![Page 1: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Knowledge of Language
September 22, 2010
![Page 2: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Mission Objectives1. Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism
2. Try to figure out how language can be creative.
3. One outstanding point: African grey parrots!
• The previous problems with prescriptivism:
1. Confusion about application of prescriptive rules
• (they’re not natural)
• Hypercorrection
2. Standards can shift over time
3. Prescriptive rules form a poor understanding of natural language.
![Page 3: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Problem #3: Missing Patterns• Prescriptivist rules do a poor job of accounting for many of the patterns we find in natural language.
• Here’s one prescriptive rule which misses a consistent pattern:
• “Incorrect”: I feel bad (about the accident).
• “Correct”: I feel badly (about the accident).
• Why? The verb “feel” should be modified by an adverb (“badly”), not an adjective (“bad”).
• But is bad/badly modifying the verb or the subject of the sentence?
![Page 4: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Linking Verbs• How about these examples?
• Bob is happy. (*Bob is happily.)
• Susie looks hot. (*Susie looks hotly.)
• The water seems fine. (*The water seems finely.)
• I feel sleepy. (*I feel sleepily.)
• James Brown feels good. (*James Brown feels well.)
• The verbs in these sentences are known as linking verbs.
• They connect the subject to some property describing the subject.
• (They do not modify the verb itself.)
![Page 5: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Different Standards• Rules for a standard form of a language…
• Normally describe the variety of language used by the group in power.
• Other forms of the language are non-standard.
• And are often identified with social, regional or ethnic groups.
• Linguists have discovered that all forms of language (standard or not) are rule-based and orderly.
• Non-standard forms of the language are not simply mistake-ridden versions of the standard form.
• There is no linguistic reason to consider one variety of language superior to another.
![Page 6: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Non-Standard Sentences• How do you feel about the following sentences?
• I’m done my homework.
• My car needs washed.
• All I do anymore is work.
• Mary said that she wanted to come with.
• If someone had invited me, I would have went to the party.
• Note: the grammaticality of these sentences can vary from group to group, or speaker to speaker.
• (In a sense, linguistics can be a “personal science”.)
![Page 7: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Quick Write:Appalachian English
• Appalachian English is a variety of English traditionally spoken in the Appalachian mountains.
• Developed (and maintained) unique features due to isolation from outside communities.
• One interesting feature:
• a-prefixing…
![Page 8: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
“a” prefixing, part 11. a. The man likes sailing.
b. The man went sailing.
Correct answer: (b) (80-5)
5. a. William thinks fishing is silly.
b. William goes fishing every Sunday.
Correct answer: (b) (77-8)
Rule: [a-] form cannot be a noun.
![Page 9: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
“a” prefixing, part 22. a. The woman was coming down the stairs.
b. The movie was shocking.
Correct answer: (a) (72-13)
6. a. The movie was fascinating.
b. The movie kept jumping up and down.
Correct answer: (b) (68-15)
Rule: [a-] form cannot be an adjective.
![Page 10: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
“a” prefixing, part 33. a. He makes money by building houses.
b. He makes money building houses.
Correct answer: (b) (68-16)
7. a. Sally got sick cooking chicken.
b. Sally got sick from cooking chicken.
Correct answer: (a) (63-22)
Rule: [a-] form cannot be preceded by a preposition.
![Page 11: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
“a” prefixing, part 44. a. Sam was following the trail.
b. Sam was discovering the cave.
Correct answer: (a) (77-8)
8. a. The man was hollering at the hunters.
b. The man was recalling what happened that night.
Correct answer: (a) (80-5)
Rule: first syllable of [a-] form must be stressed.
Note: Al-freakin’-berta
• Lastly: 50 people got all 8 correct.
![Page 12: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
“a” Prefixing Summary• Note: people often consider speakers of Appalachian English to be unsophisticated
• …but the proper use of the [a-] prefix involves a relatively complex set of conditions.
• Also: all of the [a-] forms are prescriptively “incorrect”
• …but they still exhibit consistent patterns of grammaticality.
• You also had (for the most part) the right sense about which forms were grammatically correct.
• …even though it may have been hard for you to articulate exactly why.
![Page 13: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Descriptive Benefits• Language tends to operate in patterns, even if they are non-standard.
• Important: Appalachian English speakers are not just speaking English with mistakes.
• Descriptive linguistics enables us to understand how those patterns work.
• History of economics analogy.
![Page 14: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
To Be Fair• Standards are useful because they provide a single form of the language to teach to non-native speakers.
• They help establish uniformity in the written language.
• They can help clear up confusions.
• for instance: supposably
• They also help to distinguish those who have mastered the arbitrary rules from those who haven’t.
• (for better or worse)
• Otherwise:
• They are not useful for (scientific) linguistic analysis.
![Page 15: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Linguistic Creativity (again)• One of the crucial design features of language was creativity (or productivity).
• Charles Hockett:
“Language users can create and understand completely novel messages.”
“In a language, new messages are freely coined by blending, analogizing from, or transforming old ones. This says that every language has grammatical patterning.”
“In a language, either new or old elements are freely assigned new semantic loads by circumstances and context. This says that in every language new idioms constantly come into existence.”
• How is it possible for human beings to do this?
![Page 16: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
To Infinity and Beyond• Last week, we found out that honeybees can produce a variety of different “dance messages”.
= “Food source beyond 65 feet, fly at 0
degree angle with the sun.”
= “Food source beyond 65 feet, fly at 45
degree angle with the sun.”
![Page 17: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
To Infinity and Beyond• The number of different messages the bees can produce is limited only by the number of angles they can differentiate:
• “Food source beyond 65 feet, fly at 1 degree angle with the sun.”
• “Food source beyond 65 feet, fly at 2 degree angle with the sun.”
……………
• “Food source beyond 65 feet, fly at 359 degree angle with the sun.”
• Q: Can the bees dance at angles they haven’t seen before?
• If so, how?
![Page 18: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
To Infinity and Beyond• A: yes, if they dance according to rule.
Their dances have to fit into a meaningful pattern.
• The rule = “Food source beyond 65 feet, fly at X degree angle with the sun.”
The bees have to know the rule.
• Knowing the rule enables them to exhibit “creativity”, in a sense.
![Page 19: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Different Infinities• What kind of infinities exist in human language?
• Note that we can say (translations of) everything the bees can say:
Fly at a 1 degree angle with the sun.
Fly at a 2 degree angle with the sun.
……………
Fly at a 359 degree angle with the sun.
• We can get as detailed as we want to about it, too:
Fly at a 45 degree, 13 minute, 27.6685 second angle with the sun.
![Page 20: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Infinity + 1• In addition to the infinity of things the bees can say, we can say other things, too.
• Examples (borrowed from Ray Jackendoff):
A numeral is not a numbskull.
A numeral is not a nun.
A numeral is not a nunnery.
……………
A nun is not a nursery.
……………
An oboe is not an octopus.
![Page 21: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Linguistic Infinities• These are uninteresting, but novel sentences.
• In order to understand them, you must know the rule by which they are constructed.
• Rule:
[Sentence] = A X is not a Y.
• Point:
• Knowledge of rules is more abstract than just knowledge of sentences.
![Page 22: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Language Model #1
• In this model, all we “know” are the individual sentences we can use in language.
• (no rules)
• This is a good enough model to describe the vervets’ “language”.
A nun is not a nursery.
Fly at a 45 degree angle with the sun.
I like linguistics.
![Page 23: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Language Model #2
• In this model, we “know” all the rules we can use to combine words to form sentences in a language.
• This is a good enough model to describe the bees’ “language”.
• Is it good enough for human language?
A X is not a Y.
X at a Y degree angle with the Z.
X likes Y.
![Page 24: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
What do you think?• No. There are even bigger infinities.
• Check out these sentences:
Bill thinks that Beth is a genius.
Sue suspects that Bill thinks that Beth is a genius.
Charlie said that Sue suspects that Bill thinks that Beth is a genius.
Jean knows that Charlie said that Sue suspects that Bill thinks that Beth is a genius.
ad infinitum...
• Some “real” examples:
![Page 25: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
How many rules do we need?1. X verbs that Y is a Z.
2. W verbs that X verbs that Y is a Z.
3. V verbs that W verbs that X verbs that Y is a Z.
• and so on…
• Q: Can we store all these patterns in our heads?
• A: No, because no matter how many we store, there is always a longer one…
• So how do we know all of these sentences?
![Page 26: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Language is Recursive
• Recursive = involving a procedure that can refer to itself.
• In language, rules for producing sentences can be used in rules for producing sentences.
• Humans have to know rules of the following kind:
[Sentence] = X verbs that [Sentence]
![Page 27: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Language Model #3
• Jackendoff: “We know not just patterns of words, but patterns of patterns.”
• This is how we can be infinitely creative with a finite set of rules.
S = X likes Y.
S = A X is not a Y.
S = X verbs that S.
![Page 28: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Check it out• Included among the infinite number of things we can say is a lot of complete nonsense.
• Examples (from Chomsky and Lewis Carroll):
• Colorless green ideas sleep furiously.
• I’m memorizing the score of the sonata I hope to compose someday.
• ‘Twas brillig, and the slithy toves
Did gyre and gimble in the wabe…
• Check out the postmodernism generator:
• http://www.elsewhere.org/pomo/
![Page 29: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
What’s the difference?• Nonsense sentences work because they fit in with the patterns formed by the sentences that actually do make sense.
• (and that we use every day)
• Compare with the following:
• Large green lizards sleep soundly.
• I’m memorizing the score of the sonata I hope to perform someday.
• ‘Twas evening, and the slimy toads
Did squirm and wiggle in the cage…
![Page 30: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
What’s the difference? (part 2)• But the following sentences don’t work at all:
• Green sleep ideas furiously colorless.
• I’m memorizing the perform of the score I sonata to hope someday.
• Brillig and, slithy and the toves
Wabe gimble in the gyre and did…
• Note: just because we can say an infinite number of things, we can’t just say anything…
![Page 31: Knowledge of Language September 22, 2010 Mission Objectives 1.Wrap up Prescriptivism ~ Descriptivism 2.Try to figure out how language can be creative](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022061305/551442905503462d4e8b49ef/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Technical Terminology• The set of rules that we know for creating sentences in a language is the grammar of that language.
• The rules of grammar that we know are very abstract. (patterns of patterns)
• Strings of words which do not adhere to these rules are ungrammatical.
• Q: If these rules are so abstract, how did we figure out what they are?
• How do we learn language?