Strengthening Michigan’s Manufacturing Workplaces:Early Warning and Layoff Aversion
Michigan Economic Dislocation SummitJune 20, 2006
Why We’re Here: Saving and Creat ing GOOD JOBS
In this Presentat ion
Toward the Next Generation of Manufacturing Jobs
Overview of SEWN
Toward a Regional Early Warning Network
Key Steps to Early Warning/ Layoff Aversion
Opening the Door—Analysis and Assessment
Saving the House—Aversion Response
The Next Generat ion of Manufacturing
Tennessee’s Industria l Heritage
America’s Manufacturing Jobs Plummeting
U.S. Manufacturing Employment, January 1991-March 2005*
14.0
14.5
15.0
15.5
16.0
16.5
17.0
17.5
18.0
Jan-
91
Jan-
92
Jan-
93
Jan-
94
Jan-
95
Jan-
96
Jan-
97
Jan-
98
Jan-
99
Jan-
00
Jan-
01
Jan-
02
Jan-
03
Jan-
04
Jan-
05
Millio
ns o
f Jo
bs
* Data Seasonally AdjustedSource: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
Manufacturing Matters
a. Productivity leader b. 2/ 3 of all R&D investmentc. Primary source of innovationd. Leading purchaser of new technologye. Leading purchaser of financial and
technical servicesf. Leader in new work org and processesg. Opportunity: economic ladder with rungs
at all levels
There is a Role for State Government to Play
– Bring together stakeholders—manufacturing associations, labor, chambers, political leaders—to pressure for strategic policies
– Push for the creation of manufacturing focus and strategic capacity within state government
– Integrate existing and new state programs into an overall strategy
There is a Role for State Government to Play
• Advocacy– for National Trade Policy Changes
• Short-term-helping workers survive • Business retention assistance• Long-term transition
– to Globally Competitive Enterprises
• State procurement• State leadership in new renewable
energy portfolio, other key resources– that supports domestic growth
The “Next Generat ion” of Manufacturing Jobs...
Governor’s Office Prioritized• Balanced trade policies
– Trade Law Compliance Office
• Retention partnerships• New industry consortia • Accessible and flexible capital
– Increased capital loan funding
• Growth strategies– New funding for “top-line”, marketing
• Workforce training– Increased incumbent worker training
Early Warning and Layoff Aversion
Early warning is a multi-stakeholder approach to identifying companies-at-risk early enough to be able to mount an effective layoff aversion strategy.
Layoff Aversion focuses on saving jobs, putting people back to work, and revitalizing industrial communities.
An Overview of SVA’sSEWN Netw ork
The SVA--a Regional Authority
Origin: Formed by mayors and legislators, small businesses, and working families in the 1980s in the Pittsburgh-Mon Valley, during the downturn of the steel industry.
Structure: The SVA is a twelve-member municipal authority, with statewide powers and programs. The SVA operates HQ office in Pittsburgh area and a new office in Harrisburg. The SVA manages projects nationally.
Programs: Jobs retention, private capital investment network, economic policy, community development.
What is SEWN?
Sponsored by PA Department of Labor and I ndustry.
Has worked with over 450 manufacturers, including steel, metals, plastics, electrical, food processing, etc.
Operates in 49 counties in Pennsylvania.
The SEWN Netw ork
SEWN Built a “Regional Retention Team” to monitor industries:
Regional Governor’s OfficesRegional Rapid Response Offices Workforce I nvestment Boards (WI Bs)City/ county development groups ( I DC’s/ I DA’s) Modernization programs ( I RCs and BFs) ;Chambers and industry associationsUnions, labor councils, L/ M groupsBanks, private investment groups, Freelance managers and consultantsI ndustry policy groups
SEWN Geographic Response
SEWN Industry Sectors
SEWN Cases by Segment
71
62
38 36
27 26 2520 20
17 17 16 1510 8 7 5 4
1
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80M
eta
l Fa
bri
ca
tion
, T
oo
l & D
ie,
We
ldin
g
Pro
ce
ss
ing
-Ro
llin
g M
ills
, F
ou
nd
rie
s &
Fo
rgin
gs
, e
tc.
Ind
us
tria
l Eq
uip
me
nt,
Co
ntr
ols
&In
str
um
en
tatio
n
Co
ns
um
er
Pro
du
cts
-NE
C
Pla
stic
s,
Re
sin
s &
Ru
bb
er
Fo
od
, B
ev
era
ge
s &
Ag
ric
ultu
ral
Gla
ss
& C
era
mic
s
Co
ns
tru
ctio
n M
ate
ria
ls &
Pro
du
cts
Tra
ns
po
rta
tion
& R
ela
ted
Eq
uip
me
nt
Pri
ntin
g,
Pa
ck
ag
ing
& P
ub
lish
ing
Fu
rnitu
re &
Sh
elv
ing
Tu
bu
lar
Pro
du
cts
, P
ipe
s a
nd
Fitt
ing
s
Se
rvic
e
Pe
tro
leu
m &
Ch
em
ica
ls
Pri
ma
ry M
eta
l
Wo
od
, L
um
be
r &
Pa
pe
r
Min
ing
Lo
gis
tics
& D
istr
ibu
tion
Me
dic
al,
Su
rgic
al &
Sc
ien
tific
Ins
tru
me
nts
2005-2006
Total
1. Tow ard a Regional Early Warning Netw ork
Tools for Early Warning
The SVA is working with the PA DLI to fashion a new information data system that will benchmark firms with inordinate layoffs, UI claims filing, etc., against the trends of their industry clusters.
SEWN utilizes the Layoff Aversion Guidebook that was prepared for the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) by the SVA. The Guidebook provides a compendium of layoff aversion strategies for communities.
Linkages to New Capita l Sources
The SEWN Network provides links to an SVA-Heartland I nvestment “Deal Flow”
Network, focused on:
Coordination of existing pension-capitalized private capital funds, with an estimated $8-10 billion in assets.
Collaboration with state development and loan programs and in-state investment groups, to explore joint investment opportunities.
Early Warning Analysis and Assessment--Early Warning Monitoring
--Pre-feasibility of Companies-in-Stress
Layoff Aversion Response--Core Retent ion Steps--Sectoral/Cluster Strategies--Workplace Change and Training
2. Key Steps to Early Warning/Layoff Aversion
Exploring Layoff Alternat ives
Corporate conglomerates frequently close or sell plants or facilities that may be profitable, but not profitable enough. They may sell or close operations that no longer meet their core business application or that are viewed as excess capacity to their overall operations.
Over the past 25 years, there have been hundreds of examples of companies that were scheduled for closing and where various interest groups have organized to rescue the business operation.
What are the Alternat ives?
Financial restructuring
Cost reviews
Conversion to new products
I ncumbent worker training, work-sharing
Bringing in new management
Labor-management cooperation
Succession planning
Employee buyouts
Company buyouts
Modernization and technology upgrades
Best Pract ice Models
Best practice models from around the country do several things
I ntegrate economic and workforce development communities, and empower labor, management and community stakeholders.
Share timely informational sources, set high standards for turnaround response time and result, and utilize flexible strategies, tactics and tools
Keys to Analysis/Response
Early Warning Monitoring: Utilizing industry and labor market systems and networks to monitor and predict plantclosures in order to implement response andprevention strategies.
Providing pre-feasibility assessments todetermine continued financial and marketviability of business or facility.
I mplementing broad retention strategies andservices to maintain and strengthenindustries.
Developing urban and rural models targetingindustrial sectors in geographic areas.
Supporting high-performance workplaces to:• improve performance and • improve working conditions, stabilize
employment• promote incumbent worker training and
labor-management cooperation, etc.
Assessment:
Core Retention Steps:
Sectoral/ Cluster Strategies:
Workplace Change andTraining:
3. Opening the Door—What Happened?
Early Warning Analysis
Pre-feasibility/ Viability Assessments
What Are Early Warning Sources?
Labor Market I nfo (declining/ underperforming sectors) and layoff data from unemployment filings, showing patterns.
WARN notice alerts of mass layoffs or plant closures, and Trade Act notices.
Public loan defaults, mirrored by bank/ financing problems.
Dun and Bradstreet (D&B) reports of stressed firms and industries.
Utility company reports of usage drops, or customer and supplier knowledge.
Labor-management committees foresee potential problems.
Business visitation and calling programs.
Local elected leaders.
Early Warning Sources
Primary Sources Secondary Sources
UC claim filing notice
Loan delinquencies
Bankruptcies
WARN notifications
Direct Referrals
– Unions, workers
– L&I , DCED, GAT
– Managers, Owners
– Local Dev. Groups
– Elected leaders
– Vendors, Suppliers
Dun and Bradstreet
Public media
Business surveys
Business workshops
Industry cluster groups
Industry sector trend reports
Company annual reports
Industry “bellwether indicators”
WARN as Start ing Point
• Through the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act (WARN), employers must give local Chief Elected Officials, the State Rapid Response Dislocated Worker Unit, and workers, and their representative, advance notice of a plant closing or mass layoff.
Thus, an informal “network” of informational channels already exists. The logical network of early warning “ informants” include states, local mayors and council members, local unions, civic and religious institutions, chambers, and other institutions.
Example of Early Warning Collaborat ion
Dun and Bradstreet provides, for a cost, a stressed company list--companies that can be selected by industry, that have high financial stress scores. I t is a strong predictive tool.
The SEWN Network discreetly shares data with the SW PA BREP county coordinators to determine if a special visit or coordinated business call should be arranged.
We developed a protocol so that the BREP coordinators will share the results of confidential calls, and a joint action plan will be developed if the firm is at-risk of closing.
Example of Early Warning Collaborat ion
The SEWN Network has worked closely with the Rapid Response Offices, and receives copies of WARN notices, trade petitions, etc.
We developed a protocol so that SEWN staff can monitor WARN cases or other closure and mass layoff notices. I f there are cases to investigate for potential layoff aversion, the staff will work with the RR office to provide introductions to managers, workers.
The SEWN staff will share the results of any contacts with the company, so that a duel plan--assisting dislocated workers, yet exploring the alternatives--can move forward.
Pre-feasibility Studies
An assessment of a company to determine if it could be operated viably and profitability. I t looks at options for a company or group, including the workers, to purchase or re-organize a plant or company and continue in operation.
I t examines: organizational structure, market, operations/manufacturing equipment, financial condition/new investment requirements, legal issues, conclusions and methodology.
Cost--between $5,000 and $20,000 per company--depending on the size, accessibility of information, and the need for specialized consultant assistance.
4. Saving the House—Layoff Aversion/Response
Core Retention StepsSectoral/ Cluster StrategiesWorkplace Change and Training
Responsible Layoff Aversion
The goal of layoff aversion is to anchor existing firms where they currently conduct operations. I n its most basic form, this business retention approach consists of interventions…to influence the location decisions of business firms in that locale. I t is not enough to salvage equipment or real estate…good job retention programs work to retain the skilled workforce and efficient managers. ( from "Markets, Economic Development and Business Retention," 1996)
Core Retent ion Steps
SEWN’s Approach…
• Financial Restructuring
• Company Buyouts
• Business Continuity
• Operations and Cost Management
Sectoral/Cluster Strategies
Cluster projects focus on groups of companies within an industry cluster.
Sectoral strategies start with a geographic analysis, identified key sectors, and organized services around those sectors.
Pennsylvania DLI is sponsoring Manufacturing Workforce Partnerships to align resources in areas such as workforce development, technology deployment and technical assistance.
Workplace Change and Training
• Workplace change and training models include modernization skills upgrading and cross-training, “high performance” workplaces, and “ learning”workplaces.
By addressing the training needs and knowledge practices of workers, the workplace change approach does not just provide training on specific skills and techniques of the job or production.
Rather, it seeks out strategies to promote greater cooperation between management and workers in production techniques as firms attempt to re-direct operations or upgrade their production capabilit ies.
Workplace Change and Training
“New Works Systems”: worker participation and information-sharing
“Open-book management” provides training for workers on how to understand the company’s financial statements and general trends.
Employee ownership training teaches workers to think about the overall success of the firm, and provides governance structures to ensure their voice is heard.
“Lead mentor training” and self-directed work teams help workers to train themselves, and adapt to changes.
High performance workplaces– front-line workers receive training, incentives and job security to participate in decisions that alter organizational routines.
Early Warning and Layoff Aversion provide new tools to the State to bolster manufacturing w orkplaces, build a stakeholder approach, and re-posit ion the state’s jobs foundat ions for new industries and grow th.
Presented by the Steel Valley Authority