Room for improvement?Experiences of health and social care services among older people from minority ethnic groups
Jo Moriarty
King’s College London
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 2
Outline
What are the issues?These will be familiar!
Inequalities in old age
Evidence on services
Making improvements
Background
Race Equality Foundation promotes race equality in social support and social care http://www.reu.org.uk
Funded to develop a national resource to help improve the quality of health and housing provision to black and minority ethnic communities
Includes series of briefing papers containing research evidence, good practice tips, resources, and key messages for practice
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 3
Presentation uses….
Asked to do briefing paper on health and social care experiences on black and minority ethnic older people from http://www.reu.org.uk/health/files/health-brief9.pdfCurrently have 13 briefing papers on health and 12 on housingPresentation today is overview of topic, not a single research project
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 4
Presentation uses (2)
Evidence from ESRC project on social support and quality of life among older people from different ethnic groupsWork for the former Healthcare Commission
Asked to talk to BME communities as part of a wider review of the National Service Framework for Older People
Practice guide for Social Care Institute of Excellence (SCIE) on user participationWork with SCIE on depression and BME peopleOther literature
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 5
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 6
Why this topic is important (1)
Increase in older population from minority ethnic groups
Projections influenced by migration history and patterns of settlement
Currently 30 per cent people aged 65 and over in Brent and 20 per cent Lambeth and Hackney (Evandrou, 2000) are from BME communities
And in Bristol?Council’s Improving the Quality of Life of Older People in Bristol Equalities Impact Assessment
BME community in Bristol lower than average overall but very concentrated in certain areasCurrently younger than average but likely to change
Why this topic is important (2)
UK (especially England) is becoming increasingly ethnic diverse
Term ‘super diverse’ is increasingly used
Reflected in work for Healthcare Commission (now CQC)
Focus groups with older people from Yemeni, Somali, Bosnian, and Vietnamese backgrounds
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 7
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 8
Impact of ageing on ethnic inequalities
Age accentuates health inequalitiesBritish Household Panel Survey data show that inequalities in self assessed health INCREASE with age (Sacker et al 2005)
May experience ageing process at younger age (Ebrahim et al, 1991)
Prevalence of limiting longstanding illnessHigher among Irish, Black Caribbean, Indian, Pakistani and Bangladeshi communities
Lower among Chinese (Evandrou, 2000)
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 9
Ageing and health inequalities
Prevalence (frequency) of some age related health problems diseases varies
Coronary heart disease
Diabetes
(Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology, 2007)
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 10
Inequalities in access to services
Inequalities in access to health careOver represented in primary care
Under represented in secondary services (Ascheson, 1997)
Inequalities in reports of treatmentPatient surveys suggest older people from BME communities are more likely to report receiving poor care (Healthcare Commission, 2006)
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 11
Recognised in policy documents
Legislation and policy guidance recognises differences in treatmentExamples include
Race Relations Amendment Act 2000National Service Framework for Older People (2001)New Single Equality Bill (2009)
Public Sector Equality Duty
Dementia strategy (2009)
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 12
But why don’t we know more? (1)
Still neglected issue in mainstream research
Just eight per cent of articles in two old age psychiatry journals included people form a minority ethnic group (Shah et al, 2008)
Presents methodological challengesComplexities of separating out multiple factors
e.g. socio-economic status and ageing
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 13
But why don’t we know more? (2)
Studies of older people still have low numbers of older people from minority ethnic groups
e.g. English Longitudinal Study of Ageing
Studies may fail to report differences by age
e.g. studies of depression and ethnicity
But we do know some things….
Differences in access to information
Knowledge and attitudes of staff
Provision of culturally sensitive services
Need to put this into action!'Let's move on': Black and minority ethnic older people's views on research findings (Butt and O’Neill, 2004)
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 14
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 15
Differences in access to information
Access to information about health and social care services is always variableStudies have shown that BME people are more likely to report they lacked information (Lindesay et al, 1997, Butt and O’Neill 2004)
Specific issues
Lack of access to materials in translation
Content of leaflets may not be relevant
Shortage of good quality interpreting services
Reliance on other family members(Manthorpe et al, 2009)
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 16
Dementia
Research has shown that knowledge about dementia is less among Asian and Black Caribbean communities
(Adamson, 2001, 2005, Bowes and Wilkinson, 2003)
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 17
Image from Dementia Strategy
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 18
Consequences are….
May contribute to poorer outcomes
Later access to dementia servicesPrevents benefits of early intervention
Can lead to increased carer stress (Bowes and Wilkinson, 2003)
Dementia strategy
Improving access to information (1)
There are many ways in which improvements can be made
Why reinvent the wheel?Costs of preparing and translating leaflets are high
But there are many resources that exist already
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 19
Resources may already existAlzheimer Scotland has a set of translated leaflets on dementia which can be downloaded free from their website
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 20
Improving access to information (2)
Different media formats may work better
DVD may work better than leaflets for some communities, especially if they are not literate in their own language
Consider content – using simple language and avoiding jargon
SCIE guide – use of ‘jargon busters’ from community groups
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 21
Improving access to information (3)
Health and social care services are making increasing use of advice lines
May actually INCREASE inequalities“There is lack of information in Gujarati on benefits, social and health care services to this particular over-50s women’s group. The women say that there is no system where they can just pick up the phone and get help from services.”
– (Manthorpe et al, 2009)
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 22
Also remember that…
Access to information variesHistory of migration meant many older people worked in health and social care
Older Black Caribbean women had better levels of knowledge (Moriarty and Butt, 2004)Experience of member of advisory group at Carers’ Group very negative
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 23
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 24
What role do our expectations play?
Differing expectations may influence help we seek/expect (Chahal and Temple, 2005)
Existence of stigma?
Preferences for different types of treatment?
Lack of cross cultural studies in this area
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 25
Attitudes of professionals
Professionals may also create barriers to accessing and using services
Stereotyped expectations about extent of family support (Katbamna et al, 2004)
‘They look after their own’ classic phrase
Existence of racism (Butt and O’Neill, 2004)
Unspoken issue (Culley, 2006)
Diversity among workforce
Workforce may not share same cultural backgrounds
Image from Simon Rawle’s photographs taken for International Migrant Workers’ day for UNISON http://www.unison.org.uk/file/MWphotoexhib.pdf
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 26
Katrzyna LichwalaPoland
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 27
Increasing professionals’ knowledge
Consider content of professional qualifying programmes
Role of guidelines for measuring ‘cultural competence’ as in the US?
Training across the workforceAccess to training among (non professionally qualified) care workforce
Emphasising that it is an important component of the work…
2006 Social Work recruitment campaign featured older Black Caribbean man
(But celebrity culture in 2009!)
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 28
Making services more accessible
‘Link workers’ can improve experiences of GP services, hospital appointments
Role of community groups providing advocacy and outreach
(Moriarty & Butt, 2004, Manthorpe et al, 2009)
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 29
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 30
However….
Relationships with ‘link’ people and/interpreters may be ambivalent (Chau, 2007)
Benefits of improving workforce diversity
Importance of recruiting bilingual workers
‘El Portal’
Providing culturally specific services
Role of culturally specific services?
Most often for day care/lunch clubs
Sometimes for home care
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 31
Image from Age Concern Lewisham and Southwark Black Elders Mental Health Day Centre
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 32
However….
How can we bring culturally sensitive services into the mainstream?
Issues about funding (Butt and Mirza, 1996)
Groups may be in competition with each other (Bowes, 2006)
Making mainstream services more culturally sensitive
In addition to using knowledge of workforce….
Learn from expertise of people using services
Dietary advice from Black Caribbeans (Brown et al. 2007)
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 33
Increasing public engagement
Different methods of consultation are needed for different communities
Events versus surveys may get better response
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 34
Photograph from ‘Listening event’ for Healthcare Commission
New challenges?
Increasing diversityPresentation for Making Research Count
London borough high proportion of bilingual/bicultural workers – challenges of new languages
Effects of personalisation?Will it improve services or increase inequalities?
20/04/23 Age Concern Bristol/Brunelcare Research Forum 35