Download - Nature.geoscience
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
1/80
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
2/80
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
3/80
COVER IMAGESeismic anisotropy data for
the Great Basin region of the
western United States, coupledwith tomographic images, help
delineate a northeast-dipping
lithospheric drip. Numerical
experiments suggest that the
drip could have formed owing to
gravitational instability triggered
by a density increase of as little
as 1% and a temperature increase
of about 10%. The image shows
Wheeler Peak in Great Basin
National Park, Nevada, USA.
Photo by J. D. West, Silverheels
Photography (www.fodoze.com).
Article p439; News & Views p381;
Backstory p446
EDITORIAL
371 Complex communication
CORRESPONDENCE
372 Unexpected rise in extreme precipitation caused by a shift in rain type?
COMMENTARY
374 Securing the legacy of the IPY
Bob Dickson
BOOKS & ARTS
377 Encounters at the End of the World by Werner Herzog
Reviewed by Anna Armstrong
RESEARCH HIGHLIGHTS
378 Our choice from the recent literature
NEWS & VIEWS
379 Geophysics: Tectonics in the Earths core
Peter Olson
380 Palaeoclimate: Delayed Holocene warming
Martin Widmann
381 Tectonics: Draining Nevada
Vera Schulte-Pelkum
383 Environmental science: Rising arsenic risk?
David Polya and Laurent Charlet
384 Palaeontology: Aging well
Alicia Newton
385 Atmospheric science: Biological ice formation
Corinna Hoose
386 Palaeontology: Extinction before the snowball
Frank A. Corsetti
387 Atmospheric pollution: Brief relief Anna Armstrong
REVIEW ARTICLE
389 Volcanism in the Solar System Lionel Wilson
LETTERS
398 In situdetection of biological particles in cloud ice-crystals
Kerri A. Pratt, Paul J. DeMott, Jeffrey R. French, Zhien Wang, Douglas L. Westphal,
Andrew J. Heymsfield, Cynthia H. Twohy, Anthony J. Prenni and Kimberly A. Prather
N&V p385, online Backstory
ON THE COVER
Biotic turnover
Before global glaciation
Letter p415; News & Views p386;
online Backstory
Biogenic core
Cloud ice-crystals
Letter p398; News & Views p385;
online Backstory
Nordic overflows
Driven from the Atlantic
Letter p406
NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience
JUNE 2009 VOL 2 ISSUE 6
Nature Geoscienceis printed on paperrecycled from post-consumer waste.
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
4/80
402 Relative roles of biogenic emissions and Saharan dust as ice nuclei in the
Amazon basin
Anthony J. Prenni, Markus D. Petters, Sonia M. Kreidenweis, Colette L. Heald,
Scot T. Martin, Paulo Artaxo, Rebecca M. Garland, Adam G. Wollny and
Ulrich Pschl
N&V p385
406 Observed sources and variability of Nordic seas overflow
Tor Eldevik, Jan Even . Nilsen, Doroteaciro Iovino, K. Anders Olsson,
Anne Britt Sand and Helge Drange
411 The spatial and temporal complexity of the Holocene thermal maximum
H. Renssen, H. Sepp, O. Heiri, D. M. Roche, H. Goosse and T. Fichefet
N&V p380
415 Biotic turnover driven by eutrophication before the Sturtian
low-latitude glaciation
Robin M. Nagy, Susannah M. Porter, Carol M. Dehler and Yanan Shen
N&V p386, online Backstory
419 Tectonic history of the Earths inner core preserved in its seismic structure
Renaud Deguen and Philippe Cardin
N&V p379
423 Structural reactivation in plate tectonics controlled by olivine
crystal anisotropy
Andra Tommasi, Mickael Knoll, Alain Vauchez, Javier W. Signorelli,
Catherine Thoraval and Roland Log
ARTICLES
428 Oceanic forcing of the Marine Isotope Stage 11 interglacial
Alexander J. Dickson, Christopher J. Beer, Ciara Dempsey, Mark A. Maslin,
James A. Bendle, Erin L. McClymont and Richard D. Pancost
434 Mid-Pliocene climate change amplified by a switch in Indonesian
subsurface throughflow
Cyrus Karas, Dirk Nrnberg, Anil K. Gupta, Ralf Tiedemann, Kuppusamy Mohanand Torsten Bickert
439 Vertical mantle flow associated with a lithospheric drip beneath the
Great Basin
John D. West, Matthew J. Fouch, Jeffrey B. Roth and Linda T. Elkins-Tanton
N&V p381, Backstory p446
444 Erratum
BACKSTORY
446 A hidden drip
John D. West
CLASSIFIEDS
See the back pages
The period of relatively
warm climate from 11,000 to
5,000 years ago was marked
by considerable temporal
and spatial variability. Model
simulations relate this
complexity to the influence
of the waning Laurentide
ice sheet.
Letter p411;
News & Views p380
The myriad bodies that occur
in the Solar System show
a wide range of physical
properties. Exploration by
spacecraft during the past
four decades has shown
that volcanism a major
mechanism by which internal
heat is transported to the
surface is common on many
of these bodies. Image credit:
J. D. Griggs/USGS.
Review Article p389
NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience
Nature Geoscience(ISSN 1752-0894) is published monthly by Nature Publishing Group (Porters South, 4 Crinan Street, London N1 9XW, UK). Editorial Office: Porters South, 4 Crinan Street, London N1 9XW, UK. Telephone:
+44 (0)20 7833 4000. Fax: +44 (0)20 7843 4563. Email: [email protected]. North American Advertising: Nature Geoscience, 75 Varick Street, Fl 9, New York, NY, 10013-1917, US. Telephone: +1(212) 726-9200.
Fax: +1(212) 696-9006. European Advertising: Nature Geoscience, Porters South, 4 Crinan Street, London N1 9XW, UK. Telephone: +44 (0)20 7833 4000. Fax: +44 (0)20 7843 4749. New subscriptions/renewals/changes
of address/back issues and all other customer service questions should be addressed to - North America: Nature Geoscience, Subscription Dept, PO Box 5054, Brentwood, TN 37024-5054, USA. Outside North America:
Subscriptions Department, Brunel Road, Basingstoke, Hants. RG21 6XS, UK. Telephone: +44 (0)1256 329242; Fax: +44 (0)1256 812358. Annual subscription rates: US/Canada US$3060, Canada add 5% GST (institutional/
corporate), US$152, Canada add 5% GST (individual making personal payment); UK/Rest of World (excluding Europe and Japan) 1570 (institutional/corporate), 78 (individual making personal payment); Europe 2430
(institutional/corporate),121 (individual making personal payment). Japan: contact Nature Asia-Pacific, Chiyoda Building, 2-37 Ichigayatamachi, Shinjuku-Ku, Tokyo, 162-0843, Japan. Telephone +81 3 3267 8751. For single back
issue prices contact the publisher. Nature Geoscience(ISSN 1752-0894) is published monthly by Nature Publishing Group, c/o Mercury Airfreight International Ltd, 365 Blair Road, Avenel, NJ 07001, USA. Periodicals postage is
paid at Rahway NJ. Postmaster: send address changes to Nature Geoscience, c/o Mercury Airfreight International, 365 Blair Road, Avenel, NJ, USA. Reprints: Nature GeoscienceReprints Department, Porters South, 4 Crinan Street,
London N1 9XW, UK. Subscription information is available at the Nature Geosciencehomepage at http://www.nature.com/naturegeoscience. Postmas ter: send address changes to Nature Geoscience Subscriptions Department,
Brunel Road, Basingstoke, Hants. RG21 6XS, UK or Nature GeoscienceSubscriptions Department PO Box 5054, Brentwood, TN 37024-5054, USA. 2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved.
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
http://www.nature.com/naturegeosciencehttp://www.nature.com/naturegeoscience -
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
5/80
NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience 371
editorial
Science communication will never bethe same again. Te traditional path ofscientific discoveries from bench to breakfasttable through scientific journals andnewspapers is diversifying at a staggeringrate. Blogs by scientists and non-scientistsalike are jostling for public attention; researchinstitutions provide websites, films andpress releases; and scientific information isFlickring and wittering away in Web 2.0,accessible to anyone who is interested.
Given this variety of competition,
researchers work hard to make theirwork stand out from the crowd. Asession at the General Assembly of theEuropean Geophysical Union (EGU) inApril entitled Te Significance of Marineechnology in Science Communication Challenges and Opportunities highlightedan increasingly important selling point forscience in the public arena: the volumeof publicity that can be generated bystunning images.
Planetary scientists have long exploitedthe power of unique pictures that capture theattention of researchers and the public alike.
Te Cassini/Huygens mission to the Saturnsystem led to a veritable itan-fever amongamateurs, not least because all images wereimmediately posted on a freely accessiblewebsite. Te computer-literate enthusiastseven outcompeted the space agencies when itcame to producing animations of the surfaceof Saturns moon (Naturedoi:10.1038/news050117-7; 2005).
Stimulating the imagination of thenext generation of potential scientists withbeautiful or intriguing pictures shouldbe applauded. Many a good scientist hasbeen drawn into his or her field by an early
fascination with its imagery. And as publicfunding bodies require tangible societal
benefits in return for their generosity,widespread interest in a research project is awelcome boost for the next proposal.
Presentations at the EGU session madeit clear that marine researchers have nowcaught on. Remotely operated vehicles thatdelve into the deep ocean deliver fascinatingphotographs and films from a world whereno human has ever set foot. Te footageof bizarre deep-sea creatures and ancientshipwrecks is lapped up by journalists, whoknow that images sell stories. Now public
attention is being bestowed on deep-searesearch a field not previously known forits success with the general public.
Yet photographs gained throughtechnological advances are usuallytransmitted to the public throughstakeholders. Te aim of any press officeis to gain as much attention as possiblefor their research institution. Mediaoutreach personnel are not employed tobe disinterested chroniclers of scientificprogress, but to push the findings of thescientists at their university or lab to the topof the news agenda.
As the science sections in qualitynewspapers are shrinking, press offices arebeing expanded (Nature458,274277;2009). If this trend continues, reporters willhave less time to research their stories, butmore (and better) press releases to workfrom. As a result, general readers who wantto keep up with scientific progress mayno longer be able to rely on their morningpaper to deliver a fair overview of the bestresearch (as opposed to the work done atthe institutions with the most efficient pressoffices). Already at least, young scienceenthusiasts prefer to seek out their sources
from an almost infinite online choice, ratherthan from a limited number of newspapers
delivering the same news package to alltheir readers.
But unlimited choice is not always a goodthing. In a world where everyone solicits theirown sources of information, it will be muchharder to find a common basis for discussionwithin society. It is difficult for someoneoutside a field to judge which blog provides alevel-headed assessment, and which distortsthe facts to fit an agenda. Furthermore, thereis the danger that people will choose to buildsupport for their prejudices and preconceived
ideas, rather than allowing a trustednewspaper to challenge their establishedpatterns of thinking.
Te difficulty lies with communicatingthe more complicated aspects of science tomore than a niche of dedicated followers.Explaining progress in the context of earlierwork requires background knowledgeand research, as does writing about theuncertainties, contradictions and pitfalls thatare an integral part of science. o providea fair overview of the wealth of publishedpapers requires a disinterested observer.
Researchers blogs can provide a valuable
insider perspective on the progress ofscience. Press officers can (and should) bringthe work of the scientists they represent tothe attention of the media, and stunningimages are an excellent means of achievingthis goal. But it takes someone outside theresearch institutions to assemble all theavailable information into a coherent picture.
As the advertising-based business modelof the print media is crumbling in the faceof cheaper offers online, the need for full-time science reporters (writing online or inprint) remains. A society in which scienceand technology are central must provide the
funding to bring the narrative of scientificprogress to the public.
In the world of Web 2.0, the variety of channels for communicating science is exploding. Technology can help
to generate images that attract attention, but there is much more to reaching the public than pretty pictures.
Complex communication
N
OCS/JC10
MARUM,
UNIVERSITYOFBREMEN
MARUM,U
NIVERSITYOFBREMEN
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
6/80
372 NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience
correspondence
To the Editor In their letter (NatureGeosci. 1,511514; 2008), Geert Lend-erink and Erik van Meijgaard study anhourly time series o precipitation dataobtained at De Bilt, Te Netherlands. Teyobserved an exponential increase o heavyprecipitation with temperature, with acoefficient close to that o the ClausiusClapeyron relation or lower temperatures,whereas or higher temperatures they oundsuper-ClausiusClapeyron behaviour.
We argue that the super-ClausiusClapeyron scaling or hourly, but notor daily, precipitation arises because othe superposition o two acts: (1) thedramatically different timescales betweenlarge-scale and convective precipitationand (2) the dominance o convectiveprecipitation or high temperatures andthe dominance o large-scale precipitationor cool temperatures. Our theory alsoexplains the unusual transition betweenClausiusClapeyron and super-ClausiusClapeyron scaling or hourly precipitationas the temperature changes.
It is o undamental interest tounderstand the origin o the changesin precipitation extremes reported byLenderink and van Meijgaard, considering,
or example, flood risk. o this end weconsider the wet-day probability densityunction o total daily precipitation(Ptot), which depends on precipitationintensity and temperature. Tis is thesum o the probability density unctionso convective precipitation (Pc) andlarge-scale precipitation (Pls). Byconvective precipitation we mean showeryrain that alls over a certain area or arelatively short time, or example, during
mid-latitude thunderstorm events insummer. Large-scale precipitation occurs,or example, due to slow ascent o air insynoptic systems.
Now we consider a given temperaturerange (T, T+ T) and reer to thetotal amount o precipitation withinthis range as its weighting. Generally,higher intensities are less likely thanlower intensities or both large-scale andconvective precipitation events. Dailyprecipitation is accumulated over 24 h, andits intensity is thereore an average overthis time interval.
When the transition is made tosub-daily temporal resolution (such ashourly in Lenderink and van Meijgaard)the different nature o large-scale and
convective precipitation may emerge romthe statistics. Whereas large-scale eventstake place at a lower rate during a largerpart o the day, convective events are likelyto occur as bursts o heavy rain during asmaller raction o the day. Te transitionto sub-daily precipitation then leads to amore pronounced stretching o Pctowardshigher intensities than is the case or Pls.Note that the rescaling leaves the weightingo (T, T+ T) unchanged. Hence, or
Ptotdifferent statistical behaviour andtemperature dependence will emerge ordaily, compared with sub-daily, resolution.In particular, any given percentile o large-scale and convective precipitation will shifby different offsets when the transition tosub-daily resolution is made. As large-scale(convective) precipitation dominates at low(high) temperatures, the correspondingpercentile o total precipitation willollow that o large-scale (convective)precipitation there. In the intermediatetemperature range an increase with anunexpected temperature dependence may
occur (see Supplementary Inormation ormathematical details).We illustrate our analysis in a simple
example where the daily amount o
Unexpected rise in extreme precipitation
caused by a shift in rain type?
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Intensity (mm d1)
Intensity(mmd
1)
Intensity(mmd
1)
Daily
Sub-daily
T = 23 C
T= 13 C
0.1
0
0
0.05
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.080.1
Ptot
Prob.
density
Large-scale
TIs Tc
Convective
10
1
10
1
Sub-dailyDaily
99.9th99.9th
75th 75th
Convectiv
e Large-s
cale
0 5 10 15 20
T (C)
0 5 10 15 20
T (C)
0 5 10 15 20
T (C)
a
b
c d
Figure 1 |Daily and sub-daily precipitation intensity distributions, weighting functions and precipitation percentiles. a, Probability density function of total
precipitationat T= 13 C andT = 23 C. Solid lines are for daily values of total precipitation intensity, dashed lines are for sub-daily rescaling, orange arrows
indicate 75th percentile. b, Weighting functions for large-scale (red) and convective (blue) precipitation as function of temperature: Tls= 13 C and Tc= 23 C
are indicated by vertical lines. c, 99.9th (upper curves) and 75th (lower curves) sub-daily precipitation intensity percentile of large-scale (red), convective (blue)
and total precipitation (black), and double ClausiusClapeyron increase (dotted grey); arrows indicate onset of super-ClausiusClapeyron behaviour. d, Same as
cbut for daily averaged precipitation intensity: all curves collapse on one, slope does not change as function of temperature. Note the logarithmic vertical scale
in c and d.
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
7/80
NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience 373
correspondence
convective (large-scale) precipitationoccurs constantly during 12 (24) hours othe day. For the two weighting unctions wechose equal Gaussian distributions centredat different temperatures Tls< Tc(Fig. 1b).We use identical daily distributionunctions (p, T) exp(p/(T)) where
pis precipitation intensity, Tis temperatureand is the scale parameter with equalClausiusClapeyron-like exponentialtemperature dependence(T) = exp(bT)where the coefficient o temperaturedependence b= 0.07 K1. Hence, theonly variations result rom the differencebetween Tlsand Tc, and the transition tosub-daily statistics (as shown in Fig. 1aand b). Te percentiles o the transormedPls, Pcand Ptotare depicted in Fig. 1c.Whereas the distribution unctions othe two types o precipitation have aClausiusClapeyron-like exponential
increase o a given percentile intensity,the joint distribution may deviate romthe ClausiusClapeyron-like behaviourin the transition temperature regionwhere the two weighting unctionsoverlap. For the limit o low and hightemperatures, ClausiusClapeyronbehaviour is approached. Tis eature can
be observed in sub-daily data, whereasit disappears on a daily scale (compareFig. 1c and d). Tis is precisely whatLenderink and van Meijgaard ound,both in observational and model results(compare Fig. 1a and c in their paper).Additionally, their Fig. 1a shows a
transition rom ClausiusClapeyron tosuper-ClausiusClapeyron behaviour withan onset moving to lower temperaturesor higher percentiles, which can alsobe seen in our Fig. 1c. We tested theanalysis presented here on model dataand ound generally consistent results(see Supplementary Inormation).
In conclusion, we have provideda general argument which makes theorigin o the unexpected increases inextremes obvious by simple histogramre-weighting or sub-daily values.Super-ClausiusClapeyron behaviour
emerges as a consequence o simultaneousClausiusClapeyron behaviour o both thelarge-scale and convective precipitationin the temperature regime where the twotypes coexist. Outside o this regime theClausiusClapeyron behaviour againemerges. Concerning precipitation in achanging climate, we suggest investigating
whether seasons and regions with mainlylarge-scale or convective precipitationsee only a ClausiusClapeyron increasein extremes with temperature. Forseasons and regions with coexistenceo the two types, our analysis stressesthe importance o studying whether the
temperature o their transition shifs withchanging climate.
AcknowledgementsTis study was partly unded by theEuropean Union FP6 project WACH(contract number 036946). We acknowledgethe HadRM group or providing dataunder the ENSEMBLES project. We thankA. Haensler, S. Hagemann, D. Jacob and. Stacke or ruitul discussions.
Additional informationSupplementary inormation accompanies thispaper on www.nature.com/naturegeoscience.
J. O. Haerter1*and P. Berg2
1Max Planck Institute for Meteorology, 20146
Hamburg, Germany, 2Institute for Meteorology
and Climate Research, University of Karlsruhe
and Forschungszentrum Karlsruhe, 76344
Karlsruhe, Germany.
*e-mail: [email protected]
Lenderink and van Meijgaard reply Intheir correspondence, Haerter and Berg pro-pose an interesting explanation o the super-
ClausiusClapeyron scaling o precipitationextremes we ound in hourly observationsat De Bilt, Te Netherlands and reported inour letter (Nature Geosci. 1,511514; 2008).Tey argue that because convective pre-cipitation events are by their nature moreintense than large-scale events, a changein relative requency o occurrence o bothprecipitation types (histogram re-weighting)influences the scaling o precipitation ex-tremes with temperature. Tey show that inan intermediate temperature range, linkingthe two precipitation regimes, the statisticaleffect o histogram re-weighting may give
rise to a super-ClausiusClapeyron scaling,even when the scaling o the large-scale andthe convective events separately both satisythe ClausiusClapeyron relation.
For the most extreme precipitationevents histogram re-weighting is onlyrelevant when the number o convectiveevents is relatively small comparedwith the number o large-scale events.For temperatures at which the numbero convective events is larger than (orequal to) the number o large-scaleevents, the extreme 99.9th percentileis dominated by the scaling o theconvective events (compare Fig. 1b and
c in the correspondence rom Haerterand Berg). Te temperature range wherethe super-ClausiusClapeyron relation is
obtained is thereore primarily determinedby the ratio between the number oconvective and large-scale events asa unction o temperature. Tis ratioollows rom an arbitrary choice in theconceptual model o Haerter and Berg,not supported by observations and alsoconsiderably different rom the climatemodel results (compare their Fig. 1b andSupplementary Fig. 1b).
We think that the maniestation o thesuper-ClausiusClapeyron scaling has aphysical origin, rather than the statisticalorigin proposed by Haerter and Berg;
in our opinion it is a property o theconvective regime itsel, and results romthe dynamics o convective clouds withstronger updrafs due to increased latentheat release as the temperature rises. Tesuper-ClausiusClapeyron scaling osub-daily precipitation extremes is a robusteature in the observations at De Bilt. Itis consistently obtained using differentmeasures o the temperature (daily meanand daytime maximum), different timeperiods (all year, summer months, summerhal-year), and different measures o thesub-daily precipitation intensity (meandaily intensity at wet hours, hourly
intensity, and daily maximum o the hourlyintensity). Considering the mean dailyintensity at wet hours (daily sum divided
by rainall duration) as in Haerter andBerg, a dependency exceeding two timesthe Clausius-Clapeyron relation is oundin the observations, without any clear signo levelling off in the high temperaturerange (as would be expected romhistogram re-weighting).
Te atmospheric conditions mayvary considerably across the range otemperatures or which the scaling has beenobtained. Tis does not only determine thenumber o rainall events(Nature Geosci.1,511514; 2008), whether precipitation islarge-scale or convective (as mentioned in
Haerter and Berg), but could also influenceother aspects o shower complexes, suchas their level o mesoscale organization ortravel speed. Tese actors potentially affectthe scaling relations ound or the present-day climate and their interpretation inthe context o climate change althoughwe think not in a crucial way and needurther investigation.
Geert Lenderink* and Erik van Meijgaard
Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute
(KNMI), 3730 AE De Bilt, PO Box 201,
The Netherlands.
*e-mail: [email protected]
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
8/80
374 NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience
commentary
Securing the legacy of the IPYBob Dickson
Paradoxically, as the International Polar Year ends we enter its most important phase. Now we must
decide and quickly which mix of observations to sustain, based on what we have learnt.
Acouple o months ago, it did seem alittle bizarre to be asked to addressan international workshop1on the
climate o Spain with a talk about observingthe Arctic during the International PolarYear (IPY). But in act I neednt haveworried. Nobody lef. Te delegates got thepoint. Not just that extreme change was
passing through the oceanatmospherecryosphere system o our northern seas,interesting though that was. Te interesto the organizers was ocused much moreon a whole complex o physical processesthat were in some way implicated in drivingthese extreme changes through polarseas: processes that the IPY had set out toobserve and understand, processes that arenot yet represented realistically (or at all) inclimate models.
In act, climate models are inherentlyweak in quite a long list o processesimportant to our understanding o how
change takes place in northern seas andhow it might affect climate. Tese include,as just one example, most aspects o oceancirculation, mixing and exchange on thebroad circum-Arctic shelves (climatemodels have no continental shelves!). Wecould list many more2. Although theseprocesses may range down to relativelysmall scales in space and time, they allhave at least a potential importance orthe prediction o Arctic change. Andthe hope was that many or most othem would have been drawn into theobservational net o the IPY, thus (one
day!) materially improving our ability tosimulate climate.Te environment during the IPY
(March 2007 to March 2009), was in astate o spectacular change. Even thoughconditions over the Arctic were verydifferent during 20002007 compared withmost o the twentieth century describedas unique and given its own special label,the Arctic Warm Period3 the eventsduring the first year o the IPY (2007) weresomething else again, with a persistent andstrong meridional airflow directed acrossthe North Pole rom the Bering Strait ormuch o that summer (locations shown
in Fig. 1). Entering stage lef, and partlyin response to this airflow, the oceanicheat flux passing into the Arctic Oceanthrough Bering Strait in 2007 was at amaximum since records began in 1990,only slightly warmer than normal but withincreased transport (R. Woodgate, personalcommunication). Entering stage right,
our longest hydrographic series confirmthat the warm saline Atlantic currentpassing into the Nordic seas through theFaroeShetland Channel and continuingnorth to enter the Arctic Ocean throughFram Strait and the Barents Sea was at itswarmest or more than 100 years.
Te observing effort that was deployedto meet these changes was in many waysequally spectacular4. But it takes nogreat thought to realise that rather thanthe two-year project itsel, it will be thelegacy phase o the IPY, sustained overyears to decades, that will develop our
understanding o these processes, theirchanges, their eedbacks and their likelyclimatic impacts to the point where theycan be o use to climate models. Plainly,we cant continue everything. What havewe have learnt in the IPY that can helpus design its legacy phase? At the ArcticScience Summit Week in Bergen in March5,the Arctic Ocean Sciences Board setitsel the task o developing a ully costedproposal by the time o the post-IPYconerence in Oslo6in June 2010.
Tere has been little-enough time asyet to assess the data, but hal a dozen
examples illustrative o the ways ourideas have changed or developed duringthe IPY will help to define the scope otheir task.
Six new ideas from IPYFirst, the inputs and a new capability inmeasuring them. Te Norwegian Atlanticcurrent is the principal oceanic transportero heat, salt and mass to the Arctic Ocean.Where it passes west o Norway, we haveknown or some time that it consists otwo branches, but whereas one branchhas been measured or >12 years, theother had not been measurable beore
the IPY. Now the ingenious combiningo hydrography (water sampling),satellite altimetry, conventionalmoored current measurements,seaglider transects and modellingin the Norwegian flagship projectiAOOS-Norway part o the integratedArctic Ocean Observing System has
or the first time provided a completemeasure o both branches (K. A. Mork &. Skagseth, personal communication;computer algorithms to calculatevolume transports based on seagliderand other data are available rom re. 7).As a result our estimates o these keyocean fluxes have effectively doubled.Furthermore, as the Norwegian projecthad intended, the main measurementline off Sviny has been developed intoa complete, sustainable, simple androbust upstream reerence system ormonitoring Atlantic inflow towards the
Arctic Ocean.Second, a change in our conceptualrole or these inputs. When the IPY beganin March 2007, it would probably havebeen the consensus view that a 100-yearmaximum in the warmth o the inflow tothe Arctic must in some way be bound upwith an increased melting o sea ice. Sincethen our ideas have altered in responseto new simulations by a group rom theAlred Wegener Institute (M. Karcher,personal communication), which suggestthat as the warm Atlantic-derived layerspread at subsurace depths through
the Arctic deep basins it did so at asignificantly greater depth than normal.Tough the increased warmth may thusbe too deep to have much effect on the seaice, the intriguing suggestion is made that,as and when this layer circuits the Arcticand drains south again into the Nordicseas, its changed depth and density nowseem capable o slowing the overflow odense water through the Denmark Strait,hitherto regarded as largely unchanging.Tus, in the Atlantic sector at any rate,the climatic impact o the recent inflow owarmth to the Arctic may have less to dowith local effects on sea ice than on the
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
9/80
NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience 375
commentary
Atlantics thermohaline conveyor, yearslater and ar to the south. As a candidateor the IPY legacy phase, the importanceo this result seems clear. Maintainingsurveillance on an evolving change takingplace throughout the length and breadtho our Arctic and subarctic seas on a
timescale o decades will probably provehighly instructive to our understanding othe role o our northern seas in climate,although detecting and ollowing suchdecadal transient signals is likely to imposea need or new tools in observationalnetwork design.
New thinking has also illuminatedthe old issue o how the signals o oceanclimate change may be carried into andthrough the Arctic deep basins romsubarctic seas. Warm, salty Atlantic-derived waters enter the Arctic Oceanin two branches, the relatively cool
and resh Barents Sea branch and thewarmer, saltier Fram Strait branch. Andthe greatest change in our thinkingconcerns the new idea put orwardby Bert Rudels (Univ. Helsinki) at theArctic Science Summit Week5that theBarents Sea branch may be the one thatdominates the Arctic Ocean beyondthe Nansen basin, with the Fram Straitbranch seldom penetrating beyond theLomonosov ridge. I so, the source o therecent warming graphically describedalong the boundary o the Laptev Sea andCanadian basin8,9 has effectively been
reassigned. esting Rudels idea will bean important task or the legacy phaseto resolve, but the tools to do so are wellproven: detailed ship-borne hydrography,sustained flux measurements throughthe northeast Barents Sea, and continuedor intensified coverage o the boundarycurrents along the Eurasian margin othe Nansen basin rom the point whereboth branches first flow together to theirsupposed points o separation at theLomonosov ridge.
Our ourth example highlights howtechnical advances in the use o untended
instruments have led to a huge growthin the ocean data set. As one example oan increasingly elaborate array o theseinstruments (see Fig. 2), the expanded useo conductivitytemperaturedepth (CD)profiler systems10,11moored to the drifingice has, since 2004, contributed around18,000 high quality temperaturesalinityprofiles to the data set o the Arctic Ocean(J. oole, personal communication),transorming this ormer data desert intoone o the most densely observed oceanson Earth. Te continuing analysis o thesedata (B. Rabe, personal communication)has mapped out the pan-Arctic distribution
o reshwater content, confirming earlierconclusions12that the Beauort gyre is
the largest marine reservoir o reshwateron Earth. Whats more, the analysiso the Woods Hole OceanographicInstitution Beauort Gyre ExplorationProject13has revealed that this centre is asystem in rapid transition, with stronglyincreasing trends in its reshwater contentbetween 2003 and 2008. As the efflux oreshwater rom the Arctic is expected tobe one way in which Arctic change mayreach south to affect the Atlantic conveyor,these are findings o direct relevance toclimate. And with such a key parameter insuch rapid transition, it would be barelyconceivable to enter the legacy phase
without ice-tethered profilers at the core oits observing system.
Fifh, we have learnt some o the keyobservational requirements or improvedsea-ice prediction. Te 22 ice-predictiongroups that participated in the SEARCH-or-DAMOCLES Sea Ice Outlook exercise14concluded that an improved measureo ice thickness in spring was the primerequirement or improved predictiono ice extent at the time o the latesummer minimum. Such an unequivocalrequirement must surely commend the use,in the legacy phase, o the large numbero new techniques (above, on and beneaththe ice) that are now available to assess icethickness. Examples o such techniques
Bathymetric and topographic tints
5,500 4,500 3,500 2,500 1,500 500 300 200 100 20 0
Barents
Sea
Lom
onos
ovridg
e
Canadian
basin
Denmark Strait
Nan
senba
sin
Beaufort
Sea
Laptev
Sea
Nordic
seas
Bering
Strait
Atlantic
current
Fram
Strait
(m)
Figure 1 |The Arctic-subarctic domain showing the system of ridges, shelves and deep basins. The Bering
Strait, Fram Strait and Barents Sea carry the main oceanic inflows to the Arctic Ocean; the gyre of the
Beaufort Sea is the largest marine reservoir of freshwater on Earth; and the Denmark Strait carries both a
main outflow of freshwater from the Arctic and the principal overflow of cold dense water by which the
deep North Atlantic Ocean is renewed. Because of their known or suspected importance to climate, all of
these features are monitored and are strong candidates for continued or expanded monitoring in the IPY
legacy phase. Base map courtesy of Igor Polyakov, Univ. Alaska.
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
10/80
376 NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience
commentary
include laser and radar altimetry onICESA and ENVISA, tiltmeter buoysdeployed on the ice surace, and thesub-ice floats fitted with upward-lookingsonar that are coming to ruition in
EC-DAMOCLES.Finally, in what may be the big dealo the IPY thus ar, we are beginning torecognize effects o the ice-ree polarocean on the regional and hemisphericatmospheric circulation. As the ice inthe Pacific sector o the Arctic meltedback to its record minimum in summer2007, and the heat storage o theunderlying ocean increased, the release othis heat in autumn was ound to erodethe stratification o the atmosphere toprogressively higher levels, leading to aclear change in the regional atmosphericcirculation15. A similar association o
events also seems to be implied in thereport16that winter Northern Hemisphereweather patterns seem to remembersummer Arctic sea-ice extent. With suchdirect apparent links to polar climate, it
makes sense to enquire, in planning anobservational legacy phase or the IPY,what continued coverage o the upperwater column would be needed to keeptrack o oceanatmosphere heat exchangeas the sea ice dwindles away.
aken together, these ew examplesmake a urther insistent point: that thesubarctic seas are intimately involved; thatyou cant understand Arctic change just bystudying the Arctic.
The road to OsloFrom the point o view o understandingthe role o our northern seas in climate,
these hal-dozen insights alone might havejustified the IPY; but they are intendedas examples only, not an exhaustive list.No doubt with time some o these ideasmay ounder, others will take their place.Te basic need is or a plan capable ointegrating national efforts to provide
a reely shared, flexible, reliable andreasonably complete ocean data set. Itwould detract rom the effectiveness othis pan-Arctic effort i national issues osovereignty, access and logistics promotea dataset whose coverage, quality, cost andaccessibility would be a variable unctiono the country responsible. Needless to say,even when the science o the legacy phaseis agreed, a range o external actors willbe on hand to constrain it, including thickice, orbidden or costly access, icebreakeravailability and technical challenges.Whether top-down or bottom-up solutions
are more appropriate will be defined bythese external constraints, as will thedebate on the type o international body,long-term international coordination andlogistics planning that will be required tominimize them.
I we are to meet the plan o theArctic Ocean Sciences Board to present adetailed and ully costed proposal or theIPYs legacy phase at the 2010 post-IPYconerence in Oslo, we have roughly oneyear to decide.
Bob Dickson is Emeritus Research Fellow at the
Centre or Environment, Fisheries and AquacultureScience (CEFAS), Lowestof NR33 0H, UK.
e-mail: [email protected]
References1. http://clivar.iim.csic.es/?q=es/node/269
2. Dickson, R. R., Meincke, J. & Rhines, P. (eds)ArcticSubarctic
Ocean Fluxes: Defining the Role o the Northern Seas in Climate
(Springer, 2008).
3. Overland, J. E., Wang, M. & Salo, S. ellus
60A,589597 (2008).
4. Dickson, R. R. Te integrated Arctic Ocean Observing System in
2007 and 2008; available rom .
5. http://www.aosb.org/assw.html
6. http://www.ipy-osc.no/
7. http://dokipy.met.no/projects/iaoos-norway/owsm-glider.html.
8. Polyakov, I. et al.Eos88,398399 (2007).9. Dmitrenko, I. A. et al. J. Geophys. Res.
113,C05023 (2008).
10. Krishfield, R. et al.J. Atmos. Ocean. ech.25,20912105 (2008).
11. Kikuchi, ., Inoue, J. & Langevin, D. Deep-Sea Res. I
54,16751686 (2007).
12. Carmack, E. et al.inArctic-Subarctic Ocean Fluxes:
Defining the Role o the Northern Seas in Climate
(eds Dickson, R. R., Meincke, J. & Rhines, P.)
145170 (Springer, 2008).
13. Proshutinsky, A. R. et al. J. Geophys. Res.(in the press).
14. Search Sea Ice Outlook: Summary Report Overview and
Highlights (2008); available at .
15. Overland, J. E. & Wang, M. ellus(in the press).
16. Francis, J. A., Chan, W., Leathers, D. J., Miller, J. R. &
Veron, D. E. Geophys. Res. Lett.36,L07503 (2009).
Figure 2 |The Super Buoy Array at 86 34 N, 134 39 E on the Lomonosov ridge of the central
Arctic Ocean, after deployment by F/S Polarsternin September 2007 perhaps the best example
of the elaboration and integration of Arctic observing systems that was such a strong feature of the
IPY. This particular ice-top observatory combines: an autonomous CTD profiler (ITP; the Woods Hole
Oceanographic Institution Ice-Tethered Profiler10), which has rapidly transformed the Arctic Ocean from
a virtual data desert to one of the best-described oceans on Earth; an Ice Mass Balance Buoy, (IMB;
Don Perovich and Jackie Richter-Menge, CRREL) designed to measure variations in surface and basal
ice-melt during their drift of up to two years; an Autonomous Ocean Flux Buoy (AOFB; Tim Stanton,NPS Monterey) designed to provide accurate measurements of vertical heat fluxes through the upper
ocean; and a prototype Ice-Tethered Acoustic Current profiler (ITAC; Alfred Wegener Institute) designed
to provide regular profiles of ocean current velocity to 500 m as the system drifts through the polar
sea. Photos reproduced with permission from Lasse Rabenstein, Lars Gremlowski, Benjamin Rabe and
Ursula Schauer, Alfred Wegener Institute for Polar and Marine Research.
ITAC
AOFB
ITP
IMB
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected] -
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
11/80
NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience 377
books & arts
Werner Herzog has always
been interested in extremeenvironments, and in therelationship between manand nature. In Encounters atthe End of the World, Herzogfinds a new way to lookat the Antarctic, findinginsights in the stories othe people who live there,and showing us beauty in
unexpected places.With equal measures o wit and curiosity,
Herzog interviews some o the peopleworking in this remote corner o the globe.
Among the glaciologists and biologists, wemeet a philosopher-turned-orklif-driver, alinguist-turned-gardener and a plumber oroyal descent.
First stop is the town o McMurdo, theheart o the US Antarctic programme, andhome to a thousand or so people. Full oconstruction sites and orklif trucks, thisrather bleak and muddy town is a ar cryrom the images o Antarctica we are usedto seeing on television. But the drabness othe place belies the extreme likeability o thecharacters that live there.
One such inhabitant a part-Apache
plumber has immense pride in his fingers.Once told by an anthropologist that theseare the hands o Aztec royalty, he holds themup again and again or the camera tosee. Unortunately, he doesnt explain what isunique about them.
Another resident, an East Europeanmechanic, lived most o his lie like aprisoner behind the Iron Curtain. Chokedback with emotion, he is unable to talkabout his lie then. Instead, he shows us thecontents o his rucksack, which he keepspacked at all times, always ready to escapeor to go on new adventures and explore
new horizons.Outside McMurdo we meet the scientists.Particularly moving is an encounter with acell biologist on mainland Antarctica. Tebiologist, who is about to embark on his lastdive into the Southern Ocean, sits pensively,preparing himsel or his final encounterwith this underwater world. When drawninto conversation by Herzog, he muses onthe unexpected violence and horrors o thathidden world. Te creatures he describesare like something out o a science fictionnovel. One uses its tentacles to ensnareits prey the more the prey struggles,the tighter the tentacles grow. Eventually
the victim exhausts itsel and the creaturemoves in or the kill. Te camera ollowshim on his dive; rather than terriying, it ishauntingly beautiul.
Another touching moment is Herzogsmeeting with a penguin specialist; a reclusiveman who has been studying these creaturesor 20 years. Although not orthcomingwhen it comes to human interaction, hebreaks into a smile when Herzog probeshim on the subject o gay penguins, andexpounds with great amusement on thedynamics o penguin prostitution.
Watching the film, it becomes clearthat there must be something very specialabout Herzogs manner that allows peopleto interact with him in an achingly honestand open way. But he doesnt pander to
the rivolous or sel-indulgent. So when atraveller talks in painstaking detail abouther experiences in a garbage truck inArica, her voice ades out and we hearHerzog in his sof, affable way herstory goes on orever.
But its not just the people that captureyour attention. Although Herzog didntwant to make a film about fluffy penguins,one o the most heart-breaking scenes iswhen a penguin aced with the decisiono whether to ollow his companions to thewaters edge or back to the colony shufflesround in a circle and then heads straightor the mountains and the interior o
Antarctica. Watching the penguin waddleto its death, you will them to interject. But,as our narrator explains, it wouldnt make adifference its mind is made up.
Herzog uses these small stories as a wayin to the majesty, epic scale and strangenesso Antarctica. As he intersperses personaltales with ootage o towering ice cliffs, andicy underwater scenes o colossal beauty,you understand the tremendous andcontagious reverence Herzog has orthis place.
Te topic o climate change is scarcelytouched upon directly, but the theme ohuman ragility and destruction runs rightthrough. From the apocalyptic films theresearchers watch in their spare time toa volcanologists words o warning about
the planets catastrophic past, it is hardto escape. One researcher says that in hisdreams he can hear the iceberg screeching,this iceberg is coming north.
In the final scene, the philosopher-turned-orklif-driver quotes Alan Watts,we are the witnesses through which theuniverse becomes conscious o its glory.Perhaps Herzog shows us a touch o thisglory here.
ANNA ARMSTRONG
Encounters at the End of the World
by Werner Herzog, Discovery Films: 2007.
UK release date: 24 April 2009.
FILM
Tales from Antarctica
REVOLVERENTERTAINM
ENT
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
12/80
378 NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience
research highlights
Feeling the heatLithos doi: 10.1016/j.lithos.2009.04.002 (2009)
Geochemical and textural evidence suggeststhat pieces of the Earths crust picked up bymagma may at least partially melt in a matter
of hours. These crustal xenoliths, as theyare called, are then carried to the surface byvolcanic eruptions, where they are prized forthe insights they provide into the processesthat alter magma composition.
Cliff Shaw of the University ofNew Brunswick in Fredericton, Canadacompared the mineralogy, texture andchemical composition of crustal xenolithsand host lava from the Rockeskyllerkopfvolcanic complex of the West Eifelvolcanicfield in Germany. The result indicated thatthe glassy rinds that coated many of thexenoliths formed in just 12 hours or so, as the
silica-rich fragments reacted with the hot,silica-poor magma.
Xenoliths from this particular region areunique in that they are almost completelyseparated from the surrounding rock. Shawsuggests that the creation of gas bubblesduring rind formation separated thexenoliths from the enveloping lava.
Restless MoonJ. Geophys. Res. 114,E05001 (2009)
Clusters of quakes in the Moons deep
interior called moonquakes aregenerally attributed to deformationfrom the Earths gravity. Although this isprobably the case for some quakes, a seismicreanalysis shows that others may be causedby mineralogical changes deep within theMoons interior.
Renee Weber, of the US GeologicalSurvey, Flagstaff, and colleagues reanalysed39 moonquake clusters that were recorded bylunar-based seismometers during the ApolloPassive Seismic Experiment, from 1969 to1972. About a third of the quakes could beattributed to failure along discrete planes ofweakness, triggered by tidal deformation
arising from Earths gravitational pull.However, this mechanism could not explainthe remaining moonquakes.
The structure of minerals within theMoons deep interior may evolve in responseto increasing pressure with depth, as on
Earth. The team speculates that that thesestructural changes could generate stressesthat would give rise to some moonquakes.
A tough shellGeol. Soc. Amer. Bull.121,688697 (2009)
Desert pavements are hard surfacesconsisting of a mosaic of pebbles, and arecommon in very arid regions. Dating of suchpavements from the Negev Desert of Israelshows that these particular pebbles haveresisted the forces of erosion for well over amillion years.
Ari Matmon of the Hebrew Universityof Jerusalem and colleagues measured
exposure ages from multiple samples ofdesert pavement at two sites separated byover eight kilometres in the Paran Plainsregion. Whereas individual samples ofpavement from other deserts have suggestedlong exposure times at single locations, thesamples of Negev pavement indicate thatmost of the surface has been exposed for upto 1.8 million years.
The ages of the Negev pavement pointto a landscape that has been exceptionallystable for a long period of time, probablybecause of a combination of environmentalconditions such as extreme dryness, surfaceflatness and a lack of significant tectonic
disturbance, as well as the armouring effectof the pavement.
Carbon consumptionProc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA106,70677072 (2009)
The Intergovermental Panel on ClimateChange projections show that the upperocean is likely to warm by 16 C by theend of this century. Experiments show thatthis warming could decrease the amount ofcarbon transported to the deep ocean.
Julia Wohlers, of the Leibniz Instituteof Marine Sciences, Germany, and
colleagues exposed natural planktoncommunities to temperature increasesof up to 6 C in an indoor mesocosmexperiment. Under the maximum warmingscenario, net consumption of dissolvedinorganic carbon fell by 31%. Theirmeasurements indicate that this was notdue to a reduction in photosynthetic uptake,but rather to an increase in respiratoryconsumption of the photosyntheticallyderived organic carbon, which re-releasesdissolved inorganic carbon. Furthermore,warming increased the concentrationof dissolved organic carbon relative to
particulate organic carbon, making theaccumulating material less susceptibleto sinking.
The researchers warn that an increasedconsumption of organic matter in thesurface ocean, combined with a reductionin the amount of carbon sinking to depth,could increase the atmospheric load ofcarbon dioxide.
2
009GSA
The last glacial period was punctuated by abrupt transitions to interstadial (warm)
conditions. An analysis of an event 38,000 years ago as recorded in the ice core from
the North Greenland Ice Core Project reveals that mid-latitude climate change preceded
Greenland warming by several years.
Elizabeth Thomas of the British Antarctic Survey and colleagues used multiple proxies
to reconstruct climatic conditions during this abrupt warming, one of the most prominent
of the last glacial period. The ice cores annual layers showed that the approximately 11 Cwarming over Greenland occurred over about 26 years. However, the team also found that
a few years before the warming kicked in, the dust supply from Asia declined, which they
relate to a strengthening of the summer monsoon. At about the same time, there was a shift
in the hydrogen and oxygen isotopes of the ice, suggesting a northward migration of the
polar front.
The lag between the strengthening of the Asian monsoon and Greenland warming
could point to a trigger for glacial abrupt climate change in the tropics or the Southern
Hemisphere, rather than the north.
Interstadial timing J. Geophys. Res. 114,D08102 (2009)ISTOCKPHOTO/CAROLINASMITH
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
13/80
NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience 379
news & views
The solid inner core, with an averageradius of 1,220 km, is the mostremote part of the Earth and would
seem to be an unlikely place to find arecord of the evolution of our planet. Yet,among all of the primary subdivisions ofthe Earth, the inner core seems to be the
youngest and possibly the most rapidlygrowing. Te inner core has grown to itspresent size in less than 2 billion years1,and possibly within 600 million years2.Calculations by Deguen and Cardin,discussed on page 419 of this issue,show that the structure of the inner coreprovides clues about the later stages of thechemical differentiation of the Earth3. Moresurprisingly, it preserves evidence of active,gravity-driven tectonics.
Considerations of the rate at which heatis being lost from the planets deep interiorindicate that the inner core is crystallizing
from the iron-rich, fluid outer core at arate of 45 million kilograms per second2.Te rapid growth traps heat and chemicalheterogeneity, and the inner core hasacquired a remarkably complex structure.For example, recent seismic imaging hasrevealed differences between the deepestparts of the inner core4,5and regions closeto the inner-core boundary the contactbetween the inner and outer cores. Whereasthe innermost parts seem to be anisotropic,the region immediately below the inner-coreboundary shows an isotropic texture aswell as differences between the eastern and
western hemispheres
6
.As the inner core solidifies throughcrystallization, it develops a radial thermalgradient due to the release of latentheat: that is, it is hottest in the centralpart. Tis gradient tends to destabilizethe inner core by inducing convectiveoverturning. But the inner core also hasradial gradients in the concentrations oflight elements such as oxygen, sulphurand silicon, which are enriched in theouter parts of the inner core during thesolidification process. Tese gradients leadto a stabilization of the density distributionthroughout the inner core and thereby
act to prevent convective instabilities. Tetwo processes act in competition witheach other, and their relative importancedepends on the particular stage in the innercores growth.
Another complication in the growth
process is introduced by the non-uniformrate of solidification at the inner-coreboundary. Owing to the influence of fluidmotions in the outer core, the removalof heat from the inner-core boundary isexpected to be greater near the inner-core equator than at other latitudes. Teinner core therefore cools and crystallizespreferentially in the equatorial regions;as a result, these regions are expected tobe topographically higher7. Preferentialheat loss from the equatorial regions isrelated to the northsouth alignment of thegeomagnetic dipole, although the highertopography at the inner-core equator
produced by the more rapid crystallizationinduced by such heat loss has not beendirectly observed.
Deguen and Cardin use numericalsimulations to determine how these variousprocesses, including the thermal gradientsand light element distribution as well as
preferential crystallization at the equator,conspire to produce the heterogeneousinner core that seismology reveals3. Teymodel the evolution of the inner corefrom its inception to its present state.Te calculations suggest that when theinner core was very small, preferentialsolidification at the equator and thermalconvective overturning produced a nearlyuniform solid texture. At this stage, noperceptible compositional stratificationdue to enrichment of light elements in theuppermost regions had developed.
Te situation seems to have changed,
however, as the inner core approached itspresent-day size. Te researchers suggestthat as the growth rate decreases, thereis enough time available for a gradient inlight element concentration to develop, thestabilizing effects of which now come todominate inner-core evolution. Instead ofthe thorough convective churning typicalof the early stages, thin sheets slide off theequatorial topographic high and are thrustover one another, just below the inner-coreboundary (Fig. 1). Tis deformation isloosely analogous to the style of tectonicsseen in mountain belts, where thin slabs
of the continental upper crust are stackedupon each other.Te evolutionary model proposed by
Deguen and Cardin3may help to explainthe structural variations in the fabric ofthe inner core. For example, the shearinginduced by the tectonic activity in theoutermost parts of the inner core over thepast 100200 million years may help tohomogenize the material just beneath theinner-core boundary, thereby providinga possible mechanism for the isotropyinferred from seismic data. Te model alsoimplies that the innermost regions wouldnot be affected by deformation during
GEOPHYSICS
Tectonics in the Earths coreThe complex three-dimensional structure of the Earths solid inner core reveals how it has grown through time.Numerical simulations of the solidification process suggest that part of this structure has resulted from recent
tectonic activity.
Peter Olson
Innermost inner core
Inner-core boundary
Figure 1 |Inner core tectonics. The schematic
sketch shows gravity-driven overturning in a
shallow layer below the inner-core boundary.
Deguen and Cardin suggest that late in the
history of inner-core growth, this activity becamedecoupled from the deeper parts owing to
stable compositional stratification imparted
by the distribution of light elements3, which is
indicated by shading. The white curve denotes the
topographically elevated inner-core equator.
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
14/80
380 NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience
news & views
the later stages of inner-core growth. It istherefore plausible that the fabric in thedeepest parts of the inner core is an ancientone, potentially providing informationabout ancient processes.
Of course, the simulations do notcement the case for active tectonics on
the top of the inner core. Te researchersexplanation is intriguing, but complicatingfactors remain. For one, the seismicexploration of the inner core is stillincomplete and the proposed model cannotyet be fully tested. And almost certainly,tectonic deformation is not the only
process that affects the structure and fabricof the inner core8.
Interpreting the three-dimensionalstructure of the Earths inner core and itsevolution is a difficult problem, especiallybecause multiple physical processes forexample, convection, solidification and
grain deformation operate simultaneously.Deguen and Cardins modelling work3not only provides new insights intothe history of Earths deep interior, butmay also be a first step on the way tounderstanding the inner cores of otherplanets in the Solar System.
Peter Olson is in the Department of Earth and
Planetary Sciences, Johns Hopkins University,
Baltimore, Maryland 21218, USA.
e-mail: [email protected]
References
1. Buffett, B. et al.J. Geophys. Res. 101,79898006 (1996).
2. Nimmo, F. in Treatise on GeophysicsVol. 8 (ed. Schubert, G.)
Ch. 2, 3165 (Elsevier, 2007).
3. Deguen, R. & Cardin, P. Nature Geosci. 2, 419422 (2009).
4. Cao, A. & Romanowicz, B. Geophys. Res. Lett.
34,L08303 (2007).
5. Sun, X. & Song, X. D. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 269,5665 (2008).
6. Niu, F. L. & Wen, L. X. Nature410,10811084 (2001).
7. Yoshida, S. et al.J. Geophys. Res. 101,2808528103 (1996).
8. romp, J.Ann. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci. 29,4769 (2001).
Varying incoming solar radiation, drivenby changes in the Earths orbit aroundthe Sun and in the tilt of its rotation
axes, is the primary natural climate forcingon timescales of millennia to hundreds ofthousands of years. Climate proxy data,
however, show that temperature changes donot simply follow the orbital forcing, so theclimate response to the forcing must also beaffected by internal feedbacks in the climatesystem related to slow components suchas ice sheets and biogeochemical cycles1,2.Tese feedbacks seem to be relevant for the100-thousand-year cycle of the recent glacialto interglacial transitions, which does notcoincide with the frequencies of the strongestorbital forcing. Additionally, millennial-scaletemperature variability across the NorthernHemisphere in the early part of the Holocenecannot be explained solely by orbital forcing.
On page 411 of this issue, Renssen andcolleagues show that even while decaying,the Laurentide ice sheet kept large parts ofNorth America and western Europe coolthroughout the early Holocene, despite therising incoming solar radiation in mid andhigh northern latitudes during summer3.
Te transition from the cold climate of thelast glacial maximum to the warm Holoceneinterglacial began about 15,000 years ago,stabilizing at warmer interglacial conditionsabout 11,700 years ago. Tis warmingwas associated with rising incoming solarradiation (insolation) in the NorthernHemisphere summer months, which peaked
between 11,000 and 9,000 years ago. Itled to the complete disappearance of theFennoscandian ice sheet, which covered
much of Europe, by about 9,000 yearsago. But on the other side of the AtlanticOcean, despite the warming climate, the lastremains of the Laurentide ice sheet coveredmuch of northeastern Canada until about7,000 years ago3(Fig. 1).
Proxy-based reconstructions oftemperatures throughout the NorthernHemisphere show that temperature evolutionduring the early Holocene was not uniform47.Maximum temperatures occurred slightlymore than 9,000 years ago in Alaska andnorthwest Canada, in accordance with theorbital forcing. emperatures in northeasternCanada, Greenland and Europe, however,peaked between 8,000 and 5,000 years ago,and it had been suggested that the delays inwarming were caused by the remains of theLaurentide ice sheet8.
Renssen and colleagues3test this
hypothesis through a set of climatesimulations tailored to identify how theLaurentide ice sheet affected early Holocenetemperatures. Tey use an Earth systemmodel of intermediate complexity (EMIC)that simulates atmosphere, ocean andvegetation processes. Compared withthe more complex general circulationmodels (GCMs), EMICs use lower spatialresolution and simplified dynamics forthe atmosphere and ocean, which makesthem computationally fast and thus ideallysuited for the relatively long simulationsneeded in palaeoclimatology. Te teamusedproxy-based temperature reconstructions
PALAEOCLIMATE
Delayed Holocene warmingRemnants of the Laurentide ice sheet lasted until about 7,000 years ago. Climate simulations show that theycaused the multimillennial delay between maximum early Holocene solar radiation and temperatures evident in
Northern Hemisphere proxy records.
Martin Widmann
Laurentide
ice sheet
Greenland
ice sheet
Figure 1 |The extent of the Laurentide and
Greenland ice sheets about 9,000 years ago.
At the last glacial maximum, the Laurentide ice
sheet covered most of Canada and the northern
United States (its extent is shown by the blue
line). By 9,000 years ago, the ice sheet was limited
to northeastern Canada. Model simulations
from Renssen and colleagues3show that these
remnants delayed Holocene warming across
eastern North America, the Labrador Sea and
western Europe.
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
15/80
NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience 381
news & views
rom several locations in North America,Greenland and Europe to assess whether theEMIC can realistically simulate the climaticeffect o the early Holocene ice cover, despitethe considerable simplifications.
Renssen and colleagues perormed severalsimulations designed to investigate the effects
that the decaying Laurentide ice sheet wouldhave on climate across North America andEurope. One model run prescribed thedecline o the ice sheet as reconstructedrom data collected rom its ormer margins.Another simulation also included themeltwater rom the ice sheet entering theLabrador Sea. In addition, the effects o orbitaland greenhouse-gas orcing were simulated.
Te simulations showed that, althoughorbital orcing was the dominant controlon the evolution o average NorthernHemisphere temperatures, the ice sheetstrongly influenced temperature patterns.
Locally, the higher albedo o the ice sheetkept air temperatures low, and the cold airwas advected downwind. But the most ar-reaching effects arose rom the meltwaterflowing into the Labrador Sea. Tisreshwater influx promoted sea-ice ormationand inhibited the deep convective circulationound today, and its attendant northward heattransport. ogether these processes delayedHolocene warming throughout easternNorth America and western Europe, in aregional pattern broadly consistent with theproxy records.
Although cooling effects rom the
Laurentide ice sheet in the early Holocenehave been suggested previously, the study
is highly relevant as it shows that i thehistorical evolution o the Laurentide icesheet is prescribed, a climate model is ableto capture many aspects o the temperaturepatterns during this period and thatprocesses other than local cooling areinvolved. However, the agreement with the
empirical temperature reconstructions is notperect. Potential reasons or discrepanciesinclude uncertainties in the proxy-basedreconstructions and biases in the simulatedatmospheric and ocean circulation, whichwould in turn affect the models propagationo temperature and circulation anomaliesaway rom the ice sheet. GCMs couldprovide an avenue to assessthe influences omodel biases inherent to EMIC studies, assimulations over several thousand years arenow easible9.
Simulations using prescribed ice sheets,such as those o Renssen and colleagues,
are necessary to isolate the influence othe cryosphere on climate, and provideprocess understanding that cannot directlybe obtained rom coupled simulations o theatmosphereoceancryosphere system. Butonly coupled simulations provide the meansto estimate millennial and longer variabilityin both past and uture climates rom theknowledge o external orcing actors,such as orbital parameters or greenhouse-gas concentrations.
EMICs coupled to ice-sheet models havebeen used to simulate past climates10, whereasGCMs or the past have only been used to
drive ice-sheet models without the changingice sheets eeding back on the climate11.
Simulations o uture climate have beenconducted with ice-sheet models coupled toboth model types12,13, but the dynamic ice-sheet model component, and its orcing bycoarsely resolved climate data, is a challenge,and improvements are needed to increasethe reliability o the simulations14. A realistic
representation o ice sheets in climate modelsis not only crucial or estimating sea-levelchange, but, as demonstrated by Renssen andcolleagues3, also or an accurate simulation oregional temperature changes.
Martin Widmann is at the School of Geography,
Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of
Birmingham, Birmingham B15 2, UK.
e-mail: [email protected]
References1. Jansen, E. et al. in IPCC Climate Change 2007: Te Physical
Science Basis(eds Solomon, S. et al.) 433498
(Cambridge Univ. Press, 2007).
2. Claussen, M., Berger, A. & Held, H. in Te Climate of PastInterglacials (eds Sirocko, F., Claussen, M., Sanchez Goni, M. F.
& Litt, .) 2935 (Elsevier, 2007).
3. Renssen, H. et al.Nature Geosci. 2, 411414 (2009).
4. MacDonald, G. M. et al. Quat. Res. 53,302311 (2000).
5. Davis, B. A. S. et al.Quat. Sci. Rev. 22,17011716 (2003).
6. Kaumann, D. S. et al.Quat. Sci. Rev. 23,529560 (2004).
7. Jansen, E. et al.in Natural Climate Variability and Global
Warming: A Holocene Perspective(eds Battarbee, R. W. &
Binney, H. A.) 123137 (Wiley-Blackwell, 2008)
8. Kutzbach, J. E. & Webb, . III in Global Climates Since the Last
Glacial Maximum(eds Wright, H. E. Jr et al.)
511 (Univ. Minnesota Press, 1993).
9. Wanner, H. et al.Quat. Sci. Rev.27,17911828 (2008).
10. Calov, R., Ganopolski, A., Claussen, M., Petoukov, V. & Greve, R.
Clim. Dynam. 24,545561 (2005).
11. Otto-Bliesner, B. et al.Science311,17511753 (2006).
12. Driesschaert, E. et al.Geophys. Res. Lett.34,L10707 (2007).
13. Vizcano, M. et al.Clim. Dynam. 31,665690 (2008).14. Alley, R. et al.Science310,456460 (2005).
Most travellers crossing the vastand apparently empty expanseo the central Nevada desert will
have little inkling o the puzzlement andcontroversy that the region has causedamong geophysicists or decades. Not onlyhas Nevada somehow managed to extendand triple its surace area without thinningits crust, but it also boasts an enigmatictopography and gravity structure1. On topo that, seismic shear waves in most o thewestern US show considerable splitting, butthis is not the case or central Nevada. Onpage 439 o this issue, West and colleagues
characterize a cylindrical drip o lithospherethat is sinking beneath Nevada2. Teresulting vertical flow in the uppermostmantle differs rom the surrounding largelyhorizontal motion, which may help explainthe distinct shear-wave splitting pattern.
Away rom the boundaries o tectonicplates, the mantles uppermost cool anddense layer the lithosphere generallysits more or less inertly atop the convectingasthenospheric mantle. Under someconditions though, the lower portions o thelithosphere can become unstable and sink ordrip off3. Sinking lithosphere can be detected
by seismic tomography, which makes useo the act that seismic waves tend to travelaster through cooler and denser material.
Another, more direct seismic method todetect mantle flow is the measurement oshear-wave splitting. When a portion o themantle flows, it develops a abric owing tothe preerred alignment o its constituentminerals. Tis causes shear waves passingthrough it to split into two perpendicularpulses, each o which travels with itsown velocity. Te most robust splittingmeasurements are perormed on shear wavesthat travel almost vertically through the
TECTONICS
Draining NevadaThe lack of strong splitting of seismic shear waves below central Nevada is in marked contrast to the surrounding
region. Seismic data and numerical experiments suggest that a skinny, cylindrical drip of lithosphere may be to blame.
Vera Schulte-Pelkum
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected] -
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
16/80
382 NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience
news & views
mantle. Such waves show strong splitting orhorizontal mantle flow, but not or verticalflow (Fig. 1).
In most parts o the western US,substantial shear-wave splitting is observed.Tis pattern has generally been consideredto arise because o the horizontal motiono the North American plate relative to theunderlying mantle. A notable exception is aregion o reduced splitting in Nevada, whichhas been interpreted as upwelling mantle4or as toroidal flow around a sinking slab ooceanic lithosphere5.
West and colleagues use tomographicas well as shear-wave splitting techniquesto analyse a new seismic data set or thewestern US and to explore the mantle below
central Nevada
2
. Teir tomographic imagereveals a cylindrical body o cold lithosphericmaterial through which seismic wavestravel aster than the surrounding warmasthenospheric mantle. Te body extendsrom about 75 km below the surace to atleast 500 km below the surace, well into theasthenospheric mantle.
Tis high-velocity cylinder underliesthe region where there is little or no shear-wave splitting. Tis suggests that mantleflow beneath this region is vertical becauseo parts o the lithosphere dripping intothe underlying asthenosphere. Te steepnortheasterly tilt o the drip seen in the
tomographic image is probably due to a pushimparted by asthenospheric flow relative tothe continent. Te direction o asthenospheric
flow in the region has been a subject o debatein the past, and the geometry o this dripprovides a new constraint.
West and colleagues find that numericalexperiments using parameters typical ormodelling lithospheric drips are able tomatch the observed geometry. Te resultssuggest that a density increase o only about1% along with a local temperature increaseo about 10% could have initiated sinking.Increased density is ofen related to coolertemperatures; however, accumulation omaterial lef in place afer melt extraction,or example, could contribute the warm
yet dense material that triggers the drip.Te researchers find that the developmento a lithospheric drip in this setting couldhave taken between one million years andtens o millions o years, depending on theboundary conditions.
Detachment o dense lithospheric mantlerom the overlying crust causes the latterto bob higher, causing uplif at the Earthssurace. Such uplif has been observed inmany other regions o the world, but it isnoteworthy that there is no evidence or it incentral Nevada. Te regions unusually thinlithosphere may cause insignificant uplifrom detachment, or a decoupling layer in
the crust or mantle may prevent uplif byallowing lateral movement.
Te lithospheric drip inerred byWest and colleagues provides a unifiedexplanation or the ast velocities revealed bytomographic analysis and the reduction inshear-wave splitting below central Nevada.
Te drip was not observed in anothertomographic model using the same dataset, with nominally sufficient resolution6.Interestingly, however, a study that usedsurace waves instead o the body waves usedby West and colleagues, recorded at the samestations7, does hint at the existence o thiseature. Tere is an art to tomography, andthe picture in the western US is likely to berefined urther in the near uture.
Te shear-wave splitting pattern inthis region was known previously andwas explained in other ways4,5.West andcolleagues discuss some o the problems with
these previous interpretations, but their ownhypothesis o a lithospheric drip does notexplain some eatures o the pattern either.Tis includes, or example, the wide, bow-wave-shaped pattern o ast orientations thatsurrounds the region o very low splitting,which the previous studies managed toaddress to some extent.
In addition, an intriguing contrast ingravity and topography coinciding withthe southern edge o the proposed drip hasgenerally been interpreted as evidence orhot and buoyant upwelling mantle undercentral and northern Nevada8, including
the region o the proposed drip. A cold,dense downwelling as proposed by Westand colleagues is thus the opposite o whatis needed to explain gravity and suracetopography observations, and increasesthe conundrum rather than putting it torest. It seems that Nevada has not given upall o its secrets quite yet, but the resultspresented by West and colleagues2suggestthat we may be slowly on our way tounderstanding the tectonic evolution o thisenigmatic region.
Vera Schulte-Pelkum is at the Cooperative Institute
for Research in Environmental Sciences and at the
Department of Geological Sciences, University of
Colorado at Boulder, 399 UCB, Boulder, Colorado
80309-0399, USA.
e-mail: [email protected]
References1. Jones, C. H. et al.ectonophysics213,5796 (1992).
2. West, J. D., Fouch, M. J., Roth, J. B. & Elkins-anton, L. .
Nature Geosci.2,439444 (2009).
3. Houseman, G. A. & Molnar, P. Geophys. J. Int. 128,125150 (1997).
4. Savage, M. K. & Sheehan, A. F.J. Geophys. Res.
105,1371513734 (2000).
5. Zandt, G. & Humphreys, E. Geology36,295298 (2008).
6. Burdick, S. et al.Seismol. Res. Lett. 79,384392 (2008).
7. Yang, Y. & Ritzwoller, M. H. Geophys. Res. Lett. 35,L04308 (2008).
8. Saltus, R. W. & Tompson, G. A. ectonics14,12351244 (1995).
Drip
Crust
Lithosphericmantle
Asthenosphericmantle
N
Seismic station
Figure 1 |Mantle flow and shear-wave splitting. In an area with horizontal mantle flow, a vertically
incident shear wave splits into a fast (red) and an orthogonal slow (blue) pulse. When dense lithosphere
becomes unstable, it can drip off. In the presence of such downwelling material, a vertically incident shear
wave (green) travels with a single velocity and little splitting occurs. The drip will sink vertically but the
horizontal asthenospheric flow in the region will cause its base to tilt in the direction of flow. West and
colleagues suggest that such a lithospheric drip is responsible for the enigmatic seismic observations
below central Nevada2.
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected] -
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
17/80
NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience 383
news & views
Today, over 100 million peopleworldwide rely on groundwaterthat is contaminated with arsenic1.
Exposure is greatest in southern Asia, wherearsenic trapped in buried sediments leachesinto groundwaters that support heavilypopulated regions. Tere are now growingconcerns that human manipulation ogroundwater supplies may be exacerbating
the problem. At the American GeophysicalUnion Chapman Conerence on Arsenic inGroundwaters o Southern Asia2, held thisMarch in Siem Reap, Cambodia, participantsdiscussed the possibility that groundwaterextraction may be increasing arsenic levelsin shallow aquiers3(C. Harvey, MI, USA)and aiding the movement o arsenic todeeper, hitherto uncontaminated layers(W. Burgess, UCL, UK).
Arsenic is a naturally occurring elementin the Earths crust, and many soils andsediments contain small amounts o thetoxin. I ingested over long periods o time,
even low doses o arsenic can cause cancerand other diseases: a lietime exposure to just50 g l1o arsenic in drinking water may killone in a hundred people prematurely, andjust a ew years o childhood exposure willlead to increased lung cancer risks as an adult(A. Smith, UC Berkeley, USA). Indeed, thereare growing concerns about environmentalarsenic exposure or some groups in Europeand the US (res 5, 6).Te acuteness o theproblem in southern Asia groundwater-induced poisoning o villagers in Bangladeshhas been described as the largest poisoningo a population in history4 relates to
the environmental conditions there, whichare thought to avour arsenic releaserom sediments.
Te mechanisms that govern arsenicrelease into groundwater are only juststarting to be understood. Arsenic buriedbeneath the surace is thought to be largelybound up with iron and sulphur minerals(B. Bostick, Dartmouth College, USA;G. Breit, USGS, USA; F. Larsen, GEUS,Denmark). Subsequent arsenic release romiron-bearing minerals relies on desorptiono arsenic rom mineral suraces (J. Hering,EAWAG, Switzerland; Y. Zheng, QueensCollege, City Univ. NY, USA) and microbial
reduction under anaerobic conditions7.Genetic profiling o arsenic hotspots andcarbon isotope labelling experiments point toanaerobic iron-reducing and arsenic-reducingbacteria as the main culprits (J. Lloyd, Univ.Manchester, UK). Organic matter stimulatesthe activity o these bacteria, with the degreeo stimulation dependent on the type oorganic matter supplied (D. Polya, Univ.
Manchester, UK working with B. Van Dongenand R. Pancost, Univ. Bristol, UK; D. Postma,echnical Univ. Copenhagen, Denmark).
Some have speculated3that the massiverise in groundwater use in southern Asiain recent years could be increasing theamount o arsenic entering groundwatersupplies (C. Harvey, MI, USA). Shallowtube wells, essentially tubes that bore intounderground aquiers (Fig. 1), are designedto draw water up rom depths o typically2040 m, exactly the region where arsenic-rich groundwaters are ofen ound. Teextraction o large volumes o water or
irrigation rom the shallow aquiers drawssurace water that is rich in highly reactive
organic compounds below ground. Tesecompounds uel the microbes implicatedin the reduction o arsenic-bearing ironminerals, and the reduction o arsenic itsel.Both processes result in arsenic transer romsediments to groundwater.
Tis theory o human-induced arsenicintensification is highly plausible. Terequired mechanisms are well known, and
increases in arsenic concentration withgroundwater age o 1030 g l1per yearhave been observed in Bangladesh (M. Stute,SUNY, USA). Tere are, however, nopublished time series data o sufficient length(over 30 years) to demonstrate unequivocallywhether this process is taking place at a highenough rate to be a concern to policymakersover the next 50 to 100 years. Resolvingthis should be a ocus or uture research;this should include the study o aquiers,or example in Vietnam8and Cambodia9,that are at present relatively unaffected byhuman activities (S. Ferndor, M. Polizzotto,
Stanord Univ., USA; S. Benner, Boise StateUniv., USA).
ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
Rising arsenic risk?Millions of people in southern Asia rely on arsenic-contaminated groundwater to live. Massive water withdrawals
through wells may be increasing the problem by drawing arsenic-mobilizing substances into shallow aquifers and
arsenic-contaminated shallow groundwaters into deeper aquifers.
David Polya and Laurent Charlet
Figure 1 |Tube well used to supply groundwater to villagers. At the Chapman conference 2, participants
discussed the possibility that human manipulation of groundwater supplies is increasing groundwater
arsenic levels. Specifically, there is growing concern that tube wells are drawing arsenic-mobilizing
substances into shallow groundwater supplies, and deep tube wells are drawing arsenic-rich waters
to depth.
THOMASROSENBERG
2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
-
8/10/2019 Nature.geoscience
18/80
384 NATURE GEOSCIENCE| VOL 2 | JUNE 2009 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience
news & views
Long before the reign of complex
animals, the Earths crust stretched
and thinned, creating a marine basin in
what is now central India. The Vindhyanbasin was flooded with sea water, and
subsequently filled with sediments.
But it is unclear just when these events
happened. Radiometric ages from
zircons and diamonds, as well as the
orientation of magnetic grains, suggest
that the basin began to fill between
1.7 and 1 billion years ago. However,
purported fossils hidden in the lower
rock layers hint at the presence of
simple animals that are consistent with a
much later origin for the layers in the
Ediacaran or Cambrian periods (about
640 to 500 million years ago).
The ensuing debate has seen some
researchers question whether these
fossils are actually of biological origin,
whereas other groups have suggested that
the radiometric ages reflect the source of
the sediments, rather than the creation of
the basins lower layers. Stefan Bengtson
of the Swedish Museum of Natural
History and his colleagues have jumped
into the fray, with new fossil specimens
and new ages for the surrounding rocks
(Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USAdoi: 10.1073/
pnas.0812460106; 2009).
Aging well
PALAEONTOLOGY
The miniscule fossils are mostly
contained within phosphorous-rich nodes.
The nodes revealed the remains of bacterial
colonies, which generally show up as small
clusters of filaments that form distinctive
shapes. The group also found segmented
tubes, less than 200 m in diameter,which could be the remnants of algae. But
they failed to find the most contentious
microfossils from previous studies: embryos
from primitive multicellular animal life.
Instead, they suggest that the tiny spherical
shapes are air bubbles produced by
bacterial activity, trapped in the sticky film
covering the microbial mats. Overall, they
contend that the fossil assemblage probably
represents a pre-Ediacaran ecosystem.
Direct dating of the phosphate-rich
material surrounding the fossils using lead
isotopes minimized potential sources of
contamination. Their analyses converged on
an age of roughly 1.65 billion years well
in line with previous mineral-based
estimates leading the group to conclude
that the rocks, and the fossils within, are
indeed from the Palaeoproterozoic era.
Although the rocks no longer seem
to reveal
early animals, Bengston and
colleagues are quick to point out that
the exceptional preservation of the
fossils provides a unique window into
life 1.6 billion years ago. Interpretation
of the segmented tubes as algae would
push back the earliest appearance
of multicellular eukaryotes by up to
600 million years, and the bacterial clumps
show a rare glimpse of pre-Cambrian
calcifying cyanobacteria proving that
there is still much to learn from these
controversial rocks.
ALICIA NEWTON
Given that shallow tube wells tap intoarsenic-laden sedimentary layers andthe concentrations o this toxin in watermay increase, it seems sensible to lookelsewhere or clean water supplies. Teheterogeneous nature o arsenic distributionin shallow groundwaters means that
well-switching 10 many villages lie close tolow-arsenic wells is a useul short-termremediation strategy (A. Van Geen, LDEO-Columbia Univ., USA). Furthermore, the olderand deeper aquiers, made up o Pleistocenedeposits (laid down more than 10,000 yearsago) are ofen low in arsenic, possibly becausethey contain a high proportion o mineralsuraces able to sequester the poison. Tusdeep tube wells, which tap into groundwaterwell below the arsenic-affected layers, are apotential source o arsenic-ree water.
But as highlighted repeatedly at themeeting, even water in these deep aquiers
may not remain arsenic-ree. Tere aregrowing concerns that extensive deepwater extraction will draw arsenic-richwater rom the top o the aquier to de