-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
1/38
Republic of South Sudan
Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
David H. Shinn
Elliott School of International Affairs
George Washington University27 October 2011
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
2/38
TAKE-AWAYS
Begins independence with high expectations.
Euphoria will prevail over short-term.
Faces huge internal challenges. Faces huge external challenges.
Has about year to make significant progress.
Alternative is failed state.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
3/38
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
4/38
INDEPENDENCE PROCESS
2005 Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA).
National Congress Party (NCP).
Sudan Peoples Liberation Movement (SPLM).
Shared national government for 6 years.
Goal to make unity attractive.
CPA established governments in north andsouth.
Shared oil revenue 50-50.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
5/38
INDEPENDENCE PROCESS
Separate northern and southern armies.
Joint units assigned to sensitive border areas.
North/south had separate command structures.
Withdrawal of 91,000 northern troops fromsouth.
National civil service positions split 70/30 favor of
north. Special provisions for sensitive areas.
Includes Abyei, Southern Kordofan & Blue Nile.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
6/38
INDEPENDENCE PROCESS
Sharia law applicable only in north.
North and south had own flags.
2005 death of SPLM leader John Garang. Ended prospect of north/south unity in south.
North failed to take steps encouraging unity.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
7/38
WORLDS NEWEST COUNTRY
January 2011 South Sudan secession referendum.
Overwhelming vote in favor.
9 July 2011 independence South Sudan.
Population now 8.2 million.
Slightly smaller than Texas.
Landlocked; 15 percent is swamp.
Borders Central African Republic, DRC, Uganda,
Kenya, Ethiopia & Sudan.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
8/38
Salva Kiir & Omar Bashir
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
9/38
WORLDS NEWEST COUNTRY
More than 60 local languages.
Majority animist, minority Christian, some
Muslims.
90% population lives in poverty.
27% adult literacy rate.
2 airports with paved runways. 4% agricultural land cultivated.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
10/38
UN Mission in South Sudan (UNMISS)
Became operational 9 July 2011.
Mandate one year renewable.
7,000 military personnel.
900 civilian police.
Foster state-building and economicdevelopment
Conflict resolution and protect civilians.
Strengthen security and justice sectors.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
11/38
The Oil Conundrum
50-50 oil revenue split is finished.
75% Sudans oil in South Sudan.
90-95% oil field personnel are northerners. Pipelines and refinery in north.
Oil Revenue 98% of South Sudan budget.
South Sudan now marketsits oil.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
12/38
The Oil Conundrum
South Sudan ships oil through northern
infrastructure.
South Sudan pays pipeline/terminal fees to
north and private companies.
Receives all revenue from its oil.
Khartoum markets its 25% share.
Khartoum experienced huge revenue loss.
North-south negotiating revenue sharing.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
13/38
The Oil Conundrum
South Sudan offered to pay standard pipelinefees.
Khartoum wants much higher fees.
South Sudan says Khartoum threatened to closepipeline.
Khartoum wants agreement by end of October.
Deal currently stalemated. Alternative pipeline through Kenya or Ethiopia.
Would take years to construct.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
14/38
Abyei Region
Located on north-south border.
Contested by both sides.
Resident Ngok Dinka support South Sudan.
Nomadic Misseriya support Khartoum.
Referendum on future never occurred.
Limited oil in Abyei.
Khartoums main interest support forMisseriya.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
15/38
Abyei Region
Sudan Armed Forces (SAF) invaded in May 2011.
100,000 Ngok Dinka fled to South Sudan.
SPLM properly called foul.
Both sides agreed to admit Ethiopian
peacekeepers.
Only about half of 4,000 peacekeepers present.
SAF and South Sudan troops still in place.
Both sides accepted joint oversight committee.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
16/38
Other Border Issues
20% of north/south border still not agreed.
Constitutes 5 different pieces of border.
South Sudan wants to demarcate 80% agreed
upon. If no agreement on 20%, wants binding
arbitration.
South Sudan issued map claiming large chunk ofKenya.
Likely to cause friction with Kenya.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
17/38
SPLM/North
Led by Yasir Arman; opposed Bashir for
president.
SPLM/N split from SPLM on 8 September.
Became opposition party in north.
Khartoum banned SPLM/N days later.
Banned 16 other parties linked to SouthSudan.
Effectively have new south in north.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
18/38
SPLA Troops
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
19/38
SPLM/North
SPLM/N called publicly for ouster of Bashir.
Linked to opposition groups in Darfur and NubaMountains.
All of them trying to topple Bashir. Receives support from individuals in South
Sudan.
Probably supported by SPLM in South Sudan.
Several thousand SPLM/N troops in Blue Nile andSouthern Kordofan.
Come from former 9th and 10th SPLA divisions.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
20/38
Southern Kordofan
North of border, but disputed by north/south.
Rich in oil; 115,000 barrels per day.
Nuba people sympathetic to SPLM. SAF tried to disarm SPLM/N troops in June.
Up to 150,000 persons fled homes since June.
NCP won governorship in disputed election.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
21/38
SPLA/North Forces in Southern
Kordofan
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
22/38
Southern Kordofan
Fighting between SPLM/N and SAF.
Khartoum vowed to crush rebellion.
SAF reportedly using aerial bombing.
SPLM/N asked US to impose no-fly zone.
US demurred.
Military stalemate.
SPLM/N calling for overthrow of Bashir.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
23/38
Blue Nile
North of border, but disputed by north/south.
Not oil producing area.
Population split on support for Khartoum and
SPLM/N. SPLM/N troops did not disarm according to
agreement.
SPLM/N candidate Malik Agar won governorship. September SPLM/N troops loyal to Agar attacked
SAF.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
24/38
Blue Nile
Khartoum sacked Agar.
Replaced Agar with NCP military governor.
Khartoum recruiting friendly Rufaa and Fellata
militias. Trying to crush opposition.
Military stalemate.
Fighting displaced 100,000 persons.
25,000 refugees fled to Ethiopia.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
25/38
Security Challenges
Seven South Sudan armed groups opposeSPLM/A.
Claim to fight SPLM/A corruption.
Some led by former SPLA leaders. Some allegedly have ties to Khartoum.
Marginalization is driving these groups.
Most are not significant threat.
South Sudan Liberation Movement/Army is Nuergroup.
Objective to bring down government.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
26/38
Security Challenges
Lt. Gen. George Athor most significant threat.
Former senior SPLA commander.
Padeng Dinka closely linked to Nuer.
Athor failed to win election for governor ofJonglei State.
Claimed SPLM rigged election.
Took his followers to bush. South Sudan claims Khartoum supporting rebel
groups.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
27/38
Security Challenges
Much of South Sudan population pastoral.
Long history of cattle raids in South Sudan.
Caused many deaths in past.
Recent resumption of attacks.
Luo Nuer recently killed 400 Murle.
Murle then killed 600 Luo Nuer; stole 25,000
cattle. Cattle raid in Unity State left 30 dead.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
28/38
Aftermath of Cattle Raid
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
29/38
Security Challenges
South Sudan is awash in small arms.
Tribes better armed than police.
Police often run from these conflicts. Culture of violence developing.
Traditional conflict resolution not working.
South Sudan becoming broken society.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
30/38
SS National Army
Need to demobilize many South Sudan soldiers.
Most have no civilian skills.
Need vocational training.
Need army pension program.
Will be reluctance to downsize.
Could lead to strain on national debt.
Unplanned demobilization equals security threat.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
31/38
Demobilization of SPLM
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
32/38
Corruption
Half of budget goes to salaries.
90% of military budget is for salaries.
Some salaries go to non-existent people.
Not sustainable budgetary program.
South Sudan received $8-10 billion in oil revenue.
No transparency in oil revenue.
Except for salaries, almost nothing to show for
$8-10 billion.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
33/38
Corruption
Much of it disappeared.
Officials have millions in bank accounts.
Corruption in contracting and tax collection.
Payments for illegally acquired land.
Capital flight out of country.
Obama raised corruption issue with South Sudan
president.
If corruption continues, aid donors will hold back.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
34/38
Lack of Development
South Sudan inherited terrible situation.
Minimal infrastructure.
Inadequate numbers of trained persons.
Significant poverty.
Some 340,000 southerners arrived fromnorth.
Development concentrated in Juba. Leads to complaints in rest of South Sudan.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
35/38
South Sudan Road
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
36/38
Lack of Development
Most food imported from Uganda.
South Sudan will produce half of food needs in2011.
36% of population moderately or severely foodinsecure.
South Sudan facing chronic food shortages.
Could be 1.2 million severely food insecure in2012.
Need major push to develop agriculture.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
37/38
Political Issues
SPLM is authoritarian party.
Still shifting from rebel group to ruling party.
Sees opposition as treasonous.
Little tolerance for opposition parties.
Opposition parties are weak anyway.
Raises questions about future of democracy.
-
8/3/2019 Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead
38/38