Neil Douglas Douglas Economics
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
1
Also NZ report
Julieta Legaspi TfNSW Peter Bannister & George Karpouzis helped Not an official view of course!
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
2
3
Also in 2013 – this NZ report which reviews alternative evaluation approaches And parameter values (mainly public transport but includes some road values)
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
4
Cost Effectiveness Analysis
Multiple Criteria Analysis
Economic Impact Analysis
Social Cost Benefit
Analysis
Financial Appraisal
The ‘same answer’ Special Case
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
Focus of this talk
Gut feel!
The starting position and finishing position?
Toll Roads
1. A Brief history of transport appraisal in NSW/Australia
Bradfield meets Lang for ‘tea and scones’ early 1920s Personal briefings to discuss alternative plans, costs toll charges and forecast revenue “I remember” John Lang
The Harbour Bridge
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
5
Gut feel?
1960s Agriculture applications (after USA)
1966 “Investment Analysis” Commonwealth Government
1970s Vernon Commission – a high point after ‘60s credit squeeze
1972 Whitlam Gov’t States Grants: 2/3rds grants to States having done CBA
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
6
Roads
“Engineering Economy” 1970s = Design, speed, discounting NASRA/ARRB – advocate approach at conferences But Treasury involvement minor
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
7
Manuals/Guidelines
1st = Water/Electricity 1970s
NSW 1988 NSW Capital Works Committee >$5m CBA Only Stipulation 7% discount rate NSW Treasury: “Guidelines on Economic Appraisal of Assets”
workshops , accredited list of evaluators 1990s Total Asset Management Process (TAM) >$1m Process included “Value Management” Early 1990s Roads and Traffic Authority 1993 State Rail Authority
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
8
9
NZ History Project Evaluation 1970 Ministry of Works 1982 Cost Benefit Appraisal the standard approach for road eval 1986 National Roads Board set up – developed TR9 a CBA Manual 1988CBA required for all roads 1991 Project Evaluation Manual developed BCR>4 1991 Resource Management Act – land use effects of roads 1995 Transfund set up (efficient alternatives) 1996 Review of alternatives – CBA selected 1997 Alternative to Roading Eval. Methodology – Efficiency Ratio 2002 Value of Time Study – WTP values for road and PT 2003 Package evaluations 2004 Land Transport NZ set up 2006 Economic Evaluation Manual developed 2008 Green Party instigates move away for CBA 2008 Roads of National Significance
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
2. Transport funding
$4.3b Petrol /Diesel Tax
$1.3 billion investment
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
10 Who collects the money WHO determines how it’s spent?
800,000 sq kms 1/10th 7.3 million people 1/3rd
State
Federal
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000
Tota
l Tax
Tak
e %
States
Federal
Wider – vertical fiscal “imbalance
Henry tax review > land tax suggested
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
11
Applications for Commonwealth funding
Commonwealth Department of Infrastructure Transport (DoIT)
National Building Program – roads/rail (& cycleways)
$37 billion 4 years 2009- $10b per year NSW $3billion per year 33%
Infrastructure Australia projects >$100 million advice to Minister
Northern Sydney Freight Corridor No NSW public urban transport project so far But Parramatta Epping $2.1b approved ?!
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
12
Infrastructure Australia assessment framework
Priority List 1. Early Stage 2. Real Potential 3. Threshold 4. Ready to Proceed
Framework Strategic Alignment Problem definition Solution development
CBA – required at 3 and 4 stages 7% discount rate Best practice/standard parameters Non monetized impacts appended – 7 point scale Wider economic benefits not in core evaluation Non monetized impacts appended – 7 point scale
Seven National Priorities +
Align with State Plans
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
13
Economic appraisal manuals guidelines
Australian Economic Appraisal Guidelines
NSW Road Evaluation Manual
NSW RailCorp Capital Project Evaluation Manual
ATC National Guidelines
TfNSW Principles Guidelines for Economic Appraisal
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
14
No shortage of manuals!
Recent developments in economic appraisal techniques
Gateway reviews
2004 Assurance to Gov’t –process as well as project
George Karpouzis: Engineering / recurrent cost focus Much less on scope /benefits
Misunderstanding of financial versus economic
A UK Treasury import
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
15
“a number of major projects that have been selected have either been delayed or cancelled – notably the Sydney metro, a $400 million bill for taxpayers for nothing at all. The underlying failures leading to these outcomes have been poor planning and project selection rather than an inability to deliver”. Infrastructure NSW
Still can blow $400 million on Metro project - INSW
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
16
Bloated business cases – escalating cost Retrospective Advocacy One way progression Secrecy
Business Case Problems
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
17
Centralisation of transport planning in NSW
Integration - road rail buses ferries………..
BUT
Separation from grass roots & history shows evaluation most useful at middle level?
(Top level – all politics?)
For economists: One ‘value of time’– a return to the 1970s
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
18
19
Mackie v Nash
Continuing Transport Economics Boxing Match
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
Value of Time
20
“There is no reason for the value that the
individual is willing to pay to reduce travel time to
be equal to the value that society as a whole
attaches to the reassignment of time of that
individual to other activities”.
Mackie concluded that “using individuals’ or
groups’ willingness to pay as their value of time
savings is inappropriate for social evaluation”
and therefore Mackie supports the UK practice of
adopting an ‘equity’ approach to the valuation of
non-working time, Mackie et al (2003).
Peter Mackie
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
21
“the British approach, again like many others, attempts to allow
for equity considerations by using common values of time, risk of
accidents and environmental amenity regardless of income.
Nash:
This might have been reasonable at a time when appraisal was
mainly applied to road schemes which were paid for by the
government but gave time savings to users,
but now that appraisal is often applied to schemes which trade-off
time savings against money cost (e.g. whether to replace buses
with higher priced light rail services, whether to reduce road
congestion by means of road pricing), it may be highly misleading.
It would be quite possible for the appraisal to conclude that the
scheme was desirable on the basis of a standard value of time,
when according to the actual values of the users it was not (or vice
versa).” (Nash, 2010, p. 9)
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
22
In March 2013, TfNSW released “Principles and Guidelines for Economic Appraisal of Transport Investment and Initiatives” (PGEATII),
TfNSW Harmonised (same) value of time for equity reasons of $13.76/hr for ‘private’ road & PT. Dates to a 1997 AusRoads working group (40% wage)
I recommend: Income standardisation – considers income differences Allows for differences in mode (hence quality), mode, travel time component, journey purpose See Douglas & Jones ATRF 2013
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
NZTA announced move to a common value of time in July 2013
23
Declining Discount Rates (except in NSW) Makes discounting (and economists) less important! Longer evaluation period (bigger spreadsheets) Greater importance in forecasting the future – ‘mugs game’ The ECONOMIST
Country Discount Rate Evaluation Period
England 3.5% for first 30 then 3% 60 years
Germany 3% nk
Netherlands 2.5% plus 3% risk premium varies 100
years/infinite
Sweden 3.5% changed from 4% recently 40-60 years
USA 7% Federal with State rates varying from 3-7% 25-30 years
NSW Australia 7% - never changed for nearly 20 years 30 years
QLD Australia 6% varies
WA Australia No official position – looking at it NK
New Zealand 10% for decades then 8% around 2010
Now 6% from July 2013 40 years
from July 2013
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
Wider Economic Benefits – needed to offset cost increases?
Sydney Airport Rail Link 1990s Urban consolidation benefits
Since mid 2000s Factoring for agglomeration etc Eddington – origins in London Cross Rail project Now Infrastructure Australia but ‘not in core evaluation’
24
Neither is Macro Economic Modelling of projects But IA NSW used it to evaluate CW and other projects NZTA commissioned Deloittes to evaluate RONS using CEG model
25
NZ Roads of National Significance
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
26
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
Significance and RONS
27
Wellington Northern Corridor RONS comprises 7 projects
Five have BCRs < 1: Airport to Mt Victoria, Terrace tunnel, Peka Peka to Otaki,
Transmission Gully MacKays Crossing to Peka Peka
Two BCR > 1 (and only just) Basin Reserve Flyover & Aotea Quay to Ngauranga upgrade
How come they are getting built?
Projects rated on "strategic fit" and "effectiveness“
Green / Labour Party changed funding rule from largely CBA basis requiring a BCR of 4 for Transfund funding to one based on MCA.
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
28
So how justified economically? Answer: as a corridor package. The 7 projects have a combined BCR just >1 with ‘wider economic benefits’ included
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
29
Transmission Gully
27kms
26kms
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
30
Linden
Wainui Saddle 262m
Height of Ngauranga Gorge Summit 130 metres
Proposed Transmission Gully Route
McKays Crossing
170m
Pukerua Bay
Existing SH1
SH 58 Intersection
SH 58 Intersection
Transmission Gully
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
31
Escalating Cost – “build it now or the cost will go up” It has! -A politician’s argument not an economist’s -but the politician has been proved right
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
32
Transmission Gully
Two consortiums –
Wellington Gateway Partnership Positive Connection New Zealand-based and international organisations. Each consortium was made up of a construction firm with road designers, investors and companies able to maintain and operate the road.
The road will be built and operated by a consortium for 25 years in a PPP which ensures the government retains ownership of the road. Availability Toll – amount of time road is available for Toll – patronage risk
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
33
Transmission Gully
Pros Existing Route is Unsafe Congested esp bank holidays/peak Alternative earthquake route – ‘resilience’
Cons Terrain - Escalating Cost Few would use TG especially if tolled HGVs use flatter coastal highway (Tolling wrong road) How effective in earthquake? (crosses fault lines) Environmental impact - Pauatahanui Inlet (tree planting) So argue improve coastal route Improvements have been done -BCR now close to 1
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
34
Wellington Basin Reserve Flyover ($90-$100 million)
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
35
Amenity Value v Cost – Flyover (Bridge) or Tunnel?
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
36
NZTA argues Flyover is a Public Transport enabler WTN can’t have BRT/LRT if WCC does not agree to NZTA’s Flyover Bargaining chip or blackmail?
$10 m Cycle lane included not wide enough very low BCR $10 m New stand at Basin Reserve Road designation – SH v local road Social Media – eg Scoop
Flyover & PT
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
Conclusions: Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
37
CBA only a tool – can’t select options Bigger models and fatter reports But technique not much different Forecasting future still a mugs game
Costs escalating – easy roads built! Search for WEBs to cancel out (but WECs?) Equity values of time Discount rates lowered
Environmental impacts Still can’t value amenity And probably never will
Economists not the high priests of decision making Politicians still ‘kings and queens’
38
Can economics help in the argument over what’s a good structures?
“Beauty in things exists merely in the mind which contemplates them” David Hume Essays, “Moral and Political”, 1742
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
Ross Hayward the ‘hands dirty’ transport manager
How does government decide on projects such as Transmission Gully
Such projects certainly do not stack up in terms of economic appraisals. So what? All this means is Government understands perfectly the value of economic appraisals. People vote, economic appraisals don't. The government gives its customers what they think they want to ensure it stays in power. That is the lesson pure and simple.
Is an economic appraisal really important?
Not really and that is as it should be. If you want Ross’s ‘no prisoner’s taken view’ on project evaluation I can email you the report (it got censored)
Trends in Transport Project Appraisal by Neil Douglas - by Neil Douglas - Roads Conference Informa, Sydney - March 2014
39