Download - Sustainable Tourism Planning for Lofoten
27 February 2019 Ben Martin Principal, HKS Advisory
Sustainable Tourism Planning for Lofoten
Introduction
Sustainable tourism development requires planning and control.
Page 2
March 11, 2019
Who is the Planning Authority for the South Pole?
Itinerary: South Pole ExplorerDeparting: 29 Dec 2019Duration: 6 nightsPrice: $60,000 (per person)Activity Level: ModerateProvider: Antarctic Logistics & Expeditions LLC
Introduction Page 3
March 11, 2019
• Tourism’s Unique Characteristics?
• Tourism Will Increase
• Pros & Cons of Tourism Growth
• How Destinations Evolve Over Time?
• How to Manage Demand Growth?
• What is “Carrying Capacity”
• Sustainability Matters
• Tactical Initiatives for Lofoten
• Closing Remarks
On 19 May 2012234 climbers made an Everest summitattempt.
Jan 2019:China restricts Everest climbers from thenorth by one-third, as part of clean-upinitiative.
Without planning and control we destroy the thing that we love.
Introduction Page 4
March 11, 2019
Ben Martin, PrincipalHKS Advisory
• Degree in Recreation & Tourism Management
• Masters in Tourism Management
• Joined ERA in 1995
• ERA joined AECOM in 2009
• AECOM to HKS in 2018
• 23 years in Tourism Consultancy
Tourism’s Unique Characteristics
Tourism development impacts the whole community.
Page 5
March 11, 2019
A hugely complex organism…..
Employing 1 in 10 Globally
Involving a multiple stakeholders:
• Tourists• Host Population• Tourism Enterprises (locally)• Tour Operators (internationally)• Public Sector & Government
Tourism Will Increase
Do you want to encourage and/or control increased tourism visitation to Lofoten?
Page 6
March 11, 2019
• International tourism is booming
• Strongest growth from Asia
• More visitors will come to Lofoten
• Are we prepared for them?
1950 2018 Total Increase CAGR
Global Population 2,256,000,000 7,700,000,000 201% 1.6%
Global Tourism 25,000,000 1,400,000,000 5,500% 6.1%
Pros & Cons of Tourism Growth
The positive impacts are proven, but we must be conscious of the challenges that come with tourism growth.
Page 7
March 11, 2019
The Pros The Cons
Economic Diversification Sensitive Economic Sector
Direct Foreign Investment Pressure on Infrastructure
High Yielding Investment Seasonality of Demand
Job Creation Character of Employment
Safeguarding Assets Pressure on Assets
Promote Understanding Degradation of Community
Build Local/National Pride Threats to Local Culture
Destinations Evolve Over Time
Lofoten is on the ‘international tourism radar’. Word of mouth will help to drive increased demand.
Page 8
March 11, 2019
Source: Butler, R.W. (1980)
Where is Lofoten today?
A developing destination needsto plan for maturity and stagnation.
What is the ‘CAPACITY’ of yourcore ‘elements’
• Natural Environment
• Accommodation Stock
• Community
• Infrastructure
Carrying Capacity & Sustainability
Pressure will be felt most ‘keenly’ at peak months of the year (these are the ‘pinch points’).
Page 9
March 11, 2019
Sustainable Destination
Tourism Carrying Capacity is:The maximum number of peoplethat may visit a tourist destinationat the same time, withoutcausing destruction ofthe physical, economicand social environmentand an unacceptabledecrease in thequality of visitors’satisfaction.
World Tourism Organisation
Carrying Capacity & Sustainability
How ‘crowded’ would you like Lofoten to become? What is the visitor management plan for the peak weeks?
Page 10
March 11, 2019
Different markets have different definitions for‘over crowded’
Carrying Capacity & Sustainability
It is possible to be ‘scientific’ about Capacity Management.
Page 11
March 11, 2019
Source: Manning, R. 2001
There is level of demand beyond which the ‘authenticity’ and quality of the tourism offer become degraded.
You risk destroying the Asset & Appeal
Social Sustainability
Your acceptance of tourism inflows is inevitably associated with the nature of your employment.
Page 12
March 11, 2019
Are you missing out on the biggest asset
a destination has to offer – Local People
Tourists want to feel welcome.
“Turismen skal være til berikelse for befolkningen, og ikke en belastning.” Strategiplan Lofoten Som Reisemål 2017 - 2022
Environmental Sustainability
Tourists are generally more ‘aware’ of ‘Ecotourism Principles’ but often need encouragement.
Page 13
March 11, 2019
“The ability of the
environment to continue to function properly indefinitely.”
“Living off nature’s Income
rather than its Capital.”
Economic Sustainability
This can be a real challenge in destinations where tourists are much wealthier than local residents.
Page 14
March 11, 2019
The level of economic change that is sustainable, where the destination is able to accommodate
tourist functions without the loss of local activities, facilities and services for local people.
House Price Inflation Over Time
Ho
use
Pri
ces
Meaningful Retail Accessible Dining
Managing Growth: Spreading Demand
Real imagination and creativity is required to really drive increases in low-season and shoulder-season demand.
Page 15
March 11, 2019
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Nordland Sardinia Iceland
Manage the Peaks
Build the Shoulders
Seasonality is dictated by climate, the social scheduling of our society, accessibility or simply habit
Build capacity, manage the peaks and build up the troughs:
• Festivals and events
• MICE tourism
• Adventure tourism
• Domestic tourism
Managing Growth: Mix Up Your Markets
Tourism Demand comprises a myriad of niche markets each with its own desires and requirements.
Page 16
March 11, 2019
• Different Seasonal Peaks
• Spreads Demand Risk
• Resident Demand Underpins Tourism
• Consider Compatibility of Guests
Managing Growth: Control Access
Controlling access may feel like a last resort, but it can strengthen ‘desirability’ (increasing perceived value).
Page 17
March 11, 2019
Advanced Purchase or Lottery for Access Permits
Requires Enforcement
Managing Growth: Expand Capacity
Planning control can play a vital role in ensure that expansions in ‘supply’ align with you Strategic Vision.
Page 18
March 11, 2019
The Exceptional Is Achievable in Sensitive Environments (no need to compromise standards)
Managing Growth: Value Scarcity
Price is already a determining factor for foreign nationals considering a holiday in Norway.
Page 19
March 11, 2019
Do you measuregrowth in terms ofvolume or value?
Which slice of themarket pyramid willyou target?
Managing Growth: People Matter
“People” have to be at the heart of all strategic tourism planning considerations. They’re at the heart of it all.
Page 20
March 11, 2019
The Biggest Challenge for a Strengthening Market
• This is a People Business
• As the sector grows how will you staff your businesses?
• Find staff / train staff / retain staff......
• The challenge of seasonality
Managing Growth: Focus & Dispersal Page 21
March 11, 2019
Gateway Hub (airport, station, road junction) – tourists enter system here
“Must See” Primary Asset – tourist will want to see this (respond to this)
Secondary Asset – tourists may not even know about this
Sensitive Area – keep tourist impact to a minimum
Primary Tourist Route
Secondary Tourist Routes (different lengths for different markets)
In the Planned Approach, you influence:• Where tourists travel to• What they travel in• Where they stop and/or stay• What they do
Focus tourism activity in gateway locations and places designed to cope with demand.
Disperse tourists within a region so that all can share the economic and employment benefits and you lessen the impact on any one specific location
‘En fremtidig forvaltning av Lofoten må også ivareta steder som ikke defineres som turiststeder.’ (Strategiplan Lofoten Som Reisemål 2017 – 2022)
Use the geography of the destination as a central pillar to the strategy for management growth.
Managing Growth: Focus & Dispersal Page 22
March 11, 2019
Mapping the investment priorities, zones for protection and infrastructure corridors provides focus.
Managing Growth: Scenic Routes Page 23
March 11, 2019
Golden Triangle (Major Attractions)
• Route between major sites of Delhi, Agra, Jaipur – features several UNESCO World Heritage Sites
• Full circuit is over 700km
• Domestic tourism extremely important (e.g. TajMahal receives around 2.5 million visitors per year, of which 200,000 international)
Focus on the Journey or the Destinations?
Ring of Kerry (Coastal Scenery)
• 170 km circular route, typically starting and finishing in Killarney
• Spectacular coastal views
• Approx 2 million tourist visitors to SW Ireland (Co Cork and Kerry)Focus on the
Journey
Focus on theDestinations
“Signage is Power” – GPS may challenge this to some degree, but people love to be lead.
Managing Growth: Public Sector Toolkit
There is much that the Public Sector can do, but some measures may require Central Government support.
Page 24
March 11, 2019
The Tool Kit
Tax Incentives
Tax Deterrents
Gifting Land
Infrastructure Investments
Regional Masterplanning
Policy Planning
Grants & Subsidies
Education & Training
Destination Marketing
Lobbying Government
Public Services
Security
Managing Growth: Destination Marketing
TripAdvisor (et al) my be growing in influence, but this is still your ‘Shop Window’ to the world.
Page 25
March 11, 2019
• Every business stands or falls
on the reputation of the destination
• Understand the hierarchy of brand
awareness
• Need to develop Lofoten’s
international brand position
• Interaction with the Ministry of Tourism
• Collaboration with Private Sector
• Who do you want to attract?
• What messages will appeal to
these markets?
• Evolve a coordinated
Marketing Strategy
Managing Growth: Access, Access, Access
Ultimately, this is where you control ‘visitor flows’ – public/private collaboration starts here.
Page 26
March 11, 2019
The Cannula for Tourism(also known as)....
• Airport• Landing Strip• Road• Bridge• Railway• Boat Transfer• Cruise Terminal• Hiking/Biking • Train
What Next for Lofoten: Be Strategic & Save Money
Is there consensus about where Lofoten wants to go over the next decade?
Page 27
March 11, 2019
Where Are We Now?(Audit and Assessment)
Where Are Going?(Vision)
How Are We Going to Get There?(Strategic Planning)
Failing to Plan is Planning to Fail
‘Vekst represen-terer muligheter, men forutsetter en overordnet strategi for å unngå negative effekter.’ (Strategiplan Lofoten Som Reisemål 2017 – 2022)
What Next for Lofoten: Refine the Plan?
It may be time to push strategic tourism planning further up the political and social agenda.
Page 28
March 11, 2019
Is there a requirement to establish or refine the Tourism Framework Plan for Lofoten?
• Agree Vision – What do we want to be?
• Where are We Today?• Understand Market• Review Assets• Engage with Stakeholders
• Where Are We Going?• Consider Options• Understand Realistic Market Opportunity• Evolve Proposed Plan• Engage with Stakeholders• Agree Plan & Direction
• Establish Action Plan• Engage with Stakeholders• Implement Plan in Logical Phases
This is anIterative Process
(markets change, keep plan “alive)
What Next for Lofoten: What Assets and Where?
Use the local geography to your advantage and take control of the flows (properly fund this effort).
Page 29
March 11, 2019
1. Define your assetsi. Attractionsii. Activitiesiii. Accommodationiv. Support Facilitiesv. Preservation Zones
2. Location of your assets
3. Consider Carrying Capacity
4. Plan Your Visitor Flow
We only stop where we can park!
What Next for Lofoten: Collaboration is Key
Steering Committees, Advisory Boards, Stakeholder & Focus Groups will all have a role to play.
Page 30
March 11, 2019
The winning crew works together in harmony….Successful Tourism Development Requires Public / Private Collaboration
(Recognise that the Private Sector will be Better at Some Things)
Public Sector Private Sector
Highways
Golf Courses
AirportsSignage
Marinas
Residential
Hotels
DestinationMarketing
Emergency Services
National Parks
Ports
Waterparks
Communication
Collaboration
Consensus Me
asu
rem
en
t
Action
Closing Remarks: Principles for A Successful Destination Page 31
March 11, 2019
• People Matter
• Value Scarcity
• Mix Your Markets
• Collaboration is Key
• Access, Access, Access
• Tourism is a Growth Sector
• Don’t Wait – Others are Moving Forward
• Planning = Better for Tourists/Locals/Environment
• Be Proactive not Reactive (be strategic & save money)
• Above All - Safeguard the Future of the Assets Themselves
Travel Is The OnlyThing You Buy
That Makes You Richer(Lofoten Has So Much to Offer)
Lofoten er en av Norges spydspisser innenfor reiseliv.....(Strategiplan Lofoten Som Reisemål 2017 – 2022)
27 February 2019 Ben Martin Principal, HKS Advisory
Sustainable Tourism Planning for Lofoten
Questions & Answers