Download - report on live case interview
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
1/17
EXECUTIVESUMMARY
Premier mercantile services private limited is one of the oldest and largest stevedores and terminaloperators in Pakistan. pms was initially started by Mr. Haleem Siddiqui and his younger brother
Mr. Muhammad Shoaib Siddiqui in 1964. The inspiration and idea to start the project came from
Karachi port trust which lacked in efficiency and productivity, the brothers felt the need of private
stevedoring and terminal operating company to capture the large market by providing betterservices, improved quality and efficient handling by installing modernized equipments and latest
machines and by installing a computer based system.
Mr. Siddiqui has faced several challenges and problems in running the business. The intervention
of government has caused many obstacles for the company; to become proficient the company had
to set up modernized machines which required permission from the government, the company wasdependent on the govt. and this took a lot of time. Other problems, which they have to go through,
were malfunctioning of machines, accidents in handling which affected the productivity plus
customs obligations.
But, due to the hard work, commitment and expertise of Mr. Siddiqui in this field, he managed tocope with all the problems successfully and established PMS as one of the largest stevedoring
company at the Karachi Port at one point handling half the container traffic of Karachi Port.
According to Mr. Siddiqui there are three factors that play a significant role in leading the
company towards the path of success. Number one being the Services that are provided by thecompany, secondly, the commitment of the company in fulfilling its orders and promises with its
clients or customers and last but not the least, honesty of the company in terms of providing better
quality services.Today around 75% of the revenue in this industry is generated by PMS itself.
PMS now provides on-board stevedoring services to over 30,000 Container Units. Per months andprovides container handling services to several shipping lines calling at the Karachi Port. The two
major competitors of PMS are m/s badaruddin stevedores and friends corporation stevedores.
1
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
2/17
INTRODUCTION
Premier Mercantile Services (pvt) limited was founded by Mr. Haleem Siddiqui and his younger
brother Mr. Muhammad Shoaib Siddiqui in 1964.
PMS has been engaged in providing cargo handling services at the Karachi Port since its inception
in 1964. PMS was one of the first stevedoring companies in Pakistan to invest in modern container
handling equipment. Through progressive investment and steady growth PMS is now one of the
largest stevedores at the Karachi Port at one point handling half the container traffic of Karachi
Port.
Equipped with the latest container handling equipment, PMS Provides on-board stevedoring
service to over 30,000 TUE (Twenty Foot Equivalent Container Units.) per month and provides
container handling services to several shipping lines calling at the Karachi Port. PMS has a
dedicated container yard at the East Wharf of Karachi Port used for stacking containers and
delivery to the trade/Shipping lines.
PMS also operated and empty container yard at TPX area outside the Karachi Port.
PMS is also the main sponsor and majority shareholder of Pakistan International Container
Terminal Limited which operates a state-of-the-art container terminal at the East Wharf, Karachi
Port.
2
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
3/17
SALIENT FEATURES OF THE COMPANY
Following are the salient features of the company that makes it best among others:
PMS is the oldest and largest stevedore and Terminal Operator working on Karachi Port
Terminals on both East and West wharf for the handling of vessels as well as containers
Total area of around 70000 sq. mts at East wharf, KPT for handling of containers.
Total area of around 20000 sq. mts at West Wharf, KPT for handling and marshalling of
containers.
Total area of around 45000 sq. mts at TPX, Outside Port premises at M.T. Khan Rd. as well
for the handling and storage of empty containers.
Most modern equipments for the handling of containers which are:
Four Reach Stackers of 5 high
One Top loader of 4 high
Four Empty container handlers
One Heavy Fork Lifts (TCM)
Ten fully equipped hydraulics Trailers
PMS is the only company in the history of KPT to have its own State of art Shed for the
handling and storage of export cargo.
PMS is the proud sponsor of PICT which is the first Pakistan based state of art terminal
equipped with the most modern equipments for the handling of vessels in KPT
Skilled and efficient staff for the handling of cargo as well as containers
3
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
4/17
ORGANIZATION CHART
Director
Operations
Secretary &
Off. Asstt
Chief
Accountant
Terminal
Manager
Chief
Engineer
Accountants
& Assitants
Commercial
Staff
Dy.Manager
Terminal
Equipment
InchargeOff. Asst.
Asst. Mgr
Admin & Claim
Dy. Manager
Operations
IT
Department
Drivers &
helpers
Onboard
SupervisorYard Foreman
Export
Consolidation
Hardware &
Network
Assistants
Computer
Data Entry
Staff
Tally ClerksOn board
checkers
Asst.
Foremens
Alongside
ClerksCheckers
STAFF HIERARCHY
SERVICES PROVIDING TO TRADE
Following are the esteem services that PMS are providing to their customers:
Vessels Stevedoring
Handling containers under hook
Terminal Operations for the cargo & containers of nominated customers
24 hrs Receive / delivery facility of Containers
De-stuffing of nominated Containers in KPT Sheds
Consolidation of cargo meant for export in very own state or art shed
Storage of Laden & Empty Containers
Maintaining of stock line/Customer wise
Transportation of Laden as well as Empty containers.
Prompt reporting to our customers through electronic media.
4
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
5/17
One window Operation through efficient and friendly customer Service
Repairing and washing facility of dirty and damage containers
Office facility with all basic necessities like Telephone, Fax and computers with internet
facility etc.
5
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
6/17
CLIENT LIST
PMS is very fortunate and feels proud that it has some of the big names of the trade in its clients
list such as HLL, Maersk, PIL and Safmarine. They are also the stevedore of countrys national
shipping line (PNSC). Following are their prominent clients in the trade which are using the
services of their company: AMI Pakistan
Anchor Shipping (Maruba & Emirate Shipping Line)
Buksh Investment (MNSL)
CIM Shipping (ARC & EM Key Shipping Line)
Consolidation Shipping and Logistics
Delta Shipping (PIL Shipping Line)
Delta Transport (HLL Shipping Line)
Globelink Pakistan (Pvt) Ltd.
IAL Pakistan (IAL Shipping Line)
ISPI Corporation (MISC Shipping Line)
Maritime Agencies Pvt. Ltd. (K Line )
Maersk Pakistan (Pvt.) Ltd. (Maersk Line)
Marine Services (Pvt.) Ltd. (Norasia, Transasia & Pollux & Castor Shipping Line)
Ocean Shipping and Logistics (Maxicon Line)
Pakistan National Shipping Corporation (PNSC Line)
Ravian International Agencies.
Riazeda Pvt. Ltd. (Balaji Shipping Line)
Safmarine Pakistan Pvt. Ltd (Safmarine Shipping Line)
Sea Hawk (Sea Hawk Shipping)
United Marine Agencies Pvt. Ltd (RCL Shipping Line)
Yaseen Shipping (STX Pan Ocean Line)
PROJECTS
6
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
7/17
Below are some of the projects of the company which can clearly portrait the company image
regarding reputation, efficiency and professionalism:
Development of Software for the tracking and reporting of cargo as well as containers
Setting up a custom examination yard with all the basic requirements such as CCTV,
Computers with internet link via remote links and security guards Stuffing of Cargo on in reefer containers with the help of Stuffy at -65 temperature
Handling of Project Cargo Vessels
Handling of RORO vessels contains APV & APC
Consolidation of Export Cargo
FORTHCOMING PROJECT
To facilitate the trade one step further the management has decided to build a modern dry port in
Punjab at Prem Nagar near Raiwind in collaboration with Pakistan Railways. Currently the
feasibility work has been done and construction phase started, it provides a complete service of
marine and train/tailored to the customers specific needs, saving time, controlling costs, and
streamlining operations at Karachi Port and at Lahore ICD along with flexible and comprehensive
expertise.
7
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
8/17
8
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
9/17
PROFILEOFTHE ENTREPRENEURS:
Name: Mr. Muhammad Shoaib Siddiqui
Age: 50
Family: Married and has three children.
Education: BA (private) from Pakistan, ITC (Inter transport course), ICD Course from UN and
CILT (Chartered institute of Logistic & Transport)
Last job held:No other jobs.
Designation: Director Operations of Premier Mercantile Services,
Personal funds invested: No personal funds, loan obtained from bank.
Other companies started: Started Al-Hamd Internatinal in partenership with a foreign company
but left it after a few years; Plans to establish another Inland Dry Port in Lahore.
Name: Mr. Haleem Siddiqui.
Age: 55
Family: Married and has three children.
Education: BA (private) from India.
Last job held: Worked in Navy as a Captain for 2-3 years, and then worked as a tele-contractor in
KPT.
Personal funds invested: No personal funds, loan obtained from bank.
Other companies Started: Mercantile Services ltd.
9
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
10/17
INTERVIEW
About yourself and brief introduction of the business? What kind of services do you
provide?
Mr. Shoaib Siddiqui did private graduation and then started this company with his elder
brother Mr. Haleem Siddiqui.
Mr. Shoaib Siddiqui has a work experience of about 35-40 years. The company has bulid
many strong international contacts with the various countries, which helps in providing
better services.
PMS basically provides cargo handling services at the Karachi Port. PMS currently has
around 2000-3000 employees and four offices. PMS deals with the handling of 60,000
containers per month on average. Other than KPT (Karachi port trust), PMS is one of the
first stevedoring companies in Pakistan to invest in modern container handling equipment.
PMS is the only group in Pakistan involved in the handling of cargo, equipments and ships.
How was the firm created? How did you get the idea?
How did you get started:
How were the finances arranged?
All the initial investment was made by obtaining loans from banks as huge
investment was needed. It would not have been a wise decision to put personal
assets at stake.
Location of the company?
The companys first office was on rent in Wrighters Chamber, with the passage of
time, the company moved its offices at Business Center, now the company has huge
offices and stills plans to expand the business and establish a separate building for
PMS.
Basic competitors?
10
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
11/17
In general there are 30 other stevedoring companies but following are the two major
competitors of PMS:
- M/S Badruddin Stevedore
- M/S Friends Corporation Stevedore (pvt) ltd.
Growth in terms of revenue?
75 % of the revenue is generated by PMS and the remaining is shared among the other
stevedoring companies.
What are the measures that your company takes to maintain stability?
The company believes in making less investment in order to maintain stability, to sustain
the environmental and other external factors and to keep up with the normal pace. To
maintain the stability, the company reduces the administration cost, management cost and
repairing cost of the machines to up to 60%. And the company cut downs it cost by renting
the equipment for handling the cargo instead of buying them.
Legal obligations?
The company faces major interference and involvement of customs and agencies. The
company is required to recieve permission from the customs after thorough investigation in
order to remove the threat of any suspicious movement of object. To make this method, less
time consuming PMS has installed scanners to detect any suspicious object in the
containers.
Documents are provided to the customs and KPT, beforehand to avoid any delay, and to
keep the track of the containers.
What are your company policies?
The company ensures to provide:
Complete handling of cargo, from uploading to discharging of containers.
The company aims to bear all the cost in case of damages and theft.
To prevent from losses, the company has insured itself.
11
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
12/17
The company follows the organizational safety regulations from UN to protect
the staff.
The company is completely against downsizing; it wants to maintain the
current number of permanent employees (i.e. 3000); for extra workload it hires
temporary staff.
Transit claims: when the company exceeds the specified time they have to pay
extra charges.
In order to protect the activities the company records all the activities of the
employees.
Effect of political, economical situation on your business?
The economy of Pakistan plays a vital role in the stability of the company. As a matter of
fact, the import and export of the country always depends on the economy of the country,
and PMS basically deals with the import and export of cargo both outside and inside the
company. Presently the export and import of the country has reduced up to 35%, which has
also affected the company.
In adverse conditions, the export and import of container reduces, which lessens the
number of containers eventually. In adverse condition the company does not believe in
downsizing the employees, instead the company considers to cut the number of equipment
for handling of the cargo on port. The company avoids making any additional investments
in the period of recession. The number of containers due to the present situation has
reduced from 60,000 to 40,000.
What are the changes that came in the company over the years?
In the early period of 80s the operations of Premier mercantile services were basically
manual, as the containers were not containerized, the companies had to discharge the cargo
manually. With the passage of time they started to use crane-lifting and fork-lifting andnow they are using reach-stackers; also all their record keeping is computerized. The
company has brought many changes in itself from the time started, the company started
with the handling of general cargo but then in 1978 the company started the handling of
bulk cargo (which generally includes coal, wheat & sugar etc). In 2001, the modernization
in this field helped the company in cutting cost and to be more productive and efficient in
12
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
13/17
terms of dispatching and uploading cargo from/on ships, which in result made the company
more successful. They have also installed scanners which make it a lot easier to scan the
containers for the Custom.
What are the success factors of your company?
Mr. Siddiqui believes that three factors play a significant role in companys success.
Services
Commitment;
And honesty.
Do you have any future plans/new business?
Mr. Siddiqui plans to start a mega project; an inland dry port in Lahore in the August 2009,
Inshallah!
Challenges of the new project: Government has played a major role, in delaying the Lahore
project. Mr. Siddiqui had planned Lahore inland dry port about 5 years ago, but the plan
took enormous time due to the inefficiency of the government managers, which in turn
caused delay in receiving loans from the banks.
Strengths of the new project: Government has dry ports but due to lack of marketing they
attract very few customers. This new dry port would offer efficiency and reliability to their
customers. They would provide guaranteed transit time, no fluctuation in freight charges,
no need of security deposits, one window operations; they would offer direct custom
documentation.
Marketing for the future project:
Personal marketing
Newspaper and magazine advertisement
Do you think your company is flexible in adopting change?
The company adopts new changes without any resistance. It even accepts changes easily;
as they installed computers with the changing demands of the time, hence they can claim
that they are the only stevedoring company which has complete computerized systems.
13
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
14/17
Even now there are companies which are lagging behind as they havent accepted the
changes with time.
What are the challenges faced by the company?
The company has faced many hurdles from time to time; the interference of brokerage has
caused many problems for the company. And the government has also caused many
disturbances for the company; the involvement of the government in this business refrains
the company from bringing change in terms of modernization of equipments. The company
had to fight with the government for permission in this regard for a period of about 15
years (1980-1995) and had to go through a phase of constant struggle and fight. The delay
in the modernization of equipments, in installing new equipments effected the growth of
the company. The company is bound by law that they have to hire DLB (dock labor board).
What do you think is your companys competitive advantage?
According to them their competitive advantages are:
- The company has large amount of latest equipment which makes the
company more efficient as compared to its competitors.
- They have the expertise in this field. Mainly the extensive experience of the
entrepreneur Mr. Shoaib Siddiqui.
- Services_ they provide all three services in one package.- They charge relatively low prices.
How your company differentiates itself from its competitors?
Their cargo handling is very efficient they dont waste any time. Their prompt shifting of
unloading and loading the cargo is also another way they differentiate themselves. They
reduce the occurrence of damages by careful handling and even if any accidents happen
they compensate the damages.
How do you market yourself?
The company believes in word-to-word marketing of their services, their strong
connections and relationships build throughout the passage of time plays a major role in
14
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
15/17
this regard. The company also markets itself through advertisements in newspapers and
magazines such as Murad Shipping Advertisment.
What do you think are the major qualities of an entrepreneur?
To become a successful entrepreneur, Mr. Shoaib Siddiqui believes that anindividual should be patient and calm. he should avoid hastiness and rapid success.
An individual should know how to manage his time efficiently.
And last but not the least; an individual should be committed to his work. He should
be committed and loyal to his words and fulfills his promises made to the
customers.
15
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
16/17
Developments in Global Seatrade and ContainerShipping Markets: Their Effects on the Port Industryand Private Sector Involvement
Hans J F Peters
Baltic Maritime Advisers, 1444 Colleen Lane, McLean, Virginia 22101, USA
Abstract
During the past 20 years world seaborne trade increased by almost 40%.Liner shipping grew the fastest. Containerised cargo was clearly the mostdynamic sector of global seaborne trade. Containerisation has thus beena major and increasingly important element of not only maritime activity,but also of world trade and of entire global industrial structure. Thegrowing significance of containerisation is a reflection of the changesthat have occurred in the international organisation of manufacturing and
production. Container lines have moved through several organisationalphases in the search for profitability. Most of the advances incontainership design have been associated with the upsizing of vessels,both to accommodate trade growth and to offer economies of scale in ahighly competitive market. Information technology is now seen as thegreat battleground of the next decade among not just carriers, but alsoforwarders, logistics based integrators and, potentially, pure technologycompanies who may use their systems expertise to enter the industry atthe expense of traditional players. Container handling in ports is anotherarea where technical advance is noticeable. Increasingly larger tonnage,especially of vessels deployed in the container market, will havesignificant implications for ports. Massive investments and substantialproductivity improvements are generally required to enable ports to meetthe stringent service requirements of their customers efficiently. Thespeed of container handling and consequent vessel turnaround time is acrucial issue in terms of competition. The worldwide trend towardsgreater private sector involvement in ports has become apparent. Whilewholesale privatisation has occurred in a few cases, what is morecommon is the introduction of private finance, operation andmanagement in place of state funds and administration. The advent of theso-called 'global stevedore' in the 1980s has had a fundamental effect onport facility financing and management. The international stevedoringindustry is made-up of participants with a commercial remit. The bottomline with port facility acquisitions or new terminal developments is thatdevelopers of all categories look for annual pre-tax returns in excess of20% of turnover. While the acquisition and development of port facilitiesis a global business, it is one that is highly influenced by key individuals
within the international stevedores. Competition among internationalstevedores and between these parties and ocean carriers for portconcessions has never been stronger.
16
-
8/14/2019 report on live case interview
17/17
CONTAINERSHIPPING AND PORTS: AN OVERVIEW
THEO E. NOTTEBOOM*Institute of Transport and Maritime Management Antwerp (ITMMA), University of Antwerp
The market environment in which container ports and shipping lines are operating is substantially
changing. One of the main driving forces to change emerges from the globalization process and the
large-scale adoption of the container since the late 1960s. Worldwide container port throughputincreased from 36 million TEU1 in 1980 to 266 million TEU in 2002. Forecasts point to between
432 and 468 million TEU in 2010 (OSC, 1997 and OSC, 2003). While the Atlantic Rim is thecradle of containerization, economically dynamic East Asia has become the worlds main container
region. The share of Asia in worldwide container port throughput rose from 25 per cent in 1980 to
about 46 per cent now, while Europe saw its share drop from 32 per cent to 23 per cent.
The rise of world containerization is the result of the interplay of macroeconomic, microeconomicand policy-oriented factors. World trade is facilitated through the elimination of trade barriers and
the liberalization and deregulation of markets. Practical evidence shows that the public sector has
redefined its role in the port and shipping industries through privatization and corporatizationschemes. Contemporary government intervention in an efficiency-oriented industry typically
focuses on the issue of market liberalisation and the creation of a level playing field for faircompetition, the monopoly issue and the public goods issue (see Goss, 1990; Baird, 2000; DeMonie, 1995; Notteboom and Winkelmans, 2001 and Everett, 1996). With the reassessment of the
role of the government much attention is now paid to governance issues in ports and shipping (see
Brooks, 2001 and Wang, 2003). Market liberalization revealed to enhance the development of
logistics throughout the world. International supply chains have become complex and logisticsmodels evolve continuously as a result of influences and factors such as the globalization and
expansion into new markets, mass customization in response to product and market segmentation,
lean manufacturing practices and associated shifts in costs. Customers need for a wider array ofglobal services and for truly integrated services and capabilities (design, build and operate)
triggered integrated logistics strategies (Christopher, 1992 and McKinnon, 2001) and a shift from
transportation-based 3PLs (Third Party Logistics) to warehousing and distribution providers and atthe same time opened the market to innovative forms of nonasset related logistics service
provision, that is 4PL (Fourth Party Logistics)2. Intensified competition at the supply side creates
pressures on cost management and on margins. The evolutions in supply chains and logisticsmodels urge container ports and shipping lines to re-think their function in the logistics process.
Recent literature has addressed the impact of changes in logistics on the functional role of ports
and shipping in value chains. Robinson (2002) places the role of seaports within a new paradigm
of ports as elements in value-driven chain systems. Notteboom and Winkelmans (2001b) andHeaver et al (2000) primarily discussed the changing role of port authorities in the new logistic-
restructured environment, while Martin and Thomas (2001) addressed structural changes in the
container terminal community. Slack et al (2002) demonstrates how the organizational
restructuring of the container shipping industry is taking place against the backdrop of logistics.
17