Download - Text to Greek Philosophy
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
1/132
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
2/132
EX
BiBLIOTHECA
FRANCES
A.
YATES
|
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
3/132
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
4/132
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
5/132
Texts to illustrate
a Course of
Elementary Lectures
on
the
History
of
Greek
Philosophy
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
6/132
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
7/132
Texts
to
illustrate
a
Course
of
Elementary
Lectures
on
the
History
of
Greek
Philosophy
from
Thales
to
Aristotle
,
MeN
tinac
AgIac,
oi Ae
reNece^i
'
reroNAciN
London
Macmillan
and
Co.,
Limited
New
York
:
The
Macmillan
Company
190
I
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
8/132
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
9/132
TO MANY
FRIENDS
tuhose
questions^ criticisms^
mid
suggestions,
have
helped
and
encouraged
ine in the
past,
I dedicate
this
compilation,
prepared
for
the use
of
their successors
in
the
lectuj^e-room
of
Trinity
College.
HENR Y
J
A
CKSON.
3
I
filly
1
90
1
«
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
10/132
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
11/132
PEEFACE
Under
regulations
recently
made
by the
Senate
of the
University
of
Cambridge
for
Part
I
of
the
Classical
Tripos
Examination,
short
passages illustrative
of
Greek and
Eoman
philosophy
will,
after
1902,
be set
for
translation
and
comment.
In
order that
candidates for
this ex-
amination
who
attend my lectures may have before them
the
passages
which
I
shall
discuss or refer to, I
have
prepared
this
volume
of
selected
texts.
I
have
however
included in
it,
together
with
the
passages
required
for
my
primary
purpose,
some
others,
likely to be
of
use
to
any
of
my hearers who,
later
in their
Academic
career,
may
make
a
more exact
study
of
the
subject.
In preparing
the
paragraphs
which
represent
the
Prae-
platonics,
I
have
made
frequent use
of
the
Historia
Fhilosophiae
Graecae
of
H.
Ritter
and
L.
Preller.
It is
a
pleasure
to
me
to
have
here
an
opportunity
of
expressing
the
sincere
gratitude
which
I
have
long
felt,
both
to
the
authors
of
this
work,
and
to
its
present
editor,
Ed.
Wellmann,
whose
labours
have
made
the
recent
editions
indispensable
to
all
serious
students
of
early
Greek
philosophy.
In
the
chapter
on
Plato,
my
method
has
been
to
select
from
each
of
the
principal
dialogues
a
passage
or
passages
which
will
give
me
an
opportunity
of
explaining
what
I
suppose
to
be
that
dialogue's
contribution
to
the
system.
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
12/132
viii
TEXTS
FOR LECTURES ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
In
the
chapter
on Aristotle,
I
have drawn
for
the most
part
upon
certain
of the
more
important
philosophical
treatises
:
and,
as
far as
my limitations permitted,
I
have
tried
to
secure
continuity
of
exposition.
The
excerpts
from
the organon
do
not
pretend
to represent
the treatises
from
which they
are taken
:
they are added
because
they
will
be
wanted
for
reference.
Paragraphs
about
the
ethics are introduced in the hope
that they
will
help
students
who
are
reading
that instructive treatise
for
the
first
time, to
undei'stand
its
scope
and
to follow
its
argument.
In
my
lectures,
and
therefore in
this
compendium,
my
aim
is, not
so
much to record
the details of
Greek
philo-
sophical systems,
as
rather to
trace
the
development
of
Greek philosophical thought.
On
this
subject,
quot homines
tot
sententiae : and I acknowledge
that I have views
of
my
own.
The
passages
which I
have chosen are
however, for
the most
part, such
as
would
be
generally
acknowledged
to
be important
:
and it is conceivable that
my
selection,
though
made with
a view
to
the
exposition
of
particular
interpretations, should
provide texts for
teachers
who
have
no
sympathy
with
my
heresies.
In the hope
that
my
little book
may
be
useful
in this w^ay,
I
\^nture to
publish
what
I had originally intended for
private
circulation only.
H. J.
Trinity
College,
Cambridge
21
September 1901.
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
13/132
CONTENTS
Section
1-3
•
Introductory
I The
Ionian
Monists
5
Thales
6-8
Anaximander
9-11
Anaximenes
12-18
Heracleitiis
II The
Pythagoreans
19-21
III
The
Eleatic
Monists
23,
24
Xenophanes
25-30
Parmenides
31,
32
Zeno
11
12
12
15
IV
The
Pluralists
33-38
Empedocles
.
39-42
Anaxagoras
.
43-47
Leucippiis
and
Democritus
18
21
24
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
14/132
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES ON GREEK PHILOSOPHY
V The
Sophists
Section
Page
48
.
.
. .
.
.28
49
Protagoras,
Hippias
.
.
.
.
.29
50
Gorgias
.
.
. .
.
.29
51
Thrasymachus
. .
.
.
.30
52
Euthydemus
and Dionysodorus .
. .30
53
Isocrates .
. . .
.
.31
VI
Socrates
and
Minor
Socratics
54-58
Socrates
.....
59,
GO
Aristippus
.....
61,
62
Antisthenes
....
63
Eucleides
and Eubulides
64
Stilpo
.....
65
Phaedo
and Menedemiis
VII
Plato and the Old
Academy
66
Euthypliro
....
41
67
Me^io
....
41
68,
69
Phaedrus
....
42
70
symposium
....
44
71-74
republic
....
45
75,
76
Phaedo
.... 49
77-83
Parmenides
51
84-86
Philehus
....
55
87
Theaetetus
....
57
88-92
sophist
....
58
93
politicus
....
62
94-100 Timaeus
....
63
101
laws
....
68
102,
103
Aristotelian
evidence
69
104-106
Speusippus
and
Xenocrates
.
. 71
107
The
Old
Academy
.
73
36
37
38
39
39
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
15/132
CONTENTS
xi
VIII
Aristotle
Section
Pa.re
108-114 metaphysica
.
.
.
.
.74
115-121
metaphysica
.
.
.
.
.80
122,
123
de generatione
et corruptione
.
.
.
.86
124-129
de
anima
.
.
. .
.
.88
130-132
categoriae
.
.
.
.
.94
133-137
analytica
priora
.
.
.
.
.95
138
analytica
posteriora
. .
. .
.98
139-141
topica
.
.
.
.
. .99
142-149
ethica Nicomachea
.
.
. .
.102
150
politica
.
.
.
,
.
.110
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
16/132
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
17/132
1-3]
INTRODUCTOEY
1
Diogenes
Laertius l
1
2
^
^
vOayopa^
kavrov
.
. . .
yap
elvaL
[]
'
.
Plato
symposium
203
ovSeU
'
9
jeveaOat'
'
ovV
el
rt?
aXko
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
18/132
2
TEXTS FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[3
,
6
, 6\
-
€Tt
,
'
,
irepLiraTetv
{jyieoa.
Compare
A
3.
983a24
and
sphysica
2.
194
b
23.
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
19/132
6]
I
THE
IONIAN
MONISTS
4
Aristotle
metaphysica
A
3.
983
b
7
iv
etSet
^
elvai,
yap
,
^^
,
,
5
,
-
^
,
Sta '^'^
,
^^-
,
^^
,
-
,
,
.
5
Plutarch
Solon
3
6\
Thales
^
^
'
5
.
iogenes
Laertius
23
^/
.
.
.
.
8
-
^
-
.
^
^°
Aristotle
metaphysica
A
3.
983b20
&
6
[cf.
§
4]
[sc.
]'
/
.
6
Simplicius
in
physica
^' /cat
Auaximauder
J
^
^
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
20/132
4
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[
'
aireipov
^
'^
y,
,
ypv ,
35
.
8
Aristotle jpliysica
A
4. 187
a
20
ol
'
\
'
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
21/132
12]
ANAXIMANDER,
ANAXIMENES,
HERACLEITUS
5
€
^^-
//
yap
fcal
ovtol
.
etapMjsica
2.
1069bl8
'
€
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
22/132
6
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY [l2
,
'
alel
,
.
Plutarch
de
EI 8
6
'.\€
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
23/132
18]
HERACLEITUS
7
,
*
,
ovSe
Vi^dSj^'
'
^
avvayec,
Be
ovBe
,
'
,
3
16
Heracleitus,
Heracleitiis
allegoriae
Homericae
24
re
-
,
6
.
Plutarch
consolatio
ad Apolloniwn
10
y
,
evi
,
-
Jopb
,
veov
^
'yap
.
Heracleitus,
Sextus
Empiricus
VII
126
'^
-
[Bernays
-
].
5
17
Heracleitus,
Stobaeus
florilcgium
ill
84
.
,
,
.
yap
'
yap
2
7yvea.
'
Sextus Empiricus
133
Bib
-
yap 6
·
.
fa.^v*
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
24/132
8 TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[l8
BoKei,
%6',
,
elvai
he
erepov
,
ovnrep
.
35
8€
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
25/132
20]
II
THE
PYTHAGOREANS
19
Aristotle
metapliysica
A
.
985
b
23
iv he
irpo
ol
^
llvOayopeLOL
,
iv
-^-»·*
·
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
26/132
10
TEXTS
FOR LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[20
,
irap
Xojov
yap iyeveTO
cvAM^tjQ*^*^
^^
yepovTi
UvOayopa,
he
-
Ayt^^*^
'^.
yap
elvau
Svo
^
5
,
\eyv
<
^
,
,
yXvKv
,
ayaOov
,
/
.
^i1U^^,lJt^
^;
, he
-'^}^\
y0p€LOL TLve^
€€
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
27/132
22]
III
THE
ELEATIC MONISTS
22
Aristotle
metapliysica
A
.
986
b
9
'
€<
he
Tive
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
28/132
12
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ES
ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[23
Xenophanes
23
Xenophanes
'
r.
·
'
,
,
.
V'
iboc^c
i
(9e^^
re
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
29/132
26] XENOPHANES,
PARMENIDES
13
4-^^
XPV
^
elvai
Boa
iravrh^
.
32
Xevaae
'
irapeovra
;
ov
,
)
^
.
.
.
. ^
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
30/132
14 TEXTS FOR
LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[27
27
Plato
sophist
2-44
D
HE.
he
;
ro
6\oi>
erepov
(m^Xc^ci^
;
.
9
fyap
ur^
U
iJ^*^
re
;
HE.
Et
\
,
Xeyet,
5
evaXiyKiov
,
]
yap
TL
Tjj
},
'
'
€,
^^^^
cvo*
;
.
;9.
t^ouA'^'-j'^
'-^^
'
HE.
6
'^-^^^^^•^^'^
^
,
.
'
;
HE.
To
'
<
a.U
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
31/132
31]
PARMENIDES,
ZENO
15
ov,
/xeV
,
[],
irdvroae
,
220
'
€€
^'^^'^'
,
aharj,
Se/za?
re.
eyo)
,
rt?
^
).
5
iireiht]
125
^
€
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
32/132
16
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[31
d-^^
0
XoyoL,
^'^
^-^|^
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
33/132
32]
ZENO
17
€9,
7€
€€ iv
^9.
Bevrepa
',·
9,
ovheTTOTe
''
€-
yap
avayKawv
€
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
34/132
[33
THE
PLURALISTS
Empedocles
33
Sextus Empiricus
VII
123
Se
[sc. 'EyLtTre-
8\
6
^AKpayavTLVO^^ ev
-
<
'
*
jc*«-*«-^
yap
'
2
Stein
^^^^\AJ^^^
'
.
\
c
^Lc^d-cu-o^
,
5
,
'
6\
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
35/132
EMPEDOCLES
jg
'
'
^
,l....v,,r,.
',
aveXiaOac
if
6,
^Xio,
el^relv
''
^poiac
.
\\
yhp
^
,—
I
6
^
i)
20
s
\
ipihovirov
^
,
pvKe
voec
'
.
4
Empedocles
-
-,^^
^'^
re
8'
.-
iW-,,^
^
Teyyei
.
XXo^Be
Tot
-
36
,
{
^^^^
/^^^
\^'
,
'
.
...
.5
198
aLyX
'
',
'
yivovTo
\
.
5 Empedocles
^^'^
/^^^
^
yciiav
,
'
,
333
2
'
,
,
e
trt
)
,
Xvypo).
l:yav
336
^
.
heophrastus
de
sensu
7
'
. .
.
25
[sc.
]
sc.
]
'
,
,
Usener
],
'
so
.
ristotle
de
anima
3.
427
a
21
y
,
''
'
yap
.
35
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
36/132
20
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[36
36
Empedocles
^''
'
€
yap ev
elvac
61
,
'
ifKeov etvat.
^-^
\'\a^dcL·
(^ffvv-iyi?^
SoiT] jiveac^
Solt]
'
'
ap
,
'^'^-^
\jrftM^K,
«-<
[Stein
:
codd.
-
ti^-^'^^
6]
.
-
65
^
\^,
(
(fv-^
<
'
ev
,
'
^
'.
.
.
.
^
',
?
yap
75'
'
hiirJC
'
yap
c^jlu
:
,
'
,
,
^
yaia
{;i|ro9.i<
'7^?'^^^'*''^
yap yhvav ,
.
(^--
^)^
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
37/132
EMPEDOCLES,
ANAXAGORAS
r
,
-
alev
,
alev
eTrrjei
Imj
^,^^^'^^^^
^(;
^;
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
38/132
22
TEXTS
FOR LECTURES
ON GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[39
,
[codd.
aXXo)?]
'
€
yiyveadao
ovre
-
aWa
.
Aristotle
de
caelo
3.
302 a28
'
/^-
\€
€
XeyeL
'» 6 yap
oc^itX
5
yrjv
'
elvai
^
6
^-
.
yap
^,
\ey
,
aa
elvai
yap
yyvea
.
40
Anaxagoras, Simplicius in
physica
33^
34^
fr.
1
Schaubach
'
,
aireipa
·
yap
.
-
^;
'
':'^
15
yap
',
i^^-^
.
yap
ya
^'-^-'-^
y.
,
fr.
2
yap
-^.
y
'
/-^j^i^^
^°
'^^
.
r.
3
^
'^
y
'
^
'^
^
^
'
^'
'.'
, ;^*
:^^
^.
25
fr.
6
^'
yap
'
'^,
^
3
.
yap
.
cU^v-u^^^
fr.
14
yvv
'
.
yap
<
>
,
35
.
fr.
22
yva
-
^'
yap
'^
yva
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
39/132
42]
ANAXAGORAS
23
'
^
re
,
vLyeaL·
.
1
Diogenes
Laertius
6
.
. .
-
Trj
€7€6,
^^^
. .
.
s
'
6
8€€.
/
Anaxagoras,
Simplicius
in
physica
33 ,
35''
fr.
8
,
,
V
el
yap
iir
,
,
,
l
*
ev
yap
eveaTiv,
ev
XeKefCTai,
eyeva,
''
.
yap
is
yvv
y
yLov,
y
,
,
.
,
[codd. ']
^-^^^
,
.
yev
eyv
.
,
, ,
,
25
6
.
-
.
.
.
.
.
'
,
.
35
42
Plato
FJiaedo
97
'
,
,
vaaypo
vayyv
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
40/132
24
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[42
\€<
iarlv
6
re
^,]
rrj
re
€v
'
eivac
,
rjyr)-
,
€
^
<
',
ye
5
\^€^
)
otttj
e^y
ei
evpeiv
irepl owrj
yiyveTai , Beiv
ire
evpeiv,
)
eaTiv
elvai
irda^^eiv
iroieiv
€
Se
\0yov
ovSev
aKOTTeiv
TrpoarjKeiv
irepl
eKeivov
irepl
'
.
8
,
eraipe,
'
€-
€,
eTreiBr)
vayyvv
^
ovBev
'^pevov
[ovhe
e7aevov^
15 €
€
7pyaa,
Be
aevov
.
Aristotle
mctapliysica A 3.
984b
14
'
-
rrj
) €7
lpaya
el^ev.
eiircbv
iveivai KaOdirep
ev
2 ev
Trj
ve
€
,
eiKrj
Xeyova
TTpOTepov.
4. 985
a
17
€
yap ovBev
'pevo
'
.
vaaypa
re
yap
'
'
,
)
5
vy
,
€ TrapekKei
, ev Be
yyvoevv
.
Leucippus
and
43
Simplicius
in
physica
7^
[sc.
Aeo]
Democritus
>/ >
/ *
//
«
\
j
/
aTTeipa
aei
voveva
vTreueTO
'
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
41/132
44]
LEUCIPPUS
AND
DEMOCRITUS
25
Kevov,
6v
Be
ov
eKciXei'
yap
?
^
^
^
.
'
'^
BtaOLyr}, Be
elirelv
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
42/132
26
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES ON GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[44
^^
6
tl
'yap
f),
-
,
eh
cL«Xv^Wi*-*t.
,
elvaL.
,
Sextus
Empiricus
135
jdp [sc.
-
^^^^
cev^^^'^^'^
-
f^pi^rj-Q^'^
yXvKv
,
,
^,
tyjitJilSi^
''
eTefj
Se
,
'
^
elvai
,
Be
aXijeetav
,
Kev0v.
45
Aristotle de
anima A
2.
405
a
8 Be
s
kJ^^e^^-4CLj
^\€
epev.
.
. .
'
€
-i
^,
Be
.
46
Diogenes
Laertius
31
^
jvaJtej^
·^
_
'
25
^
,
^
,
-
'3(^·'4u.Wti^
^^pL4fc£C^
W^-^^
-^
.
,
^*·
-'^^
-
3
ef
,
,
b
^
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
43/132
47]
LEUCIPPUS AND
DEMOCRITUS
27
Stobaeus
eclogae I
160
AevKiTTTro^
,
.
Xiyeo
'yap
ev
Ilepl
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
44/132
[48
V
THE
SOPHISTS
48
Plato sophist 231c
.
olov
^,
'
'^^^^
'^·\
I'd
,
,
6
vxi»
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
45/132
]
PROTAGORAS,
HIPPIAS,
GORGIAS
29
*
,
6
;
.
Xv^^c^
49
Plato Theaetetus
152
yap
[sc.
Upay6pa]
Protagoras
'
elvai,
9
,
Se
.
s
.ou^cC^XCo
;
.
-^
^.
21.
,
,
8
'
8
<
;
.
<
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
46/132
30
TEXTS FOR LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[50
70
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
47/132
53]
THRASYMACHUS,
EUTHYDEMUS,
ISOCRATES
31
275
Kal
,
€
[sc.
],
,
,
,
oirorep
,
ji^
iu
.
.
3
Isocrates
de
permutatione
§
180
isocrates
^
j€vea\oyovvTe
irepl
'r-'^*^'-'
<
6
'
'^
.
v
'^-
^^'^'
'
^
ev
uy\^-
ava
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
48/132
[54
VI SOCRATES
AND THE
MINOR
SOCRATICS
54
Plato apologia Socratis 21b
iiri
^
elvat.
. . .
^
. . .
fcal hta\e'y6^evo
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
49/132
56] SOCRATES
33
55
Xenophon
memorabilia
A
I
11
ovSe
jap
nrepl
rjirep
SteXeyeTo,
6
^
,
$
^.
,
,
-
.
'
^
\<
8
.
. .
.
8
'
,
-:,
^
,
^
,
;
2
'
,
'
>
y
^^
;
ay
^
^,
,
,
' ,
,
ahiKov
2s
,
'
,
'
,
'
,
^
'
^
-
.
3
56
Xenophon
memoraUlia
13
avTiXiyoi
€
,
/
,
-
;
yap
.
,
yov
yao
;
.
D
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
50/132
34
TEXTS
FOE
LECTURES
ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[56
acUn-^^i^C^cUc;^
iv
'^
6
'^
-
t6\lv
;
,
.
^
ye
i
.
:
.
>
>
6
;
9
yap
;
^
o?
civ
; -
5
;
.
\
iv
^^
6
;
/-^
.
'
eir
,
'
^
.
tl
,,
Sta
^
,
oyov
Toiyapovv
'
Xiyoi
^
8
.
5
V 12
'
^-^^'
'
6
,
-
' yap
^
°
<
.
c
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
51/132
58]
SOCRATES
35
-.
'^^^'-'
\-^^
>??
^
,
Xefc
Se irepl
^
'
,
€,
,
elvai]
/cal^
09,
/,
\
elirelv
OTTOto?
Tt9
iariv
;
/^
,
,
6
s
.
^
he
;
-
Sei
.
6
68
Bei
;
',
.
''
6
€8
Seiv
oiBev
;
r^ap
,
.
9
;
,
.
8
;
.
6
;
yap
;
?
15
;
,
.
;
yodv,
,
.
58
Xenophon
memorabilia
A
10
,
,
,
'
,'
^
'
,
^
X
5
25
' yap
/^
'
,
30
ya
,
y'pv
,
ristotle
ethica
Nicomachea
2.
1145 b
21
'
.
U^c^-^^^-l
'
35
yp
,
,
.
X0yov
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
52/132
36
TEXTS
FOR LECTURES ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[58
D-vs> 2i
'>
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
53/132
61]
ARISTIPPUS,
ANTISTHENES
37
T6
^
avrrj
.
ehat
^
yevaL.
. .
.
el
yap
,
'
Sl
.
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
54/132
38
TEXTS FOR LECTURES ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[62
62
Aristotle
metaphysica
29.
1024b32
^
€0
€<
XeyeaOac
€v
'
€v0
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
55/132
65]
EUCLEIDES,
STILPO,
PHAEDO,
MENEDEMUS
39
\6yov^
.
.
. .
[sc.
6
]
h
~^^
vs
ore
jap
,
ore
,
.
108
]'
S
Eu/cXetSou
StaSo'^Tj^
€cto
^'
Eubulides
6
^;,
o?
iv
}
;?
s
,
re
^
^
:
*^>''f**f''v^
Mov'
.
4
Plutarch adversus
Coloten
23
Stiipo
€7
^
ECTiVt
et
'^
,
irepl
-
^,
a)OC
Xoyov,
^'
yap Xoyov
is
.
yopova
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
56/132
40
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[65
erepov
erepov
erepov
iart
;
val.
erepov
he
ayaOov
;
.
.
avrjpei
he,
,
,
^'
aifKa
Trpoaheyofxevo^
5
avypet, he
7\
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
57/132
67]
VII
PLATO
AND
THE
OLD
ACADEMY
66
Eitthyphro
C
^
Plcato
^
elBevat
^
^
}
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
58/132
42 TEXTS FOR LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[67
^
'^,
6
tl
,
6
,
.
2. Bl
6
tl
,
.
y
elire.
Sil.
5
^
^
.
.
^
\6
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
59/132
69]
PLATO
: MENO,
PHAEDRUS
43
ov
^
^;
,
8
irakiv
eU
,
.
6
^/
€
,
€7
)
.
49
yap
,
,
*
paSiov
,
,
.
oXiyac
8
,
,
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
60/132
44
TEXTS FOR
LECTURES
ON GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[69
Sil.
To
y
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
61/132
7^]
PLATO
:
SYMPOSIUM,
REPUBLIC
45
^
irXeov
€
/^^^
V ,,,
,^^^^^
^
.
8
Sta
ro
^^^
epdv
,
>«^^
/
.
yap
€7
levat
^,
-
s
,
,
8
,
,
^^^^^^
^
,
V
,
6
)
,
vS
.
,
^,
,
,
.
is
71
rejmUic
478
,
repuhlicl^'^--^^
,
6
,
,
8
,
,
}
\
,
.
yap
8,
,
,
;
,
SiKov
;
,
;
,
'
vy,
,
,
25
.
;
;
.
ya
8
,
,
;
'
,
,
.
3°
,
;
,
,
,
avya
^
,
^
'
yp
35
,
lay
.
^
,
'
y,
6
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
62/132
46
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[71
re
elvat
;
6 yap
^'^'^^^
elvat
,
lvat,
^,
.
,
eotKev,
OTt
Y^jiA^'iJ^^z
5
v6ta
re
Trept
\tvSetat
re
5
el\ttv.
.
^
,
iocs*
..
iti-v-^
Tt
TotodTov
,
'
^
^ir^eZ^'tlc^
^^^^
^-,
.caC;^,
.
'^^.
\
,
^
ayovTt e'^at,
,
,
,
,
^^^
.
^
,
5
.
;
^
^^
-
I
;
^
,
C.v^
zjJ^^
*^
\
'
^
^rfxcj^-^^^^
'^,
*
;
2
72
republic
509
,
,
^
,
^
,
^
. yap
;
^^
,
5
aXka
:
U^\jU
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
63/132
73]
PLATO:
REPUBLIO
47
airrerai
rrj
8\€
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
64/132
48
TEXTS
FOR LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[73
6<
'
iyepTLKOv
.
,
e
8
;
<
,
iv
'
;
'
a\A.cX^
5
;
'
^;
;
,
(^'^
'^
-
,
TrapayyeXXei
'
;
,
.
,
y,
^
iv
^
,
06
,
eyet,
,
,
el re
15
;
yap,
,
ye
vkX^«^L
»^^
cltottoc
^
^.
(^cSxcJ2^.
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
65/132
75]
PLATO
:
REPUBLIC,
PHAEDO
49
;
IheaL
ye
irepl
,
,
Be
^;.
Nat.
Xeyecv,
ore
6
^'^
^-^^-^^^'
ISeav
iroLel
6
,
6
Be
,
ah
,
;
s
yap
y
Iheav
Biopy
Bopyv' yap
;
.
97
,
,
,^^^
^
,
;
Et
\€,
.
yiyvovTai'
Ty
,
,
ya,
pyaa.
;
,
.
Mta
y
6
;
,
.
Mta
ypo.
yap
;
.
Zypo
,
,
,
.
.
, ,
is
vy
Tjj
'pyaa
,
'
.
;
.
,
'
,
^
,
2
.
kj\;^cX.
,
,
,
^
.
, .
,
,
,
,
,
.
25
.
opyv
-
ayopv
;
^
yodv,
,
y
.
Bopyv
;
/.
ypov
Bopyov
;
3©
.
;
,
'
09,
oy
7poayopa,
Bopyo.
,
'
,
yvvao
;
,
.
75
Phaedo
74
t'
,
6,
Phaedo
.
,
Xy
-
^
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
66/132
50
TEXTS
FOR LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[75
krepov
,
tl eivau
j^/^^^^^X^
i^^JL.
;
,
6
^J\Jj^r^-
yvov\
yap
,
yva
.
yp
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
67/132
77]
PLATO
:
PHAEDO,
PARMENIDES
51
,
^;
/c
ireaelv,
,'
eivao
-
, '
)
€,
^
/-
,
;
N
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
68/132
52
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[77
^
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
69/132
81]
PLATO:
PARMENIDES
53
e/caarov
;
X^pl?
yevoLTo
;
ttco?
;
^^^^54^'.
(
elirev.
aoc
elZoma»V«^
*f
vy/c
€ya
;
.
'
.Jr.
^
yo
,
*
yo
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
70/132
25
\
du^c
54
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[81
,
^
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
71/132
8i]
PLATO
:
PARMENIDES,
PHILEBUS
65
^
,
irepl
^,
€ €v
ehe
ev,
;
166
C
6
,
€olk€v,
€v
€
eaTLv
€€
,
€
s
.
-
84
Philebus
14
c
Sil.
Xojov
Philehus
Si
^
.
.
-
Ir^S^^W^^.
hrj
;
.
7pyaa
^o*^^^ffvJ^feixju^ij^
.
.
^ ^^
.
.
8
, ,
.
yap
,
paStov
-
.
.
^
$
Xeyet?
',
'
7
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
72/132
56
TEXTS
FOR LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[84
JUL
dejLft
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
73/132
87]
PLATO:
PHILEBUS,
TEEAETETUS
57
ovv
ovS [codd.
ov
a Ti^}?
yjrv^rjf;
^
,
,
€
^
^
,
elvaL
rot?
,
6
\\
^vj'yevri
;
.
,
^.
€/79
,
e9ep,ev
-
s
,
,
,
e
;
2.
.
SO..
')
iv
yevea,
,
'
iv^vvevec
6
\6yo
ev
)
-
lvau
,
87
Theaetetus
184
^.
^,
Theaetetus
hi
,
elvaL
Bt
,
,
,
-'
,
Be
^sv:
^u^v.·*A«>
,
BC
;
.
? yap
;
^'^^^'*^
^.
Eif
TL
,
^^^'
^^^
,
-
*
cr-
(^^
.
.
;
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
74/132
58
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[87
sophist
5
---
«
-«''
eV
re /cat ^
,
Be
on
re
,
676,
Sia
Ty '''}
.
Sil.
',
,
,
€
.
.
,
^,
6^·^ '^
35
.
.
9
;
.
)
yva
;
.
.
.
';
yvovov
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
75/132
90] PLATO:
SOPHIST
59
;
. .
HE.
ye
iravTL
-,
o?
-
<
oirrjovv.
Is^^^vaX^j*-
.
,
ye.
HE.
,
eoiicev,
avayKri Sia
,
s
€
6V
€8
eyvv
€<
^',
re
)
-
€
,
v^Tjv,
,
6
re
vva6epa
eyev.
.^.
90
sophist
251
D
HE.
TloTepov
€
€
e
7€
e
8€
8€,
o-U^
.
'
ea\avev
^V.ivttic*Jp6Ji.
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
76/132
60
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[90
''·
'
'^'
'
erepov Trpoaayopevetv.
.
9
;
HE.
re
elvai irepl
'/
jfeUx,
cfxl^n
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
77/132
92]
PLATO:
SOPHIST
61
Sec,
a^ehov
ye
^eyl-
;
HE.
TtV
ovv
,
,
et?
iXev-
,
;
s
.
9
\€y€L
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
78/132
62 TEXTS FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[93
politicus
93
politicus
261
HE.
9 ye,
^-
7)
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
79/132
94]
PLATO:
POLITICO
S,
TUIAEUS
63
Tt9
,
TO
jevo
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
80/132
64 TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[94
yap
6
\6
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
81/132
97]
PLATO:
TIMAEUS
65
SLOVpyav,
irepl
icUo^c,
yeveaLv.
'
^
'
eivai
,
\€'6
^
6
,^'c^->^
<
<
^;
^·
Xotrrovs'^^^^^?
6
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
82/132
66 TEXTS FOR LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[97
^
.
yap
6v
67€6
tlvI
re
,
^^^J^^H*^
ekOoL,
^'
,
-
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
83/132
i]
PLATO:
TIMAEUS
67
eivac
,
ciyevvyTov
,
ek
eavTo
^,
et?
LOV,
he
9
,
^^cc
hr]
^
iinaicoirelv'
'
,
re
SevTepov,
,
^,
,
s
j^Mt^l *^
^
re
eV
tlvi
ttoKlv
i/cetOev
-
]
Be
7eVo9
aei,
,
'^
ehpav
8e
€€
yeveaiv
,
€
^
,
^
,
^-,^^^^
ovecpoiroXov
elval
ev
tlvl
,
/
,
ev
elvai.
'
98
Timaeus
53
^
tiju^MM^)^
,
opyavov
is
,
'
,
'
8
,
.
9
'
2
,
8
yrjv
,
,
-
ye
,
,
8
8
.
25
^
,
^
'
\.
yap
8
Si
30
8
\yva vy,
.
rj
,
.
'
vy
35
pyvv
.
pyva
pyvov,
yvav,
-
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
84/132
68
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[98
^,
'
erepov
.
8
^
€
'^,' Xoyov
.
99
Timaeus
7
C
,
eyove'
'
ev
€T€pa
,
ev
'^
^
,
'
,
,
.
Sio
^
'
t]
^^
.
5
59
'
'yy
,
€,
'
,
oXiyov
,
-
,
yXa
,
yvo
yyov'
'
,
1^
^
,
'
yyvvov
Xya.
-
8
SaXoyaa
,
,
25
Xyo,
yve-
,
.
100
Timaeus 92
8
X0yov
yp
3
68
,
,
,
yo
-
yovv,
ovoyv .
laws
101
laivs
896
c
.
y
oXoyav
35
,
.
.
.
Xoyol
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
85/132
102]
PLATO
:
TIMAEUS,
LA
TVS
69
<
€
yeyovora
,
etirep
.
.
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
86/132
70
TEXTS FOR
LECTURES ON GREEK PHILOSOPHY [l02
TO
€v),
,
^
€8
67
'
ev
iv
eiheai
XeyeTat, otl
8 ,
'
.
ev
^
^
,
,
'^
vaaypav.
103
Aristotle onetaphysica
A
9.
990
a 34
ol
,
^,
.
^
yap
8
,
^
yap
'
15
[]
,
,
^
8,
yap
vy
yyva
XKoyv,
'
yyva.
yap
2
\yo
8
,
-
,
-
yp
TL
.
Xyv
8,
25
^
yvo,
Xyov.
991 a
2
18
-
',
yap
^
,
;
3
,
,
,
^
-
, 8
yyvovo
.
5
yap
.
8
(
yap
yap
),
,
'^
y
^.
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
87/132
104]
THE
OLD
ACADEMY
71
992
b
9
T6
8€
elvai,
^
otl
ev
airavra,
&'
rf}
yap
yiyveTat
ev
'
ev, eav
rt?
.
ovhe
,
el
yevo^
Scoaei,
elvac
'
ev
evioi^
.
vSeva
'
e^et
Xoyov
ovSe
^eTa
^
s
eiriireha
aTeped,
ovTe
^
eaTiv
€,
€
exec
-
yap ovTe
ecSy
elvai
{
yap
elauv
),
ovTe
ea
{
yap
e/celva),
€
,
€
yevo^.
104
Aristotle
metaphysica
8.
1084
a
7 ert
el
The
Old
Ihea TLv6(;, ol
'
Iheai,
6 aireLpo^
eaTat
ISea
,
.
ovTe
evhe^eTai
ovTe
Xoyov,
'
.
el
le7epaevo
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
88/132
72 TEXTS
FOR LECTURES
ON
GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[l04
on
'
^
^. yap
7
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
89/132
107]
THE
OLD
ACADEMY
73
€<
,
^
yovv
<
<
,
Be
7<
elvai.
Aristotle
ethica
Nicomachea
HI
3.
1153bl
aXka
OTi
^
yap
7?
,
)
.
,
/.
vy
ayaQ0v
elvai.
yap
^^
,
,
yap
.
07
Cicero
academica
postcriora
17 Platonis
autem
auctoritate,
qui
uarius
et
multiplex
et
copiosus
fuit,
una
et
coDsentiens
duobus
uocabulis
philosophiae
forma
instituta
est,
Acaclemicorum
et
Peripateticorum,
qui rebus
cougruentes
nominibus
differebant.
.
. .
ita
facta
est,
quod
minime
Socrates
probabat,
ars
quaedam
philosophiae
et
rerum
ordo
et
descriptio
disciplinae.
quae
quidem
erat
primo
duobus,
ut
dixi,
nominibus
una
;
nihil
enim
inter
Peripateticos
et
illam
ueterem
Academiam
differebat.
22
communis
haec ratio
et
utrisque
hie
bonorum
finis
uidebatur,
adipisci,
quae
essent
prima
natura
quaeque ipsa
per
sese
expetenda,
aut
omnia
aut maxima
: ea sunt autem
maxima,
quae
in
ipso
animo
atque
in
ipsa
uirtute
uersantur.
itaque
omnis
ilia
antiqua
philosophia
sensit
in
una
uirtute
esse
positam
beatam uitam,
nec tamen
beatissimam,
nisi
adiungerentur
et corporis et cetera, quae supra
dicta sunt,
ad
uirtutis
usum
idonea.
ex hac
descriptione
agendi
quoque
aliquid in
uita
et
officii
ipsius initium
reperiebatur,
quod
erat
in conseruatione earum
rerum quas natura
praescriberet.
hinc
gignebatur
fuga desidiae uoluptatumque
conteniptio.
34
Speusippus autem et
Xenocrates,
qui
primi
Platonis
rationem
auctoritatemque
susceperant,
et post
eos
Polemo
et Crates
unaque
Grantor,
in
Academia
congregati,
diligenter
ea quae
a
superioribus
acceperant
tuebantur.
iam
Polemo-
nem
audiuerant
adsidue
Zeno
et
Arcesilas
:
sed
Zeno,
cum
Arcesilam
anteiret aetate
ualdeque
subtiliter
dissereret
et
peracute
moueretur,
corrigere
conatus
est
disciplinam.
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
90/132
[108
VIII
AEISTOTLE
metaphysical
108
meiapliysicci
1.
1028al0
ov
Xeyerai
-
9·
. .
.
ryap
iart
,
Be OTL
.
'
\eyoevov
*'
*
,
.
.
.
.
'
XeyeTai
76<
eivac, ^;,
,
.
.
. .
^
\
'
.
'^'
XeyeTac
'
6<
\oy(p
'^.
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
91/132
109]
ARISTOTLE:
METAPRYSICA
75
el
ifKeova^oi^, aXk'
ev
ye
-
yap
TO
TL etvat
yevo
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
92/132
76 TEXTS FOR
LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY [l09
.
iT€p\
<
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
93/132
112]
ARISTOTLE:
METAPHYSICA
77
'
,
^
'
ev
-
^
jap
-
evva. I
,
Sia
,
aXkat
jeveaei^
XeyovTai
.
'
elalv
5
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
94/132
78
TEXTS
FOR LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[ll2
irotel
'
he
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
95/132
113]
ARISTOTLE
:
METAPHYSICA
79
ev
yap
)
ev
Trj
vXy.
'
eZSo?
ev
TaiaSe
6
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
96/132
80
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[ll3
-
ovre yeveaei re
elvai
'
jap
. 6
8>
.
Se
,
,
^
5
,
^
,
'
,
8
69
^.
0
,·
-
,
/
,
.
,
6
.
yap
-
yap 8
,
'
,
,
15
·
yap
.
,
.
}
114
metaphysica 16. 1040 b 5
'
,
2
(
yap
,
),
yrj
'
yap ,
'
6
[.1.
]
yva
ev.
'
-^^
25
\
'pyy
yyva
,
}.
'
,
,
'
yap
.
etaphysical
115
iiietapliysica
3.
1070a9
(
yap
)
,
)'
,
,
'
^
,
^.
35
^
,
,
('
yv
,
'
ya
),
'
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
97/132
116]
ARISTOTLE:
METAPHYSICA
,
A
81
etirep,
€7
.
Slo
8
<
6
€8
,
etirep
,
,
,
jap
,
.
^
,
'
9
09
.
ore
5
yap vjLaivec 6
,
vjieia
,
'
'^
,
l
he
,
.
eir
yap
ovSev
,
el
^^)
,
'
·
yap
.
oijhev
10
hel
ye
.
yap
jevva, 6
'
'
yap
6
X6yo
ya.
.
. .
',
yij
,
8,
,
6
,
5
6
6
,
,
.
16
mctaphysica
6.
1071
b 3
'
,
,
'
,
vy
.
2
yap
,
el
,
.
'
yvai
'
yap
.
^
yap
,
7]
'
^5
yap
.
'
,
.
,
vpyov
,
-
yap
evpylv.
'
so
,
,
el
'
,
'
;
-
yp
vpy,
.
'
,
'
·
yp
-
yp
33
.
8
vpya.
dvai
yp
,
y
G
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
98/132
82
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
ivepyeia
.
. .
.
'^
,
,
ivepyeia
€.
el
Srj
ael
[^],
Bel
ael pieveiv
evepyovv.
el
Se
eWe
yeveai^;
5
elvai, Set eivat
ael
evepyovv
·
?.
vy
evepyelv,
he
·
•
eeov
.
vy
'
ttoXlv
yp
eKelvo
re KaKeiv(p.
.
yap eKelvo
ael
'
€€,
'
ael
.
€.
Bet
ev
;
117
metaphysica
7.
1072al9
eirel
'
evBe-
eaL,
el
,
€
'
15
, ,
eVrt ael
-
evov
,
'
'
epy
.
e
.
eVrt KLvel. eirel
Be
Lvoevov
[codd
.
€^
2
voevov
KLvei,
ivepyeia
.
Kivei
Be
oiBe
6peov
Kivei
-
€.
.
i'ov
yp
avevov
,
Be
.
6peyea
Be
BoKei BoKei
opeyea'
25
yp
.
Be
vea,
Be
,
ivepyeiav.
'
Be
ev
'
€
yap
ev
ave,
'
€
.
3°
apeov
iv
*
ael
avaXoyov
.
'
eveKa
iv
,
Bape
.
€
yap
eveKa
,
€
€
'
''
Kivei Be
ipevov,
Be
35
Kivei.
el
^
vea,
ivBeea
exeiv.
el
%f
^
^»]
ivepyeui
iv,
€,
y ivBeea
exeiv
el
iTTel
'
i
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
99/132
118]
ARISTOTLE:
METAPHYSICA
83
6v,
ivepyeia 6v,
evhe^eTai
^
;.
yap
,
8e
-
e
.
]^
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
100/132
84
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[ll8
aTreipov
,
Soa
e^oL
',
'
^
^'.
^;
\-
'yap
^;
5
.
hrjXa
.
19
mctaphysica
8. 1073
a
14
Be
,
, Set
-
OaveLV,
?
,
TL
irepl
77]
ohhev
,
6
elirelv.
yap
'^^
yap
^
^
,
6
^,
'
9
'^^
'
,
.
'
.
yap
^
,
y
,
,
'
,
,
,
yap
25
·
'
),
vy
^
.
yap
,
,
vayaov
.
vayalov
^
yo,
-
.
,
35
,
.
pXoya'
yap
'
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
101/132
120]
ARISTOTLE:
METAPHYSICA
A
85
Trepl
ouSeyu,m?
, rj
re
^.
on
,
-
yap
.
^
,
^
s
^,
y
}
8
Xom-ov
8,
,
^,
,
.
. .
)
]
,
^
^.
1074
a
31
,
.
.
'
,
2
.
?
6
,
.
.
\
.
2
.
8
s
^,
.
.
3
120
metaphysica . 9.
1074 b
15
'
'
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
102/132
86
TEXTS FOR
LECTURES ON GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[l20
.
etre
yap
voet,
,
e^6t
el 6 eire voet,
'
(
yap
eaTL
6
eaTLv
)
,
),
etrj'
5
yap voelv hirap^eL. €TL Be etre
etre
eVrt,
voet
;
yap
€Tep6v
'
el eTepov
,
ael
.
TTOTepov
Bta^epet
tl oi)hev
voeiv
'
;
Bavoeia
irepl
;
OeioTaTOv
voel,
\
eaXX€L'
eh
'
yap
eaoX,
.
€
el
,
eXoyov eTriirovov
elvai
ve^e
€.
eirecTa
tl
et
-
15
Tepov 6
, €.
yap
voelv
7peL
'^
.
el
ebv
{
yap
evta
KpecTTOv
),
€
.
voel, elirep
,
€
voe
.
2
121
metapliysica
10.
1075al2
e7neleov Be
e^eL
ayaOov
,
TTOTepov
e'pevov
^
,
V^y^^j^'^W
'^
rep pea)
yap
ev
e
ed 6
pay, '
25
yap
'
eev
.
Be
,
'
,
'
^
e'^ei
e
eivai
daTepov
,
'
-
,
€
yap
ev
.
. . .
Be Xeyove
3
ael
^
^-
'
,
e'eoBB
(€
yap
eTepa
XXea
),
'
e oXea
7oXeeaL
.
ayaOov
-^^·
eh
€.
de
generatione
122
dc generatwue et
corruptione
1.
329a24
el
Be
et
corruptione
^^^
eival Tiva
,
'
el
e
evave,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
103/132
122]
ARISTOTLE:
DE
GENERATIONE
ET
CORRUPT
lONE
87
jLverai
^.
^
v
^
'
,
^
\
·
s
yap
\
,
,
.
'
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
104/132
88
TEXTS FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[l22
,
TO Se
8 •^
vypov,
Se
yrj
^
. .
.
'
7^
rerrapa
evo
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
105/132
124]
ARISTOTLE
:
DE
89
,
'yap
,
he
e^et
,
'
'
he
/^
hi
)
re
.
ee'^ov
€,
'
.
iirel
'
TOiovhe,
yap
'^,
€
·
yap
^
7oeevo
,
?
^oeevov
\.
avayKalov
'^
elvai
elho^
hve
€.
)
evTeXe^eia.
evTeXe^eia.
he
XeyeTai
hl',
€
€,
'
epelv.
avepov
'
iv yap
-^
'^
^ypVl^P^'^ ^
eVrtz^,
avaXoyov
'
\
iypyop
€,
6
'
e^eiv
ivepyeiv.
he
yevee
eirl
).
hio
^-^
evTeXe^eia hve
'.
he,
opyaviKOv.
opyava
he
,
,
,
he
irepiKapiriov
,
he
avaXoyov,
yap
eXKei
.
el
^;
eirl
·^
hei
Xeyeiv,
6pyavo.
2.
413
a
20
Xeyoev
^
hpa
^
^
.
.
. .
iirel
he
hi-^
XeyeTai,
,
Xyoev
[]
he
',
yap
,
he
yavov,
yLa
,
'
ya
eh6
Xyo
-
ya
heo,
7)
yao
{
yap
'
hav
vpya),
havooa
,
6yo
lho,
%
yap
Xyoev
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
106/132
90
TEXTS FOR LECTURES ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[l24
€7€,
69,
\,
,
\
^^,
-,
iirel
^,
evTeXe^eia
^,
'
.
5
125
de anima
3.
414a29
^.
rot?
^
^
,
aire
,
,
.
'
,
,
,
.
^
.
'yap
,
,
,
'
-,
8
15
,
,
,
jap
.
^
yap
'
yap
ypol
^
,^
'
'
'
-
,
yap
'^
)
.
.
.
.
' ,
'
^.
'^
Xoyv yap
'
Xoy
,
5
,
'
,
Xoy,
,
.
Xyo.
126
de
anima
6.
418
a
7
^
.
Xya
3
,
^
,
.
Xy
'
^
,
^
5
,
y
'.
.
'
y
^,
'
, .
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
107/132
127]
ARISTOTLE:
ANIMA
91
Ovv XejeTac
,
Be
^,
rjpe-
,
,
,
^·
yap
€
8,
\\
.
yap
}
'^
<
€
.
8e
XeyeTai
,
€
XevKov
,
·
-
s
yap
,
y
.
Se
^
;
,
<
.
e
sensu
7.
449
a 8
vy
ev
elvai
,
,
evo
.
*
y
ivipyeiav, yXo
,
yva
vpyav,
;
'payv
,
yap
yX
,
,
^,
.
,
,
yv
.
,
'
.
de
imientiite
3.
469
a 10
y
[sc.
]
2
yap
avayKaiov
.
27
dc
anima 7.
418
a
26
,
.
'
Xoyco
y
3
Xyov
.
yap
.
'
^
^
,
'
.
Be
vpyav
,
,
.
Be
Xey
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
108/132
92
TEXTS
FOR LECTURES OX GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[l27
,
,'
<
elirelv,
8
'.
8
'yap
17
^
'
fi
8
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
109/132
129]
ARISTOTLE
:
DE
93
Kov
'
jap
^^-
'
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
110/132
94
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[l29
voei ore
'
voel.
'^^
'
^
oirep
,
.
-
,
otl
,
6
^;
^
',
avev voel.
categoriae
130
categoriae
1.
1
a
1
,
9
<
,
6
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
111/132
133]
ARISTOTLE:
ORGANON
95
TLVo^ Xeyerai
iv
tlvl
,
olov
0
rk^
6
rU .
Sevrepai
XeyovTat,
iv
oh
eiheaiv
al
^
€
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
112/132
96
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[l34
134
analytica
prior
a
A
31.
46 a 31
on
'
Sia
yevcov
tl
,
yap
^
^'
yap
,
vXoy€aL
'
5
.
'
^
,
^^
yiveaOai
\
.
6 TL
^^
Woyaa
,
.
Siy
Woyaa
',
,
yva
6
Xoy,
'
yap
.
yap
''
,
>
13
,
'
,
'
,
0yov
8
,
.
'
,
,
^
.
,
-
2
.
XXoy
i)
,
vayaov,
vayaov,
'
'
^
XXoyaa.
135
analytica
2^
23.
68
b
8
25
-
,
'
XXoyol
8
yivovTai
'],
^
,
.
yap
XXoyo
layy.
€ayy
^ayy
XXoy-
XXoya-
,
,
35
yap
'ayy.
'
''
^,
*
^
[],
[qu.
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
113/132
136]
ARISTOTLE:
ORGANON
97
A
·
yap
[Pacius
,
codd.
]
.
'^
',
^^
.
el
virepTeiveL
,
'.
heheiKTao
yap
irpoTepov
hvo
^)
-
s
,
ayopo. hel Be
voelv
yeevov'
yap
e^ayy
.
'
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
114/132
98
TEXTS
FOR LECTURES
ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[l36
TO
eheiKwev
'
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
115/132
139]
ARISTOTLE:
ORGANON
99
^
Xoyov rr)?
,
Se
.
€
ylveTac
,
,
e/c
Se
)
'
yap
,
.
'
s
^,
irapa
,
ivrj
,
)
,
,
8
6,
.
,
^,
'
,
]
,
,
^
.
8
^
^
'
.
'
'
,
8
,
.
yap
8
,
Trj
''-^}
(
yap
15
'
,
'
,
,
'
)
,
1
,
.
;^
^
'ayy
yvpv
avayKaiov yap
20
.
8
8
,
,
,
8
8^
'8, 86
Xoy6,
'
,
8
yvo
,
'
'
-
^5
8
yvppa,
'
Xyo
€,
'
,
8
8
8
,
€
',
8-
]
8,
8'
.
3°
el
8
yvo
^
,
).
}
^
,
8
^
Tpya.
139
topica
1.
lOOalS
TTpay-iopica
8
'
86
XXoyd
8,
Xoyov
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
116/132
100
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[l39
,
6 ^· yap
-
'.
€
8
\\
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
117/132
141]
ARISTOTLE:
ORGANON
101
&
elvac
,
irepl
8.
\
-
Btaipeacv
yiveaOat,
jevo^
.
s
^
'
)
\yLV
'
,
'
^;
ylvovTac.
.
ap
,
;
^
'
;
.
,
;
[
^
;]
.
41
topica
5.
101b38
,
, is
/09,
.
'
9
6
.
.
.
.
'
,
'
-
^-
',
yap
,
ypaa
2
,
ypaa
,
.
yap
\y
'^
,
'
'}
'^
'.
.
.
.
yivo^
'
ayoovov.
25
ayopla
Xy,
,
.
yvov
yv
.
yap
30
yv'
-
'
yap
yvo
,
B\yvo
yv.
yvo
,
,
B\yvo
35
yv
.
,
yvo,'
Be
pya,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
118/132
102
TEXTS FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK PHILOSOPHY
[Ul
fcal
',
'^
'
'·
Be
Xev/cov, yap
ore
6€
Be
elvai.
ethica
142
ethica Nicomachea
.
1094al
6
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
119/132
^43]
ARISTOTLE:
ETHIC
A
lOB
.
irepl
€
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
120/132
104
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES ON GREEK
PHILOSOPHY [l43
TO
,
€V'
el
'
,
epjov
,
Be
'y^v^ff^
ivepyecav
\6yov,
'
€v
,
'
ev
5
'
el
'
,
yjrv^rj^
evepyeta yiveraL
apeTrjVy
el
nfkeiov
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
121/132
145]
ARISTOTLE:
ETHICA
105
.
. . .
iyyivovTat
,
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
122/132
,
106
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES
ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[l45
Xe^yofxev
.
lvat
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
123/132
147]
ARISTOTLE:
ETHIC
A
107
'^
'^
oyjnv,
·
eav
]
,
iv
,
e^i?
<
.
eirl
,
6
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
124/132
108
TEXTS
FOR
LECTURES ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[l47
3.
1174
a 8
ort
ovre
6
,
8\
elvai.
4.
Il74b31
reXeLOL
ivepyeiav
^
',
'
?
eirt'yivop.evov
,
5
9
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
125/132
148]
ARISTOTLE:
ETHIC
A
109
reXeia
,
;
riXeiov
ovSev
yap
areXe?
iart
'.
6
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
126/132
110 TEXTS FOR LECTURES
ON
GREEK
PHILOSOPHY
[l48
ye
^
el
ivhe^erat
avev
e'/cro?
elvai-
yap
ev
rfj
€\ €
'
,
Se yrj^
5
TTpcLTTeiv
'
yap
epv
rt?
7€
€.
149
etJiica Nicomachea
9.
Il79b20
yiveaOao
'
ayadov^
,
€
,
'
,
^}.
/c '
',
\
''
6 Be \yo
'^
ev
',
Bet irpoBLeLpyaa0ai
WeaL
^
^
,
yrjv
-
.
yap
15
Xyo
6
'
;
.
'^
,
pyov
^
'.
'
yy
2
'
'
yap
^
,
.
-
'
ap
yvva. . . .
25
^
^
avayKalov,
,
'
6 avayKaaTCKrjv
e^et
,
Xyo
.
10.
1181 b
12
-
3
,
^^
, ,
.
olitica
150
politiccc
()
3.
1325bl4
'
XyaL
7payav
,
35
KOLvrj
'
.
avayKaiov
,
,
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
127/132
150]
ARISTOTLE: ETHIC
A,
POLITICA
111
'
eic
,
-
<
^' yap
,
€
·
'
^.
'
5
^
*
,
)'
^'
yap
-
ap
,
^
'
o-^oXy
yap
^
6
,
.
'
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
128/132
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
129/132
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
130/132
'J
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
131/132
GETTY
RESEARCH
INSTITUTE
-
8/17/2019 Text to Greek Philosophy
132/132