Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Penn State Facilities Engineering Institute
The Salvation Army Pure Energy Conference 2018
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
John Hajduk, BSEE, MBA, ProFM DIRECTOR, PENN STATE FACILITIES ENGINEERING
INSTITUTE, THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY
John Hajduk, MBA is the Director of the Penn State Facilities Engineering Institute (PSFEI). With more than 20 years of industry experience, Hajduk is responsible for all services offered at the Institute. His areas of expertise include facilities management at the enterprise level and technical engineering in energy, power systems, and controls. Prior to his tenure at PSFEI, Hajduk managed real estate and facilities in North America for Westinghouse Electric Company, inclusive of real estate, operations and maintenance, energy, and construction. He also served in facilities, asset management, engineering, and maintenance roles at Schlumberger, Axalto, and Appleton Papers.
Kurt Homan, PE, CEM ENERGY PROGRAM MANAGER, PENN STATE
FACILITIES ENGINEERING INSTITUTE, THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY
Kurt Homan, PE, CEM is the Energy Program Manager for the Penn State Facilities Engineering Institute (PSFEI). He is responsible for the Institute's supply and demand side energy services, which include electricity and natural gas procurement and facilities energy conservation services. Homan developed his facilities energy engineering expertise over a 37-year career. Prior to joining PSFEI, Homan was the District Energy Engineering Manager for Siemens Building Technologies (SBT) Energy and Environmental Solutions. He also served as product manager for Enron Energy Information Solutions, and as Principal in Charge of Systems Engineering at Comprehensive Design, Architects and Engineers in State College, Pennsylvania.
Facilities Engineering Institute
PSFEI Services
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Energy Procurement and Utility Management
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Salvation Army Training
Salvation Army Training
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Salvation Army Training, cont.
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Agenda Overview Developing an Overall Strategy and Goals
– Tracking energy use and cost at the local, regional, and enterprise level to establish baselines, benchmark, and track progress
– Selecting program goals
• Reduction targets for energy use
• Reduction targets for energy spend
• Sustainability targets (GHG reduction goals, water usage reduction goals, waste to landfill reduction)
Facilities Engineering Institute
Why Develop a Strategy…Why Develop Goals ?
– Enhance good stewardship practices and make better use of the earth’s natural resources
• Reduce usage • Reduce demand • Reduce cost • Reduce carbon footprint
– Realize cost savings and redirect funds to support your mission and maintain your facilities – Where do I start?
Facilities Engineering Institute
Start at the beginning
5. Apply alternative energy technologies
4. Fine-tune your energy use
3. Improve your energy efficiency
2. Conserve your energy use
1. Understand your energy use
Facilities Engineering Institute
Tracking Energy Use and Cost – How much energy do you consume?
• Energy Intensity—Btu (use) per building SF • Consumption • Cost • Carbon footprint
– Has energy use and cost changed over time? If so, why?
– Do you use more energy than you should?
– How does your energy use intensity compare to other similar facilities?
Facilities Engineering Institute
Tracking Energy Use and Cost – How are utility bills paid? – Knowledge/awareness of energy
use and cost
– Efficiency and carbon footprint
– You cannot manage what is not measured…
Measure & Benchmark
Facilities Engineering Institute
Energy Tracking Options – Spreadsheets
(time consuming, cumbersome, limited ability to access and share)
– Hire a consultant to do it
– Web-enabled software –Collecting and inputting data
is the challenge!
– Advanced data collection and analytics
Facilities Engineering Institute
Energy Analytics & Cost • Solve data collection • Manage energy and utilities • Improve efficiency and
sustainability
• Cost Ø Yr. 1 0.5% to 1% spend
Ø Yr. 2 forward 0.35% spend
• Potential Savings Ø 1%‒3% energy spend (conservative) Ø 5%‒15% energy spend (likely)
14
Facilities Engineering Institute
RECOMMENDATIONS
15
• Implementation—a positive action step
• Fund through utility budget
• Select pilot location(s)
• Pilot implementation 6‒8 months
Time and resource commitment required
üImplement ü Train ü Manage
Energy Analytics and Cost
Facilities Engineering Institute
RECOMMENDATIONS
16
Consider restructuring how utility bills are paid National Headquarters Territory Headquarters Divisional Headquarters (state) Area Commands (i.e. Houston) Corps Standalones
Energy Analytics Strategy
Facilities Engineering Institute
Benchmarking Sources Other Salvation Army facilities and datasets
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Selection of Program Goals
Facilities Engineering Institute
Why Develop Reduction Targets?
Drives action towards improved efficiency
Provides the basis and motivation to achieve energy efficiency
If you don’t know where you’re going, any road will get you there
Requires supporting policies and plans
Facilities Engineering Institute
Reduction Target Considerations Will the target be based on a historical base year, benchmark, or projection?
Facilities Engineering Institute
Reduction Target Considerations Will the target cover specific sites, building types, or regions?
Will the target be based on a combination of local or regional targets?
Facilities Engineering Institute
Reduction Target Considerations How will the target interact with other targets or policies?
Facilities Engineering Institute
Reduction Target Considerations How long is given to achieve the target?
Facilities Engineering Institute
Reduction Target Considerations Will compliance be mandatory?
Facilities Engineering Institute
Reduction Target Considerations How will progress be measured?
Facilities Engineering Institute
Reduction Targets for Energy Spend • Energy procurement strategies
– De-regulated – Regulated
• Utility rate analysis and rate switching • Alternative fuels options • Facility design considerations (new and renovation)
• Facilities scheduling
Facilities Engineering Institute
Sustainability
• U.N. Sustainable Development Goals—2030 Agenda
Facilities Engineering Institute
Greenhouse Gas Sources
Facilities Engineering Institute
Sustainability Target Example Greenhouse gas reduction goals (short term)
Facilities Engineering Institute
Water Usage Reduction Goals
Behavior modifications Retrofit opportunities
Facilities Engineering Institute
Waste to Landfill Reduction
Facilities Engineering Institute
Sustainability Targets Overall goals example Reductions are based on a defined baseline year and a target year.
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Time for a Break!!
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Effective Facility Management: Integration between O&M,
Energy, Risk, and Asset Management
O&M Best Practices and Innovation
Facilities Engineering Institute
What exactly is FM?
Facility management: “organizational function which integrates people, place,
and process within the built environment with the purpose of improving the quality of life of people and the productivity of the core business”
~(ISO 41011: 2017)
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Agenda Overview Overall FM Strategy and interdependency between FM functions
– Operations and maintenance
– Capital investment
– Business Management
– Risk Management
Operations and Maintenance – Facilities and activities scheduling
– Development of policies, standards, and process
– Education and training (staff, guests, and facilities users)
– Technology opportunities and application
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Why focus on O&M?
37
How many square feet of real estate does The Salvation Army have in the Southern Territory?
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Why focus on FM?
38
– Building Owners and Managers Association (BOMA)
Agency Revised
SqFt O&M Cost @
BOMA BenchmarkUtilities Cost @
BOMA BenchmarkTotal FM Cost@
BOMA BenchmarkDivisional Headquarters 500,000 $ 1,150,000 $ 1,055,000 $ 4,160,000 Corps (Churches and Chapels) 4,100,000 $ 9,430,000 $ 8,651,000 $ 34,112,000 Boys and Girls Clubs 1,000,000 $ 2,300,000 $ 2,110,000 $ 8,320,000 Shelters 5,000,000 $ 11,500,000 $ 10,550,000 $ 41,600,000 Officers Quarters 1,200,000 $ 2,760,000 $ 2,532,000 $ 9,984,000 Thrift Stores 3,100,000 $ 7,130,000 $ 6,541,000 $ 25,792,000 Kroc Centers 410,000 $ 943,000 $ 865,100 $ 3,411,200 Total All Buildings 15,310,000 $ 35,213,000 $ 32,304,100 $ 127,379,200
Average BOMA O&M $/SqFt $ 2.30 Average BOMA Roads and Grounds $/SqFt $ 0.19 Average BOMA Cleaning $/SqFt $ 1.94 Average BOMA Administrative $ 1.78 Average BOMA Utilities $ 2.11 Total BOMA FM $/ SqFt $ 8.32
Facilities Engineering Institute
The total cost of ownership (TCO) is all the expenditures an owner can expect to make during the service life of a structure/asset.
Copyright ProFM 2018
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute 40
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Operations & Maintenance
41
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute 42
We will invest time help you to understand:
• Knowledge of maintenance systems • Types of maintenance: Preventative,
Predictive, and Corrective Maintenance • Work Management and Metrics • How maintenance and operations impacts
energy usage • Automation
Facilities Engineering Institute
Goals of a successful O&M program
• Maximize productivity, lowest cost, safely • Identify cost reductions • Minimize energy usage • Provide accurate equipment records • Collect maintenance cost information • Optimize resources • Optimize equipment life • Minimize inventory
Facilities Engineering Institute
FEMP O&M Practices Rev 3.0 • O&M Management • CMMS • Types of
Maintenance • Predictive • Commissioning • Metering • Systems overview &
general O&M specs
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Asset Inventory
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Asset Risk Assessment Scope Team
1. Understand Equipment Operation & Design 2. Understand Impact of Business Interruption
from loss of equipment 3. Understand Financial loss from forced outage 4. Understand Impact on reputation, fines,
impact of clients as a result of forced outage
• Roles & responsibilities • Linkage between organizations • Establish and manage functional relationships
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Business Consequence / Impact
Safety & Environment: aliments, injuries, fatalities or minor release contained to owned property, minor release into environment, environmental disaster Reputation & Compliance: internal review, internal audit, public / political and media scrutiny, legal action and national medial attention (scandal) Mission / Continuity: client welfare threating, service degrading or briefly interrupted, service failure or extended interruption Asset Financial Impact: financial damage to asset threshold $5K to above $500K
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Business Consequence / Impact
Freq
uenc
y
Equipment Criticality
25-50 50-125 125-250 250-500
25-30 30-75 75-150 150-300
20 20-40 40-100 100-200 200-400
5-10 10-25 25-50 50-100
10 10-20 20-50 50-100 100-150
Rare (1)
Unlikely (2)
Possible (3)
Likely (4)
Certain (5)
5
15
25
Low Medium High
Asset Risk Matrix
12
7
12
5
0 3 7 12 15
2 6 12 15 20
10
2 6 12 15 20
People (PE)
Reputation (R)
Mission (O)
Asset Value (A) 0 3 5 8
X
Asset Risk Level 180
Asset Risk Index (0-65)
Frequency (1-5) 5
36
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Elements of Work Management Identify Know work tasks to be performed Prioritize Evaluate significance of work tasks Group Bucket work tasks for performance efficiency Schedule Sequence work tasks for performance Plan Develop work instructions Execute Complete scheduled work Close Document work performance Critique Identify improvement opportunities
Facilities Engineering Institute
Baseline Schedule (007)
Deficiency Identification and Reporting (002)
Equipment Reliability
Capital/Improvement Projects
Screening/Prioritization (003)
Long Range Schedule (007)
Planning (008)
Scheduling/T- process (007)
Project Planning
Minor Maintenance (005)
Breakdown
Maintenance
Feedback loop (001)
FIN (004)
FEGs (011)
Tool Pouch (006)
Work Completion (001)
Production Schedule
PMs
Work Management Process
Facilities Engineering Institute
DEFINE
A long-range plan that includes the Production Schedule, Periodic and Predictive Maintenance, seamlessly integrated with Deficiencies and Improvement Tasks
ATTRIBUTES
- Production Planning Integration - Outages and Major Holidays Identification - Incorporated Training/Vacation schedule - Minimal Impact Across Production Boundaries - Sufficient Time to Integrate Lessons Learned - Improvements and Deficient Tasks are integrated into known Windows of Opportunity
Long Range Scheduling
Facilities Engineering Institute
Reactive Maintenance • Generally, the most expensive way to coordinate
maintenance • Leads to equipment service levels below acceptable
levels • Run to failure might be an effective strategy
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Planned vs. Unplanned Work
Facilities Engineering Institute
Corrective Maintenance
• Make up the maintenance backlog • Needs to be planned and scheduled • 2–4 times more cost effective than reactive • Equipment service levels maintained
Facilities Engineering Institute
Preventive Maintenance (PM)
• Actions performed on a time or machine run based schedule that detect, preclude, or mitigate degradation of a component or system with the aim of sustaining or extending its useful life through controlling degradation to an acceptable level.
~FEMP O&M Best Practices
Facilities Engineering Institute
Preventive Maintenance (PM)
• Correct potential problems before they occur • Equipment service levels are acceptable
Facilities Engineering Institute
PM • Key to successful asset management program • Reduces the amount of reactive maintenance • Most important of maintenance programs • Are your PM programs effective? • Goal: 80/20
Facilities Engineering Institute
Predictive Maintenance • Measurements that detect the onset of system
degradation, thereby allowing causal stressors to be eliminated or controlled prior to any significant deterioration in the component physical state.
~FEMP O&M Best Practices
Facilities Engineering Institute
Predictive Maintenance
• Trending a parameter vibration, temperature, or flow • Using technology and scheduling the work • Equipment service levels very high
Facilities Engineering Institute
PdM • Focus is not to purchase all the technology
available—what are your chronic equipment problems?
• Rotating, vibration, and electrical thermography • Planned, scheduled, and recorded in CMMS
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Predictive Maintenance
Facilities Engineering Institute
Predictive Maintenance Technologies • Infrared Thermography • Lubricant Analysis • Ultrasonic Analysis
• Motor and Electrical Analysis • Performance Trending
Facilities Engineering Institute
Infrared (IR) Thermography IR detection devices fall into two groups:
1. Infrared Thermometer 2. Infrared Imager
• Simple Imager • IR cameras with full radiometric capability
Facilities Engineering Institute
Infrared (IR) Devices
Facilities Engineering Institute
Electrical System Application Distribution lines/systems
- Splices - Line clamps - Disconnects - Oil switches/breakers - Capacitors - Pole-mounted transformers - Lightning arrestors - Imbalances
Substations
- Disconnects, cutouts, air switches - Oil-filled switches/breakers (external and internal faults)
- Capacitors
Generators – Bearings – Brushes – Windings – Coolant/oil lines: blockage
Motors – Connections – Bearings – Winding/cooling patterns – Motor Control Center
Facilities Engineering Institute
Electrical Examples
67
Facilities Engineering Institute
Mechanical System Application Steam Systems • Boilers
– Refractory – Tubes
• Traps • Valves • Lines Heaters and furnaces • Refractory inspections • Tube restrictions Fluids • Vessel levels • Pipeline blockages
Environmental • Water discharge patterns • Air discharge patterns
Motors and Rotating Equipment • Bearings
– Mechanical Failure – Improper Lubrication
• Coupling and alignment • Cooling Blocked
Facilities Engineering Institute
Mechanical Examples
69
Facilities Engineering Institute
Lubricant Analysis Application • Turbines • Boiler feed pumps • Electrohydraulic control (EHC) systems • Hydraulics • Servo valves • Gearboxes • Roller bearings • Anti-friction bearings • Any system where oil cleanliness is directly related
Facilities Engineering Institute
Lubricant Analysis
Facilities Engineering Institute
Ultrasonic Analysis Application • Unbalance • Eccentric rotors • Misalignment • Resonance problems • Mechanical looseness/weakness • Rotor rub • Sleeve-bearing problems • Rolling element bearing problems
Facilities Engineering Institute
Ultrasonic Analysis
73
Facilities Engineering Institute
Electrical Analysis
Facilities Engineering Institute
Facilities Engineering Institute
ASHRAE Standard 180-2012
Facilities Engineering Institute
ASHRAE Standard 180-2012 This image cannot currently be displayed.
Facilities Engineering Institute
CMMS and EAM • Manages the collection, processing, and analysis of
data from maintenance functions • Data has to be accurate—cannot achieve asset
management if you do not have a means to track asset cost
• JUST A TOOL to make administrative functions of maintenance and operations efficient.
Facilities Engineering Institute
Training
• Insures that the technicians have the skill to understand and maintain the equipment
• What about interpersonal training? • Work flow and procedure training for technicians,
supervisors, managers, engineers, and planners.
Facilities Engineering Institute
Life Expectancy Optimization Optimizing the life of equipment
• Maintaining it so that it lasts 30-40% longer than poorly maintained equipment
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute 82
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute 83
Facilities Engineering Institute
Building Automation System
Facilities Engineering Institute
Energy Modeling with Advanced Meters Allows you to correlate facility conditions with energy consumption data and see cause and effect, as well as isolate and troubleshoot
85
Facilities Engineering Institute
Facilities Engineering Institute
Building Automation System
Facilities Engineering Institute
Energy Optimization • Well maintained equipment can use
5-15% less energy than poorly maintained equipment
Facilities Engineering Institute
Flow Diagram
Facilities Engineering Institute
Chillers
Facilities Engineering Institute
Chillers (cont.)
Condenser HOT
SURFACE Hot Gas Line
High Side Metering Device Compressor
Suct
ion
Line
Low Side Evaporator
COLD SURFACE
Cool Air or Water
Hot/Warm Air or Water
SEALED SYSTEM
Facilities Engineering Institute
Chiller Maintenance Daily log books
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
A well-constructed chiller log sheet can reveal problems that cost you money
Excess condenser approach is an indication of possible tube fouling
Facilities Engineering Institute
Chiller Maintenance According to the DOE, a dirty condenser can increase energy consumption by 30%
Facilities Engineering Institute
Chiller Maintenance (cont.)
• Clean tubes based on process and approach temperature, not on a scheduled PM program
Facilities Engineering Institute
Cooling Towers
Facilities Engineering Institute
Cooling Tower Maintenance • Must be an ongoing
endeavor • Lapses can result in
system degradation, loss of efficiency, and potentially serious health issues
• Affects chiller in open system
Facilities Engineering Institute
Cooling Tower Maintenance (cont.)
Facilities Engineering Institute
Cooling Tower Poor Performance Causes
• Scale deposits (a sign of water treatment problems)
• Clogged spray nozzles (a sign of water treatment problems and clogged strainers)
• Insufficient cleaning
• Poor air flow
• Debris at inlets or outlets of the tower
Facilities Engineering Institute
Cooling Tower Poor Performance Causes (cont.)
• Loose fan and motor mountings
• Poor motor and fan alignment
• Ice • Moisture in fan blades • Poor gear box maintenance • Improper fan pitch • Damage to fan blades • Excessive vibration
Facilities Engineering Institute
Cooling Tower Poor Performance Causes (cont.)
• Poor pump performance – Loose connections – Failing bearings – Cavitation – Clogged strainers – Excessive vibration – Bad mechanical seal
• Seal life depends on water quality
Facilities Engineering Institute
Best Practices • Controlling Cycles of Concentration
– Work with chemical vendor – Automate
• Instrumentation – Leak checking – Sewer credits
• Condensate recovery for make up water • Covers to block sunlight related to algae growth
Facilities Engineering Institute
AIR HANDLER UNITS
Facilities Engineering Institute
Air Handler Units (AHU)
Facilities Engineering Institute
AHU Major Components • Large metal box/housing • Blower/fans • Heating/cooling coil • Humidifier • Filtration devices • Dampers • Control package • Heat recovery devices
Facilities Engineering Institute
Facilities Engineering Institute
What Does it Do • Conditions air
– Heating – Cooling – Humidify/dehumidify – Filter
• Circulation • Ventilation
– Outside/fresh air • Heat recovery
Facilities Engineering Institute
Heating • Hot water • Preheat/reheat • Steam • Gas/oil-fired • Electric • Geothermal/WSHP
Facilities Engineering Institute
Cooling • Chilled water • Direct expansion (DX) • Free cooling—economizer
Facilities Engineering Institute
Maintenance
Facilities Engineering Institute
Filtration • Removes particulates and contaminants from air
– Return/outside air • Preventative maintenance
– Scheduling – Fan performance
• Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) – Sick building syndrome (SBS) – Building related illness (BRI)
Facilities Engineering Institute
Filtration (cont.)
Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value (MERV)
Facilities Engineering Institute
Box, Bag, or HEPA Filters
Pre Filters
Facilities Engineering Institute
AHU Maintenance Belts and alignment
Facilities Engineering Institute
AHU Maintenance (cont.)
Belts and alignment (cont.)
Deflection= “span”x 1/64”
Facilities Engineering Institute
AHU Maintenance (cont.)
• Consumables – Filters – Lubrication – UV
Facilities Engineering Institute
AHU Maintenance (cont.)
• Louvers – Freedom of movement – Bearing lubrication – Full close/full open – Loose linkage – Environmental considerations, i.e., wildlife and weather
Facilities Engineering Institute
AHU Maintenance (cont.)
• Duct cleaning
Facilities Engineering Institute 119
Facilities Engineering Institute
SENSORS
Facilities Engineering Institute
The Why
Facilities Engineering Institute
Calibration
Facilities Engineering Institute
Facilities Engineering Institute
Occupant Perception and Behavior • There is no energy conservation measure greater than
changing the behavior of the building occupants! – This is hard! – It takes time! – They have to want to change!
• The keys – Education – Visibility – Transparency – Good data!
Facilities Engineering Institute
Facilities Engineering Institute Facilities Engineering Institute
Why focus on FM?
126
– Building Owners and Managers Association (BOMA)
Agency Revised
SqFt O&M Cost @
BOMA BenchmarkUtilities Cost @
BOMA BenchmarkTotal FM Cost@
BOMA BenchmarkDivisional Headquarters 500,000 $ 1,150,000 $ 1,055,000 $ 4,160,000 Corps (Churches and Chapels) 4,100,000 $ 9,430,000 $ 8,651,000 $ 34,112,000 Boys and Girls Clubs 1,000,000 $ 2,300,000 $ 2,110,000 $ 8,320,000 Shelters 5,000,000 $ 11,500,000 $ 10,550,000 $ 41,600,000 Officers Quarters 1,200,000 $ 2,760,000 $ 2,532,000 $ 9,984,000 Thrift Stores 3,100,000 $ 7,130,000 $ 6,541,000 $ 25,792,000 Kroc Centers 410,000 $ 943,000 $ 865,100 $ 3,411,200 Total All Buildings 15,310,000 $ 35,213,000 $ 32,304,100 $ 127,379,200
Average BOMA O&M $/SqFt $ 2.30 Average BOMA Roads and Grounds $/SqFt $ 0.19 Average BOMA Cleaning $/SqFt $ 1.94 Average BOMA Administrative $ 1.78 Average BOMA Utilities $ 2.11 Total BOMA FM $/ SqFt $ 8.32
Facilities Engineering Institute
Continuous Improvement (CI) • “Best is the Enemy of Better” • Ongoing program of evaluation and benchmarking • Must know current status before attempting to
improve