., p. 66.
38 Report of the Indian Universities Commission, 1902, Shimla:Printed at the Government Central Printing Office, 1902, p. 7.
39 Ibid, p. 57; The Report of the University Education Commission,
op.cit., pp. 19-20; Nurullah, Syed and J. P. Naik, A Students Historyof Education in India - 1800-1947, Macmillan, Bombay, 1949, p.167.
40 A Collection of the Acts passed by the Governer General of Indiain Council in the year 1904, Act no. VIII of 1904, Calcutta, Officeof the Superintendent of government Printing, 1905, pp. 59-82.
41 The Report of the University Education Commission, (December1948 August 1949), Vol. I,p. 22.
42 Basu, Aparna, op.cit.
43 Census of India, 1931, Vol. I, pt. I. p. 326.
44 Ibid, p. 330.
45 Bombay Gazetteer, Vol. II, Bombay, 1877, P. 526; Vol. IV,Ahmedabad, 1879, pp. 34-35.
46 Mitra, H. N. (ed.), The Govt. of India Act 1919 Rules Thereunder& Govt. Reports, 1920,Annual Register Office, Calcutta, 1921,pp. 125-126, 130-132.
47 The Indian Statutory Commission was a group of sevenBritish Parliamentary Members of United Kingdom that had beendispatched to India in 1928 to study constitutional reform inBritains most important colonial dependency. Member of theCommission were Sir John Simon, Clement Attlee, Harry Levy-Lawson, Edward Cadogan, Vernon Hartshorn, George Lane-Foxand Donald Howard.
-
7/26/2019 The Educational Policy in Colonial India:Causes and Effects
16/16
85The Educational Policy in Colonial India: Causes and Effects
48 Sir Phillip Hartog had served as a member of the SadlerCommission. He had also been a Vice-Chancellor of the DaccaUniversity in 1921. Since he was the chairman of the Committee,the Committee was known as Hartog Committee.
49 Mohanty, Jagannath, Teacher Education, Deep & Deep Publication,New Delhi, 2007 (First Published 2003), p. 10.
50 Report of the Secondary Education Commission, October 1952To June 1953, Ministry of Education, Government of India, p. 12.
51 Former Chief Inspector of Technical Schools, Board of Educationin England.
52 Director of Intelligence, Board of Education in England.
53 Report of the Secondary Education Commission, op.cit., p. 13.
54 Rao, V.K., Higher Education, in Encyclopaedia of EducationalDevelopment, Vol. IV, APH Publishing Corporation, New Delhi,2008, pp.180-81.
55 Bureau of Education, pamphlet no. 6; Sargent, John, Progress ofEducation in India, 1937-1947, Vol. I, p. 220-221.
56 Sargent, John, op.cit.,p. 232.
57 Ibid, pp. 231-237.
58 Zvobgo, R., Racism and Education in Southern Rhodesia (1880-1965), Unpublished M. Phil. Dissertation, J.N.U., 1977, p. 145.
59 Census of India, 1931, Vol. I, pt. I, p. 326.
60 Ibid, p. 330.
61 Basu, Aparna, op.cit., pp. 65-66.
62 Hill, Napoleon, Think and Grow Rich, 1937.