MetLib 2010 - Zagreb
How Inclusive is Your Library
A Toolkit fromCanadian Urban Libraries
Jeff Barber
MetLib 2010 - Zagreb
What is Social Inclusion?
Social inclusion is the participatory, authentic and
accountable manner in which organizations uphold and
reinforce the principles of access and equity for all.
And…
• In particular, social inclusion is the manner in which organizations:– understand and engage their communities– explore, view and challenge barriers, values and
behaviours– develop, implement and evaluate systems, programs,
policies and procedures– provide equitable access to services and
decision-making opportunities– demonstrate the level of inclusion through tangible
outcomes
MetLib 2010 - Zagreb
Why Does It Matter?
• Social inclusion facilitates positive outcomes:– Increases employment– Decreases poverty– Enables civic engagement– Reduces discrimination and racism– Promotes access to public resources and institutions
• An audit:– Formalizes, informs and guides the removal of barriers– Provides an analysis of the degree to which barriers have
been removed
MetLib 2010 - Zagreb
Why CULC?
• Canadian Urban Libraries Council– New Strategic Plan/Reinvent the organization– Research and Knowledge Transfer agenda
• Canada– Immigration
• ~250,000 people emigrate to Canada each year• 70% settle in Toronto, Montréal or Vancouver metropolitan areas
– Aboriginal population• 1.2 million people• Growth rate more than 3 times that of non-aboriginal population• 45% live in urban areas
MetLib 2010 - Zagreb
SIA Toolkit
• Result of (CULC’s first) major research project, spanning about two years
• Includes:– Introduction to concepts– Detailed review of each of the 12 questions/outcome
statements and a measurement system – the audit– Survey and focus group results from immigrant youth– Literature review and research summary
• Intended to permit self-assessment
MetLib 2010 - Zagreb
Audit
• Audit requires at least two measurement points– current Status– Progress over time
• Audit measures 3 indicators with 12 questions:
MetLib 2010 - Zagreb
Indicator Measures Qs
Openness How well the library knows the community 2
IntentionalityHow well the library reinforces the principles of social inclusion
7
Inclusion How well the library is the community 3
SI Indicator Matrix
Criteria Indicator
Social inclusion is the manner in which institutions:
• are open to understanding and engaging their communities
OpennessIntentionality
• explore, view, and challenge barriers, values, and behaviours
OpennessIntentionality
• develop, implement, and evaluate systems, programs, policies, and procedures
Intentionality
• provide equitable access to services and decision making opportunities
IntentionalityInclusion
• demonstrate the level of inclusion through tangible outcomes
Inclusion
MetLib 2010 - Zagreb
Example: Question 6
• Indicator: Intentionality• Question/Outcome:
– “A plan of action has been developed which includes:• analysis of community needs and gaps in service;• annual social inclusion audit results;• targeted strategies for:
– governance,– human resources and training/learning, plus– programs/services,– collections development, implementation, and evaluation.”
MetLib 2010 - Zagreb
Example: Question 6
• Toolkit includes:– Suggested community assessment tools– Sample charts to assist in:
• Evaluating previous performance on SI audits• Evaluating current strategies and proposing change
– Overview of information from Toronto and Hamilton relevant to the question
– Measurement system– Tips– Audit Tool Interpretation (post measurement)
MetLib 2010 - Zagreb
Measurement System
MetLib 2010 - Zagreb
Low StatusLow Progress
Low StatusHigh Progress
High StatusLow Progress
High StatusHigh Progress
Moderate StatusModerate Progress
0
48
48Status
Tidbits from the Survey
• The longer immigrant youth have been in Canada:– The more they prefer youth related collections over EAL or
cultural collections– The more they prefer programming relevant to their age
over ethnic or newcomer themes– The more they want to see ethnic diversity reflected in the
staff• Length of time spent in Canada was not a significant
factor in how immigrant youth used library computers, use the catalogue, appreciate diversity in art, or feel comfortable in the library.
MetLib 2010 - Zagreb
Latest Developments
• Currently preparing for use/implementation of the toolkit in:– London (ON), Halifax (NS), Barrie (ON), Oshawa (ON),
Ottawa (ON), Edmonton (AB), Windsor (ON), Hamilton (ON), Vancouver (BC)
• Toolkit printed in English and French• Online at www.siatoolkit.com and includes 5 short
‘how-to’ videos
MetLib 2010 - Zagreb