Need for Recovery, Off-Job Activities and Well-being:
A Day Reconstruction Study
Master Thesis Research Project
Ivan V. Valev
28-Aug-13 2 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational Psychology
Agenda
• Purpose of Research • Theoretical Background • Theoretical Model • Sample • Method • Empirical Findings • Empirical Model • Conclusions • Limitations & Future Research
28-Aug-13 3 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational Psychology
Well-Being: always en vogue
28-Aug-13 4 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational Psychology
Purpose of Research
• To examine the direct effect Daily Need for Recovery has on time spent in specific off-job activities
• To investigate how Daily Need for Recovery moderates the link between off-job activities and Daily Well-being
• To propose Psychological Need Satisfaction (PNS) as a mediating mechanism explaining how engaging in certain activities in off-job time affects Well-being
28-Aug-13 5 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational Psychology
Theoretical Background I
28-Aug-13 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational Psychology 6
Effort-Recovery (Meijman & Mulder, 1998)
• Investing effort at work is unavoidable, causing acute load reactions
• When off-job activities don’t occupy the same type of resources needed for work, then these activities possess a recovery function
Conservation of Resources (Hobfoll, 2002)
• People strive to obtain, retain, protect, and build personal resources
• People attempt to restore their resource during after-work hours
Need for Recovery (Demerouti et al., 2009)
• Sense of urgency that people feel to take a break from job demands when personal resources are exhausted
• Indicates an impaired state of well-being
Theoretical Background II
28-Aug-13 7
Psychological Need Satisfaction (Deci & Ryan, 2000)
• People have the basic psychological needs (PNS) for Autonomy, Competence and Relatedness
• Satisfying these needs is a growth-related activity, leading to such outcomes like better health and well-being
Well-being (Shirom, 2004; Sonnentag, 2001)
• Vigor: cognitive liveliness & physical strength
• External Recovery: the extent to which people restore their personal resources to pre-stressor levels during off-work time/activities
Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational Psychology
Theoretical Model
28-Aug-13 8
Physical Strength
Low-effort Autonomy
Workload
Job
Characteristics
Need for Recovery
Time spent on
off-job
Activities
Well-being
at bedtime
Social
Well-being
prior to start of
workday
Self-rated
Performance
Psychological Need
Satisfaction
Relatedness Recovery
Physical Competence
Cognitive Liveliness
Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational Psychology
Method
• Trait Questionnaire to establish baseline levels
• Daily Questionnaire to assess day levels
• Day Reconstruction to evaluate PNS at the activity level
Day Reconstruction Method: Kahneman et al. (2004)
Ecologically valid method of accounting for daily intrapersonal variation Closer examination of momentary constructs experienced at the task level Accurate subjective evaluation of past events Limits recall bias & social desirability effects
28-Aug-13 9
Daily Job Characteristics & Workload
Daily Need for Recovery
Well-being: start day PNS
Well-being: bedtime Performance
Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational Psychology
DRM: Example
28-Aug-13 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational
Psychology 10
Sample • 112 participants logged at least 1 day
87 multiple days 79 selected for analysis
– Mean age: 32.01 (SD = 11.19)
– Gender: 43 M, 62 W, 7 undisclosed
• 351 days reconstructed
• 2,556 logged activities overall
• Working hours, weekly average: 37.58 (SD = 13)
• Activities
28-Aug-13 11
Social (daily average) 45.42min (SD = 90.23)
Physical (one weekly session) 80.55min
Low-effort (daily average) 68.66min (SD = 93.91)
Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational Psychology
Empirical Findings I
28-Aug-13 12 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational Psychology
H1: est = .20, ***
a
Scheme
*** = p < .001, n.s. = p > .05 , est = estimate
H2: n.s.
Empirical Findings II
28-Aug-13 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational
Psychology 13
Scheme
Social Activities, *** = p < .001,
n.s. = p > .05, est = estimate
H4: est = -.39, ***
H3: n.s.
H4: n.s.
Time spent on
off-job
Activities
Empirical Findings III
28-Aug-13 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational
Psychology 14
a a
Scheme
Physical Activities, *** = p < .001,
n.s. = p > .05 , est = estimate
Empirical Findings IV
28-Aug-13 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational
Psychology 15
Scheme
Social Activities Physical Activities Low-effort Activities
n.s. = p > .05
Empirical Model
28-Aug-13 16
Workload
Job
Characteristics
Need for Recovery
Time spent on
off-job
Activities
Well-being
at bedtime
Social
Well-being
prior to start of
workday
Self-rated
Performance
Psychological Need
Satisfaction
Physical
Low-effort
Relatedness
Competence
Autonomy
Recovery
Physical Strength
Cognitive Liveliness
H1: est. = .20, ***
H4: est = -.39, ***
H6 Low-effort: n.s.
H5 Social: n.s.
H5 Physical: est = -.57, ***
H7: n.s. H8: n.s. H9: n.s.
Moderation H’s
H10: n.s.
H10: n.s.
H3: n.s.
H4: n.s.
H2: n.s.
Mediation H’s
Conclusions
• High Daily Workload contributes to higher Daily Need for Recovery
• High Daily Need for Recovery leads to less Time spent on Social off-job activities
• Daily Need for Recovery and Time spent on Physical Activities interact to impact Daily Well-
being at bedtime:
28-Aug-13 17 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational Psychology
Limitations & Future Research
• External recovery only: internal recovery to be considered
• PNS: low Reliability (internal consistency issues) • Dispositional characteristics not included: the
role of personality in the process? • Participants’ Commitment • Further Constructs:
– Relaxation Techniques (Behavioral) – Detachment (Psychological) – Sleep (Both?)
28-Aug-13 18 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational Psychology
Thank You for Your attention!
28-Aug-13 Ivan V. Valev, MSc Organisational
Psychology 19
Well-being!
What is the purpose of being?