Download - Positive Accounting Theory
ACCOUNTING THEORY AND PRACTICE
FAR 600
Positive Accounting Theory
By:Prof Madya Dr Roshayani Arshad
Faculty of AccountancyUiTM
04/08/23
1
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
At the end of this lesson, students should be able to:Contracting theory Agency theoryPolitical processes
04/08/23
2
POSITIVE ACCOUNTING
THEORY
04/08/23Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
3
04/08/23
4
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES
Economic consequences is a concept that asserts that, despite the implications of
efficient securities market theory, accounting policy choice can affect firm
value.(Scott, W.R., 2003, p.259)
04/08/23
5
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
Despite implications of efficient market theory, accounting policy choice have economic consequences for various constituencies of financial statement users
Standard setting bodies includes different constituencies in their board in order to reach a consensus between accounting and political demands.
THE RISE OF ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES
Economic consequences as defined by Zeff (1978) the impact of accounting reports on the decision-making behavior of business,
government and creditors. (Scott, 2003, p.261)
Third party interventions complicate the setting of accounting standards because they try to influence or influenced the accounting the standard setting bodies
Example: attempt by several US corporations to implement replacement cost accounting during the period of high inflation (1947-1948)
04/08/23
6
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
THE RISE OF ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES
Since there is no theory that clearly prescribes what accounting policies should be used other than a vague requirement tradeoff between relevance and reliability is necessary
This opens the door for various other constituencies to argue for their preferred accounting policies
Hence standards setting requires both the accounting theory domain as well as the political domain
04/08/23
7
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
PHILOSOPHY OF PAT A science to predict unobservable phenomena
and seeks to explain observed accounting phenomena by searching for the reasons events occur
‘The objective of (positive) accounting theory is to explain and predict accounting practice … Explanation means providing reasons for observed practice. For example, positive accounting theory seeks to explain why firms continue to use historical coat accounting and why certain firms switch between a number of accounting techniques. Prediction of accounting practice means that the theory predicts unobserved phenomena. (Watts & Zimmerman, 1986, p.2)
04/08/23
8
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
PHILOSOPHY OF PAT
Economic focus
i.e., focus on the costs and benefits of the alternative
accounting methods, regulations & accounting std setting
process & the effects of reported FS on share prices.
More scientific in methodology i.e., empirically
explaining & predicting what occurs.
Central idea is to develop hypotheses about factors
that influence the world of accounting practices and
to test the validity of these hypotheses empirically.
04/08/23
9
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
NATURE OF NORMATIVE THEORY & ITS LIMITATIONS
Prescribes what should occur or the best way to account
Limitations Normative presupposes PAT (Jensen, 1983)
Normative not based on identified, empirical observations & methods (Watts & Zimmerman , 1986)
‘Valid prescription requires specification of both an objective and an objective function.’ (p.7)
Normative produces irrefutable prescriptions (Popper, 1968)
‘No amount of empirical testing can prove a theory to be correct – i.e. tests of a theory against real-world data - but a theory should be refutable or capable of falsification.’ 04/08/23
10
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
04/08/23
Copyright@2004 by
Rohana Oth
man. All
Rights
Reserved.
11
SCOPE OF PAT
Capital Market Research (CMR)
Efficient market hypothesis (EMH)
Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM)
Positive Accounting Theory
Accounting Policy Choice (APC)
Opportunistic reasons
Efficiency reasons
04/08/23
Copyright@2004 by
Rohana Oth
man. All
Rights
Reserved.
12
SCOPE OF PAT PAT attempts to understand & predicts
firm’s APC PAT asserts that firms need APC to minimize
contracting costs PAT implies it is more efficient for firm to
have a set of accounting policies (GAAP) from which management can choose
However, this flexibility in APC opens the door to opportunistic management behavior
04/08/23
Copyright@2004 by
Rohana Oth
man. All
Rights
Reserved.
13
SCOPE OF PAT Efficiency assume that internal control systems limit
opportunism and motivate managers to choose
accounting policies that minimize contracting costs.
Sweeney (1994) found that managers change
accounting policies only when it was cost effective &
Dechow (1994) further confirmed Sweeneys’ findings.
Both the above studies confirmed that managers
choose accounting policies more for efficiency reasons
rather than opportunistic reasons.
04/08/23
Copyright@2004 by
Rohana Oth
man. All
Rights
Reserved.
14
SCOPE OF PAT PAT developed in two stages
First-stage literature did not explain accounting
practice. The earlier of the two stages involved
research into accounting and the behaviour of capital
markets
Second-stage literature sought to explain and predict
accounting practices across firms
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN NORMATIVE THEORY AND POSITIVE THEORY
Normative theory: what they should do What is a good normative theory: it is judged by its logical consistency with
underlying assumptions of how rational individuals should behave
Positive theory: to predict which acct policy firms will choose
04/08/23
15
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
THE RELATION BETWEEN NORMATIVE THEORY AND POSITIVE
Both are valuable to theory development and
testing
Positive theory helps to keep the normative
research on track by empirical testing
04/08/23
16
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
STRENGTH OF PAT
04/08/23
17
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
WHY PAT? What was? What is? What ought to be?
A theory that is consistent with the existence of economic consequences
explain or predict real world phenomenon and are tested empirically
Based on scientific methodology using economic based empirical literature
Enable theories to be refuted, to explain & predict, to rationalize accounting principles and to model connection between accounting, firms & markets
Attempt to understand why accounting policies matter and predict which accounting policies firms will choose
04/08/23
18
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
PAT HYPOTHESES Predictions made by PAT largely organized around
3 hypotheses formulated by Watts & Zimmerman (1996), all other things being equal:The Bonus Plan Hypothesis
Choose accounting policy that shift reported earnings from future periods to the current period
The Debt Covenant Hypothesis Firm with prospect of violating accounting-based debt
covenants (e.g. going below the agreed specified level of debt equity ratio) would shift reported earnings from future periods to current periods
The Political Cost Hypothesis Choose accounting policy that defer reported earnings from
current to future periods.
04/08/23
19
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
PAT HYPOTHESES
Managers of firms with bonus plan predicted to choose less conservative accounting policy & oppose
accounting standards that may lower reported net income than managers of firms without such plan
Managers of firms with high debt-to-equity ratio Choose less conservative accounting policy & oppose new
standards that may lower reported net income.
Managers of large firms Choose more conservative accounting policies & less likely
to oppose new standards that may lower reported net income.
04/08/23
20
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
POSITIVE THEORIES
‘Experiences’ or ‘facts’ of the real world
explaining reasons for current practice
predicting how accounting information is used in economic decision-making
04/08/23
21
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
NATURE OF POSITIVE THEORIES
Provide description of what accounting is Descriptive, inferential & objective Objective of PAT is to explain & predict
accounting practice A science to predict unobserved phenomena Observable & verifiable Derived inductively from specific set of
observation Analytic (logic), semantic & pragmatic
04/08/23
22
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
NATURE OF POSITIVE THEORIES Based on scientific empirical methodology,
relating or testing accounting hypothesis to experience or facts of real world e.g., efficient market hypothesis
Focus on Accounting policy choice Capital market research
Assumptions Efficient capital market A firm is a nexus of contracts Accounting is important in contract enforcement Accounting information is an economic good Managers, investors, lenders & others are assumed to
be rational & evaluative utility maximizer Discretion to choose accounting policies that maximize
their utility and value of firm 04/08/23
23
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
CRITICISMS ON PAT
Positive theory are not value free
VALUE FREE IS NOT ALTERED OR INFLUENCED
BY VALUE JUDGMENT
Value judgment of the rightness or
wrongness or usefulness of something base
on persona; view.
The theories use large-scale statistical
research, remote from practitioners and their
concerns
04/08/23
24
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN NORMATIVE & POSITIVE ACCOUNTING THEORIES
Normative Prescriptive
Prescribed how people should behave
Positive Descriptive, explanatory or predictive
Describe how people behave Explain why people behave in a certain
mannerPredict what people have done or will do
Suggestion: can coexist & complement each other
04/08/23
25
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
CONTRACTING THEORY
Firm is a legal nexus (connection) of contractual relationships
amongst suppliers and consumers of factors of production
Rationale for the firm:
‘it costs less to transact (or contract) through central
organization than to do so individually’
‘firm is an efficient means of organizing economic activity
because they reduce contracting costs’
Hence firm exists to reduce transaction costs
PAT-APC focuses on two main types of agency contracts to
explain accounting practices:
Management contracts (shareholders & managers)
Debt contracts (lenders & managers who is acting on behalf of the
shareholders)04/08/23
26
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
AGENCY THEORY
Developed to explain & predict the actions of agents (e.g. managers) & principals (e.g. shareholders or lenders).
Assumption: no ‘ a priori’ reason to believe that agent will act in the best interest of the principal
Jensen & Meckling (1976) describe an agency relationship arises when there is a contract under which one party (the principal) engages another party (the agent) to perform some service on the principal’s behalf.
Under the contract the principal delegates some decision-making authority to the agent
04/08/23
27
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
AGENCY THEORY – PROBLEM
No reason to believe that the agent will always
act in the principal’s best interests.
Agency problem is the problem of inducing an
agent to behave as if he or she were
maximizing the principal welfare, resulting in
agency cost
04/08/23
28
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
AGENCY THEORY - COSTS Agency costs are costs that arises from
agency relationships (because of the separation of ownership from control of an entity)
Three types of agency costs identified are: Monitoring costs Bonding costs Residual loss
04/08/23
29
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
AGENCY THEORY - MONITORING COSTS
Costs of monitoring the agent’s behavior Expenditure by principal to measure,
observe & control agent’s behavior Examples: mandatory audit costs, cost to
establish management compensation plan, & budget restrictions among others
Price protection is the way the principal protects against agency costs by paying according to the level of costs expected.
Price protection is borne by agents
04/08/23
30
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
AGENCY THEORY - BONDING COSTS
Costs of establishing & complying with mechanisms (bonding agent’s interest with the principal’s interest)
Borne by agents - Price protection resulted in agents ultimately having to bear monitoring costs associated with contracts
Examples: frequent quarterly financial statements
Costs to managers includes: time & effort, constraints, & income forgone
04/08/23
31
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
AGENCY THEORY – RESIDUAL LOSS
Residual loss occur when the net value of the agents’ output is less, when they make decisions that are not entirely in the principal’s interest (deadweight loss)
When the agent make decisions that do not keep the best interest of the principal, it results in residual loss
Strong form efficient market provide information on incentives & opportunities that will trigger the agent to act contrary to the interest of a principal
The agent would then use information to set their remuneration level i.e., the principal will remunerate the agent to the point that the principal expects the agent to likely become contrary to the interest of the principal
Principal is price protected04/08/23
32
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
AGENCY THEORY – SETTLING UP Settling up means the principal review the
remuneration package given to the agent base on the principle that the remuneration level has to tally with the agent’s effort.
If the agent is deemed to have acted more in favor of the interest of the principal the it is likely that the remuneration will be revised upwards
In contrary, remuneration will revise downwards if the agent is deemed to have acted more in contrary to the interest of the principal
If the contract is to be continued then it should start with the remuneration decided upon at the settling up
04/08/23
33
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
AGENCY THEORY – RESIDUAL OPPORTUNISM
Residual opportunism – cost borne by agent
due loss of reputation & potential loss of long-
term returns to them
With incomplete price protection & settling up,
residual loss is borne partly by agent & partly
by principal
04/08/23
34
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
AGENCY COSTS Monitoring costs
Cost of monitoring agents behaviour and expenditure by principal to measure, observe and control the agent’s behaviour.
Examples: audit costs, operating rules, budget restrictions Bonding costs
Costs of establishing and complying with these mechanism (bond’s agents interest to match principal’s interest).
These costs are borne by agents Examples: frequent (weekly, quarterly, semi-annually)
reporting to shareholders Residual costs
Also known as deadweight loss is when the net value of the agent’s output is less than if the agent’s interest were completely aligned to the principal
Not reduced by monitoring or binding costs However, under strong-form efficient market, it is assumed that
the firm can be price protected in the form of agent’s remuneration
04/08/23
35
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
AGENCY PROBLEM AND COST Agent problem and cost arise from the opportunistic
behaviour of management Opportunistic tendencies increase with decrease
proportionate share (ownership) which increases residual loss.
Shareholders are prepared to bear agency costs as long as marginal benefits to shareholders exceed marginal cost
Price protection of shareholders could be in two forms: Share price adjustments to reflect opportunistic behaviour Share price exclude monitoring and binding cost Limitation of price protection is that share price is not
always available due to thin trading and when manager’s efforts can be directly related to earnings performance
04/08/23
36
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
SUMMARY
A number of conflicting theories have developed
A theory generally consists of three parts
There are several criteria for judging a theory Persuasiveness of evidence
04/08/23
37
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.
SUMMARY
Many different approaches to theory formulation in accounting
All methods of theory formulation have strength and weaknesses
Accounting practitioners should use theories they find most persuasive
04/08/23
38
Copyright@2005 by Rohana Othman. All rights reserved.