AESE, Inc.
Primary restoration versus “replace or acquire the equivalent” of tribal reserved
lands under NRDA
Dr. F.E. Kirschner, LHYG, LG
ACES, December 10, 2010
Phoenix, Az
AESE, Inc.
A Little About Us . . .
AESE, Inc.
Current Superfund/NRDA Projects
• Midnite Uranium Mine Superfund RI/FS and NRDA, Spokane WA
• Bunker Hill Mine Superfund RI/FS and NRDA, Kellogg, ID
• Upper Columbia River Superfund RI/FS and NRDA, Spokane WA
• Leviathan Mine Superfund RI/FS and NRDA, Carson City, NV
• Anaconda-Yerington Superfund RI/FS and NRDA, Yerington, NV
• Sulphur Bank Mercury Mine Superfund RI/FS and NRDA, Clearlake, CA
• International Paper Superfund RI/FS and NRDA, Leech Lake, MN
• Hanford Nuclear Reservation, Hanford, WA
• Tar Creek Superfund RI/FS and NRDA, Miami, OK
• Onondaga Lake Superfund RI/FS and NRDA, NY
AESE, Inc.
Other Areas
• Tribal Surface Water Quality Standards
• Tribal Hazardous Substances Codes
• Tribal Integrated Resource Management Plans
• Tribal-Specific Human Health Risk
• Tribal-Specific Resource Advisories
AESE, Inc.AESE, Inc.
I. Goals of RI/FS: Cleanup that is protective of Human Health and the environment.
II. Goal of NRDA: Return Natural Resources
and use of those Natural Resources to their original states (Make Tribe Whole Again)
AESE, Inc.
EPA-RI/FS (aka the dark side)
NRDA
Tribal/Federal “CERCLA Universe”
AESE, Inc.
NRDA
EPA-RI/FS (aka the dark side)
TRIBAL LOSS
Federal “CERCLA Universe”
Tribal “Universe”
AESE, Inc.
NRDA
EPA-RI/FS
TRIBE
AESE, Inc.
Spokane Reservation
1. Reservation can be conceptualized as an Island with Finite Resources
2. Each Acre Lost to Contamination (or Stigma Associated with Contamination) or Development Results In:
• Reduction of the Carrying-Capacity of the Land (Number of Members Able to Practice Traditional Cultural Lifeways)
• Members Currently Practicing Traditional Lifeways Must Relinquish Some Uses to Other Members
Bottom Line: ALL Land is Highly Valuable to the Tribe and therefore must be Preserved for All Future Uses (PAFU)
AESE, Inc.
A little about the SpokaneLarge portion of current members are subsistence hunters, fishers, and gatherers
Culture is not classical anthropocentric (utilitarian). Ecology is considered just an extension of the temporary person.
“The environment is what makes a Spokane, Spokane. And the reservation is the only place where I can, and where my children and there children’s children will be Spokane.”
-- Rudy Peone
AESE, Inc.
EPA’s RELIANCE ON PERPETUAL OR LONG-TERM INSTITUTIONAL CONTROLS IN REMEDIES ON TRIBAL LANDS COULD BE CONSTRUED AS TANTAMOUNT TO EXPROPRIATION
expropriation…the action of the state in taking of modifying the property rights of an individual in the exercise of its sovereignty (Webster).
EPA’s REMEDIAL ACTION TOOL BOX:1. REMOVE
2. CONTAIN/CONTROL3. INSTITUTIONAL CONTROLS (HANG A SIGN ON IT)
Little environmental contact.Few exposure pathways.Some environmental recreationGroundwater release
Air release
Simplified Concept of a Suburban Exposure Scenario
AESE, Inc
GAMEPROCESSING
AIR AND DUSTINHALATION
GAME MEAT
GARDEN PRODUCE
WETLANDSRESOURCES
MONTANERESOURCES
CULTURALACTIVITIES
GROUNDWATER
AQUATIC FOODS
GATHEREDFOODSSURFACE
WATER USE
IRRIGATION
DESERT RESOURCES
RIPARIANRESOURCES
SEDIMENTEXPOSURE
DIRECT SOILEXPOSURE
A Traditional Environmental Knowledge-based Scenario
AESE, Inc
AESE, Inc.
The Spokane Tribe’s Multipathway Subsistence Exposure
Scenario and Screening Level RME
Barbara L. Harper, Brian Flett, Stuart Harris, Corn Abeyta, and Fred Kirschner
Risk Analysis, Vol. 22, No. 3, 2002
509.924.0184
GreensPine Nuts Roots
XX Tribe’s Food Pyramid2500 kcal/day –
(Quantities of each food group by %)(Not an exhaustive species list)
Berries,Other
Unique Pathways:• Sweat Lodge• Other cultural
More resource use:• more species• more habitats• more native foods
and medicines
Greater Contact:• more water• more soil ingestion
RESULT: Subsistence lifestyles result in 10 to 100 times more exposure than suburban lifestyles.
Drinking Water 2 liters per day 4+ liters per day
Fish Ingestion 17.5 grams/day 500-1000+grams/day
Duration of exposure 30 years 70 years (+ generations)
Exposure Factor Suburban Subsistence
Frequency of exposure 180 days/year 365 days/year
AESE, Inc.
Sweat Lodge, other NO YES
EPA (Omernick) Ecoregions
Scenarios – EPA Star Grant (OSU; Harper) and/or mixed funding
Scenarios – other funding sources
Spokane(complete)
Umatilla(complete)
Swinomish(in progress)
Washoe(complete)
Ojibwe(in progress)
Maine Tribes(in progress)
Elem (Pomo)(in progress)
Quapaw (in progress)
AESE, Inc.
“4 out of 5 People in the World Use Plants as their Main Source of Medicine”
Dr. Mark Plotkin (Ethnobotanist)
Plotkin is the author of several books, and has been named an environmental "Hero for the Planet" by Time magazine.
AESE, Inc.
Summary 1
• If a Tribe is Not Consulted Early, Cleanup will be based on State ARARs or Federal Health Standards/Goals for the General Public.
• These Circumstances Result in a Very Large Future Residual for NRDA (Return to Baseline Services)
AESE, Inc.
"an eye for an eye", is a quotation from several passages of the Hebrew Bible (Leviticus 24:19–21, Exodus 21:22–25, and Deuteronomy 19:16-21) in which a person who has injured the eye of another is instructed to give the value of his or her own eye in compensation. It defined and restricted the extent of retribution in the laws of the Torah.
Restoration, Rehabilitation, Replacement, and/or acquire the equivalent of…
"an eye for an eye", or the “principle of exact reciprocity” is very clearly used concept in the Code of Hammurabi
HEA is merely an attempt to achieve equivalency
AESE, Inc.
HUMANS
Ecosystems SimplifiedThe “Headwaters” of all Resource Service Flows for a Given Physical Setting Originate with Indigenous Abiotic Media Replacement of Indigenous Abiotic
Media within a Similar Physical Setting will Restore all Service Flows
…as Long as Legal Rights and Proximity to Users is not an Issue
AESE, Inc.
Four “Ends of the Spatial Spectra”
AESE, Inc.
No Off-Reservation
Tribal Reserved Rights
Tribal Owned
Other Owned
Tribal Government Owns Nearly All Lands within their Reservation and the N&E is Fully Contained within the Reservation Boundary
Extent of Contamination
AESE, Inc.
Off-Reservation Tribal Reserved
Rights
Tribal Owned
Other Owned
Tribal Government Owns Some Lands within their Reservation and the N&E is Fully Contained within the Reservation Boundary
Extent of Contamination
AESE, Inc.
Reserved Rights
Tribal Owned
N&E Wholly Outside of the Reservation Boundary, but Impacting Resources in which Rights are Reserved for the Tribe
Extent of Contamination
AESE, Inc.
Reserved Rights
Tribal Owned
•N&E Wholly Encompasses the Reservation, AND Impacts ALLResources in which Rights are Reserved for the Tribe
Extent of Contamination
AESE, Inc.
These examples are further complicated, when attempting replace specific habitat, which is even more scarce
Baseline Quality Habitat
ReservedNR Rights
ReservedRights for Self Governance
AESE, Inc.
A More Typical Situation…
Baseline Quality Habitat Reserved
NR Rights
ReservedRights for Self Governance
…requiring expansion of Reserved Rights for Self Governance and Reserved Rights for Unlimited Use of Natural Resources
AESE, Inc.