Download - Not invited to the Christmas party
WELCOME TO THE SEMINAR:“NOT INVITED TO
THE CHRISTMAS PARTY”
NOT INVITED TO THE CHRISTMAS PARTY
2
Keeping sustainable company values
and competence with increasing use
of external competence providers
3
Welcome
CARL-VIGGO ÖSTLUND
Chairman, Pause Sholarship Foundation
INGALILL HOLMBERG
Professor, Department of Management and Organization,
SSE
Leading a mixed workforce
EDIN COLAK
MSc, SSE and Recipient of the Global Village/Pause
Scholarship 2015
International patterns in leading
external providers
ELLEN MONTÉN
BSc, SSE and Recipient of the Global Village/Pause
Scholarship 2015
PROGRAM
Multiple HR systems for mixed
workforce
PERNILLA BOLANDER
Assistant Professor, Department of Management
and Organization, SSE
Scania case
SOFIA VAHLNE
Lawyer, Manager, HR, Scania
Discussion and concluding remarks
INGALILL HOLMBERG
Professor, Department of Management and Organization,
SSE
Lunch and mingle
4
CARL-VIGGO ÖSTLUND
Chairman, Pause Sholarship Foundation
INGALILL HOLMBERG
Professor, Department of Management
and Organization, SSE
5
EDIN COLAK
MSc, SSE
Recipient of the Global Village/Pause
Scholarship 2015
HAPPILY EVER
AFTER? How the use of temporary
employees
affect standard and nonstandard
employees’ attitude and behavior
towards organizations
Pause Scholarship foundation
Edin Colak
16-11-2015
THE HETEROGENEOUS WORKFORCE IS
HERE TO STAY
• What is contingent work?
• Contingent work one of the most spectacular and important evolutions in Western working (cf. De Cyuper et. al., 2008 )
• How does the use of temporary employees affect both standard and nonstandard employees’ attitude and behavior towards the organization?
– Employee perspective: coordination, learning, and shared values among the workforce
– Organizational perspective: strategic flexibility, cost structure, ability to adapt to changing market conditions
16-11-2015 7
DEFINING TEMPORARY EMPLOYMENT
• Contingent, temporary, non-permanent, casual etc.?
• “Work done on a fixed schedule – usually full-time – at the employer’s place of business, under the employer’s control, and with the mutual expectation of continued employment” (Kalleberg, Reskin & Hudson, 2000: 258).
• Standard employment agreements (SEA) differ from nonstandard employment arrangements in three dimensions– Permanency and continuity of employment
– Employees under SEA work at employer’s workplace, on the employer’s premise and under the employer’s supervision as compared to their counterparts
– Benefits and entitlements
16-11-2015 8
PSYCHOLOGICAL CONTRACTS FOR
UNDERSTANDING EMPLOYEE BEHAVIOR
• “Idiosyncratic set of reciprocal expectations held by employees concerning their obligations and their entitlements” (cf. McLean et. al., 1998: 698)
• Transactional and relational psychological contracts
• Type of psychological contract affect how employees perceive factors related to their working environment
– Work stress
– Social comparison and social exchange
16-11-2015 9
FOUR GENERAL PSYCHOLOGICAL
OUTCOMES EVOKED
• Job satisfaction
– Low job satisfaction believed to evoke unfavorable attitudes and behaviors
– In general results are inconclusive
• Organizational commitment
– High organizational commitment should result in more favorable attitude and
behavior
– Scattered results both supporting and opposing theory
16-11-2015 10
FOUR GENERAL PSYCHOLOGICAL
OUTCOMES THAT ARE EVOKED
• Well-being
– Linked to perceived uncertainty and is believed to be high when uncertainty is
low
– No greater evidence for any major conclusions to be drawn
• Productive behaviors
– Productive behaviors are believed to be favorable in cases of high level of job
security, organizational commitment and well-being
– No firm conclusions can however be drawn in regards to employees’ productive
behaviors from research
16-11-2015 11
GROUP HETEROGENEITY TO
UNDERSTAND PSYCHOLOGICAL
OUTCOMES
• Consequences of group heterogeneity depend on the relative
proportions of majority and minority sub-group members
• Greater portions of minority members will evoke increasingly
negative psychological and social reactions among members of the
majority
• Temporary employees are seen as a minority group affecting
psychological reactions among group members toward their
supervisors, peers, and work groups
16-11-2015 12
MANAGERIAL IMPLICATIONS
• Contingent work must fit into the organization's overall business
strategy if it is to be successful
• Transparency behind the aims of using contingent work towards all
parties is key if capitalization is to be optimal
• Employees need to feel as, and be, one team if high productivity and
good results are to be obtained
16-11-2015 13
THANK YOU!
14
15
ELLEN MONTÉN
BSc, SSE
Recipient of the Global Village/Pause
Scholarship 2015
Ellen Montén I November 2015
Temporary employees and outsourcing:
Dos and don’ts from international examples
How should a leader act to make sure that hiring temporaryemployees and/or outsourcing does not affect the organisation and current employees in a negative way? What are the main risks one should be aware of when implementing these changes?
27 interviews 5 mini cases
1/14
Ellen Montén I November 2015
Background
Outsourcing Temporary Employees
o Outsourcing is present in-house
o What is outsourced is changing
o Problem area: Relationship
between provider and customer
o Increasing in the Nordics
o Increased number of part-time
and temporary jobs in the EU
o Full-time will become less of a
standard
o In 2013 close to 700 000
temporary employees in Sweden
2/14
Ellen Montén I November 2015
Background
3/14
Ellen Montén I November 2015
Background
4/14
Ellen Montén I November 2015
Background
5/14
Ellen Montén I November 2015
Background
25% 76%
6/14
Ellen Montén I November 2015
Background
What we think
organisations look like…
What organisations
will look like…
Dual loyalties? Harder to work in
close teams? Not invited to the
Christmas party?
7/14
Ellen Montén I September 2015
International best and worst practices
1 Young professional from Spain
o High unemployment
o Outsourcing and temporary
employees seen as a threat Biases, lack of
information/education
8/14
Ellen Montén I September 2015
International best and worst practices
2 Business student from South Korea
o Loyalty is central
o Dual loyalties = Risk Clear communication, moving
slow
9/14
Ellen Montén I September 2015
International best and worst practices
3 Young entrepreneur from Ghana
o Sharing resources and
employees
o Familiar approach to employees Personal connections used to
limit risk added by dual loyalties
10/14
Ellen Montén I September 2015
International best and worst practices
4 Student from Egypt
o Personal story – no
communication
o Drastic loss of initial employees There is a negative
reputation, work against it
11/14
Ellen Montén I September 2015
International best and worst practices
5 Marketing student from Hong Kong
o Personal story
– the startups do it right
o Open work place
= Inclusive business One team, even if employees
comes and goes
12/14
Ellen Montén I September 2015
Key words: Communication,
Inclusion, Pace, Connecting, Biases
Let’s dwell on that…
Setting the pace
Communicating
Handling the biases
Including the employees
Connecting Motivation
Building a team where
people feel needed and
where temporary
employees can come
and go with ease.
13/14
Ellen Montén I September 2015
Q&A
Thank you!
14/14
Report available at pause-stiftelse.com/stipendiater
30
PERNILLA BOLANDER
Assistant Professor, Department of
Management and Organization, SSE
MULTIPLE HR SYSTEMS FOR A MIXED
WORKFORCE
31
Pernilla Bolander
Department of Management and Organization
Stockholm School of Economics
Retention
management
Competence
development
HR policies, processes and practices
Human Resource
strategy
Business
strategy
Recruitment and
induction
Performance
management
HR SYSTEM
Knowledge
management
Change
management
SOME QUESTIONS RAISED
• Who is responsible for introducing new employees to the organization
in an adequate manner?
• How are different employee groups developed? Who makes sure
they have the right competencies?
• How is goal alignment achieved throughout the whole organization?
• How to secure knowledge that is created in interaction between
different employee groups?
• How to create loyalty among different employee groups?
• How can unified change be achieved in organizations with different
employee groups?
33
Retention
management
Competence
development
Recruitment and
induction
Performance
management
Knowledge
management
Change
management
MIXED WORKFORCE
• From core and peripheral employees…
• … to a more complex mix of internal full-time
employees, temporary employees, contract workers,
interim managers, employees at off-shore sites, consultants on long-term contracts working side-by-
side with internal employees, and so on
34
MULTIPLE HR SYSTEMS FOR A MIXED WORKFORCE
35
HR
system 1
HR
system 3
HR
system 2
MULTIPLE HR SYSTEMS FOR A MIXED WORKFORCE
36
ALLIANCE
Collaborative HR system
DEVELOPMENT
Commitment-based HR system
CONTRACTING
Compliance-based HR system
ACQUISITION
Market-based HR system
High uniqueness
Low uniqueness
High valueLow value
Source: Lepak & Snell (1999)
MULTIPLE HR SYSTEMS FOR A MIXED WORKFORCE
37
HR
system 1
HR
system 3
HR
system 2
38
SOFIA VAHLNE
Lawyer, Manager, HR, Scania
39
Partnership driven leader in the shift towards
sustainable transport systems
40
Strategy – focus on customer profitability
Scania’s offering
Provider of sustainable
transport solutions
Long-term commitment
Premium product and
services
41
Provider of transport solutions
Heavy trucks
Heavy buses
Engines
Workshops
Service agreements
Parts
Driver training
Scania Assistance
Scania Rental
Operational leases
Financial leases
Hire purchase
Insurance solutions
Products Services Financing
More than 1,600 sales and service points
globally – 1,000 in Europe
Sales and service network
Non-captive
Captive
Scania’s Core values
QualityRespect for the individualCustomer First
Scania’s core values permeate its entire corporate culture and
influence its day-to-day work. Customer first, Respect for the
individual and Quality are closely linked and apply in unity. They
constitute the starting point for all business development.
44
Respect for the individual
Recognising and
using all employees’
knowledge
Ideas and inspiration from
day-to-day operations
Example temporary work – production Sweden
Why:
Flexibility
Increased job security for
individuals
Only way in to employment
How:
Agreement with union
Partnership with suppliers
Implementation project – three parties
Continous improvement
What:
Equality in salary, work clothes, competence
development, job rotation etc
45
Example consultants / development assignments – R&D/IT
Why:
Flexibility
Competence
Volontary – one of
recruitment bases
How:
Consultants on site
Outsourcing / development assignments
What:
Equality in values
General guidelines
Aim transfer of competence
46
Success factors and challenges
Values apply to everyone working at Scania
Corporate culture integrated in partners
Transparency and involvement
Sustainability in the supply chain
Future?
Global minimum requirements with local variations
Prioritising – long term vision / daily business
47
Activities at Scania
Skill Capture – mindset journey, collect best practice,
aggregate corporate HR activities
Sustainability integrated into leadership trainings
Improving global HR guidelines – ex labour relations,
flexibility
48
Scania Labour Relations – why?
51
0
20,000
40,000
60,000
Produced vehicles/year
1995 2014
Vehicles produced
per employee80,000
100,000
0.0
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
3.5
6.5
1. Scania core values
2. Continous
improvement –
capturing the skills
3. Compliance
52
53
DISCUSSION AND
CONCLUDING REMARKS
Moderator: Ingalill Holmberg
THANK YOU
54