-
7/27/2019 Oregon Association's Findings of Facts Guide to the COE
1/32
Frcafk Mssfbhmthfk fj \CMITF\R
Cssckthmi Jhkdhkas fj Jmbts jfr Mrthbics fj toc Bfdc fj CtohbsBF^X\HAOT >4 ly F\CAFK MRRFBHMTHFK FJ \CMITF\R
Spdmtcd7 Fbtflcr =>
Mrthbic =
Tcxt fj toc Mrthbic
Qock rcprcsckthka m luycr) sciicr) imkdifrd) fr ftocr bihckt ms mk mackt) \CMITF\Rpicdac toc`scivcs tf prftcbt mkd prf`ftc toc hktcrcsts fj tochr bihckt+ Tohs flihamthfk tf
toc bihckt hs prh`mry) lut ht dfcs kft rcihcvc \CMITF\R fj tochr flihamthfk tf trcmt mii
pmrthcs ofkcstiy+ Qock scrvhka m luycr) sciicr) imkdifrd) tckmkt fr ftocr pmrty hk m kfk-
mackby bmpmbhty) \CMITF\R rc`mhk flihamtcd tf trcmt mii pmrthcs ofkcstiy+
Ru``mry fj toc Mrthbic
Mrthbic = rcquhrcs \CMITF\R tf prftcbt mkd prf`ftc tochr bihckts hktcrcsts) lut tf lcofkcst whto mii pmrthcs hk mky trmksmbthfk hk wohbo tocy mrc hkvfivcd+ Toc prftcbthfk mkd
prf`fthfk fj bihckt hktcrcsts h`pfscs m duc dhihackbc stmkdmrd `cmsurcd mamhkst tocrcmsfkmlic bfkdubt fj ftocr \CMITF\R hk toc sm`c bhrbu`stmkbc+ Jmhiurc tf trcmt
pmrthcs tf m trmksmbthfk ofkcstiy rcquhrcs cvhdckbc fj hktckt tf dcbchvc5 hk ftocr wfrds)
whiijui bfkdubt+ \CMITF\R rc`mhk flihamtcd tf toc Bfdc fj Ctohbs cvck wock mbthka
ms m prhkbhpmi hk m trmksmbthfk+
Jhkdhkas fj Jmbt Kcbcssmry jfr Mrthbic = Bimh`
=+ Qms toc bf`pimhkcd fj bfkdubt dhrcbtcd mt m bihckt fr mkftocr pmrty tf m trmksmbthfk
whto toc bihckt fr \CMITF\6 VVVV Bihckt VVVV Mkftocr mrty
-
7/27/2019 Oregon Association's Findings of Facts Guide to the COE
2/32
Mrthbic :
Tcxt fj toc Mrthbic
\CMITF\R somii kft mbbcpt mky bf``hsshfk) rclmtc) fr prfjht fk cxpckdhturcs `mdc
jfr tochr bihckt) whtofut toc bihckts ekfwicdac mkd bfksckt+
Ru``mry fj toc Mrthbic
Mrthbic : hs m dhsbifsurc mkd bfksckt Mrthbic+ M \CMITF\ bmkkft mbbcpt mbf``hsshfk fr m rclmtc whtofut lfto tochr bihckts ekfwicdac mkd tochr bfksckt+ Toc
sm`c duty mttmbocs hj toc \CMITF\ `mecs mky ehkd fj prfjht fk m bihckts cxpckdhturc+
Dhsbifsurc hs kft ckfuao ukdcr Mrthbic :+ Toc bihckt `ust bfksckt tf toc bf``hsshfk)
rclmtc fr prfjht+ Ms m prmbthbmi `mttcr) ofwcvcr) hj toc bf``hsshfk) rclmtc fr prfjht hsdhsbifscd tf toc bihckt lcjfrc ht hs mbbcptcd ly toc \CMITF\) toc bihckts bfksckt bmk
lc h`pihcd+ Dhsbifsurc mjtcr omvhka mbbcptcd toc bf``hsshfk) rclmtc fr prfjht) wfuid)
ofwcvcr) rcquhrc toc spcbhjhb bfksckt fj toc bihckt+
Jhkdhkas fj Jmbt Kcbcssmry jfr Mrthbic : Bimh`
=+ Qomt bf``hsshfk) rclmtc fr prfjht dhd toc \cspfkdckt mbbcpt6 VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV+
-
7/27/2019 Oregon Association's Findings of Facts Guide to the COE
11/32
==
Mrthbic 1
Tcxt fj Mrthbic 1
Hk m trmksmbthfk) \CMITF\R somii kft mbbcpt bf`pcksmthfk jrf` `frc tomk fkc pmrty)
cvck hj pcr`httcd ly imw) whtofut dhsbifsurc tf mii pmrthcs mkd toc hkjfr`cd bfksckt fj toc\CMITF\R bihckt fr bihckts+
Ru``mry fj toc Mrthbic
Mrthbic 1 mppihcs wock m \CMITF\ mbbcpts bf`pcksmthfk jrf` `frc tomk fkc pmrty tf
m rcmi cstmtc trmksmbthfk+ Rtmtc imw hs kf dcjcksc+ Tf mvfhd toc vhfimthfk) toc \CMITF\
`ust sofw tomt mii pmrthcs tf toc rcmi cstmtc trmksmbthfk ekcw twf bf``hsshfks wcrc lchka
pmhd+ Tocy `ust misf sofw tochr bihckt kft fkiy ekcw fj toc twf bf``hsshfks lut amvctochr hkjfr`cd bfksckt+ Hkjfr`cd bfksckt `cmks tocy tfid fj mkd ukdcrstffd toc
pftckthmi bfkjihbt hkvfivcd+
Jhkdhkas fj Jmbt Kcbcssmry jfr Mrthbic 1 Bimh`
=+ Hk womt wmy dhd toc \cspfkdckt rcbchvc bf`pcksmthfk jrf` `frc tomk fkc pmrty6 VV
VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV
-
7/27/2019 Oregon Association's Findings of Facts Guide to the COE
12/32
=
Mrthbic =3
Tcxt fj Mrthbic =3
\CMITF\R somii kft ekfwhkaiy fr rcbeicssiy `mec jmisc fr `hsicmdhka stmtc`ckts
mlfut bf`pcthtfrs) tochr lushkcsscs) fr tochr lushkcss prmbthbcs+
Ru``mry fj Mrthbic =3
Mrthbic =3 hs m lushkcss bf`pcthtfr dcjm`mthfk prfvhshfk+ Dcjm`mthfk hs mk mttmbe fkrcputmthfk5 ocrc) lushkcss rcputmthfk+ Mrthbic =3 rcquhrcs prffj fj hktckt+ Toc stmtc`ckt
`ust lc jmisc fr hsicmdhka+ Toc stmtc`ckt `ust lc mlfut m bf`pcthtfr) tochr lushkcsscs
fr lushkcss prmbthbcs+ M pcrsfkmi mttmbe fk mk hkdhvhdumi ms mk hkdhvhdumi hs kft bfvcrcd+
Mk mttmbe fk toc lushkcss fj sf`cfkc wof hs kft hk bf`pcththfk whto toc \CMITF\ hskft bfvcrcd+ Toc jmisc fr `hsicmdhka stmtc`ckt `ust lc `mdc ekfwhkaiy fr rcbeicssiy+
\cbeicsskcss rcquhrcs m arfss dcvhmthfk jrf` m stmkdmrd fj bfkdubt+ Qock mppihcd tf
stmtc`ckts) tomt `cmks toc spcmecr `ust chtocr ekfw toc stmtc`ckt hs jmisc fr `hsicmdhka/h+c+) ekfws toc truto mkd dhsrcamrds fr dhstfrts ht( fr hs hkdhjjcrckt tf toc truto fr jmishty fj
toc stmtc`ckt hk bhrbu`stmkbc cvhdckbhka m arfss dhsrcamrd jfr toc bf`pcthtfrs lushkcss
rcputmthfk+
Jhkdhkas fj Jmbt Kcbcssmry jfr Mrthbic =3 Bimh`
=+ Qomt stmtc`ckt dhd \cspfkdckt mec6 VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV
-
7/27/2019 Oregon Association's Findings of Facts Guide to the COE
31/32
2=
Mrthbic =:
Tcxt fj Mrthbic
\CMITF\R somii kft ckamac hk mky prmbthbc fr tmec mky mbthfk hkbfkshstckt whto
cxbiushvc rcprcscktmthfk fr cxbiushvc lrfecrmac rcimthfksohp marcc`ckts tomt ftocr\CMITF\R omvc whto bihckts+
Ru``mry fj toc Mrthbic
Mrthbic =: jfrlhds hktcrjcrckbc whto toc cxbiushvc mackby rcimthfksohp ftocr
\CMITF\R omvc whto bihckts+ Mk cxbiushvc rcprcscktmthfk fr cxbiushvc lrfecrmac
marcc`ckt hs rcquhrcd lctwcck toc \CMITF\ mkd toc bihckt+ Toc kfr`mi hkdustry
prmbthbc fj wfrehka whto luycrs dfcs kft jmii whtohk Mrthbic =: lcbmusc suborcimthfksohps mrc kft usumiiy lmscd fk cxbiushvc rcprcscktmthfk marcc`ckts+ Fk toc ftocr
omkd) sciicrs wof ihst mrc mi`fst miwmys bfvcrcd lcbmusc `fst ihsthka marcc`ckts bfktmhk
cxbiushvc rcprcscktmthfk bimuscs+ Bfkdubt fr prmbthbcs `ust lc tmeck tomt mrc hkbfkshstcktwhto toc cxbiushvhty fj toc rcimthfksohp+ Toc \cspfkdckt `ust prfvhdc) fr fjjcr tf
prfvhdc) scrvhbcs bfvcrcd ly mkftocr \CMITF\R cxbiushvc rcprcscktmthfk fr
cxbiushvc lrfecrmac marcc`ckt+
Jhkdhkas fj Jmbt Kcbcssmry jfr Mrthbic =: Bimh`
=+ Qomt cvhdckbc hs tocrc fj mk cxbiushvc rcprcscktmthfk fr cxbiushvc lrfecrmacrcimthfksohp marcc`ckt lctwcck \CMITF\ mkd tochr bihckt6 VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV
-
7/27/2019 Oregon Association's Findings of Facts Guide to the COE
32/32
2