Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 1
Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 2
Content
1. Introductory lesson and comparison between qualitative and quantitative methodology
2. Conducting quantitative surveys 1: Structuring a topic / Developing hypothesis 3. Conducting quantitative surveys 2: Questionaire design / Pretest / Sampling
methods / Interview situation 4. Conducting quantitative surveys 3: Sources of error / Working, interpreting and
presenting the data 5. Methodology: Epistemology / Theory of social sciences / Critical Rationalism 6. Methodology: Hermeneutics / Symbolic Interactionism / Constructivist
Paradigm 7. Conducting qualitative research 1: Narrative Interviews / Interviewing experts 8. Conducting qualitative research 2: Focus groups / Participant Observation /
Participatory Research / Grounded Theory 9. Conducting qualitative research 3: Transcription / Approaches to interpretation 10. Mixed methods / Hybrid methods 11. Choosing the right research design / Research ethics
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 4
How does science work? How do we get to scientific results?
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 5
What are the differences between natural and social sciences?
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 6
Theoretical findings
Empirical findings
Quantitative rationale
Qualitative rationale
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 7
Aim of first lesson
• To comprehend the fundamental difference between the quantitative and qualitative research rationale.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 8
Political and social change in exurban villages
Comparing quantitative and qualitative research
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 10
Quantitative Research
• Making statements about the universe of all exurban villages (population)
– Highest possible number of cases – Random sample
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 11
Hypotheses
Statements about correlations / causalities 1. The closer a village lies to the urban agglomeration,
the higher is the potential for conflicts between agriculture and residential use.
2. The more intensive the agriculture in a village is, the higher is the potential for conflicts between agriculture and residential use.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 12
Definitions
• Village – Municipality < 5.000 Inhabitants • Urban agglomeration– Hamburg, Bremen und
Hanover • Exurban area – Counties adjacent to urban
agglomerations • Proximity– As the crow flies • Intensity of agriculture – Index of land tax and
livestock units/inhabitant • Potential for conflicts between agriculture and
residents – Survey of mayors
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 13
Standardized survey / Questionaire
To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statement? (please mark with a cross) „Agriculture is a topic that leads to a lot of conflicts inside our commune.“
-Strongly agree -Mildly agree -Neither agree or disagree -Mildly disagree -Strongly disagree
- I don‘t know
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 14
Data
Name Confl Agr Distance Land Tax LSU
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 15
Measure of correlation
• Statistical Measure: Rank correlation (Spearman‘s Rho)
• Between –1 and 1 • -1: direct negative correlation • 1: direct positive correlation • 0: no correlation
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 16
Rating of the potential for conflicts
• Correlation proximity: -0,05 • Correlation index of agricultural intensity:
0,35
• Could this result be accidental? • Significance test • Only possible with a random sample • The correlation is signifikant on a 95% level of
significance.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 17
Findings
• There is a verifiable connection between the intensity of agriculture and the potential for conflicts in the village.
• There is no detectable influence of the distance to the urban agglomeration on the potential for conflict.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 18
Qualitative Research
• Making statements about the actor‘s perception and construction of meaning
• Exploring subjective worlds – Interpretation of comments (i.e. also looking for
inconsistencies and contradictions) – Small number of cases – Conscious sampling of cases/persons
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 19
Qualitative Research
• „Topography“ of the research object is only little known – Openly approaching the research object – No formulation of hypotheses in advance – Interpenetration of theoretical and empirical work
as well as selection of new cases
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 20
Conscious sampling of cases
• Village „Kuhdorf“ • Lies 30 km east of Hamburg • Has got 650 inhabitants • Many older farm buildings were bought up
and renovated by incoming housholds from Hamburg
• 16 farms, 8 full-time farmers, 2 organic farms • Proportion of votes for the Green Party is
outstanding (12,3 %) • Large nature reserve
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 21
Interview with mayor
• Extensive conversation • Literal recording • No ready-made questions, it is possible to
react to the respondent • Interview partner has to express his answers • Interview partner can touch on new subjects • Biography and seemingly remote subjects are
important
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 22
Interpretation
• Context of a statement • What is said? What isn‘t said? • Frequency and vehemence of statements • Different levels of meaning • Reasoning styles • Metaphors and images • Inconsistencies, contradictions
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 23
PD Dr. Florian Dünckmann
Context: Nature reserve
„I try to balance conflicts with agriculture alltough I‘m not always sucessful.“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 24
PD Dr. Florian Dünckmann
following
„And then there is the problem of smell. Especially hog feeding.“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 25
PD Dr. Florian Dünckmann
following
„Are you the only one here in the village who is disturbed by this or are there more people ?“
„Yes, but only behind the back. No one has openly adressed it yet.“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 26
PD Dr. Florian Dünckmann
following
„It is not a topic in the local council? “
„A large portion of them are farmers who have stables“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 27
PD Dr. Florian Dünckmann
Position of the farmers, following
„They say: If you move to the countryside then you have to accept it“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 28
PD Dr. Florian Dünckmann
Context: A successful local organic farm
„Now I‘m surely riven (...) Shurely we are fans of that organic farm (...) Well, in the local counsel there are many farmers who say, you and your ecology. We have to secure profit maximation (...) For me as a mayor it‘s a tightrope walk“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 29
The perspective of the mayor
• There are latent conflicts between agriculture and residents (odor nuissance)
• Farmers try to defend their local hegemony, i.e. they try to equate their interests with the „village‘s interest“.
• Rejection of agriculture is first of all directed towards conventional farmers. The organic farm is viewed positively.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 30
Questions to the quantitative analysis
• What does is mean when a mayors says that there are no conflicts between ? – There should be no conficts with agriculture
becaus it is a central part of the village. – Personally I think that surely there are conflicts
with agriculture. But as a mayor I can‘t put it that way.
– There are no conflicts with organic farming, but with conventional agriculture.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 31
Questions to the qualitative analysis
• How can I contextualise the case of Kuhdorf? – How can I justify the choice of Kuhdorf ? – Is Kuhdorf an interesting exception? – Is Kuhdorf an example for a certain type of
village? – Can I find the patterns that I have identified in
Kuhdorf in all the other villages? – When interpreting the protocol, have I stressed
the remarkable statements at the expense of the normal ones ?
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 32
Differences between qualitative and quantitative research
• Question of sample size is not central! • Different direction of inquiry • Different research questions • Different confidence in the researcher‘s
power of judgement • Different conception of measuring and
evaluating • Different meaning of „result“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 33
Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 34
Content
1. Introductory lesson and comparison between qualitative and quantitative methodology
2. Conducting quantitative surveys 1: Structuring a topic / Developing hypothesis 3. Conducting quantitative surveys 2: Questionaire design / Pretest / Sampling
methods / Interview situation 4. Conducting quantitative surveys 3: Sources of error / Working, interpreting and
presenting the data 5. Methodology: Epistemology / Theory of social sciences / Critical Rationalism 6. Methodology: Hermeneutics / Symbolic Interactionism / Constructivist
Paradigm 7. Conducting qualitative research 1: Narrative Interviews / Interviewing experts 8. Conducting qualitative research 2: Focus groups / Participant Observation /
Participatory Research / Grounded Theory 9. Conducting qualitative research 3: Transcription / Approaches to interpretation 10. Mixed methods / Hybrid methods 11. Choosing the right research design / Research ethics
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 35
Conducting quantitative surveys
1. The more liberal the law on divorce, the lower is the proportion of married persons in a society.
2. When the proportion of foreign workforce rises, than the income of the domestic people sinks and unemployment rates rise significantly.
3. Persons with a strong environmental consciousness have a higher willingness to save energy than less environmentally conscious persons.
4. Regions with a better supply in day nursery have a higher fertility rate.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 36
Cause for caution 1: Scientific and practical reason
• We are all experts in our daily lives! • Practical expertise • Judgment s, assumptions, theories about society • Scientific inquiry has to abandon common sense. • Instead: structured and inter-subjective proceeding • Formalizing and theorizing our day-to-day expertise
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 37
Cause for caution 2: Injection of scientific results into society
• The object of social research (society) is also its addressee.
• Scientific results might change the course of social change.
• Scientific concepts and terms are taken up by common language – Globalization – Urbanization – Gentrification
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 38
Cause for caution 3: Ethical problems
• Relevance and choice of research question • Implicit moral judgments • Research funding
– Study sponsored by BMW with the result that a speed-limit on the autobahn significantly reduces the risk of accidents and car emissions (?)
• Personal rights of the test person
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 39
Dimensional analysis / Conceptual analysis
• Either translation of fuzzy concepts of everyday thinking into distinguished dimensions
• Or translation of abstract concepts of theoretical thinking into distinguished dimensions
• Linking idealistic concepts to empirical reality • Decision about the relevance of traits / criteria
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 40
Dimensional analysis
• Brainstorming: What dimensions could be part of a concept? – Individual quality of life – Acceptance of environmental conservation
measures – Environmental consciousness
• Structuring: Identifying high-level and low-level dimensions
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 41
Dimensional analysis
Relevant dimensions? -Sunspots -Situation of the national economy -Infrastructure -Political Situation - Social Recognition
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 42
Dimensional analysis
• „Is there a relationship between the social background of a person and its professional career?“
• Social Background • Professional career
• Nature of relationship?
– Education
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 43
Social Background
• Social status of family • Social network of family • Habitual style of the family • Demographic characteristics • Place of origin • Ethnicity
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 44
Dimensional analysis
• Place of origin:
– National origin – Regional origin – Urban / rural – Neighborhood
• Temporal scope of „origin“ (Parents, birth, childhood, formative
adolescence etc.)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 45
Dimensional analysis
• Social status of family – Father, parents, wider family? – Wealth – Income – Professional prestige – Education
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 46
Dimensional analysis
• Justified selection: What dimensions are included in the survey and why? – Centrality to the theoretical framework – Relevance – Empirical managerability – Correlation between dimensions
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 47
Conceptual analysis
• Ambiguous conceptual term • Designates different empirical contents in different
contexts • Example: Germany
– comprises an area of 357.121 km2
– won the FIFA world cup in 1974 • Globalization • Capital • Development / Underdevelopment • Brainstorming / structuring / justified selection
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 48
Conceptual analysis
• What is development? (Kenia, Colombia, Norway) • Apart from physical geographical differences
(development is not restricted to the temperate zone)
• Apart from cultural differences (development ≠ westernisation)
• Apart from individual happiness
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 49
Conceptual analysis
• 331 variables of the World Bank – % employed in agriculture – % access to electricity – Mortality Rate – Pupil-teacher-ratio – CO2 emissions per capita – Number of teenage mothers – Cars per 1.000 people – Poverty gap – Researchers in R & D – Military expenditure (% of GDP) – % urban population – GDP / capita
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 50
Indicator
• Indicates (points at) • Concrete dimension that can stand for an abstract concept • Three criteria for quality of indicator:
– objective (measurable independently of person) – reliable (trustworthiness of measurement) – valid (indicator really mirrors abstract concept)
• Development indicators? • Human Development Index:
– Economy: GDP/capita – Health: Life expectancy at birth – Education: literacy rate & years in school
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 51
Summary
• Translation of complex concepts into distinguished dimensions – Fuzzy concepts of the everyday language: dimensional analysis – Abstract concept of academic language: conceptual analysis
• Three steps: – Brainstorming all possible dimensions – Structuring higher- and lower-level dimensions – Justified selection of the analyzed dimensions
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 52
Theories and Hypotheses
• Quantitative research tests theories and hypotheses. • Theory:
– Abstract theories (rational choice, structuralist theories, cultural theories etc.): Provide terms, research objects, perspectives etc.
– Mid-ranged theories: Provide explanatory models for sections of reality
• Coping strategies • Succession of value orientation through generations
(materialist – post-materialist) • Tragedy of the commons
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 53
Theories and Hypothesis
• Hypothesis derived from theory. • Statements about relation between two or more
variables. • „A lot of people are afraid of climate change“ is not a
hypothesis. – „A lot of“ is too vague – No statement about a relation between two or more variables.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 54
Theories and Hypothesis
• Deterministic and probabilistic hypotheses – In social sciences normally probabilistic models
• If…then-hypothesis • The (more/less) … the (more/less)-hypothesis • Individual or collective hypothesis
Individual variable 1 (education)
Individual variable 2 (voluntary environmental behaviour)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 55
Theories and Hypothesis
• Deterministic and probabilistic hypotheses – In social sciences normally probabilistic models
• If…then-hypothesis • The (more/less) … the (more/less)-hypothesis • Individual or collective hypothesis
Individual variable (voluntary environmental action)
Collective variable (existence of rules that govern collective environmental action)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 56
Theories and Hypothesis
• Deterministic and probabilistic hypotheses – In social sciences normally probabilistic models
• If…then-hypothesis • The (more/less) … the (more/less)-hypothesis • Individual or collective hypothesis
Individual variable (individual or household dependence on use of natural resources)
Collective variable (existence of rules to govern collective environmental action)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 57
Theories and Hypotheses
• A hypothesis should be mortal. There should be a possibility of not being approved.
• A hypothesis should have informational content. • The informational content of a sentence increases with the
amout of sentences excluded by it. – „Communities in which more than 50% of the households either
rely on hunting, agriculture or fishery as the dominant occupation will exhibit more elaborate environmental institutions than communities with a lower index of direct natural resources dependency“
– „A widespread dependency on the use of natural ressources in a community may lead to an increasingly elaborate system of environmental institutions.“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 58
Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 59
Content
1. Introductory lesson and comparison between qualitative and quantitative methodology
2. Conducting quantitative surveys 1: Structuring a topic / Developing hypothesis 3. Conducting quantitative surveys 2: Questionaire design / Pretest / Sampling
methods / Interview situation 4. Conducting quantitative surveys 3: Sources of error / Working, interpreting and
presenting the data 5. Methodology: Epistemology / Theory of social sciences / Critical Rationalism 6. Methodology: Hermeneutics / Symbolic Interactionism / Constructivist
Paradigm 7. Conducting qualitative research 1: Narrative Interviews / Interviewing experts 8. Conducting qualitative research 2: Focus groups / Participant Observation /
Participatory Research / Grounded Theory 9. Conducting qualitative research 3: Transcription / Approaches to interpretation 10. Mixed methods / Hybrid methods 11. Choosing the right research design / Research ethics
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 60
Theories and Hypotheses
• A hypothesis should be mortal. There should be a possibility of not being approved.
• A hypothesis should have informational content. • The informational content of a sentence increases with the
amount of sentences excluded by it. – „Communities in which more than 50% of the households either
rely on hunting, agriculture or fishery as the dominant occupation will exhibit more elaborate environmental institutions than communities with a lower index of direct natural resources dependency“
– „A widespread dependency on the use of natural ressources in a community may lead to an increasingly elaborate system of environmental institutions.“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 61
From hypothesis to questionaire
• What/who is the object of inquiry? – Individuals? – Individuals of a certain group? – Households?
• Selection and specification of indicators – E.g. Accessebility: distance as the crow flies /
distance in conducted miles / traveling time and expenditure
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 62
Scales
• Nominal scale: a is different from b – Sex (male / female) – Profession
• Ranking / Ordinal scale: a is higher/smaller than b – Ranking: fully agree/ agree/disagree/fully disagree
• Interval scale: a is the value of c higher/smaller than b – Temperature in °Celsius, Age
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 63
Scales
• Amount of information decreases from interval to ordinal to nominal scale
• Statistical procedures demand interval scales • Ordinal scales can be analyzed with non-parametrical
measures (more rough) • Higher scales can be transformed in lower scales (but
not vice versa) • Always aim for the highest scale possible! • Age: age categories / year of birth / age in years
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 64
Categories
• Categories press a multiformed reality into chunky containers.
• Criteria for the quality of categorization: – Limited number of categories – Distinct: No ambiguity in classification – Exhaustive: Every empirical case belongs to one category
• Logic of categorization: – Equally spaced (every 10 units) – With regard to special content (under 18 years, over 65 years)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 65
Place of residence
• Adress? • Postal code • Town/city/county • Special categories becoming more general with
increasing distance – Kiel, Kiel region, rest of Schleswig-Holstein, Lower
Saxony/Hamburg/Mecklenburg/Bremen, Rest of Germany, Rest of Europe, other
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 66
Questionaire
1. Forms of surveys 2. Types of questions 3. Constructing a questionaire
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 67
Forms of surveys
• Postal • Online • Telefone • Face-to-face
– With a fixed date – Household survey – Spontaneous
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 68
Types of questions
• Demographic information: Age, sex, income etc. • Attitudes: Acceptance, Agree/disagree, Satisfaction • Questions about actions: How often do you go
shopping? / Where are you coming from today? • Questions about motives:
– Never ask: „Why do you do x?“ – But: „What is important to you when you do x?“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 69
„The identification of reasons for the shapes of a certain variable must be part of the interpretation of the date and is not a task for the interviewee. “ (Nisbett & Wilson 1977)
• Ad-hoc-Answers
„My questions as a researcher are not the questions I
can ask my interviewees“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 70
Constructing a questionaire
• Open questions (without categories) – Ex post categorization – Explorative
• Closed questions – Dichotomous categories – Categorical scheme with/without ranking – Possibility to give multiple answers?
• Semi-closed questions – With one open category (else:____________)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 71
What is wrong with these questions?
• „How would you assess the economic impact of sea level rise in Schleswig-Holstein?“
• „How many journeys did you do last year?“ • „Did you receive subsidies from the EU, the national
government or the commune?“ • „In which way are you helping to save the climate?“ • „What is your monthly income?“ • „If you would have one million Euro available, how much would
you spend on environmental issues?“ • „How would you assess the ecological quality of this part of the
beach?“ – Excellent / good / neither good nor bad / bad / terrible
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 72
• Easy, concrete • Without ambigiuty • One-dimensional • Neutral, not suggestive • Sensible • Not hypothetical • „Don‘t know“ as a category
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 73
Constructing a questionaire
• Max. 10 minutes for spontaneous interviews • Introductory commentary: Who are you? What is the
survey for? Anonymity. • Warming-up: First question should be fascinating and
relevant. • Rule of thumb: Central questions in the middle third • Sensible questions (e.g. age, income) at the end
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 74
Constructing a questionaire
• Filtering questions • Questions have surrounding fields of framing (mostly
unwanted) • Buffering questions (to reduce the biasing effect) • Control questions (asking the same question
differently in order to check central points)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 75
Rating technique
• Assessing different statements on a standardized scale
• Rate the following statement on a scale from 1 (totally agree) to 5 (totally disagree)
• „I think that economic interests should have priority when balanced with environmental interests.“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 76
Pretest
• Testing the questionnaire (10-20 times) • Questions a pretest should address:
– Are the questions understandable? – Are questions interpreted in the wrong way? – Do all the interviewees give the same answer? – Do some questions have a biasing effect on the
following questions? – Are the categories appropriate
• Ideally with two interviewers • No questionnaire is perfect without a pretest!
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 77
Sampling
• Random or non-random • Arbitrary (without rules) • Non-random sampling methods:
– Ideal types – Snowball – Extreme cases – Theoretical sampling (Grounded theory)
„Non-random samples don‘t allow for statistically validated inferences on the population/universe. Predications can only relate to the cases of the direct sample. Otherwise they are generalizations!“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 78
Central requirement for a random sample
„Every case of the population / universe N must have exactly the same possibility to be integrated in the sample“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 79
Sampling procedures
• Random numbers • Systematical procedure (every fourth person) • Multi-layered procedure (1. random selection of
specific subgroup, 2. random selection of individuals of that subgroup)
• Stratified sample – Division of the universe N in subgroups – Random sample in every subgroup – E.g. age – No proposition can be made concerning this variable – Variable can be used as an independent variable
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 80
Sample size
• Not dependent on the size of the population / universe N
• The more the better! • Samples with less than 30 are too small. • The smaller the sample the bigger the uncertainty of
the findings. • The bigger the variance the bigger the uncertainty of
the findings.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 81
Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 82
Content
1. Introductory lesson and comparison between qualitative and quantitative methodology
2. Conducting quantitative surveys 1: Structuring a topic / Developing hypothesis 3. Conducting quantitative surveys 2: Questionaire design / Pretest / Sampling
methods / Interview situation 4. Conducting quantitative surveys 3: Sources of error / Working, interpreting and
presenting the data 5. Methodology: Epistemology / Theory of social sciences / Critical Rationalism 6. Methodology: Hermeneutics / Symbolic Interactionism / Constructivist
Paradigm 7. Conducting qualitative research 1: Narrative Interviews / Interviewing experts 8. Conducting qualitative research 2: Focus groups / Participant Observation /
Participatory Research / Grounded Theory 9. Conducting qualitative research 3: Transcription / Approaches to interpretation 10. Mixed methods / Hybrid methods 11. Choosing the right research design / Research ethics
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 83
Interview situation
• Artificial situation of communication – Interviewee: Object – Interviewer: Instrument
• No forerun, no follow-up • Extremely one-sided • Standardized • Danger of rejection
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 84
Sources of error
• Sampling error: Bias in the selection of the analysed cases (e.g. sympathy)
• Coverage error: Certain parts of the population are not included in the sampling procedure (e.g. because they are difficult to address)
• Non-response error: Bias due to non-random distribution of rejections
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 85
Important terms
• N: Population / universe • n: sample • Variable • Case • Characteristic value
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 86
• Population: All households in a flood risk area in the city X
• Sample: Specific sample of 200 households • Variable: Main source of household income /
Number of household members • Case: Specific household • Characteristic value: informal street trading / four
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 87
Modes of data analysis
• Descriptive, analytic statistics • Primary / secondary frequency distribution • Absolute, relative, percentage frequency • Building classes • Graphical representation (charts) • Parameters of distribution
– Measurements of centrality – Measurements of variation – Standardization
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 88
“Statistical methods are means to analyze numbers as numbers and not as indicators of a property.” (Diehl & Kohr 1994, p. 25)
Statistics can never replace interpretation of content. It
can only order large sets of data and thereby facilitate interpretation.
Computer-programs might give you the average of male
and female coded as 1 and 2, since they don’t know what 1 and 2 stand for.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 89
Statistics
• Descriptive statistics: – Displays data – Simplifies complex sets of data – Delivers no analysis – Delivers no inference from sample to the universe / population
• Analytical/deductive statistics – Analyses data – Identifies relations between variables – Infers from sample to the universe using theory of probability
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 90
First steps in describing the data
• Raw data Case Variable X Variable Y
1 5 3
2 6 2
3 9 4
4 1 2
5 7 3
6 6 4
7 3 1
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 91
• Ranking the cases Case X Y
4 1 2
7 3 1
1 5 3
2 6 2
6 6 4
5 7 3
3 9 4
First steps in describing the data
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 92
Erste Schritte der Datenbeschreibung
• Ranking the cases
Case X 4 1 7 3 1 5 2 6 6 6 5 7 3 9
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 93
First steps in describing the data
• Ranking the cases
Case X Position 4 1 1 7 3 2 1 5 3 2 6 4,5 6 6 4,5 5 7 6 3 9 7
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 94
Erste Schritte der Datenbeschreibung
• Frequency distribution
Case X 4 1 7 3 1 5 2 6 6 6 5 7 3 9
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 95
First steps in describing the data
• Frequency distribution
X Absolute frequency 1 1 3 1 5 1 6 2 7 1 9 1
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 96
First steps in describing the data
• Frequency distribution
X Absolute frequency Relative frequency
1 1 1/7 = 0,14 3 1 1/7 = 0,14 5 1 1/7 = 0,14 6 2 2/7 = 0,28 7 1 1/7 = 0,14 9 1 1/7 = 0,14
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 97
First steps in describing the data
• Frequency distribution
X Absolute f. Relative f. Percentage f. 1 1 1/6 = 0,14 14 3 1 1/7 = 0,14 14 5 1 1/7 = 0,14 14 6 2 2/7 = 0,28 28 7 1 1/7 = 0,14 14 9 1 1/7 = 0,14 14
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 98
First steps in describing the data
• Frequency distribution
X Absolute H. Percentage f. Cumulative f. 1 1 14 14 3 1 14 28 5 1 14 42 6 2 28 70 7 1 14 84 9 1 14 98
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 99
Classification
• Breaking down the raw data into classes • Loss of information, gains in clarity • Requirements for classification:
– No overlapping – Covering the whole range of values – Equal class intervals can be useful – Class boundaries on integral numbers (if possible)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 100
Sturge‘s Rule
• Number of classes : 1 + 3,32 * lg n • 140 cases result in ca. 8 classes • Just a crude rule!
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 101
Diagrams
• Circular chart • Bar chart • Polygon
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 103
Bar chart
0
0,5
1
1,5
2
2,5
1 3 5 6 7 9
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 104
Säulendiagramm
0
0,5
1
1,5
2
2,5
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 105
Polygon
0
0,5
1
1,5
2
2,5
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 106
Means of transport
1
2
3
4
5
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 107
Figures of distribution
• Centrality – Arithmetric mean – Median – Mode
• Variation – Range – Standard deviation
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 108
Arithmetric mean
• Sum of all values / Number of values • Sensible to extreme values • Integrates all values in calculation • Only possible for metric scales! • Example: Per-capita income?
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 109
Median
• 50% of cases have higher / lower value • Departing from ranked order • Impair number of cases: value of k +1 case • (n = 2 x k + 1) • Pair number of cases: mean over kth and
k+1st value • (n = 2 x k)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 110
Median
• Not sensible to extreme values • Also possible for ordinal scales (not for nominal
scales) • Has less information content than aritmetric mean
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 111
Mode
• Most frequent value • Also for nominal scales • Contains few information
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 112
Range
• Maximal value minus minimal value • Only possible for metric data • Strongly influenced by extreme values • Few information about distribution of values
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 113
Standard deviation
• Integrates the whole distribution into calculation • Extreme values are weightet higher because all
values are squared • Same measuring unit as variable • The better the aritmetric mean characterizes the
distribution the more meaningful is the standard deviation
• Great significance in statistical procedures
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 114
Z-Transformation
• Deviation of a value from the aritmetric mean measured in standard deviations
• Standardization of the distribution • Mean= 0, standard deviation = 1 • Independent from the measuring unit of the
variable • Enables the comparison of the position of a case in
different distributions of different variables
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 115
Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 116
Content
1. Introductory lesson and comparison between qualitative and quantitative methodology
2. Conducting quantitative surveys 1: Structuring a topic / Developing hypothesis 3. Conducting quantitative surveys 2: Questionaire design / Pretest / Sampling
methods / Interview situation 4. Conducting quantitative surveys 3: Sources of error / Working, interpreting and
presenting the data 5. Methodology: Epistemology / Theory of social sciences / Critical Rationalism 6. Methodology: Hermeneutics / Symbolic Interactionism / Constructivist
Paradigm 7. Conducting qualitative research 1: Narrative Interviews / Interviewing experts 8. Conducting qualitative research 2: Focus groups / Participant Observation /
Participatory Research / Grounded Theory 9. Conducting qualitative research 3: Transcription / Approaches to interpretation 10. Mixed methods / Hybrid methods 11. Choosing the right research design / Research ethics
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 117
Epistemology
• “There is an apple” implicates a lot of preconditions • Perceptual apparatus • Subject • Concept of space and time • Concept of an apple
• Are Robinson and Freitag both “seeing” a ship at the
horizon?
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 118
Epistemology
• Can I say anything about the apple insofar as it is not perceived be me?
• Anything an apple means to me is based on my perception of the apple!
• The apple “in itself” is a mystery to me! • My perception has a priory settings: Space, time, causality • And categories: quantity, quality, relation, modality • “Thoughts without content are empty, intuitions without
concepts are blind” • Distinction between a priory (necessary) knowledge and a
posteriory (contingent) knowledge
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 119
Deductive and inductive reasoning
• Deductive reasoning: Linking of premises with conclusions
• Going from general statements to specific statements • Inductive reasoning: Linking specific observations to
broader generalizations • Basis: Identification of patterns and regularities • Theory: Approach in explaining the underlying
mechanism that lead to this regularity
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 120
Problems of inductive reasoning
• Probabilistic: Inductive reasoning never provides absolute certainty
• “All swans are white” can never be absolutely verified!
• “All material substances are affected by gravity”. • “Mankind cannot alter the global ecosystem
fundamentally.” • How can inductive statements be scientifically
reliable?
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 121
Critical rationalism
• Karl Popper (1902-1994) • General statements can never be verified. • They can only be falsified (by one black swan). • Scientific must not try to prove theories • But should try to refute them. • As long as a theory is not falsified it can be considered as valid. • Science is NOT about discovering or constructing new theories • Science is about exposing these theories to a substantial and
controlled inspection. • Truth is always provisional and contestable. • Critical rationalism was the dominant paradigm of sciences in
the post-war period.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 122
Sequence of inquiry
Research question
Theory
Hypothesis
Operationalization
Empirical Survey
Statistical Analysis
Falsification Confirmation
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 123
Problems of critical rationalism in social sciences
• Only applicable to repeatable events. Not to single historical events.
• Problem of falsification by mistake. • Social theories are not falsificable by one single case:
Probabilistic theories • Relation between status as single partent and
poverty is not falsified by one affluent single mom • Work with levels of significance • Critical rationalism is only analyze (and thereby
justify) the status quo.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 124
Specific challenges of empirical social sciences
• We are all experts of our everyday social lives • Folk and everyday theories about social relations
• Clarified, structured and transparent theories
• Expectations • Pseudo-regularities • Selective perception
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 126
Causes and motives
• Human actions have a meaning. • Reversed causality: Motives and agendas (in the
future) are cause • Actions relate to a social and cultural context
(stuctures of meaning) • Only individuals can act, but no act is purely
individual • Routines / Repetitions reduce complexity
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 127
Collective structures or individual agency?
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 128
Different approaches to reasoning in social sciences
Rational choice • Actions as rational results of aims, values, perceived costs and
benefits • Theories of social action Structuralist approaches • Collectives and societies have their own logic of development • Cannot be reduced to sum of individual actions • Marxism or Systems Theory Culturalist Approaches • Neither structures nor actions are independent of each other • Culture shapes actions which in turn produce and reproduce
culture • Culture is contingent
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 129
Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 130
Content
1. Introductory lesson and comparison between qualitative and quantitative methodology
2. Conducting quantitative surveys 1: Structuring a topic / Developing hypothesis 3. Conducting quantitative surveys 2: Questionaire design / Pretest / Sampling
methods / Interview situation 4. Conducting quantitative surveys 3: Sources of error / Working, interpreting and
presenting the data 5. Methodology: Epistemology / Theory of social sciences / Critical Rationalism 6. Methodology: Hermeneutics / Symbolic Interactionism / Constructivist
Paradigm 7. Conducting qualitative research 1: Narrative Interviews / Interviewing experts 8. Conducting qualitative research 2: Focus groups / Participant Observation /
Participatory Research / Grounded Theory 9. Conducting qualitative research 3: Transcription / Approaches to interpretation 10. Mixed methods / Hybrid methods 11. Choosing the right research design / Research ethics
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 131
Positivism
• Positivism: Depart from and concentrate on the ‘positive’ (manifest) facts.
• Sciences should restrict its statements to what can be objectively said.
• Natural and social sciences follow the same logic. • The researcher should have the minimal influence
possible. • Intersubjective, representative measurement
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 132
Critical points in positivist social sciences
• Social phenomena don’t exist outside of individuals but are based on the individual interpretation of a certain group. Meaning is central!
• Social phenomena cannot be identified objectively, since they always depend on the context.
• Positivism hold the manifest for the real. Latent or virtual patterns are excluded. Thereby they tend to just legitimate the status quo.
• Departing from hypothesis formulated by the researcher only perpetuates his/her perspective. There is no possibility of being confronted with a different view.
• Measurability and not relevance determines what can count as a research topic.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 133
Development of qualitative research
• Early 20th century: Sociological Schools and Studies – Chicago School of Sociology – Cultural Anthropology (Malinowski) – “Die Arbeitslosen von Marienthal” The unemployed of
Marienthal (Lazarsfeld et al.)
• Mid 20th century: Suppressed by ‘hard’ science
• Since 1970ies: New discussion about methods
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 134
Interpretative Paradigm
• Basic assumption of qualitative research • Every social interaction is an interpretative process • Actors act in reference to one another • On the basis of their interpretation of what the
others do. • Social reality: action, communication, interpretation • Scientific task: Comprehend the interpretations that
guide action
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 135
Qualitative research is: Interpretation of interpretations
or Re-constructions of constructions
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 136
Interpretative Paradigm
• Relevance of ‚reality‘? • Socially relevant is the social construction
of reality! • Qualitative social research
– identifies – interprets – compares
constructions and their becoming conventional.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 137
Symbolic Interactionalism
• Stresses the significance of the symbolic system • e.g. traffic signs (bus stop) • e.g. language • e.g. place of residence (symbol of social status)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 138
Three basic assumptions of symbolic interactionalism (H. Blumer)
• "Humans act toward things on the basis of the meanings they ascribe to those things."
• "The meaning of such things is derived from, or arises out of, the social interaction that one has with others and the society."
• "These meanings are handled in, and modified through, an interpretative process used by the person in dealing with the things he/she encounters."
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 139
Symbolic Interactionism
• Symbols and meanings are bound to culture. • Scientific approach:
– Understanding thesubjective theories through which people make sense of their world
– Autobiographical stories by which people make sense of biographical facts (e.g. meaning of migration)
• Scientific re-construction is – construction – Bound to theory – Not ‚objective‘
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 140
Hermeneutics
• Art (science) of understanding / interpreting • Comprehend the motives behind and meaning of
actions and statements • Identify the context of meaning • „Fusing of horizonts“ • Openness toward object of inquiry • No fixed hypothesis • Not subject-object but co-subjects • Danger of misunderstanding and misinterpretation • Hermeneutic circle
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 141
Qualitative research as science?
• Total fusing of horizonts is never possible. • ‚Scientific‘ interpretation is subjective • Criteria: consistency and plausibility of
interpretation • Analysis must be grounded in a theoretical
approach • Theory as a guideline for interpretation
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 142
Characteristics of qualitative research
• Methodological spectrum • Methods relate to the research question • Everyday practice and knowledge • Difference of perspectives • Reflexivity of the researcher • Understanding • Openness • Contextuality
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 143
Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 144
Content
1. Introductory lesson and comparison between qualitative and quantitative methodology
2. Conducting quantitative surveys 1: Structuring a topic / Developing hypothesis 3. Conducting quantitative surveys 2: Questionaire design / Pretest / Sampling
methods / Interview situation 4. Conducting quantitative surveys 3: Sources of error / Working, interpreting and
presenting the data 5. Methodology: Epistemology / Theory of social sciences / Critical Rationalism 6. Methodology: Hermeneutics / Symbolic Interactionism / Constructivist
Paradigm 7. Conducting qualitative research 1: Narrative Interviews / Interviewing experts 8. Conducting qualitative research 2: Focus groups / Participant Observation /
Participatory Research / Grounded Theory 9. Conducting qualitative research 3: Transcription / Approaches to interpretation 10. Mixed methods / Hybrid methods 11. Choosing the right research design / Research ethics
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 145
Marienthal
• Small industrial town in Austria • Classical social study about the impacts of high unemployment
rates (about 50%) on social life • Marie Jehoda, Paul Lazarsfeld, Hans Zeisel • 6 weeks of field research in 1932 • Special characteristics:
– Attempt to characterize unemployment (individual and collective) as precisely and detailed as possible
– Precise, poetic and naturalistic writing style – Researcher are not mere observers but immerge into the
community – Wide range of different methods
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 146
Methods of the Marienthal-Study
• Non-reactive methods – Statistics – Documents
• Complaints • Account books • Diaries
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 147
Methods of the Marienthal-Study
• Reactive methods – Participant observations
• Family visits • Consultation hours of physicians • Drawing lessons • Gymnastics for girls • Political work • Educational counseling
– Expert interviews (Teacher, mayor, physicians etc.) – School essays – Written surveys
• Inventaries (of meals) • Time sheets
– Biographical interviews
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 148
Aim of qualitative research
• Quantitative research: Testing known, pre-formulated hypothesis and theories
• Qualitative research: – Thick description – Exploring new phenomena – Discovering new insights – Constructing mid-range theories out of empirical
data
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 149
Role of theory and the researcher
• Theory stands at the end. • But:
– Starting point can never be tabula rasa. – Researcher always departs from theoretical
assumptions. – Identification of a topic already means employing
a theory. – Clarify your theoretical assumptions – Clarify your perspectivity
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 150
Interviews
• General openness of conducting the interview. • Encourage the interviewee to interpret and evaluate
the events. • Situate the interview in a intimate setting. • Follow the rules of social interaction (trust,
politeness, sensitivity, mutuality) • Situation of strangeness is not necessarily a
disadvantage (“passing stranger”) • Anonymity? Confidentiality?
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 151
Directives for qualitative interviews
• Plan with enough time! • Don’t dominate the conversation! • Don’t depart from your own standpoint! • Listen patiently! • Lead a conversation and don’t work through your
questions! • Clarify the purpose of your study! • Use your ignorance as a resource!
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 152
Qualitative Interviews
• Different techniques • Differ in openness and participants • Three examples:
– Guided interview – Narrative interview – Expert interview
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 153
Guided interview
• Focuses on a certain topic • Half-structured
– Questions are pre-selected – Order is flexible – No categories – Interview guide based on a theoretical concept
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 154
Elements
• Beginning of the conservation (“Could you tell me how…”)
• General inquiry (“What happened in detail then?”) • Specific inquiry (Summaries, contradictions,
feedbacks) • Ad-hoc questions • Post-script with thhe most important impressions
and information about the context (directly after the interview)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 155
Other possible elements
• Short questionnaire • Drawings (i.e. mental maps) • Photos, texts, sounds as impulses • Biographical stories • Diaries
• Number? • Bottleneck is the analysis of the protocols
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 156
Narrative interview
• Open and unstructured • Story of own experiences and events • Telling a story means:
– Selecting – Ordering – Making sense of – Contextualizing – Interpreting
• Examples: – Life stories – Migrant stories – Experiences with big events (Fukushima) – “The fight against Möbel Kraft”
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 157
• Structure of a story: – How it began (“once upon a time” or “in the beginning”) – How it went on (selecting and developing relevant elements) – How it ended (meaning of the story)
• Function of the interviewer: Sustaining the structure and recapturing the flow of storytelling by asking questions
• Plausibility and completion of the story is part by the interviewee
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 158
Narrative interview
• Schedule of a narrative interview 1. Expanation phase (What is this conversation about?) 2. Introductory phase (“ Could you tell me about how the
protest against Möbel Kraft started at that time?”). Open ambiguous introductory question.
3. Inquiry phase (“Just just mentioned that … Could you tell me more about it?)
4. Wraping-up (Making sense of the story)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 159
Narrative interview
• Researcher gains access to stories (creative, meaningful reproductions of events)
• NOT to events itself • Problem: Analysis of a massive body of unstructured
(but often exciting) texts.
• Decision depends of the research question
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 160
Expert interviews
• Very common • Hardly ever thought through critically • Nearly absent in methodological literature • Often combined with other methods • What is an expert?
– Special knowledge – Decision making – Professional distance
• Gap between private person and representative of an organization
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 161
Expert interviews
• Expert interviews address persons as experts • “Mental problems of young adults”: Teacher is addressed as an
expert • “Mental problems of teachers”: Teacher is addressed as a
person involved • Expert interviews aim at reconstructing the expert’s
knowledge: – Explicit knowledge – Tacit, practical, embodied, local knowledge
– Inside knowledge – Context knowledge
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 162
Expert interview
• Ignorance is NOT a resource! • The better the interviewer is qualified the freer and
more informal the conversation • Bounded openness of the conversation • Flexibility in adjusting to the specific language game
(code).
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 163
Expert interview
• Problematic courses of a conversation: – Expert is not qualified for the topic or backs out on a formal terrain. – Expert blows the whistle about internal, personal or confidential
information – Expert constantly changes position between professional and personal
perspective
• Successful interviews are based on a two-sided curiosity with regards to the topic
• Clarify your research in an interesting way • Show qualification inconspiciously • Researcher is seen as a co-expert (can be problematic)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 164
Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 165
Content
1. Introductory lesson and comparison between qualitative and quantitative methodology
2. Conducting quantitative surveys 1: Structuring a topic / Developing hypothesis 3. Conducting quantitative surveys 2: Questionaire design / Pretest / Sampling
methods / Interview situation 4. Conducting quantitative surveys 3: Sources of error / Working, interpreting and
presenting the data 5. Methodology: Epistemology / Theory of social sciences / Critical Rationalism 6. Methodology: Hermeneutics / Symbolic Interactionism / Constructivist
Paradigm 7. Conducting qualitative research 1: Narrative Interviews / Interviewing experts 8. Conducting qualitative research 2: Focus groups / Participant Observation /
Participatory Research / Grounded Theory 9. Conducting qualitative research 3: Transcription / Approaches to interpretation 10. Mixed methods / Hybrid methods 11. Choosing the right research design / Research ethics
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 166
Focus group interview
• How can a group interview represent individual structures of meaning?
• Classical study about antisemitic ideology in the 50ies – No traces of antisemitism in individual interviews – Escalation of antisemitism in group discussions
• Collective structures of meaning are only detectable in “natural” conversations.
• Opinions are situational and are negotiated by participants. • Groups who know each other well tend to complete each
others statements.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 167
Focus group interviews
• Natural or artificial groups • Homogeneous or heterogeneous groups • Ideal seize: 5-12 persons • Course of a focus group interview:
1. Explication 2. Introduction of the participants 3. Impulse for the discussion (film, text etc.) 4. Moderation of the discussion 5. Metadiscussion
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 168
Moderation
• Basic impulse should be emotional, polarizing • Formal Moderation (list of speakers, speaking time) • Substantial Moderation • Moderator can keep the discussion going by
– Asking in more detail – Paraphrasing – Questioning – Provoking – Introducing new perspectives
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 169
Monitoring and interpreting
• Tape the discussion! • Ideal: Quite listener to monitor the group situation • Problem: Transcription of several people speaking
simultaneously • Problem: The dynamic of group interviews is always
uncompareable. How can you derive general results from it?
• Two levels of interpretation: – Basic content of what has been said. – Situatedness of statements in the dynamic of discussion
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 170
Focus groups
• Sense and nonsense of focus groups – High input in work and time – No strategy of saving input in comparison to individual interviews – Only appropriate when collective opinions and social dynamics are
object
• Selection strategies of participants: – Complete inventory – Snowball – Gatekeeper – Theoretical sampling – Extreme or ideal types – Pseudo-representative selection
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 171
Observation
• Does reality only consist of language and verbal data? • Embodied meaning • Concrete situations • E. Goffmann: Sociologist (1922-1982) • E. Laurier: Geographer • Exploring the richness and complexity of ordinary
situations • Difficult to represent verbally • Structured observation and interpretation
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 172
Types of observation
• Secret vs. open observation • Participant vs. non-participant observation • Systematic vs. unsystematic observation • Natural vs. artificial situations • Self-observation?
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 173
Observation
• Object: Events and actions • Researcher reduces the complexity of situations with
three filters – Selectivity of intention – Selectivity of perception – Selectivity of protocol
• Observation is not a merely receptive capturing of facts but an active re-construction by the researcher.
• The aim is not just the description of situations but the re-construction of meaning.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 174
Objects of observation
• Actors: shadowing persons through different settings • Events and Actions: whole social context with
different roles and practices (restaurant, meeting). Difference between routine and unexpected events.
• Artefacts: Analysing actions that are related to a certain material objects (blood preservation, class room).
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 175
Problems of observation
• Defining and delimiting a whole cycle of action • Access to all relevant situations • Familiarity of “normal” situations • Significance of marginal details • Complexity of situations
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 176
Participant observation
• Attempting to get the “inside” perspective • “Doing pidgeon” • Reenacting embodied, situated meanings • Difficulty of distinguishing between scientific outsider
perspective and participative insider perspective • Constant balance act between two modes of
perception • “Going native” • Constant self-reflection of the researcher! • Always keep a research diary!
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 177
Phases of participant observation
• Descriptive analysis: – Crucial phase when everything is still new and noteworthy to the
researcher. – Unfulfilled expectations bear great potential for new insights – Focus on the social and the physical setting
• Focused analysis: – Reconstruction of structures of meaning – Variation of perspective – Construct “normality” – Identify dimensions of meaning (social, factual, temporal, spatial)
• Detailed analysis: – Concentrate on particular topics – Detailing, modificating
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 178
Participatory Research
• Blurring the strict separation between science and practice • Science as a democratic, communicative process • Researcher as engaged part of the process • Participatory Action Research (PAR):
– Aims at change of practices or structures – Working with competent and reflexive participants – Adresses real-life issues – Involvement of participants in knowledge generating
• Paulo Freire: Pedagogic of the opressed • Research as a possibility for conscientização • Make poor marginalized people aware of the forces
affecting their lifes
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 179
Public Sociology
Construction of topic
Scientific Community Non-academic
Problem solving Traditional social research Applied social research
Challenging Critical social research Public Social Research
Audience
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 180
Methods in participatory research
• Art and media • Diagramming and drawing • Group work and discussions • Political action and advocacy • Mapping (paper and using GIS) • Ranking and scoring • Role plays and theater • Secondary data analysis • Shared analysis, writing, and presentations • Storytelling • Transect walks
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 181
Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 182
Content
1. Introductory lesson and comparison between qualitative and quantitative methodology
2. Conducting quantitative surveys 1: Structuring a topic / Developing hypothesis 3. Conducting quantitative surveys 2: Questionaire design / Pretest / Sampling
methods / Interview situation 4. Conducting quantitative surveys 3: Sources of error / Working, interpreting and
presenting the data 5. Methodology: Epistemology / Theory of social sciences / Critical Rationalism 6. Methodology: Hermeneutics / Symbolic Interactionism / Constructivist
Paradigm 7. Conducting qualitative research 1: Narrative Interviews / Interviewing experts 8. Conducting qualitative research 2: Focus groups / Participant Observation /
Participatory Research / Grounded Theory 9. Conducting qualitative research 3: Transcription / Approaches to interpretation 10. Mixed methods / Hybrid methods 11. Choosing the right research design / Research ethics
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 183
Grounded Theory
• Developed by Glaser & Strauss 1967 • Strategy of developing mid-range theory • Grounded in empirical data • Deduction – induction – abduction • Abdutive reasoning: Infering a hypothesis from given data. • Data: “The lawn is wet.” • Sufficient and most economic explanation: “It rained last night.” • Iterative process of gathering data – interpreting data –
selecting cases
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 184
Theoretical sampling
1. Starting with one case study 2. Analysing and interpreting the data 3. Developing a theoretical explanation 4. Selecting the next case based on your theoretical
assumption 5. Expand, modify or re-think original theory 6. Selecting each new case on the basis of each
modified theoretical structure 7. Go on until theory is saturated
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 185
Rules of grounded theory
• Memoring: Writing down memos about theory • Memos accumulate in the process of doing research • Sorting of memos • During sorting process new ideas are memored too
• Theoretical split of Glaser & Strauss:
– Glaser: “Let the data speak” – Strauss: “Everything is construction”
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 186
Transcription
• Most common qualitative data: tapes and audio files • Transcripts of audio files are re-constructions
(selection of “relevant” levels of meaning) • Transcribing is very laborious and time consuming. • 1 hour interview takes about one working day to
transcribe and makes about 30 pages! • Facilitating software in speech recognition.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 187
Accuracy of transcription
• As original as possible? – Dialect? – Injections? – Pauses – Accentuations – Laughs – With parts that don’t relate to the topic?
• Two dangers: – Loss of important information by sloppy transcription – Fetishism of accuracy
• Level of accuracy should be determined by the research question.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 188
Strategies of analysis
• Coding • Standardisation • Interpretation
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 189
Coding
• Aim: – Breaking up texts – Developing and assigning categories – Ordering
• Reducing and generalizing • Coding strategies
– Open coding – Theoretical coding
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 190
Open coding
• Move on by line, sentence or paragraph • Summarize into generalizations
– What is being said? – Who acts? – How are the facts adressed? – Context – What motives move the statement? – What strategies are employed?
• Step by step generalizations of generalizations • Does a pattern emerge? • Advantage: flexible responding to the text
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 191
Theoretical coding
• Close commitment to a given topic • Three steps
1. Single case analysis with a characteristic statements and summary
2. Detailed content analysis 3. Comparison over given cases
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 192
Software
• To structure and organize the text • No interpretation or analysis of the text! • Coding of text passages • Retrieval-Function: Listing of passages with
the same code • Retracting the context of each passage • Searching for certain words
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 193
PD Dr. Florian Dünckmann Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 194
Constructing idealtypes
• Idealtypes are the most important non-quantitative instrument in social sciences
• Max Weber: Idealtype (doesn‘t have to exist in reality)
• Aim of qualitative inquiry: Identification of empirically grounded idealypes
• Internal homogeneity, externeal hetergeneity
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 195
Constructing types
• Single case: coding of single case • Types: Total number of cases are
aggregated into distinct types • Typology: Differences and similiances of the
types are identified
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 196
Interpretation
• Interpretation is ALWAYS taking place • Conscious act! • Putting oneself into the other position,
understanding • Text, speaker, spoken • What is said / What is meant / What is understood • Ways of understanding: Information about facts,
Relation, Confessing, Appeal
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 197
Objective Hermeneutics
• Hermeneutic circle • Interpretation – better understanding of
the text – new Interpretation • Aim: Revealing the latent (objektive)
structure of meaning of the text • Step by step analysis of small text snibblets
– 1 page of protokoll – 5 Interpreters – Each 30 hours of interpretation work – Ca. 50 pages interpretation text
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 198
Approaches to interpretation
• From the content of the text • From the biography of the autor • From the objective circumstances of its production • From the reader • From motives and decisions
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 199
Topic based content analysis
• Coding different topics • Identifying the similarities that mark all text passages
concerning the topic. • Identifying the different contexts (social,
chronological etc.) in which this topic is addressed. • Identifying the different ways how the topic is
treated in one or more interviews • Integration of the results into research question
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 200
Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 201
Content
1. Introductory lesson and comparison between qualitative and quantitative methodology
2. Conducting quantitative surveys 1: Structuring a topic / Developing hypothesis 3. Conducting quantitative surveys 2: Questionaire design / Pretest / Sampling
methods / Interview situation 4. Conducting quantitative surveys 3: Sources of error / Working, interpreting and
presenting the data 5. Methodology: Epistemology / Theory of social sciences / Critical Rationalism 6. Methodology: Hermeneutics / Symbolic Interactionism / Constructivist
Paradigm 7. Conducting qualitative research 1: Narrative Interviews / Interviewing experts 8. Conducting qualitative research 2: Focus groups / Participant Observation /
Participatory Research / Grounded Theory 9. Conducting qualitative research 3: Transcription / Approaches to interpretation 10. Mixed methods / Hybrid methods 11. Choosing the right research design / Research ethics
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 202
Mixing Methods
• Bridges over the qualitative – quantitative divide? • Calls for easy integration are naïve. • Triangulation: Applying qualitative and quantitative methods on
the “same” question • Possible?
– Different epistemology, – different model of doing science, – different ways of constructing a topic/research question – different angle of enquiry
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 203
Integration of qualitative and quantitative methods
• During the course of research • Different functions in the research design
1. Qualitative exploration (interviews) and quantitative analysis (questionaire)
2. Quantitative exploration / construction of idealtypes (statistical analysis) and qualitative analysis
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 204
Exurban villages
• What political and social processes shape the development of exurban villages near urban agglomerations?
• Tree step inquiry: 1. Identifying types of villages using factor
analysis and cluster analysis of statistical data
2. Quantitative questionaire with mayors 3. Qualitative interviews in selected villages of
each type
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 205
Hybrid methods
• Post-positivist quantitative methods • Quantification of qualitative elements (discourse
analysis with lexicometric methods) • Q-Method
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 206
Q-method
• Method to make subjectivity tangible • Tension between the individual and the collective • Based on complex statistical methods • Interpretative approach • Invented in the 50ies by physicist and psychologist W.
Stephenson • Q-method as opposed to R-method (Correlation)
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 207
Q-method
• Basis: Ranking of stimuli (controversial statements, fotos etc.) by persons
• Statistical analysis resembles normal factor analysis • Not correlating tests over individuals • But correlating individuals over tests • Factors are re-constructions of commonly shared
views • Individuals load (correlate) to a different degree • Aim: identifying and understanding internal,
subjective structure of complex frames of reference
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 208
Q-method
• Not counting isolated opinions but taking the entire setting of a persons standpoint into account
• Persons are not homogeneous entities but are shaped by different discourses and identities
• Variety and inconsistency in a subjective view that lie beyond simple dichotomies and group attributes
• Subjectivity is not indefinitely diverse but that there exist certain common patterns that are socially shared
• Less interested in the people doing the constructing than in their actual constructions
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 209
Topography of a topic Example „Rural development“
X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X
“People in the village have not enough understanding for agriculture.”
“We should create as much jobs as possible in our village”
“How I live is not any villagers business”
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 211
Pattern of evaluation
+ + + + + + + + + +
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + + + + + + + + +
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - -
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 212
Patern I and II
+ + + + + + + + + +
+ + + + + + + + + +
+ + + + + + + + + +
+ + + + + + + + + +
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
- - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - -
+ + + + + + 0 0 - -
+ + + + + + 0 0 - -
+ + + + + + 0 0 - -
+ + + + + + 0 0 - - + + + + + + 0 0 - - + + + + + + 0 0 - - 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 - - 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 - - - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - -
Re-constructions of constructions
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 214
4) Result: Three perspectives on rurality in Panten
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 215
A) The reform perspective
B) The idyllic perspective
C) The anti-museal perspective
4) Result: Three perspectives on rurality in Panten
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 216
A) The reform perspective Differentiating statements
A B C Farmers promote the establishment of new building sites because they hope to make a lot of money by selling their land. 3 -2 -4
Farmers still have too much influence in our village. 1 -1 -4 We must conserve and cultivate the traditions of our village. -1 3 2
We tend to overestimate the advantages of ecological farming. -4 -2 3
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 217
A) The reform view
Citations from interviews
Hegemony of the farmers: „The communal counsel is clearly dominated by farmers. They sit there already in second generation. “ Sceptical when it comes to traditions: „You can conserve traditions. But sometimes times are changing. It would be terrible if we would conserve everything there ever was.“ Progress: „We definitely have an anti-progress alliance in our village“
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 218
A) The reform perspecitve
Pattern
Breaking up old structures
Ecological modernisation
Hegemony of the traditional farmers
Sceptical against growth
Sceptical with traditions
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 219
B) The idyllic perspective Pattern
Children Healthy life
Roots
Tradition Community Continuity
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 220
Colonization
Production Economy Practical
constraints
False idyll
Artificial museum
C) The anti-museal perspective Pattern
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 221
Political model of village life: Gesellschaft
A-political model of village life: Gemeinschaft
Multifunctionalist model of agriculture
Reform perspective Idyllic perspective
Productivist model of agriculture
Anti-museal perspective
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 222
Loading of persons on different factors
Profession Years in the village
Reform Idyll Anti -museal
Driving instructor 20 years 0,02 0,80 - 0,17
Housewife Local -0,15 0,74 0,13
Retired engineer 20 years 0,14 0,73 -0,15
Government employee 12 years -0,39 0,71 -0,03
Retired midwife 30 years 0,27 0,66 0,09
Housewife 10 years -0,22 0,6 0,12
Architect 12 years 0,63 0,55 -0,16
Physicist 20 years 0,64 0,37 0,25
Farmer (Eco) Local 0,68 0,3 -0,32
Farmer Local 0,05 0,19 0,91
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 223
Last words
• Because Q-methodology aims at the plurality of perspectives on a certain topic, it is an appropriate method to explore the different concepts of environment that co-exist.
• One important advantage of the Q-methodology is its approach to take the constructions of reality themselves as the central objects of analysis and not the individuals who hold them. Thus it is possible to bypass the risk of readily falling back on the distinctions between pre-existent groups (e.g. newcomers vs. natives or farmers vs. residents) or socio-demographic factors and ascribing certain positions to them.
• Even though they appear to be ‘objective’ results of an automated statistical operation, the final factors identified by Q methodology should nonetheless always be seen as scientific constructions.
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 225
Choice of a method
• What data sources and methods are potentially available or appropriate?
• What can these methods and sources tell me? • Which components of “social reality” can these data
sources and methods help me to address?
• Co-construction of research topic and methodology
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 226
Informal dynamics of urban developments in the Pearl River Delta/China: Perception of stress factors and coping stratgies under the influence of global change in the megacity of Guangzhou
• - qualitative interviews with inhabitants - autophotography - No standardized survey with questionaires
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 227
- Urban governance in european metropolitan areas: Actors constellations in integrated development programs and the role of trust for the realization of projects
- qualitative interviews with actors
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 228
- Social spaces and migration: Transnational migration. Ecuadorians between home, Germany and Spain (Transnational ties and networks)
- qualitative interviews with selected migrants and with migrant organizations - Biographical method - Participant observation in Ecuador
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 229
- Sociodemographic change and new housing markets: An
analysis of the inhabitant structure and the motives of locational decisions in innercity housing areas in Hanover
- Standardized survey of all housholds - Qualitative Interview with inhabitants - Expert interviews
Prof. Dr. Florian Dünckmann - Lecture ‚Social Research Methods‘
Folie 230
- Traditional use strategies of marine resources in Central America: Culutral Change and use conflicts
- Qualitative interviews - Focus groups - Participant observation