Download - Investing in Uncertain Markets
Presentation to AAII
Baton Rouge Chapter Meeting
April 2014
INVESTING IN UNCERTAIN MARKETS
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 2
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 3
BEARS (going into 2013):•Without the Fed, this market falls apart, because …•The global economy is buried under the weight of debt•Deleveraging (reducing the debt) cycle will keep earnings and investor sentiment down•Eurozone workouts and China slowdown are big known risks.•U.S. budget issues and related debt are a big potential risk The Fiscal Cliff!
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 4
What a DRAG!
THE IMPACT OF GLOBAL DEBT
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 5
• Living in Reinhart/Rogoff World:• Research by Reinhart/Rogoff widely sited for concerns about U.S.
debt
• Studied financial situation of 44 countries over two centuries
• Found that debt to GDP >90% was a tipping point
• Led to reduction in growth of -1% for years on end (20+ years)
• Why? Limits government’s ability to invest
• Resources going to pay down/support debt
• Interest rates spike as markets demand more compensation
BUT THE RULES DON’T APPLY TO THE U.S. … YET
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 6
• Is the U.S. different?• Yes – for now.
• Almost unlimited ability to borrow, and very cheaply!
• Reserve currency and related Treasury bond market provide important “buffer” – size of markets without peer
• Debt has been transferred from private to public – lowers net interest expense in the “system”
• Debt supporting investment is preferential to debt supporting consumption – “hello Greece”
• It gives us the “freedom to be irresponsible”
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 7
Government spending growth grinds to a halt
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 9
@parhedge Be LONG insanity and SHORT common sense
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 10
How common is it to have a 10%+ intra-year decline?
WHAT DRIVES MARKET PRICES?
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 11
• Fundamentals Economic Cycle and Corporate Earnings
• Investor Sentiment Enthusiasm drives P/E ratios for stocks; Yield spreads for bonds
• Liquidity Availability of capital; money flow; Fed policy can influence this
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 12
Corporate Earnings x PE Ratio = Market Prices
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 13
And then THIS Happened …
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 18
What if only a fraction of that bond wave flows back into stocks?
19DON LANSING ([email protected])
“The stock market is all about money. Money goes in and the stock market goes up. Money flows out and the stock market goes down.”
– Jesse Livermore
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 20
Asset Allocation Funds have a poor year
BEARS: FALLING LIKE DOMINOS
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 21
• “I have been prepared to underperform for the fun of being proved right when markets crash. But that could be in three-and-a-half-years’ time.”
• “I cannot look at myself in the mirror; everything I have believed in I have had to reject. This environment only makes sense through the prism of trends.”
• “I am out of justification to fight the uptrend. Up until now, I have had what I thought was compelling evidence to believe in the bearish case, but it has now been revealed to have been insufficient for the task.”
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 22
20%+ Returns are Common
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 23
Compared to Historical Rallies
THIS BULL MARKET JUST WON’T STOP!
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 24
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 25
Been a long time …
26
WHAT IS “NORMAL”?
DON LANSING ([email protected])
“In the average bull market, the S&P 500 falls by 10% or more every 16 months. It has now been over 31 months since the last such pullback. Investors have forgotten what a normal market looks like.”
– CIO of $130B firm
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 27
What is “normal”?
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 28
ARE STOCKS EXPENSIVE?
Corporate Earnings x PE Ratio = Market Prices
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 29
NOT COMPARED TO RECENT PRIOR PEAKS
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 30
Nor Compared to Projected Earnings
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 31
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 32
Compared to Historical Rallies
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 33
2014 – the Road to Nowhere?
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 37
Will Higher Interest Rates kill the rally?
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 38
And Stocks do fine
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 39
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 40
Spending Changes As We Age
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 41
How to invest in a rising rate environment?
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 42
What bonds are best in a rising rate environment?
MANAGING INCOME PORTFOLIOS
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 43
• Importance of Duration• +1% move in interest rates = -D% move in bond price
• Managing spreads instead of rates• Spread = Difference between rate of bond & Treasury rate• Higher the spread, the more compensation being demanded• Lower spreads = nearer to end of cycle• Watch spreads for clues about the end of the cycle!
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 44
Dealing with Uncertainty
45
WHY THE UNCERTAINTY?
DON LANSING ([email protected])
“Here is the simple reality we try desperately to ignore: Most of the time, we have no idea what is going on.”
– Barry Ritholtz
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 46
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 47
WAYS TO MITIGATE RISK – INCREASE DIVERSIFICATION
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 49
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 50
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 51
DEALING WITH UNCERTAINTY:PORTFOLIO CONSTRUCTION – COMBINING IDEAS
• Carry a low-volatility core portfolio• Can be low-volatility stocks and/or bonds
• Bonds can be adjusted for risk target – e.g. HY
• “Allow” allocation to higher performance/volatility pieces when applicable• When market trending up – own higher-beta pieces
• Market volatility increases – cut high-beta positions
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 55
DOWN/UPSHIFTING A PORTFOLIO
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 56
• We can also take half-steps in making our portfolio more tactical
• Reduce our risk by adding more yield• Move from stock index position to
1. High yield stock ETF (DVY/SDY/HDV/SDIV)
2. Convertible bond ETF (CWB)
3. Hybrid yield ETF (GYLD/INKM, PDVYX)
4. High yield bonds (HYG/JNK, VWEHX)
5. Corporate bonds (LQD)
Decreasing Risk
HEDGING YOUR PORTFOLIO WITH OPTIONS
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 57
• Buy Index Put Options• Go x% out of the money with some time (3 months)• Use most volatile indexes – e.g. Russell 2000• $130 for a 3-month 10% OTM option – will rise 3x • Take your gains! (and roll over)
• Sell VIX Put options – need to sell a lot to offset total portfolio risk (each option may generate $30)
• Sell Index Call Options – helps for short-term/pair with buying puts
A STRATEGY FOR ADDING RETURN
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 58
DEALING WITH UNCERTAINTY:A PORTFOLIO ADDER
• Sell VIX Options at “edges”• Sold Puts go up as market drops – a reasonable ongoing
hedge
• Sold Calls go up as market rises
• “Cash-settled” options• All that matters is the expiration close of the VIX
• Pocket almost ALL of your premium
• Downside = $100/contract per point
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 59
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
• Markets rarely STAY down on geopolitical issues • BUY THEM!
• Markets do not STAY down without a recession• There is none in sight
• The “normalization” of markets will increase volatility and create opportunities
• Brokers like: Europe (recovering and cheap)• U.S. Large Caps (small-caps have become expensive)
• Always watch High-yield bonds for a market signal
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 60
TO SUMMARIZE
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 61
• Investors became far more comfortable in 2013.• This resulted in a rush toward equities as it became more expensive
to be out of the market than in.• The question is whether this is a calm before another market storm or
the end of a decade-long secular bear market • Europe and China remain uncertain though appear to be improving• We don’t know how stock markets will react to the end of the Fed’s
bond buying program.• There are ways to substantially lessen volatility while still achieving
solid returns.• Remember what matters – positive economic growth and generally
positive sentiment – not political noise, nor nebulous forecasts of doom
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 63
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 64
"Every day I get up and look through the Forbes list of the richest people in America. If I'm not there, I go to work. " -Robert Orben
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 65
THANK YOU BATON ROUGE!
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 66
Backup
BUILDING AN INVESTMENT STRATEGY
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 67
• Objectives• Long-term (retirement) vs Short-term (project)
• Personality Profile• Knowledge
• Maintenance
• Stomach (Ability to Handle Volatility)
DISCUSSION OF RISK
68
• What is risk? A result that is different than expected – investors focus on worse than expected. • Volatility is the enemy of successful investing (though it also
creates opportunities)
• Deviation is dangerous because it pushes emotional buttons in individual investors makes them anxious, induces fear, …
• Deviation from account peak – what we call “drawdown” – is a key focus• Investors emotionally “own” an asset value
• Thus, the goal is to minimize drawdown and hold on to the bulk of gains offered
DON LANSING ([email protected])
69DON LANSING ([email protected])
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 70
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 71
2-3 Years Up; 1-2 years Down
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 72
Corporate Earnings x PE Ratio = Market Prices
BEARS:•Without the Fed, this market falls apart, because …•The global economy is buried under the weight of debt•Deleveraging (reducing the debt) cycle will keep earnings and investor sentiment down•Eurozone workouts and China slowdown are big known risks.•U.S. budget issues and related debt are a big potential risk.
DON LANSING ([email protected]) 73
Are we in the middle of a long-term bear market?