Download - Reputation and higher education
OCTOBER 1, 2014 Michael Stopford
Scope1. Competitive landscape
2. Reputation management – process and levers
3. Communications – fizz and focus
Scope1. Competitive landscape
2. Reputation management – process and levers
3. Communications – fizz and focus
In today’s competitive landscape a university has to be
as intentional in protecting, safeguarding, enhancing
and promoting its reputation as any corporation.
You face global competition just as multinational
corporations do. You compete for the best students,
the best faculty, the best managers: globally, not just in
your cities, your regions, your countries.
Global Competition
Today’s higher education landscape is global
• The competition is global
• The opportunity is global
International student recruitment: our young friends in Guangzhou
and Shanghai now have a lot more choices. They can go to Michigan
or Chicago, Manchester or Warwick, Melbourne or Adelaide or
Toronto – or stay at home in one of their new campuses.
Rankings: Impact
Corporate Reputation Rankings
Fortune:
World's 50 Most
Admired Companies
Harris
Interactive/WSJ:
Reputation Quotient
Business Ethics
Magazine/CRO:
100 Best Corporate
Citizens
Reputation Institute:
RepTrak Pulse
United States
Reputation
Institute: Global
RepTrak Pulse
Key Attributes
1: Innovation
2: Leadership/
Management
3: Community
Responsibility
4: Environmental
Responsibility
5: Quality
Products/Processes
6: Financial
Performance
7: Workplace
8: Good Governance
Covered Not Covered
University Reputation Rankings
Outcomes…
how “schools ranked highly received increased visibility and prestige, stronger
applicants, more alumni giving, and, most important, greater revenue potential.”
(to quote Boston magazine again).
What do they measure?
University rankings systems craft their lists by measuring a combination of the
performance and perception of higher educational institutions
REPUTATION = PERFORMANCE + PERCEPTION
Deconstructing…
Focusing on peer assessment. Which is where reputation is almost a self-fulfilling
prophecy: your reputation depends on how your peers perceive your reputation.
“Deconstructing” the rankings
Some Key Rankings
International
• Shanghai Jiao Tong World Universities Rankings
• QS World University Rankings
• TIMES World University Rankings
National
• US News and World Report University Rankings (USA)
• Forbes America’s Top Colleges (USA)
• Princeton Review (USA)
• College Factual (USA)
• LinkedIn (USA…brand new!)
• The Sunday Times University Guide (UK)
• Maclean’s University Rankings (Canada)
QS World University Rankings
1. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
2. University of Cambridge
3. Imperial College London
4. Harvard University
5. University of Oxford
6. UCL (University College London)
7. Stanford University
8. California Institute of Technology
9. Princeton University
10. Yale University
Perception criteria – 50%
Top 10
1. Academic reputation (40%)
- Based on survey data
2. Employer Reputation (10%)
- Based on survey data
TIMES Higher Education World University Rankings
1. California Institute of Technology
2. Harvard University
3. University of Oxford
4. Stanford University
5. Massachusetts Institute of Tech.
6. Princeton University
7. University of Cambridge
8. University of California, Berkeley
9. University of Chicago
10. Imperial College London
Perception criteria – 45% Top 10
1. Teaching (15% on peer
assessment, 15% performance
data)
The learning environment - the
dominant indicator here being
the results of the world's largest
invitation-only academic
reputation survey.
2. Research (30%)
Volume, income and reputation
for research excellence among
its peers, based on the 10,000-
plus responses to our annual
academic reputation survey.
Shanghai Jiao Tong Academic Ranking of World Universities
1. Harvard University
2. Stanford University
3. Massachusetts Institute of Tech.
4. University of California-Berkley
5. University of Cambridge
6. Princeton University
7. California Institute of Technology
8. Columbia University
9. University of Chicago
10. University of Oxford
Perception criteria – N/A
Top 10
US News and World Report University
Rankings (USA)
1. Princeton University
2. Harvard University
3. Yale University
4. Columbia University
4. Stanford University
4. University of Chicago
7. Massachusetts Institute of Tech.
8. Duke University
8. University of Pennsylvania
10. California Institute of Technology
USNews is just about to launch
its own world university rankings.
USNews
Perception criteria – 22.5%
• Undergraduate academic reputation (22.5%)
• (survey data, opinions of those in a position
to judge a school's undergraduate academic
excellence)
Other Criteria
• Retention (22.5%)
• Faculty Resources (20%)
• Student Selectivity (12.5%)
• Financial Resources (10%)
• Graduation rate performance (7.5%)
• Alumni giving rate (5%)
Princeton Leads U.S. News List; Dartmouth Drops From Top 10
….student outcry over sexual harassment and reports of fraternity hazing
…….. ‘Animal House’
Scope1. Deconstructing the rankings
2. Reputation: performance and perception – and process
3. Communications enhancing reputation
Scope1. Deconstructing the rankings
2. Reputation: performance and perception – and process
3. Communications enhancing reputation
#1: Coca-Cola, Marketing, US
#2: The New Yorker, English, NYC
http://www.uis.unesco.org/EDUCATION/Pages/international-student-flow-viz.aspx
UNESCO database
http://www.uis.unesco.org/EDUCATION/Pages/international-student-flow-viz.aspx
UNESCO database
http://www.uis.unesco.org/EDUCATION/Pages/international-student-flow-viz.aspx
UNESCO database
Scope1. Competitive landscape
2. Reputation management – process and levers
3. Communications – fizz and focus
Reputation and student choice go beyond academics, just as
companies are perceived to be more than their products.
The Student as Consumer
• Safety
• Sustainability and ethics
• Athletics
• Cafeteria/food service
• Prestige
• Cost
• Internships and jobs, etc.
• Location
• The most beautiful campus
• The best social life
2222
Defining “Reputation”
Reputation is driven by:
• Overall quality or character
• How people judge it, and in what regard they hold it
Reputation is a combination of two factors:
• Performance
• Perception
Performance + Perception = Reputation
WEBSTER’S DEFINITION:
rep·u·ta·tion – nounOverall quality or character … seen or judged by people in
general; a place in public esteem or regard
2323
US
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
France
Germany
Great Britain
India
Italy
Japan
Mexico
Russia
SA
Turkey
10%
30%
50%
70%
90%
-15.0% -10.0% -5.0% 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0%
DME Productivity
Co
mp
an
y N
et
Fa
vo
rab
ilit
y
Australia
China:
-33.9%Spain
-16.5%
50%
10%
95%
A corporate case study – DME is Productive Above a Corporate
Reputation “Floor” When the Majority of Consumers are Receptive to
Communications
Declining DME ProductivityAve. –Strong Reputation
Declining DME Productivity
Low Reputation
Increasing DME Productivity
Avg. – Strong Reputation
2424
Reputation
Management
Process
4.Input Into
Business Planning
5.Invest & Act
6.Validate &
Re-Calibrate
2.Gather
Perception Measures
1.Gather
Performance DataRepeat process
3.Map the
Findings
25
Perception
Perf
orm
an
ce
Leverage
Fix Analyze
Push
Low Performance, Low Perception
High Performance, Low Perception
High Performance, High Perception
Low Performance, High Perception
Reputation Map: Action
26
#49
Top 100
#168
Northeastern University
Rankings: A Case Study:intentional…..
By Max Kutner | Boston Magazine | September 2014
27
Peer Perception
Scope1. Competitive landscape
2. Reputation management – process and levers
3. Communications – fizz and focus
A unified story is important. It has to be connected.
Communicating: telling a unified story
What differentiates the institution?
What is its story? Its voice? Its narrative?
What is its unique value?
What does it do better than anyone else?
What makes it distinctive?
What do its messengers - current students, alumni, partners - say about
it?
Georgetown is a world-class research university grounded in
the liberal arts. It has many different centers and programs and
academic disciplines. But it is united by its brand identity, its
“mission” – an altruistic, service-oriented purpose through the
Catholic and Jesuit tradition
Northeastern is about coops – and opportunity = and jobs
Connectivity
The Connected College
How we communicate in our
hyper-connected
hyper-competitive world
Reputation being formed every
day by the millions upon
millions of little communications
transactions
Chief Listening Officer?
College confidential
Yik Yak
Communicating: The Connected College
02-14-2013 at 2:27 pm edited
November 2013 in Women's Colleges
The WC experience sounds like
something I would love. But like most
girls, I still want the chance to interact
with boys, have guy friends, and
date…
…Which interact the most and
in what ways with nearby
coed schools?
Also, what type of guys are connected
to the colleges?
….I've heard that -most- guys at
counterpart Hampden-Sydney are
conservative, partying, "manly men"
types (which aren't my
type personally).
Communicating: Story Telling
Your reputation with students, faculty, alumni, donors, corporate partners, and
government funders ... is all connected.
So you have to treat it holistically, recognizing the connectivity.
Not just a collection of academic departments and programs and research
centers – brand identity, a story, that informs all branches
One way of doing that is through story-telling and story-mining – the stories that
every institution embodies.
We have to be careful here and not “unauthentic.”
Visual – video – infographics
Curate the content ... creating conversation.
Fizz or Flop? Goucher’s Video
“trivialization” of education
in America
Fizz or Flop? Remember New Coke
The University of California released a statement Friday that it would cease use of a newly
released logo following “a significant negative response by students, alumni and other
members of our community.”
Daniel M. Dooley, senior vice president for external relations at the University of California
Office of the President, wrote that the response to the new logo had resulted in an
unfortunate community controversy.
Brand Authenticity
Communicating: The ToneBe transparent
Human
Honest
Modest
Informative
Helpful
Humorous (if possible)
Non-defensive
Authentic
Credible
Acknowledge mistakes
Interactive
Targeted and individualized
Unified and integrated
Personal and responsive
Global – the ultimate connectivity
Our marketing, our appeal, our platforms have to be consciously,
intentionally GLOBAL and internationally connected
You need to use communications to
• Expand your reputation globally
• Communicate and market your offering overseas
• Support overseas ventures, campuses, programs and initiatives
• Forge and sustain international institutional partnerships
• Recruit international students
• Create a global culture
Communicating: Global
Communicating ConvergenceUniversities are now centers for building connections – Partnerships,
Relationships and Networks
Business schools have to be entrepreneurial and innovative.
• They have to incorporate creativity: previously the province of the arts.
Technology infuses everything; it has escaped from engineering.
International permeates every sphere; not just in International relations
Communications must acknowledge convergence – forge a uniting identity.
The new architecture of communications – design thinking
Now accepting ideas.
Now accepting innovation.
Now accepting applications.
Xxx University, Class of 2018.
Your scores don't define you. Your ideas do.
You are more than a transcript.You are more than an SAT score.Show us who you really are.
Your scores don't define you. Your ideas do.
You are more than a transcript.You are more than an SAT score.Show us who you really are.
The Connected University• Unique
• Unified
• Intentional
• Interactive
• International
• Convergence – the Connected University
Universities establish
relevance and exert
influence through the
connections they make
The transformational agenda…
…can also bring all
kinds of risks
Thank you
41
2,400 employees,
125 offices in 81
markets
90+ years in the
communications
industry7 year average tenure
among our top 150 clients850+ industry awards in
over 10 years
60% of client engagements
multi-market
staff speak 65 languages
Our Global Network
Current Clients