Download - Non destructive testing basics
ATSNY© 2012 1
Basic Nondestructive
Testing
for EXPO 2012
by
Neville W. Sachs, P.E.
Applied Technical Services New York
ATSNY© 2012 2
What we plan to cover
1. Definition of nondestructive testing
2. Some philosophy on why it is helpful
and the major pitfalls
3. Basic theory
4. Explanations of common techniques
5. Demonstrations of common analysis
techniques
ATSNY© 2012 3
Nondestructive Testing
(NDT)
Also known as nondestructive examination
(NDE)
Involves inspection and analysis of
machinery or components without affecting
the operation or the properties of the subject.
(As opposed to a tensile test or other
destructive test such as sectioning.)
ATSNY© 2012 4
From the ASNT Website (American Society for Nondestructive Testing)
What Is Nondestructive Testing?
Nondestructive testing asks “Is there
something wrong with this material?”
Nondestructive testing (NDT) has been
defined as … “those test methods used to
examine an object, material or system without
impairing its future usefulness.”
ATSNY© 2012 5
The British View (BINDT)
“Non-destructive testing is the branch of engineering
concerned with all methods of detecting and
evaluating flaws in materials.”
“The essential feature of NDT is that the test process
itself produces no deleterious effects on the material
or structure under test.”
“The subject of NDT has no clearly defined
boundaries …”
ATSNY© 2012 6
A Brief History
Formal NDE dates back to early railroad days
when a mixture of oil and talc were used to detect
cracking in axles and wheels.
Since then science has developed a wide range of
tools and abilities to noninvasively detect
problems before they become disasters.
ATSNY© 2012 7
Wikipedia says
nondestructive testing is … Acoustic emission testing (AE or AT)
Blue Etch Anodize (BEA)
Dye penetrant inspection Liquid penetrant testing (PT or LPI)
Electromagnetic testing (ET)
• Alternating current field measurement (ACFM)
• Alternating current potential drop measurement (ACPD)
• Barkhausen testing
• Direct current potential drop measurement (DCPD)
• Eddy-current testing (ECT)
• Magnetic flux leakage testing (MFL) for pipelines, tank floors, and wire rope
• Magnetic-particle inspection (MT or MPI)
• Remote field testing (RFT)
Ellipsometry
Guided wave testing (GWT)
Hardness testing
Impulse excitation technique (IET)
Infrared and thermal testing (IR)
• Thermographic inspection
Laser testing
• Electronic speckle pattern interferometry
• Holographic interferometry
• Low coherence interferometry
• Profilometry
• Shearography
Leak testing (LT) or Leak detection
• Absolute pressure leak testing (pressure change)
• Bubble testing
• Halogen diode leak testing
• Hydrogen leak testing
• Mass spectrometer leak testing
• Tracer-gas leak testing method Helium, Hydrogen and refrigerant gases
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and NMR
spectroscopy
Metallographic replicas [7] [8]
Near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS)
Optical microscopy
Positive Material Identification (PMI)
Radiographic testing (RT) (see also Industrial
radiography and Radiography)
Computed radiography
Digital radiography (real-time)
Neutron radiographic testing (NR)
SCAR (Small Controlled Area Radiography)
X-ray computed tomography (CT)
Scanning electron microscopy
Surface Temper Etch (Nital Etch)
Ultrasonic testing (UT)
ART (Acoustic Resonance Technology)
Electro Magnetic Acoustic Transducer (EMAT)
(non-contact)
Laser ultrasonics (LUT)
Internal rotary inspection system (IRIS)
ultrasonics for tubes
Phased array ultrasonics
Time of flight diffraction ultrasonics (TOFD)
Time of Flight Ultrasonic Determination of 3D
Elastic Constants (TOF)
Vibration Analysis
Visual inspection (VT)
Pipeline video inspection
Corroscan/C-scan
IRIS - Internal Rotary Inspection System
3D Computed Tomography
Industrial CT Scanning
Heat Exchanger Life Assessment System
RTJ Flange Special Ultrasonic Testing
ATSNY© 2012 8
So, going back to the ASNT website,
these are the common NDT
techniques
Acoustic Emission Eddy Current
Liquid Penetrant Magnetic Particle
Ultrasonic Testing Visual Inspection
Vibration Analysis Radiography (X-ray)
Also common are:
Infrared Thermography Hardness Testing
ATSNY© 2012 9
Your Personal NDT
When you go to the market to select fruit
or veggies, what do you do? How do you
make your choice?
If your car is making a new strange noise,
what do you do?
Do you ever glance at your car tires to
see if they are soft?
ATSNY© 2012 10
The goal –
A. Look at it without causing a
damaging interruption
B. Use the test information to
form a plan
ATSNY© 2012 11
NDT in everyday life
Would you rather have an MRI - or should we do exploratory surgery for that knee problem?
Would you prefer an EKG or exploratory surgery?
For both of these, consider the possible costs and the possible benefits.
ATSNY© 2012 12
The goal of NDT is to analyze a piece of
material, without damaging its performance
capabilities, and then use that information to
predict future performance.
The graph below shows leaks in the roof of a process
vessel. (Replacing the vessel will cost about $50,000,000
and take about a year.)
300
200
100
0 4
Routine inspections of a vessel with stress corrosion cracking
Roof leaks vs.Inspection date
Years from vessel installation
Nu
mb
er
of
leaks
8 12 16 20
ATSNY© 2012 13
The goal –
Look at it without causing a
damaging interruption
So, not only can we look at and inside
pieces, but we want to do that without
causing an interruption.
Then a question arises - Do humans
really commit that many errors?
ATSNY© 2012 14
Human Error Experts say the average person makes six significant errors per
week.
BUT, our surveys show the typical industry
person believes they make a significant
error about once every FIVE months
ATSNY© 2012 15
In 23 years of doing industrial training
programs and asking people to compare their
skills with others in the same job,
only 37 people have rated themselves as below
average!
For the last six years we have also asked people
to rate their safety awareness. Only TWO have
said they were below average!!!
( 23 years x 15 seminars/year x 15 people/seminar = 5100 students
37/5100 = 0.7% )
ATSNY© 2012 16
How Often Do Human Errors
Happen? (From Chemical Engineering Magazine, McGraw Hill, NY,NY)
Industrial Activities • Critical routine task - 1/1000
• Non-critical routine task - 3/1000
• General error rate for high stress rapid activities - 1/4
• Non-routine operations (startup, maintenance, etc.) - 1/100
• Checklist inspection - 1/10
General Human Error • of Observance - 1/50
• of Omission - 1/100
ATSNY© 2012 17
How Often Do Human Errors
Happen? (From Chemical Engineering Magazine, McGraw Hill, NY,NY)
Industrial Activities • Critical routine task - 1/1000
• Non-critical routine task - 3/1000
• General error rate for high stress rapid activities - 1/4
• Non-routine operations (startup, maintenance, etc.) - 1/100
• Checklist inspection - 1/10
General Human Error • of Observance - 1/50
• of Omission - 1/100
ATSNY© 2012 18
Infant MortalityF
ailu
re P
rob
ab
ilit
y
The "Reliability Bathtub"
Time (log scale)
Normal Run Period
Wear out
Infant Mortality
The period right after
the machine is started.
These failures are
usually related to errors
in assembly.
Normal Run Period
The long stable time when
successful operation can be
expected. Failure in this time
is usually from unexpected
wear or a change in operating
conditions.
Wear out -
A function of
the original design
ATSNY© 2012 19
So, what % of equipment
actually suffers from Infant
Mortality
It really depends on the training of the installation personnel and their training and care. There is data from studies of maintenance activities around the country and
have seen it range from
a low of about 5% to as high as 22%!
Several North American studies have shown
the average is about 14% substantially
defective!
ATSNY© 2012 20
The most important benefits of NDT are that
it allows us to inspect materials and
machinery:
1. Without introducing infant mortality.
2. Without damaging the material.
ATSNY© 2012 21
And .. The data shows that:
All humans make frequent errors.
We tend not to recognize those errors.
The benefit of NDT is that it can find
defective material/equipment without
damaging the pieces and without the
interruptions that increase the
probability of human error.
ATSNY© 2012 22
Common Uses for NDT
• Component/machine condition evaluation – Example – Inspection of a ski lift component or an elevator rope.
•Predictive method - Vibration analysis on motors, and pumps, infrared inspection of transformers.
•Product and/or material quality
assurance – Examples – Run-in test
on a new vehicle, cleanliness of steel
ATSNY© 2012 23
The PE’s Challenge
We are asking technicians to conduct an
inspection.
They are not engineers and, by definition,
must have criteria to inspect to, i.e., have
to know what is considered a defect.
ATSNY© 2012 24
So, before we ask for a
specific NDT, we have to
know what to ask for!
Q. What is the difference between a flaw and a defect?
A. Almost all materials have lots of flaws. When the flaw impacts the performance of the material, it becomes a defect.
ATSNY© 2012 25
Important Terminology -
Defects and Flaws
All parts have “flaws” of some magnitude
but the parts are not necessarily defective.
A defective component is one that will not
perform as required for the necessary
time.
A “defect” is a deviation from what is
allowable.
ATSNY© 2012 26
Dialogue of a Common Problem
Client - “We want our xyz part mag particle tested. Can you do
that?”
Us – “Sure, we do lots of mag particle testing. What is your
standard?”
Client – “Huh? The drawing says it has to be tested.”
Us – “Does the drawing have a spec on it?”
Client – “Yeah. It says MIL-TDD41.” (Unfortunately, that is a
mil spec that was retired in 1990 and the last issue described a
procedure, without specifying flaw tolerances.)
Us – “Let’s talk about what you really need.” (More than once,
we’ve have had people ask us to MagnaFlux aluminum parts!)
ATSNY© 2012 27
So, before we ask for an
NDT, we have to know what
to ask for!
… and one of the significant challenges is to define what is considered a defect.
In a precision machined part, a 0.04” flaw may be a defect, but in a large casting, it may be just a 0.4” flaw!
ATSNY© 2012 28
Defects or Flaws???
When NDE people talk about flaws
(not serious stuff) they’re called
indications.
Defects are called “relevant
indications”.
ATSNY© 2012 29
Next, the inspection should
be done by a qualified and
certified person.
ATSNY© 2012 30
Certification
A certified inspector is a person who has demonstrated their capabilities and met a legal requirement.
Please don’t risk your life or your reputation by having inexperienced and uncertified inspectors do the work. (Would you want to have a surgeon operate on you who practices once a year? Or one who has developed his skill by watching other people do the job?)
ATSNY© 2012 31
ASNT Personnel
Qualifications Level I – Can conduct a test under Level
II supervision
Level II – Knows what they are doing
within specific inspection area
Level III - Knows and can perform a wide
range of NDT methods
(Typical inspector may be certified Level II in
VT, PT, MT, and UT)
ATSNY© 2012 32
Some of the more common NDT
methods
Acoustic Emission Eddy Current
Liquid Penetrant Magnetic Particle
Ultrasonic Testing Visual Inspection
Thermography Vibration Analysis
Radiography (X-ray) Hardness Testing
ATSNY© 2012 33
Some of the more common NDT
methods
Acoustic Emission Eddy Current
Liquid Penetrant Magnetic Particle
Ultrasonic Testing Visual Inspection
Thermography Vibration Analysis
Radiography (X-ray) Hardness Testing
ATSNY© 2012 34
Visual Inspection
An assurance that the person conducting
the inspection can see and recognize the
indications.
Certification in VT is largely directed
toward weld inspection. However, to
maintain any certification, visual acuity is
tested every year.
ATSNY© 2012 35
We have actually had experience
doing these: Acoustic Emission Eddy Current
Liquid Penetrant Magnetic Particle
Ultrasonic Testing Visual Inspection
Thermography Vibration Analysis
Radiography (X-ray) Hardness Testing
ATSNY© 2012 36
Glossary
DEFECT – A flaw that can significantly impact the
performance of the material
FLAW – An irregularity in the material
TRANSDUCER – a device that converts a mechanical
force to and electrical signal and vice-versa
RELEVANT INDICATION – something to be concerned
about
ATSNY© 2012 37
Acoustic Emission (AE)
Common Applications
Pressure vessels, especially tank cars
Fiberglass and other composite tanks
Long term bridge structure monitoring
ATSNY© 2012 38
x
x x
x x
x
Computer
Inspected vessel
Acoustic Emission (AE)
Start with a selection of
transducers that are wired
into a computer.
Securely anchor the
transducers to a vessel or
structure in precisely
determined positions.
The computer records the
high frequency signals from
the transducers.
ATSNY© 2012 39
Acoustic Emission (AE) Start with a selection of transducers that are
wired into a computer.
Securely anchor the transducers to a vessel wall
in precisely determined positions.
One time test
• Increase the pressure (stress) in the vessel above the
normally experienced pressures (stresses).
Long term test
• Compare the recorded data over the time period
Analyze the noises detected by the transducers.
If the noises are relevant, triangulate the signal
and specify additional testing in that area.
ATSNY© 2012 40
A
D E
B C
F
Computer
Inspected vessel
*
Acoustic Emission (AE)
Start with a selection of
transducers that are wired
into a computer.
When the noise signals
exceed a limit, triangulate
the indication.
Then do further inspection
in that area with other
methods.
*
ATSNY© 2012 41
Eddy Current (EC)
Common Applications
Heat exchanger tubes
Aircraft fuselage and wing surfaces
Easily contacted surfaces
Tube and wire production
Ferrous and nonferrous bar production
ATSNY© 2012 42
Eddy Current (EC)Testing
A probe with an AC field is moved across
a metallic surface at a relatively controlled
speed and the response from the field is
monitored.
When the field is interrupted by a change
in the structure, the response changes.
ATSNY© 2012 43
Radiography (X-rays)
Common Applications
Critical fabrication welds
Any material inspection where a record
has to be available for future reference
Searching for unwanted contaminating
materials
ATSNY© 2012 44
Penetrant Testing
“PT”
ATSNY© 2012 45
Penetrant Testing
“PT”
We’re going to do a penetrant test, but it is a
relatively time consuming procedure (and it is also
more prone to human error than other NDT). So
within the “PT time”, we’re going to do a magnetic
particle test.
ATSNY© 2012 46
The Types
There are three types of penetrant tests but the common ones are those using either visible or fluorescent dyes. The photo to the right shows the results of a visible penetrant test on a vessel weld.
ATSNY© 2012 47
The Types
Also, there are solvent cleanable and water washable tests.
We’ll do a solvent-based test.
ATSNY© 2012 48
Visible PT - How it works
1. We suspect our piece has a defect that is open to the
surface. So we thoroughly clean the surface. Then
allow the part to dry. (5-10 minutes)
2. Next, we spray a coating of a thin red liquid, the
penetrant, onto the surface and allow the liquid to be
absorbed into the defect. (5 to 25 minutes)
ATSNY© 2012 49
Visible PT - How it works
3. Then we thoroughly clean the surface again, but
carefully, so we don’t clean the penetrant out of the
defect. Then we allow the part to dry. ( 5 to 10 min.)
4. Next, we spray a very thin layer of a white paint-like
material onto the surface, allow the “paint” to absorb
the penetrant out of the defect, (5 to 15 minutes) and
visually inspect the piece.
ATSNY© 2012 50
The Procedure
1. Clean
2. Spray penetrant
3. Dwell
4. Carefully clean off
excess penetrant
5. Spray developer
6. Wait and watch
ATSNY© 2012 51
The
Procedure
This shows a weld inspection. One of our
people is waiting for the penetrant dwell
period inside a large process vessel.
ATSNY© 2012 52
Visible
Penetrant
After the penetrant is
cleaned off, the
developer is sprayed.
Note that there is
no dye remaining!!
ATSNY© 2012 53
Applications
Parts with cracks open to the
atmosphere that can be cleaned well
For mechanical components -
structural components or aluminum,
stainless, or steel, etc.
Relatively inexpensive initial cost for
materials
ATSNY© 2012 54
What can it find
Really depends on the surface
cleanliness and roughness.
On polished stainless parts we have
found cracks that were 0.00004” wide
and 0.003” deep!
ATSNY© 2012 55
PT Problem Areas
Is probably the most frequently misused NDT
technique. Frequently done by inexperienced
personnel leading to gross procedure errors,
misinterpretation, and wasted $$$.
Requires careful and thorough precleaning before penetrant application.
Grinding and other mechanical power cleaning can hide indications.
Time consuming, manpower intensive and greatest opportunity for human error.
ATSNY© 2012 56
PT Demonstration
ATSNY© 2012 57
Magnetic Particle Testing
“MT”
ATSNY© 2012 58
MT Procedure 1. Generally inspect the part and review the testing
criteria.
2. Clean the part well.
3. Set up a magnetic field in one direction.
4. Cover the field area with a contrasting magnetic
medium. (Can be a dry powder or an oil with
fluorescent particles.)
5. Set up a magnetic field in another direction.
6. Again, cover the field area with a contrasting
magnetic medium.
7. Inspect the areas where the particles accumulate.
ATSNY© 2012 59
Set up the Magnetic Field
SouthNorth
Steel or Nickel Plate
Particles onEdges of Flaw Flaw
SouthNorth
Then find the irregularities
ATSNY© 2012 60
MT Procedure
1. Clean the part well.
2. Set up a magnetic field.
3. Cover the field area with a
contrasting magnetic
medium. (Can be a dry
powder or an oil with
fluorescent particles.)
4. Inspect the areas where
the particles accumulate.
ATSNY© 2012 61
Two
views of
a weld
crack
This is WFMP testing –
wet fluorescent mag
particle.
It is viewed with a
black light.
Results of MT inspection with black light
Showing attracted particles after exam
ATSNY© 2012 62
MP Tests Dry powder particles
Both of these exams
used wet fluorescent
particles
ATSNY© 2012 63
Typical Applications of MT
Steel parts and martensitic stainless
with cracks open to the atmosphere.
(not many nickel parts)
Moderate initial cost for materials.
Lowest applied cost.
ATSNY© 2012 64
MT Problem Areas
Training is not extensive or expensive and
leads to good results.
Requires an understanding of the magnetic fields.
Can’t be used on nonmagnetic materials.
Poor cleaning and grinding can hide defects.
Generally WFMP is far superior to dry particle
testing.
ATSNY© 2012 65
Dry Magnetic Particle Demo
ATSNY© 2012 66
Infrared Inspection
Infrared inspections allows us to see
thermal images (radiation) much as our
eyes see visual images.
ATSNY© 2012 67
A Belt Drive on a Air Handler
We can see that the belt
temperatures are suspect.
(c) 2012 by Applied Technical Services, Inc.
ATSNY© 2012 68
We can see that these belts are
much too hot and are slipping.
(c) 2012 by Applied Technical Services, Inc.
ATSNY© 2012 69
Infrared Inspection
Applications Transformers, switchgear, and other
electrical equipment where there may be
poor connections, etc.
Insulation system effectiveness (air
leaks, wet insulation)
Process equipment liquid levels, etc.
Steam trap operation
ATSNY© 2012 70
Infrared Inspection Cautions Two common errors with scanners:
• Reflections – In much the same manner as
light reflects, infrared radiation can also
reflect and give erroneous readings
• Emissivity – Black body objects have
significantly different emissivity that polished
and shiny objects and the images will differ.
With hand-held infrared thermometers – They will average the temperature over a given
target area, and that may be much larger than
your area of interest!
ATSNY© 2012 71
Infrared Thermography
Demonstration Rather than me give a demo of how an infrared
scanner works, I’ll pass one of ours around so you
can look through it.
COMMENTS:
• It is focused for the range from about 5 feet to
infinity.
• I know this is a bunch of engineers that want to
play with controls, so I’ve taped the controls
closed so the next person doesn’t get a useless
demo! (If you want to play with it, please see me
afterward.)
ATSNY© 2012 72
Ultrasonic Flaw and
Thickness Testing
- “UT”
ATSNY© 2012 73
UT
Common Applications Thickness testing of tanks, vessels,
piping, etc.
Quality inspection of components such
as forgings, castings, welds, etc., looking
for internal voids
Flaw testing of materials looking for
process induced cracking (bolts, shafts,
etc.)
ATSNY© 2012 74
Ultrasonic
Audible Sound - 20 to 20,000 cps (Hz)
Normal UT Range
• 100,000 to 25,000,000 Hz
• 0.1 to 25 MHz
Wavelength = Velocity/Frequency
10 100 1000 10000 100000 1000000 10,000,000
Subsonic
Cycles per second (Hertz)
UltrasonicAudible to Humans
ATSNY© 2012 75
UT Application
A field check on a weld
of a large process vessel
ATSNY© 2012 76
Wave Types
Longitudinal
Shear
Surface
Plate
Others
Selection depends on application.
ATSNY© 2012 77
UT Transducer
HousingDamping Material
Piezoelectric Crystal
Power Cable
Inspected Material
SoundPattern
Transducer sends
out a sound wave
and then reads the
reflected wave
To get an accurate
measurement, the signal
has to be essentially
perpendicular to the flaw
FLAW
ATSNY© 2012 78
Ultrasonic Testing
Ultrasonic Device
Transducer
1.500"
Sound Wave
The “black box” generates a signal and sends it to the transducer, then reads the signals returning from changes in “Acoustic Impedance”.
ATSNY© 2012 79
Thickness Testing
Ultrasonic Thickness Tester
Transducer
Used to measure thethickness of materials1.500"
Sound Wave
ATSNY© 2012 80
Straight beam transducer
HousingDamping Material
Piezoelectric Crystal
Power Cable
Inspected Material
SoundPattern
ATSNY© 2012 81
Angle beam transducer
Housing
Piezoelectric Crystal
Power Cable
Inspected Material
Plastic Wedge
45 deg60 deg
70 deg
Changing Wedges results in different signal paths
But what do you do
when the flaw lies
at an odd angle?
(such as a weld)
ATSNY© 2012 82
Ultrasonic Flaw Tester
Transducer
Used to search for internal variations in materials
Ultrasonic Flaw Tester
Transducer
Sound echoes back fromchanges in acoustic impedence
UT Flaw Testing
ATSNY© 2012 83
dB
Calibrated Distance
Rel
ativ
e p
ow
er (
dB
)
6 dB
Calibrated Distance
Rel
ativ
e p
ow
er (
dB
)
How does the technician
know the true size of the
flaw?
Compare the size of the
echoes and we know that
6dB represents a doubling
in size.
Flaw Testing
ATSNY© 2012 84
UT Flaw Testing
Demonstration
ATSNY© 2012 85
UT Testing Comments
What sort of accuracy is there when a digital Thickness Testeris used and the backwall isn't flat?
Transducer
1.500"
Where does that sound wave reflection go?
ATSNY© 2012 86
Common UT Application
53 1/4"22 1/4"
228 13/16"
70 1/2"
31.3"18 3/4"
64 1/16"
20"
29.4
9"
25.4
9"
27"
30.0
0"
30"
Bearing Fit Bearing Fit
Drum Fit
Find the depth of the crack in this headshaft
crack
ATSNY© 2012 87
Unusual UT Inspection
Application
Transducer
Flaw Tester Screen
Axle
Axle and Hub Assembly
Ideal Sound Path
Testing the shrink fit tightness
ATSNY© 2012 88
Transducer
Flaw Tester Screen
Axle
Axle and Hub Assembly
Loose FitSound Path
Unusual UT Inspection
Application (cont’d)
Finding it is loose!!
ATSNY© 2012 89
Phased Array UT
Courtesy of Olympus NDT
Newer UT Method
This is essentially the same as the
ultrasound tests used on humans
and animals. There are multiple
crystals in the transducer and the
computer software analyzes them.
ATSNY© 2012 90
Common Applications
Complex and Internal Welds
Shafts
Bolts
Internal areas that are hard to
inspect with other methods but
have a known crack geometry
ATSNY© 2012 91
UT Problems Areas
Very operator intensive
Requires good knowledge of the part
geometry
Insensitive to flaws that are basically
parallel to the sound path
Have to have certified, qualified inspector
ATSNY© 2012 92
Vibration Analysis
A. Purpose of Vibration Analysis
B. Basic Principles of Vibration
Analysis
C. Basic Terminology
ATSNY© 2012 93
Vibration Analysis
As mechanical machinery became larger and more
complex, science began to realize the problems that
resulted from excessive vibration. By the end of WWII the
first methods to analyze and control vibration had been
developed.
Vibration analysis is used to measure
machinery movement to understand
why it is happening.
ATSNY© 2012 94
Comments • Frequently used as an acceptance gage on new
machinery.
• Is an excellent comparative method for monitoring machine condition.
• On existing operating machinery, monitoring and analyzing vibration data allows for very early warnings (2-3 months) of impending failures.
• The data is relatively easy to gather and, with computers and software programs, relatively easy to handle.
• Requires skilled, well-trained and certified inspectors.
ATSNY© 2012 95
Vibration Analysis Example
Readings on the motor
and the pump tell us the
condition of the bearings and
the coupling, the alignment,
and whether the base, grout,
and foundation are in good
condition.
High frequency monitoring of the
bearings can tell us the lubricant
film thickness.
Trending of this data can alert us to worsening problems.
Motor
Coupling
Pump
Base Plate
Foundation Block
Grout
ATSNY© 2012 96
Typical Machine
Monitoring
How often do you have to check? That depends on
the operating conditions and the criticality of the
machine. It could vary from once per month to once
every six months.
Motor
Coupling
Pump
Base Plate
Foundation Block
Grout
ATSNY© 2012 97
Vibration Terminology
Measurement Units
Amplitude - Describes the amount of
vibration and is expressed in three ways.
• Displacement (miles)
• Velocity ** (miles/hour)
• Acceleration (0 to 60 mph time)
Frequency - Describes the periodical nature of the vibration
and is expressed in one of three ways;
• CPM or Cycles Per Minute
• Hz or CPS or Cycles Per Second
• Orders or multiple of a frequency of interest
ATSNY© 2012 98
Looking at a Vibration Spectrum
Misalignment, imbalance,
structural problems, etc.
Bearing, gear, and
lubrication problems
Overall reading gives a general
guide to the machine condition. A
M
P
L
I
T
U
D
E
FREQUENCY – CPM or Hertz
ATSNY© 2012 99
Data Trending A doctor doesn’t need a lot of your medical history to diagnose a
broken arm, but it does help your long-term health to understand how
blood pressure, cholesterol, etc., are changing. In a similar manner, the
vibration analyst can immediately spot imminent serious problems, but
trending of data can alert the site to longer term situations.
ATSNY© 2012 100 100
One Last Nondestructive
Inspection Method –
Hardness Testing
There is a relationship between hardness and
tensile strength. The relationship is much
better for some (steel) than for others (cast
iron, rock).
The harder a material is, the stronger it is.
ATSNY© 2012 101
Commonly used as a QC tool to readily
verify the tensile strength or other
property of a metal or plastic.
Metals – Rockwell and Brinell are the
common types of test
Plastics – Barcol
Elastomers - Durometer
Hardness Testing
ATSNY© 2012 102 102
Hardness vs.
Tensile
Strength
for Steel
200 300 400 500
Te
ns
ile
str
en
gth
(k
si)
80
0
Brinell Hardness Number
40
120
160
200
240
Typical Hardness -Tensile Strength Range for Steel
data from SAE handbook
100
HBN x 500 ≈ Tensile Strength
HRC x 10 ≈ HBN
Easy Conversions
ATSNY© 2012 103 103
Brinell Hardness
Circa 1900
Two common scales, 500
kg and 3000 kg
Very good for castings
where there may be
inhomogenities
Problems with thin
materials
Applied Load
10 mm ball
Measure impressiondiameter, interpretfrom ASTM chart
d
ATSNY© 2012 104 104
Rockwell Hardness
13 ranges - with the
most common as HRC, HRB, HRA
Operation - Apply a minor load to reduce surface effects, then apply the major load. After movement stops measure the change in depth.
Versatile - with a wide range of applications
Minor load depth
Major load depth
Indenter with loaddepending on scale
Rockwell test indenters include
diamonds and balls. The loads
vary from 15 to 150 kg.
ATSNY© 2012 105
There are lots of other NDT tools
available from coating thickness
gauges to magnetic flux leakage
devices (checking for loss of material in tubes and tank
floors) to X-ray diffraction (checking for residual
stress in metallic components).
ATSNY© 2012 106
How do we suggest YOU
should approach NDT?
Sit down with your knowledgeable folks and ask
yourselves what your real materials, mechanical,
and electrical challenges or unknowns are.
Then ask, “Can they be anticipated?”
If the answer is either “Yes” or “I don’t know.”,
call somebody in the NDT business, describe
your problem, and ask them for their ideas.