04/13/2023
S
The Legal Challenges That Affect The Collection of
Zakat By A StateBy: Laila Abdul Latif
1ST BI-ANNUAL CONFERENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW IN KENYA
School of Law, University of Nairobi (UON)
04/13/2023
Introductory Remarks
Why this topic? What is its importance? Poverty alleviation strategy Welfare of the poor Equitable distribution of wealth Uniform application of rules on zakat: Prophetic era
and caliphate system
04/13/2023
What is zakat?
Definition Arabic meaning “purity” Duty enjoined by Allah (God) and a form of worship No equivalent practice in other religions
Assessed once a year
Specific beneficiaries (Quran; Chapter 5, Verse 60)
Different percentages
04/13/2023
Assessment of Zakat
2.50%2.50%
5.00%
10.00%
20.00%
Assessment of Zakat
Invested wealthUnivested wealthHarvest from cul-tivated landHarvest from uncul-tivated landFortuitous fortune
04/13/2023
Assessment continued
Camel Sheep/Goats Cows
5-9 Camels = 1 Ram/Goat
40-120 Sheep = 1 Ram/Sheep/Goat
30-39 Cows = A 2 year old calf
10-14 Camels = 2 Rams/Goats
120-200 Sheep = 2 Sheep
40-59 Cows = A 3 year old calf
04/13/2023
Collection and Challenges
Who should collect zakat? State, if objective is to be met Muslim versus secular state
Legal challenges; Affects collection of zakat Impacts and raises questions concerning the
effectiveness of zakat as a method of; Poverty alleviation and Equitable wealth distribution
04/13/2023
Methods of collecting zakat
Compulsory: State approach Case study; Sudan Used to be voluntary in 1984 (Sudanese Pounds 35million) Made compulsory in 1989 (Sudanese Pounds 504million) Case study; Pakistan (automatic deduction of zakat by
banks)
Voluntary/Zakat Fund: Through charitable institutions/Mosques in countries where the State does not collect zakat – Case study; Kuwait (Kuwait Zakat House)
04/13/2023
What are these legal challenges?
Different schools of thought hence no uniform application: Hanafi: Zakat can only be collected on ‘visible’ property
(livestock and crops, gold and silver). E.g., Saudi Arabia and Pakistan. Distribution limited to poor and needy.
Maliki/Shafi: Zakat can be collected on all property. E.g., Sudan and Yemen. Distribution not limited.
Assessment methods: Declaration system (Saudi Arabia and Sudan) – Payers
themselves calculate the zakat owed and pay it Deduction at source (Pakistan)
04/13/2023
Continuation
Unresolved jurisprudence issues: Saudi Arabia excludes from zakat fixed business assets;
other countries require conditions to be met to impose zakat on fixed business assets (condition of growth whether real or potential to be satisfied)
Imposing zakat only on self employed individuals leaving out salaried professionals, even if latter earn more
Lack of a transparent and accountable system in assessing zakat – declaratory method not transparent and effective
04/13/2023
Continuation
Lack of experience of officials assessing zakat, poor accounting practices by companies
Neglecting responsibility to collect zakat and distribute to poor and needy, assessment made on crops and livestock but distribution not discussed (Saudi Arabia)
Non official channels (Malaysia – inconvenience, lack of confidence in government administration, inefficiency, giving to known people)
04/13/2023
Continuation
Lack of knowledge and information about the law on zakat because the law is not specific (Kuwait)
Lack of effective administrative laws (Sudan lacking adequate storage and transportation facilities)
Lack of implementation strategy (no database on eligible beneficiaries of zakat)
04/13/2023
Recommendations Proposed
Review and harmonise the opinions of the different schools of thought
Educate Muslim public on zakat; coverage and assessment
Train government officials in collecting zakat
Implement efficient zakat administration system (Pakistan experience as a guide, regional offices)
Promote and regulate non official channels
04/13/2023
Continued
Offer tax incentives to zakat payers
Promoting accountability in the collection of zakat (show how zakat is being spent)
04/13/2023
Conclusion
Since zakat is a method by which poverty can be alleviated and wealth can also be equitably distributed in a society it is important to have a zakat collection system that is free from legal challenges
04/13/2023
End of the presentation