L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
1
Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics L. J. Farrugia MSc Core Course C5
Text books : Inorganic Chemistry - Housecroft & Sharpe Ch 23 - the very basics
Inorganic Chemistry - Shriver & Atkins Ch 16 - the very basics
This course assumes familiarity with the Level-2 and Level-3 courses on Organometallic Chemistry, and this is covered in the above texts
Organometallics - Elschenbroich & Salzer (library) - much more useful
Topic 1 - Introduction to Cyclopentadienyl Compounds
First part of course covers the role of the ligand cyclopentadienyl (Cp) and its derivatives. Cp is one of the most important ligands in organometallics after CO. A considerable percentage of organometallic compounds contain this ligand - it is also a good ligand for main group metals and the f-block metals (lanthanides & actinides).
Cyclopentadiene Cyclopentadiene complex (4 e donor ligand) very rare as a ligand
The anion C5H5
- is a very useful synthetic reagent. It is usually treated as equivalent to occupying THREE coordination sites, so that C5H5 ≡ 3(CO). In electron counting terms, it can be treated as either as a 6-e donor ANION or a 5-e donor NEUTRAL molecule. The latter is the recommended approach because it is simpler (do not need to worry about oxidation levels). 1.1 Bonding in cyclopentadienyl compounds
Cp has 5 π electrons in the 5 out-of-plane p-orbitals on the C atoms. These 5 orbitals combine as a1 + e1 + e2 under five-fold symmetry. With a single Cp ring,
H
H
H
H
Fe
OC CO
CO
H
H acidic H atom
Na / -H2
Na+
planar aromatic (6-pi electron) dienyl anion
-
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
2
inspection shows the possible combinations with the metal d-orbitals are shown below
Cp orbitals Metal orbitals Symmetry of bond a1 pz dz2, s σ e1 dxz dyz px py π e2 dx2-y2 dxy δ
For two Cp rings in a metallocene M(C5H5)2 the rings may be either staggered or eclipsed - Fe(C5H5)2 is eclipsed but Co(C5H5)2 and Ni(C5H5)2 are staggered.
The bonds can also be divided into sigma, pi and delta symmetry as shown in OHP #1 OHP # 2 shows the formal MO interaction diagram for ferrocene - Fe(C5H5)2 The main points to remember (i) the 9 filled orbitals have 18 electrons - hence the rule ! (ii) the LUMO is a doubly degenerate π* orbital, so Ni(C5H5)2 is paramagnetic
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
3
This shows how the metal and ring π-orbitals match by symmetry. The resultant MO scheme for ferrocene shows the way that the basis orbitals having the same symmetry can combine to give new orbitals (NOT necessary to remember the MO scheme) The filling of the nine bonding orbitals in ferrocene explains the high stability of this compound. The mixing of metal and Cp orbitals indicates a strong covalent character to the transition metal - cyclopentadienyl bond. In Co(C5H5)2 ONE electron fills the e*1g while in Ni(C5H5)2 there are TWO unpaired electrons - hence both compounds are paramagnetic
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
4
Co(C5H5)2 readily loses an electron to give the cobalticinium cation [Co(C5H5)2]+
an 18e cation. Similarly Ni(C5H5)2 loses one electron to give a 19e cation, but further oxidation results in decomposition. 1.2 Structural types of Cp compounds (i) Metallocenes MCp2 These are known for the metals Ti, V, Cr , Mn, Co and Ni. Staggered or eclipsed rings leads to D5h or D5d symmetry with virtually NO barrier to rotation of the Cp ring about the metal-Cp axis. So all Cp protons appear as equivalent in the 1H NMR spectrum V, Cr, Fe, Co and Ni give the "classic" sandwich compounds illustrated above. The exceptions are
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
5
(a) Titanocene "TiCp2"
This is really a fulvalene complex made by reducing Cp2TiCl2. It contains bridging hydrides and a Ti-Ti bond - gives 16 e Ti atoms. Real "titanocene" TiCp*2 has recently been made but is extremely reactive. (b) Manganocene MnCp2 This is ionic at low temperature, with a polymeric chain like structure
Above 159oC it becomes isomorphous with ferrocene, so must adopt a sandwich structure. All the sandwich metallocenes apart from ferrocene are paramagnetic
No. unpaired electrons Cp2V 3e Cp2Cr 2e Cp2Mn 5e high spin Mn2+ Cp2Co 1e Cp2Ni 2e
(ii) 'bent' metallocenes These have non-parallel rings due to the presence of other ligands. Some examples are
18 e 16 e 17 e 18 e
W
H
H
Ti
Cl
Cl
V CO Re H
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
6
(iii) half-sandwich compounds - piano stool compounds These have one Cp ring and a variety of other ligands. Some examples are
4-legged stool 3-legged stool Chem-3 lab 2-legged stool The 17 electron species CpMo(CO)3 and CpFe(CO)2 are not stable as such, but dimerise to give the familiar compounds with a Mo-Mo or Fe-Fe metal-metal bond. This is typical behaviour of odd-electron organometallic species. (iv) other types of bonding mode
So far only the so-called eta-5 η5-C5H5 bonding mode has been illustrated, where (in principle) all five C atoms are equally bonded to the transition metal. However there are other possibilities, most common are η3-C5H5 and η
1-C5H5
η1-C5H5 η3-C5H5
1 e donor - like alkyl group 3e donor - like allyl group
One good example is Mo(NO)Cp3 - with "normal" η
5-C5H5 bonding modes, electron counting give a 24 electron compound (!!) - simply not possible. In fact it is an example of a compound containing all three types. η1-C5H5 ligands are usually fluxional. Consider the compound (C5H5)4Ti - again cannot be 4 η5-C5H5 bonding modes because it would be a 24 e compound. In this case it has two η5-C5H5 and two η
1-C5H5 ligands.
V Mn Ru Co
OCCO
COOC
OCCO
COCl PPh3
PPh3
OC CO
H
M
M
H
Mo
ON
Ti
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
7
At the very lowest temperature measured, the 1H NMR spectrum shows a singlet for the two (equivalent) η5-C5H5 groups and an AA'BB'C multiplet for the two (equivalent) η1-C5H5 groups (three different H environments). This compound shows two fluxional processes (i) migration of metal atom around the η1-C5H5 group via 1,2 shifts (ring whizzing) (ii) exchange of the η1-C5H5 and η
5-C5H5 groups Process (i) is a very low energy process, which is frozen out only at the lowest temperatures. Process (ii) occurs at higher temperatures ~ room temperature. The net result of (i) and (ii) is that all 20 protons appear equivalent at the highest temperatures measured. Process (i) could in principle occur also by 1,3 shifts or random shifts. How can we tell which ? We can if it is possible to assign the protons of the AA'BB' signal
The resulting exchanges are :
a→c a→b i.e. both a type protons exchange b→a b→b i.e. only half of b type protons exchange c→a
So... the rate of broadening for the a type protons is twice as fast as for the b type protons The actual spectrum of (η5-C5H5)(η
1-C5H5)Fe(CO)2 which exhibits a similar exchange is shown below.
bb
aa
M c
b b
a
c
M
a
ab
cb
M a
1, 2 shift
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
8
1.3 Oxidation states in Cp compounds Since Cp is formally charged with a -ve charge, each Cp ligand present in a compound contributes a charge of +1 towards the formal oxidation state of the metal. Hence a metal must be in a +ve oxidation level. The only exception would be with +ve charged ligands - NO+ is the only common example. CpNi(NO) has a zerovalent Ni atom. In terms of its ability to stabilize oxidation states, Cp is comfortable with both low and high oxidation states of the metal (unlike many pi-acid ligands like CO which are only found for low oxidation states). In general Cp is a good sigma- and pi-donor, but a poor pi-acceptor. Substituting H for Me on the Cp ring makes it an even better sigma-donor - Cp* is the common symbol for C5Me5 .
Re
OCCO
CO
Re
OO
O
H2O2
CO
Re (+1) Re(+7) - oxo complex
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
9
Topic 2 - Reactivity of Cyclopentadienyl-type Ligands Very often Cp is a spectator ligand (i.e. it does not take part in the reaction and it is unchanged at the end). Under some circumstances however the ring will react. Ferrocene Fe(C5H5)2 has been the most studied (because it is a stable 18 e metallocene) but ruthenocene Ru(C5H5)2 and osmocene Os(C5H5)2 will give similar reactions - they are in the same periodic group ! However, most Cp compounds will not survive the reaction conditions described below. 2.1 Electrophilic substitution at ring This is a very facile process, occuring some 3×106 times faster than with benzene.
E+ is a general electrophile, see E/S p 328-330. A concrete example is a Friedel-Crafts acylation
The mechanism probably involves exo attach at the ring C-atom, followed by a movement of the proton down to the metal.
The hydride intermediate can be made by treating FeCp2 with very strong acids. The hydride signal in the 1H NMR spectrum comes aroound -2.1 ppm, which is typical of metal hydrides. This reaction does not work if the electrophile is an oxidising electrophile as many are such as NO2
+. These reagents oxidise the complex to give the
Fe
E+
Fe + Fe
EE
H
- H+
Fe
CH3COCl/AlCl3
Fe
C
O
Fe
C
O
C
O
+
Fe Fe
EE
H Fe
E
H+
+
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
10
ferricinium cation [FeCp2]+ and the +ve charge now on the rings makes
electrophilic attack very difficult. Another example and indication of the high reactivity of FeCp2 is that the Vilsmeier reaction works
This reaction only works well with highly activated aromatics such as amines (anilines) and phenols. Because of the high reactivity of the Cp rings, there is little of the selectivity observed in aromatic compounds.
2.2 Reactivity of attached organic groups Organic functional groups attached to Cp undergo many of the most common reaction types, e.g. below (non-oxidising conditions)
Fe
(i) POCl3
Fe
CO
H
(ii) H2O
C
O
HMePhN
+
substituted formamides
Fe
Et
4.2
1.0
for Friedel-Crafts acylation
CH3COCl/AlCl3
1.4
Fe
C
O
H
Fe
PhCOMe/base
H
O Ph
H
Fe
H
R
H
Ph3P=CHRWittig ylid
Fe
C
O
CH3
Fe
RCHO/base
O
H
H
R
aldol condensation
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
11
2.3 Metallation of ferrocene Further substituents may be introduced by the very useful reaction with butyl lithium
Note that it is not possible to introduce the NO2 group directly by nitration as the electrophile NO2
+ is oxidising 2.4 Stabilization of αααα-carbonium ions
The hydrolysis of the aceto substituted ferrocene proceeeds seven times faster than the solvolysis of Ph3C-OAc (this is a classic example of SN1 hydrolysis via the stable carbonium ion Ph3C+ the trityl ion). So we conclude that the carbonium ion intermediate is more stable that the trityl cation. Reactions involving vinylic substituents also proceed through α-carbonium ions, e.g. the reaction with CH3CO2H
FeFe
Fe
FeFe
PPh2Cl
Li
BuLiFe
CO2H
Fe
NO2
CO2
N2O4
Fe/HCl
NH2OMe
NH2 2 BuLi
Li
Li
PPh2
PPh2
Fe
PPh2
PPh2
Fe(CO)4Fe(CO)5
Fe FeH2O/H+
OAc
RH
R
H
+
OH-
Fe
OH
RH
carbonium ion intermediate
Fe FeH2O/H+
CH3
H
+
OAc-
Fe
OAc
CH3H
carbonium ion intermediate
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
12
The carbonium ion can actually be isolated and crystallised as the BF4- or PF6
- salts. The crystal structures show clear evidence of an "interaction" between the exo- C-C bond and the Fe atom - "bends" towards the Fe atom.
There is also NMR evidence for the presence of a π-bond between the exo-C atoms and the Fe atom. Uses 57Fe-13C coupling constants, which was observed to be 1.5 Hz in the above cation. Clearly indicates that the bond between the carbonium carbon and the Fe is nearer to a π-bond.
Type of bond J(57Fe-13C) /Hz
σ Fe-C ~ 9 π Fe-C 1.5 - 4.5
2.5 The "indenyl" effect and ring slippage Indene is a bicyclic hydrocarbon closely related to cyclopentadiene
Indenyl forms complexes which are similar to Cp, but substitution reactions are much faster (up to 108 times !!). Example
(Ind)Rh(CO)2 + PPh3 → (Ind)Rh(CO)(PPh3) + CO This is an SN2 reaction, i.e. 2nd order and associative. Therefore the rate determining step involved addition of the phosphine Example
(Cp)Mn(CO)3 + PBu3 → no reaction (Ind)Mn(CO)3 + PBu3 → (Ind)Mn(CO)2(PBu3) + CO (Flr)Mn(CO)3 + PBu3 → (Flr)Mn(CO)2(PBu3) + CO
Fluorenyl (Flr) is 250 times faster than the indenyl reaction
Fe
Ph
Ph+
overall 6 e donor
Fe
160 deg
crystal structure
HH
base
indenyl anion Ind
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
13
What is the reason for this ? - ring slippage shown in the mechanism below
The C5 ring is moving from eta-5 to eta-3 back to eta-5 coordination to the rhodium atom. The driving force is that the benzene ring can become fully aromatic when the ring is slipped. This is even more so in fluorenyl. Evidence for ring slippage The ring slipped complex is usually a reactive intermediate and is not observed as a stable compound. However in the following reaction the ring slipped compound can be isolated
(Ind)Ir(PMe2Ph)2 + PMe2Ph → (Ind)Ir(PMe2Ph)3 18 e 20 e ??
Fluorenyl anion Flr
Rh
OC CO
Rh
OC CO
eta-5 eta-3
Rh
OC
eta-3
PPh3
CO
PPh3
Rh
OC PPh3
eta-5
- CO
18 e16 e 18 e
18 e
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
14
The X-ray structure shows that only 3 C atoms of the C5 ring are coordinated to the iridium
The eta-3 coordination means that the bond between the Ir and the indenyl group is weakened and it may be displaced by a further mole of phosphine. The displacement of Cp or Cp related ligands is highly unusual ! 2.6 Heterocycles as Cp analogues The CH group in Cp may be replaced by hetero-atoms to give heterocycles
N (P, As etc) ≡ CH (isolectronic)
C4H4N
- N pyrrolyl C4H4P
- P phospholyl C4H4As
- As arsolyl These anions form π-complexes which are directly analogous to Cp
Ir
PhMe2PPMe2Ph
PMe2Ph
18 e
PMe2Ph
[Ir(PMe2Ph)4]+ Ind-
16 e
N
CpFe(CO)2I +N
N
N
FeFe
OCOC
heat
- 2CO
Aza - ferrocenesigma-complex
[CpFe(CO)2]2 +P
Ph
150 C
P
Fe
Phospha - ferrocene
+ 2P
Li
P
P
FeFeCl2
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
15
The P (and indeed N) atoms have lone pairs and so are capable of acting as ligands in their own right. May be thought of as derivitised phosphine ligands.
Thiophene C4H4S has one extra electron and so behaves as a six-electron donor analogous to benzene
Boroles C4H4BR have one less electron and so behave as four-electron donors. So compare Cp2Fe(CO)4 with (C4H4BMe)2Co(CO)4 - isostructural and iso-electronic compounds.
There are a large number of heterocycles which can act as ligands (see E/S p 376-385 for other examples). The replacement of CH by P for example can go the whole way.
All the P atoms are equivalent and give a singlet at 153 ppm in the 31P NMR spectrum.
P
P
Fe+ 2 Fe(CO)4(THF)
Source of 16 e "Fe(CO)4"
P
P
Fe
Fe(CO)4
Fe(CO)4
S
Cr(CO)3Cr(CO)3
S
Fe Fe
C
O
CO
OC CO
BMe
BMe
Co Co
C
O
CO
OC CO
[Cp*Fe(CO)2]2 +
150 C
PP
PP
P
Fe
Penta phospha - ferrocene
P4
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
16
Topic 3 - Stabilisation of Unstable Molecules by Complexation Transition metals have the remarkable ability to stabilise unstable, unknown or highly reactive organic (and inorganic) molecules. This is because coordination to a metal changes the electron density in the ligand. This facet of organometallic chemistry will be illustrated by a few pertinent examples. 3.1 Unstable molecule - Cyclobutadiene This is a highly strained and unstable molecule. It is non-aromatic, i.e. doesn't obey the (4n+2) π-electron Hückel rule. In fact it is anti-aromatic and is destabilised by a square-planar arrangement of C atoms. This is easily seen by thinking about the π-orbitals in this symmetry (D4h)
The four π-electrons thus give rise to an expected triplet state, which is subject to Jahn-Teller distortion. In fact C4H4 is not square but rectangular with localised double bonds and D2h symmetry,
In 1955, Longuett-Higgins and Orgel predicted theoretically that the aromatic square form of C4H4 would be stabilised by complexation to a transition-metal. The synthesis of such a complex was soon accomplished.
v antibonding slightly antibonding bonding
ψ−4 ψ−3, ψ−2 ψ−1
ψ−1
ψ−3, ψ−2
ψ−4
H H
HH t-Bu H
t-But-Bu
highly reactive stable because of steric restraints
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
17
In 1959 the nickel complex of tetramethylcyclobutadiene was synthesised and the X-ray crystal structure determined. The Ni(CO)4 also abstracts the two chlorine atoms and NiCl2 is a by-product. The C-C distances are ~ 1.45Å which is intermediate between a single and double bond. The first complex of the parent unsubstituted cyclobutadiene was made in a similar way
This compound is a low melting yellow crystalline complex with a signal at 3.91 ppm in the 1H NMR spectrum and two ν(CO) stretches in the IR spectrum, consistent with the pseudo three-fold symmetry. This reaction also proceeds by halogen abstraction and it is a general reaction for the synthesis of complexes of cyclobutadiene (and substituted cyclobutadienes)
The anion [Mo(CO)5]2- is a powerful nucleophile. Another synthetic route for
cyclobutadiene complexes is through the dimerisation of alkynes. This is a thermally forbidden reaction (Woodward-Hoffman rules) but with the mediation of a transition metal, this may be overcome
3.1.1 Physical properties In complexes the ring is essentially square-planar. If all distances are approximately equal, this indicates bond delocalisation and a fully conjugated π-system. Some structures however show partial double bond localisation. The ring has aromatic properties, for example the 1H NMR signals of the CH ring protons are in the range 4 - 6 ppm, similar to Cp protons.
H3C CH3
CH3H3C
Cl
Cl+ Ni(CO)4
Ni Ni
Cl
ClCl
Cl
+ Fe2(CO)9
Cl
Cl
Fe
OC COCO
+ FeCl2 + 6 CO
2 Na+ [Mo(CO)5]2-
Cl
Cl
Mo
OC CO
COOC
CoCo
COCO
RC CR+ 2
R
RR
R
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
18
3.1.2 Chemical reactivity 3.1.2.1 Spectator role The cyclobutadiene ligand is often a "spectator" ligand in much the same way as Cp
In the latter complex the butadiene ligand act as steric "plugs" preventing access to the metal atom 3.1.2.2 Reactivity at ring Electrophilic substitution occurs very readily and in a very similar fashion to Cp. For example the Vilsmeier reaction gives aldehyde substitued ring product
Organic functional groups also show the same reactivity as with Cp rings.
Likewise the stabilisation of the α-carbonium ion occurs in a similar fashion to Cp
Fe(CO)3 Fe(CO)2(PPh3)
+ PPh3
Fe Fe
CO
C
O
CO
18 e with triple FeFe bond
hv
Fe(CO)3 Fe(CO)3
N C
H
O
Ph
Me H2O
POCl3+
O
H
Fe(CO)3
O
H
Fe(CO)3 Fe(CO)3
Fe(CO)3
CH2OH CH2Cl
CH3
BH4- HCl
LiAlH4
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
19
3.1.2.3 Release of free cyclobutadiene Low temperature oxidation with mild oxidants such as Cerium(+4) oxidises the Fe atom and releases free cyclobutadiene. This is highly reactive and it is prepared in situ with the reactive substrate. This reaction may be used in organic synthesis. A nice example is the preparation of cubane in E/S p315
2. Unstable molecule - Trimethylene methane This molecule C4H6 is an isomer of butadiene. It is extremely unstable in the free state since it doesn't obey the conventional rules of bonding.
Fe(CO)3
CH2Cl
Fe(CO)3
+
Fe(CO)3
Fe(CO)3
CH2+ CH2
CH2OH
SbCl5 HCl
OH-
H2C C
CH2
CH2
butadiene trimethylene methane
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
20
Stable complexes of this ligand (and derivatives) can be easily made, in an extension of the routes used to make the cyclobutadiene complexes.
FeCl2 is formed as a byproduct from halide abstraction. The four C atoms are not quite coplanar so the shape is a little like an umbrella, with the exterior CH2 groups bending towards the Fe atom. The whole ligand acts as a four electron donor
The crystal structure of this complex is shown above. The six H atoms are equivalent and the complex adopts a staggered geometry, as shown by a view down the 3-fold axis
How is this odd molecule bonded to the transition metal ? Need to consider the lowest lying π-orbitals
H2C CCH2Cl
CH2Cl+ Fe2(CO)9
H2CCH2
Fe(CO)3
CH2
Fe
COOC
CO
H H
H
HH
H
e symmetry non-bonding
a1 symmetry bonding
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
21
The a1 is the σ-donor orbital and the e set are the π-acceptor orbitals. The Fe(CO)3 fragment has a similar set (as far as symmetry is concerned) of orbitals which provide a perfect match
The bonding is thus the "classical" σ-donotion from ligand and π-back-donation from metal. This orbital approach provides a delocalised view of the bonding and avoids the problems with the conventional view of localised bonds. The coordination geometry of the Fe atoms is roughly octahedral and there is a high barrier to rotation about the 3-fold axis. This barrier cannot be observed in the Fe(CO)3 complex, because all 6 protons are equivalent anyway. In order to observe any barrier, we need to make them chemically inequivalent. So choose an ML3 fragment which does not have 3-fold symmetry
All six H's are now chemically inequivalent (the compound is chiral) and even at elevated temperatures, there are 6 signals between -0.1 and 3.5 ppm in the 1H NMR spectrum, showing that if rotation occurs that it must have a high barrier. 3. Unstable molecule - Benzyne This molecule is highly strained and hence very reactive, but is stable in an inert matrix at 8o K. The alkyne group should be linear - hence the strain. Benzyne can be made in situ by abstraction of HCl from chlorobenzene, using a very strong base such as sodamide NaNH2. The generated benzyne may be trapped using a diene such as cyclopentadiene by the Diels-Alder reaction
high lying sigma acceptor
sp hybrid
high lying pi-acceptor and low lying pi-donor
derived from eg
IrCl(CO)(PPh3) + H2CCH2SiMe3
CH2Cl
Ir
PPh3OC
Cl
H H
H
HHH
- SiMe3Cl
Benzyne
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
22
Simple and stable benzyne complexes of transition metals are known, for example
Benzyne has obvious similarities to alkynes in its complexes. Quite a few are known for cluster compounds
Os3(CO)12 + C6H6 → H2Os3(CO)9(C6H4) The alkyne "dances" around the three Os-Os edges
4. Unstable molecule - E2 (E=As,Sb, Bi) analogues of N2 While N2 is the stable form of elemental nitrogen, the corresponding molecules P2, As2, Sb2 and Bi2 are not stable at room temperature. While P2, As2, Sb2 have been observed in mass spectra at high temperatures, Bi2 is wholly unknown. However, when coordinated to transition metals, these molecules may be isolated at room temperature.
The Bi2 ligand with a formal Bi≡Bi triple bond is analogous to alkynes RC≡CR
Ta
H3C
H3CCH3
Ta
H3C
H3C
heat
- CH4
(OC)3Co Co(CO)3
CH
CH
(OC)3Co Co(CO)3
Bi
Bi
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
23
The "Mercedes Benzenes" have a similarly E2 group (E=As, Sb, Bi) coordinated to three M(CO)5 groups (M = Mo, W). They are made by the simple reaction
ECl3 + [M2(CO)10]2- → E2[M(CO)5]3
The structures of typical examples are shown below, both schematically and in 3D.
Mercedes Benzene
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
24
Topic 4 - Reactivity of Coordinated Olefin Complexes 4.1 Introduction The coordination of ligands to metals can, in general, quite substantially change not only the stability (as shown in previous topic) but also the reactivity of the ligand. The reason for this is that coordination to a metal changes the electron distribution within the ligand. As an example to show why this happens, consider the case of butadiene
The ligand π-orbitals (frontier orbitals) are the most important in bonding to the metal. Assuming the conformation found in complexes, we get
(OC)3Fefree ligand
ENERGY
LUMO
Ψ-4
Ψ-3
Ψ-2
Ψ-1
(δ)
(π)
(π)
(σ)
π-orbitals of butadiene
(+)
(+)
(+)
(+)
(+)(+)
(+)
(+)
(+)
(+)
(-)(-)
(-)
(-)
(-)
(-)
coefficients are either 0.37 or 0.60
HOMO
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
25
The coefficients of each basis p-orbital on the C atoms tells us qualitatively about the bonding/antibonding nature of each of the orbitals • Orbital Ψ-1 provides π-bonding between all atoms, but more so between the
two inner C-atoms. • Orbital Ψ-2 provides π-bonding between the inner and outer C-atoms, but is
antibonding between the two inner atoms. • Orbital Ψ-3 provides π-bonding between the two inner C-atoms, but is
antibonding between the inner and outer C-atoms. • Orbital Ψ-4 is antibonding between all C-atoms but is not occupied or used. For the ground state, the bonding is the sum of Ψ-1 and Ψ-2, which leads to a higher π-bond order between the inner and outer atoms (as expected from conventional ideas). For the excited state, the partial population of Ψ-3 and partial depopulation of Ψ-2 leads to an inversion of π-bond orders compared with the ground state. This is the simple Hückel picture of bonding. Coordination of butadiene to a metal fragment such as Fe(CO)3 uses the same orbitals as previously shown
Ψ-1
Ψ-2
Ψ-3
Ψ-4
π-bond order bond lengths
0.89
0.44 1.48Å
1.34Å
ground state
Ψ-1
Ψ-2
Ψ-3
Ψ-4
π-bond order bond lengths
0.44
0.72 1.39Å
1.45Å
excited state
high lying sigma acceptor
sp hybrid
high lying pi-acceptor and low lying pi-donor
derived from eg
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
26
These orbitals interact with the ligand orbitals to give delocalised bonds of σ- and π-symmetry (the δ-orbital is too high lying and has no symmetry match with any metal orbital). The synergic bonding between metal and ligand redistributes the electron population of the butadiene in a similar fashion as that explained above for the excited state. Thus qualitatively we can see that : (a) changes in the relative populations of the frontier orbitals of the ligand can change the bonding density in the ligand. Some examples show the effects on the bond lengths.
The arrows show the direction of flow of electrons and the numbers are the bond lengths in Ă units. The Fe fragment is electron rich and the Zr fragment is electron deficient. In the case of the Fe compound there is thus a small population of the LUMO of butadiene, while in the Zr compound there is a small withdrawal from the HOMO of butadiene. In terms of the valence bond approach, it is possible to view the bonding as arising from two extreme canonical forms
Early transition metals such as Zr which are electron deficient are more like B, while later transition metals such as Fe are electron rich and more like A (b) The orbital approach also allows us to rationalise the site of attack of the incoming nucleophile. The LUMO of butadiene has most of the wavefunction on the outer C-atoms and the lone pair of the nucleophile will seek this, hence leading to preferential attack at the outer carbon atom. The reaction of nucleophile with electrophile is a Lewis acid-base interaction.
(OC)3Fe
1.41
1.45
Cp2Zr
1.45
1.40
MLn MLn
A B
Nu
better overlap here than at the inner C atom
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
27
A number of MO studies of individual complexes has led to a set of simple rules for determining the site of nucleophilic attack at unsaturated hydrocarbon ligands in cationic metal complexes. 4.2 Green/Mingos/Davies Rules (GMD) for Nucleophilic Addition Normally, unsaturated hydrocarbons are not at all susceptible to nucleophilic addition. On coordination into a CATIONIC metal complex this changes, and attack by nucleophiles to give addition products is well known. The increase in susceptibility to nucleophilic attack arises because there is a net flow of electrons from the ligand to the metal (i.e akin to introducing electron withdrawing substituents). An example from organic chemistry of this enhancement is the attack on the bromonium ion by the relatively weak nucleophile Br- during the bromination of alkenes.
The nucleophilic additions to transition metal complexes are generally very regio-specific, i.e only one out of a possible number of products are formed. For attack on 18-electron organometallic cations, where reactions are kinetically controlled, the most favourable position for nucleophilic attack is given by the GMD rules. Some definitions are needed first. Hydrocarbon ligands described as even or odd and as open or closed Even n = 2,3,4 ...... Odd n = 3,5,7 .... refers to the η number, i.e. how many C-atoms of ligand are
bonded to the metal Open not cyclically conjugated Closed cyclically conjugated Rule1 Nucleophilic attack prefers EVEN polyenes with no unpaired
electrons in their HOMO.Cyclo-C4R4 only common example) EVEN before C4R4 before ODD
Rule2 OPEN before CLOSED
Rule3 For even open polyenes, attack occurs at terminal C-atom.
For odd open polyenes, attack occurs at terminal C-atom only if MLn is strongly electron withdrawing
Br
Br-
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
28
Rules are best illustrated by examples
Even before odd. NOTE that the nucleophile attacks from the EXO position
Open before closed Attack occurs at terminal C-atom of conjugated system
M M M
eta-5 eta-5 eta-5
odd closed odd open odd open
M M M
even closed even open even open
eta-6 eta-4 eta-4
Fe
eta-5 odd
eta-6 even
FeFe
H
Et
cyclohexadienyl
Et
H
EtMgCl
Et
Rh
eta-5 closed
eta-5 open
Rh
H
H
NaBH4
H
Rh
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
29
Rules need to be applied sequentially. Consider the case of the Mo+ cation shown below when treated with hydride source (BH4
-)
Rule 1 even before odd - therefore allyl NOT attacked Rule 2 open before closed - therefore butadiene attacked Rule3 terminal C-atom - therefore product the methylallyl complex Another way of expressing Rules 1 & 2 is that the order of reactivity of unsaturated hydrocarbons coordinated to cations is as shown below
It can be seen that Cp is the least reactive - this explains it's stability and role as a "spectator" ligand. It may be used to design complexes for nucleophilic addition to even ligands and allyl and pentadienyl ligands. CAVEAT Cations which contain only ONE unsaturated hydrocarbon ligand and at least ONE carbonyl ligand may undergo nucleophilic attack at the CO. This most often occurs with nucleophiles having heteroatoms as the nucleophilic site (e.g. methoxide -OCH3) and when choice is between a CO and an eta-5 ligand.
When there is more than one unsaturated ligand, the normal MGD rules apply again, e.g. for [(C5H5)Mo(CO)3(C2H4)]
+ attack occurs at the ethene ligand.
Mo
eta-6 even closed
eta-3 odd open eta-4 even open
Mo
Me
BH4
Os
OCCO
CO
Os
OCCO
O
OMe
OMe
Os
OCCO
CO
slow isomerisation
MeO
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
30
Topic 5 - Carbene and Carbyne Complexes Textbooks : E/S pages 210 - 220 5.1 Introduction Carbene :CH2 is a highly reactive and unstable molecule. Carbene itself can be made by the thermal decomposition of diazomethane
CH2N2 → N2 + :CH2 → (CH2)n polymerises to "polythene" Chlorocarbene is also easily made
CHCl3 + strong base → :CCl2 (reactive intermediate) Carbenes may be stabilised by coordination to transition metals, as in this
example of the formation of a carbene complex directly from carbene. This reaction is the organometallic analogue of the reaction of carbenes with alkenes to give cyclopropanes. Carbenes are thus further example of unstable molecules which are stabilised by coordination to transition metals. Relatively recently, stable carbenes at room temperature have been synthesised by Arduengo - contain N-heterocycles.
The terms carbene complex and alkylidene complex and also carbyne complex and alkylidyne complex are used interchangeably. 5.2 Fischer Synthesis of Carbene Complexes Carbene complexes were first made in 1964 by E.O. Fischer who subsequently won a Nobel Prize for his work. The synthesis is based on the nucleophilic addition of heteroatom nucleophiles to coordinated CO (see last part of Topic 4).
Rh Rh
OC
CO
+ CH2N2 Rh Rh
OC
COCH2
NNRR
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
31
The lithium intermediate is unstable and methylation with Me+ reagents result in thermally stable and isolable carbene complexes. Many examples of this type are now known, most with OR or NR2 substituents. These have several resonance forms.
The latter canonical form bears a positive charge on the carbene carbon, and so may be expected to be electrophilic at this atom. 5.3 Schrock Synthesis of Carbene Complexes This is the other very important route to carbene complexes, of quite a different character to those made by Fischer. The reaction was the treatment of the
neopentyl (Np) alkyl complex of tantalum Np3TaCl2 with two moles of the lithium reagent LiNp. The original purpose of the experiment was the synthesise TaNp5 but the actual product was much more interesting (as is often the case in organometallic chemistry). The first stage involves an α-deprotonation step, whereby a proton from one neopentyl group is transferred to another neopentyl group. This releases the volatile hydrocarbon neopentane (tetramethyl methane) which is one of the driving forces for this reaction. This α-deprotonation of alkyl groups ONLY occurs with very sterically bulky groups and is unusual. A related reaction forming carbenes is that of hydride abstraction from methyl groups
WOC
OC CO
CO
CO
CO
WOC
OC CO
CO
CO
C
WOC
OC CO
CO
CO
C
R OLi R OCH3
(i) (ii)
(i) nucleophilic addition to CO with LiR(ii) methylation using Me3O+ BF4-
LnM C
OR
R
LnM C
OR
R
LnM C
OR
R
(Me3CH2)3Ta
Cl
Cl
TaNp5(Np)2ClTa
CH2CMe3
HC
H
CMe3
Np2Ta
Cl
C
CMe3
H
- CMe4
LiNp
LiNpTaNp3 C
H
CMe3
Np = neopentyl = Me3CCH2-
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
32
The two research groups of Fischer and Schrock have developed the chemistry of these carbenes, which are intrinsically different. The most important differences lie in their reactivity. • Fischer carbenes have π-donor hetero-substituents and are electrophilic at
the carbene • Schrock carbenes have alkyl (or H) substituents and are nucleophilic at the
carbene 5.4 Evidence for Multiple Bonding 1. X-ray Structures. These show (i) planar trigonal sp2 C
(ii) M=C bonds is shorter than a single bond, but not as short as M-CO bond
2. 13C NMR chemical shifts are in the region 200-400 ppm - cited as evidence for a δ(+) charge on C 3. MO picture predicts a barrier to free rotation in Fischer carbenes, which is observed in NMR spectra. Also the observed inequivalence of CR2 groups in Schrock carbenes in the NMR spectra also indicates a very high barrier to rotation about M=C bond
Re
L
ONCH3
Re
L
ONCH2
Ph3C BF4 + Ph3CH
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
33
5.5 Why the distinction between Fischer and Schrock carbenes ? The table below lists their general properties and differences Property Fischer Schrock
Nature of carbene carbon Electrophilic Nucleophilic Typical R group π-donor (e.g. -OR) Alkyl, H Typical metal Mo(0), Fe(0) Tav(V), W(VI) Typical ancilliary ligands Good π-acceptors - CO Cl, Cp, alkyl Electron count 2e 2e Oxidation state change on addition of CR2 to metal
0 +2
Actually not easy to provide a convincing explanation for the difference. The MO scheme suggests that while both ligands are effective σ-donors • the Fischer carbene is a π-acid • the Schrock carbene is a π-base
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
34
5.6 Reactivity of Fischer carbenes Fischer carbenes are readily susceptible to nucleophilic substitution
The analogy between metal carbenes and organic ketones is quite strong. For another example, compare their reactions with P-ylides:
Another important reaction is with alkenes to give metallocycles, which in turn decompose to give re-arranged alkenes. This is the so called "alkene metathesis" reaction, which is of major commercial importance. The resultant olefin has the =CPh(OMe) group from the carbene complex and the =CH2 group from the starting CH2=CH(OR) alkene. This re-arrangement involves breaking a very strong C=C double bond, and is impossible without the presence of the organometalic carbene catalyst
(OC)5Cr
CH3
OCH3
(OC)5Cr
CH3
NHEt
(OC)5Cr
CH3
Ph
NH2Et
+ MeOH
+ MeOH
PhLi
(OC)5Cr
CH3
Ph
OCH3Mechanism involves the intermediate
Similar to amminolysis of esters
O
CH3
OCH3
NH2R O
CH3
OCH3
O
CH3
NHR
NHR
H
(OC)5W
Ph
OCH3
H2C
Ph
OCH3Ph3P=CH2+ (CO)5WPPh3
compare with Wittig reaction
O
Ph
Ph
H2C
Ph
PhPh3P=CH2+ OPPh3
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
35
Carbene complexes are excellent catalysts for the general alkene metathesis reaction
R2C=CR'2 + R''2C=CR'''2 → R2C=CR''2 + R'2C=CR'''2 etc 5.7 Reactivity of Schrock carbenes Schrock carbenes behave much like ylides
They are easily attacked by electrophiles (i.e. behave as nucleophiles) - two example reactions are
One of the most useful carbene compounds is Tebbe's reagent.
(OC)5Cr
Ph
OCH3
OR
(OC)5Cr
C
OR
Ph OCH3
(OC)5Cr
C
Ph OCH3
OR
(OC)5Cr
H
OR
Ph
OCH3
+
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
36
The reagent is released by the treatment with ammine bases NR3. It behaves as a carbene transfer reagent, and has a number of specialised uses.
"Cp2Ti=CH2" + RC(O)OR' → R(OR')C=CH2 This has the useful advantage over Wittig's reagents in the same reaction in that it works !!. When used with enolisable ketones it does not result in racemisation.
While the distinction between Fischer and Schrock carbenes is a useful one, it should be realised that this distinction is not rigid, but merely represents two extremes. An example of an "in-between" carbene is Roper's carbene based on osmium, which shows both types of reactivity, depending on the substrate. SO2 here is acting as an electrophile, while CO is acting as a nucleophile. The "in-between" character of Roper's carbene is sensible in terms of the descriptions given in the Table, as there are both π-donors (chloride ligand) and π-acceptors (nitrosyl ligand) and the carbene carbon has no π-donor substituents. 5.8 Carbyne complexes Carbyne complexes have a CR group attached to a metal atom, with a triple M≡C bond. Their chemistry is closely related to those of carbenes :
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
37
The evidence for a triple bond comes from crystal structures, which show a very short M-C bond. Moreover the M-C-R angle is close to 180o indicative of linear sp hybridisation. The bonding of the C atom to a metal is quite similar to that of CO, with a sigma-donation and pi-back donation to the (unhybridised) p-orbitals of the carbyne atom
The reactions of carbyne complexes show some similarities with carbene complexes. Thus alkyne metathesis with carbyne complexes as catalysts is possible.
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
38
This is usually only possible with alkyl or aryl R groups. Carbyne complexes may be thought of as "half-inorganic" analogues of alkynes
For instance the analogy is obvious by comparing these reactions
The PtW2 compound can also be viewed as a cluster of 3 metals with two bridging CR groups
In fact, carbynes (or alklidynes) are very common as bridging ligands. One particular well know series of very stable compounds can be easily made Co2(CO)8 + CRX3 (X=Cl, Br, I) → CoX2 + Co3(µ3-CR)(CO)9 - "Fred" A huge variety of derivatives with different R groups have been made and extensive chemistry is known. The structure of the simplest CH derivative is shown. The three cobalt atoms and the bridging carbon make up a tetrahedron
L.J. Farrugia : MSc Core2 Course C5 - Reactivity of Transition Metal Organometallics
39
Using the reactions described above it was possible to synthesise a related compound with three different metal atoms. Because the vertices of the tetrahedron were all different, the compound is chiral and it is possible to resolve these chiral clusters by making derivatives with homo-chiral phosphines PRR'R''. They have proved to be some of the most chiral molecules made (i.e. have the highest molar rotation coefficients).